is that the full error
#Getting error messages from pyright when defining a command group inside a Cog class
nocturne schooner
steady flame
That is, yes.
It seems to be listed as multiple because there is an error for each overload of the group decorator.
steady flame
Python version, or Pycord?
nocturne schooner
pycord
steady flame
just in case, can you show the full file
I can, but it's 829 lines.
steady flame
Python version, or Pycord?
I just installed it with py -3 -m pip install -U py-cord --pre.
nocturne schooner
print discord.__version__
nocturne schooner
mhm
steady flame
2.1.1
I'm migrating from Discord.py.
I have the file on GitHub, it's hard to send it here.
nocturne schooner
wait
the command seems to work fine when executing, but when editing it storms me with error messages
so can you actually run it fine?
steady flame
Yes. It's like doing
banana: int = "some string"
Doesn't mean it's all right, though.
nocturne schooner
this seems more like a problem with your env than the library; perhaps you have conflicting packages?
as far as I can tell, 2.1.1 doesn't inherently cause any issues close to the one you've showcased
steady flame
I don't have discord.py installed.
That's the only possible conflict I can imagine could happen.
But you may be right. I'll see if I can figure something out.
cosmic lotus
can you run pip freeze and send the results here?
steady flame
can you run `pip freeze` and send the results here?
steady flame
Parameter 1: type "Concatenate[CogT@group, ContextT@group, P@group]" cannot be assigned to type "Self@Charsheets"
More importantly, in fact
Type "(self: Self@Charsheets, ctx: Context[Unknown]) -> Coroutine[Any, Any, None]" cannot be assigned to type "(Concatenate[CogT@group, ContextT@group, P@group]) -> Coro[T@group]"
steady flame
Coro = Coroutine[Any, Any, T]
CogT = TypeVar("CogT", bound="Cog")
ContextT = TypeVar("ContextT", bound="Context")
P = ParamSpec("P")
# [...]
# One of the possible types @command/@group takes in as the original function:
Callable[[Concatenate[CogT, ContextT, P]], Coro[Any]]
# And therefore
Callable[[Concatenate[Cog, Context, P]], Coroutine[Any, Any, Any]]
Interesting. Doesn't that disallow other args as an annotation?
E.g. because of
Callable[[Concatenate[ContextT, P]], Coro[Any]],
It's okay if I do:
@commands.group()
async def test_group(ctx):
pass
But not if I do:
@commands.group()
async def test_group(ctx, something: int):
pass
Same error as before.
cosmic lotus
why are you trying to add other args to a command group?
steady flame
A group can be called as a command if invoke_without_command=True, no?
And if I can add extra args to a command, should I not be able to do the same to groups, since they end up delegating behavior to command?
cosmic lotus
I didn't think that was possible
nocturne schooner
it's always been possible for ext commands, but when testing earlier i don't recall my ide complaining about it
interesting
steady flame
Coming from discord.py, I use this a lot.
My editor is a mess right now, blowing with errors from me trying to fix the annotations manually.
At least I'm sure it's something in the annotation definitions.
@template_field.command(
name="rename",
aliases=("rn",),
usage="charsheets template field rename <old name> <new name>",
)
async def template_field_rename(
self, ctx, template_name: str, old_name: str, new_name: str
) -> None:
This is an example.
It actually seems to work in py-cord, btw.
nocturne schooner
yeah ik it works perfectly fine
steady flame
A distinction I noticed is that Rapptz's discord.py doesn't annotate func.
(in the command decorator)
nocturne schooner
i can't test it myself because i literally can't repro, but feel free to send a PR on the github if you find an appropriate adjustment
steady flame
Weird. I'll see if I can do anything about it, although I'm considering just going back and forking discord.py.
nocturne schooner
fair enough, though can't you just silence this particular error