#MOB!!

1 messages · Page 5 of 1

tacit mountain
#

as always

upbeat monolith
#

I haven’t really played much with logic, I figured out some dispensers and collision stuff but haven’t put enough time into that

coral mantle
#

what would i get on average if it was like +20%?

#

is what im looking for

#

its max price on average how much id get per piece not per stud

upbeat monolith
coral mantle
#

oki

stable roost
#

Hur

#

One sec

#

I was only getting like 5.5k/min for optimized

coral mantle
#

whats the average doe

stable roost
#

like 4.3k

#

could prolly be higher but i was using different numbers of trailers

#

sapphire spawn rate isnt very good

#

anyway im gonna actually get magmite data now since i didnt do that yestersay

stable roost
#

urgh the semi is impossible to use for magmite it just never wants to turn

floral shard
#

yeah it sucks

stable roost
#

im just gonna do the classic sellner and 1 trailer, i tried 2 but then one of the trailers fell over

upbeat monolith
lilac raptor
#

Ive got some advice, move adurite back, or give it a better location, they moved it cause some players couldn't get to it, but they put it in a literal impossible place to farm efficiently, making it worthless

lime kite
#

just grind something else atp 🥀

torpid ocean
lilac raptor
lilac raptor
upbeat monolith
lilac raptor
lilac raptor
upbeat monolith
coral mantle
coral mantle
floral shard
#

this is due to grimestone volume decreasing by 40% from processing

coral mantle
#

is that a bug

floral shard
#

zero clue but its applying to a couple rocks rn

coral mantle
#

why does the volume matter

floral shard
#

this is list

coral mantle
#

i thought it would translate from big pieces

floral shard
#

volume = stud?

#

less stud = less money

coral mantle
#

oh

#

well yea i meant like if you have a huge piece of uranium it should be a huge pieec of uranim forged or refined

floral shard
#

in rock form the volume bigger

#

refined volume smaller

coral mantle
#

and forged even smaller

floral shard
#

nah for some reason only decrease after refine

#

forge stay same as refined

coral mantle
#

im sure thats prob a bug

stable roost
#

That’s how

coral mantle
#

i just need the average price bro

stable roost
#

About the same thing, 4.1k

coral mantle
#

not for sapphire

#

sapphire is 2300

upbeat monolith
floral shard
#

its just decrease the volume for certain rocksshrugge

stable roost
#

It’s a fun little treat

upbeat monolith
floral shard
#

no clue also congrats on number 1 trader

#

how many reps?

upbeat monolith
upbeat monolith
stable roost
stable roost
#

@torpid ocean did 1 run with magmite plus flameslate and both together gave me like a 6-7k optimized rate

#

i only did 1 trailer tho but im gonna try and do 2 trailers, semi is near impossible to control in its current state so im just waiting for that to get fixed

#

uhhh if you want i can do a run with JUST magmite cause im not sure if you'd want to buff both magmite and flameslate cause it seems you want people to be grabbing both flameslate and magmite when they mine

torpid ocean
#

ya you should grind both

stable roost
#

ok ill just keep doing what im doing then

floral shard
#

Magmites fine run imo

stable roost
#

what you could do is buff flameslate a bit maybe

floral shard
#

I think it’s better to only grind marmite and serverhop

#

Ew spell check

torpid ocean
#

7k a min aint very good for something thats supposed to be end game

stable roost
#

mhm

floral shard
#

I’m getting 9k

torpid ocean
#

mm

stable roost
#

or like

floral shard
#

Yeah

stable roost
#

oh

floral shard
#

Via the pa TV I showed

stable roost
#

that would do it

floral shard
#

Path

stable roost
#

ehhh i could try and use semi again

#

cause that would give better results

floral shard
#

Tbh is magmite hard? I just find it tedious

stable roost
#

nah not really

#

tedious yes

#

i mean if you use fire potion only issue is it takes awhile to mine the nodes

#

theyre quite tough

floral shard
#

Yeah

stable roost
#

hmmmm

#

ok heres what i say

#

@torpid ocean you could probably give flameslate a small buff since it seems magmite is fine ish on its own

#

im gonna try and get a semi run with both

stable roost
#

@floral shard where do you even park your semi so stuff stays heated

#

nvm figured out a crude way to get my semi in my usual spot

stable roost
#

alright, got my semi run in, optimized run is like 8-9k

#

i think best bet is to give flameslate a buff

upbeat monolith
stable roost
#

well with semi i grabbed both and it gave about the same rate as magmite (at least with lucky's data)

#

he got 9k with just magmite, i got about 8-9k with both magmite and flameslate

#

so i mean if jak wants it to where people should grab both, flameslate buff is the way to go

#

given i dont server hop at all

stable roost
#

@torpid ocean i was just thinking, one thing you could buff more is lumite, i was only able to get like 7-8k for it

#

oh wait you wanted it to be like 8-9k nvm

upbeat monolith
#

But is lumite ment to be more focused for credz and opening up room for other cash meta ?

floral shard
#

Jak are you able to view the mat leader board?

stable roost
#

cause this is what it looks like in game rn

floral shard
#

oh you think that's inaccurate?

stable roost
#

uhhh idk

#

i just know the api is really out of wack rn

torpid ocean
#

yea I wouldn't trust api rn

#

pretty sure it's broken

#

luck is like redoing it all

torpid ocean
#

could buff it up 1k /min

#

maybe 2

stable roost
floral shard
#

Rate the processing set-up🤑

floral shard
#

my magmite spread sheet is broken for sum reason

#

doesn't properly calculate high rate vs low rate

stable roost
#

how so

#

ohh wait i see the issue

#

the hell does it mean by divide, ill see if i can fix it rq

#

mm nvm i see the problem

stable roost
#

should look like this

floral shard
#

did I do it wrong it no worky

stable roost
#

mmm lemme look

#

change the 3rd and 4th value to 1

#

there you go

#

oh your rates wtf

#

OH

#

move all your run times up a row

#

your first row is empty so your rates arent working

#

yeah see

floral shard
#

first run is nil

#

I just got too lazy to fix the number lol

stable roost
#

mm

upbeat monolith
#

Does anyone have a A-Z list of plants/fruit

floral shard
#

Magmite Run 4 Notes:
Magmite is good 10k per min
Some magmite turned to obsidian(mostly smaller pieces)
Server hopped 3 times(Bad luck with spawn times)
NO FIRE POTION
Magmite and Flameslate Run 5 Notes:
Figured out how to consistently get over my fears!
Flameslate sucks needs a large buff; magmite is just so much better
flameslate 1.4k per min vs magmite 7.5k
That's a 5x difference (thats a lot)
does not include the down cost of the fire potion which would lower the overall rate by 1k per min

#

did not server hop

upbeat monolith
#

Is that something that should be taken into consideration

floral shard
#

whelp then I would be making negative money per run lol

upbeat monolith
#

Yeah I guess that would be hard to add in

#

With it being 1 time purchase

stable roost
#

Flameslate buff it is

#

Given it would be a small buff

#

Uhhh @floral shard do some lumite runs ked

#

Cause from my data it wouldn’t hurt to buff lumite a bit as well

floral shard
#

I'm getting 8-9k per min

stable roost
#

Should be fine then

floral shard
#

In this video, I test out the NEW Luminescent Kelp farming in Oaklands to see if it’s really worth your time.

I spent one full hour farming both Normal and Luminescent Kelp, using the Refined Scuba Tank, and ended up making LOADS!

🔔 Subscribe for more Oaklands content, guides, and gameplay!
👍 Like the video if it helped and comment i...

▶ Play video
#

10k per min

low moon
#

hold up

#

money?

stable roost
#

Mmmm kelp

#

I’ll do some lum kelp runs

nocturne peak
#

Damn that's alot of stuff

upbeat monolith
floral shard
#

trailers don't save during server hops anymore

#

lumite such a coin flip; sometimes 9.5k per min somtimes 8k

upbeat monolith
#

It cleared up for a bit sorta but still mostly happens

#

Semi ftw

stable roost
#

Yeah that’s why I don’t server hop

floral shard
#

How does hardness/toughness for rocks/trees work?

#

scaling-wise

#

bro my 2nd trailer spawns in but my first trailer didn'tcursed

upbeat monolith
#

What’s the max overall % a material can drop on market board ?

floral shard
#

20%

#

so 0.8 of base

stable roost
#

Ye

upbeat monolith
#

Ok Ty

#

So for example uraniums lowest would be 544?

reef oar
#

Has anyone tested the kelp method that someone made a video on a bit ago I tried replicating it and couldn’t get anywhere close to it

agile kite
#

yes

like 1 truck load is newrly 13 k

#

so having to go however many times to in 1 hour is ALOT

#

maybe like 15 trips or so(pure guessing) with trailers

#

so its js not realistic

floral shard
agile kite
#

i dont remember exactly but i think it was only 1 truck

agile kite
floral shard
#

then ur grinding suboptimaly

#

ofc ur not gonna be getting optimal rates

oak stone
#

I tested 3 times

#

all over 600k an hour 😮

#

@reef oar

#

which includes the processing time ...

reef oar
#

Damn

#

Guess I’m just slow then lol

agile kite
reef oar
#

@oak stone I can get 16 ish per load but how did you get the kelp to spawn so quickly half the time I’m just driving around for one or two at a time

#

And sorry for the ping by the way

#

I can confirm it works though with like 20 min of farming I got 160k

oak stone
#

I also do both Normal and Luminescent kelp

floral shard
#

@torpid ocean any forageble near spawn is probably broken rn if its jarred price > 400, since lavender is at 8-9k rn; e.g. sakura apparently its 16k per min based on someone's testing

#

defo not 16k per min but its probably above 10k

reef oar
#

Like Sakura trees?

digital aurora
#

🪦

torpid ocean
floral shard
#

Jak did Emberbane get buffed in the most recent update?

#

and how does the emberbane mechanic work with the multi chops?

floral shard
#

10.6k per min MM runsteamhappy

stable roost
#

yeah mm is basically balanced

#

eeuhhh i may make a list of stuff thats currently balanced so we can see where we're at

#

im gonna go back and redo like all my old data now that we have like different sized trees and stuff

floral shard
#

caps only 11k per min high ratesteamhappy

#

shrooms are so back

#

love driving sellner plus trailers into the canyon🙃

stable roost
#

mmmmm yes

lime kite
#

just curious, did you guys account for failed runs when doing the balancing data for magmite?

stable roost
#

But yeah, if we did record a failed run it gets accounted for

#

Usually failed runs just cause stuff like a higher farming time or a higher travel time if you flip or something

stable roost
#

Jak kinda bases the balancing off like “optimized” runs which use a hypothetical processing time, so if the optimized run is like 1-2k within the ideal money/min, means it’s balanced

#

Cause like everyone has different kinds of loaders and unloaders

hot thistle
#

Is their any thing better than plek and not magma wood cause I don’t like to farm it lol

stable roost
#

Try boomite, it’s good

hot thistle
#

Alright

floral shard
#

plek is absurdsteamhappy

#

still hate it tho

floral shard
#

cosmic how'd u do 3 trailers for plek

#

I keep clipping random bumps and go flying😭

floral shard
#

Plek is new metagnarp

hot thistle
#

I do 4

#

Doing 5 is almost impossible

#

Cause how long it is

hot thistle
#

Ima start grinding it more

floral shard
#

14k per min

hot thistle
#

Wow

floral shard
#

4k more than other late game

hot thistle
#

YES I don’t have to grind boring magma wood

floral shard
#

Yeahhhhh

upbeat monolith
hot thistle
#

It’s way easier and better to grind

floral shard
#

Less dreary imo

hot thistle
#

Magma has more steps and is boring

upbeat monolith
# floral shard Less dreary imo

I play mobile and usually have Netflix on Picture in Picture mode floating on top of the game so it doesn’t bug me too much lol

upbeat monolith
hot thistle
#

Mobile is so hard to play onnnn

floral shard
#

Does ur game not lag?

#

Dang what phone model

upbeat monolith
#

Surprisinglyruns really well

floral shard
#

I need this

hot thistle
#

Might be cause I’m not use to it

upbeat monolith
#

When acid lands first came out it broke my phone ngl lol

#

But the devs have done a lot of good work to reduce that and it’s running great again

stable roost
#

I love plek

upbeat monolith
# stable roost I love plek

See I was on my year break when river cave and plek came out so I never played when it was the meta. I don’t know the route 😦

floral shard
#

the route completely changed since then lol

#

before was the maze now we have scenic route

stable roost
#

ye

upbeat monolith
stable roost
floral shard
#

dang I just found it lol

#

#1337177575612612649 message

junior tulipBOT
stable roost
#

this was made before the map revamp but its still about the same

floral shard
stable roost
#

yyes

floral shard
#

jak also recorded one iirc

stable roost
#

yeah

#

well idk

lime kite
#

why not boomite, or magmite, or magma trees, or uranium

stable roost
#

still max is like 14k for the solo one so

#

mmm tomorrow ill see if i can get up to that

lime kite
stable roost
#

ye

lime kite
#

im trying to build one but ive been struggling 🙁

stable roost
#

idk i built tupi's

upbeat monolith
floral shard
#

I think 5 solo runs is enough data for plek

#

now time to never touch it again until river reworksteamhappy

floral shard
#

pallidium 10k per min🔥

#

can we get more tree metas cause rn its 3 tree vs 7 rock

upbeat monolith
#

Sometimes I’ll spend 15 minutes in the cave and only find 1 node

floral shard
#

Nope still pure luck

upbeat monolith
#

Ok thought so lol

reef oar
#

How do I get plek?

#

I’ve never seen it in the lumite caves

stable roost
junior tulipBOT
reef oar
#

That seems like a long way lol

stable roost
floral shard
#

can we get an artic kelp buff its 3k per min

#

a 2x size increase would be 🔥

stable roost
#

Is artic kelp even supposed to be a viable farming method

torpid ocean
#

not late game

#

well if you dont have scuba you cant

#

so no not really ig

stable roost
#

And then I can keep track of stuff that’s properly balanced

floral shard
#

plek nerf when

upbeat monolith
floral shard
#

nope just get in and get out quickly

#

if you cut it right the pieces should be pretty straight

stable roost
#

I really need to do more plek runs, cause when I did it the optimized run was fine

floral shard
#

I think ember buff made it a lot faster or sum; or leaf collision

stable roost
#

I mean I used pollaxe

#

Doesn’t the emberbane have the same stats as reinforced now?

floral shard
#

yeah but multihit so idk

stable roost
#

And I did the run when leaf collision was removed so

stable roost
floral shard
#

didn't ur run do sawing?

stable roost
#

No

floral shard
#

where no sawing run

stable roost
#

At least I don’t think so

floral shard
#

me no see

stable roost
#

Uhhh lemme see

floral shard
#

15 min grind time for 3 trailers is absurd if no saw

stable roost
#

Idk maybe I did saw????

floral shard
#

u defo sawwed ked

stable roost
#

Either way yeah ima do another run with emberbane later cause im gonna hit the gym

floral shard
#

gym is good u should get do azy challenge to get statue

#

good motivation fr

stable roost
#

I mean I’m trying to lose weight so, I’m mainly doing cardio

upbeat monolith
floral shard
#

Cosmic did one

upbeat monolith
floral shard
#

Excercise

upbeat monolith
floral shard
#

Cosmic knows the route

upbeat monolith
floral shard
#

Push-ups pull-ups

#

Tailored for person to person

upbeat monolith
#

I reach out to him for my amounts ?

floral shard
#

Yeah give desc of ur abilities

upbeat monolith
#

Interesting Alr

stable roost
#

Hello

#

I’ve sent my plek route a few times in here

upbeat monolith
#

@torpid ocean #1400110704211525632 check out this guys post. Could be a great idea for a market revamp

#

You’d still have to add in the refined and sanded. But how is shows base price and current price and the tax thing makes it easier to understand how it works

torpid ocean
#

Yea Ive asked hoof to do it a few times

#

I'm gonna figure it out myself lel

stable roost
#

Splendid

#

Also I think once I get home I’m gonna make a spreadsheet or something so we can keep track of what’s balanced and what still needs work

floral shard
#

is there a mid-game prog in oaklands rn? just feels like u can make uncertain pick and then go straight for boomite or make emberbane and go for MM

stable roost
#

Ehhhh idk, unfortunately people usually just do sequoia and skip mid game

#

Rosa quartz is the only like mid game thing I can think of

#

Kelp maybe???

floral shard
#

rosa is like pretty good tho ngl

#

8k per min

stable roost
#

Yeah

floral shard
#

kelp needs scuba for good rate without its a little slow

#

compared to rosa

stable roost
#

Eeeuh lemme look at my data

#

Eh kelp is early game nvm

#

Idk I’ll look at the old list Jak made in a sec

stable roost
#

ok so i took a look at the old list jak made for intented rates for some materials, and based off that we have boomite, fungiviolet, rosa quartz, mm, lumite, and magma being balanced

#

im gonna try and retest a ton of my old tree data tomorrow with the emberbane and see if i can get better runs in

floral shard
#

12k rose gold plus pallidium high rate

#

only got 4 pall nodes total rest was rose gold

#

so I don't think I got too lucky with it

#

no serverhop

floral shard
#

second run 9k high rate 3 pall nodes(nodes were the skinny nodes)

#

zero clue if semi is more viable than sellner plus 3 trailers

#

only doing sellner so its easier to sort pall and rose

#

put my runs under CANYON GRIND

floral shard
#

12.5k first run, 10k second run, 11k third run high rates

#

so sellner plus 3 trailers > semi

torpid ocean
#

End goals for each material (UPDATED)
higher difficulty/investment > higher rates

these rates should represent the higher end of the max sell price ACTUAL rates. Optimized Max sell rates shouldn't be more than 2k over

Early game / early mid game - anything else not listed is either meant for early game, or mainly building. rates from 0k/min-2k/min

Mid/late mid game (USING MID/LATE MID GAME ITEMS)
Petrified oak 4-5k/min
olive 3-4k/min
acacia 3-4k/min
blue pine 4-5k/min

spruce 5-6k/min
Kelp (and luminescent)- 5-6k/min (no refined scooba)
Purple Cactus - 5-6k/min
Red Cactus - 6-7k/min
Sakura Blossom - 5-6k/min
Regular Mushroom - 5-6k/min

blueslate /smokeyslate ore - 4-5k/min

fungi violet - 6-7k/min
Rosa Quartz 5-6k/min
Quartz 4-5k/min

Lavaslate and Blackstone ore (magma cave) - 7-8k/min

Probably gonna make these 2 late game, however if they are they need to have higher tier rock
Palladium - 5-6k/min (9-10k late)
Boomite - 7-8k/min (9-10k late)

late game

ice pine - 9-10k/min
magma - 9-10k/min (not meteors)
plek - 9-10k/min
Mysterious Mushroom 9-10k/min

magmite/flameslate - 9-10k/min
lumite - 8-9k/min
sapphire - 9-10k/min
Uranium - 9-10k/min

greeb - 7-8k/min

any non end game mats shouldn't be over 8-9k/min when using end game stuff

FORAGABLES
<5k/min
fruits will give buffs for eating, jarred fruits makes buffs last longer

floral shard
#

rose gold

#

fungiviolite

#

oh nvm

#

"Kelp (and luminescent)- 5-6k/min (no refined scooba)" what about with scuba?

split locust
#

what is mm

floral shard
#

mysterious mushrooms

upbeat monolith
torpid ocean
#

They should really be even lower than that but that's the max

#

Depends on the matsrial and difficulty

lime kite
#

why is magma trees the same as magmite

floral shard
#

both aren't hard at all

torpid ocean
#

not hard at all!!!?!!

lime kite
#

and why is sapphire the same rate as uranium?

stable roost
#

OH, I forgot to share my thingy I made to keep track of stuff

#

For some I used both me and Lucky’s data, but today I’m gonna regather a TON of my tree data since the emberbane is buffed so like half of it is empty rn

floral shard
stable roost
#

Yes

floral shard
#

Where does red and purple cactus spawn mostly?

#

Also it would be kinda cool if red cactus show thorns at you like the corrupted version

#

Shot

stable roost
#

the higher areas of the desert

upbeat monolith
#

By the old classic shop

floral shard
#

this made 47,487

#

red cactus 3k per min with max set-up

#

I miss old map purple cactus grindingcrying

#

also I remember during halloween we were able to jump/climb to the classic store area from the ground floor of the desert

#

am I just going crazy

#

also purple and red cactus spawns are right next to each other why would a player not grind red over purple?

twin thunder
#

It's impossible to take a semi into the plek cave right

hard lark
twin thunder
#

Boxed upgrade

#

It can't fit

#

And crates are terrible

hard lark
junior tulipBOT
hard lark
#

idk how

twin thunder
#

How old is that

hard lark
#

today days old

floral shard
# junior tulip

prolly suboptimal since semi speed slow af and that route is also slow af

#

chance based ores are so silly

#

13k per min lumite peak 8k mininum rn

floral shard
#

#oak-questions message

junior tulipBOT
floral shard
#

Jak did you finally nerf plek76starsineyes ?

upbeat monolith
#

Savage

torpid ocean
#

hasn't even been an update

#

I think

stable roost
#

They prolly didn’t load the trailers all the way or summ

floral shard
#

its down 20% today76starsineyes

stable roost
#

That’s prolly why

floral shard
#

I wish it was always down 20%gnarp

floral shard
#

scrap needs a buff

#

only 8k per min high rate

lime kite
floral shard
#

jak is stud = unit?

stable roost
floral shard
#

ITS A GRINDABLE CURRENCY

#

GOTTA MAKE SURE ITS BALANCED

stable roost
#

Bro

stable roost
floral shard
#

alr thanks

stable roost
#

Jak can correct me if he wants but yeah

lime kite
#

alien spawnrates got nerfed 🥀

twin thunder
#

Literally who cares steamhappy

lime kite
twin thunder
#

What's wrong

#

@lime kite

wanton dune
#

4500 messages gnarp Kurt

floral shard
#

new optimal scrap method 16k scrap per min #oak-media message

junior tulipBOT
reef oar
#

Uhm what

#

How?

stable roost
lime kite
#

the picture explains nothing 🥀

floral shard
#

not serious

lime kite
ebon egret
#

perhaps metal detector

floral shard
ebon egret
#

oh

#

i think it spawns in one specific location, idk tho i haven't found them since the devs moved where it spawns

#

should be on or around one massive vein of raw adurite

dark sundial
floral shard
#

Oh Jak someone's having trouble with the blue keycard quest is it still possible with map revamp?

upbeat monolith
floral shard
#

Gotcha thanks

jade halo
#

Yo how do u farm it fast

#

Its really annoying fighting with the skeletons and healing

torpid ocean
#

Has anyone tried bluepine recently

#

Max setup

floral shard
#

oh wow blue pine got taller?

floral shard
#

ok so 20k optimized but.....

#

my processing time counts cutting the tree

#

I didn't bother cutting tree before processing

#

cause yk too annoying

#

so 9k high rate

#

if the crate bug where u store a ton of mat in a crate is still a thing I think blue pine is broken

#

since my processor can't handle this much wood rn

#

I only cut down three trees and like 10 big ones spawn per server

floral shard
#

cutting took 50% of the time

floral shard
stable roost
#

Yeah I think the biggest issue rn is the really big trees, I’m gonna get data where I just gather it normally

lime kite
#

its like impossible to get the bandsaws to do what i want 😭

floral shard
#

because conveyor?

#

hit a 10k per min run for blue pinesteamhappy(9,667)

lime kite
upbeat monolith
stable roost
#

Basically like best tools

upbeat monolith
#

Nothing to do with processing setup?

stable roost
#

Not really cause we have the optimized

upbeat monolith
stable roost
#

On the spreadsheet

upbeat monolith
#

But what I’m wondering is are the rates based off just the collection of the materials ?

#

Cause in my opinion that’s what it should be based on . Have nothing to do with what happens once it reaches your plot

stable roost
#

Based off of travel time, farming time mostly

upbeat monolith
#

Yes ok so that’s it ?

stable roost
#

Basically yeah

upbeat monolith
#

And nothing to do with time to process and sell?

stable roost
#

It’s also taken into account yeah, but there’s both an “actual” rate and “optimized” rate

#

Actual rate uses your processing time, optimized uses a theoretical processing time

upbeat monolith
#

I don’t think it should be taken in to account tho

#

It should all be based purely on difficulty of farming + travel

#

Once the farmed material reaches your plot timer should be stopped

#

Cause after that it’s a wild ball game and will vary so much

stable roost
#

Again that’s why we have an optimized section for the materials, we can plug in whatever number for that

#

Optimized is basically like the “max” for how much you could make an hour

#

Or min

upbeat monolith
#

Hmm

floral shard
floral shard
#

Not something we need to worry about as of the momentcrying

lime kite
floral shard
#

that would only be a prob for blue pine right?

#

ohhh nvm ic

lime kite
#

it affects any tree

floral shard
#

maybe bandsaw all in one area to overlap cutting?

lime kite
#

maybe

#

but the more bandsaws you have the more likely it is to get stuck

#

(on the thin bars or whatever)

floral shard
#

yeah...

#

I can only think of the proccesing setup being the ground then

upbeat monolith
#

Cause that’s where data can imo get crazy

floral shard
#

How so?

lime kite
#

but its pretty decent

stable roost
#

Mk in that case I’ll just make a sheet that gets rid of processing time and see what the difference is

#

You know what, @torpid ocean can you explain why you take processing time into account

torpid ocean
#

its the difference between a sweat and average player

stable roost
#

Yeah cause they think it shouldn’t be considered at all

torpid ocean
#

why

#

if i dont consider processing time at all stuff will be over nerfed

stable roost
#

Because it can vary too much apparently

#

Which is why optimized and actual exists

torpid ocean
#

actual should represent a good player's setup
and the optomized is like a theoretical max if someone had a crazy setup

#

which is why i dont really mind that much if optomized is a bit higher as long as actual isnt aswell

stable roost
#

Yeah

#

Also while you’re here, I think the biggest thing rn that’s gonna affect balancing of trees is the like really big ones

#

Cause lucky did a run where they only grabbed like a few big trees and got like an insane rate

torpid ocean
#

is it just because you can get more alot faster

#

@floral shard

#

ive been thinking about increasing their like cut time

#

toughness

#

whatever

stable roost
#

The farming time was literally just 1 min

#

I’m still gonna do runs where I kinda just grab stuff like the average player would and see how it is

#

Cause my old data is like 2k max per min but that’s pre terrain update

torpid ocean
#

its hard because if i just nerf it, its gonna be horrible for normal players

stable roost
#

Mhm

torpid ocean
#

like most people dont have insane bandsaw machines

stable roost
#

Yeah my setup now is like multiple sanders and planters

#

Plankers

torpid ocean
#

if you are cutting them manually its probably perfectly fine

stable roost
#

I do however have a save with like a horrible setup so I can test on there

#

I mean hypothetically if you want the “best” run you’d really only be grabbing the really big trees

#

Kinda like sequoia kinda, it’s just cause of the large volume

upbeat monolith
#

Wouldn’t it just mean they farm a lot of stuff faster

torpid ocean
#

based on the setup

upbeat monolith
#

An average player can build the most efficient setup

#

My point being a sweat would farm faster and more efficiently

torpid ocean
#

i dont think typical players are going to build the best possible setup

upbeat monolith
#

But I just feel material value should be based purely on the time to farm, with difficulty, and travel time and even just time to mine ( magmite) should be what makes it more valuable

stable roost
#

mk so i removed processing time and it basically caused my actual rate to increase

#

by like 1k

torpid ocean
#

it doesnt make sense to not consider a variable

upbeat monolith
torpid ocean
#

its accounted for

stable roost
#

ok but the sheet accounts for that i believe

upbeat monolith
#

I’m saying it’s a variable though lol

stable roost
#

yeah

upbeat monolith
#

It could be anywhere in between low and high aswell

stable roost
#

the point is trying to figure out the hypothetical max someone could make from a material

torpid ocean
#

@floral shard you are using bandsaw setup right

#

when you got 9k/min with blue pine

#

I think I need to make it so the bandsaws aren't like a million times faster than cutting by hand

stable roost
#

Prolly

#

I don’t think lucky has bandsaws tho

#

Neither do I

torpid ocean
#

are they selling raw?

#

well their actual rate was high too

stable roost
#

Good question, I don’t think so cause earlier they mentioned their machine having issues with it

floral shard
stable roost
#

I mean the high rate is cause its literally like a 1 min farming time

floral shard
#

Pure just me cutting

#

I can quite lottery throw the tree to my base

#

Literally

#

Thats how close it is

torpid ocean
#

Ya

stable roost
#

Plot 5 my beloved

#

Should I gather blue pine the “normal way” and just grab whatever trees are near me, regardless of size

floral shard
#

biggg better

#

thicker trunk

stable roost
#

Dude but then if it gets nerfed the smaller trees will be worth nothing

floral shard
#

yep

#

thats the problem

#

I think nerfing it would make it suck for progression

torpid ocean
#

well it should probably be similar to oak

#

given that it's right next to base now

stable roost
#

The big trees are a NIGHTMARE

floral shard
#

also wat you do for progression run cosmic

torpid ocean
#

could you try doing great oak

stable roost
#

Basically whatever tier that tree needs

stable roost
floral shard
#

great oak = big oak tree?

stable roost
#

Yeah

torpid ocean
#

ya

floral shard
#

zero clue that existed ngl

torpid ocean
#

they are all called great

#

internally

floral shard
#

its still affected by stocks tho?

torpid ocean
#

ya

#

it's all combined into one tree but the generation is technically different trees

floral shard
#

o just noticed there are two blue pine values in the mat sheet

stable roost
torpid ocean
#

Idk

stable roost
#

cause i still feel like grinding it normally is just as important to consider, because obviously bigger tree = more money

floral shard
#

are we grinding normally?

stable roost
#

thats why sequoia is good despire being like 1 dollar

stable roost
#

not just focusing on the great trees

floral shard
#

o

stable roost
#

because obviously those are gonna give a lot of money

floral shard
#

so like max vs progression how we grind?

stable roost
#

max is like maxxed tools and setup, progression is based on the minimum tier required

#

so like using a rusty axe for oak

floral shard
#

sander affected by size or smth?

#

big = money? so no take small cause sub-optimal right?

#

quality > quantity fr

stable roost
#

yeah but not everyone knows to just go for the big trees

floral shard
stable roost
#

i feel like we shouldnt base the balancing off of JUST the great trees

floral shard
#

but then we don't know wat to nerf or not

#

cause sub-optimal

torpid ocean
#

Great trees should effectively be no different than getting a few normal trees

#

Is the goal

floral shard
#

you would have to change values individually then

torpid ocean
#

I don't think changing values fixes this

stable roost
#

yeah thats the issue

#

the great trees have more volume

#

you would have to make 2 seperate values

floral shard
#

yeah volume > value in this case

torpid ocean
#

It's a problem with the chop time scaling i believe

floral shard
#

for great trees

torpid ocean
#

Yes

stable roost
#

maybe???

floral shard
#

yeah that works as well

torpid ocean
#

Like

floral shard
#

it would have to be a very sizable difference tho

#

like veryyy

stable roost
#

yeah either make great trees harder to cut or like, put great trees in their own value range

torpid ocean
#

It should take the same time to process a great tree than it does to process equivalent value normal trees

floral shard
#

I think you would have to triple toughness for great blue pine as an example

stable roost
#

eeeeh, lemme grab like 2 great oak trees that are near my base and see what i get

floral shard
#

where spawn

#

and what plot number

stable roost
#

finlay bruh

torpid ocean
#

Forests

floral shard
#

idk the names ked

stable roost
#

literally any plot on finlay

stable roost
floral shard
#

I have zero oaklands knowledge

stable roost
#

bruh

#

HOW CAN YOU BE BALANCING AND KNOW NOTHING KED?????

floral shard
#

I JUST CUT TREE AND MINE ROCK

#

AND HIRE PEOPLE TO MAKE PROCESSORS

#

AND TRADE

stable roost
#

im going to shake you like a latte

#

anyway oak time

#

lucky you will rue the day

floral shard
#

of wat

stable roost
#

you just will

floral shard
#

aw

floral shard
#

huh red birch also has two values in the mat list

torpid ocean
#

No

floral shard
#

we're saved

lime kite
#

what would be the point of bandsaws if theyre nerfed?

floral shard
#

murder ppl

#

many a uses

torpid ocean
#

If you READ 🧌you would see luck y said they got without

#

So clearly they aren't the problem

lime kite
#

🙏

floral shard
#

oh right wat tierr is cutting red mushrooms at

torpid ocean
#

I think steel

stable roost
#

id ignore the optimized but yeah i got like 5.5k ish

#

@torpid ocean

#

only grabbed like 2 trees

torpid ocean
#

yea def broke

stable roost
#

i think you may have to put great trees in they own value cat

torpid ocean
#

It's unintuitive

#

I want to fix the chop time scaling

stable roost
#

yeah true

#

cause with emberbane it didnt take much time at all

#

would prolly fix sequoia too

#

actually no it wouldnt, that tree is just so big that it gives a lot of money no matter what

floral shard
#

oo red mushroom new best mid game tree?

#

6k per min but veryy suboptimal

#

didn't even take the caps lol

stable roost
#

i swear

#

0.43 farming time

floral shard
#

it just cut

#

once for bottom once for top

stable roost
#

god bless, at this point i should drop out of the balancing effort and just let you handle it

floral shard
#

1.75 for full charge its pretty fast ngl

stable roost
#

emberbame

floral shard
#

yep

stable roost
#

i may still gather data gathering different sized trees cause tbh i dont think its intended to just be grabbing the great trees

#

not even may, im going to do that since it should all be about the same

robust nimbus
#

@torpid ocean what flowers are you nerfing because ill quit if you nerf the ones I grind 🙁

torpid ocean
#

Are you on rn btw

torpid ocean
robust nimbus
torpid ocean
#

no

robust nimbus
#

so lavender is getting nerfed 🙁

torpid ocean
#

if you can make over 8k a min

robust nimbus
#

oh no I dont think u can

#

wait so then no flowers are getting nerfed

#

because it depends on the machine u have and the method you do u cant make that much unless you have that stuff

stable roost
#

was there something specific you wanted me to look at

torpid ocean
#

no but im doing some testing for the toughness thing

#

if you wanna join

stable roost
#

bet ill join

upbeat monolith
#

Am I crazy or was the semi walls made thinner… I have stuff clipping through all the time now

#

Also it’s annoying the trailer wheels stick out further than the seller … the truck fits through then my trailer gets stuck :/

upbeat monolith
upbeat monolith
upbeat monolith
#

It’s like playing the game operation.. if i touch the side while loading the thing explodes

torpid ocean
#

@stable roost thought of a potential solution

Change how cutting works
When a tree is still rooted, the first cut you make hit requirement is determined by the total volume of the tree (& toughness constant)

Then, when the tree is down, all the other hits are a lot shorter, so most of the time is spent on the initial first chop

stable roost
#

ooooo

#

yeah that could be good

#

wouldnt that make it like way too easy to cut down the smaller trees tho?

torpid ocean
#

Well we'd make sure they are the same as before

#

It would mainly just effect large trees

stable roost
#

ohhhhh

#

in that case yeah that sounds like a decent solution

torpid ocean
#

I feel like people might like it better that way

#

idk

stable roost
#

lol def not, people hatw anything that isnt like a buff

torpid ocean
#

like once you have the tree down, it won't take a million years to cut each individual peice

stable roost
#

ohhh

torpid ocean
#

well like just for building ig

stable roost
#

wait actually yeah

torpid ocean
#

it will just take a bit longer to cut down initially

stable roost
#

that actually sounds pretty good tbh

lime kite
#

seems more realistic

floral shard
#

the sapling aren't included when you want all tree size varients to be equal right?

upbeat monolith
torpid ocean
#

so sapling would be

stable roost
#

Mmm sapling

floral shard
#

whelp alien axe best axe now ig

#

does more per hit than emberbane and is faster

torpid ocean
#

great

stable roost
#

Lmao are you fonna be nerfing it

torpid ocean
#

not gonna stay like this

#

Yes

#

why would a limited item be better than perm stuff

#

makes no sense

stable roost
#

Yeah plus emberbane is a pain to get

#

Makes sense for emberbane to be the best axe

torpid ocean
#

and now everyone is gonna be crying about ts

#

uhg

stable roost
torpid ocean
#

idek they were gonna be like this vro

stable roost
#

Mm maybe you could slightly buff the emberbane more or summ so it’s on par with the alien axe

#

Although idk if that would make it too powerful

torpid ocean
#

I don't wanna do that

#

The alien pickaxe can just have same stats as uncertainty

#

and axe can be same as emberbane without the magma tree buff

stable roost
#

Ye

#

People are still gonna complain but when do people ever not complain

stable roost
torpid ocean
#

nvm ig

stable roost
#

People keep saying it’s a bug lmao

upbeat monolith
#

I still prefer gleam ..

lime kite
#

good thing i didnt waste my money on the alien tools 🙏

floral shard
#

huh alien pick < uncertain

#

are the ufo's suppose to do dmg cause I rlly can't tell

hard lark
floral shard
#

gotcha
its only noticeable with weaker rocks

hard lark
#

true

torpid ocean
floral shard
#

so the axe tier req is intentional then?

#

found a sellner worth of lumite on the ground free 100k🤑

torpid ocean
#

idk

torpid ocean
stable roost
#

Hoping people vote for the new one

#

Well it’s winning so

#

This is splendid

upbeat monolith
# torpid ocean

goated for having that idea and implementing it working 24 hrs!

#

Is making it so the initial cut can vary depending on which type of tree be something that’s feasible? Or would that all come down to axe type

lime kite
stable roost
upbeat monolith
stable roost
#

Like the great oak and great willow

upbeat monolith
#

You’ll be able to trim them to fit a lot faster which should reduce time I think

stable roost
#

Cause rn the great trees kinda break balance cause of their volume so more time should be spent on the initial cutting of the tree

#

So I don’t think it’ll reduce time much, it’ll kinda just make great trees similar to regular trees in terms of gathering time

torpid ocean
#

I just made 2 axes with different stats for the new system

stable roost
#

LMAO

torpid ocean
#

hoofer would need to actually add it because idk how to without breaking everything

upbeat monolith
stable roost
#

Mmm I wonder if you can ask hoofer to add it in like testing or summ

torpid ocean
#

well if I do add it, I'll need to change like all of the tree's toughness so they don't take longer to cut than before

marsh patio
#

every single thing in icelands is not worth it for the time it takes

marsh patio
#

and effort

#

and money

torpid ocean
#

I thought sapphire was still good

lime kite
stable roost
#

Eh…

marsh patio
#

besides sapphire

torpid ocean
#

well the only other thing is ice pine

stable roost
#

I think when I did testing with ice pine it was still mid

#

Lemme see

lime kite
#

sapphire might be good, i just hate waiting for things to spawn in steamhappy

marsh patio
#

its already basically impossible to get anywhere there without falling down and spending 10+ minutes figuring out how to get back up

#

it might be a skill issue

#

but then theres also the price just to get there

#

and ufo's cant even go there

fast yoke
#

yeah

stable roost
fast yoke
#

jak

#

can you make it so ufo can go on the lift in icelands

lime kite
stable roost
#

I meant ice pine

lime kite
#

oh

stable roost
#

It’s known as snow internally

#

Mm yeah ice pine needs a buff for sure

lime kite
stable roost
#

Only like 4-6k optimized

lime kite
#

It seems buggy for me lately

stable roost
#

lol no

#

It’s supposed to be for keeping your items intact in the case of an accidental disconnect

lime kite
#

alr 😄

stable roost
#

Yes

lime kite
stable roost
#

Idk why it’s suddenly being buggy tho

#

You using semi when hopping?

lime kite
#

yeah

stable roost
#

Cause apparently semi has issues with that

#

Ah, that explains it

lime kite
#

I just dont server hop anymore

stable roost
#

I honestly never server hop when gathering data, I never have a need to

torpid ocean
#

it was only really a thing for foraging

fast yoke
#

jak

torpid ocean
#

Hi

fast yoke
#

was flame thrower 200k back then

torpid ocean
#

i dont think the price has changed

stable roost
#

Ok

marsh patio
#

bro im pretty sure it was 200k

fast yoke
#

also how good is saphire

marsh patio
#

cause it says 324k

stable roost
#

Nuh it never was

fast yoke
#

is it worth it

torpid ocean
#

if you plan to be in the icelands alot

#

sure

marsh patio
#

oh buddy

stable roost
#

Also yeah Jak ice pine can use a buff

marsh patio
#

pls lower price

#

of flamethrower

stable roost
#

4-6k optimized so

torpid ocean
#

130>165

#

162.5>206.25

stable roost
#

Mm

#

Lemme see

torpid ocean
#

would be like 8.5k on high end

stable roost
#

Mhm

celest fiber
#

Buff flameslate and the obsidian belt

stable roost
#

Yeah a small flameslate buff wouldn’t hurt since it would get everything to 10k

celest fiber
floral shard
stable roost
#

mmm i may have but i dont remember

#

either way im gonna redo the data for it so

floral shard
#

What was I even doing for my ice pine data💀

stable roost
#

shrug

floral shard
#

Balance changes coming with fishing then?

fast yoke
#

how much is flame thrower again?

torpid ocean
stable roost
#

or was it luminescent kelp

torpid ocean
#

yea

#

both

stable roost
#

ok

torpid ocean
#

like 10%

stable roost
#

gotcha

torpid ocean
#

20

#

54>45

stable roost
#

wouldnt hurt to give flameslate a small buff too

#

like a teeny tiny one

torpid ocean
#

what are yalls optimized rates

stable roost
#

mmm lemme see

#

so i got like 6-7k with 2 trailers and like 8-9k with semi

#

mmm maybe it doesnt need a buff, lucky got like 10-11k optimized

torpid ocean
#

ya it seems alright

stable roost
#

hmmm lemme see what else...

#

mmmm with sapphire i was only able to get like 5k at most for optimized

#

but i think thats just cause of the awful spawn rate

#

so maybe like slightly increase the spawn rate for sapphire???

#

also if you want something easy to buff? quartz, because it is bad

floral shard
#

I would nerf magmite a little that buff flameslate

#

Then

stable roost
#

oh

#

no i think magmite should stay the same

floral shard
#

I did server hop a lot ig

torpid ocean
#

could increse spawnrate for that too

floral shard
#

I server hopped around 5-7 times per magmite only

torpid ocean
#

do you include loading time

floral shard
#

Yeppp

torpid ocean
#

dang

#

how long is that total do you think

floral shard
#

10 min?

#

My base is somewhat large

stable roost
#

bruh

#

hmmmm

floral shard
#

I did have a run where it was spawning oddly fast and I didn’t server hop at all lol

#

Regret not getting the potion for that one

#

Nvm 30 sec per hop

stable roost
#

sounda about right

floral shard
#

Just timed myself

torpid ocean
#

ok

#

its prob safe to increase spawnrate then

stable roost
#

ooo

#

yeah tbh

#

do the same for sapphire maybe

torpid ocean
#

yea

stable roost
#

and like, buff quartz

floral shard
#

ngl I never grinded saph before

stable roost
#

i barely got 1-2k optimized with that

floral shard
#

what ther rocks does quartz spawn in?

#

other

upbeat monolith
torpid ocean
#

what

#

no

#

wait till friday

stable roost
torpid ocean
#

then itll be better lol

floral shard
stable roost
#

mmm

#

either way quartz is mega buns

upbeat monolith
floral shard
#

clay is worth more than quartz per studcursed

stable roost
torpid ocean
upbeat monolith
#

Rip I haven’t crashed in ages lol

floral shard
#

could server hopping blue steel be viable?

#

I remember there being a good spawn location for it or smth

stable roost
#

mmmmm

lime kite
#

I thought server hopping wasnt an intended mechanic

stable roost
#

it isnt, doesnt mean you cant do it

floral shard
lime kite
floral shard
#

does greeb spawn in anything other than grimestone

stable roost
#

the unobtainable ore market

upbeat monolith
#

Damn crashed again 😦

stable roost
#

i HATE the unobtainable ore market

#

LMAO

#

whats funny is technically you could destroy it at any time

torpid ocean
#

add an area that spawns every possible rock and ore combination