Topic: Display points from each alliance member to Leader and/or Officers.

[noble schooner]

Reason: Prevents leeching

Why:This will help alliances keep better track of who contributes to alliance score with how many alliance tasks they have done. Each member can contribute a total of 9 points. We can simply display how many points the member is at. This will help out alot since someone can join an alliance an do 3/9 tasks an receive the same rewards as someone who did 9/9 alliance tasks.

Additional: There is already a function that displays how many days members were offline. Can use this same idea an apply it to display how many points each an every person in the alliance is at. Even have space for this if the picture I provided. Can be 1 column that updates as the daily as the alliance ranking updates.

[torpid mountain]

Each member can contribute a total of 9 points

Incorrect. Each can pick up to 9 refreshed tasks per week. Completing previous ones the week after will still contribute, up to much more than 9 total.

[balmy island]

Why not just ask members to post SS of completed Alli tasks, and if they dont, kick?

[sick whale]

The notion that someone in an alliance is "leeching" based off of their number of alliance tasks completed is some toxic mentality that I think NGS can do without.

What even is there to leech in an alliance? The alliance mag? Alliance creative space? Perhaps your alliance makes purchases in the base shop, but that is wholly disconnected from NGS and alliance tasks in NGS. If your criteria for leeching is number of alliance tasks disregarding any amount of interaction within the alliance, then I think the focus of your alliance is a bit misguided.

There is no tangible benefit to alliance tasks in an alliance aside from Alliance ARKS Records and the Alliance Badge Shop - and the latter is individual. Alliance ARKS Record is just a matter of 5 / 3 / 1 Beta Reactors a week - which is trivially overshadowed by doing daily/weekly/playing for 15 minutes.

This suggestion reads as someone trying to get SEGA to automate toxic behavior and I don't think that should be supported.

[exotic sable]

People who care about rankings will like to gather people with same mindset and work together towards rankings
It’s the person that already been informed beforehand but still refuse to contribute causing trouble, it’s not toxic to call them out
“How can people want to leech just a few reactors while 15mins of dailies/weeklies can already cover that?” Oh boy you really underestimate how lazy and shameless a person can be

[sick whale]

If you want to enforce your alliance doing tasks, then there are already ways of doing so. The game does not need to automate and streamline people being toxic and having an elitist attitude. If the only focus an alliance has for its membership is hitting 9/9 tasks, then I think the alliance should be abolished.

The fixation on alliance tasks is already a blight - one that SEGA partially alleviated by offloading the SG aspect to alliance badges.

The fact that you consider it "leeching" is problematic because there is effectively nothing to "leech" from it - which somehow makes you think of people as further shameless rather than realizing it is inconsequential.

[exotic sable]

It’s their alli not yours, you don’t make the rules

Hardcore alli has hardcore rules, casual alli has casual rules, don’t try to mix one with another

[sick whale]

A "Hardcore alli" with their "hardcore rules" can deal with the consequences of maintaining their rules themselves.

SEGA should not facilitate "hardcore rules" at the detriment of other players, because clearly those rules do not belong as part of the norm.

[torpid mountain]

*Topic: Display AC spent by other players

Reason: Prevents leeching.

Why: This will help out a lot since someone can join the game and be free to play and receive the same social interaction and enjoyment from this game as someone who spent 10k AC (supporting the game) when we could socially isolate them so easily if this were to be implemented.*

Hopefully this feedback is noticed the way it deserves.

[exotic sable]

Again it’s their alli not yours, if their rules scare off newcomers it’s their own consequences they deserved, not your business to care of nor any outsider should involve

[exotic sable]

Open your own thread

[torpid mountain]

You said it so perfectly fine. Their rules, their issue. Mine doesn't allow ugly people and ain't asking for an ugly-o-meter.

[torpid mountain]

And no, it's the same feedback just worded differently, but thanks for the offer. 🙏🏻📿

[exotic sable]

Not even close but whatever tho

[torpid mountain]

It hasn't been an issue for 13 years and it is one now how again?

[exotic sable]

Make whatever rules you want, it’s your alli

[torpid mountain]

Make your rules and find your ways, correct.

[exotic sable]

Your alli, you make the rules, no others can judge you

[modern sparrow]

Alliance ranking was a mistake.

[split gorge]

Adding what you suggest is just gonna make it easier to see which Alliance been doing the rotating door method of kicking out members that already completed their task and replace with new ones.

We don’t need to minmax rankings this way.

[exotic sable]

Can’t remember details but sega should already addressed it long ago, nowadays no alli does that anymore

[lucid jolt]

There aren't really that many new players to swap around anymore.
Even on ship 2 alliances struggle to reach 900 points sometimes. So I guess they had to stop.
There is also inflation and dailies completely eating up the 500/300k

[simple falcon]

NGS got a wave of new players through Playstation.
Alliances taking advantage of new players and kicking them, leaving a horrible impression for the community.
NGS suffering from lack of new players.
Gee.... I wonder why.....
(there's many other factors in play, I know).

[split gorge]

[noble schooner]

Some ppl don’t use discord. An that’s fine y block a whole group of ppl just cause they don’t use an app.

Naw everyone is welcome .

Also maybe to you 500, 300 or even 100k is not much but to f2p players that’s something.

If you put in the work to help your alliance y is it that someone who puts in the bare minimum get the same exact rewards. That doesn’t make sense.

Thats leeching. I mean you feel differently that’s fine

[noble schooner]

lol

[noble schooner]

Appreciate you

[noble schooner]

Sega has addressed this issue…not a issue for mine tho since we do it legit can’t speak for others

[sand grove]

as a f2p honestly 500k is a few PSE bursts, about 15 minutes of work in the Alnothe mines

[noble schooner]

Well I’m speaking from a week to week standpoint…an weekly you get a fresh 9

[noble schooner]

Great…for doing alliance you get another free 300 to 500k for even let’s work

[noble schooner]

Now instead of just having 1 avenue of meseta you have more coming in basically for free

[noble schooner]

I mean well this isn’t just for a hardcore alliance this can be implemented for alliances that wanna just be in the top 30 are content with just be there. Or maybe alliances that want to get they’re community more active

Not just about being a hardcore alliance

[noble schooner]

Then there should be consequences for alliances that do so.

I cant speak on that since we have never an will never do some like that

[split gorge]

Don't care, you are opening the doors for others to capitalize on it. It's pretty much being brought back through this way regarless how honorable you may be and we can agree we can't speak for others that want to exploit.

[exotic sable]

Iirc sega has stated somewhere that it’s bannable so no alli risk it anymore since then

[split gorge]

No rational person would

This potentially would be treated as a work around if allowed

[noble schooner]

I mean Thai already happened an Sega addressed the alliances that were doing this.

If this were to happen a ppl exploit it would be simple to just report it

There are already exploits that give some alliances an edge that others just won’t have

[noble schooner]

The door has already been opened for exploits but if done correctly this can benefit the ppl who do things the right way