#Unshielding / Shielded transfer broken ?

1 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

wintry wedge
#

It seems that for most (all ?) of us, shielded transfer are broken and end up with a VP error

keen cedar
#

thanks! will alert devs

wintry wedge
#

grarco already responded on the issue, I think they're investigating already. Some people seem to be able @candid cliff mentionned he managed to do a transfer. Maybe @topaz sequoia too ?

topaz sequoia
# wintry wedge grarco already responded on the issue, I think they're investigating already. So...

I'll try to test it out while on the move via phone.

It does seem that for some reason my shielded-sync resetted completely, so have to do this again. I think it happened either by:

  • Running two shielded-sync's accidentally at once, or
  • Cause of trying to shielded-sync a new VK (after I was already synced) by implicitly calling the command with the --viewing-keys flag.

This will make it slower for me to get up to speed again and test it out.

wintry wedge
#

Feel free to share your commands for what works and what does not work

topaz sequoia
#

Okay hmm, I tried. You're right, VP rejects the following:

  • Shielded => Transparent (Unshielding)
  • Shielded => Shielded

Transparent => Shielded did work.

#

Log for Unshielding (armor is my shielded addr, zen is my transparent address):

namada client transfer --source armor --target zen --token naan --memo $MEMO --amount 5 --gas-payer zen
Transaction added to mempool.
Wrapper transaction hash: 085CD2806C23A4861EEC052E2A8AF7CE66A5DEFBC6E10EFFD39E2C40A8BA0F0D
Inner transaction hash: 96CFCF65A5F72B9A59619BD12820AE2CAFBD6F77FBDC9185F8A1964ADAB85261
Wrapper transaction accepted at height 245244. Used 70 gas.
Waiting for inner transaction result...
Transaction was rejected by VPs: [
  "tnam1pcqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqzmefah"
].
Changed keys: [
  "#tnam1pcqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqzmefah/commitment_tree",
  "#tnam1pcqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqzmefah/nullifiers/B338AE0D8C50E1FDC434DDEB52B56065FBC7F46E033DB4AA355761EC068C22E2",
  "#tnam1pyqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqej6juv/#tnam1qxvg64psvhwumv3mwrrjfcz0h3t3274hwggyzcee/balance/#tnam1pcqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqzmefah",
  "#tnam1pyqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqej6juv/#tnam1qxvg64psvhwumv3mwrrjfcz0h3t3274hwggyzcee/balance/#tnam1qq22qmw72m3e6c8lajx8jmzzh2h4t3dp7cfs4dxf"
]
Last committed epoch: 62
Transaction added to mempool.
Wrapper transaction hash: 943EDB45B0897B4153987337870D65E4F076908A85F232D7E0A8D54D2AF5873D
Inner transaction hash: 58F1D628C9666F534079A0C2F262760FD1507844FDDD65F34BD76ADD21691AD6
Wrapper transaction accepted at height 245246. Used 70 gas.
Waiting for inner transaction result...
Transaction was rejected by VPs: [
  "tnam1pcqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqzmefah"
].
Changed keys: [
  "#tnam1pcqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqzmefah/commitment_tree",
  "#tnam1pcqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqzmefah/nullifiers/7D5FAF80F162374C7D25B36EAB31191C9CCD8E910A2F9EF4D88FFB529F4BC68C",
  "#tnam1pyqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqej6juv/#tnam1qxvg64psvhwumv3mwrrjfcz0h3t3274hwggyzcee/balance/#tnam1pcqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqzmefah",
  "#tnam1pyqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqej6juv/#tnam1qxvg64psvhwumv3mwrrjfcz0h3t3274hwggyzcee/balance/#tnam1qq22qmw72m3e6c8lajx8jmzzh2h4t3dp7cfs4dxf"
]
Last committed epoch: 62
#

Log for Shielded => Shielded (the payment address is of a different shielded address):

namada client transfer --source armor --target znam1qqtnyzu97zknt3sff74aj8fnxxx6lr5gke2vqp8w8pmxz7dp25rt7jsmq46dn2g2t0al2ps2paryv --token naan --memo $MEMO --amount 5 --gas-payer zen
Transaction added to mempool.
Wrapper transaction hash: EC358F8D0DDC8322FB8ACF2DC537856E1871800B91CCF9FF24E16326BDC2374A
Inner transaction hash: 15985D85D3C6D241C16D667136A13993C7B3D81E0B4396282C713760F73AB181
Wrapper transaction accepted at height 245255. Used 67 gas.
Waiting for inner transaction result...
Transaction was rejected by VPs: [
  "tnam1pcqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqzmefah"
].
Changed keys: [
  "#tnam1pcqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqzmefah/commitment_tree",
  "#tnam1pcqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqzmefah/nullifiers/B338AE0D8C50E1FDC434DDEB52B56065FBC7F46E033DB4AA355761EC068C22E2"
]
Last committed epoch: 62
Transaction added to mempool.
Wrapper transaction hash: 0A6FC7A5D643EC07AE93708633D1F693470E093CE31B2F817243A53D0589F2D3
Inner transaction hash: 0DA5D0085B1FB496FDB92E195C346E7692BEC21635571E96E1368B639513F5D7
Wrapper transaction accepted at height 245257. Used 67 gas.
Waiting for inner transaction result...
Transaction was rejected by VPs: [
  "tnam1pcqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqzmefah"
].
Changed keys: [
  "#tnam1pcqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqzmefah/commitment_tree",
  "#tnam1pcqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqzmefah/nullifiers/7D5FAF80F162374C7D25B36EAB31191C9CCD8E910A2F9EF4D88FFB529F4BC68C"
]
Last committed epoch: 62
wintry wedge
#

yep, correct. Ok so the bug seems to be everyone accross the board. Just waiting for hkey who said yesterday he had fixed his shielding issue

topaz sequoia
wintry wedge
#

that's a very good point !
That would prevent someone from messing the shielded.dat file

topaz sequoia
wintry wedge
#

😄

#

at least, we're right after the HF, so syncing again is fast

topaz sequoia
#

Yess it was quite fast

charred saffronBOT
#
jojoraky has been warned

Reason: Posted a link

tidal stratus
#

oh shoot

wintry wedge
#

🤣 you've been MEE sixt !

#

@cedar garden you can report here once you've tested on youru side !

tidal stratus
#

😆

#

h ttps://github.com/anoma/namada/issues/2967#issuecomment-2025309864 team responded

#

Complicated issue idk anything about it haha

wintry wedge
#

I love it when they respond with cryptic technical terms and Im here scratching my head "ok, what did he actually say 🤔 ?" ... "oh yeah, we are looking for solutions"

tidal stratus
#

😆 haha make sense

keen cedar
#

we're discussing this now with devs

#

@candid cliff were you able to do something? that would make sense to me if it's purely a client issue

primal scaffold
#

A lot of player will get approve point in task Bug =]]

novel cypress
#

Shielding transfer works.
Shielded transfers are being rejected by the MASP VP.
Unshielding transfers are being rejected by the MASP VP.

stray kestrel
#

for me too

reef hatch
#

Hi,
I did shielded transfers, and all works fine:

Transparent => Shielded
B20712E49658369824D8F5D61AD67F00E0E3FD9CA907DD915853E30E2DE6CDDD

Shielded => Shielded
A587B609C86BFD6DA5199CF7E3D9BD57F96B1837CB7D2472F17794CA54650BDE

Shielded => Transparent
E429E3E557335906A0D8304A2E935F966A9E9D960C20989C2D4A3E4419E1414F

novel cypress
reef hatch
novel cypress
#

It's not an expected behaviour anyway, let's see what team has to say after investigating

reef hatch
wintry wedge
candid cliff
copper mural
#

@reef hatch Did you run exactly namadac shielded-sync --from-height 237907 every minute?

#

It always starts fetching from block 237907, I think it takes a lot of time after a while? Isn't it

keen cedar
tidal stratus
#

Apologies not sure,

lone warren
#

Not working

lone warren
tidal stratus
wintry wedge
#

Yep that's the first thing I tested yesterday when I had the issue. Not working

weak cave
reef hatch
last tundra
topaz sequoia
void dirge
robust solstice
#

are shielded transactions fixed? have anybody tried it recently?

lone warren
keen cedar
#

@here devs say it will take some days to have a work-around (not solution), probably next week we will have something. no hard fork, it will likely just be a client change

robust solstice
#

i see the same error with vp reject for shielding ibc-transfer, anybody did shielding ibc transfer correctly?