Issues with Batch B 🐠

[empty current]

pls tag @winged raft if you have any issues

[fringe forge]

@winged raft, our submission was sent by 16.02, but I don't see it in the spreadsheet. I also have a screenshot of the submission. Could you please double-check it?

[empty current]

@rose python pls work w Spork here (i can't do 1:1 support by DM)

[misty scroll]

I also sent two tasks on February 16th, but I don't see them

[rose python]

Hi @winged raft I also sent a request on February 19th, but I am not on the list.
tpknam1qzaq68ktlmru7g873fjhezyfmjzg24az5yta3dwrgryglylk6a2kwj5ty5r

[fringe forge]

Our address, btw 👉 tpknam1qzscetsy54ma0x6amzamfuvrvx2lalsms6uz03uayccah7ryytgvv560v68

[dense hamlet]

For example if our indexer was rejected, and after some time we fix it, and it will work. Should we submit this task again?

[fringe forge]

@polar light, please paste the link with spaces between the dots to evade bot blocks

[polar light]

@winged raft Hi, my explorer is in a different category, why is it marked as a duplicate, maybe they got it wrong? The line in the document is 146, here is my link https: // namada-explorer.sined222. xyz/

[winged raft]

happy to, do you have your public key?

[winged raft]

do you have your public key?

[fringe forge]

#1210652838984941659 message

[rose python]

my public key: tpknam1qzaq68ktlmru7g873fjhezyfmjzg24az5yta3dwrgryglylk6a2kwj5ty5r

[winged raft]

no need, just @ me when it's working again and i'll check it out

[quaint rivet]

@winged raft i also sent my submission (operating namada rpc) on february 16, but i don't see myself in the table. my public key: tpknam1qz69pw6txezn0lrgapdyx0gx38tgdkzggplnzq68pkefnlwspf28jvmvytu

[misty scroll]

tpknam1qztk3xek678p7h7l3yl4pe80xxusassg9wwnez3yme2m3xc8jjruushmsmf
``` this is matched with pk in chrome extension

[rich fossil]

I also send my submition but I don`t see myself on the table tpknam1qrlu4t3y8s632eq4jzhdxkt3jahcgf2wkg466ck43jscfd380x5w7tm3dhq

[gusty canyon]

@winged raft
Hi! When I sent the RPC everything worked well, apparently when you checked, I was updating the node due to a new patch. You can check now that everything is working correctly.
I am 162 row in the table
My public key tpknam1qp4jrzt5xmdnhzg893f6avv2lnsw3rhqr2j8xv9av5jhhudaezln2nupw4f

[winged raft]

I'm not finding anything for that public key in our form submission feed, can you dm me the submisison details?

[fringe forge]

Sure

[winged raft]

thanks! fixed

[polar light]

Thank you.🙏

[winged raft]

not finding an entry yet but can you dm me?

[rose python]

sure, minute

[tawdry heart]

I just add feedback for #260 page is too simple and outdate already with chain . but #239 got rejected 😄

[winged raft]

no luck finding it yet but please dm me!

[fringe forge]

Sent a DM

[winged raft]

don't see a submission but please dm me

[quaint rivet]

sure, just dm'd

[winged raft]

not finding it yet but please dm me!

[winged raft]

lgtm, thanks, updated the sheet

[misty scroll]

check dm

[rich fossil]

Please check dm

[undone lava]

@winged raft Hello. I sent rpc and explorer. My rpc is not in the table.
My public key is tpknam1qqectlsnk443lc5m4s746ew20md3fetm96xdzc72rt8tvceyhfysys5pzq8

[manic finch]

Hey @winged raft , i sent two submissions on 16th Feb , but none of them are included in the sheet
my public address :

tpknam1qprzf0s5vtjqg09qyymul22msekwdnqfw5sxyex2th3l3cggpt4h62ysz9z

[dusky hill]

should I resend my indexer endpoint if there was inactive?

[winged raft]

we have the explorer submission but can you dm me the submission details for the rpc?

[winged raft]

you can @ me when it's working again so i can take a second look

[sullen star]

@winged raft hey hey . my explorer should be under Building Namada ecosystem integrations and tooling not under running namada as service / please check . thanks

[wet crystal]

@empty current for number 225 we submitted 3 different contributions and it was classified as spam? Really?

[empty current]

pls tag @winged raft

[wet crystal]

As for the reasoning, aren’t all indexers just a deployment of namadexer?! And RPCs just a running node?

The task didn’t say to create anything new, at least not in the public goods category.
@winged raft

Tried to avoid spamming the submit task button by doing 3 tasks in one and it gets classified as spam 😂

[empty current]

okay but don't spam this thread now 😉

pls let Spork eat some food and then check what's up? if he's a jerk to you, then you can fill the thread with indignation

[sour yoke]

I've sent my submission on February 20th but unfortunately can't find myself in the table.
My public key:
tpknam1qztkcjqpfnctc9ts5ysjgwv0zwjdcrt2f7jjaa2x2rhzgc0sdt95vcvecz7

[hollow axle]

How come 229 is accepted as a vulnerability/security S class for spamming the faucet, but 44 is not ?
Can anyone explain ?
@empty current or @winged raft ?

[winged raft]

you're right, fixed now!

[pallid gyro]

right

there is a mistake

in the comment of submission 229 it says Faucet spam but not a security vulnerability but it was approved, probably a mistake
@empty current

[hollow axle]

Also, why is 129 refused ?
Are these tasks evaludated by techincal or non technical people ?
I mean, have you tried using the CLI with or without this autocomplete tool ? This is a gamer changer when you're looking for the correct argument for a command

[winged raft]

sorry, this probably happened because the links to the rpc/indexer were obscured by the columns in the sheet. this qualifies for points, i'll update it

[wet crystal]

Thank you 🙏

[full mortar]

hello, #242 mark my indexing not work but it's working , can you recheck ?

[empty current]

glad you're notifying us, but pls tag @winged raft (not me)

[lusty pewter]

I agree
I don't understand why a simple not so usefull frontends are rewarded but not the cli autocompleter (disclaimer I wrote it) it maybe short in code lines number but it is very usefull and I writing it took me one full day (*sh scripting is hard)
and It is really usefull to the project
every serious tool has a an autocomplete

[shell girder]

tpknam1qrj4pnajqheqwnjrvpx7hw2vu9a7nn33cv0734arwsyxk9fs8mxwwyxsllt
Not finding my submission

[winged raft]

agree, auto completer is small but pretty handy. deserves points, i've made the change to the sheet

[winged raft]

looks good to me, fixed on the sheet

[winged raft]

not finding it either, can you dm me your submisison?

[dusky hill]

https://indexer.namada.n1stake.com/block/last

Could you check it, thanks!

[hollow axle]

@winged raft Not sure I understand why the 266 submission is valid

[winged raft]

looks good! fixed

[hollow axle]

(see my comment on the spreadsheet for the details)

[winged raft]

i don't see any extra features, so i'm not sure what the notes are referring to either... will have to ask someone about this

[winged raft]

i can't find a matching submission for this but can you pls dm me the details and we'll get it sorted

[faint grove]

What does it mean when it's yellow marked?

[chrome lichen]

phoenixv110 has been warned

Reason: Posted a link

[dawn mango]

@lusty pewter Is there any Batch C as my submission is not there. My address tpknam1qq78mp640t445hjju35sz8kjhs2c9wc05jxuelx6e28kq4xunepfjdc8kcd

[viscid ruin]

@winged raft in task #220 the comment says: 'No endpoints from what i could see, cool but cannot be verified', but then it is written Yes for the points even in the comment it says it cannot be verified?

[lusty pewter]

got the same comment for the 226
I don't see what it does that namada.me doesn't have
it seem ot be just a clone
anyway a github url would be nicer so I could see the commits
I cannot udnerstanbd how open source it is if there is no code

[lusty pewter]

I'm no team sorry

[nimble falcon]

hello, @winged raft can you please check tpknam1qzgn0juwqgvzx30p59dpscnf4v2tj5uqp8fgmqvv0gyc7zzv84r3x4lqq6l for task relayer I didn't see it on the spreadsheets. Thank you

[full mortar]

thanks , on #246 mark duplicate but it's namada <> cosmos relayer , #245 is namada <> osmos , please recheck

[hollow axle]

I think the rule mentionned in the FAQ is "1 submission per category". So 1 relayer is enough to score, no need to do 2

[full mortar]

I see cases are approved twice for different IBCs, is there a difference?

#199 , #202 , #217

[hollow axle]

@winged raft ☝️ Duplicates in IBC Channel subcategory for a single account

[hollow axle]

It should be accepted only once. Otherwise they need to all agree on what's what. Can we submit multiple relayers or you get the same amount of points, whether you submit 1 or 5 ( that is what's in the FAQ)

This address actually has 5 : tpknam1qz06fyhkje5ez4wk6plghydug9htgadtq7xucjhxj8rzhwj9jfxfzujumay

[hollow moon]

@empty current check please tpknam1qpy32vfy7vlyteqly4clalqj399u47ykhnw2k4sukrcjxufn08t876zxgyg I submit 16.02 IBC chanell with Babylon testnet. #🫂︱se-community-support message

[frosty phoenix]

@empty current I completed S CLASS ASTEROID SUBMITTED with IBC relaye on Feb 20th, but I can't find my submission in the documentation. can you confirm?

• tpknam1qqhat5nkkkjhvas5z8s4zk6adcfshprd9wxrk407uwa98ddhkwsucfqmnd7

[chrome lichen]

kadieu has been warned

Reason: Posted a link

[soft parcel]

@winged raft, I have sent proof regarding the s-class assignment, delivery at approximately 09:00 PM at 2024-02-23, class type is operating namada infrastructure as a service by providing Public RPC endpoint. The following is proof of our RPC URL htt ps://rpc.kadieu.xyz.
I would be very happy if the data I submitted could be updated on the S-Class Submission spreadsheet.

my public address tpknam1qr0wzjl3hv2zhc0r8u3g0zqtnknpx4sd4e6fjxccw6rdcwzckpstqwj60gk

thanks

[tawdry heart]

I can see this wallet #228 submit multiple Relayer still valid for same sub-class task #75 #159 #181 #228 same subclass task ?

[pallid gyro]

166 is not a security vuln. but marked as Finding security vulnerabilities
@winged raft

[dense hamlet]

it is fixed now, can you check it, or you want me to send you the link in DM ? @winged raft

#176

[wild bramble]

@winged raft I have a submission of rpc related task, much earlier than 20.2.2024, but I didn't see it listed in the sheet, can you check it? thanks, my public key is: tpknam1qzndq3sytzpv6z0t6ufug47g7kc0x7xpk3d228swfy3rz2zlp7v8cmd2xt8

[tired garnet]

Hi, line 240 - this was the first version of the browser, I've improved my explorer, added a search, and now you're showing all the blocks and all the validators @winged raft

[normal oasis]

Hi @winged raft I submitted relayer task 20th, but cannot find record in google sheet. could you please help to double check ?

PK: tpknam1qr8plwnj863wsa8lcm92daynl3u8z68uyjtkj8m0l6c6e3rry0euxhyey48
Evidence: https://github.com/bngq323/docs/blob/main/se_osmosis_testnet_relayer.md

[cyan birch]

Hi, I don't see myself, I sent the task on the 20th of the day rpc. alaina. tech , my public key: tpknam1qp2yhc5zchqf39drdmysqamdmw37elrxlrfn3nx8qwkz2e7munetxycqq8x2 @winged raft

[knotty igloo]

@deft pivot 11

@faint stone 1

[raven perch]

Hi sir @winged raft , Could you please help to check my task for relayer submission not found on the doc file?
And when I submit S class , there is a problem about User is not a Shielded Expedition participant.
Here is my Pubkey:
tpknam1qrq9x32kr46r3drz7830azdwww6ve0mj27kx6xexnlyy7pk7em4hjxy0a4h

[dusty linden]

First follow the steps here. Otherwise manually submit it #📣-se-announcements message

[desert dock]

@winged raft I submitted two s-class on the morning of feb 20, so I assume they should be here if they were processed in a linear fashion?

I may have typed one word wrong in one of them which may add some confusion, can provide correction if needed

[dusty linden]

Did you see them in the excel sheet?

[desert dock]

no.

but I see a few others have the same, so assuming it may be due to internal workload distribution in team or someth. just wanted to flag it in case it got lost/missed

[cobalt magnet]

@winged raft task#147 I have fixed the rpc rpc-namada.kryptogem.xyz
There was an issue with the configuration.

[full mortar]

yeah true, that's reason I asked is there a diff between 1 approve and 5 approve

[timber yarrow]

@winged raft Hi, couldn't find myself on the lists, sent earlier this week, my key is tpknam1qpefndqklsjhw4f2sjee570697ak74f28p207awyqh6hz5y25kuujugrhs7
my rpc rpc-namada. edatsushi. tech

[desert thistle]

is the excel sheet public? where can i see that? i just wanna make sure if i submitted correctly

[desert thistle]

it already in announcement, sorry my fault

[rough lava]

How do i submit my s task manually since i get user isn't a shielded expedition from the extension, I'm using the latest 02.4 version and still not work on both edge n chrome

[lusty pewter]

@winged raft how can I be sure the ROID will (when) be updated after you update the spreadsheet ? since it's a bit shadowy. thx

[rough lava]

Manually submit through discord??? @winged raft the extension doesn't work on my end for both chrome and edge, I'm unable to submit s class, what the way out ?

[fringe forge]

What's the problem on your end?

[rough lava]

It says users isn't shielded expedition participants when I click on submit

[fringe forge]

cc @winged raft

[rough lava]

@fringe forge @winged raft ....

I am unable to submit due to extension error, our S task is operating namada infrastructure as a service by providing public Rpc endpoint.

Below is the evidence of our Rpc url that's has been used and still in synch with the network. http:// 104.251.222.134:26657/

Our Pubkey :tpknam1qrvsyrczhgm2v6k0pkwawuy8049shsvz2l5xde7gpcpnyuzeg9znxv2xtcu. I would be happy if this can updated on the S class submission spreadsheet.

[fringe forge]

Thank you for the details. Please wait for the Spork response; no need for multiple pings

[dusty linden]

Just post it here, and spork will respond back. This thread as you can see is for such queries. Also please don't tag one person multiple times.

[desert dock]

rather the correct thread for this is #1210426293087371314

I think?

[dusty linden]

Actually its https://discord.com/channels/833618405537218590/1210649213499871243

@rough lava can you post your isseue and submission here. Spork will get to it when he gets a chance

[desert dock]

ah right, they locked the other one

[empty current]

pls tag Spork

[empty current]

pls tag Spork

[hollow moon]

@winged raft check please tpknam1qpy32vfy7vlyteqly4clalqj399u47ykhnw2k4sukrcjxufn08t876zxgyg I submit 16.02 IBC chanell with Babylon testnet. But don't see it in your list. #🫂︱se-community-support message

[frosty phoenix]

@winged raft I completed S CLASS ASTEROID SUBMITTED with IBC relaye on Feb 20th, but I can't find my submission in the documentation. can you confirm?

• tpknam1qqhat5nkkkjhvas5z8s4zk6adcfshprd9wxrk407uwa98ddhkwsucfqmnd7

[cyan crag]

Hi, I guess the network was down during the test, now my rpc is working, line 253, rpc-namada. systemus. site @winged raft

[fair topaz]

Hello, @winged raft. We've submitted 2 S class tasks on Feb 20, but they are nowhere to be found in the Google Sheets. Please advise.

tpknam1qrm5husws0a3lzgfll7v23h768lacw3c9xmz8h0xunkg48rt5rjsxcej4u2

L.E.: it seems like one of our tasks was there, so 1 more submission that we can't find in the Sheets

[winged raft]

hey all, hope everyone had a great weekend
we'll be working through the posts sequentially and putting 👀 emojis when they've been reviewed. as you can see, there's some backlog here, not to mention the other threads and my dm's so i ask that you bear with me. but i'll get to everyone's concerns as soon as i'm able.

a couple things:

• afaik the nebb hasn't been updated yet but hopefully today; working with the team on it this morning
• it is always possible to make changes whether it's the 4th entry or the 200th entry on the sheet, you don't have to worry about things being finalized prematurely and missing the boat (until the end of s-e which will be announced ahead of time)
• duplicates will be removed by automation prior to going in the nebb. including eg: if someone submitted multiple ibc channels as separate submissions... i've been fixing any i come across just because i think it makes it more clear for people reading the sheet, but it's not strictly necessary to flag them and will be handled by the scripts
• team is looking into the submissions backend about why some were left off the sheet, and it's possible some of the issues will be resolved this way in the meantime without extra steps from us. but either way we'll keep you posted

[winged raft]

yes, i see three submissions matching that public key in the queue so they will be included in a future batch

[winged raft]

i think it means we don't have a way to verify correctness of the data displayed... (but the tool itself is checked and operational)

[winged raft]

see a submission for rpc but not ibc relayer; can you pls dm me the submission details?

[winged raft]

i see a submission for rpc (awaiting review) but not ibc relayer, can you dm me the details?

[winged raft]

i see a submission for ibc relayer and one for security vulnerability in the queue to be included in the next batch; if this is not correct pls feel free to dm

[dense hamlet]

@winged raft can check on this please?

[winged raft]

i can see it in the queue (plus another for ibc relayer) so it will be in a future batch

[winged raft]

true, there's not really a good category for it though tbh

[winged raft]

can you dm me the details pls?

[winged raft]

oh awesome, great job! updated to points=yes

[winged raft]

thanks! i'll make sure it gets added to the batch i'm working on now

[winged raft]

will make sure it gets added to the next batch

ty, fixed!

[winged raft]

glad to check, what's your public key?

[frosty phoenix]

Thanks! Correct!

[winged raft]

rpc looks good, just to confirm you're tpknam1qzr84ydtsd2zg28k62qwds37x446pjy3zcsmwy5rcfdhejuwdezm72gaccy?

[winged raft]

ty! looks good, will make sure it gets added

[winged raft]

i see a submission for rpc but not for ibc; can you pls dm me the ibc submission details?

[winged raft]

ty, updated!

[winged raft]

i see an entry for ibc relayer and another still in the queue for review (building protocol improvements) from today, is that everything? please feel free to dm if something's missing

[winged raft]

ty, looks good! although you already have points in that category for your rpc so it won't affect your score

i've tried to work from top to bottom with 👀 , did i skip anybody by accident along the way?

[dense hamlet]

yeah i know 🫡 thanks for reviewing

[quaint rivet]

@winged raft hi! so we now need to resubmit our tasks, and not dm you?

[dense hamlet]

can you also check this please #168 ?

[winged raft]

@heresee #📣-se-announcements message about missing submissions
up until now i've been asking people to dm me, but as there's so many more people affected than first thought from this point forward we'll kindly ask you to resubmit your tasks the usual way. this will make it much easier for us as we'll have a centralized record of everything.

if you've already dm'd me prior to this announcement then you should already be good, and you can find your submission on the sheet in the light green background. you don't need to resubmit in that case

ty and lmk if you have any questions

[desert dock]

is that all submissions between feb 16 and feb 20 that were lost? I can resubmit, but seeing as submitted feb 20, I want to be sure it doesn't put me in lesser standing in the queue.

[winged raft]

yes, the team is evaluating all the submissions sent to security email themselves, but it may take a little longer for that to be updated given the evaluation is a little more involved

[winged raft]

no not all, and i'm not sure why some were lost and not others. but when in doubt you can resubmit

[desert dock]

would you mind checking if mine are there somewhere or would you rather I just resubmit?

[winged raft]

i can check, what's your public key?

[dense hamlet]

ok and if we dont see our submission in batch C, but we submitted the task around 24 feb. Should we resubmit?

[winged raft]

sorry but can't find anything for either, def resubmit

[winged raft]

anything after feb 20 should be unaffected
i see one from feb 24 for you for security vulnerabilities (in the queue, not on the sheet yet), is that the one you mean?

[dense hamlet]

yeah 👍 then everything is ok

[desert dock]

thanks!

we are good to submit in both classes if we compete as both pilot and crew right? (different tasks)

[dusty linden]

@winged raft I submitted some tasks around Feb 24th too, just checking if they got through. Can resubmit if needed 🙂

[winged raft]

i see two from yesterday for the explorer, was one meant to be your other task?

[winged raft]

yep

[dusty linden]

Yep, another one was for security vulnerabilities with crew wallet 🙂

[desert dock]

security vulnerabilities 👀👀👀

not jealous at all 😅