new shakers with magnetic strip for phones and a compartment for powder

[eternal nest]

As someone who stores metallic things in their bag which would be next to the shaker that would be such a ball ache and an annoyance

[junior quiver]

simple solution to that kodi, just dont buy the shaker with the magnetic strip then lol. not every product is for everyone

[eternal nest]

Was just a comment as i'm not the only one that has the situation of putting metalic stuff in their bag. It's the kinda thought that has to go into products. But yeah sure I won't buy it. Good comment on 👍

[junior quiver]

you can say the same about your comment, if someone asks for something, you're marketing to the people that want that item, not the people who don't like the idea and wouldn't buy the item for personal reasons . its one thing to give a reason why a suggestion would be impossible or not feasible, or to explain it already exists / was already done, but its another to comment on idea because an option on it would annoy you if u had it even though you wouldn't buy it in the first place, making your comment a moot point. So yeah, good comment mentioning why you personally wouldn't buy the item 👍 .

[eternal nest]

Completely different scenarios. Giving feedback on a recommendation because it may actually prop up to multiple people and just putting a general point towards it is very different than being unhelpful and just saying "tee hee don't buy it lol"... But yeah sure fella, you do you. No one else is allowed to comment on any products with any ideas / problems they'd think because that's apparently bad according to Hoya

[junior quiver]

first , i wasnt talking about just "tee hee don't buy it" comments, i was talking about "here's why i wouldn't buy what you're suggesting " posts like yours. i think this is exactly the same scenario, you are literally turning down the idea of adding a magnetic strip to a shaker because you would be annoyed that your metal items in your bag would get stuck to the magnet. If someone is suggesting the idea, obviously there are people who want the idea to happen, and this is for the people who would buy the item to comment. what you're doing is just saying the reason you wouldn't buy the item, which is a moot point because not everyone is going to like every product, and the simple solution is to just don't buy it if you don't like it, and leave it for the constructive criticism posts like explaining an idea already exists or explaining why an idea can't be done. People can comment on ideas, its just that they shouldnt be comments about why they wouldnt buy the product due their own personal reasons.

[eternal nest]

Mhm okay buddy. So no one is every allowed to give criticism on any points at all? Pretty wrong. Since i've already asked and it's fine to give criticism. Sooooooooooo good one there fella. Carry on just shooting people down. This might be why people don't comment the negative ideas because people like you just come along and say "don't like it don't buy it" instead of letting them maybe bounce off different ideas / solutions.

Talking with you is like talking with a brick wall. We'll all just stay silent from now on because obviously criticism isn't allowed. Have fun bud. Enjoy

[junior quiver]

you are misunderstanding me. you can have criticisms, but they shouldnt specifically be using the idea someone is suggesting as a reason they wouldnt buy it. Like this case, someone suggesting a magnet strip so that metal things will stick to the shaker, and then you basically saying "i dont like it because my metal things will stick to the shaker" . there is a difference between criticizing and using the idea as the reason you dont like the idea. Criticisms are okay , but in this case you are literally just using the idea as a reason you dont like the idea. I feel like talking to you is like talking to a brick wall too.

[eternal nest]

Wow. Are you serious 😂 I'm giving an issue that it might arise. I gave a quick example of something that could become an annoyance. Obviously I know a magnetic strip will make magnetic things stick It's called an example fella. But yknow the instant solution is immediately "shut up don't buy it" that is literally what you do and did and always do lmao. Just keep quiet if you've got nothing to add on that helps slightly or that gives an extra idea or whatever. No one likes it and no one thinks it's welcoming. I literally never comment on these because of this exact reason but yknow i'll just listen to you fella :)

But yeah, I'll keep quiet and never give an example of anything and I'll make sure that I'll never comment on anything that I don't like just because "don't like it shut up don't buy it"

Also you look nothing like a mod. So maybe just shut up and raise it to a mod if you think it's wrong??

[junior quiver]

If this isnt "the pot calling the kettle black" i dont know what is. you aren't a mod either, so maybe you should follow your own advice and just shut up and raise it to a mod if you think im wrong. Your "criticism" was to say the idea was the exact reason you dont like the idea. The whole thing is moot at this point since the original post has now been deleted at this point. I'm not wasting any more time on this because I'm obviously not getting through your stubborn thick skull . This is worse than talking to a wall. Have fun turning down ideas just because you don't like them for the same reason someone else likes them and made the suggestion.