#[2.1.89] Mux costs more than it's supposed to

1 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

fleet sail
#

See related discusion here: #new-patch-talk message
Basically, Mux costs about twice as much gate as the Multiplexer solution.

fleet sail
#

[2.1.89] Mux costs more than it's supposed to

warped dew
#

The same problem. I have two Multiplexer solutions: 25/3 and 33/2. But the builtin Multiplexer component has 33/3 and 65/2 instead

fleet sail
#

Switch

  • Solution cost: N/A
  • Component cost: 16 gate 1 time

NAND

  • Solution cost: 8 gate 1 time
  • Component cost: 8 gate 1 time

NOT

  • Solution cost: 8 gate 1 time
  • Component cost: 8 gate 1 time

Add

  • Solution cost: 56 gate 18 time
  • Component cost: 64 gate 18 time

Mux

  • Solution cost: 33 gate 2 time
  • Component cost: 65 gate 2 time

Negate

  • Solution cost: 21 gate 8 time
  • Component cost: 21 gate 8 time

Delay Line

  • Solution cost: N/A
  • Component cost: 40 gate 4 time

Register

  • Solution cost: 80 gate 5 time
  • Component cost: 129 gate 5 time

Counter

  • Solution cost: 95 gate 13 time
  • Component cost: 128 gate 13 time

OR, AND, NOR

  • Solution cost: N/A
  • Component cost: 8 gate 1 time

Equal

  • Solution cost: 31 gate 5 time
  • Component cost: 32 gate 5 time

XOR, XNOR

  • Solution cost: 24 gate 2 time
  • Component cost: 32 gate 2 time

Low < (unsigned)

  • Solution cost: 73 gate 20 time
  • Component cost: 128 gate 20 time
#

Less < (signed)

  • Solution cost: 128 gate 20 time
  • Component cost: 128 gate 34 time

Count leading zero, Count trailing zero

  • Solution cost: 29 gate 4 time
  • Component cost: 32 gate 4 time

Shift Left, Shift Right, Rotate Left, Rotate Right, Arithmetic Shift Right

  • Solution cost: 99 gate 4 time
  • Component cost: 99 gate 4 time

Multiply

  • Solution cost: 576 gate 145 time
  • Component cost: 576 gate 145 time

Divide

  • Solution cost: 990 gate 160 time
  • Component cost: 990 gate 160 time

Modulo

  • Solution cost: 1.0k gate 161 time
  • Component cost: 1.0k gate 161 time

Increment

  • Solution cost: 22 gate 8 time
  • Component cost: 32 gate 8 time
#

It's a little disheartening to see just how many word components cost more than their associated solutions.

nimble vector
fleet sail
#

What about it?

nimble vector
fleet sail
#

Perhaps, but I'm not sure what I should say over there

prisma cairn
#

Can you DM me the game save folder @fleet sail :?

fleet sail
prisma cairn
#

Fixed in 2.1.96