#🧠|serious-chat

1 messages Ā· Page 860 of 1

rugged gyro
#

When everyone knows Christianity is against violence

slender coral
slender coral
toxic lake
#

Cough Cough. Rohingya genocide.

shy summit
#

Please do not delude yourself my dear.

wind zephyr
shy summit
#

Christianity is as guilty as Islam and whatever other religions you could name

toxic lake
slender coral
wind zephyr
shy summit
# rugged gyro Ok how?

Salem, the Crusades (obvs low hanging fruit), modern discriminatory practices, several genocides.

feral river
#

the opposite I would consider if you are talking me supporting an evil side

shy summit
#

Yeah… they ain’t exactly any better.

toxic lake
sturdy mango
#

I will clear this in 3 to 4 points

First: the Quran does not prescribe death for leaving Islam Belief and disbelief are repeatedly left to God’s judgment

Second: this report refers to zanadiqa, a historical term for people involved in political rebellion, or violent subversion not someone quietly changing belief

Third: even in this report, it is about state authority and courts, not individuals

Vigilante killing is forbidden in Islam

Reducing Islam to a single historical report while ignoring the Qur’an and centuries of scholarly debate is exactly the misinformation I was talking about

wind zephyr
feral river
#

justice or evil is subjective in broad general concept of public standard

shy summit
#

Kinda hard to say that Christianity is peaceful when I look out my window and my several local churches are preaching to end my existence.

sturdy mango
#

I’ve explained my position clearly
And now l’m not interested in going in circles

#

I don't think so when you have fault in your own religion you should blame others

feral river
shy summit
feral river
#

it is not before slavery abolished

rugged gyro
feral river
#

I would have a huge respect to people who have a commitment to support their life, but none for anyone use this commitment as a way of scam to push people into a deep hell while plunge everything into dust

rugged gyro
shy summit
#

You cannot separate the two

#

There is corollary causation.

feral river
#

that's why I would suggest if everybody should be allowed to follow any religion or ideology/commitment, but using this to influence society is prohibited

#

that was quite different from what we used to say 'our view' which is the view of CCP bureaucrats

#

I'm much more liberal than that

sturdy mango
#

If you say verses commanding death in your scripture are no longer valid or were changed by humans, then you are admitting you don’t follow those commands anymore

That means you’re not following the text literally you’re interpreting it
And that’s exactly the point I’m making

shy summit
#

There’s a reason most homophobic people are christian, why most anti-lgbt legislation is voted for by christians, why most anti-trans people are christian,

toxic lake
shy summit
#

This is not a hard thing to see

feral river
shy summit
#

And it’s not to say Christendom is worse or better than other faiths

feral river
#

just leave that space for guns and wars to solve

shy summit
#

Tradition is the enemy of progress and often the oppressor of minorities

feral river
#

and give people a common right of believing anything they want

#

war is the supreme court of the civilization of humanity

#

but we don't have to use the most expensive way to solve the issues

sturdy mango
# rugged gyro Guess you know better than scholars

I don't claim this that I know better than scholars

I’m saying people should study their own religion seriously and understand scholarly debates before using selective quotes to attack another faith

feral river
#

now I have to agree because I'm quite anti-tradition but not conservatism

shy summit
#

Just because something is old, does not grant it my respect

feral river
#

tradition is much more right than just being conservative

rugged gyro
shy summit
sturdy mango
shy summit
#

^^^^^^

feral river
rugged gyro
shy summit
#

You can’t even grant the same grace to another person’s faith as your own.

rugged gyro
shy summit
#

Even your bio @rugged gyro screams prejudice

sturdy mango
shy summit
sturdy mango
#

Behave.

#

If you want a respectful discussion I'm open

feral river
#

and violence isn't a bad thing dude

rugged gyro
#

Omds

#

I'm at work chill out on me lok

shy summit
#

This is what gets my goose. Here you are saying Christendom doesn’t endorse all these bad things, @rugged gyro But then you’re being discriminatory on the basis of religion.

Make it make sense.

feral river
#

only you use violence in a situation that you shouldn't use it is bad

#

violence is not the goal but the way to realize the goal

#

violence itself is neutral

feral river
#

even it is bad defined by who has in charge

#

if you are the emperor and you sign the execution order against who you don't like that could work

#

send anyone to concentration camps, not a surprise

#

you used violence maybe that's not the best way to deal with it, but that could work

#

and you pay the price of using it

shy summit
#

I mean your bio is clearly a statement against refugees from Middle Eastern countries fleeing to Western countries.

How do you sit here and justify blanket assumptions about these people?

@rugged gyro

rugged gyro
#

How the fuck am I going to respond all these wtf

shy summit
#

Yet look at your bio

rugged gyro
umbral narwhal
#

Hey!
How can I understand movies fluency in English??

slender coral
# sturdy mango I will clear this in 3 to 4 points First: the Quran does not prescribe death ...

I never said vigilante killing is allowed in Islam.
Mohamed is clear with his words in the report. Quran changed it's philosophy toward multiple things through it, whether its drinking alcohol, Nikah al-mutah, etc.. and the idea that god will judge people does not negate that Muslims could be commanded to kill those.
Also, you are wrong about zanadiqa. It simply means someone who is an "atheist", it was used and still used to label Muslims who don't follow mainstream ideas, not strictly rebels. No mention of rebellion in the Hadith I brought.

Zindīq (pl. zanādiqa) is an Islamic pejorative applied to individuals who are considered to hold views or follow practices that are contrary to central Islamic dogma.[1]
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zandaqa#

Zindīq (pl. zanādiqa) is an Islamic pejorative applied to individuals who are considered to hold views or follow practices that are contrary to central Islamic dogma. Zandaqa is the noun describing these views.
Zandaqa is usually translated as "heresy" and is often used to underscore the seriousness of the religious views of the accused indivi...

rugged gyro
#

Oh nooo how dare I

feral river
shy summit
feral river
#

nobody in the middle east besides somebody in Gaza is starving

#

also Yemen

rugged gyro
#

I'm gonna respond all these when I'm home

feral river
#

also they are refugees does not justify they should be accepted in another country

manic juniper
#

Aren't they supposed to take refuge in the first safe country

shy summit
# rugged gyro 😱

I’m just saying. You say others are misusing your religion. But you’re not even abiding by those principles either

slender coral
toxic lake
manic juniper
#

I'm saying they should take refuge in the first safe country

shy summit
feral river
toxic lake
feral river
#

developed states in western europe

#

that's it

rugged gyro
#

I support massive deportation actually

wind zephyr
#

Hm

toxic lake
shy summit
#

That tracks

rugged gyro
#

Deport all the illegals

shy summit
#

Are you from Europe?

#

Or North America?

rugged gyro
#

And most of Muslims too

manic juniper
rugged gyro
feral river
shy summit
shy summit
manic juniper
#

I once met someone from Gambia and he said he was a refugee in my country
But aren't there at least 5 or more safe countries between Gambia and Finland

kind sage
#

talking about immigration, how can I (a Brazilian) can go to the US nowadays? legally

feral river
#

that's racist

sturdy mango
#

Epic

rugged gyro
shy summit
sturdy mango
#

My brain is bursting

manic juniper
sturdy mango
wind zephyr
#

Hm

rugged gyro
# shy summit But they aren’t illegal

Yeah we gotta pick and choose let the smart ones stay and kick low iq inbreds and everyone who demands sharia law, assaults women and kids, who doesn't respect culture and destroy churches

manic juniper
#

It can't be a coincidence that every single thing Trump does, except the Maduro arrest, benefits Russia

toxic lake
gloomy frost
shy summit
rugged gyro
manic juniper
sturdy mango
feral river
manic juniper
opal surge
#

A thought just spawned in my head: Why is english so painfully slow?
I know 2 languages: polish and english. When I compare them to each other, it is much faster to convey a message in polish than in english. I know that languages have different speeds, but that's not what I mean. I've noticed that english takes much more time to express simple thoughts, for example: | I don't eat vs Nie jem | | I don't think so vs Nie sądzę | | I've been thinking vs Myślałem | . English is very blocky and bad at delivering information in fast speed. I think both of these languages could be considered as slow. English should compensate by being spoken faster, yet it isn't.

feral river
#

also they are mostly illegal aliens in the country

rugged gyro
#

That would be so inappropriate

wind zephyr
#

Hm

rugged gyro
feral river
shy summit
# rugged gyro Noo

Perhaps you should take a break, drink some water, reflect on what you said and reconsider if that was appropriate for this forum.

manic juniper
#

I'm sorry for you guys in Caucasus but literally your countries are small and some of you (Armenia and Azerbaijan) allied with Russia, Russia only has Turkey opposing them there. Your countries may stop existing in some decades

shy summit
manic juniper
#

It's one of the shittiest place to exist geographically

ornate dirge
#

hey @misty zinc , @stable magnet ,

feral river
rugged gyro
feral river
#

I thought Azerbajan Soviet Socialist Republic was still part of Russia

opal surge
opal surge
slender coral
feral river
#

hot solves everything bro

opal surge
sturdy mango
wind zephyr
#

Hm

sturdy mango
gloomy frost
sturdy mango
gloomy frost
sturdy mango
sturdy mango
gloomy frost
feral river
real lily
#

What's happening, why is this chat always an active war field

sturdy mango
feral river
sturdy mango
#

Actually I have an interesting story

real lily
feral river
#

Hail the Supreme Leader

real lily
#

Who is that?

#

Xi Jinping?

shy summit
gloomy frost
feral river
shy summit
feral river
#

proven educational scam to indoctrinate people to become liberals

opal surge
real lily
#

Ugh 2026 is hurting my brain

opal surge
gloomy frost
shy summit
real lily
#

I'm exhausted, physically and mentally. Too much has been happening

opal surge
#

That's why you should take a bath

real lily
shy summit
#

If being correct is woke then my eyes are open wider than the Mariana Trench.

real lily
shy summit
real lily
#

I just came back from gym I really need a shower

real lily
opal surge
#

get yourself a bath

gloomy frost
opal surge
#

a nice one with warm water

feral river
opal surge
#

some candles

shy summit
opal surge
#

idk anything that would make you relax even bottles will do

shy summit
#

It teaches facts

feral river
#

I'm not saying they should defend slavery and racism to be conservative but at least hold a position that is swinging between these

shy summit
shy summit
#

It teaches you to function in society. Tolerating your peers is a requirement to a functional democracy.

#

That’s not woke that’s just preschool shit

feral river
#

that is out of the line dude

real lily
#

😭

real lily
#

Lmao that's the most liberal thing you could think of?

feral river
#

saying everybody even aliens deserve US constitutional rights

opal surge
#

Minecraft is a grifter don't listen to her

feral river
#

it's like what in the fucking shit

shy summit
#

That’s it

opal surge
shy summit
#

The fuck are you on about

real lily
feral river
#

if it's just teaching kids not to bully

opal surge
feral river
#

don't question his IQ

shy summit
real lily
opal surge
#

I genuinely think Minecraft is a troll hired by the russian government

feral river
#

that's not a secret, everybody knows

shy summit
#

Don’t defend it

#

Only warning

feral river
#

nah I'm just saying he's smart of doing that

#

nothing pretty much

opal surge
shy summit
opal surge
#

Far right politicians in poland get hired by russians all the time

real lily
gloomy frost
real lily
shy summit
feral river
slender coral
feral river
#

he's one of the core link that provide the best services to upper class people

gloomy frost
shy summit
#

Mine, you’re soundin’ really fucking sus right now

feral river
#

they have to redact the file almost entirely covered or else it's gonna be a huge drama

opal surge
feral river
real lily
#

People of the serious chat should file an appeal for Minecraft to shorten his name for easier conversations

shy summit
opal surge
feral river
opal surge
#

they are not serious at all

shy summit
opal surge
feral river
opal surge
real lily
shy summit
#

Getting rid of Mine is like trying to ban Ronald McDonald from McDonalds.

He’s a clown but he’s our clown.

feral river
#

Minecraft is invincible

opal surge
#

no

slender coral
real lily
#

He baits people to argue more

shy summit
opal surge
real lily
#

Capitalists finding profit in capitalists

feral river
shy summit
opal surge
#

Minecraft how's life in Taipei?

feral river
cerulean pivot
real lily
woven quail
#

Epic horsey leader no way SadHamster 😭

feral river
opal surge
real lily
#

I MEANT NANJING BTW

woven quail
feral river
#

Jinan is the capital of the province of Shandong in East China. With a population of 9.2 million, it is one of the largest cities in Shandong in terms of population. The area of present-day Jinan has played an important role in the history of the region from the earliest beginnings of civilization and has evolved into a major national administra...

real lily
#

Because of the sister Hong incident

opal surge
real lily
#

Do you know about the sister hong incident, Minecraft

feral river
woven quail
feral river
opal surge
real lily
woven quail
feral river
opal surge
#

I live in Jilu

feral river
#

I will finally get to America

woven quail
real lily
# feral river never heard of it

The Nanjing Sister Hong incident (Chinese: å—äŗ¬ēŗ¢å§äŗ‹ä»¶; pinyin: NĆ”njÄ«ng hóng jiě shƬjiĆ n) is a scandal that emerged in July 2025 involving a 38-year-old man surnamed Jiao (Chinese: 焦; pinyin: Jiāo) from Nanjing, China, who allegedly posed as a woman, "Sister Hong" (Chinese: 红姐; pinyin: Hóng Jiě; lit. 'Sister Red'), and has ...

feral river
real lily
#

Why not? Don't they affect you as a chinese citizen?

sturdy mango
# slender coral I never said vigilante killing is allowed in Islam. Mohamed is clear with his w...
  1. A report's** "clear words"** do not eliminate the need for interpretation.
    Islamic law has never been derived solely from one report. Prophetic practice, Qur'anic principles, context, and corroboration are all important.
    Because of this, there has historically been disagreement among jurists regarding apostasy, including whether or not there is any punishment in this world

  2. The "changing philosophy" of the Qur'an does not imply that killing for religious reasons is acceptable
    Like alcohol, gradual legislation focuses on social regulation rather than conscience-based punishment.
    The Qur'an does not prescribe any human punishment for those who believe, disbelieve, and then believe again.
    From a methodological standpoint, that is important.

  3. In Islamic law, "God will judge" is a legal boundary rather than a catchphrase.
    Islamic law makes a distinction between crimes decided by courts and sins judged by God.
    The Qur'an consistently places belief in the former category.

  4. Regarding zindiq/zanadiqa You are correct that the term encompasses more than just "rebel." In the past, it was used to describe individuals who were accused of politically and publicly undermining Islam
    these individuals were frequently dualists, , or secret groups thought to be causing social unrest.
    That's exactly the point: it wasn't "someone who privately stops believing," but rather a political-theological category.
    Modern atheism as a personal identity is not equivalent to classical usage.

  5. Lastly, even proponents of punishment in classical law never permitted vigilante murder. It is already more in line with historical treason law than belief policing because it was always presented as a state matter with courts, evidence standards, and barriers. Therefore, portraying this as **"Islam commands Muslims to kill apostates" **is still oversimplified and ignores legal theory, juristic disagreement, and the primacy of the Qur'an.

feral river
real lily
#

How does it not affect you if you live in MainLand China

real lily
bitter jackal
#

Hi

feral river
#

even Jeffery Epstein wasn't that huge

#

the administration could hold it off

opal surge
stark aurora
#

Can a non-native speaker reach higher than c1?

real lily
#

Why not?

stark aurora
#

@sturdy mango why did you "😭" me?

stark aurora
# real lily Why not?

Idk I heard someone say the highest a non-native speaker can reach is c1 and you would have to move to an English speaking country or be born in an English speaking country to reach c2

cerulean pivot
#

Learn another language

opal surge
#

around 10% of native speakers are c2

#

then almost everyone else is c1

stark aurora
#

I tried taking a c2 test before, the only thing I understood was the word "the"(jk but you get the idea, it's really freaking hard)

opal surge
#

how did it look like

stark aurora
#

I don't remember but I just answered 5 questions(all wrong probably) then just gave up and went to doom scrolling for the next century or so

opal surge
stark aurora
opal surge
#

did you even check the answers afterwards?

#

did you get the results?

stark aurora
stark aurora
cerulean pivot
opal surge
#

do you have an example phrase? do you still have the test somewhere and is it free?

#

yes coward

stark aurora
opal surge
#

I WANT TO CHECK IT OUT 😭

stark aurora
#

If you want to test your English I recommend EF set test(not the c2 test but it's pretty good+it's free and accessible+it's actually humanily possible)

stark aurora
#

Cause let me tell ya, that shi wasn't English

sturdy mango
#

relax

stark aurora
sturdy mango
opal surge
stark aurora
opal surge
cerulean pivot
opal surge
#

It's not like muricans are not doing it either

#

pacifier vs dummy for example

stark aurora
opal surge
#

dummy is the first word

stark aurora
opal surge
#

I've got no time for that

opal surge
stark aurora
opal surge
#

thank you blossom

opal surge
stark aurora
#

Btw mid test you'll feel terrible and like you never learned English and you will get a2 result but don't worry you didn't mess up you're fine

real lily
stark aurora
stark aurora
# opal surge I've got no time for that

It doesn't actually take that time cause you don't actually have to finish it in 90 minutes, 90 minutes is just the celling you can't go above but you can finish it in like 20 minutes if you're fast and good enough

real lily
#

Or just share the site, I'd be super grateful

stark aurora
# real lily Nooooo, tell me the name please

EF set test, there's 90 minutes or 50 minutes or 15 minutes, btw that time Is only the celling, you can finish it in less than quarter the time if you're fast enough and good enough

#

@real lily

real lily
#

Tysmmmmmm!!! Be right back in 15 minutes

stark aurora
#

Like the 15 mins got me b1-b2 but the 50 mins got me c1

opal surge
#

I don't want to fill that information

stark aurora
opal surge
#

i already closed the site

opal surge
stark aurora
# opal surge i already closed the site

Btw the 50 mins one you can do it only once per 90 days and the 90 day one only.... Once in your existence, it hardware bans you even with vpn or anything

stark aurora
opal surge
#

Jokes aside, there were some hard questions, but I think that I managed

stark aurora
#

I took the 90 minutes one and got c1

opal surge
#

I got a lot of questions regarding a university

opal surge
#

I want to play games vro

stark aurora
stark aurora
opal surge
#

I rearranged the furniture in my room and honestly I feel much more relaxed right now

tiny crag
#

Hi

opal surge
#

bi

opal surge
stark aurora
opal surge
#

Do you like Matilda by Roald Dahl

#

That's going to be my second read

stark aurora
opal surge
#

I'm almost at the end

opal surge
#

It's based on this book

real lily
opal surge
#

the story is a little different though

stark aurora
opal surge
stark aurora
#

Take the 90 minutes one, at your level it's very worth it

real lily
#

Tysm! I'll try

stark aurora
real lily
#

I'm tempted to give the 15 minutes test again and try for a perfect score

stark aurora
#

Just go for the 90 minutes one

#

Read questions don't just go straight to answers like I did on the 50 minute one

real lily
#

Okay okay

feral river
#

fact check guys

real lily
#

I don't know where I went wrong though, I think my bad memory made me lose in the questions where it'd just BOMBARD me with spoken info

#

I forgot a lot of stuff that it'd say even if I understood it

opal surge
real lily
#

But I know I got some questions wrong

opal surge
real lily
#

So that affects the grade

opal surge
#

but the grade is still c2 proficient\

stark aurora
#

Mid

real lily
#

Yes, but it's 75

opal surge
#

so what

stark aurora
#

Jk you did great, be proud

opal surge
#

don't be a perfectionist

#

you did a great job

real lily
#

Thank you stone

#

How much did you get

opal surge
#

i didn't do it

#

I was reading a book instead derp

real lily
stark aurora
real lily
opal surge
#

haha

real lily
#

I wasted my time doing silly quizes

opal surge
#

it was in english too

real lily
opal surge
opal surge
#

i think i want to play games now

#

i'm gonna hop in between voice chats and play my game in the background bye

real lily
#

Have a good time reading

#

Or playing games, whatever you end up doing

thorny steeple
#

Matilda?
I stopped in the middle of it

#

Anyone recommend for me books?

slender coral
# sturdy mango 1) A report's** "clear words"** do not eliminate the need for interpretation. Is...

Because of this, there has historically been disagreement among jurists regarding apostasy, including whether or not there is any punishment in this world
Can you give any examples of older scholars reject the apostasy death penalty?

The Qur'an does not prescribe any human punishment for those who believe, disbelieve, and then believe again.
From a methodological standpoint, that is important.
Islamic jurisdiction does not only rely on Quran, Hadiths are taken into account as well.

In Islamic law, "God will judge" is a legal boundary rather than a catchphrase.
Islamic law makes a distinction between crimes decided by courts and sins judged by God.
The Qur'an consistently places belief in the former category.
These categories can be implicit, but since there is a Hadith that clearly states apostates should be killed, then it puts into something that can be punished in this life.

That's exactly the point: it wasn't "someone who privately stops believing," but rather a political-theological category.
Modern atheism as a personal identity is not equivalent to classical usage.
When you say it's a theological category that basically means that it's a punishment that's used against those who are theologically different. There's nothing such as old or new atheism, and the law doesn't only apply to atheists, the apostasy death penalty is used against anyone who leaves Islam regardless of their new religion/philosophy. And both the texts and the scholars did not distinguish between just believing in something different and rebelling against the state.

Lastly, even proponents of punishment in classical law never permitted vigilante murder
I never claimed it permitted vigilante murder.
Therefore, portraying this as "Islam commands Muslims to kill apostates" is still oversimplified
It's not. You basically say that apostates should be executed, therefor you are saying apostates should be killed. It's still oppressing people and killing them.

sterile fractal
#

Helloe

slender coral
#

Would you like to talk about something?

sterile fractal
#

Sure

slender coral
sterile fractal
#

Or the past

main zephyr
#

Hello 😺

sturdy mango
# slender coral > Because of this, there has historically been disagreement among jurists regard...

1. Abū Ḥanīfa (50 AH)
did not view apostasy as a crime in and of itself.
He:
completely rejected the execution of female apostates
Punishment based on political disobedience rather than a shift in beliefs
This is crucial: disbelief was not the only reason for punishment, even in those cases

  1. Islamic law makes use of Hadith and the Qur'an.
    However, usūl al-fiqh enforces rules of hierarchy and interpretation.
    Apostasy is mentioned several times in the Qur'an, but it is never punished in this world, even when:

"They believe, disbelieve, then believe once more." (Q 4:137)

a) The Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him, never executed Muslims who left Islam unless they were a threat
b) The Prophet Muhammad imposed death on those who betrayed him and/or shifted allegiances during war (or engaged in hostile rebellious activity against his authority)
c) The other hadiths prescribe execution for rebellion against the Muslim community, not for changing religion
Thus, many scholars classify apostasy as a rebellion in the same category of crime as Ḅirābah (rebellion), and not as a mere crime against God.

  1. Traditionally:
    Ridda does not equal Private Disbelief.
    Ridda means a public departure from Loyalty to a State.
    Breaking your Oath
    Joining the Enemies of Your State
    Endangering a State with an Emerging and Fragile Political Structure
    This is because:
    There has not been a Private worldview of Atheism prior to the 20th century.
    Identity, Law, and Loyalty were closely linked.
    You are correct that the Law applied regardless of the new faith, but it was not your New Belief that caused Suspension of the Law; it was your Public Departure from the State and the Threat you posed to the State.

  2. They did, although they didn't do so perfectly. Evidence for this is as follows: there was no punishment for secret apostasy,
    there was no punishment for women (per Abū Ḥanīfa),
    and there was no execution of the apostate until they publicly declared their apathy, or were unwilling to accept reconciliation, or had caused perceived harm to society.
    If belief was the only thing being punished, then none of the aforementioned distinctions would exist.

  3. The statement,** "Islam commands that all Muslims kill apostates,**" is incorrect for several reasons:

  • It lacks an individual command,
    -It is not universally applicable,
  • There is no abortion of apostasy.
  • These distinctions are substantial and serve to clarify the law as well as provide a proper understanding of its meaning.
sturdy mango
gloomy frost
slender coral
#

My question was "Can you give any examples of older scholars reject the apostasy death penalty" and that certainly not it. If you think I'm wrong here you can quote the man.

sturdy mango
# slender coral My question was "Can you give any examples of older scholars reject the apostasy...

IbnHishām's "Sīrat Rasūl Allāh" includes many examples of people (including ʿAbdullāh ibn Ubayy) who acted against the Muslims, but they were not executed simply for leaving their religion.
Al-Bukhārī had an established rule that it was only in instances where apostasy was coupled with murder, fighting the Muslims, or aiding their enemies that one would be executed by the Prophet ﷺ, not merely for changing one's belief.
The Qur'ān itself mentions apostasy, but at no point indicates that there is a penalty imposed for it in this life (2:256; 4:136). This leads us to continue to view changing one's belief alone as not deserving of a death penalty. Historical documentation also highlights ʿUmar b. ʿAbd al-ʿAzīz had a preference for imprisoning an apostate instead of executing him; it helps establish the separation of apostasy from the commission of a crime.
As a result of these examples, it is clear that early Islam did not mandate the death penalty for apostasy.

slender coral
# sturdy mango IbnHishām's "Sīrat Rasūl Allāh" includes many examples of people (including ʿAbd...

Abdullah ibn Ubayy was not publicly an apostate, it was claimed that he was a Munafiq "hypocrite" but he publicly converted to Islam. I know this because I listened to the Egyptian Islamic history scholar Raghib al-Sirgani lectures on the Sirah.
Here's what the Wikipedia article says:

Abd-Allah ibn Ubayy (Arabic: Ų¹ŲØŲÆ الله بن أبي بن Ų³Ł„ŁˆŁ„, died 631), also called Ibn Salul in reference to his grandmother, was a chief of the Arab tribe Banu Khazraj and one of the leading men of Medina (then known as Yathrib). Upon the arrival of Muhammad, Ibn Ubayy became a Muslim, but the sincerity of his conversion is disputed. Because of repeated conflicts with Muhammad, Islamic tradition has labelled him a munafiq or hypocrite (plural: munafiqun) and "leader of the munafiqun".[1]
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abd_Allah_ibn_Ubayy#

Abd-Allah ibn Ubayy (Arabic: Ų¹ŲØŲÆ الله بن أبي بن Ų³Ł„ŁˆŁ„, died 631), also called Ibn Salul in reference to his grandmother, was a chief of the Arab tribe Banu Khazraj and one of the leading men of Medina (then known as Yathrib). Upon the arrival of Muhammad, Ibn Ubayy became a Muslim, but the sincerity of his conversion is disputed...

#

I asked you for quotes and you brought none, in addition to the absence of any sources for these claims.

#
fresh flower
#

Oh

turbid dome
#

I noticed Quran 4:137 wasn’t even cited in full above, so I’m just going to add the full context of everything surrounding it to change from ā€œthey believe, disbelieve, and believe once moreā€ into the full context.

4:136-4:143

O believers! Have faith in Allah, His Messenger, the Book He has revealed to His Messenger, and the Scriptures He revealed before. Indeed, whoever denies Allah, His angels, His Books, His messengers, and the Last Day has clearly gone far astray.

Indeed, those who believed then disbelieved, then believed and again disbelieved—˹onlyĖŗ increasing in disbelief—Allah will neither forgive them nor guide them to the ˹RightĖŗ Way.

Give good news of a painful punishment to hypocrites,

who choose disbelievers as allies instead of the believers. Do they seek honour and power through that company? Surely all honour and power belongs to Allah

He has already revealed to you in the Book that when you hear Allah’s revelations being denied or ridiculed, then do not sit in that company unless they engage in a different topic, or else you will be like them. Surely Allah will gather the hypocrites and disbelievers all together in Hell.

˹The hypocrites areĖŗ those who wait to see what happens to you. So if Allah grants you victory, they say ˹to youĖŗ, ā€œWere we not on your side?ā€ But if the disbelievers have a share ˹of victoryĖŗ, they say ˹to themĖŗ, ā€œDid we not have the advantage over you, yet we protected you from the believers?ā€ Allah will judge between ˹all ofĖŗ you on the Day of Judgment. And Allah will never grant the disbelievers a way over the believers.

Surely the hypocrites seek to deceive Allah, but He outwits them. When they stand up for prayer, they do it half-heartedly only to be seen by people—hardly remembering Allah at all

Torn between belief and disbelief—belonging neither to these ˹believersĖŗ nor those ˹disbelieversĖŗ. And whoever Allah leaves to stray, you will never find for them a way.

sly apex
#

Too serious

slender coral
mint parrot
slender coral
#

It has always felt strange to me, even as a kid.

turbid dome
soft star
#

What's the main contention?

mint parrot
turbid dome
# turbid dome Talent

On a serious note it comes across as a guy forgetting what he said and repeating himself

turbid dome
mint parrot
sturdy mango
sturdy mango
mint parrot
turbid dome
slender coral
#

I guess we wouldn't reach an agreement here, let's agree to disagree.

real lily
#

They are a Muslim

thorny steeple
#

im a true hater

#

ā¤ļø

sturdy mango
thorny steeple
#

when did this happen

mint parrot
real lily
#

Phoiba?

mint parrot
thorny steeple
real lily
#

soya?

thorny steeple
sick bronze
#

soja

thorny steeple
sick bronze
sturdy mango
thorny steeple
#

today was only tge first day after a two day weekend and im already tired and back to crazy

#

i might as well puke my pill and rest with my wife

mint parrot
slender coral
#

I wish more Muslims had this mentality.

sturdy mango
real lily
thorny steeple
#

there was some blood but this should do

real lily
#

Toxicity exists in all religious communities though

real lily
thorny steeple
#

schizo is a miracle of god

thorny steeple
real lily
#

Are you schizophrenic?

thorny steeple
#

no idea

#

@thorny steeple hi long time no see

real lily
#

Wow, you're spiraling

#

Take a shower immediately

thorny steeple
#

im joking btw

sturdy mango
#

@thorny steeple I saw u pooping on street yesterday

mint parrot
thorny steeple
#

bro if i was real schizo you would have killed me with the shower thingy😭

sturdy mango
thorny steeple
sturdy mango
real lily
#

I'm sorry, I shower when I get a brainfog

thorny steeple
sturdy mango
thorny steeple
#

bro i literally give advicešŸ’€

real lily
thorny steeple
mint parrot
thorny steeple
real lily
thorny steeple
#

nyzas if you dont share stuff, you will drown one day from the weight

real lily
#

I hate studying, studying hurts my brain

thorny steeple
real lily
#

But I also like it when it's not rushed

thorny steeple
real lily
#

Just not anything from the curriculum

thorny steeple
slender coral
thorny steeple
real lily
#

Such leaders rise to power, and in turn radicalise more of their population. Some ideologies of the leaders do reflect on the general population too, that's also probably why there is negative rep around that faith

thorny steeple
real lily
# thorny steeple forcing kniwledge never works

I agree, I think studying what you're really good at and passionate about together, is the key. I am passionate about science but I'm not good at it, I do like Maths but that's about it. I've never really liked stuff that's been taught in my class till now

#

I'm switching to Law major this year and I couldn't be happier

#

The amount of weight I've had on myself to finish this whole thing altogether was mindboggling. But it's amazing I pulled through, I never thought I had the ability too

thorny steeple
#

i understand

thorny steeple
real lily
#

Yep, I have huge respect for you all, all the Med students and science students. This is definitely not everyone's cup of tea

thorny steeple
#

i see

#

i dont see us the same though

real lily
thorny steeple
real lily
thorny steeple
#

i dont know, sometimes overthinking and trying to know more is wrong. You get nothing but pain from it. Though there is a truth behind it.

#

slay

real lily
#

Wouldn't it be me neither

uneven olive
#

Эахаххахахахахах

thorny steeple
uneven olive
#

I see

thorny steeple
#

or me neither

thorny steeple
mossy cargo
#

all of us r fascists right

thorny steeple
mossy cargo
thorny steeple
mossy cargo
thorny steeple
#

AYO

#

I JUST GOT A FREE PDF FOR DSM 5

#

SO COOL

thorny steeple
mossy cargo
#

they r impulsive and manipulative people

#

but maybe compared to a physco or narc

ornate shore
ornate shore
thorny steeple
ornate shore
ornate shore
thorny steeple
thorny steeple
slender coral
thorny steeple
slender coral
coral belfry
rugged gyro
slender coral
rugged gyro
slender coral
rugged gyro
#

Oh I'm here for 10 days

#

I'd be banned in other servers by now

rugged gyro
slender coral
slender coral
#

I didn't make you do anything creepy

rugged gyro
#

Let's blame nale

fresh flower
#

Those conjuring movies are legit garbage

rugged gyro
#

I love the conjuring universe

fresh flower
#

They're like final destination

rugged gyro
#

Conjuring 1 and 2 are good 3 is garbage

#

4 was funny

#

The curse of la llorona meh

#

The nun 1 good 2 ok

#

Horror of Amityville

#

Amazing

#

Annabelle 1 terrible

#

2 and 3 good

final jasper
#

@slender coral Hey, You know we've debated a long time ago on the topic of treating womens as property in islam and you've showed me a hadith too. I've found a Quranic verse which makes it clear.

#

4:19 Quran

#

uhh idk how to use the bot

#

The Women (4:19)
"O believers! It is not permissible for you to inherit women against their willĀ or mistreat them to make them return some of the dowry ˹as a ransom for divorce˺—unless they are found guilty of adultery.Ā Treat them fairly. If you happen to dislike them, you may hate something which Allah turns into a great blessing."

#

Qur’an 4:19 explicitly says women cannot be inherited against their will. Property is inherited; women are not. That verse alone disproves the claim that Islam treats women as property.

velvet laurel
#

Hallo

shy summit
turbid dome
turbid dome
cerulean pivot
#

From now on I'll only communicate with emojis

#

Speaking is so mutable these days

slender coral
turbid dome
final jasper
# slender coral I didn't mean that women are literally property in Islam (although they can lite...

you know in the past,Before, the practice was that when a man dies, his male relatives used to have the right to do whatever they wanted with his wife. If one of them wants, he would marry her, give her in marriage, or prevent her from marriage, for they had more right to her than her own family. Thereafter, this Ayah was revealed about this practice to stop and the hadith you were referring to does not says that womens should be or are treated as property. It was the time of ignorance. the Disapproval of the Prophet itself discourages.

final jasper
turbid dome
final jasper
turbid dome
final jasper
turbid dome
final jasper
#

anyways, I guess it's enough for you to understand. if you insist to argue more, then I may consider you a person who is blind for guidance.

manic juniper
#

Not very convincing isn't it

turbid dome
final jasper
#

and also show me

errant yacht
final jasper
errant yacht
final jasper
turbid dome
# final jasper Does Quran commit to "treat them fairly but doesn’t describe fairness "? If your...

It claims specifically in the passage you showed to treat specifically inherited widows fairly.

Though I think burden of proof would be an excellent concept to apply. As you are claiming a positive, you would have to show where it defined fair treatment of inherited widows (or a broader category under which inherited widows would apply). The alternative would be me having to show every single line in the Quran.

Also, I was talking specifically about that one line lmao. You’re using one line out of many in a book, completely divorced from the rest of the book, and claiming it as representative, without addressing any possible contradictions to the claim.

errant yacht
#

@turbid dome hiya

turbid dome
errant yacht
turbid dome
#

So if I was to give you the criminal record of Jeffrey Epstein and nothing else about him it’s unfair for me to judge him?

#

So if I thought Jeffrey Epstein was bad for child s trafficking you would have an objection?

manic juniper
#

What about šŸ‡?

turbid dome
#

Ngl I’d rather take the bullet

cerulean pivot
#

I don't want to get banned

lyric hinge
#

Who comes first egg or hen?

#

So how dinasaurs came ?

fresh flower
final jasper
# turbid dome It claims specifically in the passage you showed to treat specifically inherited...

Property can't own property. The Quran (4:7 and 4:32) gave women the right to own their own money and land. If they were property, that would be legally impossible. Verse 4:19 doesn’t just 'treat widows fairly'. it explicitly bans people from inheriting them.

If you can’t see that banning the inheritance of a person is the opposite of treating them like property, that's a 'you' problem. I’m not going to keep explaining the basics to someone who’s just looking for a fight. Stay stuck if you want, I’m done.

cerulean pivot
fresh flower
final jasper
cerulean pivot
final jasper
#

that was very much wasting time with you for nothing. Hope you seek guidance.

cerulean pivot
manic juniper
manic juniper
# lyric hinge So how dinasaurs came ?

It's a group of reptiles that appeared after a mass extinction called Great Dying, they originated in the South of the supercontinent Pangaea. There already were reptiles roaming the planet but they weren't particularly big

#

The first dinosaurs weren't that big either, other reptiles were filling different roles around the planet

fresh flower
cerulean pivot
turbid dome
# final jasper Property can't own property. The Quran (4:7 and 4:32) gave women the right to ow...

I think you missed the core of devil’s above message.

Property isn’t literal, it means they have lesser rights and are treated as broodmares. By my understanding, slaves have some rights in Islam too, yet slaves are definitionally property.

And it only bans people from inheriting them unwillingly (which ignores societal pressures and is narrow regardless) and still treats them as a thing to be inherited.

Also if you think I’m stupid because I would rather die than make someone live with a lifetime of trauma, good on you lol

final jasper
#

I'll debate on this with Devil later.

fresh flower
turbid dome
fresh flower
turbid dome
mint parrot
turbid dome
#

The white people getting shot is the only thing that’s caused a little bit of unrest

mint parrot
#

Oh is that so

fresh flower
fresh flower
turbid dome
mint parrot
turbid dome
#

You’re not wrong

mint parrot
fresh flower
#

Cop is lowkey a chill job in the US

#

Hardly any education, no fitness requirements, no responsibility if you shoot someone

manic juniper
#

Especially since dogs and children often can't shoot back

mossy cargo
slender coral
turbid dome
turbid dome
slender coral
#

Lol

turbid dome
#

😭😭😭😭😭

mint parrot
cerulean pivot
crystal kayak
mint parrot
crystal kayak
lavish finch
woven quail
high rapids
mint parrot
sick bronze
#

Easy to invade… no one wanna reconstruct the society

#

That’s the whole problem of today’s society

rotund urchin
#

hope vegans support this humans too Sadgepepe

dusk panther
#

help I just joined this server while seriously expecting it to be normal lol

lunar plume
#

hi

cursive bobcatBOT
#
Topic

What’s your favorite holiday movie?

wet flax
#

dude idk

#

?t

cursive bobcatBOT
#
Topic

What TV show character would it be the most fun to change places with for a week?

open vault
#

?t

cursive bobcatBOT
#
Topic

If you could have an all-expenses paid trip to see any famous world monument, which monument would you choose?

open vault
#

Not interested

#

?t

cursive bobcatBOT
#
Topic

Do you think that humans will ever be able to live together in harmony?

open vault
#

No

#

?t

cursive bobcatBOT
#
Topic

How much do you plan for the future?

neon sierra
#

we suck as species

open vault
#

I hate generalizing sorry kekk

neon sierra
#

if i point out

#

doesnt that make me racist, even if i was about to be right

open vault
neon sierra
#

i cant

#

it is not right after all

open vault
#

There is some people are doomed to be bad forever me and u know them dw tomsip

neon sierra
#

ive seen so many videos of people getting shot

open vault
neon sierra
open vault
neon sierra
open vault
#

This is sick

neon sierra
open vault
neon sierra
#

I agree

open vault
neon sierra
#

so we might not see the world with the same eyes

open vault
neon sierra
#

I am kurdish

neon sierra
open vault
#

Yeah nice to meet u

#

I was waiting for a straight answer tomsip

neon sierra
#

sh says the same as the post above I think

open vault
#

I am Tunisian

neon sierra
#

no i wanted you to reflex on the part where u said me and u know them

#

maybe i see u as the bad one for example

open vault
#

I mean what’s happening there are they deporting people who have legit papers or immigrants

neon sierra
#

šŸ’€

#

or you me as one

#

who is good and who is bad

#

idk just some questions that i cant stop thinking about

open vault
#

People who hurt innocent people are bad

neon sierra
open vault
neon sierra
glossy ether
#

hola amigos

neon sierra
glossy ether
#

what religion are we dissing today?

neon sierra
#

hola chicka

open vault
neon sierra
#

well this month made me depessed

#

ive never started a year worse

open vault
#

Where plz show me

neon sierra
open vault
neon sierra
#

but seems like ur muslim bc of that symbol or am I delusional

open vault
neon sierra
#

Oh LOL

neon sierra
#

the moon symbol she has on her profile

open vault
#

I am muslim but there is no symbol

neon sierra
open vault
neon sierra
fresh flower
#

What

neon sierra
#

idk how that moon thingy became a symbol when it is not

fresh flower
#

What's this then ā˜Ŗļø

neon sierra
#

i think it is bc of some nations that had that one on their flags and they were muslim

#

like ottoman idk

open vault
neon sierra
#

tbh

#

do u know tamazigh

glossy ether
#

as an ambassador of islam ā€œā˜Ŗļøā€ has everything to do with islam

fresh flower
neon sierra
#

good question actually idk

open vault
#

It’s how we count months

neon sierra
#

ohh smart

neon sierra
#

but originally it is not a symbol of islam

fresh flower
#

Gonna ask a real Islamic scholar

glossy ether
open vault
glossy ether
#

i have answers

fresh flower
#

@high raven Is ā˜Ŗļø the symbol of Islam

neon sierra
open vault
neon sierra
fresh flower
open vault
glossy ether
#

ya hussain…

#

may allah save you from your ignorance

neon sierra
#

be free

neon sierra
fresh flower
#

"Shia's kill other Muslims" meanwhile these guys prop up the US defence budget by buying their weapons

open vault
neon sierra
fresh flower
open vault
#

And ur lying

open vault
fresh flower
open vault
neon sierra
#

i currently dont see any islamic country that can represent islam

high raven
neon sierra
#

neither do i think their practicer are right but saudi arabia is getting better by time

open vault
neon sierra
glossy ether
fresh flower
glossy ether
#

sheikh sanna has spoken

neon sierra
fresh flower
neon sierra
glossy ether
neon sierra
#

šŸ’€

fresh flower
neon sierra
soft star
#

Saudi had Cardi B twerking in the land of "Tawheed" btw

open vault
neon sierra
#

i think muslims should learn to respect each other

fresh flower
open vault
neon sierra
open vault
open vault
neon sierra
neon sierra
#

wallah astagfirullah but even the jews can go to ishell for free but muslims cant provide each other fairly

high raven
#

The issue is Arabs not Muslims

open vault
open vault
#

?t

cursive bobcatBOT
#
Topic

What’s the silliest thing you’ve seen someone get upset about?

open vault
#

I took the place of a girl in classroom creepy

neon sierra
open vault
neon sierra
#

and would it be different if she was middle eastern

open vault
open vault
high raven
neon sierra
#

you identify as arab right? @open vault

open vault
neon sierra
#

or differently

open vault
#

I have no idea about my roots

neon sierra
high raven
open vault
#

But I don’t understand why people hate on a full culture whole ethnicity

neon sierra
#

i wasnt hateful till januari started… now i am at least trying to avoid the maybe slight hate i have…

open vault
neon sierra
neon sierra
#

if continuesly seeing people violate your people in the name of their background or religion, wouldnt that force hate from you

open vault
neon sierra
#

it is not about being logical sometimes

#

it is a feeling

neon sierra
neon sierra
#

Even if generalising is wrong

open vault
neon sierra
# open vault It would yes

before januari i couldnt think that way. I would say the correct answer is no, you cant hate. jews, muslims or arabs bc it is wrong and generalising

#

but if you have experience, then it just doesnt work in the logical way

open vault
neon sierra
#

for example kurds dont like arabs bc they are doing stuff, in the name of god or arabhood

neon sierra
open vault
#

Not everyone is qualified to be politician

#

We need to be logic

high raven
open vault
#

And simply think as something u wouldn’t like for yourself u wouldn’t do it for the other

neon sierra
#

how does this video affect my imaan? or my view of arabs?

open vault
open vault
#

It’s between u and god

neon sierra
open vault
open vault
high raven
high raven
neon sierra
open vault
neon sierra
#

not everyone hates just to be racist of themselves or phobws

#

phobes

open vault
high raven
neon sierra
#

just a check: hola are u still here?

open vault
neon sierra
open vault
#

Have u heard of capitalism and what the USA did to it make word-wide system ?

open vault
neon sierra
# open vault Yeah I understand u

i know generalising is not correct and you should avoid it but you have to understand other people as well or why they feel that way

open vault
#

And they went through war like any other group of people who wanted to spread his religion

open vault
rotund urchin
open vault
cerulean pivot
cerulean pivot
open vault
#

She brought her brother in kofer kekk

neon sierra
#

you cant forcefully convert people in war

rotund urchin
open vault
open vault
cerulean pivot
#

What time is it for y'all

#

Damn it's 3:30 am

fresh flower
#

Imma sleep she stopped replying to Sanna this is no longer interesting šŸ‘ŽšŸ»

neon sierra
neon sierra
fresh flower
fresh flower
cerulean pivot
#

Nvm

open vault
open vault
cerulean pivot
open vault
neon sierra