#Polls 5.0

1 messages · Page 11 of 1

mint talon
#

ok

brisk copper
mint talon
brisk copper
#

i think we should stop now wholesome

mint talon
#

same

woeful ivy
#

the joke is that theres no andromeda galaxy visible on my pic

#

it should be there

#

but no

ivory mural
split tinsel
#

@brisk copper @mint talon we can stop now. If I have to bring it up again, there will be timeouts

fallen obsidian
#
poll_question_text

what do i image untracked

victor_answer_votes

5

total_votes

9

victor_answer_id

2

victor_answer_text

Northern Lagoon

mint talon
plucky vigil
#
poll_question_text

What is the worst star?

victor_answer_votes

18

total_votes

18

victor_answer_id

1

victor_answer_text

Alnitak

victor_answer_emoji_id

669023392766361610

victor_answer_emoji_name

dancing_star

victor_answer_emoji_animated

true

woeful ivy
cerulean elm
woeful ivy
# cerulean elm

ok so?

why not put a tiny mask on it so it blocks the light from it

cerulean elm
#

That's not how telescopes work. You can not just block part of the aperture and remove an object from the frame. There are coronagraphs but those focus mainly on the star observed. And as far as I'm aware of there are no consumer grade star coronagraphs. None that any of us can afford atleast.

ivory mural
cold moon
glacial bear
brisk copper
summer turret
#

Tbh ive not used davinci

tiny lintel
brisk copper
rain void
# tiny lintel

except you only get higher angular resolution if the seeing allows it

tiny lintel
mint talon
brisk copper
#

-# (they are salty about their bad section of atmosphere AwkwardSmile )

ivory mural
tiny lintel
cerulean elm
mint talon
# mint talon
poll_question_text

do you cable organize your setup

victor_answer_votes

9

total_votes

22

victor_answer_id

2

victor_answer_text

a little

brisk copper
brisk copper
# brisk copper
poll_question_text

is premier pro or davinci resolve better

victor_answer_votes

5

total_votes

6

victor_answer_id

1

victor_answer_text

davinci better

fallen obsidian
brisk copper
#

fermented stale bread usually

fallen obsidian
#

I let it rise for 24hrs and it smelled like vodka

brisk copper
#

unless it was a liquid

devout tinsel
#

Kvass is very good

tiny lintel
# tiny lintel
poll_question_text

If you had to pick one (lets assume its a 10" telescope)

victor_answer_votes

14

total_votes

18

victor_answer_id

2

victor_answer_text

Slower telescope, small FOV, higher "resolution"

brisk copper
devout tinsel
#

It's cool

brisk copper
#

so i have to make myself xD

brisk copper
#

@urban quiver @marble hearth explain thyself!!!

devout tinsel
brisk copper
#

in like 3 days

#

xD

devout tinsel
#

Share your progress

#

It's really cool

brisk copper
#

then maybe add orange peel for orangey flaver

#

for 2 days

#

after straining out the bead

brisk copper
open aspen
woeful ivy
#

i love democracy

ivory mural
summer turret
#

yea na i would move on

devout tinsel
ivory mural
# ivory mural

this doesnt specify a scope, you dont need to use something with painfully high focal length

#

could do it without a scope

low lance
low lance
fallen obsidian
fallen obsidian
ivory mural
fallen obsidian
ivory mural
#

its nothing

#

ignore that extra 3mm

glacial bear
# ivory mural ignore that extra 3mm

Hmm.

A = π x r^2
r = 0.5d

plugging in.

For 200mm
r = 100mm
100mm ^2 = 10,000
10,000π = 31,415.9265mm

For 203mm
r = 101.5mm
101.5 ^2 = 10,302.25
10,302.25π = 32,365.4729mm

32,365.4729 - 31,415.9265 = 949.5464mm

Approximately 1m in area difference between the two sizes.

Hilariously, the 203mm is roughly 3% more area than the 200mm ... which somehow in my mind tracks. 🤷

Even more hilarious is that near-meter of difference in area is around a circumference of 628.3185mm. Seems like the overall "around" circumference would be adding somewhere between a half and a third of a mm all the way around, which is near-imperceptible to the human eye, and certainly most people.

@fallen obsidian, what I'm saying is, in the end, Grand is right. Between the two, get the OTA that has better quality optics.

#

That was my recreational math session for the night, thank you for the opportunity.

rain void
#

My guy that's 950 mm^2 or about 3cm by 3cm

brisk copper
low lance
marble hearth
void jolt
#

disliking kvass is a crime

marble hearth
#

My Lithuanian ancestors would not approve

glacial bear
glacial bear
fallen obsidian
glacial bear
#

I'm familiar with Apertura as a decent brand, and that's where the votes are going.

#

I don't know about iOptron optics. I would hope that it's about the same. However, I know of the brand by the mount I have from them, not their OTA.

cerulean elm
#

Wait. iOptron or Omegon?

cerulean elm
#

TS-Optics and Omegon have the same exact truss RCTs, closed tube RCT, and newtonians😂

cerulean elm
#

Thanks discord 💀

glacial bear
#

The real question is: are they any good?

tiny lintel
#

its GSO

#

...

brisk copper
#

their rct mirrors are weirdly high quality

brisk copper
#

can defo taste bread in it tho

tiny lintel
#

nice one

cold moon
# tiny lintel ahahahah

They are ok for the price tbh, they are required to have a certain strehl value (I'm aware that strehl is really not the best method to assess the quality of a mirror, but still).

cerulean elm
tiny lintel
cerulean elm
cold moon
cold moon
tiny lintel
#

you need a corrector

#

and im yet to see people buy 6200MMs for their 8" GSO RC

tiny lintel
cerulean elm
#

So reducing it is optional. How much bad glass ypu want to add between the mirrors and the sensor. A Good CC and knowing when to shoot probably is the best mix

tiny lintel
#

its ok, and good for the price

cerulean elm
cold moon
brisk copper
# brisk copper
poll_question_text

should i brew kvass

victor_answer_votes

7

total_votes

9

victor_answer_id

1

victor_answer_text

yes

restive fiber
tiny lintel
# restive fiber

did you just ask if we would rather be
near death
kinda where we are right now
frozen to death
nothing but death

marble hearth
swift heart
# tiny lintel ahahahah

I've tested my RC out of necessity (had to fix the mirror spacing) and it's probably around 1/10 wave or so

swift heart
tiny lintel
#

at what aperture ?

swift heart
tiny lintel
#

Yeah well to test that you would need like 0,3" seeing, and thats below the diffraction limit...

swift heart
tiny lintel
swift heart
#

I have a grating for it that I need to assemble

#

You don't need perfect seeing to evaluate the correction

tiny lintel
#

Our eyes cannot see 0.1 λ

swift heart
cold moon
swift heart
cold moon
swift heart
#

Yeah I was gonna say if you want the absolute correction you would need both conics

swift heart
cold moon
tiny lintel
cerulean elm
#

Nothing beats interferometry

swift heart
#

Perhaps I'll put together such a setup in the future

cerulean elm
#

I think you gen get them all for like 200$ from aliexpress

swift heart
# tiny lintel RMS

1/10 wave RMS is difficult to spot (though possible) but that's why I cited that number as an upper bound on the wavefront error

swift heart
cerulean elm
#

Wait... λ = ?

swift heart
#

usually 550 nm depending on the optics

#

it matters less with an all-reflecting setup

dreamy cloak
cerulean elm
#

I assume the wavefront will be different at λ = 500nm compared to λ = 800nmmonkaHmm

swift heart
cerulean elm
swift heart
#

It's actually easier to test visually

#

Because you're not averaging out seeing effects and can get a better idea of what the defocused patterns actually look like

tiny lintel
#

No further comments from me, its pointless.

cerulean elm
#

Hear me out. Conjugated infinite point source of light. I was working on such projects before I got scammed with some pinholesPepeHands

#

This was the rough ideaAwkwardSmile

swift heart
#

for reference, here is what 1/10 wave spherical aberration looks like when you're 1/2 wave defocused (top) and 1 wave defocused (bottom)

#

and that's with 47% obstruction, which actually makes it harder to spot

cerulean elm
# swift heart I need to look into interferometric setups now

the one that i showed you, that's not interferometry. that's just a way to dim and reduce the size of a source of light so it appear more like a star. also it will make it into a diverging beam which will be collimated by another optical system before being sent into the tested telescope.

swift heart
swift heart
cerulean elm
#

idk if it would actually work, but worth testing XD

bronze minnow
brisk copper
#

its goated for planetary visual

#

(if seeing allows)

marble hearth
open aspen
# open aspen
poll_question_text

Smeeglezorp?

victor_answer_votes

5

total_votes

10

victor_answer_id

2

victor_answer_text

Gleep glorp!

woeful ivy
#

#1087219932900638720 message

fallen obsidian
# fallen obsidian
poll_question_text

Which Newtonian Do I Get

victor_answer_votes

3

total_votes

3

victor_answer_id

1

victor_answer_text

Apertua 8" F/4

plucky vigil
woeful ivy
#

hopefully i dont have to sacrifice it

glacial bear
woeful ivy
low lance
#

Sure your images won't look super good (unless you got a xiaomi) but still looks alright

glacial bear
# low lance Bruh phone ap is like super easy

Nah. Can't stack, can't get details on Mars, Jupiter's way too bright to get anything other than a huge dot, and you can't image the ice giants either. Lucky to get Saturn and the moon. Can't bring out details in any of the nebula because you can't stack, images are too compressed to work with.

glacial bear
#

Me, who tried phone AP

low lance
low lance
#

What phone did yiu use

glacial bear
#

There is literally no setting on the phone that would let me get a decent image.

Samsung S17, iPhone SE, iPhone 11, iPhone 14

#

Oh and one of the Samsung J series phones.

#

One of the "lower" smartphones. Then the various Flagship phone versions.

#

So ...

#

🤷

#

But I could get decent stuff with a DSLR. And probably my new mirrorless. Definitely with the planetary cam I have now. 🙂

low lance
#

But thats not to say you cant get a half decent image from them half decent considering they are phones

#

Like i said tho if you want good images you need a xiaomi

glacial bear
#

Maybe if Jupiter came through as something other than a bright blob of light they could do halfway decent. But it doesn't, so the notion falls flat right at that point.

low lance
woeful ivy
woeful ivy
#

but u can stack bad images

ivory mural
#

i use a Samsung s20

#

$150 phone

#

certainly not amazing but it works

woeful ivy
ivory mural
woeful ivy
#

idk

#

24

ivory mural
#

your data is a lot better too it just needs better processing

woeful ivy
#

how much better tho? idk the exact model

#

i forgot

ivory mural
#

my image of the same region is sending but wifi ass

#

oh one sent

#

other one failed

#

ok there other one sent

woeful ivy
#

@ivory mural

#

fake ahh moon tho

ivory mural
woeful ivy
#

idk

#

i forgor the reason

undone sinew
brisk copper
low lance
low lance
# undone sinew

Sometimes it's soo bad that i go months and months without being able to do astro

glacial bear
# undone sinew

Tom's answer is the last one. Even if it isn't, doesn't matter, he has something on his equip that disperses the clouds and settles the atmosphere when he's imaging.

glacial bear
# woeful ivy yes decent image is hard

Looking at your images I'm starting to think that my thought of how phone AP works is different than how what people actually do when they're saying "phone AP."

undone sinew
split light
restive fiber
rain void
# undone sinew

we need an even worse option for me and @marble hearth , which includes >90% humidity every day, if not straight up foggy :(

undone sinew
vagrant basin
brisk copper
vagrant basin
#

Naw

brisk copper
#

maybe if you removed the lens

vagrant basin
#

Maybe if you done it right

low lance
brisk copper
#

and used the bare sensor for ap

brisk copper
low lance
brisk copper
#

like 1up pixled

vagrant basin
#

The sensor is mid i can agree w that but you van get crazy results

low lance
brisk copper
#

yes its 50mp

#

but only about 12.5 is the actual num

vagrant basin
#

Dude i took this through sh seeing in B5 30min

#

Mid budget phone aswell

#

Stars were mid icl but there is potential

#

You lot silent now😂

low lance
#

Like just look how much noise there is and this is in day time with proper exposure

#

Like its just absurd

vagrant basin
#

I can agree w noise but it's easily fixable with calibrations

#

The noise can be hefty

low lance
#

Because its read noise

low lance
vagrant basin
#

Why would yiu take a day pic in raw

low lance
vagrant basin
#

Fairs but post processing makes up for the noise

low lance
vagrant basin
low lance
#

Like i said the only good sensors are the ones made by sony xiaomi is the only good phone camera manufacturer

low lance
vagrant basin
#

But most of the time it somewhat don't matter what phone you have you js need to know what your doing

low lance
#

So i wouldn't recommend using their phones on a day to day basis unless you root the phone

brisk copper
brisk copper
low lance
fallen obsidian
glacial bear
#

But that's a camera not a phone

low lance
low lance
# glacial bear But that's a camera not a phone

Sensor size has no effect on quality of an image wasoever sensor architecture pixel size and processing hardware on the other hand absolutely do at least when it comes to astro with normal photography larger sensor have a deeper depth of field

glacial bear
#

So "not necessarily an ideal astro cam." But great for the purpose I bought it.

#

Then again, don't underestimate Canon ... the same sensor on a different camera got this image.

woeful ivy
# woeful ivy
poll_question_text

#1087219932900638720 message should i keep my promise?

victor_answer_votes

8

total_votes

9

victor_answer_id

2

victor_answer_text

no

#

phew

#

yessss

woeful ivy
glacial bear
#

Oh well then.

ivory mural
#

I don't remember you having a scope

split light
cerulean elm
marble hearth
#

Black wires on black gear helps hide them wholesome

undone sinew
# undone sinew
poll_question_text

How’s your weather usually (during winter)

victor_answer_votes

8

total_votes

22

victor_answer_id

1

victor_answer_text

Absolutely awful, every single day is cloudy

elfin zinc
marble hearth
elfin zinc
#

Zip ties don't sound like a bad idea now haha

marble hearth
elfin zinc
#

Lighter, melt the cables, fuse the copper, issue fixed AwkwardSmile

tiny lintel
marble hearth
cedar dome
cerulean elm
tiny lintel
undone sinew
# cedar dome

10” sct because it has the highest resell value and i could do whatever i want with the money

cerulean elm
dreamy cloak
vagrant basin
#

Newtonian

split light
fallen obsidian
swift heart
swift heart
ivory mural
# ivory mural
poll_question_text

would you continue astrophotography if you had to return to untracked phone ap?

victor_answer_votes

11

total_votes

21

victor_answer_id

2

victor_answer_text

noe

victor_answer_emoji_id

1231002251599020135

victor_answer_emoji_name

asiair

woeful ivy
cedar dome
# cedar dome
poll_question_text

Would you rather buy a…

victor_answer_votes

14

total_votes

22

victor_answer_id

2

victor_answer_text

8” Newtonian

ivory mural
bronze minnow
# bronze minnow
poll_question_text

Best galilean moon

victor_answer_votes

7

total_votes

15

victor_answer_id

3

victor_answer_text

io

victor_answer_emoji_name

🌋

#

o

lofty jetty
#

though, does that mean that I am stuck permanently at untracked phone ap or I can upgrade?

ivory mural
#

can even go to the extreme and remove your phones lens to have a bare sensor

lofty jetty
#

i keep my answer of hell no

ivory mural
#

everyone is doubting phone ap

#

it's not that bad

lofty jetty
ivory mural
#

it isn't shit

somber belfry
ivory mural
#

as with any rig you have to learn how to use it

#

what a shocker

somber belfry
lofty jetty
glacial bear
desert obsidian
#

Also the earth is a dodecahedron

bronze minnow
woeful ivy
bronze minnow
woeful ivy
bronze minnow
tall rivet
tall rivet
#

Took this shot at the same time with friends, but everyone processed their own.
3 pics: one shot on a stock A7III, one on an astromodded 6D, and one on a phone.
Same total exposure time, but the cameras used 180s subs and the phone used 20s (fixed tripod).
Guess which is which

delicate lance
cold moon
cerulean elm
delicate lance
low lance
brisk copper
#

flock then baffle

summer turret
summer turret
delicate lance
split light
# split light
poll_question_text

What colors are on your rig? (select all that apply)

victor_answer_votes

23

total_votes

95

victor_answer_id

1

victor_answer_text

Black

victor_answer_emoji_name

summer turret
#

More hours at job

delicate lance
#

ill get mono eventually

vagrant basin
brisk copper
bronze minnow
#

(by rain)

delicate lance
#

mainly because the richest astrophotographers ABSOLUTELY SUCK

#

like they are HORRENDOUS

#

couldnt process ORION properly at GUNPOINT

bronze minnow
delicate lance
#

its like 40k on the setup, 4 days of processing refusing to learn how to do it properly

bronze minnow
cerulean elm
# vagrant basin

5th option. Understanding the weather patterns and knowing precisely that not every clear night is a good night

marble hearth
ivory mural
#

new prices stay, used deals can disappear at any time

lofty jetty
#

you may remember this because I mentioned this before, but this is an M31 of a guy with a ~$40k rig

#

like this data is incredible

#

but bro

#

WHY IS IT BLUE/PURPLE AND ORANGE

summer turret
#

people put more effort into getting the data instead of processing it

ivory mural
lofty jetty
low lance
#

Tbh these are the type of people who think spending a crap ton of money will immediately get them the best results

rain void
swift heart
#

for context

rain void
summer turret
#

ball

cerulean elm
swift heart
#

(It was retired between 1992 and 2020)

rain void
#

the meatball is a well designed and recognizable logo, while the worm gets rid of all identity and style

#

just letters, except the A's are missing the line through them is probably the most basic logo for anything ever

urban quiver
silver holly
#

This isn’t fair because the s30 and pix rig is significantly cheaper lol

#

You gotta match the value

urban quiver
#

pretend you get a good used deal for the rig

silver holly
#

I’m not pretending anything

rain void
#

with an S30, pix won't help AwkwardSmile

swift heart
ivory mural
silver holly
#

But if it came down to it I’d rather pix and osc over mono and no pix. Any day.

#

Siril just lacks a lot of mono processing tools. And osc processing tools.

rain void
swift heart
swift heart
#

Apparently the reason the worm was dropped in 1992 was because a good number of employees hated it

swift heart
rain void
#

how will dubious symbolism ever compete with this

#

tho i guess they were the first to oversimplify their logo ig

#

that's at least something

swift heart
#

tbh I feel like the worm might be more popular than the meatball in the US at the moment

#

this despite the general dislike of oversimplified logos

#

In this era the US government actually invested in graphic design

#

(mid 70s)

swift heart
ivory mural
#

Curious to see what everyone else thinks, imo it should be $20

urban quiver
#

One of the main appeals is that it’s open source…. So no

woeful ivy
urban quiver
ivory mural
#

Meant how much do you think it's worth

cerulean elm
# ivory mural

If siril will become payware, they just shit themselves in the foot. Because right away people will rather opt for the more expensive pixinsight

delicate lance
delicate lance
# delicate lance
poll_question_text

What should I buy when I finally have money

victor_answer_votes

11

total_votes

14

victor_answer_id

2

victor_answer_text

Mono Setup (new)

low lance
# low lance
poll_question_text

Should I flock my telescope or add baffles

victor_answer_votes

12

total_votes

12

victor_answer_id

1

victor_answer_text

Flock

low lance
cold moon
cold moon
# swift heart

Meatball but I'm saying this while wearing a hoodie with the simpler logo on it

cold moon
# ivory mural

To compete with Pix it needs to stay free imo but if Pix wasn't an option I'd probably be willing to spend even 30/40$

swift heart
# ivory mural

if Siril wasn't free I'd be doing my processing in a Jupyter or Pluto.jl notebook.

brisk copper
delicate lance
vagrant basin
# vagrant basin
poll_question_text

What is harder to master?

victor_answer_votes

19

total_votes

23

victor_answer_id

2

victor_answer_text

Post processing

swift heart
# swift heart
poll_question_text

NASA meatball or NASA worm?

victor_answer_votes

15

total_votes

21

victor_answer_id

1

victor_answer_text

Meatball

victor_answer_emoji_name

🧆

urban quiver
# urban quiver
poll_question_text

What would you rather have?

victor_answer_votes

14

total_votes

14

victor_answer_id

1

victor_answer_text

Full OSC Rig without pix

swift heart
# delicate lance

Any reflection off an anti-reflection coating is the coating not doing its job

delicate lance
swift heart
# ivory mural

alright hot take: I'd pay more for SIRIL than for PixInsight because PixInsight doesn't respect standardized FITS data, like ROWORDER or WCS distortion polynomials

#

It is a pain to deal with XISF files when you want to combine people's data

#

I just want to build a multiscale mosaic out of people's data. But no. PixInsight doesn't use WCS, they use their own incompatible garbage

ivory mural
#

id have to say smth like "how much do you think siril is worth" but premade options dont work for that

ivory mural
# ivory mural
poll_question_text

Should Siril be free?

victor_answer_votes

16

total_votes

16

victor_answer_id

1

victor_answer_text

yes

victor_answer_emoji_id

1232562185784524831

victor_answer_emoji_name

siril

cerulean elm
woeful ivy
#

DiO

brisk copper
#

i love dio

cold moon
#

But yeah, that's probably the only thing I don't quite like about Pix, it constantly cries about FITS being deprecated 😭, like shut up, NASA is still using it afaik

delicate lance
# delicate lance
poll_question_text

once my camera arrives, what should i image !? (650mm FL F/5 + IMX664 uncooled uv/ir cut)

victor_answer_votes

7

total_votes

15

victor_answer_id

2

victor_answer_text

Silver Sliver Galaxy

delicate lance
# delicate lance
poll_question_text

Which lens coating looks best? (aka as the coloured reflection off of lenses)

victor_answer_votes

7

total_votes

21

victor_answer_id

2

victor_answer_text

Purple

victor_answer_emoji_name

🟣

restive fiber
# restive fiber
poll_question_text

Where would you rather be? You can sent signals faster than lights and you can bring anything you want. land anywhere in the solar system.

victor_answer_votes

8

total_votes

13

victor_answer_id

4

victor_answer_text

far in the Oort cloud

vagrant basin
undone sinew
zealous cloak
#

10k and put it all on red

urban quiver
cerulean elm
# undone sinew

So, is a box of 20.000$ of junk, or 10.000$ cash. Gimme the cash please. I know exactly what to get

undone sinew
#

This is worse than the galaxy vs nebula one damn💔

ivory mural
marble hearth
#

200 powerseekers, please

brisk copper
woeful ivy
obsidian plover
tender hollow
obsidian plover
#

Ig lucky I never have to deal with that

#

Last time my area even had sleet was 1984

woeful ivy
#

idk if it was snowing but there was snow on ground

plucky vigil
#
poll_question_text

Ban meowing once and for all

victor_answer_votes

15

total_votes

30

brisk copper
brisk copper
delicate lance
#

technically it should

#

since it has a heatsink

#

cool it and it cools the sensor directly

low lance
swift heart
# obsidian plover

When we went out to Chaquamegon-Nicolet for first light with my friend's 8" SCT, we had an unexpected clear air snowfall

#

No clouds, just snow dropping out of a clear sky

#

It was actually pretty transparent, though to be fair we were in Bortle 2 skies at the absolute max

woeful ivy
undone sinew
# undone sinew
poll_question_text

Would you rather

victor_answer_votes

21

total_votes

22

victor_answer_id

2

victor_answer_text

$10,000 up front in cash

#

For more specifics, it gets shot by a .22 LR or it lands on flat concrete

#

does anyone have any better poll ideas cause i ran out ngl

#

my prime in polls is long gone we need to make 6.0 or something so everyone forgets about the earlier polls and repeats them again

dreamy cloak
#

Rather the rifle because of i can Control the Angle in which it IS Shot at i Just need to replace the Tube of the scope which i think is managable

undone sinew
#

you gotta kiss those lucky charms and hope it doesn’t hit something expensive

#

Same for the other one you can’t control how you drop it

#

Actually i remember some guy kept making those “would you drop your rig from _ cm for 500 dollars” i forgot who it was

undone sinew
urban quiver
#

Low chance it would hit a mirror

undone sinew
urban quiver
#

so you’d just have 2 holes in your tube so just patch it lol

undone sinew
#

Ohhh wait i thought you meant like through the holes the truss ones have

urban quiver
#

No like the side

#

Someone should buy a cheap newt and test it

#

If I get annoyed with my heritage il shoot it

undone sinew
#

i mean if you have a light telescope i dont think dropping it from a few meters is gonna hurt it that much aside from scratches

swift heart
# undone sinew

Never forget when the Harlan J. Smith telescope got shot

The Harlan J. Smith Telescope is a 107-inch (2.7 m) telescope located at the McDonald Observatory, in Texas, in the United States. This telescope is one of several research telescopes that are part of the University of Texas at Austin observatory perched on Mount Locke in the Davis Mountains of west Texas. The telescope was completed in 1968 wit...

urban quiver
#

I doubt our commercial grade mirrors would survive being shot

swift heart
#

I think it's just dummy thicc glass

undone sinew
#

How did it drop the aperture?

swift heart
#

So the total area of the mirror decreased

undone sinew
#

🎏

swift heart
#

The resolution is mostly determined by the linear aperture size, so that's not affected as much

fallen obsidian
brisk copper
# brisk copper
poll_question_text

are ophiuroids cute

victor_answer_votes

7

total_votes

9

victor_answer_id

5

victor_answer_text

yea

undone sinew
summer turret
#

well, my rig has been shat on

#

so i'd say a little damage

delicate lance
urban quiver
#

Do you mean like

1 full mono EAF, AM5
2 OSC AM3s
4 OSC GTIs?

delicate lance
#

splitting up e.g. 20k into 2k rigs

#

or even 4k rigs

urban quiver
#

I think my gear fits the 2 rigs for specific targets

#

I got the Askar for wide/medium FL, and RC6 for small and planets

obsidian plover
#

one good dso and one good solar rig

glacial bear
# undone sinew

Inexperience combined with ratchet trying to bring the RA motor tight to the mount.

glacial bear
brisk copper
swift heart
# undone sinew

Mine has rusted due to water exposure...at least the screws have. Which I need to replace but it hasn't been damaged otherwise

woeful ivy
# undone sinew

honestly my rig is my phone

rifle will have 0% chance of survival
balcony might have 5%

low lance
# undone sinew

Mine has a few scratches on the outside nothing on the optics with some minor humidity rust nothing that hurts its performance

tender hollow
#

Entire teeth sheared off.

ivory mural
#

my first rig was an abomination of random houeshold items and it fell apart

low lance
tender hollow
#

brass worm gear beats aluminum worm wheel

obsidian plover
# obsidian plover
poll_question_text

While doing astro have you ever seen snow

victor_answer_votes

9

total_votes

21

victor_answer_id

4

victor_answer_text

Never

marble hearth
undone sinew
# undone sinew
poll_question_text

Would you rather

victor_answer_votes

15

total_votes

17

victor_answer_id

1

victor_answer_text

Have your rig get shot at by a rifle

cerulean elm
# undone sinew

You know what? If you shoot my OTA sideways, it could survive even a .50 BMG. I just put some tape over the holes and resume to imagingkekw

undone sinew
cerulean elm
brisk copper
#

a drop from a balcomloyny will

brisk copper
#

it will punch through and leave a hole about 2-3x the size of the bullet

#

genuinely more survivable than a drop

fallen obsidian
brisk copper
#

rain is evil

undone sinew
# undone sinew
poll_question_text

Has your rig ever been damaged before

victor_answer_votes

12

total_votes

20

victor_answer_id

2

victor_answer_text

A few scratches

delicate lance
# delicate lance
poll_question_text

Given a pretty high budget, what would you rather have?

victor_answer_votes

13

total_votes

23

victor_answer_id

2

victor_answer_text

2 or 3 rigs for specific targets

fossil temple
summer turret
#

Crunchy peanut butter is the only acceptable thing

obsidian plover
# fossil temple

Peanut butter is literally the most revolting thing over ever laid eyes upon

undone sinew
ivory mural
#

if you imaged every clear night b9 would be better than b1

brisk copper
#

like .5 of one

#

so it takes me about 3 hours for 1 hour of data

#

wow

ivory mural
#

🥳

brisk copper
low lance
#

1.45hrs

cerulean elm
# undone sinew

I'd rather have 1 clear day every 3 months and put out a banger of an image rather than daily slopkekw

obsidian plover
ivory mural
#

the daily slop would be combined into one omage

cerulean elm
#

Seeing is all it matters

obsidian plover
cerulean elm
obsidian plover
#

Ig just to many people in a small area

low lance
low lance
ivory mural
low lance
#

I'm talking about narrowband btw

ivory mural
#

I know

cerulean elm
dreamy cloak
#

Oh Well, just saw its 1-2 most of the time

cerulean elm
#

Or Greenland

#

But you don't have anything to image in those areas

undone sinew
delicate lance
woeful ivy
undone sinew
# delicate lance

they dont let you repair your celestron products yourself you gotta send them at their facilities so they can overpay you for it

delicate lance
#

I’ve realized that celestron wouldn’t be particularly successful if Meade was still up and in the game for proper competition lol

undone sinew
#

What happened to meade

delicate lance
#

Bankruptcy iirc

undone sinew
#

how though weren’t they good

delicate lance
#

Orion bought Meade when it became bankrupt and then they realized how deep in debt it is

fossil temple
# fossil temple
poll_question_text

Peanut butter

victor_answer_votes

10

total_votes

17

victor_answer_id

1

victor_answer_text

Yes

victor_answer_emoji_name

🥜

summer turret
cold moon
# ivory mural

Yeah and obviously I'm in B5 instead of B4, the difference is crazy

undone sinew
ivory mural
#

That's your opinion

#

I want the most potential possible

#

Also every night is clear gives the huge advantage of always being able to troubleshoot

#

It would take me a year to get half arcsecond guiding in the b1 scenario

undone sinew
# undone sinew
poll_question_text

Would you rather

victor_answer_votes

13

total_votes

18

victor_answer_id

2

victor_answer_text

constant bortle 9 + average seeing, always clear daily

restive fiber
ivory mural
# restive fiber

no because whatever caused there to be zero light pollution in the world is going to be much worse than having light pollution

#

eh ig you did say only one day so fast recovery

woeful ivy
# restive fiber

remember that time when LA got blackout and ppl called emergency cos they saw milky way?

#

i vote yes

#

would be funny asf

woeful ivy
restive fiber
summer turret
#

cuz 'merica

delicate lance
# delicate lance
poll_question_text

Valid or Invalid - Celestron in reality is quite a bad company, considering their overpriced and cheaply made products (powerseeker, astromaster, AVX; list goes on and on) with the exception of their RASA and SCT.

victor_answer_votes

8

total_votes

15

victor_answer_id

1

victor_answer_text

Valid

glacial bear
glacial bear
urban quiver
#

The good thing about light pollution, if you turn off the lights it goes away

#

Unlike air or water pollution

glacial bear
#

Yeah, if I forget to turn off my faucet and turn off the lights my water bill is still pretty high.

restive fiber
# restive fiber
poll_question_text

Do you wish we can have 1 day without light pollution.

victor_answer_votes

21

total_votes

21

victor_answer_id

1

victor_answer_text

yes

swift heart
delicate lance
violet tinsel
#

assuming pixinsight includes blurx the choice is clear for me

delicate lance
#

no RC stuff

#

only pix

#

I also dont plan on getting any RC plugins any time soon

cerulean elm
delicate lance
cerulean elm
delicate lance
brisk copper
delicate lance
# delicate lance
poll_question_text

What should I get?

victor_answer_votes

7

total_votes

9

victor_answer_id

1

victor_answer_text

Guiding Setup

brisk copper
swift heart
delicate lance
#

yes of course but this is to see what the frac community thinks of frac designs

cold moon
fallen obsidian
swift heart
urban quiver
#

id get the RC personally tho

fallen obsidian
swift heart
restive fiber
#

sun

cerulean elm
marble hearth
cerulean elm
marble hearth
#

OH

#

I thought u were referring to a diff poll 😭 😭

marble hearth
obsidian plover
undone sinew
#

i tried to make this as difficult as possible hopefully it’s better than the last one

restive fiber
rain void
# undone sinew

Nah man this is too easy. You compared actual useful gear with an sct

swift heart
# restive fiber

I mean, I wish I had one more telescope that was smaller than my RC

#

I don't have room for a 16" RC at the moment but I could use a small refractor

#

Or I could use a second 8" RC pepeEvil

marble hearth
brisk copper
marble hearth
marble hearth
brisk copper
#

I HATE YOU

marble hearth
#

ONE SOLVED PROBLEM PER ITEM GUYS

swift heart
#

idk exterminating the earth sounds like it would solve every problem

marble hearth
#

So like 24hr imaging sessions and no objects that never rise above horizon

#

(if weather and atmosphere allows ofc)

delicate lance
# delicate lance
poll_question_text

Would you rather have....

victor_answer_votes

9

total_votes

13

victor_answer_id

1

victor_answer_text

Super Sharp Triplet + Field Flattener (e.g. esprit)

fallen obsidian
# fallen obsidian
poll_question_text

What scope do I get for my 2025 ragdoll 17

victor_answer_votes

8

total_votes

15

victor_answer_id

2

victor_answer_text

High Quality 8" f/4

undone sinew
# undone sinew
poll_question_text

Would you rather

victor_answer_votes

6

total_votes

12

restive fiber
# restive fiber
poll_question_text

Do you wish you had a bigger or smaller telescope.

victor_answer_votes

18

total_votes

20

victor_answer_id

1

victor_answer_text

Bigger telescope

delicate lance
#

its that everyone else ages as you go there

#

supposing you go near light speed

#

you come back and everyone you know is gone

restive fiber
#

It travels near light speed

undone sinew
brisk copper
marble hearth
# marble hearth
poll_question_text

Which fictional item would you rather have?

victor_answer_votes

18

total_votes

21

victor_answer_id

3

victor_answer_text

Atmosphere filter (no wobble or light pollution)

restive fiber
brisk copper
woeful ivy
# restive fiber

if i can decide when ill travel and i survive and thrive there

i say yes

#

if it happens the moment I vote, nah i say no

woeful ivy
#

ill pick yes, stay on earth until everyone i love dies

then i travel to avoid being accused of immortality

#

will return every thousand years or so

low lance
# marble hearth

I envy everyone who doesn't live where i live sp ima go with the cloud gun

summer turret
urban quiver
# summer turret

I wouldn’t count DeepSNR as free since it’s locked behind Pixinsight

reef viper
#

deepsnr free?

devout tinsel
woeful ivy
marble hearth
devout tinsel
#

Oiiiiiiiiiiiiiii

woeful ivy
void jolt
#

siril + affinity + dsnr/starnet

delicate lance
#

additional info:

Redcat comes with Bahtinov Mask (and drip) and has an internal focuser, eliminating focuser tilt.

Hope D60 is F/4.66, Redcat is F/5

Other than that, they come with similar stuff. Hope D60 is new and barely shows reviews.

fallen obsidian
#

to f/3.7

delicate lance
#

na if at all then imma get a 130HNT

cold moon
delicate lance
#

fair enough

fallen obsidian
marble hearth
delicate lance
cold moon
marble hearth
fallen obsidian
delicate lance
#

tbh an esprit is a really attractive pick for me

#

the sharpness

cold moon
marble hearth
#

No yeah ofc, it's worth to get a reflector for apertures over 80ish mm

cedar dome
ivory mural
obsidian plover
#

Autumn has the best weather for me

brisk copper
cerulean elm
cerulean elm
delicate lance
summer turret
#

I love long astro dark

obsidian plover
#

No way u guys are saying O eee

delicate lance
#

oxygen

cold moon
brisk copper
cold moon
brisk copper
marble hearth
delicate lance
marble hearth
obsidian plover
#

Aye aye doesnt sound like eye eye

marble hearth
#

Yes it does?

#

The stuff pirates say

obsidian plover
marble hearth
obsidian plover
marble hearth
#

Like "aye aye captain"

brisk copper
marble hearth
#

Literally any text or caption of that sound in that context will have that spelling

brisk copper
#

eye and aye sound so different

#

its too noticable

#

pease stop the raggebait

marble hearth
#

I get how u can say aye as "ayy" but like aye as "eye" also makes perfectly good sense

woeful ivy
cold moon
#

Either way, it's the worst language on earth and pronunciation makes zero sense

obsidian plover
woeful ivy
#

why is yes X

#

and no a checkmark

marble hearth
obsidian plover
#

because the yes answer is just wrong

marble hearth
#

Nuhuh

obsidian plover
#

😭 🙏

brisk copper
summer turret
# summer turret
poll_question_text

Favourite FREE Astro Processing Software/Tools?

victor_answer_votes

16

total_votes

19

victor_answer_id

1

victor_answer_text

Siril

delicate lance
marble hearth
# marble hearth
poll_question_text

How do you pronounce Oiii in your head

victor_answer_votes

9

total_votes

19

victor_answer_id

2

victor_answer_text

Oh-three

desert obsidian
delicate lance
# delicate lance
poll_question_text

Would you rather have...

victor_answer_votes

7

total_votes

9

victor_answer_id

1

victor_answer_text

Hope D60 (Quintuplet 60mm)

cedar dome
# cedar dome
poll_question_text

Best season to image in

victor_answer_votes

6

total_votes

19

obsidian plover
# obsidian plover
poll_question_text

Is Aye and Eye the same sound

victor_answer_votes

10

total_votes

16

victor_answer_id

2

victor_answer_text

No

victor_answer_emoji_name

devout tinsel
fossil temple
obsidian plover
#

i aint drinking that battery acid bruh

fossil temple
#

Fair enough

#

I only drink for flavor

summer turret
#

i dont like energy drinks tbh

#

during my exam period I have them bc i need the energy/ caffeine but apart from that they suck shit

#

🚮

#

also that shits really bad for you

tribal coral
#

way too sweet imo

brisk copper
cerulean elm
restive fiber
# restive fiber
poll_question_text

Do you wish you can travel to another star system without ageing

victor_answer_votes

10

total_votes

13

victor_answer_id

1

victor_answer_text

Yes

undone sinew
delicate lance
#

redbull only has a few good ones but thats it

dreamy cloak
glacial bear
#

I stick with the classic and known to not contain a chemical shitstorm.

Coffee.

brisk copper
delicate lance
#

its a sweet, sugary 500ml can of heart attack

brisk copper
#

well, the flavour i drink isnt

delicate lance
#

they are

#

they are absolute ass.

brisk copper
#

redbull you can taste the caffeine and its horrible

delicate lance
brisk copper
brisk copper
#

the grapefruit monster is good

delicate lance
brisk copper
delicate lance
#

so you tasted a bitter soapy note?

brisk copper
#

the original is by far the worst tho

delicate lance
#

never had that, i dont know what nuclear waste you drank

delicate lance
brisk copper
#

is that what caffeine tastes of

delicate lance
brisk copper
#

bc thats all i could think that flavour is due to

brisk copper
delicate lance
delicate lance
#

never tasted that

brisk copper
#

weird, its really strong

low lance
low lance
void jolt
#

(yet)

mint talon
#

dont ask for a source i dont have one

glacial bear
#

"Common sense". One rehydrates with water. Caffeine is a diuretic.

undone sinew
low lance
late summit
#

I can be as hydrated as a lake, caffeine will still have 0 effect on me

bronze minnow
# fossil temple

I just demolish a chocolate bar and temporarily acheive nuclear fusion
the crash comes but it just sets me back to normal

fossil temple
#

A gram of uranium usually does it for me

cerulean elm
woeful ivy
hard slate
#

Can also go to sleep on the same drunk 30 mins before bedtime kekw

glacial bear
low lance
cerulean elm
#

If you burn them fast enough, they don't stick

violet tinsel
fossil temple
# fossil temple
poll_question_text

Favorite energy drink

victor_answer_votes

15

total_votes

23

victor_answer_id

10

victor_answer_text

I don't drink energy drinks

undone sinew
# undone sinew
poll_question_text

How many eyepieces do you own

victor_answer_votes

13

total_votes

27

victor_answer_id

2

victor_answer_text

1-3

low lance
#

Some people aren't affected

lofty jetty
#

As far as option one, I will buy a new roki 135mm and return the old one as many times as necessary until i get a good copy

#

Also, my rig is sort of built around the lens (mainly being the astrodymium ring set) so that is a big factor as to why I want to have a good copy

cerulean elm
lofty jetty
#

I mean… if they don’t come from the same factory…

#

Then maybe the qc is better?

cerulean elm
lofty jetty
#

As I’m sure you know

cerulean elm
cerulean elm
lofty jetty
#

Mine is nowhere near that good at 4.5

cerulean elm
lofty jetty
#

Wait, what does the T stand for?

cerulean elm
# lofty jetty Wait, what does the T stand for?

My lens is not measured in f-stops (ratio between focal length and aperture) is measured in Transmission stops. Basically it counts for how much light actually makes it trough the optical system. That's honestly how telescopes should be measured as well. In T-stops and not f-stops

lofty jetty
#

Is it a cine lens by any chance?

cerulean elm
lofty jetty
#

Not sure if I the Astrodymium rings will work with that

#

Though, I think they might

#

I know I need to buy a new part for my EAF

cerulean elm
lofty jetty
cerulean elm
# lofty jetty Unfortunately no

Don't ask why, but I have it modeled in fusion360. So I can give you a .stl file that you can 3D print and test it with your rings

lofty jetty
#

But I can make things work lol

cerulean elm
undone sinew
#

aaaand i made a mistake whatever i dont feel like fixing it

#

“past year” means this year second 500 is supposed to be 501 blah blah blah whatever

fallen obsidian
undone sinew
#

dude thats like at least 8

cerulean elm
zealous cloak
obsidian plover
tiny lintel
tidal tundra
fallen obsidian
#

would be like 1000 without the ragdoll

devout tinsel
# devout tinsel
poll_question_text

Should I make thread in share your data with all my data (like ashen) ?

victor_answer_votes

11

total_votes

14

victor_answer_id

1

victor_answer_text

Yes

devout tinsel
undone sinew
# undone sinew
poll_question_text

How much money have you spent on telescope equipment in the past year?

victor_answer_votes

14

total_votes

21

victor_answer_id

6

victor_answer_text

$1000+

somber belfry
leaden copper
#

its not even a competition

summer turret
#

nuclear is just incredibly dangerous to produce

leaden copper
#

eginearing

urban quiver
leaden copper
#

alr bro who voted for fossil fuiels

leaden copper
summer turret
#

dont get me wrong - nuclear energy is really good but its just very dangerous

#

solars way more safer and pretty much infinite

leaden copper
zealous cloak
urban quiver
#

nuclear is the only option

#

and it’s extremely safe

#

Solar actually sucks

zealous cloak
#

I love when people talk about opinions in these topicskekw

urban quiver
#

saying solar sucks is a fact not an opinion

zealous cloak
somber belfry
somber belfry
#

i hadnt realised coolant pumps were off...

zealous cloak
#

Governments just sell solar, wind, hydro and so on as "green, clean energies" to discourage people from supporting/investing in nuclear. Nuclear means free energy for everyone and the oil industries dislike that idea very very much AwkwardSmile

tiny lintel
# tiny lintel
poll_question_text

How much money have you spent on your equipment in total ?

victor_answer_votes

6

total_votes

27

zealous cloak
#

And dont even talk about nuclear fusion, it will literally get you killed AwkwardSmile

zealous cloak
#

No, fusion

somber belfry
#

...

#

im gonna go kms

zealous cloak
#

You dont know what nuclear fusion is?

somber belfry
zealous cloak
#

Its alright

somber belfry
#

i thought i went crazy for a sec

#

fewww

#

😭

zealous cloak
#

I said nuclear fusion will get you killed because of the recent death of Nuno Loureiro, look him up

fallen obsidian
glacial bear
# summer turret nuclear is just incredibly dangerous to produce

Science and studies have borne out that nuclear is the safest to produce, I believe by a long shot.

The problem is that when something goes sideways, it tends to be ... noticeable in a manner that is substantially harder to overlook than when something goes sideways with other forms of power. Oh and Yellow Journalism and Sensationalism need to be accounted, as well. There's a town in PA that is uninhabitable because a coal mine is burning below it. That disaster doesn't get the news that 3 Mile Island or Chernobyl or Fukishima had. And Chernobyl was the only one that arguably had a larger immediate and larger potential impact than the burning coal.