#Ritchey–Chrétien enjoyers thread

1 messages · Page 3 of 1

harsh matrix
#

Yeah?

vapid patio
#

does your dec axis still have some friction with the clutch disingaged?

harsh matrix
#

i adjusted to where it didnt have so much that it wouldnt move with the clutch disengaged and with the dec unbalanced

#

mine was very stiff

vapid patio
#

mine has none like none so when I try to balance my scope it's impossible. But if I put the littlest friction on the clutch, it stays

#

mine was hyper tuned so maybe the dude messed with the clutch?

harsh matrix
vapid patio
#

like my other mount sky watcher gti has a good bit of friction when disengaged

harsh matrix
#

it has to do with how well the dec axis is attached to the right ascension

#

id say if there is a point where the dec doesnt move with even a tiny bit of friction with the clutch just barely engaged, it's probably good enough

#

im not familiar with those celestron mounts so idk if the dec to RA meshing is something that can be adjusted/easily adjusted

vapid patio
#

ok it does a 360 if i let it go. like no matter how i have it i have no clue why

harsh matrix
# vapid patio nope

yeah so that means that the dude who tuned it probably had no control over this

#

it's just being annoying ig

vapid patio
#

@harsh matrix

#

i got it

#

i had to flip the eaf and put counter weights on it haha

vapid patio
brisk swift
#

What mount is that

vapid patio
#

@brisk swift Cgem

brisk swift
#

Oh

harsh matrix
#

i just realized that the mirrors in my RC havent moved, even a little bit, over the last 11 days laughinghard

#

Maybe i lie

#

I think i moved the primary a week ago, but that's not it moving on its own.

analog portal
analog portal
#

I was talking to a buddy who has a 10" GSO flex tube jobbie, and he said my star spikes not aligning issue is likely due to focus rather than mirror flop 😦

harsh matrix
#

but i live in an area with frequent extreme temperature flips, huge atmospheric pressure drops on a regular basis, and I move it in and out of the house regularly

vapid patio
#

And how would I check it with that cashier eye piece thing

harsh matrix
#

considering all of those things, im happy it doesnt move more often astroThumbsUp

vapid patio
#

Yeah very nice

vapid patio
harsh matrix
# vapid patio Haha yeah

honestly it's very hard and will only get you close but i can at least give you some pointers i think

vapid patio
#

Ok I will save you and I will watch a video

#

But do I need to get one of those laser things?

#

They are kinda pricey

harsh matrix
#

i dont use any tools to collimate mine

#

i collimate on a star which is easier than it sounds.

vapid patio
#

Oh cool yeah not bad

harsh matrix
#

it is confusing to get down at first though

#

i found watching SCT collimation videos to be a massive help

thorny path
#

I have a Cheshire for my newt

#

But I’d say that’s better than any laser and more than enough

analog portal
#

Indeed. Lasers only get you so far, you need to make sure the secondary mirror in a Newt is properly rotated. I learned this the hard way starting off with an f/4 system.

harsh matrix
#

I put some time off in the books for next Tuesday and Wednesday PepeHype

#

The B3 site is looking quite promising on those nights, can't wait to experience those skies again. Sniffa

#

I plan to shoot M104 with my RC both nights if things pan out

frosty shard
#

I had to recollimate mine, but it might be because I was testing Allen keys to see which one would fit in the mirror screws and accidentally turned it a bit too far

#

Idk if it was even the drop that caused the problems

frosty shard
analog portal
frosty shard
frosty shard
analog portal
#

40-ish

frosty shard
#

Hopefully I'll have my guide cam in Soon™️

analog portal
#

I should clarify, my southern horizon is into the light dome of the b7 city glow, and that swims right through it.

#

it's difficult to shoot broadband below 60 degrees to the south

frosty shard
#

That sucks. M104 is one of the most luminous nearby galaxies though, so of all the galaxies to try through the light dome that's probably the one

analog portal
#

i usually go to my dad's in a bortle 4 to shoot broadband.

frosty shard
#

Worth

analog portal
#

just a few miles up the road, and he enjoys the company 🙂

frosty shard
#

I need to find a good place to shoot from - both in the city and outside of it

#

My dilemma though is that if I'm in Bortle 4 or lower skies, I'd rather observe visually

#

Solution: go with friends who have telescopes

analog portal
#

indeed!

#

I will often sky surf with binos while my rig (or rigs) are running

frosty shard
#

One of my friends is much more of an astrophotographer than I am, so I told him that he can shoot with my RC if he lets me use his Askar 120 APO visually

analog portal
#

a buddy has a wonderful night vision setup, so if he's along it's amazeballs

frosty shard
#

Night vision is next on my list at this point

frosty shard
#

Especially since you get good IR transmission and no chromatic aberration in an RC

harsh matrix
#

btw my SQM-L and Oiii + H-beta filter shipped

frosty shard
#

Hell yeah

#

@harsh matrix do you have 2" eyepieces at all?

harsh matrix
#

i need to get a dew heater to keep that one and my other one from fogging up while im out there

frosty shard
#

Honestly I should invest in one too

#

Unfortunately there's a problem I didn't realize until recently about doing that with an RC

#

You risk having bad baffle currents with smaller eyepieces

#

It just acts as a stovepipe and makes the effective seeing horrific

harsh matrix
frosty shard
#

I should be okay with my eyepiece selection though

#

Alternatively you can use a prism diagonal, but I'd prefer to use my mirror

vapid patio
#

@harsh matrix

#

I'm outside seting it up

harsh matrix
#

good luck PepeHype

vapid patio
#

Why do my stars look like dots? @harsh matrix

#

I thought it would make spikes

harsh matrix
#

if you point at Sirius you'll have your fun

oblique sun
#

or any constellation star

vapid patio
#

Yay

#

Stupid asiair

#

Glitch smh

#

@harsh matrix Can you hop in a call and help me rq?

harsh matrix
vapid patio
#

Ok just lmk I will be in a channel

harsh matrix
#

i can join now

vapid patio
#

i could do 60s without guiding haha im just too good

frosty shard
#

My phone cooked on the Double Cluster tonight

thorny path
#

I don’t like the framing much

#

Wish I could get in closer

analog portal
high aspen
high aspen
analog portal
#

Should I try it?

#

someone run starnet on this, or post it to the blurx request thread kekw

harsh matrix
vapid patio
thorny path
#

So cool

high aspen
#

this post should be renamed to ritch cretin enjoyers thread

brisk swift
#

Nu

high aspen
#

guys 200 days to a tracking mount

prime sequoia
#

Anyone have experience with one of these.

vapid patio
#

@harsh matrix

harsh matrix
vapid patio
analog portal
prime sequoia
vapid patio
#

It works it works

prime sequoia
#

Love to see the jankness.

#

Mine is the swsa wedge as a counterweight

oblique sun
#

when i get an rc if i need a dec counterweight im not just putting a weight on there lol

#

that is an area that follows tracking, im using that

#

a dslr is going on there

harsh matrix
#

Weather may not work out at the B3 next week smadge

#

Though predictions are generally unreliable >3 days in advance.

prime sequoia
# oblique sun a dslr is going on there

I would worry about the mirror flop causing vibrations in the main imaging. I am sure guiding would see it. Now if you put a mirror less there you will be fine.

oblique sun
#

then id put a phone on there

#

phone ap isnt actually that bad

analog portal
harsh matrix
#

My RC is still perfectly collimated kekw

#

The temp plummeted like 30 degrees over the last 2 days, again.

frosty shard
oblique sun
harsh matrix
#

IT WONT STOP smadge

harsh matrix
#

When my RC loses collimation, it's only ever small adjustments I need to make.

#

It's not ever tear down the entire rig and collimate it all over again like it is with my newts.

#

It's incredibly convenient

oblique sun
#

i have a kinda fast newt, f/5

#

i hate it

harsh matrix
#

Like owning the sharpest refractor you can think of.

frosty shard
harsh matrix
oblique sun
#

the only thing im worried about with rcs is int time

#

big central obstruction and high f ratio

harsh matrix
#

Collimating at f/3.45 is complete hell

frosty shard
oblique sun
#

i have 2.9um pixels

#

but wouldnt binning get rid of the whole point of an rc?

#

you lose the insane sharpness

frosty shard
oblique sun
#

but most objects i like are sharpness based

frosty shard
#

If you're looking to go deep on something like integrated flux nebulae then binning is probably the move. If you want to do planetary (nebulae) it isn't

oblique sun
#

like m51 is one of my favorite targets, and it has a bunch of fine details but also many dim bits

frosty shard
harsh matrix
#

If your seeing is pretty bad, and you want better SNR, binning is definitely the move

#

I think the 585 is quite over sampled on an RC too, so it's the perfect opportunity to do it

oblique sun
#

with bad seeing and a 0.63x reducer would it still be sharper than this?

harsh matrix
#

But you do have the color one.

#

Maybe you don't want to bin since you already sacrifice resolution with the bayer

frosty shard
oblique sun
#

mono prob wont be for a year or two after the rc

oblique sun
harsh matrix
#

I shot this at native f/9, 1377 mm and had really bad seeing

#

My processing could use some work but it's still my sharpest galaxy set to date excluding my current project.

frosty shard
#

with OSC cams in general

harsh matrix
#

Im pretty big brain but not that big brain Despairge

#

Not sure what the right amount of dithering and amount of pixels would be enough

#

I don't think i really overcame the matrix with my 533.

frosty shard
harsh matrix
#

Yo this wind needs to chill out

frosty shard
#

I definitely sacrificed some field size by dithering by too many pixels (like 50) but that is totally fine at the end of the day

harsh matrix
#

Oh jfc

#

My mount wouldn't settle if I dithered by more than 30 pixels.

frosty shard
#

I was doing it on my C5+ mount (manual with tracking), took 18 second exposures, and repositioned the center of the Orion Nebula every 8 or so exposures (shot with an intervalometer attached to my DSLR)

#

I spent two hours in the cold just monitoring everything but it was worth it

oblique sun
#

another thing, you think an eqm35 pro will be able to handle it?

harsh matrix
oblique sun
#

rc6 ofc

#

i both do not have the money or the mount for an rc8

harsh matrix
#

It will handle a reduced RC6 best, but it can just barely work at native.

oblique sun
#

guided?

harsh matrix
oblique sun
#

ill be using guiding but not oag

#

240mm fl

harsh matrix
#

You and Shady will have to let me know how that goes

#

I think it would save a ton of time each night if I could guide with a guide scope instead of an OAG

oblique sun
#

whys that?

thorny path
#

I would honestly like to guide with a guide scope over OAG. I wonder if my 60mm is good enough

#

Idk if larger guide scopes exists

oblique sun
#

isnt oag supposed to be better

oblique sun
#

doesnt need to be labeled as a guider

thorny path
#

In a way, but it isn’t perfect and with longer FL and slower speeds of an RC. It can complicate things

thorny path
#

I’ve read of people with slower scopes struggling

frosty shard
#

But I've heard of 8" RC and SCT users using guidescopes

frosty shard
oblique sun
#

one of my friends uses a 9.25" sct with a guidescope and does 180s subs i thinik

harsh matrix
#

i have a hard time getting guide stars

#

and i cant get exposures longer than 60 seconds with my existing guide scope

frosty shard
#

I ordered the Askar 52mm Super ED so I may try both now that I'll have both

#

That's got 250 mm of focal length, probably not enough for a native RC8 but I'll try it regardless

oblique sun
#

mines like 2 arcseconds

harsh matrix
#

and it wasnt bad

#

it was consistently 0.67" rms +/- 0.1" rms

oblique sun
#

oh thats great then

frosty shard
oblique sun
#

was yours tuned?

harsh matrix
#

it was the fact that stars started trailing after 60 seconds of exposing which stopped me from going longer

oblique sun
#

i have never touched anything inside my eqm35 and i am scared to do so lol

harsh matrix
#

that's a classic sign of differential flexture

harsh matrix
#

but i tuned the dec over about 6 months of iterating

#

finally found a mix that worked, and then the RA died on me right about the time I got my AM5N

#

I fixed that and the mount works as expected and guides a little better than before so i cant complain too much

#

i do want to hypertune it to see just how smooth i can get it

oblique sun
#

well i do have a lot of time before next galaxy season

#

and that 2 arcsecond guiding was me with no idea what im doing guiding for the first time

frosty shard
#

Has anyone attempted to remove the dovetail tails on their RC? If so, are there any important considerations I should be aware of?

#

I may vinyl wrap mine

analog portal
#

the top one has been removed from mine

frosty shard
#

I've heard the carbon fiber ones may flex in unexpected ways with one rail removed

analog portal
#

yeah it's a CF tube

#

i haven't noticed any flexure, and honestly never thought about that

#

no issues other than having to refocus when the mirror gets significantly colder

frosty shard
#

I haven't heard clear reports on it, only speculation

analog portal
#

i no longer have the vixen one for the top, and i've never taken the losmandy off of the bottom. i wish i kept the top one though 😅

harsh matrix
#

I just wanted to experiment with other ways to remove the gradient left behind from my light pollution and I didnt want to add the Ha to encourage myself to overdenoise the image again

#

I added a negative for fun

#

this is NIRRR lol

analog portal
#

near infrared red red?

vapid patio
#

@harsh matrix

#

Is that the other Polaris?

prime sequoia
#

Anyone who uses a gso .75 reducer can you share a image of your scope so I can figure out the back focus.

#

this is the best I can get in focus, the oubjects in the background cant get in focus becuase the focuser it all the way in

vapid patio
#

What’s your current spacing

prime sequoia
#

@vapid patio

vapid patio
#

Hm wow your quite close

#

Ok

#

Add another spacer ring somewhere in front of the reducer dont wanna mess its backspacing up

#

Is that a astro tech?

brisk swift
#

What cam is that

prime sequoia
#

yes

prime sequoia
brisk swift
#

zwo?

prime sequoia
#

yes

brisk swift
#

Why is it brown

prime sequoia
#

sun destroys anodizing

brisk swift
prime sequoia
#

the other side is still red

prime sequoia
#

where is the 80mm measured from? the front of the reducer. Maybe I have to much spacing

vapid patio
prime sequoia
#

I wonder if I have to much back focus. I am not sure where the reducer ends. I know you screw in behind it but does it take up the whole bit. Would it be from the back of the last element of glass.

analog portal
#

have you tried removing this spacer?

#

I have to do this for visual/planetary with my RC, as my Moonlite doesn't have enough inward travel to get into focus.

prime sequoia
#

not yet, did this over my lunch break. i work from home

#

messing with the eaf remote, if I pull the focuser out close objects get in focus.

#

so either its a issue with the back focus from the reducer or spacing in front of the focuser. What is odd my flattener was fine in this config

analog portal
#

likewise. the ccdt67 i used also didn't seem bothered by that spacer in front of the focuser.

vapid patio
analog portal
#

I would assume the 80mm is from the back of the reducer to the camera sensor. that's usually how correctors/reducers are designed.... usually

prime sequoia
#

based on my math at the red line I am 74mm

#

I did try with a 5mm after the redline but it was even worse with close focus.

analog portal
#

when you back out the focuser, do the things get more out of focus?

prime sequoia
#

yes

analog portal
#

i suspect it is that spacer on the rear of the ota then.

prime sequoia
#

could I remove the nose piece I have on it and just push the reducer into the focuser?

#

that did not occure to me until now.

#

I have something like this mounted in front of the reducer, but what is stopping me from pushing the reducer into the focuser

#

like an eye piece.

analog portal
prime sequoia
#

yes

analog portal
#

that could work

#

it might not 'square' your sensor though, sometimes those things are fickle

prime sequoia
#

at the end of the day the compression ring is aready holding it in technically

prime sequoia
#

@analog portal pushing the reducer into the focused worked.

#

I can fully focus on

analog portal
#

glad to hear it 🙂

harsh matrix
harsh matrix
analog portal
#

i look at my RC more than it looks at space

#

clouds everywhere, almost all the dang time

harsh matrix
frosty shard
#

But then again it's just too cold and windy

harsh matrix
#

I've made the observation, now that I know what I'm looking for, that right after sundown, and before all of the city lights and street lights turn on, I can see the Milky Way passing overhead, in a vary small strip of the sky at zenith.

#

It's an unintelligible smudge, just barely brighter than the sky around it.

#

Can't really see it with direct vision, only averted vision, and there's no structure.

brisk swift
ripe crystal
#

RC or SCT...?

brisk swift
#

RC

oblique sun
brisk swift
#

he uses a 6" RC

harsh matrix
ripe crystal
#

How come?

#

Easier to mod?

ripe crystal
ripe crystal
harsh matrix
#

like wayyyyyy sharper

#

weight too

brisk swift
#

da best of the west

ripe crystal
#

how

brisk swift
#

RC uses Hyperbolic mirror instead of Parabolic in normal reflectors

harsh matrix
#

the entire field is virtually flat with my 533

#

id say the resolution is equal across the field for that reason, the stars are tight all the way around the frame

#

they dont need corrective optics either

ripe crystal
#

Bigger field

#

Better sampling

harsh matrix
#

no blurx or sharpening of any kind provided here

#

this is just the 6 inch

#

not reduced, that's important

#

the right image is NIR and the left is R, stars will be bigger in NIR because the wavelengths are longer

ripe crystal
harsh matrix
#

in general, ive been resolving some really stupidly small stuff with my RC

#

things that arent supposed to be possible with a scope as small as my little 6"

ripe crystal
#

Lmao noice

#

Beast scope

harsh matrix
#

and here's my sharpest galaxy dataset (tbh), my current project. left is NIR and right is R, no BlurX or anything but reduced this time

#

I got the reducer to turn this thing into a light bucket and it never fails to surprise me

#

I also just expose longer with the NIR filter because my camera's QE is worse in the NIR, it helps overcome the read noise, but causes the stars to grow quite a bit.

ripe crystal
#

Better QE in IR

#

Than the 533

harsh matrix
#

Just for fun, these are the globs the BAT resolved in M82, but by my RC and not doing lucky imaging laughinghard

ripe crystal
harsh matrix
#

there's like 10+ others at least, and it DID THE EXACT SAME THING ON M81 OMEGALOOL

#

it wasnt some kind of dumb fluke

harsh matrix
#

with the back spacing correct, the difference isnt very big fortunately

harsh matrix
#

it was noticably worse when I had a good 20+ mm too much of back space though

ripe crystal
#

20mm?!?!!!

harsh matrix
harsh matrix
# ripe crystal 20mm?!?!!!

yeah it came with an extension tube on the back and i didnt know if it was supposed to be included in the backspace calculation or not

#

turns out it wasnt supposed to be included

ripe crystal
#

Mean company

#

Ruined some of your data

harsh matrix
#

it wasnt too bad

#

i probably got better signal than i meant to

ripe crystal
#

Btw here is my first IR test from just a couple days ago. Conditions were terrible

#

Also banding 😭

ripe crystal
harsh matrix
#

well if youre using the guide camera to shoot IR, it's going to have banding

ripe crystal
#

B-but

#

I don’t have a mono camera

#

Besides the guide cam

brisk swift
ripe crystal
#

I need mono imx585

#

Very very good QE in IR

#

Anyways good night

#

I will dream about the sct vs rc war

harsh matrix
#

it basically behaves like a mono cam at those wavelengths

ripe crystal
#

Wait…

#

REALLY??

harsh matrix
#

yes really

ripe crystal
#

Not just the red filter?

harsh matrix
#

not just the red filter

#

that is correct

ripe crystal
#

Oooooo

#

Thank you so much

#

You have saved me

#

From further debt

ripe crystal
oblique sun
#

@ripe crystal

ripe crystal
oblique sun
#

this is why im gonna get 850nm

ripe crystal
#

Insane

ripe crystal
#

From what I have heard, there is not enough emission in those further IR wavelengths

#

Just from what I’ve heard though

oblique sun
#

still why not have it, i can a filter for it for >$20

ripe crystal
#

Oh

#

Ok

#

Yeah definitely go for it

ripe crystal
oblique sun
ripe crystal
#

Summer?

oblique sun
#

ragh

ripe crystal
#

Just dont spread the news

oblique sun
#

im not

ripe crystal
prime sequoia
#

I forgot how heavy this flattener was

#

was also probobly overkill for my 533

harsh matrix
#

I just put my AM5N on my EQM-35 tripod

#

same tripod as the EQ6R I believe

#

hopefully guiding improves noticeably PepeHype

prime sequoia
#

what did you get total error before?

#

I get about .88 max with my oag

harsh matrix
#

Can't tell if it's because my guide cam has been restricted to a single star due to how sparse guide stars are during galaxy season, or if it's my parameters in PHD2 not melding well with the AM5N

#

It was really low and very good when guiding on Rosette though

#

A nice 0.69" rms tops

#

It never gets lower than around there though and people have been able to get way lower RMS, I suspect the tripod is to blame.

prime sequoia
#

could be the tripod. or phd2 settings. I look forward to more stars now that I have the reducer.

#

I know technically they wont be smaller but they will be due to the wider feild of view.

#

I need to calculate the new focal lenght tonight when its clear.

harsh matrix
#

I've observed the same thing occurring pretty much every night

#

Some kind of high frequency oscillation...

#

I keep thinking it's PE, but when I turn up the reliance on PPEC corrections, it still happens but mainly in the Dec.

#

My PA error last night was like, 12 seconds, something incredibly small.

harsh matrix
#

The oscillations persisting makes me think it's the tripod since the tripod may not handle the lopsided weight of my system as well as if it was a solid steel tripod, for instance.

#

It's like, no matter what it does to correct a movement, it sways too far beyond the right point, regardless of how strong the guide pulse was, which tells me the tripod is leaning or flexing in that direction.

thorny path
#

Heard it’s miles better than carbon fiber one. Not to say CS tripods are bad

#

Good tripod and leg spreader go a long ways from what people say

harsh matrix
oblique sun
#

@harsh matrix when you were limited to 60s exposures with the guidescope, was it with a 0.63x reducer?

oblique sun
#

i have slightly less focal length (750mm), but 180s seems to be fine for me

#

how come you ran into issues with the reducer at 60s?

thorny path
#

Y’all have same mount ?

#

Is this issue with high FL ?

oblique sun
#

he said its cause of differential flexture i think, but i also have a guide scope, a heavier one too, and i dont seem to have those issues

#

well i have issues with the guiding itself but thats different lol

thorny path
#

What’s the guide rate on your mount ?

oblique sun
#

should i lower it?

#

im crashing out over it rn 😭

#

lowering it made it worse

thorny path
#

Damn bro what’s wrong with your mount

oblique sun
#

idk man

#

beavers works good

#

im probably gonna throw away 80% of these subs

analog portal
analog portal
#

what are you using to note those stars?

prime sequoia
#

Nina

analog portal
#

i don't get that with my settings 😦

harsh matrix
#

Differential flexture doesn't really present as a problem until that 1000 mm mark

oblique sun
#

isnt it 850 reduced?

#

or is yours more than 1377 native

harsh matrix
#

If you look at the design of this guide scope, the one I was using, it's on a long, hallowed out support.

oblique sun
#

holy crap im actually gonna punch my mount i hate this guiding so much

harsh matrix
#

Plenty of room for it to bend around however it wants.

#

On a scale of microns ofc

oblique sun
oblique sun
#

its drilled into mt ysopce

oblique sun
analog portal
#

oh

oblique sun
#

my guide graph REFUSES to stay still

analog portal
#

guides like my gem28 often does with avg seeing

harsh matrix
oblique sun
#

it freely spins

harsh matrix
#

Dafuq

oblique sun
#

ive literally gotten like 4 minutes of exposure time

#

in the last two hours

#

cause every sub is trailed and shit

analog portal
#

i just noticed you seem to have some runaway in DEC

#

when i had that, my DEC was too tight, i had to loosen it a bit

harsh matrix
#

I got a virtually flat guide graph at 0.7" or 0.8" rms at worst with my EQM-35

analog portal
#

(on my GEM28, my GEM45 is actually a bit too loose)

oblique sun
#

physically do smth with the mount? or loosen the clutch

analog portal
#

physically adjust the gears

harsh matrix
#

Specifically the worm gear meshing is what I had to loosen up a bit.

analog portal
#

iOptron's gem28 has some screws you can adjust to increase/decrease ... tension? whatever it's called.

oblique sun
#

i love how whenever i cancel the sub the guide graph returns to normal

#

then when i start it again it starts killing itself

analog portal
#

what's your exposure time for guiding?

oblique sun
#

1.5s but it is not having trouble finding a star or smth at all

analog portal
#

have you tried taking it to like, 2.5 or something a bit higher?

oblique sun
#

it just sucks at keeping that star in the center

harsh matrix
analog portal
#

wowzers

oblique sun
analog portal
#

i seldom go below 2s

oblique sun
#

because it isnt having trouble with the view

#

its having trouble making corrections with the mount

analog portal
#

faster exposures sometimes lead to chasing seeing i think, could be wrong

#

speaking of seeing; tomorrow was forecast to be clear, now it's gone to shit... as usual.

oblique sun
#

doing 3s now

#

BRUH THE ONE SUB WHERE I GOT OK GUIDING

thorny path
#

A plug in

harsh matrix
#

Am I cooked?

#

This is the SQM for my backyard

thorny path
#

Guh

harsh matrix
#

@prime sequoia so far my guiding is more stable and less twitchy since changing tripods

#

0.77 rms at the celestial equator which is amazing

#

Should be lower than this though

harsh matrix
#

It's guiding better at the celestial equator than it is near the celestial pole

#

Wtf

#

I can't get it any better than this

#

I don't understand

#

It's the shape of the guide stars FML

#

This is so annoying to troubleshoot.

harsh matrix
#

Went up to here after an hour and a half

prime sequoia
ripe crystal
ripe crystal
analog portal
#

sky quality i think

thorny path
analog portal
#

I can't see to be sure, but when there's a curved field, the guide stars look like crescents 😅

frosty shard
# ripe crystal Why?

Even with the big chungus central obstruction, I'd say it might actually outdo my SCTs visually

#

At low power

frosty shard
harsh matrix
analog portal
#

hrm, i wonder if my baffles have agression

harsh matrix
#

and it makes PHD2 flip the hell out

analog portal
#

i'm not sure what 70% of that means

frosty shard
#

On the lower right you can see the ray traces for light entering a baffled RC at different angles

#

Green rays make it all the way through

#

Red rays are blocked by the baffles

analog portal
#

ah so that's what the angle numbers mean

bronze wigeon
bronze wigeon
bronze wigeon
ripe crystal
#

but our patience is running short

bronze wigeon
#

I FOUND IT

ripe crystal
ripe crystal
#

thats a little sharp

bronze wigeon
#

i definitely had a better version

bronze wigeon
ripe crystal
#

yo same

#

you have that with a newt...?

bronze wigeon
#

yes

ripe crystal
#

how big is the beast?

bronze wigeon
#

10 incher

#

254/1000

ripe crystal
#

nice!

#

what camera?

bronze wigeon
bronze wigeon
ripe crystal
#

sensitive in IR

bronze wigeon
ripe crystal
#

Do you have an IR filter?

bronze wigeon
#

Yes. an IR850, still havent used it

prime sequoia
#

2.5 hours last night

harsh matrix
prime sequoia
#

I really like this RC now that its effectivly a f6.77

harsh matrix
#

with very little compromise to sharpness or resolution

#

very much worth it

#

second pass on my full M63 data

frosty shard
ripe crystal
harsh matrix
#

Near bortle 7 tonight

thorny path
#

What is that ?

harsh matrix
thorny path
#

Btw

#

I’m messing with mount and guiding

#

The whole 0.1 min mo does more harm than good it seems

thorny path
#

I was having guiding issues and people said it was flexure

harsh matrix
#

i keep mine around 0.2 to 0.26

thorny path
#

And I need OAG. I changed settings and I got good guiding now

harsh matrix
#

or is that just what people said you needed?

thorny path
#

No lol

#

People say I needed one

#

Cause of guiding issues I was having

#

Numbers were good image wasn’t

harsh matrix
#

Yeah that's a correct assessment then

#

i found out i needed an OAG when i had superb guiding numbers and trailed subs

brisk swift
#

I heard the gso rcs have baffling issues

harsh matrix
harsh matrix
#

none of the later models have that issue though

thorny path
#

messing with guide settings and cant seem to get low exposures to work

#

they seemingly chase seeing and hallucinate errors. resulting in my imaging camera having bad image

#

setting it at 2 seconds fixes it

#

but not sure if this is too slow for my mount

harsh matrix
harsh matrix
#

honestly it depends on what the periodic error is

#

mine with my AM5N is extremely low

#

if your's is also very low you can get away with it

#

Guys I think I made another banger.

brisk swift
harsh matrix
#

If it's on the used market, you can't tell just off looks alone.

#

I think only the GSO named models had that issue, and the rebrands did not.

brisk swift
harsh matrix
brisk swift
brisk swift
#

new*

harsh matrix
#

It won't have that particular defect then

brisk swift
ripe crystal
ripe crystal
#

Ban him to the shadow realm

frosty shard
frosty shard
brisk swift
#

how are losmandy g11 mount?

#

it's cheaper than cem70

harsh matrix
harsh matrix
frosty shard
#

yeah I have no firsthand experience with Losmandy mounts, but they're often considered a standard for mount quality

harsh matrix
#

i may make a copy of that version of the image and do another pass of NR before I submit it

brisk swift
#

man I'm so confused rn

#

I think I need time, I'll maybe explore everything and buy my rig after a few months

#

I don't wanna rush into this and get something useless

harsh matrix
frosty shard
#

Yeah, definitely take your time. I still haven't pulled the trigger on an astrocam yet lol

brisk swift
#

I'm waiting for touptek cams to get in stock

#

their 2600mm is really good and cheaper than zwo

frosty shard
#

Me waiting for my guide cam to ship

harsh matrix
#

there's absolutely some kind of flexture with the RC's though

#

my collimation is dead on but here you can tell the stars are deformed and tilt is introduced

#

I think this is for sure that weight on the primary being a nuisance at extreme declinations

frosty shard
#

What altitude was the Lagoon Nebula when you shot it?

harsh matrix
brisk swift
#

corners

harsh matrix
#

it maxes out at about 32 and a half degrees

brisk swift
#

bottom right and top right

harsh matrix
brisk swift
harsh matrix
#

normally that means pinched optics

#

in this case, that's exactly not what the issue is lmao

brisk swift
#

Carbon otas has less chances of pinched optics? monkaHmm

frosty shard
brisk swift
#

Mhm

harsh matrix
brisk swift
frosty shard
harsh matrix
#

these are single stars on the last M101 subs of the night

brisk swift
#

it's a triangular shaped star

#

like a oni-giri

harsh matrix
#

ive been having guiding issues and i think those have been masking pinched optics perhaps...

#

fmlllllll lol

frosty shard
harsh matrix
#

should not be affected by the baffle tube

frosty shard
#

Ah, okay

brisk swift
#

maybe it's the primary mirror like uh expanding due to the mirror holder expanding or sumthin

#

same thing happened to rory

#

in his betty video

harsh matrix
#

it's not incredibly likely that this is being caused by my secondary because i worked pretty hard to not let the scondary be pinched

brisk swift
harsh matrix
#

that Ha star is PepeYikes PepeYikes PepeYikes

brisk swift
#

it's kinda a square

harsh matrix
#

i think it's temperature based and has something to do with the way the primary is held in place and how the lock screws interact with the primary mirror holder...

brisk swift
#

what I said pepeHype

#

just pour hot water on it constantly to keep it warm ( I'm joking)

brisk swift
#

I think it's due to the fact CF cools down slower than the mirror holder?

#

what's the mirror holder made up of

harsh matrix
#

i havent been able to dig up much information about the primary mirror holder, how it's mounted, etc.

brisk swift
#

the difference in cooling rate may cause pinched optics

harsh matrix
#

the primary mirror cell itself, at least the shell of it, is steel I think.

#

Some kind of sturdy, rock solid, metal.

#

there is a significant amount of space between the outer bounds of the primary and the CF tube, so if youre saying the tube itself is constricting the primary, that is not correct.

harsh matrix
#

it's probably the rate of cooling of the glass of the mirror vs the rate of cooling of the material the primary holder is made from

brisk swift
#

how are u gonna fix it

harsh matrix
brisk swift
harsh matrix
#

im good as fuqed if that's the case

#

ill need to do some research to see if there are options

brisk swift
#

100x sharper than sct vs 99x sharper than sct

#

what's the difference

harsh matrix
#

I did some extra noise reduction on here, pretty light pass.

#

i think ill submit this one to AB IOTD

thorny path
#

Yooo

harsh matrix
#

oh snap wait

#

this version is even better than the first

#

blink through the original and this one and it looks so much better lmao

#

yeah this one is on par with my pillars of creation

#

holy fuq

thorny path
#

i can get .8 rms with 2 sec exposures

#

but shorter exposures i get better numbers. at the same time short expousures seemingly just chase seeing

#

unless im missing something

#

and numbers can be improved

harsh matrix
#

i wanted a classic SHO image

harsh matrix
#

mine was unironically flat after i went to 2 secs last night

#

after having issues with it being super jagged beforehand

#

@ 1.5s guide exposures

thorny path
#

mine flattened out

#

i got better numbers at 1.5 sec

#

but as i said, the image would say other wise

harsh matrix
#

does the image get worse with sub length?

#

have you inspected that?

thorny path
#

i have guide scoped aligned

harsh matrix
thorny path
#

i believe its over correcting

thorny path
#

been testing on 3 min subs

#

only turns out good at 2 sec exposure on guide cam

harsh matrix
#

if it's differential flexture, 3 minutes is too long if your stars are eggs

thorny path
#

ill look into that aswell

#

something tells me it isnt

#

but ill look into that, ill try shorter subs and see if it goes away

harsh matrix
thorny path
#

they say an OAG is the solution

#

you have one right ?

harsh matrix
#

correct

thorny path
#

do you get better numbers ?

harsh matrix
harsh matrix
#

guide graph is still flat too

thorny path
#

mmm

#

imma have to conider that heavily if i cant fix this

harsh matrix
#

yes

thorny path
#

For an OAG ?

#

I’ll also put it behind that .75 reducer

harsh matrix
#

on an RC, not sure, been wondering that myself

#

3 hours, 1 per color

vapid patio
#

RC 6 8hr

#

i need to run it through SFS i think i had some.... odd frames in there

harsh matrix
vapid patio
#

good or bad?

#

holy fuq can go both ways

harsh matrix
#

id be a little careful with BX because it's really good at overcooking galaxies in RC data

#

im finding that out the hard way atm

harsh matrix
#

looks like collimation is dead on, and it's very sharp

#

dont really need BX to tell that

vapid patio
#

and the scope has been sitting for a year haha

harsh matrix
#

also whatever denoiser you are using seems to be hallucinating

#

in the background

vapid patio
#

how so?

#

let me look

harsh matrix
#

that'll resolve itself with more data or just less denoise strength

#

this stuff

vapid patio
#

oh yeah that whoops

harsh matrix
#

the "light worm" looking things

vapid patio
#

its a more data thing

harsh matrix
#

yeah for sure

vapid patio
#

and sometimes BlurX thinks its a star and makes it more prominent

#

thats a bluX after noiseX thing

harsh matrix
#

do BlurX before NoiseX

#

it's not working correctly if you do it after

#

and do BlurX after color calibration because BlurX can mess up the color balance if you do it before color calibration

#

looks like a very juicy first run with the RC though

#

that looks really exciting

vapid patio
#

i know that bluX after can mess it up. sometimes at the end i run it one more time to let it sharpen everything up a little more once ive done all my sutff

#

just didnt see that it did that to the background

vapid patio
harsh matrix
#

RC data, given the data was sharp out of the gate, doesnt need much BlurX'ing im finding out

#

at least for galaxies

analog portal
vapid patio
vapid patio
analog portal
#

i struggle with this, m33, and m101 getting the faint arms to pop

vapid patio
analog portal
#

kk

vapid patio
#

@analog portal its the one that i named in t here

analog portal
#

ty so much

brisk swift
#

how do I get the backspace right of a RC @harsh matrix

harsh matrix
#

add a spacer, and then rack the focuser in and out until you reach focus

brisk swift
#

don't I gotta buy back space thingy

harsh matrix
#

they come with the proper extension tubes included to reach back focus

brisk swift
harsh matrix
brisk swift
#

Are they called extension tubes?

harsh matrix
#

yes

brisk swift
#

ah

#

Will Qhy OAG work with zwo cams?

#

if I use a oag I need to calc the backfocus again

harsh matrix
harsh matrix
#

they arent a simple thread on and call it a day solution

analog portal
#

@vapid patio I definitely didn't handle the stars as well as you did. 😅 This was super clean data. Nice

vapid patio
#

Whats your workflow

#

Roughly

analog portal
#

plate solve, spcc, soft histogram stretch, remove stars, further stretch starless in histogram, run hdrmultiscale transform (i think that's what it's called) to reduce highlights in the core, noiseX, range mask to add color/saturation to the galaxy. then put a range mask on the stars to increase saturation w/o messing the cores too much. recombine, run blurX with non-steller reduced down to .10 or something? sharpening stars at .20

analog portal
#

oh and before adding stars back, i did a 'dark structure enhance' to bring out the dust around the core a bit more

harsh matrix
#

the hdr multiscale cooked the dust lane nearest to the core though Sadge

analog portal
#

the data was cleaner than i'm used to, so i forgot about gradient (there isn't much of one anyway)

#

i probably could've ran blurx first before starx, to keep those two bright stars from washing into each other

vapid patio
#

I never did hdr multiscale yet with my rc6 i will try

analog portal
#

i've seen people post their workflows on youtube and they use about 10 additional processes/scripts than i do, some i didn't even know existed, and the end result looks like a 256bit color graphic from windows xp

vapid patio
#

Real ✅

analog portal
#

"we're gonna color mask this, linear fit that, extract lum here, clone heal this, etc etc"

vapid patio
#

Clone heal? 😭

#

Yeah people be doing too much

analog portal
#

i saw a guy doing that to get rid of amp glow artifacts 😭

vapid patio
#

Dark frames where you at 💔

analog portal
#

oh he used them

harsh matrix
#

im also a certified HDR multiscale transform hater

#

so there's that

analog portal
#

i think he used a 10min sub dark for a 5min sub light, and he had dark black lines

#

subtracted too much

#

there's some real pixelmath ninjas who look like they're solving quantum physics with their formulas. some real Good Will Hunting stuff lol.

harsh matrix
#

BlurX PSA

#

and this is correct

#

this was how Russ Croman intended for it to be used

vapid patio
thorny path
ripe crystal
#

excuse me

#

what are you saying about SCT users?

thorny path
#

Strange phenomenon on Astro bin

#

Of people abusing blurx

frosty shard
#

RC's going to a dark sky site tonight

ripe crystal
coral fog
harsh matrix
harsh matrix
coral fog
#

Or do u mean the beginning of learning processing

#

I don’t rlly understand srry

harsh matrix
coral fog
#

How does that even work

#

☠️

harsh matrix
#

Makes BlurX hallucinate pretty badly

coral fog
#

Topaz denoise ahh

ripe crystal
harsh matrix
harsh matrix
#

@thorny path 2 second guide exposures are working very well

#

I'm a bit surprised.

thorny path
#

Real

#

I got a good guide graph at that exposure time

#

I ordered an OAG AwkwardSmile

#

I wanna say it’s more due to the mounts PE

#

Everything on my guide scope seems good

#

And a lot of people mention never figuring out their issue with flexure

harsh matrix
thorny path
#

I was doing 3 and then 5

#

I got good stars at 2second exposures on guide cam

#

At 1.5. It would all go to shit

#

I think it would be best to use the main imaging scope to guide for these mounts since constant correction is needed

harsh matrix
harsh matrix
#

did your mount come with a periodic error test report?

thorny path
#

It didn’t

harsh matrix
#

ugh wtf

#

yeah youre swinging in the dark then

#

are you using hysteresis or PPEC as your correction algorithm?

thorny path
#

I think I can do my own but it does seem it’s around 10 arc seconds

#

I’m using PPEC

harsh matrix
#

good

thorny path
#

At 2 sec is good but as I said, one needs constant correction so imma get an OAG

#

I really like the mount. Light and portable and I can set up so quickly

harsh matrix
#

shouldnt be periodic error then unless you arent using a high enough prediction weight

thorny path
#

Hmmm

harsh matrix
#

this is my guiding rn Despairge

#

clouds...

thorny path
#

With the RC?

harsh matrix
#

it really like to try to guide on noise YEP

#

i need that Xena M asap

thorny path
#

Imagine it just locks onto a pixel AwkwardSmile

harsh matrix
#

that's what it's doing there lol

thorny path
#

💀

#

I’ll see how it goes with the OAG. I think it will work out great

harsh matrix
#

im just going to park it and wait out the clouds hopefully

frosty shard
harsh matrix
#

if youre there until the milky way core rises, look at lagoon and Sagittarius star cloud too

#

maybe challenge yourself and look for something much more difficult

#

say the Leo Quartet, or the Mice, or the Antennae galaxies

frosty shard
frosty shard
harsh matrix
#

I don't recall if I could or not

#

I probably didn't because I was being really bad about not letting my eyes dark adapt xdx

#

Got another near B7 reading...

thorny path
#

i just got the starizona coma corrector

#

it has a cool box

#

and the glass elements look so clear

#

strange

harsh matrix
#

tell me how it goes

#

that's the 0.75x right?