#Ritchey–Chrétien enjoyers thread

1 messages · Page 2 of 1

frosty shard
#

@high aspen at least you can experience RC goodness vicariously through us

high aspen
#

should i get this

#

or is there a cheaper

#

but carbon fiber

#

i need it to be carbonfiber (for legal reasons)

frosty shard
#

Not used to pounds but I think they all tend to be around the same price

frosty shard
#

One tip I do have: check the used markets

#

It's a bit of TLC, but a lot of people sell their RCs because they don't know how to collimate them correctly

#

So you may score a cheap, fully functional OTA for relatively little

high aspen
frosty shard
#

The only thing I'll note about buying used is that you may need to install a baffle extension if it was manufactured before about 2020 (could be wrong on the year)

high aspen
#

also, full metal spiders fill me with joy

frosty shard
#

For 8" and larger RCs this should be no problem, but for 6" RCs you may actually need to disassemble the scope to install the extension

#

It's very difficult to reach into the tube unless you have tiny hands and arms

high aspen
high aspen
#

like the most common reduction amount

frosty shard
analog portal
#

I have the CCDT67 and it's awesome

frosty shard
#

I haven't seen that

#

I'd just use the Newt if you need that focal length

high aspen
#

i should have AwkwardSmile

#

at the end

high aspen
frosty shard
#

GSO made a 4.5" classical Cassegrain

high aspen
#

i want it but too low f-stop

frosty shard
#

Yeah f/12 is painful

high aspen
#

too smol appature

analog portal
high aspen
#

its tooo badddd

analog portal
#

i have one of those 😅

high aspen
analog portal
#

tried to use it with my first scope (omni xlt 102)

#

not at all. no focus achieved lmao

high aspen
#

you would have to be so far from the scope

analog portal
#

it worked visually, but all i got was a realy wide fov through a 4" achromat

high aspen
#

cool

high aspen
#

seems like an easy money to me

harsh matrix
#

it was like 50% of MSRP

high aspen
harsh matrix
analog portal
#

i tried to sell my RC8 there, no takers 😦

high aspen
harsh matrix
#

ill take it for like 300 USD AwkwardSmile

#

except i need that money for a new guide cam

#

so i wont

high aspen
analog portal
#

i bought this one there, and have been so disgruntled by the weather and only getting to use it a few times in a year, decided to sell it

#

now it's sitting on the floor in my office in it's packaging 😦

oblique sun
#

don't actually buy one to use for imaging

#

i did find a use for it tho, wide angle lens

#

if you add spacers you can reach focus with it and you can focus like a helical focuser by unscrewing it

analog portal
#

my favorite image with it 🥹

high aspen
analog portal
#

8"

high aspen
#

i see

analog portal
#

that's reduced 50% to smaller filesize, was with imx492 in bin2

high aspen
#

i see

#

was the camera pixel size that small?

analog portal
#

the focus was either off on the filter changes, or the collimation was off (we discussed this before in here lol). i dind't run blurx to correct the stars

#

it's 2.3um in bin1

high aspen
#

oh

#

amma say, oversampled by a bit

#

?

analog portal
#

it's nice in bin2

high aspen
analog portal
#

lol

high aspen
analog portal
#

i'm almost always going to be oversampled with this scope where i live. seldom do i get above avg seeing

high aspen
#

ngl, sometimes i actually prefer seti astros one

analog portal
#

i was going to take it up to cherry springs last june for the star party, had my tickets, weather was garbage. 😦

#

not driving 3hrs to hang out under clouds and showers

frosty shard
#

To be clear, I don't have issues with others using AI tools

#

I just don't like using them myself

high aspen
thorny path
#

fray balls

frosty shard
thorny path
harsh matrix
oblique sun
#

prob not gonna be anything😔

frosty shard
oblique sun
#

I never saw any rc on thr highpoint sale

frosty shard
#

Some time ago, they weren't on sale, but you can still find them if you search on site

oblique sun
#

ofc they don't put the big sale on the ones we want

#

it's even more expensive than the ioptron photron ones

frosty shard
#

Yeah I wasn't super hopeful about the RCs since they're not meaningfully different across brands

#

Actually the Orion one might be the most different just because it comes with two finderscope brackets

frosty shard
#

Man, I had a heart attack last night. Somehow the brass compression ring in my focuser disappeared

#

I was a bit worried that it fell out at one of the public events I've been doing or that it dropped down the OTA and scratched the secondary, but thankfully I found it just pushed down the focuser tube a bit

frosty shard
#

I have thought about potentially getting one of the Baader clicklock visual backs and screwing that on so I never have to deal with set screws

harsh matrix
#

Oh boy

#

I think the primary mirror on my RC6 can get pinched optics

#

Just like the secondary

#

That makes no sense AwkwardSmile

undone sedge
#

you get pinched optics, you get pinched optics, and you get pinched optics! everyone gets pinched optics!!!

harsh matrix
#

I can't even tell if that's really what it is

#

The airy disks look oblong and not circular but it feels like it's seeing

#

It looks symmetrical in live view

#

Then it turns into a triangle once it gets focused

#

I suspect my light leak baffle tube is at fault

#

Well a 60 second subs looks good

#

I think i got a very slight amount of sensor tilt

#

My guiding is excellent tonight PepeHype

frosty shard
#

Yo I just ran into another slight scare with my RC

#

The extra finderscope screws came loose and fell into the OTA

#

I'm gonna replace them with screws that have actual heads

#

Getting them out is a pain due to the baffles AwkwardSmile

analog portal
#

I removed the focuser and that extra spacer between it and the RC back, and enjoyed a few hours doing some visual observing. The moon didn't help, but at least it looked nice through the eyepiece.

frosty shard
#

I've actually managed to take mine out for outreach for the past three nights

brisk swift
#

yo how do u collimate ur RC @frosty shard

frosty shard
harsh matrix
#

Learned that bortle 7 + 84% illuminated moon is not very fun

#

Leaves the moon as the only interesting thing to look at AwkwardSmile

frosty shard
frosty shard
# harsh matrix Uh wtf

Optics still look fine, I just had to be careful about ensuring the screw didn't fall on the secondary mirror

harsh matrix
#

I went crater hunting with the dob

#

Saw some parts of the moon I've never really seen before

#

Saw what I thought were fractures, remnants around one of the large mare from the impact that created it

#

They were like terraced fractures

harsh matrix
#

this is what we are shooting with the Ritchey tonight wholesome

harsh matrix
brisk swift
#

ordered my 6" Carbon RC @frosty shard

#

4 days to go

frosty shard
harsh matrix
#

hopefully it is collimated or near collimated when you get it

#

mine was so far out that i didnt know what to do

brisk swift
#

The retailers collimate it before shipping themselves

#

it*

#

bro I'm on drugs

#

should I wait for 6200mm to come in stock or get 2600mc

harsh matrix
#

an RC cant do full frame

#

id do a 2600MM, not get a color version for the amount of money you have to spend on it

#

not worth it imo

#

or at least try to get a Player One Poseidon-M Pro

#

Player One's offerings are objectively better than ZWO's

#

plus your RC wont be fully taken advantage of with the color camera, the bayer matrix handicaps the resolution so your images will always look mushy

#

mono makes everything super crisp and allows you to eek out even more resolution

brisk swift
#

guess I gotta wait

frosty shard
#

Here's one of my friends looking through my RC on Saturday

#

And let the people who look through my telescope sign it

#

Maybe I'll vinyl wrap the tube first and then let people sign that

brisk swift
#

@frosty shard

#

which diagonal should I get? I'm confused

#

idk what size will fit the scope ( 2 or 1.25"

#

how do I check which is gonna fit

harsh matrix
brisk swift
#

Diagonal

harsh matrix
#

both*

brisk swift
harsh matrix
brisk swift
harsh matrix
#

im going to go fight an uphill battle and try to see the Milky Way core in my backyard

harsh matrix
#

Id argue that the brightest part of the core rises inside of what is probably a bortle 8 light dome

#

So I'll never in a million years see it from home

undone sedge
#

yeah the brightest part of the core at the observatory is firmly in the atlanta lp haze

frosty shard
frosty shard
#

Just so you know why: to really take advantage of the full barrel diameter you want a 2" diagonal (and ideally a 2" eyepiece with maximized field stop).

#

And in general I'd avoid prisms with an RC just because they're already well-corrected

#

Though some swear by them for planetary work

#

(Prisms can introduce some spherochromatism and coma)

#

Also 2" prisms are expensive

frosty shard
brisk swift
frosty shard
brisk swift
frosty shard
#

Oh I thought you got the CarbonStar

brisk swift
#

nu I got the gso one

oblique sun
#

well now that my newts broken i have another reason to get an rc

frosty shard
#

Either way they're really all the same, GSO makes all of them

harsh matrix
oblique sun
#

i want one but like

#

im not rich

high aspen
#

could probably get one cheaper used

oblique sun
#

Double that for me😿

high aspen
#

what currency u use

oblique sun
#

$

#

uee

high aspen
#

just your currency just needs more per gbp

oblique sun
#

that's more than 400

high aspen
high aspen
high aspen
#

i also want this camera for regular photography

#

bc it looks pretty

#

and thats the only reason

oblique sun
#

150mm rcs aren't heavy

high aspen
high aspen
oblique sun
#

my 6" newt is light af

high aspen
#

with the tripod i mean

#

the newt is liftable

#

by a bit

oblique sun
#

if i carry my entire setup it's hard because the counterweight

#

makes center of mass go silly

high aspen
oblique sun
#

mine are only 2.5kg lol

high aspen
#

idk what i have

oblique sun
#

i only use one at halfway down the cw shaft

#

cause my newt is ultralight

#

its half paper lmao

high aspen
#

B U H

high aspen
#

non farbonciber

oblique sun
#

that's still only half my mounts capacity

#

slightly more but still

high aspen
#

farbonciber

oblique sun
#

0.4kg

#

that is not worth the price difference

high aspen
oblique sun
high aspen
high aspen
oblique sun
oblique sun
high aspen
oblique sun
#

new mount before November scope

#

new

#

autocorrect 😿

high aspen
oblique sun
#

do eq5 + onstep

#

much cheaper

high aspen
#

good point

oblique sun
#

and better i think

high aspen
oblique sun
#

rahg am almost home i will attempt to go fix bent newt now

#

if i can't then uh idk

high aspen
#

that dont work and traumatise children

oblique sun
#

😨

brisk swift
harsh matrix
#

im about to pull the trigger on the Xena-M @frosty shard

analog portal
brisk swift
#

technically still a gso

harsh matrix
#

I found something weird about that pinched optics deal with the primary

#

It started out as a theory and now I think it's what is happening

#

Pretty sure it's related to temperature

#

Specifically the primary mirror cell

analog portal
#

i had that happen with a newt when i overtightened it and it got out in the cold.

brisk swift
#

THAT LOOKS CRAZY

#

no way

harsh matrix
#

My RC6 split Rigel A and B

#

Apparently seeing is cheeks tonight so this is surprising

brisk swift
#

how do u collimate your RC? @harsh matrix

harsh matrix
brisk swift
#

do u have any vids on Collimating a RC? Barely any useful vids on yt

harsh matrix
#

But

#

Lukamatico has an SCT collimation video which was very helpful for me

#

as crazy as it sounds, collimating an SCT is virtually identical to collimating an RC

#

apertura's user manual for the carbonstar helped me a lot too

brisk swift
frosty shard
prime sequoia
frosty shard
#

Since there weren't any images of amateur sized RCs

#

I'm actually trying to find proper sources so I can add more info about amateur RCs – apparently there's a book chapter out there that has some of GSO's history

oblique sun
analog portal
#

i have an ADM weight saddle for my 8"

#

i had two counterweights but they're cut into thirds, so i can be more precise with the balance. as well as adding the side bolt, if my camera is rotated where the filter wheel is off to the side i take one of the weights off and counter it to the opposite side.

oblique sun
#

add a ball head and a dslr😼

#

image two targets at once

harsh matrix
prime sequoia
#

anyone use a 6" and have any idea if 2lb is overkill for a conterweight. I would like to buy one but I dont know if 2lb is to much

oblique sun
#

might not be enougj

#

My scope is lighter than a carbonstar and i use a 2.5kg counterweight most of the way down the shaft

#

with guidescope

#

without i use it halfway

prime sequoia
#

the dec

analog portal
#

my 8" is cf and with the image train, i need almost 7lbs of counterweight up front

brisk swift
harsh matrix
#

im using my guidescope as a makeshift counterweight and i think it weighs about that much

#

not nearly enough to counter balance the amount of weight on the back

#

im also running a full fledged mono system with an OAG

brisk swift
harsh matrix
#

I need a new guide camera

brisk swift
analog portal
frosty shard
#

You can get around the speed issue by using a guide cam with big pixels

brisk swift
analog portal
brisk swift
#

@frosty shard Do u guide when using ur RC for visual

frosty shard
brisk swift
frosty shard
#

Not that you'd need it – the error with a harmonic drive mount is too small to notice visually

frosty shard
frosty shard
brisk swift
frosty shard
analog portal
#

i used my gem28 visually with an 8" SCT on it, should be fine

brisk swift
#

What about imaging

frosty shard
#

I haven't imaged with mine yet lol

#

It's too good at visual

brisk swift
#

what can u see with ur scope visually? @frosty shard

analog portal
frosty shard
analog portal
#

player one sedna-m

#

my asi120mm mini would work as well, but smaller fov so i ditched it

frosty shard
brisk swift
#

Uh I got the 6" pepeSuperSad

frosty shard
#

It showed me the Triangulum Galaxy, Rosette Nebula, several small galaxies in Ursa Major, many planetary nebulae, etc

brisk swift
#

what bortle

frosty shard
frosty shard
brisk swift
#

I'm in bortle 4

frosty shard
#

I usually observe in Bortle 7-8

frosty shard
#

But honestly it's good to hear that the Sedna-M does the job

analog portal
#

when on my rc8, i use it in bin2. on the other scopes, bin1. but the xena-m has more fov though, you should enjoy it 🙂

brisk swift
#

u have a gem28? @analog portal

analog portal
#

yeah, and a gem45

#

rc8 sits on the 45, my fma180 pro or at80edt will sit on the gem28, depending on what i'm doing

brisk swift
analog portal
#

i'm not sure, what's your rc6 weigh?

brisk swift
#

around 5kg

#

Mounts payload is 12.7kg I think I should be fine

analog portal
#

yeah i think so. imaging stuff shouldn't be too much more

#

i did use my gem28 imaging with an 8" SCT and OSC camera with OAG, it was ok in RA, but my DEC was having issues due to balance to make proper corrections

brisk swift
#

SCTS are back heavy tho monkaHmm

analog portal
#

so's the RC

brisk swift
#

the seconday of RC makes it less back heavy

analog portal
#

true. however, with my moonlite focuser my rc is just as back heavy as the sct was lol

analog portal
#

it's a terrible problem!

#

oh, i forgot to mention! when i put more weight on my GEM28, I had to tighten the RA gears. awkward

brisk swift
#

I mean all I'm gonna put on it is a 2600mm or 533mm , oag, guide cam

analog portal
#

it came from the factory a bit loose. i started to slew when i put an at115edt on it with a minipier, it dropped violently making a terrible sound of gears skipping over each other

brisk swift
#

nothing else pepeRolls

analog portal
#

i caught it before it hit the tripod, and spent the next day inside tweaking the tension/tightness

#

yeah, about 6kg

brisk swift
#

the retailers check everything before shipping the mount so idts I should be worried

analog portal
#

i got mine from High Point back several years ago

brisk swift
#

did u notice any more problems?

analog portal
#

i switched the tripod from that one to the gem45 later on, because the gem28 had built in vibration discs on the bottom, and the gem45 did not. same size legs, different 'tops' though. i setup on my roof and the extra weight on the gem45 would poke through the roof if not for the discs

#

nah, no more issues after those adjustments

#

it was about a year after that when i had the sct on it

brisk swift
analog portal
#

i got that in august 2021, it's only gone up $200 since

#

i don't see many other gem28 with that

brisk swift
analog portal
#

$1398 for me

#

bought my gem45 used from a nice feller in texas

brisk swift
harsh matrix
brisk swift
#

Man...

#

u gonna make me

prime sequoia
harsh matrix
prime sequoia
#

Ya

#

Tonight is another testing night for me. Focus on the oag has been a pain

prime sequoia
#

So much so I am really considering getting a 2600mc dual.

#

I tested and it does fully illuminate a full frame dslr so it should work.

#

I wonder if I can get my one club member to let me borrow his 2600 dual and try it out.

prime sequoia
#

Have a look. That is a flat frame of my canon 6d mk

#

2

frosty shard
# harsh matrix It does?

The GSO RCs were definitely designed to illuminate full frame sensors, though field curvature is the big limiting factor

analog portal
#

although i have swapped it out for the CCDT67 though

#

it claims it works as a focal reducer in that page, don't believe it. i stay at f/8 @ 1600mm with it in

analog portal
#

it's not something the manufacturer claims. it's listed elsewhere and specifically says it doesn't impact focal length

prime sequoia
brisk swift
#

@harsh matrix U WON THE COMP

harsh matrix
#

RC6 ftw

frosty shard
#

So I just realized my RC actually needed to be recollimated

#

Easy job actually, I just had to tweak the secondary

#

...and that is why my RC wasn't doing too hot on Jupiter last night

#

Now at 203x I can clearly see the belt eruptions

harsh matrix
#

You must have really good seeing then

frosty shard
#

Yeah the planets were lit tonight

#

On the other hand, my 8 mm Baader Hyperion might have an issue somewhere. It has a ton of on-axis chromatic aberration

frosty shard
#

Really making the most of my RC's imaging capability tonight

frosty shard
brisk swift
bronze wigeon
frosty shard
high aspen
frosty shard
#

(fun fact: the building was bombed once in 1970)

The Sterling Hall bombing occurred on the University of Wisconsin–Madison campus on August 24, 1970, and was committed by four men as an action against the university's research connections with the U.S. military during the Vietnam War. It resulted in the death of a university physics researcher and injuries to three others.

high aspen
high aspen
#

@vapid patio

#

ask here

vapid patio
#

Ahhhh

#

Well

#

I am getting one on Saturday. I don’t have a flatter. Will it matter since I have a micro 4/3 sensor? It’s only really using the middle of the scope.

frosty shard
vapid patio
#

Thats grewt to hear

#

And also

#

How hard is it to guide?

#

I bought a huge guide scope let me send you the linl

#

Link and im paring it with a asi120mm

vapid patio
#

@frosty shard

analog portal
#

I have that same guide scope, but don't use it anymore. Your guiding with that will look good, but remember that's a lot shorter than your focal length is, which could impact sharpness of your subs.

frosty shard
#

Generally you want to use an off-axis guider with an RC

#

I've heard of people being successful with guidescopes though

analog portal
#

i used that guidescope/camera combo on my at115edt, and since then i've switched to OAG. it worked well for the ~800mm focal length.

vapid patio
#

But arent oag expensive?

analog portal
#

not much more than that scope

vapid patio
#

But i have a small guide camera so it should be really zoomed in

analog portal
#

right but it's still only 240mm focal length, your 'zoomed in' is just the field of view

vapid patio
#

True

#

Well what do you think. It would be fine?

analog portal
#

if you already bought it, may as well try it out and see how it works 🙂

vapid patio
#

True, amazon does not care

analog portal
#

i use that guide scope as a finder scope with a 1.25" diagonal in the end and an eyepiece now 😛

frosty shard
#

But I'd also suggest just trying it anyway

#

You might not have significant issues

vapid patio
#

I have dew heaters for it maybe to keep it steady

vapid patio
analog portal
#

it's generally a sturdy configuration if you have it tightened well.

#

the issue i had the most was the helical focuser had some slop in it. after a meridian flip, it would throw off the framing a bit

vapid patio
#

Or i could piggy back my apaturea 72mm as a guide scope haha

analog portal
#

i worded that wrong

#

it was the focus 'tube' that extends out, not the helical part

vapid patio
#

Yeah

#

Well i will try it and say somthing here if it goes good or bad

frosty shard
#

@vapid patio biggest RC tip: stick a diagonal and eyepiece in it and have a look through it :)

vapid patio
#

I dont have eye pieces

frosty shard
#

Fair enough

harsh matrix
#

Yay the cult is growing PepeHype

vapid patio
#

Do you have the carbon one or astro tech?

#

Ive seen 2 scopes

frosty shard
vapid patio
#

Sick

frosty shard
#

I have only really used mine for visual astronomy though, so I'm not going to be the most knowledgeable when it comes to imaging with mine

vapid patio
#

They are all pretty much the same? As in quality not as in size

frosty shard
#

All consumer RCs are made by GSO and are rebadged, so they're mostly the same

#

They may come with different accessories though, which notably includes the focuser

vapid patio
#

Ok yeah i thought so

#

Thanks

prime sequoia
#

so with my focuser I found that it likes to slip.

#

I have the tension high and it still slips out every now and then

harsh matrix
harsh matrix
vapid patio
#

Can I take the one off my other scopes and put it on?

#

Is it the same style?

harsh matrix
#

No

frosty shard
vapid patio
#

Aw man

analog portal
#

gonna use my RC8 and 2x.5 reducers to record the eclipse tonight. 🙏

harsh matrix
#

Is that going to work?

analog portal
#

sure! .5 takes it to 50% reduced, another .5 takes me to .75% reduced (overall)

#

just gotta watch for reflections and physics

#

who wouldn't want an 8" f/2 RC 😅

harsh matrix
#

That would be awesome

#

RASA type beat

oblique sun
oblique sun
vapid patio
analog portal
#

i would need a .25% reducer

vapid patio
#

oh ok

#

i wanna get a reducer for my 8"

#

what do you think is best?

analog portal
#

i was joking about my rc8 use tonight, btw. i have the CCDT67 reducer for mine. depending on spacing, i can shoot between f/5.6 or f/6.4 ... usually i stay at f/6.4

#

i think it could be reduced further, but i don't have the proper spacers to get the spacing for it 😅

#

that takes me from 1600mm to 1300mm focal length at f/6.4

harsh matrix
vapid patio
#

astro tech

#

Astrophysics Telecompressor CCDT67

#

is what i was looking at

harsh matrix
#

@analog portal is the Astro tech RC line another GSO rebrand?

vapid patio
#

brain and force said it is

#

@harsh matrix also what is that bar that goes on the top of the scope called/

harsh matrix
#

It's the exact same dimensions as the one in the bottom side of my scope

vapid patio
#

hmm ok

#

the dude i bought it from doesnt have one

#

any clue on where to get one?

harsh matrix
#

You might have to ask brain for the dimensions of the one on top of the 8" RC

#

Mine's a 6" and idk if the length of the tube is the same, I'd assume not.

analog portal
harsh matrix
#

I can order the Carbonstar RC8 pretty soon if i save for a few more weeks

brisk swift
#

noo

#

I'll be the only 6 incher

thorny path
#

How easy is guiding with a strain wave mount with an RC + OAG

#

I was doing first light with mount and found 1 sec exposures do very well surprisingly

#

I thought I would be chasing seeing or something

#

How difficult is it to find a star with an OAG

analog portal
#

i do 2.5 to 3s exposures in PHD2 guiding my RC8 on my gem45, guiding in bortle 6. it's not terrible at all.

frosty shard
#

The Player One Xena-M uses the same sensor and is really better than the ASI174MM Mini (cheaper, has USB3)

frosty shard
harsh matrix
#

Ragdoll 17 i think

frosty shard
#

Ah right you need pretty fast guiding cadences for those

thorny path
#

I got .3 rms last night

#

I’m very happy

#

I worry that with an RC and slower system that at 1sec I will struggle

#

I have a 462 btw

#

Idk if that is ideal for OAG

harsh matrix
#

But my 120MM is similar in size and I haven't had problems getting a guide star until galaxy season now

#

I have to order a camera with a bigger sensor.

thorny path
#

Oh ok I didn’t know that

#

I assumed any would do

harsh matrix
#

And if you don't live in bortle 20

brisk swift
frosty shard
harsh matrix
#

P1 doesnt normally take that long

frosty shard
#

It's them waiting on a supplier, they were pretty helpful when I inquired

#

But I'm not in a rush at the moment. Got too much visual work to do lol

high aspen
thorny path
#

i see used GSO 6" RC AwkwardSmile

#

the focuser design hasnt changed much except the front part being flattened for an EAF. so i can find some m4 screw somewhere for better tightening

harsh matrix
#

just make sure it's not a very old one

thorny path
harsh matrix
thorny path
#

Oh ok 🙏

#

350 shipped

#

I’ll ask when he got it and if his focuser is EAF compatible

#

I wonder if these have mirror flop issues. It seems even the newer carbon stars are the exact same almost

harsh matrix
harsh matrix
harsh matrix
thorny path
harsh matrix
#

I dont think my flats would work ever

thorny path
#

Just what it says on listing

harsh matrix
#

if it did flop

harsh matrix
#

shoot that's very cheap

thorny path
#

I wonder cause I see it a lot on forums with GSO ones. Might be worth crying and buying once with the CS

#

Was thinking on a .75x reducer but I realize there’s a lot of small targets I wanna shoot this summer

harsh matrix
#

i use my 0.67x reducer most of the time and i find that it allows my RC to virtually ignore seeing

#

that's how I am resolving globs in M81 and M82

#

it probably would still resolve them without the reducer but guiding around those galaxies at that focal length with a 120MM is painful

#

btw @thorny path this is what Apertura's manual says about the primary mirror's mounting situation

thorny path
#

I hear The whole “seeing limited” a lot

#

Is it that bad where you prefer that reducer ?

#

I’d like to use it at its native FL

harsh matrix
#

and judging by the fact that I seem to get pinched optics on the primary with the temps being where they are right now with large fluctuations in this period of time, i'd be inclined to agree

harsh matrix
#

i actually quite like the native focal length

#

i just dont like shooting at native with my OAG + the 120MM

thorny path
#

Ah

harsh matrix
#

i have a hard time getting guide stars because the camera just sucks

thorny path
#

Lmao

#

Imma take the risk on it

harsh matrix
#

My sharpest data sets came from shooting without the reducer

thorny path
#

Low key goated with collimation since my experience with the evil sky watcher one

#

I’ll have to get an OAG as well since I’ve been putting that off

harsh matrix
#

Like this M51 pic wholesome

#

Oh and the other reason I don't like native sometimes is the f ratio, which in B7 can make things excessively difficult.

thorny path
#

Did you see the eclipse btw ?

#

I’m also in B7

harsh matrix
#

I would definitely shoot at native at a dark sky site

harsh matrix
thorny path
#

I got lucky

#

With carbon star

#

I saw it through my eye piece and I saw very little red

#

But I guess that cause of low contrast with newt

vapid patio
#

Lads

#

I need some help

#

Back focus is so hard to get my astro tech rc6

#

As its the clamp thing and not a screw on

analog portal
#

What are you trying to focus?

vapid patio
#

Like how many spacers do I need

harsh matrix
#

I believe the 50 mm spacer is sufficient to reach focus too

#

Thats the bigger of the 3 that should have come with the scope

analog portal
# vapid patio Backfocus

If you don't have enough focus 'out' then do what Veloren says, or if it's unable to focus 'in' then you may have to remove the spacer between the focuser and back of the OTA. (I have to do that for visual use)

high aspen
high aspen
vapid patio
#

How in the world am i gonna get back focus like this

analog portal
#

try un screwing the compression ring attachment from the focuser

#

under that is likely where you'll screw your camera on

high aspen
#

I HAVE TO RESTART MY STACKING AAAAA

high aspen
#

I GOT STOPPED BY AN UPDATE FOR WINDOWS FIRST

high aspen
vapid patio
#

I cant get the stupid back focus

#

And i dont even know if its collamted

high aspen
vapid patio
#

And its cloudy

#

And its a new mount

vapid patio
high aspen
analog portal
harsh matrix
harsh matrix
#

Thats the issue.

analog portal
#

Well, he also has the spacers on the camera fully inserted into the focuser tube instead of screwed on...

vapid patio
high aspen
vapid patio
harsh matrix
# vapid patio ?

Were talking in front of the focuser, at the front of the chrome ring

analog portal
#

This piece

vapid patio
analog portal
#

it can be very stiff. 😅 it should come off. the spacer Veloren is talking about on the other end of the focuser, mine was practically welded on lol

#

darned near sprained my wrist twisting it off

harsh matrix
#

Now I see where the confusion is

#

I didn't think about that. I remember now that when I used the compression ring to hold the camera, I needed a 50 mm + 25 mm spacer ring to reach focus

#

If you can thread the camera on directly, you should only need the 50 mm spacer which i think you have by the looks of things.

vapid patio
#

No it doesnt come out

high aspen
vapid patio
#

The little compressing thing on the back does not come off

analog portal
#

issue a subpoena!

#

every scope i've had, from the cheap old celestron omni xlt, has that part screwed onto the focus tube

vapid patio
#

Dude i am telling you it dies not come off as it is one peice

analog portal
#

i'm flabbergasted. what model is that?

vapid patio
#

Astro tech rc6

#

There is no seem at all

analog portal
#

hrm

#

you're saying there is no seem there?

#

Looking at Cloudy Nights, it seems that actually is a solid piece. That's a really poor design. 😦

harsh matrix
#

Looks like you're getting a 25 mm extension ring.

harsh matrix
#

my RC just casually split Polaris wholesome

#

not even acclimated to outside, focused, or have good seeing

harsh matrix
#

another over sharpened over denoised SCT image Sludge

#

this one too

#

(I know not every instance of oversharpening + over denoising and maybe even background clipping is from an SCT user but it's more often than not from one AwkwardSmile )

#

one of the only scopes that leads to this happening at a much higher rate than others

#

actually just seeing a lot of bad images rn PepeYikes

thorny path
#

What is this phenomenon called ?

#

I see it a lot on instagram

harsh matrix
high aspen
#

i think amma get the Sky-Watcher EQ-AL55i PRO AwkwardSmile

#

i want everyone to be unable to sleep

#

with its cries

brisk swift
high aspen
#

all i know is the backlash will make me want to kms

#

did he talk about the backlash

#

and did he talk about how it sounds like it's dying

brisk swift
#

he used eq-al55i in the videl

#

Video

high aspen
analog portal
#

#1350826576371257385 message

#

new RC image just dropped

analog portal
#

tornado watch, time to bring in the mount 😅

high aspen
brisk swift
high aspen
#

they cheaper and better f-stop

#

per focal length

brisk swift
#

no collimation and wide fov

high aspen
brisk swift
#

I like smoll galaxies so neither do i

analog portal
#

oh shizzle, i'm pink again

high aspen
analog portal
#

last time this happened, i rage quit the server awkward

analog portal
#

back in the old days i was red, and new roles were added and i became pink

#

i am not fond of this hue

analog portal
#

it was coming in anyway tbh, winds are gusting at 25mph and higher. i was worried the cover would tear, since it's tied to the tripod legs. or it would act as a sail and topple the gem45.

harsh matrix
#

True dat

harsh matrix
#

love my RC wholesome

#

sometimes it makes me not want to get the 8" but I know I will like that way more...

harsh matrix
harsh matrix
#

I stand my ground when I claimed it was easier to collimate one of these RC's than it was yo collimate my f/3.45 quattro

#

That will not change KEKL

vapid patio
#

Do you guys think i will have trouble guiding with a 260mm 60mm guide scope?

#

Oag was out of the budget

vapid patio
#

6

harsh matrix
#

or plan to?

oblique sun
harsh matrix
#

for reference, i was encountering differential flexture with a 162 mm 50 mm guide scope

#

im not sure how much of a difference another 100 mm of focal length will make, but i suspect it may not be enough to get sharp stars.

vapid patio
#

I plan to but not for awhile

#

Also my mount was hyper tuned

#

And i am running half the weight it can holf

#

Hold

harsh matrix
#

i suspect it will still wobble around a lot despite what your guiding says, so i dont think you will get perfect stars, but i expect it to be manageable in that case

#

just dont expect to be able to get 5 minute subs

#

i couldnt get longer than 60 second exposures when i was guiding with a guide scope, even with the RC reduced.

#

you will get subs that arent trailed, i just dont know how long you will be able to go for before you get trailing

vapid patio
#

aw man

#

whats the best oag you recommend

#

wait but you have 8"?

harsh matrix
harsh matrix
#

the prism is very big, big enough to support whatever guide cam you have now and in the future

#

the largest sensor I know of on a guide cam (in my knowledge) is the Player One Xena-M and that fits snugly with the prism on my OAG

#

cant wait to order it because guiding will be easy once I have it

vapid patio
#

i have asi120mm does that work>

harsh matrix
vapid patio
#

good lord that oag is 250

harsh matrix
#

you get plenty of guide stars near the galactic plane, but outside, you are pretty SOL

vapid patio
#

i might be screwed

harsh matrix
vapid patio
#

true

harsh matrix
#

i spent a lot of money i was not prepared to spend and i was crying with every purchase, but now my rig runs perfectly every night, reliably, and I get excellent pictures because of it

#

it was worth it in the end

#

makes me excited to get out and shoot every night knowing my equipment can handle whatever i throw at it

#

the ZWO OAG was really making me hate guiding with an OAG, and it was impossible to use with a filter wheel

vapid patio
#

i have 39 cent rn

harsh matrix
#

that's what made me buy the QHY OAG, i didnt want any problems from then on.

vapid patio
#

well i will see tomorrow i guess

#

maybe ill be lucky

#

or do i sound like a clown rn

harsh matrix
#

like i said, i could do 60 second exposures with a 50 mm guide scope, my 120MM, on a stock EQM-35 Pro

vapid patio
#

its a f/9 and i have a asi533mc pro im cooked

harsh matrix
#

whether or not you can do better than that, idk

vapid patio
#

could you explain differential flexture to me like im 5

harsh matrix
#

that's an extremely butchered and over simplified explanation but that's virtually what it means once you break it down to the fundamentals

vapid patio
#

but what if i get t hem to see the same part of the sky?

harsh matrix
#

since the guide scope is a lower focal length than the imaging scope, the guide camera perceives a slower rate of movement than the imaging camera does, and so over time, that can present as star trails

harsh matrix
#

it's unfixable

#

without some unimaginably solid mounting solution for the guide scope

vapid patio
#
#

this is what i have

vapid patio
harsh matrix
vapid patio
#

yeah

harsh matrix
#

the lower position of your guide scope will probably be a big help

vapid patio
#

well mine has those up down left right things

harsh matrix
vapid patio
harsh matrix
#

but my guide scope is on a tall pedestal thing

harsh matrix
#

mine was way more spread apart, making it impossible to align the 2

vapid patio
#

i see

#

and since it is a asi120 wont it be pretty zoomed in to account for those small movements?

harsh matrix
harsh matrix
#

my guide scope is haning off the front on the bottom

#

i basically use it as a counterweight for the dec now, but you can see it's on a little metal stand thing

vapid patio
#

odd

#

but i could see why

#

guide scope fov

#

so close to my main scope haha

harsh matrix
#

this is the guide ratio for your system

vapid patio
#

no clue what that means

harsh matrix
#

generally you want the guide number to be 5 or below

vapid patio
#

i mean it is 5?.26

harsh matrix
# vapid patio no clue what that means

imaging / guiding

imaging = the resolution of your imaging scope + camera

1370 mm focal length + 3.76 micron pixels = 0.57"/px

guiding = resolution of the guide scope + guide camera

260 mm focal length + 3.75 micron pixels = 2.97"/px

the 5.26 in the ratio means that is how many times worse the resolution of your guiding solution is

#

1:5 is really bad

#

not ideal, but manageable in some cases

#

above that is unsuitable

vapid patio
#

hm

harsh matrix
#

1:3 is generally good or acceptable

#

1:2 or lower than 2 is great and adequate

#

that's enlightening for me too

#

i wanted to look into getting a bigger guide scope to maybe get around OAG guiding altogether

#

but I do like being able to guide for 10 minutes kekw

#

with no star trails

vapid patio
#

i have a spare scope.. apaturea 72 edr that i could piggy back?

harsh matrix
vapid patio
vapid patio
harsh matrix
#

that would maybe work

vapid patio
#

haha let me sewnd you the link

harsh matrix
#

how much focal length does it have

vapid patio
#
#

480

harsh matrix
#

dafuq

#

this thing is cute

harsh matrix
vapid patio
#

thanks pepeLove2

harsh matrix
#

oh wow

vapid patio
#

with feild flatter my bad

harsh matrix
#

that's way more suitable

#

that would possibly work VERY well

#

just as long as however you mount it is solid

vapid patio
#

hehe how well we talking

vapid patio
harsh matrix
#

1:2.5

vapid patio
#

YAY

harsh matrix
#

not bad at all for the ratio

vapid patio
#

let me set it up i wanna send a pic HAHAHAHA

harsh matrix
harsh matrix
#

it's still 1:3.18

#

which is workable and not a big deal

#

if you get the reducer for the RC, it would be a perfect pairing though

vapid patio
#

I am drilling holes this is gonna work!

harsh matrix
oblique sun
#

i ended up with a bent tube but i fixed it

vapid patio
vapid patio
#

its a lil late here

#

but if it is directly mounted to the dovetail on the top it will be sturdy asf

oblique sun
vapid patio
#

oh hell nah

#

so youi drilled into thew tube???

#

im just drilling into the plate on the top

vapid patio
oblique sun
vapid patio
#

oag AwkwardSmile

oblique sun
#

my scope is not meant for imaging at all, there is no way to add guiding

oblique sun
#

unreplacable shitty helical focuser

#

well might work

#

but still

vapid patio
#

so what scope?

oblique sun
#

heritage 150

#

at some point i will get an rc6 and end the pain with this thing

vapid patio
#

the table top dob?

oblique sun
#

yes

vapid patio
oblique sun
#

moved onto a new mount ofc

vapid patio
#

thats good

oblique sun
#

this thing was designed with zero imaging capability in mind

vapid patio
#

rc6?

oblique sun
#

the mirrors are good

vapid patio
#

oh wait you sai rc6 already

#

well do you have a oag to put on it?

#

or a spare scope haha

oblique sun
#

no but i have a 240mm guidescope

vapid patio
#

@harsh matrix should i just sell the scope and get oag haha

harsh matrix
#

at least give it a shot first

vapid patio
harsh matrix
vapid patio
#

everything you have told me tonight tells me it sucks

harsh matrix
#

youre probably screwed but idk about entirely

harsh matrix
#

I wouldnt want to sell off my only guide scope and use an OAG on everything else

vapid patio
#

oh wait wait wait

#

wait

harsh matrix
#

that would be horrible

vapid patio
#

look up it was grand i was talking to

#

wait no it was you

harsh matrix
#

so you have 3 guide scopes in total?

vapid patio
#

smaller 165mm scopes for redcat and apaturea

#

so what about the piggy backing the scope? you not with it anymore?

harsh matrix
#

i think it is incredibly unlikely to bend it but i wouldnt push it if you think it's a possibility

#

I WILL say this though

vapid patio
#

i mean yeah idk if it even would i was jusst trowing it out there

harsh matrix
#

your OTA is steel

#

if it was aluminum, i think bending, or heavy flexture would be a concern.

vapid patio
#

i just got the scope yesterday so i dont know it yet lol

harsh matrix
#

I am not so sure about steel being that worrisome.

harsh matrix
#

people piggyback their redcats on their 8" and 10" newts all the time too

#

plus youre mounting it on the top rail, right?

vapid patio
#

yep

harsh matrix
#

that allows for more even weight distributing which makes bending even less likely

vapid patio
#

would i wanna drill the holes higher or lower? more twards the back or front of scope

harsh matrix
#

plus the primary and secondary mirror support cells are solid metal, i think steel

#

those wont be moving

vapid patio
harsh matrix
vapid patio
#

you have same scope?

harsh matrix
vapid patio
#

no not anymore. i wasent familiar on what "balanced" was with these moutns truly are

vapid patio
#

like i cant just unlock the clutches and move it and it stays still

harsh matrix
#

if it is balanced right now, try to get the guide scope to be as close to the center of mass as possible

vapid patio
#

easy

harsh matrix
#

you may have to move your counterweights for the RA, of course, but it's more than possible your dec can remain balanced

vapid patio
#

but the "guide scope" is backheavy as i will have a flatter on the baack and other adapters

vapid patio
vapid patio
harsh matrix
vapid patio
#

it does

#

i said it does

harsh matrix
#

o that was hard for me to understand ig Dentge

vapid patio
#

doesnt

#

doesNOT DOES NOT STAY STILL

#

SORRY

harsh matrix
#

so that means the scope is back heavy, so positioning the guide scope toward the front will help with that

vapid patio
#

no not this mount ig

harsh matrix
vapid patio
#

i followed the manual. balance RA by roating flat, then balace dec while it is sideways

harsh matrix
#

that seems like you will have massive dec backlash problems

vapid patio
#

even with nothingh on the mount the dec axis falls one way

harsh matrix
#

my EQM-35 is the same way

#

i will have really bad guiding if i dont get it to where it doesnt move if i unlock the dec clutch

vapid patio
#

could you send me a vidoe of what your scope does wqhen you unlock the clutchs

#

i need a reference

harsh matrix
#

you can follow what Galactic Hunter does though

vapid patio
#

big problem for my mount then

#

i cant like push it however i want

#

it cant stay balanced

#

it sways left or right

#

even with nothing on the scope. it goes to one side no matte how i have it

harsh matrix
#

that's... not ideal.

vapid patio
#

@harsh matrix

#

i have a question