#Modpack: All Suggestion: Admins/Devs should som...
minor agate
stray lichen
Admins/Devs should annotate each suggestion to indicate whether it will be implemented, under serious consideration, or not pursued.
This approach prevents duplicate suggestions, keeps the community informed, and provides the original poster with valuable feedback on their submission.
still yew
Admins do not have the power to add anything to the packs as we are not the developers. If people search the suggestions channels and read first we would not have the duplication issue. Even if devs say "hey yeah I'll be adding this" can still cause a person to duplicate a suggestion.
We are pretty blunt about things that 100% will not be added in, if a dev likes an idea they say it and also react to the suggestion with the checkmark. If they don't like it, it gets an x
stray lichen
We are pretty blunt about things that 100% will not be added in, if a dev likes ...
That makes sense. I mainly posted this because I have five suggestions from 1.5 months ago that each have 10-12 up-votes and minimal down votes (three have zero downvotes, one has one, another has two), but haven't really gotten much feedback on it despite the five suggestions clearly being somewhat popular with the community. Would be nice to hear back.
fluid citrus
That makes sense. I mainly posted this because I have five suggestions from 1.5 ...
You suggested for Fear Nightfall, right? I think these may have just gotten left behind because there was temporarily no one assigned to Fear Nightfall for a few months
@chorb.txt could maybe comment on whether any of these are likely to get included, I think she's the one currently maintaining FN
(here are the links):
#suggestions message
Oh nvm I can't ping chloe at the moment, lol
stray lichen
Yeah every single one has 10+ upvotes and hardly any downvotes
Haven’t seen suggestions be so popular for a while
amber kernel
in most cases if theres no reply its because im not interested in adding the mod or its already planned, replying to every single suggestion is very time-consuming especially when people will frequently disagree with whatever feedback i give
several times i have denied a suggestion and the suggester will go write an essay about why my opinion is wrong and then will leave the server if i reply
stray lichen
in most cases if theres no reply its because im not interested in adding the mod...
Iron fist 🤛. If you tell me it’s not getting added then good to go. It’ll tell me to never suggest something like that again, and I can work on the next good suggestion. But in times like this when I don’t get feedback it makes me incredibly tempted to repost the suggestion.
If you could make an exception I would truly greatly appreciate some feedback on those suggestions.
amber kernel
ill go back and reply to some
stray lichen
ill go back and reply to some
🫡
still yew
There are phases of time where there could be a lot less checking too. Vacations, school, holidays, heatwaves, etc