no

[nova laurel]

this mod breaks normal villager trades from working which makes several mods break

it also just doesn't fit bmc lol

[thorny wigeon]

how doesnt it? it makes more villager interaction and gets rid of the squidwerd villagers

[nova laurel]

exactly my point

it gets rid of the squidward villagers

[dapper mantle]

bmc is a vanilla+ modpack, how would be getting rid of the squidward villagers vanilla+? 😔

[thorny wigeon]

jw can you show me where on the modpack it says its a vanilla+ modpack

[dapper mantle]

well, the name should be enough, it's minecraft, but better, the content should stay on minecraft's style

other than that, chorb himself said it

[thorny wigeon]

ok than it should probably say that in the modpack itself bc MCA is considered a vanilla mod

[dapper mantle]

It's not vanilla+ because

1. it completely changes the original system instead of overhauling it, it breaks trades, which obviously isn't good at all
2. Destroys the villager's look from vanilla by just using player-like models with some extra parts
3. It over-complicates a simple concept such as villagers that trade to a whole UI with too many content which also doesn't fit the vanilla UI style

Villagers in vanilla are just meant to be boring entities that like emeralds, that's it, by adding this mod, you're basically breaking that whole concept of villagers from vanilla, by adding these new ones

Poor villagers, they don't deserve this

[thorny wigeon]

ok someone could argue that alex's mobs isnt a vanilla mod, or all the furniture mods arent just saying not trying to argue

[dapper mantle]

but the difference is, they're adding content rather than replacing a vanilla mechanic

that's the plus in vanilla+

[wise adder]

https://youtu.be/6ybh5733DCo
because you do don't mean it is. Most vanilla looking mods aren't vanilla but that's not as chocking as here xD learn what it is supposed to be first before making claims xD

[thorny wigeon]

okay what about the villagers+ mod wouldnt be vanilla due to it changing what the villagers do

[wise adder]

actually alex's mobs isn't at all, more like a parody of it imo but that's not really an issue as long as it's not too shocking

[dapper mantle]

Is it removing the whole concept of a squidward-like villager that likes emeralds and trades? Nope

MCA removes it and replaces it with a whole new system, that removes the original one and also doesn't support the original trades, so all trades that mods are disappear completely

[thorny wigeon]

you can still trade with the mca mod it doesnt change that

[dapper mantle]

There are issues closed by the devs due to "not their fault" about other mods' trades not working on MCA

[thorny wigeon]

Also since I got a developer in here the bloodstone from the twigs mod when you mine it crashes the game

[wise adder]

removing a well working concept for a unnecessary weird/creepy one, breaking compatibilities / other mods building on vanilla stuff, adding almost useless interaction. It's anyway not adding interesting mechanics except talking to a girl but MMC isn't an incel modpack (or maybe i missed last Chorb's changes to the modpack description )

[wise adder]

report it to the original mod dev and ask him to fix it, we dont practice magic (at the moment, but who knows)

[dapper mantle]

Better MC: E-Dating Update

[dapper mantle]

[nova laurel]

how is that not vanilla+ lol

it doesn't change vanilla it adds to it

hence the plus in vanilla +

[dapper mantle]

guys look at this new vanilla+ mod I found, add it plz 🤯

[wise adder]

more than adding instead of changing it's about added value, changing the whole system don't add anything except weird relationships and child slavery (wait why am i against this mod addition, looks cool from that angle "Come here Timmy, running won't help you. wanna mate with your mom ?")

[wise adder]

literally could fit 1.21

"the hexagons & squaresgone update", true ballin' moment ⛹️‍♂️

[nova laurel]

real

[minor trail]

all points aside

chorb literally said the mod breaks multiple other mods