#Columbia University (CUNY Morningside) (2022-2023)
1 messages · Page 2 of 1
nah i dont think so+ you could always upload it on portal
cause if there isnt that lowkey sucks
yeah im do that cause my resume basically explains my EC's
kinda hard to grasp what I really did with that 1 sentence we can write
submitted 🥳
yayy all of us submitting the day before the deadline 👏 and not the hour before 👏
and I recorded myself so when i would be rejected, i'd have some files to destroy😌
very cool
hopefully i can just repurpose my princeton essays
lemme check the prompts rq
well i did repurpose columbia's for princeton, other way around should work
What's the deadline for school supplements (e.g.: mid-year report)
College essay guys has some good advice for the community essay
Personally, I might start off with describing some challenges you've faced, what you've learned, and how that would affect your experience at columbia
most semester grades aren’t out yet
would you guys recommend uploading a resume to columbias portal?
thats what ima do cause my ecs look so bad without my resume
cause some of them need the explanation lol
congrats!
what yall doing for this it says to provide identifying info should I just type it in the box?
Cause I use this resume for all other colleges
Is there a central deadline for the supplementary materials?
specific to time-zone
do you guys know if there's a deadline for the portfolio?
I would!
yall columbia extendde their dealine
Update as of December 30, 2022: The Regular Decision deadline has been extended until Tuesday, January 10, 2023, at 11:59 p.m. (applicant's local time) for applicants affected by the current COVID-19 outbreak in China. There is no need for affected applicants to request a deadline extension. Please note that this new date will not appear on the application website, but we have noted this internally.
what
For pple in China yeah
Penn did the same pretty sure
wait what abt if you get covid but not in china
it’s only for affected applicants in china
anyone?
11:59 jan 1 ur time
Ahh I see
I made a new doc for my resume and included the info!
Is it okay to not have 125 words for the 2nd prompt?
or should i try to reach it
I included museums, news outlets, music, podcasts, movies/tv series, and content creators
should i include magazines although i don’t regularly read them?
or journals
Subreddits if you're a reddit user
I put a few video games but not sure if that's a good idea
ooo subreddits?
what did you put that under?
websites?
forums
or
Okay
Related to my hobbies
yeah i’ve pretty much contextualized all of my interests
No 😭
Ik someone in here said they did
But I really don't see how it could strengthen an application
I've always wondered how these schools feel about bootlicking like that
Does it help? Or just reduce your personality rating
r/columbiaaoadresses
😳
always check the address sub first 🤭🤭
i said uquiz dead ass i need to redo it 💀
reddit: r/chanceme
PLSSSS
r/funny (i have a great sense of humor!)
I used to be into really cringe political satire 😭
i’m contemplating putting it but the main creator’s accoutn i used to watch has devolved into madness and i would not want an ao to look him up
how long did it take after u submitted your app to get your temp pin?
did you put princeton instead
No
then ur fine
2-3 business days
i was writing a lot of the word "inequity"
and
ended up writing
that i wanted to work with dr _____ to promote socioeconomic inequity
i.
HHAHAAHAHH
im so done fr
that’s hilarious
instant reject
bro no you’re fine
IM DEON
that'll give them a chuckle
they’ll know it’s a typo
I HOPE SO
promoting socioeconomic inequity though, sounds like an absolute admit
would you know if they accept after 11:59 pm pst? Since they mentioned Jan 1, I thought they might have a grace-ish period lol
Because I'm still left with half of my video T_T
video for?
What...
the maker portfolio
columbia doesn’t have a video supplemental
oh thank god
it does in the maker section
the maker portfolio is submitted into the portal right?
they have a slideroom for that right?
yeah that's done
okay so you’re fine
maker portfolio is left
yeah there’s probably a grace period
cool thanks!
congrats!
oh damn
do you think you could email them about it perhaps?
i'm not sure if a single word is worth the email 😭
true
although it might be since i assume you meant to write "equity" right? so it would be opposite meanings there
but again, you might be right about it not really being worth it
tysm!
OMG FINALLY
i would like others opinion on this: should i bother reporting scores of 3s
and only report 4 and 5s atleast for schools of these caliber
i know ap scores prob dont matter that much but rather be safe than running in the possibility of something negative for them to point out
Jan 2 11:59
ok
ugh, why do we need references for our maker portfolios
that makes 0 sense
i think
it was that way for harvard and mit at least (due on deadline date)
ohhhh.
ok that's interesting, i'm not certain then
if you have it done, send it today to be safe ig
considering columbia is in nyc it would be a bad idea to start my essay about an experience with a rlly clear sky, no?
NYC has clear skies lol
should i fill the wordcount for the lists
the bortle is rlly high
that’s why it might not be a good idea
but i think i can still talk about it especially since there’s observational at columbia
you don’t need to
ok ty
i'd go for it
or maybe if you're not sure, you could reference the skyline? but idk what specifics you're interested in with that
i am interested in dynamics
i think i’m good—i just don’t think columbia has any serious dynamics research
yeah i had a little bit of the same issue tbh, earth sciences
i just referenced some researcher who happened to be there that's well known in the field and added on
i’m into the rlly specific and “boring” niche of orbital dynamics, the only places i’ve really seen which cater heavily to it are mit and princeton 🗿
so i’m going to try to connect back to like
idk i’ll figure something out
i have to revise my why major then start on my why columbia
that’s very cool. i’m hesitant to add this but since they focused so heavily on media and books we’re into i might as well talk add that i started with x textbook in astrophysics that kinda sparked my curiosity
however the author is a princeton professor 💀
which i hammered on in my princeton essays but
eh, you won't have to mention lol
yeah i won’t go into specifics
i forgot weed was legal in NY
wait no i knew that i was there last week and now there’s a smoke shop on every corner
legal age is still 21 😭
mayhaps
i haven’t seen where columbia is but last week i walked literally FROM TIMES SQUARE to NYU’s campus
it’s pretty
we should’ve definitely gone a more direct route tho because we got lost and walked down like 4 different avenues and 40+ blocks ugh
ooh
columbias like a 20 minute drive to times square from what i know lol
yeah unfortunately we took the train to nyc and cab prices are ridiculous
ay idek what u guys like about NYC
ah damn
honestly idk either
probably faster to walk some days
so much traffic in that city
i hate driving there
💀 no columbia is a 4 mile walk
not too bad
NYC terminology "its down the block"
yeah like 80 streets down the block 😭
nah but in ny u dont rlly feel the amount u walk opposed to when you walk in a quiet and big area
dude i’ve still get another supplemental to write for columbia and the why major is like “here’s some field im fascinated with!” columbia doesn’t have it
at least from personal experience cause there's so many ppl and buildings that u just tryna weave in between ppl and before u know it ur where u gotta be

the last part hit home for me
happened with another essay lol
but get off discord u got 2 more hours (if ur est)
omg
Just gotta do that identity essay and I'm done for the day 🙃
Central time at least so I've got a couple hours
🥳 Just submitted my Columbia application!
ay all i want is it to be past january 5th after that all I got is 2 apps left
damn i got 2 due on the 5th, stanford and nyu
probably not gonna do upenn too much work depends on the timing
I got UPenn, Stanford, and UVA for 1/5
Thankfully UVA is pretty lowkey, and stanford i'm just editing my roommate one, gotta start the last one though. upenn, the first one just needs editing, 2/3 need to get started.
bruh im in the same boat for stanford gotta edit the roommate one and start the meaningful essay lol
yeah my roommate one is supposedly very unique but doesn't talk about me enough.
honestly some of these schools ik i probably have such a low chance at cause im test op but im just applying so i can never say i didnt try
thankfully i just wrote a 690 word for harvard that is hyper specific and cute so i'll probably just edit in some parts of stanford with harvad.
true true. i still submitted my scores to every college 😂
even though it's just a 32
for the harvard one i wrote a prompt of my choice talking about how i got interested in the medical field lol
wrote that for a bs/md program so i was like im reusing it im not gonna sit here and write a whole new essay
sure dm me
oh cool
is columbia deadline only extended for chinese students
Yes.
Submitted 🤮
Yikes
not a yikes but cut it very close
was editing my essays
i submitted main commonapp hours ago thankfully
Tomorrow's an easy day for me now... just northwestern is due 😁😍
I dropped yale for Carnegie Melon. Yale is cool but new haven 🤢
fair enough tbh
And for my field (not CS surprisingly) cmu was better
I have a 500 word due tomorrow for babson... sigh
tomorrow i’m going to try my hardest to cram in yale, dartmouth, and jhu
Jfc
so i only have caltech jan 3 😭
Imma try cramming uva, upenn, stanford in the next couple days and submit all before thursday
I did harvard columbia and princeton today and it was my most stressful day so far
ouch
Northwestern tomorrow
massively productive wow
northwestern took me an hour or two
and even then it's "optional"
I had a lot of the essays done but I left the hard ones for today
took me the same haha
The community and diversity shit
ouch
ouch
i’ve had like 10 of those essays written which i just shaped differently for columbia
omg i have rice too
💀
Mit Stanford and Penn on one day is brutal
thankfully most of my stanford stuff is done already
i will die but it’ll be fine
ah i should’ve done mit ea
yup
💀💀💀 my counselor was like “we’ll meet… jan 3 to discuss mit”
I did all that and got my dumb ass deferred

wait i forgot to click submit on my columbia supple
uh oh
Do it now if it's ready
did the deadline pass?
oh ggggg
same 😭😭
yeah i clicked now
You're good dw about the deadline
but deadline was 15 min ago
ok rlly
did they still submit?
ur main app or ur writing??
if they still submitted i think ur fine
The 1.9% acceptance rate for deferred students in RD provides massive copium though
you technically have until midnight hawaii time
like first i only submitted this
then i realized i need to click submit for this
They already have your money so theyre gonna review it
Seriously you're fine
its due at 12 am ur time
okok 🙏
it was a really enjoyable one though tbh
i can’t wait for my ao to judge my music and book tastes
Except the community bs it was pretty good
my community one was good… i think
i think that was my best one 😭😭
i copy pasted another community essay
I think mine turned out okay too. Homeschooling makes a good topic for those questions at least
and just rewrote a bit
all the word counts were so short tho
literally
Can't believe they did 200 words instead of 250
I'm kinda glad for it, but if I had a more expansive topic it would have sucked
300 words is the most optimum word count tbh
I submitted my app common app on time and my supplements 5 minutes late, anything I should do about it
No. 5 minutes is not going to be an issue. Especially because kids in other time zones are still submitting
thanks man
also i don’t believe AOs get to view time stamps
they just download your application overnight
i didn’t even get the portal link i only got the one that said please look for the portal link in ur spam b4 emailing us 💀
;-; lmao
yeah same i just got 10 min ago
i did 10:30pm my time lol
mines the exact same dw
unless they’re trolling us both
prolly working on it, they get like 40-45k applicants lol
Does anyone else portal say waiting application
hopefully a bit less this year cuz of the US news troll 🤡
phew and fairs haha
this is actually somewhat tru, im pretty sure ed numbers dropped from 6400 to like 5700
can we just appreciate how far we've all made it! Im just so happy Im finally applying to colleges and getting the portals. Its a very stressful process but seeing the portal makes me smile
beautiful, isn't it?
Columbia and UNC colors especially
i love uscs portal
like ive been waiting for this moment for the past 2 years
and its finally happening
ill be done in 3 days and it's all out of my hands from there
well except demonstrating interest
Damn look at you submitting applications early
I've submited every single one on the day it was due
time traveler
?
Funny that UT austin and the HK schools don't have icons
and NYU
ohhh ya
remove and readd the bookmarks maaybe?
howd u do this? Links in folders?
It's just a folder of bookmarks
oh damn
lemme see if i can do that on windows lol (that looks like a mac)
ah i can
As long as you didn't apply for CS 😉
i didnt im more of a hardware kind of guy i build pcs from scratch but hate anything that has to do with software
did some java coding before and after that day i never touched coding again
That's fair
if anyone has submitted a portfolio to Columbia does it show up on ur portals?
doesn't show up on my and just want to make sure i haven't done smth wrong
Will I get into Columbia?
Idk legendarywplays
We all hope so
oddly enough the admissions rate is basically the exact same as harvard/stanford
okay
💀
😭
It's actually more competitive than harvard, although that's slightly outdated.
And this year because of Columbia getting exposed for lying a little bit on admissions, I'm guessing that they will be a little nicer this round.
or maybe not.
No
Thanks!
fuckkkkkk
aight, i'm gonna shoot my shot then 
good for u lmao

😂
💀💀💀
that's hilarious
yk all the colleges who contact u through ur SAT
oh well my application literally couldn't have gotten any better so
i guess it's true lmao
and they do that for the next 15 days
LMFAO exactly
case western lmao
🤣
i alr had 3 schools send that to me
columbia following in their footsteps lmao
hopefully cuz they got less apps this year!
lmfao
that's not my screenshot fyi, someone just sent it to the gc 
HAAHH dude these colleges should not be allowing me to procrastinate this hard
i alr did columbia
but aghhh
cornell
yup
have fun 🤣
when’s the deadline for cornell
jan 2, extended to jan 16
they literally said “take this as more time to work on your apps”

thank you cornell, i will!
hahaha
they read ED apps and went like.....eerrrmm we, we gonna give u guys some more time yea?
🙉
corness co 2027 be the worst one frrr
too many peeps applyign
woah wait is this for Cornell?? i wasn’t gonna apply bc the deadline passed but now I will WAIT IS THIS CORNELL SORRY I’M GETTING HYPED
it is cornell!!!!!
i’m hyped too!!
This may be indicative of them receiving far fewer apps the they hoped to bc their “experience circumstances that did not allow for them to complete their application” is so baseless
yayyy >:)
could def be
you think same with cornell?
why else would they extend it 2 weeks
Two weeks is crazy. Has that happened in previous years?
I hope this is true 😭
the application is bugged for Cornell
there's a question that sometimes doesn't appear on the General questions of their application and if u don't answer it, u can't submit ur common app
that combined with the Cornell email ppl being out for winter break probably
idk if it's the same case for Columbia, mine was fine
yea
lol everyone is experiencing the same thing
i've seen it sm on discord and reddit
anyway
if you unselect and reselect everything
and then immediately click "continue" and go back to the previous page
it should work
for me, i unselected everything, clicked on activities, clicked back and there was a new question asking regular decision or ed
and that fixed it
I experienced the same issue and I had to ask the common app people to manually fix it for me
good luck columbia RD people 🙏
I spent so so long on my Columbia essays, I hope that time was worth it 🙏
I spent an hour and a half 😭
hey im tryna do the same with my doc rn but I cant find my Columbia ID number anywhere whered u find it?
it should be on your portal iirc
oh im dumb for some reason it kept loading me into the upload a document instead of the actual portal
let's go
anyone here applying for any of the dual degree programs? if yes, which?
the portal is part of the confirmation email
👀
click the link
Columbia makes you forget your password instead of a pin iirc
ohhhhhhhhh
yeah
gl to all the columbia applicants, hopefully y'all get a better outcome than i did
still very salty abt them rejecting me
Thanks 😊
thank uu
@stable tulip hi, sorry to bother u – I wanted to know how you formatted your list question responses. the instructions seem to indicate a list like
book 1, book 2, book 3, book 4 etc.
but the exemplars online kind of look like
book 1
book 2
book 3
book 4 etc.
I did it the first way (book1, book2, book3) and separated each item with a semicolon cuz some of the titles had commas in them and that was j confusing
The online ones are like examples from previous yrs i think thats why
okay that makes a lot of sense, thanks
I did It the fiest way although how you format the list doesn't really matter
First way. It makes for a super long document if each is a new line.
Columbia
This thread will be used to discuss Columbia University, regardless of the application types (ED1/RD). Feel free to ask your questions or discuss results or anything else about Columbia here.
Columbia University
anyone else's css/fafsa not received
yoo
did y'all give explanations in your list essays?
has anyone gotten interviews yet?
No, you weren't supposed to.
yep that's what i thought
a couple of classmates did give short descriptions tho
so jw
Ouch, bad of them to do that 😂
no and no
They probably just automatically reject anyone who sends in descs for not following directions
lol
when did u submit?
You should get it in a couple days dw
It’ll take a bit longer since you submitted so close to the deadline
When there’s a huge amount of apps coming in for them to process
also check ur spam if u haven't
Sure
a few confirmation emails ended up in my spam lol
And promotions
Can you send me the email address you got the confirmation message from
🤔 I just checked and submitted 11:00 PM EST, Jan 1 and got it on Jan 2 so ... idk
Thanks y'all
@jovial crypt Also double-check that the application is actually submitted. ik a dude who thought he didn't get an email only(not Columbia apps tho) to find that he didn't pay the application fee or smth
Well, Every college picks out some students to just electronically bully..smh
lol u should check out Rutgers, they didn't even pick out some students, they're just bullying everyone
😂
oh goodness
Meanwhile Cornell is indirectly telling applicants to send in more applications
there's a chance it was b/c their common app is bugged
one of the questions doesn't show up all the time, making it impossible to submit
Man NYU is a drag
Ohh
yeaaa don'ttt they're assholes
Yeah I've tried contacting NYU twice and they haven't responded to either of my emails.
Hilary Clinton is gonna be teaching at Columbia!
won’t u be taking her classes as a polsci major
💀
I think shes SIPA grad school, not even sure if she'll be teaching or just honorary
but still cool maybe il see her
oh ic
thats so cool omg
for those who got in ED, is there a class of 27 discord server or some sort of unofficial group chat? the official instagram and facebook group are kinda dead lol
try the zeemee app
pretty active community you just need to show them proof of acceptance to get into the private admitted students chat
otherwise idk
you could always make one tbh
ok i'll try out zeemee
i'm down to make a discord server just want to make sure there isn't already an active pre-existing one
got interview
for anyone who already had the interview, what do they ask
and how conversational is it
Nice!
Unfortunately I did not get an interview so I can’t comment on how it went
do intls get interviews?
nope
hmm i prob shouldnt doxx myself but like
im in nyc so its not really surprising that i got an interview rather quickly
aah okay
makes sense
congrats! gl
did u have to indicate that u wanted an interview anywhere or do they just automatically send interviews to ppl?
They’ll reach out and offer you an interview!
If there’s an AO in your region, I mean haha
i mean im in NJ so hopefully i get that email soon lol
@drifting vigil did u get zeemee
they want acceptance letter
did u blur anything out like columbia id
I did
I don't remember exactly what I sent but I just took a picture of my enrollment confirmation which had my name (didn't censor anything)
ok
is it dead or am i just not in the right channel LMAO
it's kinda dead lol I'm in the Class of 2027 chat (for committed students), Find a Roommate, Class of 2027 Admits, and General
ok yeah same
Same here!
the grammar is wrong “you’re book” 😭
Have any of you heard from interviewers yet?
I didn't get an interview, don't worry if you don't get one. All down to availability
yes
wait did anyone get their portal yet?
i got an email about my portal with no indication of a password
you need to password reset it
no interview here
no interview as well
samee
nope
its fine guys
Haven’t checked
me neither
most of the admitted students here I’ve seen didn’t get interviews lol and many who did got rejected. really starting to think it holds almost zero weight
^ this lol
interviews are pretty much 100% based on interviewer availability
if they actually look over applications to determine who gets an interview they would not be sending interview invitations out this early
yea
they do have an effect, but theyre based on availability
scroll to bottom
Oh yes I looked at that doc and was like, "oh my"
yes im sure they do lol but im saying it feels like they arent meaningful
well the best analogyI've heard is linking interviews to caltech optional supps
it wont matter if you dont have any but if you do'em its a nice outlet for your personality, which does make an effect
I had an interview with a small liberal arts college yesterday and I've realized how FUN interviews can be as long as you make them that way.
If I have an interview with a more competitive college, my goal is to just be myself and to enjoy the experience. Because that authenticity will really come to show.
Of course providing good answers are great but at the end of the day it's about just being me.
Having social anxiety obv doesn't help but thankfully interviews are supposedly lowk
Is Columbia easy to get into if you are as smart as Elon Musk?
Being smart doesn't mean you have good character ✨
Probably
Assuming you did something similar with it
the question is how smart do you consider Elon Musk to be
If by smart you mean family money then yes
has anyone not gotten a portal?
are columbia interviews offered by availability or “we need more info”?
generally as with all T10s, should be availability
for int’ls it used to be semi-selective and might still be for many schools, but anecdotally since covid there’s way less alumni interviewers volunteering so not getting one isn’t a death sentence necessarily
source: had friends in previous admissions cycle get into Stanford without an interview as int’ls
this is the most absolutely colossally fucking stupid thing I've read
"yoyo here's two literally perfect students with insane ECs, one got great essays and one has a mediocre essay rite guys rite guys" "OH NO JOHN DOESN'T WANT TO BANG HIS MAJOR???? NOOOOO REJECT REJECT, WAIT IT MIGHT BE BECAUSE HE'S SOCIALLY AWKWARD??? NERD ALERT GET THAT BRO ON THE REJECT TRAIN RN" "MEGAN THO, GUYS SHE CAN SPEAK LIKE A 30YO GET HER IN RN"
fuck this process bro
like its way better than the intl system where a minute point diff on a standardized test cucks u out of 99% of unis but still
cries in UCAS
NAH I WANT THE SWEATSHIRT
that too bruh
thoughts on predictions
they've been 100% right so far
in state Cali
also these are ballsy asl if not obv
gently, you're wrong
ye i applied very very last minute
like day b4 due
was like
wait
GA has only 1 supp?
yea lemme apply
... john had worse essays the interview just reinforced committee view that megan was better
its not about being socially awkward either it was just john gave bad answers
you need to be good at these things to succeed anyways
the issue is that the interviewer mainly commented, “he failed to convince me he believed those answers,” which could be unlucky. I mean these revelations would otherwise be missed if he never did the interview at all, in which his interview had a negative impact
lowk
we could avoid all these issues by forcing ivies to make new campuses and take more people
they have the funds
most?
job interviews are like this too
internship interviews as well
i think its fair
i think all students should be required to interview
^
That’s what job interviews are
If it wants to comparable to job interviews, it should be a requirement
like gtown
naaah
i can say about tech internship interview
its totally different
i meant politics at least
yeah, politics is all about communicating with others
so it makes sense
They just give an example
Anyone else not receive their portal yet
anyone else did the research supplement for columbia?
i did
Yes
I did!
did columbia give out portals yeet
Haven't gotten mine yet
i got mine jan 2
i got mine like the day after the deadline
got mine 3? days? after
Has anyone heard about interviews yet?
havent even gotten my portal yet
anyone would like to have columbia's css profile fee waiver
i already paid the fees
so i don't need it
that wld be awesome😭😭
u want it?
yes pls
dm
did any of u guys get the columbia portal yet lmao
yes, they shouldve sent an email with a link in it to these instructions
the reset password page that is hyperlinked:
https://apply.college.columbia.edu/account/reset?r=/apply/status
Anyone got interviews?
nope
u didn't get interview?
nope
ohhhh
its based on availability anyways so
dont worr if you dont get one
idt thats allowed here and also there is no
yeah
decisions arent uploaded until the day of
there is one
but nvm
lets not discuss that
no, finaid isnt representative of anything
If I have a recent achievement which is def worth mentioning
where on portal do i upload it? like the supplementary section would be an obvious choice but like
its not descriptive enough to make a document out of, its literally just 2 lines saying I recently qualified for xyz
mail them
they will add that mail
to ur app
i just got an interview hell yeah
yall i need advice
so basically i got my interview email right
i responded saying i could work around their schedule, and they sent me a few timeslots, of which i picked wednesday
also inquired what platform we'd be using
this was back on sunday morning btw, the morning after their response
they never responded
should i send a follow up? since the interview is tomorrow...
u should mail them
asking for the link
Has anyone gotten interview
nah I havent gotten any interviews yet 🥹
i dont think the interview matters much for columbia
i know intls who got in ED w/o interview
or maybe it matters just for domestics? no idea
i think someone here made a nice analogy where it’s comparable to optional essays. Your application is still complete without it and you can definitely get in, but it’s an opportunity to showcase more of your person—which can end up helping. However, they can end up hurting your app based on the training slides
^^^
i think that’s such a concise way to put it
i’m mentally upvoting you or whatever it is the kids say now
idt they actually hurt in the training slides: more like the essays were mid so he wouldn't get admitted, and the interview didnt push him to admit. it had little to no effect
at least seems more likely given what everyone incl aos have said about interviews rarely being negative unless you fucked up badly
yeah I feel like unless the interviewer really hated you the interview can't really negatively impact your application
fr, although if you dont get interviews it feels a lil unfair...almost as if everyone else is getting an additional essay on CA which you really wanna do but can't cuz no one in you neighborhood went to that school
Exactly
If so many interviews for domestic are virtual, they could just roll out virtual interviews for intls too
Well they added a negative which I would say hurt him. Otherwise he may have been deferred or not so clearly rejected. But also take the case if someone has a great app but is very shy in interviews. Then their report would prob hurt them with similar comments that their app otherwise wouldn’t have had
Now it’s true that those interview skills are eventually necessary for success, but their app wouldn’t have revealed that otherwise
I don’t think that’s what hurt him
he had weak essays
this was just reaffirmation that he isn’t the best in person either
yeah it was more of a-> yeah his interview didnt give us a reason to admit him and he was headed to reject anyways
i was gonna email them this morning
but then
they responded at 1am in the morning
asking to reschedule an hour earlier
so i have 2.5 hours left to mentally prepare
That’s hurting him lol
Take my other scenario
idt thats how it would work
interviewers and aos have said that interviews cannot hurt unless you fuck it up really badly
like
kiss interviewer shit
that clashes with the training slides
at least of someone got a bad report
hard to think that wouldn’t hurt
idt you understand, im saying that the training slides never said the interview hurt, it just reaffirmed/didnt change the reject decision that woulda came regardless- a stellar interview might have pushed him to waitlist/accept
im not sure why you’re so focused on that one scenario lol. hurting an application doesn’t mean changing the entire outcome of the decision. In the other case I mentioned whats wrong with the scenario
.
im not saying it made him go from accept/defer -> reject
Bc that would be too much weight ofc
if someone is shy and has a great app, if they would have been accepted without interview, interview wont drag them down, if they woulda been waitlisted or rejected there would be no benefit
at least from what aos including columbia's have said
if someone is shy but has a great app and they get a report like John’s, that could certainly hurt their app, right?
not from what i've heard
I really find that hard to believe and I think that’s really fair lol, regardless of general “interview won’t hurt you” statements. I mean John’s report was harsh and would naturally not make you want to admit someone like that if you read it
cause you can’t really unsee or forget it
- interviewer could be a lot older than john
- could have have completely different interests / majors
- could have overall just been really stingy
^^^
Remember to read what the rating was
Rec WITH reservation
outlining weakpoints as things that without a doubt can be attributed to shyness or general anxiety/nervousness when answering questions(also I personally think its idiotic to have an intricate idea of exactly why you want to study a major, it makes sense for a solid 0 majors, i don't mean just wanting to do a major or having a weak reason is okay but needing a whole life story and global impact as reasoning is plain stupid)
like I want to do CS and Finance/biz bc I ran my own company and like coding, there's not much more to it, but I need to turn it into something its not
the thing is, most people will be rec with reservation, thats why a stellar interview will be a + on your app but otherwise it has no effect
thats true
yeah running your own company would be a good reason
the report makes it seem like john didnt really have any reasoning
which makes all the more sad if he did
well again i still think it wasnt a negative on the app
but even if it was, its fair
Without strict guidelines, I could totally see someone giving higher ratings on average then another person. But even if there are really strict guidelines, idk if everyone’s report will be as specific as “failed to convince me that…”
the thing is, aos and interviewers recognize that this is most likely someone's first time interviewing
most people will not get a perfect rating on the interview, what seems negative to you is probably the norm for interview reviews
it doesnt matter if there are guidelines or not because it wont harm the applicant at all
I’m not arguing that being able to talk well is not a desirable skill and that it shouldn’t be preferable in college admissions, but I’m saying that in the interest of an applicant, a stellar app not having an interview can avoid revealing weaknesses that the interview would show. I.e. i could not care less about the college, im referring to the interest of an applicant
and im saying that the weaknesses that the interview would show is prevalent in almost every applicant or is expected, and as such, there will be no negative effect
well i guess that’s another part I would want to be confirmed. You’re right that I thought John’s report was negative, but it would be nice to see what the majority of reports are like
im not sure about that either. I think the majority of interviews will go fine with students
there was an interview with columbia ao that basically said this
a few other t20 aos/alumni interviewers on a2c too
again from what ive seen "fine" is John's interview
stellar is the other persons
it’s hard to believe that the last sentence of John’s report is common. Like with essays, wording matters and can give off different impressions
Which could also vary with interview, as icy pointed out. I wager that if someone else interviewed John, the report could certainly appear different
but this is basically the admissions process
your app could have gotten a different report if you had a different ao for example
Yes you’re right absolutely. The interview is just another part of rolling the dice
and interview has less weight than other components
in cds
overall idt its as bad as ram says
Which you could understand might not be preferable to certain applicants

it’s a lottery in that sense
eh
id support mandatory interviews
like gtown
and make them have more weight
Yea sure, I’d support that too
but have a standardized rubric or at least have standardized something hold majority weight in the interview
Then everyone would roll the dice multiple times
well idt its rolling the dice
imo the best leaders are able to adapt to social situations
would be hard to do so but giving a rubric which the interviewers score with can help
gauge the interviewer and know what to say from there
you could still just totally not click with your interviewer
Who cares about this best leader stuff. As I said i don’t care about the colleges, im talking about the applicant
for me w/ harvard my interviewer was super into material physics and i knew 0 about it
And in helping an applicant who is not gonna present well in a live interview
he kept using jargon to get me to talk about it and i couldn’t play into it but talked about the field i’m interested in
well just as how the strongest applicant is the one with best grades, best essays, i believe a strong applicant has to be a good leader/perform well in social settings
it’s hard to connect to someone w/ a phd and sound like you’re brilliant
this is true
just like how some people dont write essays well and are automatically disadvantaged in the process even if they may be incredibly smart
Sure I agree
So someone who is not great in that should not want an interview to reveal that part of them
Yea… they feel obligated too
unless you say something wild
because of the current interview system
so as long as you don’t do so you can literally just sit down at a screen for an hour and research the bare minimum then go on a tangent and you’ll be fine
Just how we’re very meticulous to edit our apps to present ourselves in the best light possible
my columbia interview was great
interviewer was super chill
felt very natural
stuff he asked me was like general introduction, why columbia, if there was a book that you'd show everyone, something you wouldnt include about yourself in a resume, what you want ppl to say about you when you leave the room
and there was a more specific question that was region based bc he wanted to ask that to know more about me (we are from the same city)
Those are odd questions compared to what I've had with other colleges lol
Nice job though !
the odd questions stuck out more to me
there were definitely more generic questions
i said into the wild by jon krakauer!
he had also read it
and recommended me another book by the same author
i mean worst case scenario you can just pull from that list of books from the application
Oh rightttt they totally don't see that
even if they do see it, it doesn't matter, since maybe the book just stood out to you
if there was a book that i really really loved + read outside of class, id definitely go ahead and say it
just so happens that the book i chose was smth i read in school
my interviewer didn’t ask me any of that lol. I was prepared too 😭
She basically just asked Why Columbia and what I did. Super generic
rip :(
hopefully the preparedness made the responses rly strong tho
this was for ED btw. I got deferred so who knows 🤷♂️
But I definitely didn’t feel great about it like others
dang what are you guys saying for what book?
i dont think there's much point in sharing our book lists
it's supposed to be what you enjoyed reading during your education
ik im just curious on what you guys were reading
im not trynna copy your answer or anyhting
a bunch of scifi basically
had a bunch of sci-fi, creative nonfic, generic ya novels
multiple whole sci-fi series 💀
i picked some sci-fi and classic lit ^.^ i feel like that covers my interests pretty well
and also ofc the secret history i am a teenage girl
i put Elephant & Piggie Like Reading!: We Are Growing!
where you live?
i mean i'd mention the area or locality
but don't give ur address or smthng 💀
alternatively you can even suggest a meeting spot like a starbucks
they already know
they cant
okkk
oh no no
i wasnt saying that, i was tryna say it'd simply cause tons of book titles to flood the chat
i drilled down my top 3 interests
i followed the sequence
- astrophy book
- comedy book
- cooking book
- astrophy book
- comedy....
damn
nice
Mine was just kinda random ig
Except some books about econ there wasn’t a specific trend
all related to history and politics?
or somethin else even
nah had some music some econ, math, fiction
wait lemme check how many books did i list
17 books
holy shit
ur still awake
😭
Yes of course
Most interviews don’t need to be completed until like mid to late February
Does Columbia give interviews for internationals from Canada?
I just received a confirmation for financial stuff
They want me to confirm to them that I’m not applying for aid 😝
Yeah lol, coping hard cuz cousin went there, rlly wanna go 
Oh lmao
They send that to everyone
ik lol
cuz not a lot of people from Canada apply to Columbia
There are only a very few each year
really? naviance said around 15 in my school applied, out of 115 ish
Rlly?
One thing for sure I know is some people didnt apply cuz it has a ton of essays, expensive, and is not very good with aid to intls
Most people here apply with aid so
😨
columbia is pretty good for intl aid
not as good as pton and harvard for sure but
still up there
rlly? I have personally heard the exact opposite...

