Remove the guild name and IGN of player that is not within your own guild

[maiden cape]

Replace it with "ENEMY GUILD" (red name) to also remove the ally system and let the guild siege be "GUILD SIEGE" not ALLIANCE SIEGE
suggested by @granite onyx

[humble basin]

SEA brings in too much money for this recommendation to even be contemplated on.

[wind palm]

While this would make alliances more difficult (not impossible, you can coordinate uniforms/outfits/glows or w.e)...

Some issues that immediately present themselves:

• You can no longer tell who is in first in order to prioritize them.
• You can't tell two groups apart who are fighting each other, and who of those two groups you might prefer to kill over another.

[young kernel]

From playing in SEA, I know how tryhard and dirty ppl play here. This change would not be enough.

They would need to set everyone to the same costume (weapons and shield included) and hide all pets too else you’ll see the same thing and ppl focusing x guild still.

Even then one team will still say hey we will take control of this tower and you take control of the one next to us and we dont fight each other. And yes ppl will do that in SEA. Ppl would still coordinate because thats just how dirty ppl play siege.

[young kernel]

Edit: Actually nvm read my next message below on why this can't happen >.<

[dawn karma]

I agree on changes, has to be drastically to have impact. Has to be more than just “enemy guild”. Ally could still wear same colour fashion.

[young kernel]

I just thought of it and there is a HUGE problem with this. If one guild decides to feed (have another guild purposely suicide into them to get points). No one will know WHO IS FEEDING. They can bring a dummy guild and have multiple knights + merkaba kill it at spawn. This will happen sadly and don't say it won't because we all know the history 🤣

They can also say "hey everyone at last 5 minutes of siege, all come to tower 4 and die to our aoe" and there would be no way to counter it. Memes

[dawn karma]

Smart boy, unless portal spawning is random. Big changes is needed

[wind palm]

Yeah, there's not really a systemic way to prevent people from teaming up. As long as people can communicate and plan, they will, and there's nothing that can be done to stop them.

[young kernel]

Yeah unfortunately this would not be "Guild Siege". It would be "Feed Siege".

[dawn scaffold]

Removing/Hiding IGN? Howw* am I supposed to know who the biggest threat is? Guess by fashion and glow?

Hell nah, please no

[torpid crane]

The whole system is Bad designed and hiding the Name might make teaming harder, but in the end just way more inconvenient for the regular Team to propperly shotcall. This is a bad take

[celest crown]

Also u wouldn’t be able to prio a player who reaches a rampage status which can give up to 5 points

Not sure if this is the right place to make a suggestion here but a much better adjustment would be if the first ranked guildwar players give +1 extra points if killed or also like if your guild is ranked first you get +1 extra points by killing and +2 extra points for the enemy if you get killed by enemy

this would make guildwar much more dynamic and harder to snowball on all servers wether there are alliances or not

Since there is a thread going on about that ringmaster should get assist points for applying hc/moonbeam Someone might make a nicely constructed Suggestion ? 😋 the devs might look into it because assist points are already a big change for the scoring system