#‼-story-spoilers-‼

1 messages · Page 17 of 1

deep cypress
#

It’s OK!

Typing on an iPad is infinitely easier than trying to type in a keyboard, but I still often press the wrong letter (my depth perception isn’t great anymore haha) by pressing a neighbouring letter by accident and Autocirrect is just not even trying to help lol

sturdy void
#

Me neither. It's perfectly fine to be uncomfortable about being a woman sometimes.

placid wyvern
#

Thanks 😊 @sturdy void

agile mantle
#

Everett Clopton or Eric Clapton

sour pendant
#

What am I saying? Who cares who he is? Him. I pick him.

placid wyvern
#

I pick Everdeen Cramia(no this isn't a real person,yes this is a name I made up on the spot)

ionic haven
placid wyvern
#

😰

#

That's a one way ticket to Azkaban

ionic haven
#

🙂

placid wyvern
#

What about Hobhouse..

umbral fog
#

Omg just finished the main story…

#

I am so behind in power so I had to defeat ||ranrok|| so my basic attacks were doing 15 damage each 😭

#

I ||died about 9 times and got lucky on my last try||

#

I’m gonna try to unlock the house chest biw

placid wyvern
#

Power?

#

You didn't upgrade gear?Use Potions?Plants?

#

Traits?Maybe lvl up to the recommended lvl?

umbral fog
#

I did upgrade gear and everything but idk why I barely did damage

#

Also I was on the recommended level

placid wyvern
#

Huh,what about your other spells?

sturdy void
sour pendant
sour pendant
#

There's a theory that Marvolo could be Ominis' older brother. If so, I think Ominis got off lightly with the blindness.

mental pilot
#

To Salazar he would be perfect for speaking to the basilisk. No need to avoid the eyes if you’re blind.

sour pendant
#

Why just Ominis?

#

I think his blindness has to do with his inbreeding, not with being an heir of Slytherin.

mental pilot
#

I’m not saying it was on purpose, just joking that it would be convenient

sour pendant
#

Ah. Yeah, true. That's an interesting question, though---does the basilisk choose to kill you by looking at it; could Tom Riddle look straight into its eyes and be fine? Or is it just something that it does without conscious decision?

mental pilot
#

That’s a good question.

deep cypress
deep cypress
# sour pendant I think his blindness has to do with his inbreeding, not with being an heir of S...

Personally I think it’s maybe a curse of some sort, considering they’ve tried all kinds of potions and cures to fi it and he he’s entirely missing pupils (which explains how he’s blind as there’s no hole for the light to enter his eyes) which isn’t a condition that exists. It seems more magical imo.

Maybe he was cursed in utero or some potion or poison was ingested by his mother and that was the result.

sturdy void
sour pendant
runic tundra
sturdy void
#

I'll say it again: Poor Ominis.

#

Does he have any family left?

#

I mean, any nice family members?

#

He would have been taken care of way better by his aunt Noctua.

sour pendant
mental pilot
#

He has us now.

sour pendant
placid wyvern
#

No better family than friends who actually do care about how you feel unlike a few certain others

ionic haven
# mental pilot He has us now.

I'd like to think he has connections to keep him afloat. Though I'm in the minority since I kept my own MC's relationship with him largely negative and only develops into "tolerating each other" at best.

Though for narrative reasons, they'd never be friends because I felt like neither my MC nor him have any meaningful interaction chemistry I could develop. So I compensated with giving him connections to keep him afloat.

sturdy void
#

I'm gonna do the quest with Poppy next time I play.

#

Time to take down some poachers. 👊🏻

sturdy void
#

I'm having so much fun as Professor Black.

#

Polyjuice Potion 🤭

sour pendant
#

I just wish we could impersonate him longer. And-or other people.

sturdy void
#

Garreth was so scared.

#

"But, sir, I wasn't even near Honeydukes!"

sour pendant
sturdy void
#

I wonder if I could free his house elf. 🤭

#

That would be suspicious.

sour pendant
#

Waaaaay suspicious.

sturdy void
#

I'm doing Niamh's trial.

hushed bramble
#

Basically I saved in the middle which you shouldn’t do ig

sturdy void
#

That troll is a b****.

sturdy void
hushed bramble
#

I had

#

But I was just stuck for around an hour before asking here

sturdy void
#

I don't think Niamh can be saved. She's dead.

hushed bramble
#

Yup

deep cypress
sour pendant
#

Very, very dead.

sturdy void
#

When my MC says she hasn't heard from Lodgok in a while...

#

crack Oh, that was just my heart. 💔

sturdy void
#

Poppy is so unhinged. "I wonder if you could go blind from looking directly at moonstone..." 🤣🤣

sturdy void
#

Poppy's parents don't deserve her anyway.

placid wyvern
queen canyon
#

The Tobbs storyline broke me.

Although the spiders freaked me out. It was a storyline mixed with emotions. I love it

sour pendant
ionic haven
sour pendant
placid wyvern
sour pendant
sturdy void
#

"Dear Poppy's parents, I hope you get unalived by the spiders." 😘

sour pendant
sturdy void
#

The Hufflepuff who tells people nicely to go touch grass

sour pendant
sturdy void
#

angelic smile "Avada..."

gentle dome
#

I’m a hugflepuff and I just.. AVADA…

#

I might need a house re evaluation

#

Lmaoo

#

But I don’t wanna start all over again 😭😭😭

sour pendant
#

You don't need a house re-evaluation. There's nothing particularly anti-Dark Arts about patience, dedication, and loyalty.

#

@gentle dome

gentle dome
#

Yeah

#

I was thinking having the patience to talk instaead of just killing them

#

I just kill them

#

Sometimes

#

Depends on my mood and their vibe Yk

sour pendant
#

@gentle dome True. But one can also have the patience to draw out their enemy's death and make it nice and agonizing. 👀

gentle dome
#

Indeed

#

I usually feel bad tho, bud tgem poachers…

#

They another story

sour pendant
#

accidentally Bombardas poacher off a cliff Whoops.

gentle dome
#

I’m like saying avada… back n fourth

#

Lmaoo

#

I love that

#

I kill every poacher I see

#

Take my thestral for a stroll from Hogwarts around feldcroxt, and back to the train station, past hogs made and back to Hogwarts all on hoof

#

And kill every poacher

sour pendant
#

How do you get the thestral mount?

gentle dome
#

Dark arts

sour pendant
#

Oh, shoot, my PS4 version isn't deluxe, I don't think... Oh well.

gentle dome
#

I don’t think I have deluxe either

#

I just have dark arts or whatever

#

I don’t have the onyx hippogriff

sour pendant
gentle dome
#

Oh maybe I did

#

Maybe I like bought it instead of paying my phone bill for a month lol

#

Idk

sour pendant
#

😂

gentle dome
#

I was like NEED IT

sour pendant
#

Worth it.

gentle dome
#

Fr

#

I love thestrals so much

#

I also love the big water beast too

#

I love him!! He lives with my phoniex

sour pendant
#

Big water beast... Dugbog?

gentle dome
#

No the ones with The tenticals

#

The king of the shore

#

Or something

sour pendant
#

Oh, the graphorn. I don't think of it as a water beast. Can it swim?

gentle dome
#

Oh idk

#

Can you capture mongrels

#

Sounds like a bad idea but just curious

sour pendant
#

Non-magical animals are animals too, WB!

#

Y'know, it's kinda weird to go into all these little agrarian communities and not see a single horse. owo

gentle dome
#

Yeah

#

Where are the horses

sour pendant
#

Where are the horses, WB??? We know you did something with them!

gentle dome
#

Maybe they’re Mongolian wild horses and they took them all

#

(Can’t spell it lol

gentle dome
#

For safekeeping

#

Away from victor rookwood n stuff

#

Idk it had a swear word in the irl oops

#

The gif from discord

sour pendant
#

I know. :3

gentle dome
#

I didn’t wanna gets in trouble lol

sturdy void
#

Nooooo, Lodgok!!!! 😭😭😭😭

#

They're brothers.

#

BROTHERS.

sour pendant
#

just realized we've never seen a female centaur OR a female goblin

sturdy void
#

Yeah.

#

They would look gorgeous.

placid wyvern
sturdy void
#

Fighting brothers? That seems to be a recurring theme: Sirius and Regulus, Aberforth and Albus...

sturdy void
placid wyvern
sturdy void
#

I don't know, but I feel like we should.

placid wyvern
#

Yeah, better late than never

deep cypress
sour pendant
sturdy void
#

Oh yeah.

sour pendant
sturdy void
#

Percy and the entirety of his family, tbh

sour pendant
sturdy void
sour pendant
sturdy void
#

You can try and put it through an AI art app.

sour pendant
deep cypress
sour pendant
deep cypress
sour pendant
hushed bramble
#

I did a side quest with sirona later in the game (After lodgok died) and she asked me how he was doing 😭

fallen saddle
#

That’s so sad omg

sturdy void
#

I hate fighting Solomon with a burning passion.

#

I can't get past him.

#

I do so well and then I die.

fallen saddle
placid wyvern
sturdy void
#

Update: I was so angry that I actually defeated him.

sour pendant
sturdy void
#

I was angry because I couldn't defeat him at first.

#

And I decided not to turn Sebastian in.

sour pendant
sour pendant
sour pendant
#

The Jackdaw quest is the only thing that differs from house to house, right?

#

Storywise?

ionic haven
#

Yes

sour pendant
#

All right, so...no real reason to go through the game with all four houses then.

ionic haven
#

If you want the achievement you can just play up to that point

placid wyvern
placid wyvern
sturdy void
#

Poor Anne. I mean Anne Thisbe. The one who broke Richard Jackdaw's heart and ended up in Azkaban. She went mad.

TW ||Azkaban is abuse. That's not how a prison should work.||

low mauve
#

Indeed

#

Which is why ||turning Sebastian in|| is the worst possible choice

placid wyvern
sturdy void
#

Is the Jackdaw quest different for every house?

low mauve
#

Yes

sturdy void
#

I just realized it is. I'm playing on my Slytherin save file.
I wonder how Scrope lost his ear.

low mauve
#

He explains it to you if you ask

sturdy void
#

Hold on a second: Jackdaw was with Anne, but he was trying to impress Apollonia at the same time? What a player. 🤔

deep cypress
sturdy void
#

That makes sense.

#

That little girl in the memory was Isidora, right?
We see her with her father and brother when the Keepers restore their village after the drought.

sturdy void
#

Isidora's brother was sick. And Anne is sick too. That's a heartbreaking parallel. 💔

fallen saddle
#

Is thia just for main story or side story?

stable vine
#

Tho he did kinda commit yk

#

Stabby stabby

urban violet
#

I am a big Seb simp. He's morally grey as a character and I like that. Makes him interesting.

placid wyvern
stable vine
urban violet
#

Omg-

sour pendant
stable vine
#

No but the same content

vernal grove
#

Should I turn Seb in to Azkaban? On one hand I’m literally in love with him and he did the right thing, on the other hand he literally did something that’s forbidden no matter the circumstances

vernal grove
# sour pendant NO.

All my friends are telling me to but I literally fell in love with the dude from day 1 and I’ve used forbidden spells too

#

They’re like “he’s dating Ominis not you” but still

low mauve
#

Azkaban is cruel for anyone, especially a kid

vernal grove
sour pendant
next canyon
#

dont do it, dont question ur morality

#

remember, you'd do the same to npcs!

mental pilot
#

Almost no one deserves Azkaban.

#

The killing curse is more lenient than Azkaban.

earnest ingot
#

I could never bring myself to send him to azkaban

earnest ingot
fallen saddle
#

So What did you guys do with the painting I put it in the hogs head.

#

I mean if he was just tattling I would let it slide but making stuff up just to get people in trouble is where I draw the line.

fallen saddle
#

Now burning it was a bit too much I honestly believe putting him in the hogs head for a while will at least ensure the next time he does squeal its the truth.

fallen saddle
sour pendant
#

How can you say that?! Didn't I just say I burned the portrait?? Of course I'm a Hufflepuff!

fallen saddle
sour pendant
#

Bah, it's not like I killed him, he has another portrait.

#

Maybe this will teach him to treat people with a little respect.

#

Lest he wants me to break into the library in the middle of the night and "accidentally" get too close to it with a candle.

fallen saddle
#

For example if you set a giant spider on fire and watch it run around screaming in pain and you have the urge to make that one emperor's new groove meme ...

sour pendant
#

Which meme?

fallen saddle
#

The just right meme.

sour pendant
#

Ah, lol.

fallen saddle
#

Also I am curious what you all decided to do with the repository.

sour pendant
fallen saddle
#

I chose to open it ...near the beginning of the game Professor Fig said "Magic is but a tool, it depends on how it is used" or somthing like that and I agree. Such power should instead be studied to see if there is a proper way for it to be used.

mental pilot
#

I put the portrait back in the 3 broomsticks. My mc doesn’t hang out there and those kids deserve punishment for getting someone to steal the painting. They could have talked to the owner of the 3 broomsticks about its lies, rather involving criminals.

fallen saddle
#

ALSO LBH the keepers seem like kind of hipocrytes.

fallen saddle
#

"The magic isadora used is bad no wizard should use it no matter what the case is." Yea may I remind you what spell one of your own used to STOP Isadora.

#

If your going to choose a hill and die on it I better find your corpse there when the dust clears.

deep cypress
sour pendant
deep cypress
sour pendant
deep cypress
sour pendant
deep cypress
sour pendant
#

Huh. Interesting. Wonder why 1717...

ionic haven
#

There's likely no lore explanation for a specific date but let's say something in 1717 happened which likely skyrocketed the crime rate (Murder specifically) where wizards and witches were abusing them left and right.

#

Like let's say there's disagreements in the Ministry where some officials were having petty disputes which escalated that resulted in several people dead

#

But that's just my theory on it

deep cypress
#

Plus moralities change and new laws are put into effect.

It used to be that you could be hung just for stealing a horse

But then as tines and ethics changed, only the most heinous crimes earned the death penalty.

Now there’s no death penalty in the UK, it’s life in prison.

Times change and so laws and ethics do too.

runic tundra
fallen saddle
ionic haven
#

The reason why the Keepers were against her because she kept using it against students

#

It's like a teacher force feeding you drugs as a child because she said it was "good" for you

#

Then you grow up as an adult with lasting side effects on your body since the teacher jacked it up against your knowledge just to use you as a live lab rat

fallen saddle
sour pendant
#

nod I would've liked to try healing Anne with our ancient magic...

fallen saddle
ionic haven
#

But Isidora never really healed him

#

He became a living vegetable

sour pendant
#

Because she took it too far.

ionic haven
#

Devoid of thoughts and feelings

#

Then she moved to targeting her students

fallen saddle
ionic haven
#

Which is why I considered that she did not do the right thing at all

#

She just wanted to play god and assumed everyone would benefit from her methods of "healing"

sour pendant
#

But Anne very well could've benefitted. It was worth a shot, at least.

ionic haven
#

Not sure if the methods would be compatible

#

Since her ailment was induced through a curse

sour pendant
#

Still causes her pain.

ionic haven
#

I felt like it could have side effects

fallen saddle
ionic haven
#

Not Ancient Magic actually

#

It's one that Rookwood made himself

#

And Victor Rookwood had no affinity for Ancient Magic

fallen saddle
#

And your telling me that every goblin we faced did?

ionic haven
#

No they used something else

#

But Rookwood did not have the means to use it

#

But he was indeed the caster for it

sour pendant
#

Yeah, Anne wasn't cursed with ancient magic, but she still might have been able to be healed by it. shrug Who knows?

ionic haven
#

His line of dialogue in the encounter with the MC does imply that he was envious that some random had it

#

But the descendant of Charles Rookwood didn't

ionic haven
sour pendant
ionic haven
#

Like her method involved extracting pain. So I felt that if we used it

#

We have to take it on

#

I was originally going to write that my MC dies from using that method since it's an equivalent exchange to heal one but transfer the curse to the other

sour pendant
#

No, we'd just need somewhere to put it. Which would lead us to the same predicament Isadora found herself in... but Anne is literally dying here....

ionic haven
#

I don't believe in the method not having any sort of side effects

#

So which is why I wouldn't mind killing off my own protagonist for it

fallen saddle
#

No what happened was when ranrock and his goblins opened the repository under rookwood manor Ranrock took the lions share for himself and his goblin giving them the power they needed to hold their own that is where the loyalists got their power from that seems very likely he gave some to rookwood and a select few ashwinders/poachers to secure their continued assistance as we see the same red smoky aura on some of them this same aura is seen on some of the spiders/mongrels so either some leaked out and affected them or their contamination had somthing to do with the poachers.

ionic haven
#

Mongols? You mean Mongrels?

#

Because I didn't know Genghis Khan was in the game

fallen saddle
#

Sorry I meant Mongrels.

ionic haven
#

Though that bit isn't in the game in the story itself. Rookwood mentioned that he had no way of using Ancient Magic

#

The Loyalists all had to use to a device to manifest it

#

Ranrok had a gauntlet to let him use the powers from the Repository

#

Many Loyalists also have the same type of equipment

#

I think they likely engineered an equipment to enhance themselves with Isidora's corrupted stores of Ancient Magic energy

#

But the Ashwinders themselves don't use it based on gameplay

#

They used standard spells and curses

fallen saddle
#

All we know is that Rookwood was the one who applied the curse to Anne and during that time Ranrock and Rookwood were working together what he used to create that curse is not told. For all we know he had a vial of the stuff he gathered form the repository and decided to see what would happen if a Cruico spell is fired at a target through it.

sour pendant
#

We have no evidence to back that theory up, however.

fallen saddle
#

We have no evidence it was not and considering the symptoms of the curse IDK why Sebastian was still carrying on with the relic after he saw what Isadora did ...if I were him I would have banked everything on the ancient magic route.

sour pendant
#

If we have no evidence that it could be ancient magic, then we can assume it wasn't.

ionic haven
#

But Rookwood's curse could be like Ginny's self made spell

#

The Bat Bogey Hex

#

If Ginny can craft a spell as a child that does have some nasty side effects even if not fatal

#

Then Dark Wizards like Rookwood likely have far more advanced curses beyond the Unforgiveables

fallen saddle
#

Even so the ancient magic route was probably the best option....and it proved the original argument using the ancient magic to remove lets say the pain of a traumatic event or the result of a curse is not a bad thing. It is when it is used to lets say extract all of someones emotions turning them into a zombie due to some misguided belief that all emotions cause pain that is when it goes too far.

runic tundra
#

The other issue is she's meddling with emotions which are connected to the soul in the HP verse and doing any magic that meddles with the soul is one that risks perilous consequences for the person doing it or to those they use it on.

#

There's also a question of how many times she used that spell on her dad. Like did he go veggie after one use or many. Cos she had no reason to do that to him again after the first time. Unless the effect is only temp.

#

Also after the first time, did he no longer have the ability to feel any form of negative emotion or any emotion regarding his son's death when it came to his mind?

sour pendant
#

I think it was implied that she used it a lot...

runic tundra
#

Like there's an ethical issue in it regardless of her intial intent

ionic haven
#

Many times

ionic haven
#

Since as her father became a living vegetable

#

She used her own students as a new source

runic tundra
#

Yah that came later

ionic haven
#

Many of which are First Years since they'd be easier to exploit

#

I don't like Isidora mostly because she was using 11 year olds as her live guinea pigs

runic tundra
#

Yah it seems clear the magic isn't meant to used that way to me

#

Like the original use even corrupted the magic

#

so regardless of intent, the magic isn't able to be used as she used it without a dark side effect

#

It corrupts the magic which in turn if absorbed corrupts the person who absorbed it. We see that from her journal entries. It twisted her utterly.

ionic haven
#

Which is kinda why I suspect there has to be a caveat in healing Anne through that method

#

Like what if it wants equivalent exchange?

runic tundra
#

I don't think Isadora's spell would work on Anne period

ionic haven
#

It doesn't

runic tundra
#

Its not designed for that

ionic haven
#

But brute forcing it will have side effects

runic tundra
#

And you don't need AM to lessen physical pain from curses

ionic haven
#

Which is why I suspect that Rookwood's curse is a self made curse without Ancient Magic

runic tundra
#

Prob

ionic haven
#

If Ginny could make a hex as a child

#

Dark Wizards like Rookwood likely have a plethora

runic tundra
#

Though he does use that AM looking shield in the fight

#

so i dunno what gives there

ionic haven
#

Nah

runic tundra
#

Or thats just normal shield but better than the others or its just for the boss fight

ionic haven
#

That's just a gameplay mechanic

runic tundra
#

Yah assumed so.

ionic haven
#

To stop players from AK'ing him

runic tundra
#

Hmm. That one shots his shield everytime i think doesn't it?

ionic haven
#

Yes

#

AK breaks all shields

runic tundra
#

Ya.

ionic haven
#

They patched it so you can't cheese boss fights with them anymore

runic tundra
#

So they removed 1 shotting bosses?

ionic haven
#

Yes

runic tundra
#

Only thing its not 1 shotting is Ranrock himself pre-patch

#

Also those AM giant guardians i think

ionic haven
#

You can't one-shot the Dark Wizard Boss Fights anymore

#

Oh you can't one-shot them anyways

#

Since those are midgame bosses

#

You have to get to Winter to get AK

runic tundra
#

Yah unless you do a thing that lets you do it early

ionic haven
#

||The forbidden "third party tool"? 👀 ||

runic tundra
#

Aye. But yah the side effect of the Isadora spell brings to mind the villain of LRFF13s plan which would result in ||humans being unable to feel any negative emotions at all. That's not human.|| Thats what Isodora's spell leads to but even worse since its all emotions eventually.

fallen saddle
# runic tundra There's also a question of how many times she used that spell on her dad. Like d...

It was implied heavily that somewhere in her studies she came to the conclusion that the only way to free someone completely from pain was to remove all emotions from them....though it seems her mindset was that because doing this was making her more powerful it was some sort of reasoning that it was doing the right thing ....all the more reason the ancient magic should not be somthing that is stuided alone.

#

Likley she used her father for repeated experiments and once she deemd him completely free of pain she moved to the studnets of hogwarts.

sour pendant
#

"If that's the only way I can get you to hand over that book, then so be----Accio Intermediate Transfiguration."

sour pendant
#

tucks book under arm and walks away, muttering "Stupid Third Years..."

sturdy void
#

So Mr Morganach lost both of his children because Isidora went on a power trip. Sarcasm incoming: Great job, Isidora.

sturdy void
#

Well, I almost got to the end, but Ranrok in dragon form is a b****, so I'm gonna show my Gryffindor character some love now.

placid wyvern
#

Maybe..

#

Ancient magic build?

sour pendant
#

So, how come you don't get a choice between Amit and Adelaide's uncle, in terms of needing to bring someone who speaks Gobbledygook? 👀 I mean, we know for sure that her uncle understands a fair bit of the language...

deep cypress
#

Ravenclaw got a really nice common room and balcony entrance.

And then got shafted in everything else.

No companion and companion questline.

Generally unpleasant or boring NPCs

An absolutely AWFUL house exclusive quest that doesn’t even have you talking to a new NPC or go somewhere interesting.

sour pendant
#

Poor Ravenclaws. Why does WB hate them?

modest mist
#

not sure.

sour pendant
#

WB: "NERDS."

steel plank
#

Ravenclaw.:organize the owlery

#

Hufflepuff gets to go to Azkaban even. Dang

subtle mango
#

Is there a guide anyone has found for the best talents? I’ve recently unlocked it and I’ve got 9 talent points to use but I just don’t know what to use them on, any suggestions?

low mauve
#

Well it really depends on your playstyle, but I will say that if you're playing on Story or Easy mode, the Potent Wiggenweld talents aren't worth it; you're going to have more Wiggenweld potions than you're going to know what to do with, so you don't really need to stretch them.

subtle mango
low mauve
#

Personally, I recommend all of the stealth ones, and yes, absolutely, get every spell set you can

#

I also recommend the improved Incendio, because the ring of fire makes it much easier to fight Inferi

#

Let me take another look at the ones I have so I can tell you which ones I would recommend for any playstyle

subtle mango
#

Smashing thank you!

low mauve
#

So I would recommend almost all of the Core talents, except for the Wiggenweld ones depending on your difficulty, as I already mentioned. I would also recommend Protego Mastery (the shockwave one) instead of Protego Expertise (the projectile one) because the former makes the latter redundant once you're a high enough level to train it.

#

I would also recommend sinking a few points into the Dark Arts talents even if you won't be using the Unforgivables; in particular, Enduring Curse, Blood Curse, Stunning Curse, and Curse Sapper.

#

If you're going to be using plants or potions a lot, then I'd recommend the corresponding talents from the Room of Requirement category.

#

If you're going to be favouring spells, then I'd get the talents for the ones you use most often.

subtle mango
#

This is a massive help thank you!

placid wyvern
sour pendant
#

sighs Tried everything I could to be stealthy, but can't get past the goblins unseen. Oh well. Still counts as not being seen if I don't leave witnesses.

sour pendant
#

promises to look out for the thief who stole Padraic Haggerty's family heirloom ---> turns around and breaks into the house behind his stall

mental pilot
#

Good detective work the thief could be hiding in that house.

sour pendant
#

"Sebastian is to come nowhere near Feldcroft! Nowhere near Anne!" Crucios Solomon from sundown to sun-up

leaden rapids
#

Oh like he's in charge of the hamlet? Haaa....

mental pilot
#

“All evil goblins are welcome in Feldcroft and near Anne!”

sour pendant
leaden rapids
#

Naw....

mental pilot
#

It’s the hidden conspiracy. Solomon was part of Rookwood’s gang all along and was working with Ranrok. He was only taking care of Anne because he felt guilty of his friend Rookwood’s curse and then tried to get her killed by Goblins so he wouldn’t be responsible anymore. 🙃

sour pendant
placid wyvern
sour pendant
#

That bastard...

low mauve
#

Now let's not get too crazy

sour pendant
placid wyvern
sour pendant
#

Agreed.

placid wyvern
#

Oh my god how could I not realize this sooner

placid wyvern
#

SOLOMON DIDN'T FEEL GUILTY ABOUT ROOKWOOD'S CURSE...HE WAS THE ONE WHO TOLD ROOKWOOD TO CAST IT

placid wyvern
sour pendant
#

XD

placid wyvern
placid wyvern
sour pendant
placid wyvern
#

He was so jealous of his brother that he wanted to attack his kids😰

placid wyvern
#

Ranrok can learn from him

placid wyvern
#

He was just confined to a desk doing all the Auror paperwork

#

Because his boss saw so little potential in him

#

And he saw his brother being so successful as a professor

#

So he rigged the lights 😭

#

And killed his own brother and his sister in law

sour pendant
#

😭 Let's get Sebastian an Order of Merlin, First Class for getting rid of him.

placid wyvern
#

And Solomon should've been sent to Azkaban anyway

#

For attempted murder of MC and Sebastian and the murder of Mr and Mrs Sallow

#

Sebastian got rid of someone even worse than Ranrok and Rookwood

#

He's a hero 👏👏👏👏👏👏

sour pendant
#

❤️ writes his biography and negotiates the movie rights

placid wyvern
sturdy void
#

I thought the cutscene in DADA class before you learn Expelliarmus was so cute. I love how Poppy is significantly shorter than everyone else. 🥺

sturdy void
#

And she's interacting around with Everett and Sebastian. 💞

#

I bet Poppy and Adelaide are besties.

sour pendant
#

We need more time with Ominis that isn't spent listening to him scold Sebastian. :(

ionic haven
modest mist
sour pendant
modest mist
#

i suppose..

placid wyvern
#

Don't forget the gifts

sour pendant
placid wyvern
#

You gotta give them gifts, pal

sour pendant
#

brings gift card to Outback Steakhouse

placid wyvern
#

And assume it's good

sour pendant
#

And yes, is good.

placid wyvern
hearty oxide
#

@placid wyvern Thank god he didn't had one, he is pathetic

sturdy void
#

I can't wait to do the rest of my quests with my Ravenclaw.

sour pendant
placid wyvern
#

Which could be good if you're planning to get those achievements

sturdy void
#

I meant the side quests.

placid wyvern
#

Oh

sturdy void
#

I'm excited for my Hufflepuff playthrough.

#

My profile picture shows my Hufflepuff.

placid wyvern
#

Prisoner of Love is probably the best one

sturdy void
#

Ellie Scamander 💞

#

My little badger girl

sturdy void
placid wyvern
placid wyvern
sturdy void
#

I like every version of Jackdaw's quest. I like that Scrope is helping in the Slytherin version. He is kinda going behind Black's back and that's... interesting.

sturdy void
placid wyvern
placid wyvern
hearty oxide
#

@placid wyvern Amit , who else! As a South Asian he made me cringe 😬

sturdy void
#

I like Amit. What made you cringe about him?

placid wyvern
#

I think he deserves a background

sturdy void
placid wyvern
sturdy void
#

I might continue playing on my Hufflepuff save file later.

placid wyvern
#

Unless it's late and you need sleep

sturdy void
#

My Ravenclaw should have kept Gwyneira the Diricawl. I regret giving her to Madam "I'm gonna turn her feathers into fashion".

sturdy void
#

Did I spoil something?

placid wyvern
#

FEATHERS INTO FASHION...?

#

I have never ever sold a magical beast so I wouldn't know...

#

Or I'm just a lazy bum

sturdy void
#

There's a side quest that lets you rescue an Albino Diricawl. You can give it to a lady who wants to use its feathers for fashion or you can keep it. And I stupidly gave it to the lady.

#

I think I might restart my Ravenclaw playthrough after I did the last fight because that bothers me.

placid wyvern
#

I likely haven't done it either, must be one of the 5 hidden quests not on my map

runic tundra
sturdy void
#

Yeah.

sturdy void
#

I'll just make different choices with my other characters. That's okay.

#

I'm just gonna imagine my Ravenclaw kept Gwyneira.

runic tundra
#

Yah your first playthrough or whatever doens't have to be ur personal headcanon

#

made a choice u regret 1 playthrough, just say in ur headcanon ur mc made a different choice

sturdy void
#

Yep. I'm gonna do that. I kind of wish there were more story quests.

#

I'm so excited for my Hufflepuff playthrough.
I'm gonna do so many great things with her. 🥰

sour pendant
#

hufflepuffheartsparkle 🥹

hearty oxide
#

@sturdy void Everything about him made me cringe, and he is not even a character but a Stereotype in a trope

sturdy void
placid wyvern
sturdy void
#

You should.

#

I'd be a magizoologist.

placid wyvern
#

I'd wanna be a Charms teacher

#

Professor Ronen is pretty cool

sturdy void
#

Professor Hecat is badass.
"I get new students every year, but I only have one Hebridean Black skull."

mossy narwhal
#

would love to see her whooping black's ass when they were younger

placid wyvern
placid wyvern
mossy narwhal
#

sadly mine didn't work

sturdy void
#

Madam Kogawa's story is so interesting too.

sturdy void
#

I love that Imelda says flying class is only for "beginners and bumbling baboons". I appreciate the Professor McGonagall reference here. 😊

rose karma
#

Just killed Rookwood 😍😍😍

somber ridge
runic tundra
#

butterbeers on the house

somber ridge
#

i laughed at that way harder than i should have

rose karma
#

Okay so need a spot or help, when fighting ranrock as the dragon and we’ve moved to the second area, what do I have to do because I’ve just been blocking his rocks for about 10 minutes now

#

@somber ridge helppp meee 😭😭

#

Omg nvmmm, just been stood at the top of the slide thing blocking for 10 mins instead of walking down 😭😭😭

somber ridge
surreal dove
#

I got so upset cuz I kept dying & couldn’t figure it out

spring bloom
#

Just did the third trial and wow that was sick

sturdy void
#

That was so interesting.

#

I feel like San Bakar's trial was a bit short. I was expecting more interactions with other magical creatures.

spring bloom
#

HES A DRAGON NOW!?

#

I’m not ready for this

#

Avada Kedavra would’ve been nice

runic tundra
#

AK won't help ya there

spring bloom
#

Oh damn

#

Any curses work?

elder turtle
#

No

spring bloom
#

Oh no

elder turtle
#

Crucio gives you invincibility frames tho

spring bloom
#

This feel like a dark souls boss

elder turtle
spring bloom
#

Guess I’m setting crucio instead of sneaky

elder turtle
#

Might be better to set one purple and yellow spell for your slot

spring bloom
#

Yeah I’ve got purple yellow red and crucio now

elder turtle
#

Because if you can't break his shield he'll remain invincible

spring bloom
#

Second phase

spring bloom
#

Gonna redo the entire mission with more supplies because that’s hard

sour pendant
#

Salazar Slytherin and Sebastian Sallow saved the wizarding world. :3 Oh, and I helped a little.

#

I wish I could tell him that.

#

"I can't believe we found ourselves trapped in that Scriptorium. Never again." Really, Ominis? That's the first thing you say to me after I saved your ass? Not even a "Atta' girl"? 🥺

modest mist
#

no

sour pendant
modest mist
#

not allowed!

sour pendant
modest mist
#

married

sour pendant
#

q-q He doesn't have to marry me, I just want a thank you.

sour pendant
#

"Perhaps it has to do with the light and the darkness." "Perhaps it has to do with the light and the darkness." "Perhaps it has to do with the light and the dar---" Effie: "SILENCIO."

sour pendant
#

"Now that I have my gobstones back, I'm ready to take on all challengers! ...If I can find any." Y'know, as annoying as Zenobia is, I wish we could choose to play a game with her, at least once.

hushed bramble
#

I kept the gobstones... (Just kidding)

sour pendant
hushed bramble
dense eagle
#

I kept them and do play slytherin can confirm

sour pendant
#

"Wasn't putting Ferdinand in the Hog's Head a bit much?" I swear to God, Poppy, NOTHING I do pleases you. This honestly sours my perception of your character on replays.

runic tundra
#

given what his portrait's false rumors bout students has done to students over time, i'd just let it be destroyed

sour pendant
#

Not doing that again.

#

Next time, it's ARSON. 🖼️ 🔥 Wand

runic tundra
#

I mean if he agrees to stop his spying and spreading false rumors i'd allow him to be put back up. Dunno if that comes up though

sour pendant
#

Now, as for me? If he apologized to all the students he lied about, and actually sounded like he meant it, I would allow his portrait to be put back up...in the Hog's Head. Otherwise, he burns.

runic tundra
#

yah im not letting him spy and spread falsehoods bout students to black again then

#

god he even sounds annoying

sour pendant
runic tundra
#

Yah.

#

Like if ur against just destroying the portait then just put in a dark room somewhere out of way

sour pendant
#

Yeah, but the game doesn't let me do that. So...oh well.

runic tundra
#

Yah im not gonna feel guilty bout it

#

and they ain't alive as it is. not truly

sour pendant
#

Right. They may be sentient, sort of, but even that, not really.

runic tundra
#

some are just not as limited as others.

sour pendant
#

Whatever happens to him, he has another portrait in the library, and I'd like to see anyone steal something like that from Hogwarts, so....

runic tundra
#

yah and you can just put his portrait in hogs head were he won't be able to spy on students

#

and he hates the hogs head. so if ur not ok with the burning you get that at least

#

and i expect someone there will either toss his portrait in a bin or burn it themselves.

#

I think il put him in hogs head cos that will piss him off and he can't spy on students anymore and its a lesser crime than arson

#

Il just headcanon he gets moved to a storage or destroyed later by someone else.

sour pendant
runic tundra
#

yah. W scenerio

inner atlas
#

god the cutscene during and after ||fig dies|| always makes me sob, its been three times now

#

end of main story spoilers!!!

hushed bramble
spring bloom
#

Only thing left now is the O.W.Ls and 100%ing the rest of the game

sour pendant
#

I wanna know how well my character did on the O.W.L.s. ;-;

spring bloom
#

Were the star student after all

sour pendant
rose karma
#

When’s the last time we see/talk to Sebastian :/

(After NOT turning him in)

untold crater
#

The story was so bad

spring bloom
untold crater
#

How come I can kill every enemy and nobody mentions it

untold crater
spring bloom
#

@fallen saddle Isidora made everyone emotionless shells, how is she innocent?

pure rover
#

She went too far trying to save his dad from pain, she wasnt evil in that way…

spring bloom
#

Then she started making students emotionless

pure rover
#

Yeah… i shouldnt be in spoilers chat…

spring bloom
#

You haven’t beaten the game…

elder turtle
#

She mispronounced the spell guys

#

Trust me I was there

sour pendant
rose karma
#

I don’t think I’m at that part yet

sour pendant
runic tundra
sour pendant
#

It's odd how the dark wizard and witch NPCs never try to use the Unforgivables on us during battle.

placid wyvern
placid wyvern
placid wyvern
#

They probably had children

rose karma
#

So sad, I want him to say

placid wyvern
placid wyvern
rose karma
rose karma
#

Love how at the end none of our “friends” talk to us anymore, I walked past Natty and Sebastian and neither said anything to me

#

Bit rude, I have attachment issues likeee 🙄🙄💀

placid wyvern
placid wyvern
rose karma
rose karma
placid wyvern
#

Sorry , typo...

rose karma
#

Idk what steam is

#

So probs not

placid wyvern
rose karma
#

No then

sour pendant
gleaming heron
# untold crater The story was so bad

I think it's decent overall taking into account that this is all fan fiction basically. Nobody knows (obviously) and writes this world better than Jo does.

untold crater
elder turtle
#

I don't know about you but that actually sounds awesome

compact geyser
#

I finished the main quests within a week, and it’s so sad walking around cause there’s not much left to do ;-;

#

I wish it was multiplayer so that I could hang out with my friends or battle

#

Sebastian’s quest was defo the best. It could have been the main story, it was that good

tidal portal
#

I know what happens but I'm taking it slowly through the main & story quests

#

I'm currently replaying on pc, can't remember how far I got on my switch

torn olive
#

hi there, new hogwarts legacy person here, ive been plating through the main story and loving it all, im on a steam deck/PC there was a quest im looking for-its got a house elf you can free and a shop you can take over. is this a quest i can play or is it only for a specific console?

ionic haven
#

It releases for all platforms next month

torn olive
silk swan
compact geyser
silk swan
#

Fr fr

#

I also decided to turn Sebastian in and now I’m feeling kinda guilty 😭

final nova
dense eagle
silk swan
modest harness
#

Main story got over sooo quickly :/ it's quite sad

#

I would love to see a lot more

dense eagle
modest harness
dense eagle
#

Ah damn yeah well on the bright side if you didn't use unforgivables you can do a evil run

modest harness
#

I did use them

#

A lot of times lol

#

Sebastian's side quests were fun

dense eagle
#

Ya lol

modest harness
#

Yeee

#

Couldn't turn him in

solid halo
#

Noooooooo tobbs 😢

solid halo
#

Why does some beast have a star next to gender?

elder turtle
#

They're shiny beasts

#

They have a different color palette than normal ones

final nova
#

why did i never notice lmao. i think i'm the only hufflepuff who didn't spend hours with the beasts nd all

fleet ice
#

What’s the canon ending for Sebastian?

runic tundra
#

there is none

#

devs will either pick for a sequel or keep the choice intact by letting you decide in a sequel which happened if its mentioned at all

dense eagle
fleet ice
#

Tbh I’ve decided not to turn him in

dense eagle
#

Impiro is a very useful spell what a nice guy for teaching us it

leaden rapids
#

Sebastian deserves to know the truth, so never will mine turn him in.

dense eagle
hushed bramble
sour pendant
#

Sebastian's parents did nothing wrong.

fallen saddle
#

Morally or legally
We see bad parenting from the first scene which isn't illegal

sour pendant
fallen saddle
#

He's abusive and dismissive this is made clear immediately
He don't like Sebastian because of his dad/brother this is made clear immediately
"He keeps refering to me as my father's child"

He's not legally wrong just morally, a bad parent and mean to Sebastian

sour pendant
#

Er... I'm not talking about Solomon, you know that, right?

fallen saddle
#

No lol as Sebastian uncle is his legal guardian he would be his parent I missed that lol
Of course people dead before the game did nothing wrong

sour pendant
mental pilot
#

They were studying dark stuff and Omi hates it. So he’s biased.

sour pendant
mental pilot
#

I guess I misremembered. Sorry

runic tundra
#

They were regarded as optimistic, open-minded, and eager for more knowledge: traits which Sebastian wished to emulate.[1]

Their brother/brother-in-law, Solomon Sallow, told Sebastian that his father would be ashamed of his use of the Dark Arts. Therefore, it is likely that these individuals, like Solomon, held a strong aversion to Dark Magic.[5]

fallen saddle
#

There's nothing that refutes them studying dark magic ravenclaw for knowledge style though

#

They were regarded as optimistic, open-minded, and eager for more knowledge: traits which Sebastian wished to emulate.[1]

#

They were dedicated professors as they spent nearly every waking moment in their cellar library,[3

#

That in now way refutes dark magic on a knowledge basis

#

Infact the specific keyword open minded points to plausibility

#

Hell even eager for more knowledge and dark magic not being illegal can be a hint

fallen saddle
#

Additionally why is calling Sebastian his father's son a insult? What did your brother do that you dislike?

Study dark magic

sour pendant
#

It's definitely possible that his parents studied dark magic academically, but were against its use...but would be willing to make exceptions on a case-by-case basis because open-mindedness?

fallen saddle
#

I can't make the argument they used it as there's not enough evidence but the keywords reckless & open minded
Having a thirst for knowledge and doing something to upset his brother (uncle)
Definitely points to atleast studying

His parents were either ravenclaw or Slytherin as far as I know unconfirmed but if Slytherin they are usually ok with dark magic aswell

sour pendant
#

Or it's possible that his parents didn't use dark magic themselves but wouldn't automatically disavow anyone else who did, and Solomon didn't really understand his brother at all.

sour pendant
fallen saddle
#

Without evidence otherwise it should be safe to assume they shared Sebastians house aswell though

sour pendant
#

Indeed. Without evidence, it would be safe to assume one of them might've been a Gryffindor or Hufflepuff, too.

fallen saddle
sour pendant
#

points to Lenora Everleigh Exhibit A.

fallen saddle
# sour pendant *points to Lenora Everleigh* Exhibit A.

I'm sure you're aware there are exceptions to the rule but the game makes us aware of this when it happens again like sirius black

So without evidence to otherwise we can assume they are Slytherin as the majority of families share houses

sour pendant
#

We have direct evidence that family members don't all share a House, and that it's not exactly shocking to be sorted apart.

fallen saddle
sour pendant
#

It could be a slim majority, though. Like I said, when siblings are sorted into different Houses, it's not a big deal.

fallen saddle
sour pendant
#

It's safe to assume the opposite could be true, as well.

fallen saddle
sour pendant
fallen saddle
sour pendant
fallen saddle
#

I don't think you understand the definition of majority & minority
With no evidence the majority outcome is assumed

fallen saddle
sour pendant
#

I highly doubt that it's happened fewer than 10 times in the entirety of Hogwarts' history, or else the cases we do know about would make history.

#

Instead, it's just, "Oh, Parvati's a Gryffindor and Padma's a Ravenclaw. In other news, snow is cold."

fallen saddle
#

The majority is family shares house and with no evidence otherwise Sebastians parents were Slytherin

sour pendant
#

Or perhaps neither of his parents were Slytherin.

fallen saddle
#

is a rule of Hogwarts that families get sorted together. Which makes little sense, if the Sorting is supposed to be based on personality traits.Dec 9, 2018

sour pendant
#

Well...I suppose more values than personality traits, but...personality plays a part in it.

fallen saddle
#

Also I double checked and the canon people we know in different houses is less than 7 not 10

#

I'm not going to but we could compare that to same house families I can only assume the number would be much higher

sour pendant
#

If same-house families really are the majority, it's probably something like a 52%/48% split.

fallen saddle
#

Regardless without evidence of the minority occuring the majority gets assumed

deep cypress
#

To add to the argument against families akways. Ding sorted into the sane house, in Ron’s Howker from his mother, it openly congratulates Ginny on being put in Gryffindor… which blatantly implies that you aren’t guaranteed to end up in the sane house as your family.

It’s fairly common. But it’s not A RULE that says families end up in the sane house. It depends on the traits of a person. Not their family.

sour pendant
fallen saddle
#

Also

ma·jor·i·ty
noun
1.
the greater number.
"in the majority of cases all will go smoothly"

mi·nor·i·ty
noun
1.
the smaller number or part, especially a number that is less than half the whole number.
"harsher measure"

Additionally to major vs lesser arguments the burden of proof argument fallacy applies
Meaning the minority needs evidence

sour pendant
#

So probably less common than 52% of families. Maybe 49-ish percent.

#

Or less. idk. I'm not good at math.

fallen saddle
#

You can congratulate when you already know the outcome
It's the parent vs kid dynamic showing affection I'm so proud of you sweetheart yadda yadda

deep cypress
sour pendant
fallen saddle
#

Neville was a forced hatstall going against what what he should do bad example

fallen saddle
sour pendant
fallen saddle
#

Regardless it's somtning that happens and oh she is, in the books she's more affectionate towards Harry and ginny
Everyone's nicer to Harry in the books but that's another topic

sour pendant
#

She's not. It isn't that Percy gets an owl and, oh, of course, all of the other kids get a little something too. In Molly's family, you get something if you do something to deserve it.

fallen saddle
#

What a migraine inducing reply
That's a movie watcher response not knowing Molly is more affectionate in the books

sour pendant
#

No, it's the response of someone reading the books. Percy gets an owl and new robes because he's a Prefect and Head Boy and whatnot; everyone else gets hand-me-downs.

#

She shows a little favoritism towards Ginny, but not a lot.

dense eagle
#

You absolutely assume Same house unless said otherwise
Across all Harry Potter media you can count Canon different house kids or parents on your fingers

dense eagle
fallen saddle
#

Exactly

sour pendant
fallen saddle
#

Any book reader knows Ginny is absolutely favoured

dense eagle
sour pendant
dense eagle
#

No need to be dense , you admitted she gets favour thats it she's favored, that is the correct response

fallen saddle
#

This whole conversation is a useless circle bottom line is with no evidence otherwise we can only assume as the majority is the case Sebastian parents were Slytherin lol

sour pendant
#

I admitted that she gets a little favor. That does not disprove my argument.

#

We can say it's likely that at least one of his parents was in Slytherin, but we can't just automatically assume it as fact unless stated otherwise.

dense eagle
#

It does, homies only point was ginny and Harry get favored, admitting ginny gets favoured is a case closed

#

Without evidence the majority outcome gets assumed kiddo

sour pendant
fallen saddle
dense eagle
fallen saddle
#

Yep

sour pendant
dense eagle
#

The only relevancy is the confirmed Canon and lore not what you think or your headcanon

#

I'm going back to lurking before I get trapped into running around In circles with you too even now our conversation is repeating the one you just had with miss morganarch lol 😆

sour pendant
#

Textual evidence suggests that it's not anything to get excited over when someone is sorted differently from their family members. Therefore, not a big enough majority that same-House-family is the case unless stated otherwise.

dense eagle
#

No

#

Why be wrong so willingly

#

Lol I said i wouldn't reply again my bad

fallen saddle
#

Also

ma·jor·i·ty
noun
1.
the greater number.
"in the majority of cases all will go smoothly"

mi·nor·i·ty
noun
1.
the smaller number or part, especially a number that is less than half the whole number.
"harsher measure"

sour pendant
dense eagle
#

You are

sour pendant
dense eagle
#

Childish one ain't ya lol

fallen saddle
#

The lore and canon states the majority and what should be assumed this debate is just getting silly now lol

sour pendant
fallen saddle
#

Unfortunately the book pages where the lore and canon comes from is black ink and white pages

fallen saddle
#

Also I don't condone Batgirls behavior even tho she's agreeing with me just a fyi lol

deep cypress
#

<@&755190193367023772>

#

Ew sussy link

light nexus
#

Cheers m'dears

deep cypress
light nexus
#

ZOOM

primal crown
marble narwhal
fallen saddle
#

So how powerful is the HL MC compared to the Big 3 of the HP universe.

#

Well Harry was never powerful besides his mental capabilities

#

I am taling about Voldemort Dumbeldore and Grimwald.

#

Ah! Probably above voldemort and below Grim and dumbe

#

Really I would put Grim at the weakest of the big 3 the only reason he had a bit power boost was because of his elder wand what maid Grim dangerous was his cunning.

#

Exactly he was powerful in his own right and cunning enough tk make up for it in other ways
In the books when voldamort visits him he couldn't care less and calls him Tom showing his indifference

#

I would argue that Voldemort is stronger that Dumbledoor he held his own againsrt the later even against the elder wand.

#

Dumbledore effortlessly duels voldy avoiding his killing curses, even the movies do a good job showing this

#

Yea but he had the elder wand to help him with that.

#

I would argue that VOldemort is the strongest in Raw Power Dumboldore had the best Vestitility and Grimwald had the best Charisma and Cunning.

#

Raw power by itself means nothing when you can be overcomed and out maneuvered

#

And you would say the HL MC has more raw power.

#

I'm not sure, would you say it's Canon they got all of the talents?

ionic haven
#

<@&755190193367023772>

runic tundra
#

I put AD and GG above LV in power and skill given AD considered GG just slightly less skilled then himself and he never made that claim bout LV and he was calmly winning his duel with LV for most of it minus the one moment were he nearly died to an AK Nagini combo attack while he was able to beat GG while the latter had the EW amping his already insane power which was considered equal to ADs.

#

I also don't think LV had much versatility in combat at all since he mainly used AK in combat while GG in FB shows more versatility in his dueling style imo.

fallen saddle
runic tundra
#

He did but I don't think him lacking it would make a difference in that fight. If he can beat GG when the latter was master of the wand, he can beat LV without it aswell imo.

fallen saddle
sturdy void
#

Spoilers for Isidora's story ||It's so sad that San had to kill her.||

dense eagle
#

They should of let her cook longer tbh

#

Even if she still eventually dies
Let us see more results of her work

#

She took pain away from her dad , and he says thank you showing it worked
Later she took pain from the female keeper with no negative results of doing so

#

Ontop of the negative results and the bad things she did, it was also working aswell and possible to just remove pain

deep cypress
dense eagle
#

But it could of been used for good aswell, her father and the female keeper both show this

#

Additionally one of the keepers shows great interest in her work in the original memories

#

Constant paying attention and a slight smile

low mauve
dense eagle
#

I understand the negative and never denied it
I'm stating the positive aswell,
She contuined to work on her dad when she should of stopped after maybe a few sessions

#

The female keeper gets pain removed and has no negative consequence
It easily could of been used for good aswell as the evil it was used for

low mauve
#

Except it doesn't work that way????? It's a double-edged sword, you cannot take away someone's grief without taking their love as well

dense eagle
#

It does work that way, don't take it all. As per the female keeper she was fine after Refine the magic
We can't know her work stopped too soon

deep cypress
# dense eagle But it could of been used for good aswell, her father and the female keeper both...

Her father became a husk

Niamh didn’t have anywhere near the level of pain and Isidora didn’t have the chance to get a big bit like she did to her father.

Of course it didn’t affect Niamh. For one she’s a weirder of ancient magic herself and wasn’t full of pain.

Isidora wasn’t using depression. She was collecting power, getting stronger off what she took and also becoming more mad. The damage she could have done if not killed could have destroyed the Wizarding World,

Magic and using it is highly dependant in emotional state.

If you turn people into emotionless husks, there will be no more maguc

dense eagle
#

Exactly my point don't take all the pain / refine the magic / let her cook longer so we can see it doing more good instead of mostly bad then kill her

#

Say you're creating congringo, everytime you cast it you burn your eye brows off
You stop working on it and it's now a known side effect thats the finished spell

She needed more time

deep cypress
#

She was using the magic in CHILDREN

On her own students no less.

She’s not a saviour and her work wasn’t goid.

Even her own notes have her mention that she had doubts but the rush of power was greater and convinced her it was fine,

Even though it left the patient a husk.

She thought it was fine because she got a rush.

The girl was an addict who was willing to hurt her friends and the children under her care for this delusion of grandeur

dense eagle
#

I understand it was evil magic and was evil but it could of been used for good
Are you aware multiple things the army used to kill in ww1 and ww2 they turned into designs for household items to help people like a blender, air conditioner, modern cars ect once the war was over? Evil can become good

#

Say the keepers even kept trying on I don't know criminals or goblins after her death, could of eventually made a cure for depression

#

You might be thinking omg practice on goblins, but goblin murder is legal in hp

turbid trench
#

Legal doesn’t mean ethical

ionic haven
#

Lobotomy is soooo helpful guys!!! /s

dense eagle
#

Of course not, it's not ethical to practice on animals irl but it still happens

turbid trench
#

You still suggested it

dense eagle
#

Like we practice on animals irl a goblin would be a fine Harry Potter equivalent

ionic haven
#

Actually irl in the modern era most of that level of testing is illegal

dense eagle
#

It's still done and has been done as late as mid 2000s

deep cypress
dense eagle
#

Taking into account Harry potter lore a goblin is basically a animal so yes same thing lol

ancient sand
#

they literally work in finance 0.o

turbid trench
#

Well, I’d argue that certain animals that have been used in testing could think and feel and express themselves, but not in any way that we would consider to be worthy of our level

ionic haven
dense eagle
#

They're protected from being treated like regular beats because they own the banks

deep cypress
dense eagle
ionic haven
#

I didn't know my cat qualifies to be a neuroscientist if goblins = animals

#

Woooow I should get meow meow a degree so she can work in NASA

dense eagle
#

Being classified as a beast is being classified as a beast

low mauve
#

Goblins aren't classified as 'beasts' actually but go off I guess

dense eagle
#

Mermaids however are barely a beast, wizards wanted rhem to be beings

#

Yes being responsible for the money protects them

turbid trench
#

And not the fact that they can speak multiple languages, including human languages, are able to build, create tools, have a whole society of their own…

dense eagle
#

Lore is lore you don't have to like it but if I was in Harry potter I could go kill a goblin right now lol

turbid trench
#

I wouldn’t put it past you

ionic haven
low mauve
deep cypress
#

But you know

Animals I guess?

ashen lance
#

using fiction to defend heinous acts is a shield not even harry had in the plot. Also, not canon they are classified as beasts, they are intelligent beings and only racist - supremacists wizards call them beasts because they're meant to be portrayed as DISGUSTING, evil people.

fallen saddle
#

Everyday it's a argument , yall clearly need another verbal warning from mods , haven't had one since yall argued with Lilith lol

turbid trench
ashen lance
#

talk about using jk's lore (and badly) to let out the mud and filth inside 🤣

turbid trench
ionic haven
low mauve
#

Me neither???

ionic haven
#

Projectus Maximus moment?

deep cypress
dense eagle
#

Chat logs show you were all arguing with liltih (not ominis or siren)when she tried to give a verbal should I link some messages

turbid trench
#

Maybe you’re confusing us with someone else, but I didn’t argue with her. I don’t remember them arguing with her, either

fallen saddle
ionic haven
#

Yeah man I never argued with Lilith

turbid trench
#

In fact, if any of us had been nasty with Lilith, she would have given us a warning or a mute

ionic haven
#

Projectus Maximus moment

deep cypress
#

It’s 3am and I should be in bedddd

Letting the dog out

Then it’s blanket burrito time because it’s bloody freezing in the UK tonight

ancient sand
#

I just double checked and goblins are def classified as being in HP. which makes sense because it would be crazy to be like, ohh I have a chicken manage my money 😆

turbid trench
#

Actually a chicken’s not a bad idea

ashen lance
#

the warned you too, dont at like you're not the toxic guest of the month 🤷‍♀️ your passive aggressive false innocence doesnt surprise me though

turbid trench
#

Since any beast can do it

ashen lance
dense eagle
#

As I've said they are responsible for the money that's what saves them, as stated many time in the books they are expandable

turbid trench
turbid trench
ancient sand
ionic haven
low mauve
#

I think she was attempting to spell 'expendable'

turbid trench
dense eagle
#

No it was a pun
I meant expandable lol

deep cypress
turbid trench
ancient sand
deep cypress
turbid trench
ancient sand
dense eagle
#

All wizards need to do is take the banks over and they can get demoted to beasts officially

ionic haven
#

Ohohoh there it is!

low mauve
#

Not without a war breaking out lmfao?????

ashen lance
#

someone read the books and decided to only see and remember what the supremacist evil wizards think and say 😂(maybe it's the only part that resonated) gotta google what point of views are in story telling...

turbid trench
#

I mean, I love how you’re still harping on that despite all evidence to the contrary of them being actually civilized beings in their own right

ionic haven
dense eagle
#

I can literally source and site direct lines from the books do yoy ever get tired of being wrong lol

turbid trench
low mauve
#

GIRL

ashen lance
#

YOY

ashen lance
deep cypress
low mauve
#

Yeah

ionic haven
#

Apparently to the Batgirl, oppressing minorities is a good thing

dense eagle
#

Just goblins

#

Specifically

low mauve
#

HELLO???????

ionic haven
#

Same principles applies

ashen lance
turbid trench
#

The evil people are meant to show you who you don’t want to be

#

Literally the protagonists always fight for inclusivity and equity

low mauve
#

Something tells me we really don't want to know Batgirl's current stance on Jo's attitude towards certain people nowadays

ionic haven
dense eagle
#

This is a fictional not real world and universe were fans of/ in a discord group for minimum it in no way correlates to irl stuff lol

deep cypress
#

lol

Wizards have been oppressing every non human creature since forever

It’s not just goblins.

It’s at a point where despite human and non human races being able to crossbreed (vampires, Veela, giants and goblins being immediate examples) the resulting being is considered a filthy half breed by many

turbid trench
#

Attitude has a way of translating into the real world

fallen saddle
#

Yall bordering on breaking rule 1 and needing a mod ping here lol

low mauve
ashen lance
#

*lol

low mauve
#

Lmao

turbid trench
#

Oh sorry.. lol lol lol

#

Is that enough lols for past, present, and future?

turbid trench
ancient sand
dense eagle
#

Regardless hp lore is fake and just hp lore
Isadora could of optimized her magic farther on goblins or beasts

This does not correlate to yeah practice on minorities irl

turbid trench
#

Could have*

low mauve
turbid trench
#

It’s giving… ravenclaw lololol

dense eagle
#

It would give slytherin to be evil for the greater good actually lol

turbid trench
#

Sorry I got confused considering the slytherin is giving you a lesson in morality and ethics lmao

deep cypress
fallen saddle
#

<@&755190193367023772> hey just a ping to check out this chat, they dogpiling and the occasional insult such as what this ping is attached to

low mauve
#

Love how that's the message you decide to attach your ping to

fallen saddle
#

I was waiting for another insulting message, unfortunately you sent it, sorry

ancient sand
ionic haven
#

Imagine arguing that lobotomy is humane and a good thing to do for people. They won't have to feel pain at all if they can't feel anything! It's like a doctor deciding to euthanize you for having a common cold

turbid trench
#

Well… in general lol

low mauve
dense eagle
#

It's not time to ping mods yet the insults have been very light you have to wait for somthing worse to be said

turbid trench
#

I have to give credit, batgirl at least has a spine ✨

deep cypress
turbid trench
#

A lobotomy is just a lil noodle stir, nbd

dense eagle
ancient sand
deep cypress
turbid trench
ionic haven
#

"Being a living vegetable isn't so bad! You might be a zombie but hey at least you are still alive! Side effects are not covered by your insurance. Terms and conditions applied," - Isidora Morganach's Clinic Ad be like

deep cypress
dense eagle
#

If you used a blender or air conditioner that's the irl equivalent of what could of happend if another keeper took over on isadoras work, somthing good from bad

turbid trench
#

Who needs a brain anyway?? It’s 2024, I can just download it to this super cool pc and think from there

dense eagle
#

That's actually semi possible btw

ionic haven
turbid trench
#

WATCH ME HACK INTO MY FBI AGENT’S DEVICES

#

SEE HOW WELL HE IGNORES ME THEN WHEN IM LIVING IN HIS PHONE

deep cypress
turbid trench
#

Oh right.. yes… an opportunity to improve oneself and not stalk their fbi agent… yes…

#

Lololol

deep cypress
turbid trench
#

👁️👄👁️

#

Me, watching, and then typing across his screen I like the blue on you better

deep cypress
#

Your background is nice. Very organised desktop

turbid trench
#

hey, you shouldn’t eat this late at night, you’ll wake up with a sore tummy

fallen saddle
#

@deep cypress are the white embleshed gloves even in the loot pool I've been shop resetting for 5h now

deep cypress
fallen saddle
#

Ah jeez, ok