should we use inject vs constructor injection ie: dependency injection? in modern angular?

[shrewd pelican]

can anyone tell me if it would be reasonable to do so or is there still a place in angular for the normal dependency injection?

[plain harness]

https://angular.dev/style-guide#prefer-the-inject-function-over-constructor-parameter-injection Prefer the inject function

[shrewd pelican]

thank you ❤️

[finite sand]

@shrewd pelican https://youtu.be/CDNyANaVUPs?si=cd3wMU-aLXQlMA8D

a bit late but just watched this and it sums it up perfectly with visuals

[shrewd pelican]

thank you very very much ❤️

[shrewd pelican]

this guy is really good it seems

[shrewd pelican]

if it is okay with you may i add you as a friend?

[grim finch]

In most cases I would choose inject() over anything else

[dawn grove]

for me personally i prefer constructor injection.
initialisation of a parameter before the constructor lead to bad design - in every language works that implement OOP.

[grim finch]

@dawn grove I thought parameter initialisation is happening at the same time as in constructor kinda?

[dawn grove]

I'm pretty sure about that, first starting parameters and after that the constructor.

Constructor Timing: The constructor runs after the properties are initialized.

[shrewd pelican]

Angular is going towards functional programmimg and not oop so i think i will go with inject it does everything i need (and angular is heading away from oop) react also

[dawn grove]

a question what is the benefits to not make oop anymore?