turbid gale
Similar to the existing mod for Persona 4 Golden. Replace as many tracks with live band versions.
You can find a few in this playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLQ0DRySIVw1BSYfIftRnz3B-qQJhr19UX
but I'm sure there are plenty others.
Surprised it doesn't exist already.
turbid gale
i'm actually gonna attempt to do part of this just to see how it goes lol
wiping all out doesn't have a loop?
using foobar to check loops and it's not saying there is one
is there a better tool for checking existing loops?
cedar flame
are you just looking at 122.ADX or are you looking at something else?
in any case, that looks like the proper loop
cedar flame
yeah
turbid gale
i really gotta keep that program installed
cedar flame
I don't know if audacity can show the loop points itself but the song itself goes to 3662450
yeah audacity is like essential for music and sound edits haha
turbid gale
it's not an exact one to one obv
here's the song im working with
so i have to pull my own loop points
and im struggling hard with that lmao
cedar flame
yeah that was probably what was going to happen lol
the hardest part is really finding a good point to loop, I do it manually with audacity
basically finding a point that sounds like a decent loop point, and then testing it out and seeing how it sounds, repeat a few times over until i get a good result
it's not actually hard per say it's just annoying - audacity is really nice bc you can directly input samples as time instead of min:sec
turbid gale
do you have a guide for how you enable loop points in this?
cedar flame
https://gamebanana.com/tuts/15901 to actually export the song as an adx and give it proper loop points you can use this tutorial
have the codec set to ADX instead of hca
but otherwise pretty much the same process
oh and because the ADX files are loose in the P3P files you don't technically need to use FEmulator, you can just throw it in P5REssentials like how the P3P HQ music pack does it
turbid gale
oh im doing this for PSP first
cedar flame
oh well there you go lol, shouldn't be too hard to port to P3P PC though!
if you can just replace loose ADX files with aemulus then that should be straightforward (not familiar with Aemulus bc I started learning to mod after P4G64 dropped)
cedar flame
export from foobar2000 as a wav
turbid gale
ohhh that makes sense
cedar flame
i took a brief look at the song you sent, and start: 80916 + end: 7651407 sounds... ok as a loop
unfortunately due to the changes in the song it doesn't really sound perfect
turbid gale
yeah that's gonna be the hard part
cedar flame
you could try doing some stuff like fading into the start of the loop again, but other than that this is probably beyond my knowledge haha
turbid gale
alrighty
cedar flame
might see how that sounds actually
turbid gale
i think i found a good loop too but it's like barely half the song
cedar flame
you could try doing some stuff like fading into the start of the loop again, but...
honestly doing this makes it sound decent
turbid gale
i have no idea how to export it to show you
a loop i got that's sorta alright
but it's barely any of the song like i said
cedar flame
at the bottom there's like this thing here, that's what I use to get loop points
cedar flame
start: 253733 and end 7824274
did a small edit to make this work but when you loop it I think it sounds good enough
if you have a way of getting a higher quality audio file that would probably help further
turbid gale
my audio guy's computer died so i can't get higher quality for now
literally just downloaded straight from youtube
cedar flame
i noticed lol
cedar flame
oh that's a wav i think you still need to convert it
here's what I did for reference
do that, then either mix and render or you can just export it as a wav and audacity will mix it for you
turbid gale
yeah i converted it already
sorry, do what? i barely understand what i'm looking at lol
cedar flame
i took a brief look at the song you sent, and start: 80916 + end: 7651407 sounds...
so I took this initial loop (the end point there corresponds to this point here)
after that point, on the top track, that's where the song ends and the applause starts. i just applied a fade out effect to it
the track on the bottom is the start of the track
basically i copied over the circled (in red) section from the beginning to the end
then for your loop points they end up being the green lines
does that make sense? it's kinda hard to explain by text but i hope it makes some sense lol
turbid gale
i think my brain is smooth because i understood none of that lmao
can confirm the adx works and loops well
cedar flame
oof
yeah it makes sense for me bc i actually learned audacity in like middle school so i've uhhh known this stuff for years lol
cedar flame
can confirm the adx works and loops well
that's good, do you like the way the loop sounds?
turbid gale
yeah i do
cedar flame
awesome
cedar flame
i was about to say i was gonna try it on PC instead of PSP lol
turbid gale
sure the audio quality is ass compared to PC
cedar flame
let me give it a shot
turbid gale
i think that's where i'm gonna leave it lmao
leave this kind of mod to the professionals
didn't even do much and it still hurt my head
cedar flame
looks like it worked! just the sound quality is kinda iffy but well that would be fixed with a better source lol
maybe i oughta make a guide on gb for looping custom music haha
turbid gale
yeah please do
i'm still stuck on even getting the sample number to show up lmao
like
cedar flame
are you using the latest version of audacity?
cedar flame
that's probably why yours looks a little different bc i'm on 3.0.2
lol
i'd have to look at how they changed the menu but i'm not sure how easy it is to have two installs
turbid gale
do you not left click and drag to make a loop?
it's looping but not showing up in the selection
cedar flame
do you not left click and drag to make a loop?
i do
not sure why your audacity isn't showing it but as i said i'm not really familiar with the newest version so i'll see if i can get like a portable install of it working
turbid gale
you left click and drag inside of the audio track apparently >.>
very dumb
yeah like i said
leave it to the professionals
not an active project, still a suggestion
cedar flame
ohhhh yeah it's the same for old audacity
didnt realize you werent dragging inside the audio track
turbid gale
compiled as many sources as i could into a list
Deep Breath - Deep Breath Deep Breath - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DSYnub8gaUg
Mass Destruction https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-kRAMzD5bnE
Burn my Dread - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XIUaXX1SYLA\
Battle for Everyone's Soul - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uwTPQ0nPjnc
Way of Life - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0pdRIrjbiPU
Poem for Everyone's Soul - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rk6nb6st99g
obviously try and find some higher quality rips than youtube, but these are the preferred select performances
tried to find ones that matched the vibe or exceeded it, only one that doesn't fit is deep breath deep breath
turbid gale
screw it\
im proud of my progress, ill make it
will ask for opinions on what songs to use
use this version of time or stick with base?
it's definitely growing on me now
still feels a little sad
why tf is there 5 different live arrangments for mass destruction
turbid gale
in case anyone is making music mods for the first time themselves
close your eyes, and try and see if you can feel the loop
if you can, change it lmao
turbid gale
hmmm
got burn my dread last battle working
but i couldn't get a good loop
i'm testing in game and during the battle, considering it's basically automatic, you won't hear it unless you wait around
try and improve?
here it is, a little WIP
if anyone wants to check this out on PC and let me know how it goes, feel free
turbid gale
Remaining Tracks
Sun
Danger Zone
After School
Mass Destruction FES
The Path is Open
Changing Seasons
Crisis
Joy
Master of Tartarus
Master of Shadows
Shadow
think this might be it, im pretty sure i'm out of tracks
unless anyone knows a good source for these few songs?
cedar flame
no idea about the rest but you probably won't need mass destruction fes at least since that never plays in portable afaik
turbid gale
oh does it not play? that’s good to know
i think a few others do exist, but the last two i worked on i couldn’t find individual videos for
i had to download the entire concert and cut it to the song
so somewhere in the 6 or 7 concert videos, are some of the remaining songs
turbid gale
i think i kinda trapped myself with a song
and i'm really unable to make a satisfying loop
my current loop is 180071 start and 9786859 end
it's just sooooooooooooooooo close
but right at the end there's some a small slight difference it throws everything off
think i got it?
it still feels off
182250 start 9786859 end