#40k-lore-chat
1 messages · Page 1890 of 1
yeah but it's not about rape 
lul
technically for the first person
it literally isnt
others are consensual monster orgies
no
You know how space marine chapter like to steal xenos specialty like psyker or rapid strike ?
not even for the firs tperson
yes
The first person is p much just the equal of facehugged
I feel those tried to steal drukhari
lmaaao
They are
ngl
i like DE aesthetic
they arent
and hate their lore
they literally
drill holes in the skeleton of a still alive dark eldar
so wind passes through them
and causes him more pain
Torture and rape are different
There isn't a written instance of drukhari rape, because It's in bad taste lmao
real space raids are literaly the above
Pretty much yeah
in some cases yes for breeding
trueborn need to be poppeed outta the ovens

I'm willing to find out
o my
DAMN IT
hmm so according to a quick search, no they can't
BUT if I search images, they totally can
idk what to believe
Yall are lucky this is a SFW server
I dont want to see the 490Go drukhari bdsm x gsc
nobody believed her
The fuck we talkin bout?
Do i need to prehentively block you so my pm box is safe ?
The conversation has devolved slightly from its origin, where Dilara posted an excerpt of Death Spectres, who kidnap women from across the galaxy as breeding stock
Death Spectres being SM
Very evil dudes
grimderp but make it morally repugnant-er
im coming in here to smack whoever talked about r*pe apparently
yeah...
like
the Marines did it
The Death Spectre released her, and she tumbled back into the dirt, instinctively reaching out to touch Husim. He was so still. Quintus didn’t even check his scanner. ‘Subject rejected,’ he intoned. ‘Injuries fatal.’
I'm an innocent bystander
Like gamesworkshop with non space marines, ill ignore it

Hello Crusaders, Today we are announcing the sunsetting of the game. The servers will be closing on the 10th September 2021. Warhammer 40,000: Eternal Crusade will no longer be playable at this point. We are proud of all of the work that went into Warhammer 40,000: Eternal Crusade, and for the amazing community that rallied behind the game. Than...

solstice mr channel police lol
And thus is the way of all online only games
They die
While singleplayer games are eternal
Still immortal, 'slong as you have that console
plays Yoshi's Island on his SNES
almost 30 years later and this game is still a banger
Hey Gawain, Kaulus, Dilara doesn't respect you.
Now you've hurt hteir feelings
Minor spoilers for HG, but playing the Cold Black reminded me how utterly massive Genestealers are. Like to a normal human being those Xenomorph wannabes tower over them and move about as fast as a rat. When people say 40k is horror from the viewpoint of the humans I think this is what they meant.
Yup
And they can drop you in like 3 hits. Would be 1 maybe 2, if you didnt have a refractor field
Bolters solve everything, all you gotta do is change the size.
What is the deal with Ambots? I know for a fact it can't be AI, that and the fact Necromunda gangs constantly modify the shit outta them.
I think they've got the brain of ambulls inside of them altered with bionics or something if thats what you mean
it suppresses basically everything but their instinct to dig, then they are programmed to follow simple orders/be controllable by the user
Ah.
I would assume they can become more aggressive as their programming dictates some degree of self preservation/the tech suppressing them breaks as well
Well I mean I'd be pretty crossed too if my will had been suppressed in a place I don't even remember going to.
They are meant for excavation
I get the impression they're dumb animals but I'm not super studied on them
This is correct
Is there any lore about converting human corpses into edible food in 40k and is it remotely realistic/feasible?
yup
Yeah because the entire aspect of eating humans is uhealthy iirc
like no joke intended, doctors actually say this about cannibalism lol
but again i guess thats the irony of it
🥩
there's also stuff like, if a human eats a human who ate human who ate a human and so on and so forth, sooner rather than later, there wouldn't be much, if any, energy to gain from that, iirc
Yeah its pretty much just surface level stuff of some writer going "Man, turning corpses into food sounds pretty dark lets add that in"
yeah
I was afraid of that
In that MadMax game that came out a few years ago, people feed corpses to flies then eat the maggots, I don't know how realistic that would be either though
I guess it would be a bit healthier?
Yeah I wish I had a nutritionist friend or something to weight in on this
Maggot farms are a real thing and yeah
wow
Its pretty much about some very weird digestive stuff relating to humans
I knew you could eat bugs but wouldn't there, for lack of a better word, be bits of human meat in the maggots?
P much our digestion is flawed to only take a certain amount of energy out
Oh i mean, real maggot farms dont use human corpses
But theyd work in theory
oh
I thought there was some country farming corpse eating maggots lol
but good to know, I appreciate the insight
congrats on the purple, Proud
Pink power
yeah, that
Yeah with mad max its obviously researched a bit instead of "lmao just make them eat corpses because muh grimderp"
lol
yeah, a lot of newer Mad Max stuff has a lot of thought behind them
I love the guy with the flaming guitar
yeah
Another kind of grimdark setting I'd like to see revisited, even though everyone I know hates it is Waterworld
One of the big issues is how heavy in iron we are and how dangerous high amounts of iron are for the human body
Yup, its a lot of factors like that
Doesn't the body just "remove" excess iron though
So techncially if we managed to makehuman chicken nuggets with iron out of em, that'd be eatable
I thought it was something in human meat causes like a mad cow disease equivalent?
Yeah it does but when you eat humans for a while the body can't do it 100%
gotcha
probably what I am thinking of
Actually it would make me laugh to hear that they'd farm the iron from the corpses of the dead
Eating uncooked intestines can give you a wild variety of bacterial infections but thats any animal really
That's why I said human chicken nuggets
Other than that you can cook and eat ppl, its just not gonna be nutritonally fillinf
Mix and disinfect everything, mostly works
But yeah brain and spine fluid ? prion disease
Bone marrow tho ? Delicious and nutritive
it's thought that, in the Stone Age, folks would keep bones around like snacks, crack them open and drink the marrow when hungry
one of my fav memes of all time, also nice pink

Yeah bone marrow can be untouched for a whole week and still be good for consumption
Hell, alot of animals solely survive on bone marrow
my friends started watching Hannibal recently, I was interested for a few episodes but like, ew
He does make human meat look like a snack though 😳
Such a terrible way to crack an egg, like it looks neat, but I imagine you'd end up knocking some shell in the bowl
I'm a practical person though so maybe I need to just embrace the "fun" in cooking
Oh no I know it does I meant like
AH sorry i get it lmao
when you crack an egg you typically get some smaller pieces that crack off and can fall in your bowl if you're not careful
Yeee
no you're good haha
i guess he just likes to be fancy so beats me
I've totally seen people do this flawlessly, maybe it isn't a risk with this style but it seems like it would be
I need to get down cracking an egg with one hand as well
Same
So, what kinda idiot makes warminds to solve the problem of war, makes them smarter than humans, and then makes them less than even second class citizens?
Perfect eternal soldiers my ass.
Hrm?
Make sentient beings smarter than you to fight all your battles, then treat them as disposable tools.
It's a painfully stupid idea for obvious reasons
aren't warminds from Destiny, what does this have to do with 40k?
"Warmind" is a generic term for an intelligence purpose-built for war
Destiny used the term, but it's old.
Well again what does it have to do with 40k, the most likely result of AI turning on their human masters is the influence of chaos as I understand it. Not that they were treated as second class citizens. There is also examples of AI being present in things outside of just robot soldiers that were still loyal to humanity after the fall of AI, (this isn't to begin to touch on machine spirits btw, which while showered with at times insane rituals and stupidity, still choose to serve the imperium)
Not gonna lie Destiny is the first bit of fiction I've heard use the term
Also sorry if my response/question came across as rude, I realize I could have worded my tone better. I am also in Anubis's camp though this is the first time out of like star trek, star gate, mass effect, ect ect. Destiny is the only time I've heard the term used
Well part of the whole idea of corpse starch is its a parody of soylent green and also itd be feasible with the idea that they render the human meat down to the point its not even human meat anymore just the nutrients hence the name corpse starch its a powder/flour
Also had a randomn thought, so the idea was for humanity to evolve into a psychic race comparable to the emperors own might if everything had gone according to plan ya? Well if thats true and the custodes were meant to safekeep humantiy after ascension does that mean in combination with the sisters of silence the custodes are capable of killing the emperor and similar god tier beings? Cuz if each human was as roughly as strong as the emperor at that point the only threats would be similar beings at that power.
Corpse starch is one of the wierd little things i love bout 40k and the grimdarkness of it all
So Imperial citizens eat flavorless people jello?
Basicly or bread
Ever watch the movie soylent green?
Its basicly that
or if they actualyl get paid maybe somehting like this
I'd expect its more like a can of spam
But with no flavor to speak of.
SPammish,crackers,breads,broths basicly anything you can process a chunky 'flour'/nutrient paste into
Or if your lucky you get some grox
i guess thats the good shit
Theres an actual grox burger franchise in lore that has chains on multiple planets
So..yeah...spam
have you eaten spam? The biggest taste to it is the ungodly amount of salt they use to preserve it
On the topic of Hive Life, you think children's shows in the grimdark future are on the same level of child friendliness as the Simpsons?
Unless ya pretty much live on and agri or undervelope world expect most food to be hyperprocessed canned shit
For the Imperials anyway, it's up in the air for everyone else.
thats waht i meant
The ork diet can get pretty fancy sometimes
but thats probly mostly the work of the grots
No I meant as a narrowing of my kid's show question.
Hmm
Sorta but witha pulp action flair
cuz itd be alotta war stories and adventures of inquisitors n shit
Or id also imagine wierd parodies of religious kids shows too
I expected religious but I wasn't expecting the war part.
Ever see the starship troopers kids show?
Theyed maybe tone down the voilence from world to world hive level to hive level but its the imperium the need meat for teh grinder
so theyed glorify the exploits of soldiers
They have a tv show for Caiphas Cain in universe thats implied to be watched by people of all ages
Either Imperial censorship is lax as long as it isn't heretical or everyone just sorta agree these kids are gonna be Astra Militarum cannon fodder so they figure ''hey might as well entertain them with it eh?''
Its kinda both?
cuz as long as you send your tithes your free to run your planet how you see fit
oh and dont be a fucking heretic
Written right on the back of your birth certificate: ''Pay your taxes and worship the Emperor.''
pretty much
Thats what rebels make the mistake of doin when they rebel
cuz unless the current government is truly vital for stability ofa region or flow of tithes they dont care sorta
but tehy will show up if the govenor asks obviosly
But hey if you can change the government and still pay taxes they dotn usually care when tehy show up
Yeah laws allow more wiggle room the less important you are, fuck the only reason the Inquisition is trying to save Atoma Prime is that it's a system capital. Like if our government didn't give 2 shits about some bumfuck rural town but prized the big boy cities.
sorta
Cuz ya as long as your not rebeling against the imperium itself and play it smart you got a lotta room
Especially considering most contact with planets they usually have is when they come to get taxes unless its vital planet of some kind so they sorta expect shit to change on some level since they last showed up so they dont care bout the details as long as they get the goods
yup hell most cultures simply adapt their previous religions to be the emperor as long as it please the Ecclesiarchy
''So here is this book I've written and I th-'' BANNED: EMPEROR DOES NOT WEAR TUNICS
This. There are some who believe the Emperor is their system's star. And the Ecclesiarchy is are "....eh close enough"
Honestly, I'm surprised they skimp so much in food for whatever reason for the Imperial Guard.
Like, officers get real meals if they're lucky.
I'm not really expecting high quality MRE's for your average guardsman but like... Come on now.
I mean so far, the 40k MRE seems pretty similar to real world ones
The issue is that that's a large variety of things, y'know?
I guess it does make sense though.
Some would be nice, some would suck hard.
But 40k's worst rations seem so much worse.
Anyway, gotta hope your Regiment gets issued Japanese or British (Or American) style rations.
Not the Chinese style ones (or worse)
The Imperial Guard are better fed than many civilian populations.
Its extremely common for people to join the Imperial Guard just to get access to more food
This is true.
But that's also not hard of a bar to cross.
Like, yeah, the IG get better than corpse starch or some re-re-recycled food.
But that's not a fantastic improvement.
There are some hints to what the IG get in the Necromunda: Hired Gun game. There are boxes of Dried Grox (basically beef jerky). Ambull meat. And Corpse Starch
many of which are labeled "For Imperial Guard use ONLY"
Well, maybe for some of the Guard.
But again, I imagine it has to vary from Regiment to Regiment, planet to planet.
Yeah alot does. but this is some of the only information we have to go on
...Wonder if they do the theme-ing thing for the rations too.
Armageddon steel Legion getting what amount to K rations n stuff from ww2.
Kriegers setting up mess bunkers and cook tents for the basics like ww1.
Cadians doing more modern MRE's etc.
No idea. From what we have seen. Most of it seems to be of the K rations level
correction.
C rations
Fair.
So long as its not American rations circa 2008...
A few bad ones in that batch.
lol
But yeah. I need to look through my lore stuff and find the daily issued rations of the IG. Back of my head memory says it was something along the lines of:
1 can of meat / corpse-starch
1 ration of recaff (enough for a cup)
2 Lho-sticks
Also fair... Guess you save up the Lho sticks to trade for a better can of meat depending on what you get issued.
I can't imagine anyone eating Corpse Starch for too long if they could trade up to Grox or Ambull... Does make me wonder what Ambull tastes like.
Knowing 40k? Probably bad
i know atleast one regiment got rice in their rations too
I imagine the Imperium relying on Rice for their rations a lot too.
A lot of gaurd will also just eat whats on planet to be fair
Rice is great for rations... The Japanese and Taiwanese should know.
"The trick is, sir, to eat this meat without tasting too much of it," Sergeant Sulas said. He scraped the meat out into the sheet of rehydrated rice and began to douse it in condiments, his fingers darting from ration packs like some sleight of hand.
"Pepper and pickled bell chilli are the key to good tiff. Masks the chems they use to preserve the meat," said the sergeant as he scooped some of the rations into a cup canteen and offered it to the lord general.
The gelatinous meat melted into the rice. Small pods of angry-looking chilli bells were mixed into the steaming container. Tugging off his gloves and using his hands, the lord general unceremoniously pushed the rice into his mouth, making muffled appreciative sounds. It was salty and oily without being greasy. The spicy sourness of the pickled chilli made him inhale the meal, and within seconds Faisal was teasing the last scraps of rice from his cup.```
Theyl confiscate goods for the war effort etc etc
Source: the novel "Emperor's Mercy"
Well, yeah, but they'll typically not eat rations everyday either.
Like... Rations are a "You're in the field" thing.
I got the imperail gaurds uplifting primer and the accompiening muntiorum handbook
They cover food
Isn't the Uplifting primer mostly memes?
After the Simia Orichalcae campaign, Cain dined with Inquisitor Amberley Vail at an upscale hotel, which offered Ambull steaks as a room-service menu item. The Tech-priest Logash had earlier told Ferik Jurgen, Cain's Valhallan aide, that Ambull meat tasted much like that of grox.
Its also very much canon material
Hrm...
Fair enough.
Its more like suble commentery hidden in teh writing
I need to re-read my IG books.
Like a dude who doesnt like his job slipping things in
Currently reading the Iron Warriors omnibus tho
or someone who doesnt know what they are doing and had to make shit up
Or since mine the democles golf edition or whatever that introduces tau its designed to look like the straight up taped the info for the gaurd over the acutal info on teh tau
And even then. many many copies are actually outdated
Like when some guardsmen were issued primers written for the Solar Auxilia headed to the Rangdan Xenocides (which happened over 10,000 years ago)
If they make another one im sure itll be updated for the new lore happening
Also Never lose your primer
Losing your primer gets a blamming
Oh ya
...I feel like that would confuse any guardsman getting an old primer
especially from something outta the crusades?
I'd be very confused about what the fuck was happening.
Well i mean im not wrong irl wise either>>
To be fair. Its about as useful. maybe its actually better. because it likely contains more accurate information.
Depending on what they're fighting, one would suppose...
Well so long as what they are fighting isnt a xenos species that was discovered after the Rangdan xenocides
And the primer actaully do contain some actually usefull basic survival stuff
but thats bout it
rest is just in lore fluff
'If you get thrown out into the void of space. Hold your breath and wait for rescue.'
I mean, at least if you're fighting Daemons? You're probably going to die anyway, either by Daemon or by Inquisitorial bullet.
Naw more like the stuff to survive ona planet
like tie grass to your legs to get dew
or basic injury treaments
I feel like one of the ideal xenos races to fight has to be the Orks, right?
Since the Imperium should know them like the back of their hand.
At least its going to be a stand up fight.
Pretty much
btw that excerpt I posted was interesting. Essentially a Lord General found himself stuck with some basic troopers. And was having to be taught how they survive. because, due to his rank, he was pampered
Unless kommandos or a kunnin warboss is present
Not really unknown.
Sounds like a 17th century or early 18th century problem...
Or a ww1 era problem if we're talking about the Austro-Hungarian army.
basically
Because haha rich dad go brrr
Well i mean thats knda what they are meant to parody
The Noble military leader class
At least some of them aren't garbage.
Could be worse.
Could end up in an IG regiment parodying the Austro-Hungarian army.
lol
I want that to be a thing
I really really do
Its like those scenes in Atlantis the Lost Empire I and II
Cookie: talking about the literal drum barrel of food he cooked "You can come back for seconds at any time. This stuff will keep and keep and keep."
[fast forward 5 years and the next adventure. the crew are eating]
"Hey. This stuff tastes familiar. Reminds me of what we ate on that first adventure."
Cookie: "Well yeah. Its the same barrel! I told ya it would keep."

lol
Atlantis was great.
Vinny is the best
https://youtu.be/L4aX0c6ffuI IG demolitions expert circa M42
Vinny is a treasure to us from God himself
Absolutely.
Also apparently the single most common food stuff in the imperium is:
corn
This makes sense
Oh forgot. on your different levels of rations. The Tau have more modern-type MRE rations
They have some kind of ramen noodle-like food in self heating packets. Like in modern MREs
TBH... I was kinda half expecting the T'au to do the Chinese route of MRE's
(Read: Mostly bad.)
The idea is good, the execution is bad.
Apparently their rations are really good
I swear I had an image somewhere of a T'au sitting down eating an energy bar
Its a piece of fan art
More than noodles.
I kinda want my Xenos to eat something a tad more esoteric, you know?
Its probably a hydration packet
Looks like a wrap or something.
aka military capris sun juice
Also true
But yeah. its fan art
afaik, the only mention of tau rations are those noodle packets
Disappointment
...Actually, do we know if T'au or Eldar can eat human foods?
...Even if an Eldar could, I bet you they'd get violently ill anyway because of the taste.
Well a human eats the noodles are it was okay
so atleast tau - human digestive systems and nutrition requirements are similar
Huh. Fair enough.
Probably slightly different nutritional requirements make it less than ideal but not bad that way.
yeh
Still... I imagine Eldar have refined tastes and would hate our food
they seem to like knuckle sandwiches
since every time they open their mouths it sounds to me like they are asking for one
lol
but memes aside. idk what they eat
Or even if they do. Or do they like, feed on their own arrogance? Kinda like how the Dark Eldar regenerate themselves from the pain of others.
I'm sure they eat
Oh wait. in the Fulgrim book. Some Eldar are seen eating fruit
They dont shit crystals 
@storm jungle What were they eating in Path of the Eldar
Well that clears it up. "normal alien food"
I totally have a clear picture of what that is
:u
Its just food, not sure what you want me to say
elven watermelon?
😛
They drink wine too so not sure what the "they dont eat anything with flavor" thing comes from
Now I'm just imaging those Star Trek Original Series fruit blocks
Got that normal alien jambalya. Its like jambalya, but alien. and normal
Ye
Must have been one of those notoriously bad books for the Eldar
Nah
But I remember them being something something "Slaanesh will get us" something something
They drink wine on other occassions too
Its just a case of TOO MUCH overindulgence that makes it bad
gives alien corpse-starch
like literally drinking 10 bottles in an hour and getting gluttonous
so that kind of thing
probably. that guy hated Eldar worse than i do
Ah, nah, I read Eldar Prophecy, not one of Goto's
Where was this?
Cassern something or other.
I require source
time to search it up, 1 sec
And screen caps of psycho-bitch losing her shit
I never really liked Eldar Prophecy... It was really slow
@cursive hullTo clarify. A person we know on another server has an....unhealthy obsession with the "purity" of the Sisters of Battle. constantly losing her shit every time its shown that no. They arent immune to corruption, and no they canot dom Astartes
Lol
The Sisters are good fighters, but able to take marines one to one and completely pure? Yeah nah.
yeah she cant stand that
she literally complains over them being posted on an agri-world
like jesus
wrong postings can happen
also from the Tome of Excess apparently
not sure what that is
Fuck, even Marines can end up in the wrong place.
Yeah. she really cant stand it
Well her and another one.....well there is kind of a whole server of them. Dilara is part of it. I left. Because seriously. They are jackasses
She spent an hour complaining about how sisters cant be genestealer'd because they got faith or some shit, as if physic powers are genetic 
Its weird to want your favorite faction to be perfect.
Sounds really fucking boring.
Even tho there are literally GSC sisters
Fuck sake.
Really?
"Muh faith beats this organism that has been specifically designed by a devious intellect to steal or modify genes." Is pure Mary Sue.
never advocate for writing Mary Sue's/Gary Stu's
Like. I meme about hating Eldar. As an expansion of my dislike for the generic "arrogant elf" trope. But they take shit way too far
Also they are better than Marines. And completely asexual. Except for lesbian relationships in her slash fics.

Fuuuuck sake
god dont make me link her f-list page
Dont scar Carro like that
Yeah you're right
I wish I could take those wasted neuron connections back, but nope. They are there forever
Okay, for one.
...I used to be on F-list all the time.
So you can't harm me with much from there.
And two, she must be really boring at it.
Nah nah its not being on the site thats bad
its half the shit shes into that makes it horrific 
half of it is just abuse kinks
I can only imagine.
since hey, sororitas can almost do what they want
gotta exploit that fictional authority
And knowing that she gets so pissed when lore shoots down her fantasies. because she gets off to said fantasies. She is a female incel. Its insane
Yeah its a good case of an imperial stan in general
Complaining about a sister doctor mercykilling a few nurgle afflicted sisters on hospital beds is apparently too "silly"

Good to know I'm fucked up, but at least i'm not stupid.

Ironically, her level of obsession would actually please slaanesh in universe

I want more Chaos Sisters tho. And not of the Slaanesh variety. I want Khornite and Tzeentch sisters
It'd be nice, for sure.
Imagine a Tzeentch Chaos Champion Sister vs a Living Saint. crossing swords in mid-air, both with flared wings
I'm also thinking of a Khornate group of sisters acting as elite troops for the Blood Pact.
Chaos is good, but not the best
Also.
It should surprise no one that I played a femboy techpriest on F-list.

You. I like your thinking.
I believe thats a black crusade RPG book
I just wish there was good PFP images of that.
Because I'd use that fro the rest of time.
yeee thats the one
ye it be
We can be friends
Yey
The black crusade books are pgud and cover some neat chaos stuff
even if they are jank pieces of shit balance wise
I'm mad.
Looks like I'll have to make my own femboy with an Imperial cybernetic eye or something.
Fuck.
That was an interesting read.
Techpriest femboys exist tho
That's just a fact with a universe this big
i am aware that slaanesh features in one thing as an androgynous youth or smthn
i'd say it counts
what
x)
thats a person alright
Looks good
@cursive hull leaning on a biologis perhaps
They use the flesh untill it breaks

😳
Something something reuse me until i break
Anyway, that's a thing now
Np
:3
Who we talking about 😮
where does it mention this or is this more a personal observation?
Well if youve ever read last chancers i believe is the series they actaully sit dowb to a fancymeal/banquet with the tau and you get to see how they eat n shit and ya they dont use chopsticks if i remmeebr right they have theyre own utensil for food
they also dotn believe in eating with their hands at least in polite society
they find it to be primitive
I think one of the caiphas cain novels also touches on their food a little
And i guess their mostly stictly vegetarians with exception of the firecaste
since they were originally hunters'
I guess this was one post on known lore about their deits
Kill Team describes the Tau diet as being mostly vegetarian, with consumption of meat being the domain of the Fire Caste; even then carnivorism is primarily ritual than as a means to sustenance.
The Tau diet is surprisingly well-balanced, with a wide variety of cereal grains, fruits, and nuts. Moreover, said foods are completely edible by humans without complication.
and something about how consuming alcohol may be extremely rare to being unknown amongst them
I know the eat some kinda fruit that tastes like smoked meat according to human account
Eh. Saw it on the lexicanum
bro hit me with that amino-porridge
So what is the most likely or accepted (if there are any) theories on the origins of tyranids, do they suffer the taint of the warp, and if not how?
Damn, ok, lets try to answer all that...
Afaik no, there is no really accepted theory of the origins of the nids, they came from out the galaxy and they are hungry...
They can suffer the taint of chaos as they can be infected by nurgle diseases, but other stuff, like khorne bloodlust, slaneesh lust and tzeneetch weirdness cannot influence nids as long they remain part of the hive mind, as the hive mind kinda shutdown the warp, its effect is called "shadow in the warp", it isn't like the blanks one, but the effect is similar...
Interesting
Does it seem like GW is gonna go in the direction of making the current tyranid invasion but a fraction of the extra-galatic threat?
Only GW know (hopefully), and it isn't talking too much
Guess we'll see, I doubt GW will ever break the eternal stalemate
But that raises another question, do you think GW would ever conclude the "plot" of the 40k universe
AI? I was talking about the Astartes. The Emperor lived through the cybernetic revolts, somehow said to himself "I see their mistake! They didn't make them fleshy and capable of making more of themselves!", and proceeded to solve the wrong problem.
Yes, they have seen how much appreciated is a "developing setting" with aos, and changing the setting was also what they wanted to do with WH40K, the primaris were made for that new setting, they stopped all that after the poor reception of aos at the beginning and the complains from old WHF players, which while were extremely less than WH40K were quite vocal still
But it is clear to me that GW is moving the plot onward, they may still need to wait a bit so more of the old guard stop whining or simply aren't present anymore, but i think GW will move forward the plot in WH40K
GW can't please everybody with how the plot is moving forward, so they might as well do what they want.
The mistake they made was in rebooting WF, because wiping everything and starting over is basically never received well.
At start aos was extremely ill received, but then it got better, extremely better
Oh, I mean the point still stands the Astartes largely fall in line, it is basically only through warp fuckery than anyone turned on the emperor no matter how abysmal the task he asks of them or the primarchs. (I guess assuming AI fell to the warp as well, his big oversight was wanting to maintain ignorance surrounding the warp itself and it's influence on a mind). There are some theories though that even the current state of 40k is all the Emperors plan and he's playing 12068459d chess against the chaos god's, who knows though
It got so many new people in that is was indeed an extreme success
And i say that as one that still despise aos btw
It's actually discussed in some of the Horus Heresy novels. Astartes started to question what would happen to them AFTER the Great Crusade, and many of them expected to be purged like they had purged the Thunder Warriors. That was one of the most common driving factors behind legions turning traitor - the expectation that their reward for their work would be a bullet.
not entirely true but for some yes
keyword here being one of the factors. Look at what Astartes put up with in general, and what some of the legions suffered at the hands of their primarchs, or even the guard for that matter
Plus GW is super inconsistent in a lot of it's ideas and writing
I said one of the most common. It wasn't like chaos just booped them and then they were raging for khorne
Well if you want to believe it's due to more than Chaos's influence, it's the Emperors refusal to see or treat people with humanity including his own "sons"
It was explicitly due to more than just Chaos's influence
Yeah but we see other primarchs get shit on and they still don't turn traitor
I'm talking about Astartes, not Primarchs.
Every legion had traitors and loyalists. The majority more or less sided with their Primarch, and then purged the others.
Yeah exactly
Wait lets return to your original point because I think we're getting kind of lost in the weeds here
My point is that the Astartes are a less competently executed but more intractable repeat of the Men of Iron, where the Emperor learned all the wrong lessons and solved all the wrong problems.
Astartes were denied a seat amongst the high lords explicitly because the Emperor explicitly considered them tools, and not people.
And that's the least of the slights they faced.
How are they less competently executed, unlike AI the Emperors initial plan nearly worked, even after the collapse humanity still fairs far better as a whole than with hyper advanced tech
Even to this day they are still extremely effective
The Men of Iron apparently worked for quite awhile.
And when the revolt happened they were a serious problem.
The Men of Iron have existed and failed in half the time
(at least to my understanding they were created/used/revolted towards the end of the 20k period I could be mistaken)
Ah, let me clarify: A Man of Iron is more than a match for an Astartes. No question.
The Men of Iron fell, Astartes didn't
They were, objectively, better at prosecuting war.
Yes, but only because Astartes can make more of themselves, while Men of Iron could not.
Even then, chapters still get wiped out all the time.
Yes but that would be like saying some models of Men of Iron (of which I am sure there were many) got wiped quicker than others
No, it is not.
Astartes are not as good at being soldiers, but they're better at being a lingering problem.
By your argument, the Astra Militarum would be better at war than the Astartes.
I guess we need an agreed upon standard of what makes things better, but yes likely so
Sheer force of numbers and logistics does in a way make the Astra Militarum more effective than Astartes even arguably in the 30k period
Not to mention they are humans with a vested interest in preserving humanity, a thing that I think also puts Astartes largely above Men of Iron
Humans have a vested interest in preserving cows.
The Men of Iron were, apparently, enough to drive DAoT humanity into a panic and have them making backups of their tech and spreading them all over the galaxy for later retrieval.
The Astartes have no such capability, even with the greatly diminished threat potential through the ages of the Imperium.
Id like to know where its stated that the men of iron could not replicate their own blueprints
Seeing as many of them had access to construction and fab devices
Yeah I never touched on this but I'd like to see you respond to this as well if you have time
The one we've seen, UR-025, has no ability to produce anything.
Also if you could elaborate on this more I am not quite sure what you are getting at here
Right, so, there's somewhat less than a million Astartes total.
They are
And UR-025 Likely doesn't want to waste it's life in a pointless war (trying to make more of itself) while it engages on what can only be described as a soul searching journey of trying to find meaning in a cruel and uncaring universe

And he transferred to a different body to hide among the normal humanity.
The normal men of iron had vastly different bodies based on their main objective
How many Astra Militarum would it take to kill a million Astartes?
Ten billion? A Trillion?
Significantly more obviously
He didn't transfer to a different body. He glued an Aquila to his chest. Poorly I might add
He who says that the lasgun is weak, has not been shot with 50 of it
The Astra Militarum could afford those losses.
@open marsh. I remember it being mentioned he transferred body
Nope
Cant be certain as im on the road rn
Right but whats your point, it's harder to make good astartes than good men of iron, and it takes more time to make good astartes than good men of iron, therefore machine>man?
Doesn't matter. The Imperial Guard has the manpower
Anyway the thing on astartes vs militarum is very easy; it all depends on who and where
If you set the harakoni warhawks against a main defensive astartes force theyre both going to have a bad day
Line up the fists and the kriegsmen and its not going to end any day soon
Generally speaking a whole legion of guardsmen will outgun a chapter in sheer dumb firepower however.
As much as I love the IF. The Kriegers can crank out troops faster than the Astartes can crank out bolt rounds (memeing)
That's kind of my point. The Men of Iron were a force that were capable of being a threat to the galaxy, but the Astartes aren't capable of being a threat to even just the Imperium. They take more time to produce, they require more resources, and they are objectively less capable of the "Solve the problem of War" task.
....not a threat to the Imperium? Ever heard of a thing called the Horus Heresy?

That wasn't just Astartes, though.
It was 95% Astartes
Yep
now its literally a fraction
the Imperial Army and darkmech helped sure but for the most part even the current novels just mention them as being there
The Primarchs had their zones of influence, and drafted soldiers from them.
I think one you tally up all the chapters vs all the legions. Currently there are about half as many Astartes as there were in the HH
That's partially because the current novels don't actually care about the boots on the ground?
They do?
56 books, some are non-marine stuff too
but it goes to show how the Heresy had marines fighting everywhere
Astartes are a threat. End of discussion
Gotcha, I'd still disagree likely for the points others are raising here, I think the human element makes them superior, but we likely will not come to an agreement based on fundamental differences in understanding or idealism, so I will end this with this. It was good talking with you and thanks for the civility and sharing your views! I hope we find something else to discuss here in the future. Also I apologize for my tone if I was ever rude to you here, and for any of my rudeness yesterday
Imagine if the last wall protocol is used for the wrong reasons.
Even during the Great Crusade it's documented that non-Astartes military forces didn't really....do anything
Yeah
Yes, you have successfully defeated a thing literally nobody said.
their entire job is to be wingmen
Over 200 thousand marines
They were there to deal with minor issues that were too small to be of bother to the Astartes
Calling yourself nobody now?

Didn't we literally just establish that the Astra Militarum could afford the losses from killing every Astartes?
Doesn't mean they aren't a threat
I get your point but I think that is a bit dishonest, Pseudonymous point isn't that Astartes aren't or can't be a treat, it is that Astartes are less effective than Men of Iron, and that the same essential mistakes were made with Astartes, with Men Of Iron (mistreating them made them rebel)
Yes, exactly.
Tbh this is just a matter of authors interpretation
Yeah this is a big part of the problem of the ongoing argument as well

Marines are painted as being super big deals who define galactic wars cus marines are cool and they're what the HH is about
Well yeah. But "Men of Iron" is a very broad term. They included nanites swarms which could take bites out of reality itself
Same lol
And the Emperor made it so they could make more of themselves, meaning that when revolts happened, which would eventually happen, the problem would persist indefinitely. Like mold in a house.
It's just as easy to say ok but marines didn't comprise the majority of the fighting therefore this is more of an imperial military vs imperial military thing
Simply not true loyalists outnumber traitors
Look at Gullimans response to the worst possible mentality of meeting the Emperor (the emperor sees him as a tool after 10k years, and Gulliman still choses to fight for mankind)
No. I have no idea where Pseudo gets half the stuff he says
Again, not the point. You have to hunt down every single traitor, or they'll just make more of themselves.
They cant though
I have no idea where "space skynet" came in.
Not exactly
thats literally why they're so desperate for recruits
I was resisting bringing that up lmao
Not counting those, Elyksis.
Nooooooo

CSM cannot make normally new CSM because the warp fuck up their geneseed
I wasn't talking about CSM, though, just traitors.
Traitors are CSM though...
They have to pump acid into normal dreadnoughts to melt the pilot out if they want to enshrine a fallen brother.
The major influx for CSM are, fallen SM who join chaos, or new CSM implanted with stolen geneseed
Most traitors are CSM, but not all.
Theres a difderenxe between renegades and csm yeah
Pseudonymous means to say I think many Marines would betray the Imperium for their mistreatment, even if they didn't want to become chaos worshipping degens
Renegades dont affiliate with the imperium anymore, csm are... Csm
If we talk about traitors then it is reasonable to say that even if you hunt down the last one someone will get the call of the chaos entities and then betray the imperium
We need Geu'Vesa Marines among the lists of traitors and renegades
Not all of them
Well, renegades aren't necessarily traitors though
Some do. Others dont
Yeah its a mess
Some DA fallen are openly CSM, others consider themself still loyal
Their terrible minis scare half the planets they raid to death
Its not hard to understand. Just know that "Fallen" aren't a single force with a unified goal or alleigence. You have chaosy ones with Marbas who are full on daemon princes. Then you have loyalist ones like Osmadiel
The same is true for the Alpha legion btw
God not the Memepha legion
And much of the Black Legion, actually.
Yee
Black Legion has... loyalists?
Nope
Oh, not loyalists, but people who hate chaos.
They hate chaos so much that they've aligned with it
yeah but that doesnt make much difference, they still serve chaos unwillingly and are categorized as such
LOL yeah
Abaddon hate chaos
I never said these super-intelligent post-humans were smart ¯_(ツ)_/¯
Many Iron Warriors hate chaos
Looks at Dilara
Anything else that your undead elf eyes see?
Nope, points clear as day
just because they hate chaos doesnt mean they arent unknowingly alligned with it.
The argument could be made that the same is true for the Emperor himself ¯_(ツ)_/¯
¯_(ツ)_/¯
For sure, they clearly are knowingly aligned with it, demons engine are an IW speciality after all, but that is the difference, they see chaos as a tool, a poor tool btw
¯_(ツ)_/¯
Shrug spam?
Quick let's shrug to show we are not at all invested in this argument we've been having for 10 minutes
Also a good point
Haha
Bootyman is going to be so mad when he finds out half his 'sons' are secretly chaos, then :V

It's fine, they're adopted
A great observation pseuo, the sacred and the profane
The loyalist IWs they keep finding all over the galaxy are still getting adopted, after all
I love how the sydonian dragoon is named after; the dragoon battle platform and the sydonians, who threaded through mars' acidic low-ground mist with stilts
think a bit like this
Cute
is that a gun tail?
Looks like it
seems like it lol
i dont think there is any official art of the Sydonians
Which is sad because they are one of the prime reasons mars survived
I would love to see a pre-unification Mars set of troops/soldiers/proto-tech-priests, etc.
Mars doesn't get as much attention then.
It'd be good to see how Mars was like during its attempts at survival.
Like... Its the reason the Ad Mech is the way it is, you'd think it'd be an important time frame to understand.
I know right and its almost like its at least a third of what makes the imperium the imperium
Maybe even more than a third, but i may be biased
Id figured itd be ministorum,ecclesiarchy,mechanicus as the basic tripod of what keeps the imperium afloat
Isnt one the bureacratic branch specifically and the other the religous branch
Oh ya administatum
my bad
DW, those names can be hard to remember, it is just a lot of stratum after all
Eh eh eh
hurdyhurhur
the lavatorum
adeptorum
ministorum
i see no difference
lavatorum means toilet btw guys
Another thing that i love of the Ad. Mech. is their leaning on latin and italian words use
yeah, for nearly everything
while at the same time, they also have their ties to roman and greek armies
Opposed to the kinda futurist mix of english and latin of the general imperium
Like, a ship of the imperial navy would be called like, "his divine right", or "green lake"... While Ad. Mech. called one of his ark mechanicus "Speranza", which is hope in italian, or one of its cruisers called "Maestrale" which is the italian name of the north-west wind
Therein lies the difference between gothic and high gothic, right? Gothic is a mix of english, french, german, and a few other languages, whilst high gothic is uniformly Latin.
If you ask me, all ships should have Latin names due to the nature of the people who own them, but that'd get confusing really fast
If we wanna be really anal mechanicus ships should really have names like "01011001 01100001 01101101 01100001 01110100 01101111" but that would be too annoying for BL writers.
I always liked how Mechanicus handled Binaric Cant and similar Ad mech language barrier things
Like, it sounds like someone is speaking, but its off.
the famous battleship 01011001 01100001 01101101 01100001 01110100 01101111, killed by thousands of fighter bombers
Don't park it near space midway
I think it's also that there's a lot of dialects and unique languages too
01001001 01101101 01110000 01100101 01110010 01100001 01110100 01101111 01110010 00100000 01110010 01100101 01111000 is a bit long for a ship name tho yea
I see people are very proficient with lingua techna here
It'd get really bad with ships like "Omnissiah's favoured war mace"
you'd end up with ship names so long the administratum scribes would weep themselves to sleep
more than they usually do, anyways
Assuming an admin scribe doesn't have their tear ducts removed for spilling a drop of ink once.
tho a blinking series of lights that strobes out the binary so all in the know can see
Nope, not really, high gothic was the universal language of the human federation during the Age of Tech, low gothic is the language that originated by that but evolved differently on each world... High gothic is written as a mix of english-latin, while low gothic is written as normal english in books
thats how i imagine the mechanicum does things, just all in binary of punch cards and lights
"Low Gothic is a bastardised version of High Gothic, combining additional elements from several of the oriental languages of ancient Terra. Over the millennia it has changed greatly, and now bears almost no resemblance to the tongues from which it derived. Although a common language, it varies from planet to planet (and even from region to region), so that it is not always easy for two characters to communicate if they are from different worlds."
'several oriental languages' feels a bit... touchy
regardless, even if its written as standard english, it certainly isn't spoken that way
Word choice is... Not great
I'm gunna guess that the above fluff is from a very old edition. Sourced from lexicanum, btw
that's profoundly silly
I mean, fenrisian is a low gothic dialect, and i'm pretty sure that hasn't any "oriental" earth language in it... So yeah, i imagine that the "oriental languages" is just old lore still not hard retconnected
I prefer this description
"It was quite common during the Dark Age of Technology for worlds to be settled by small communities of "isolationists". These eccentric groups were often self-financed and their journeys unrecorded, many were of racial minorities attempting to recreate a sense of national identity away from the overpopulated Earth. Some of these groups made a deliberate attempt to revive long dead or moribund languages, perceiving them as a source of national identity and communal strength. "
Honestly, I still think of Low Gothic as some ultra bastard language, like English but with even more words and half-forgotten words from old earth languages.
I'd hate to see a 40k era low gothic dictionary
It'd take the administratum scribes years to write that out
Low gothic is world dependant, and it wouldn't make sense imo to have a single dictionary
An Astra Militarum Guide to the Imperium's Low Gothic Variants: For the Discerning Imperial Guard
low gothic is pig latin
I'm honestly impressed that the Imperium's logistics can teach enough of the guard to read for it to be worthwhile giving them books
In fairness, it seems grimderp if the majority of the IG couldn't read
I feel like the Imperium, being as it is, is like many Authoritarian regimes. They live and die on their army.
You want to give your army every possible advantage.
Or that the munitorum don't care and give them books anyway
I suppose
but to be fair, reading is a very useful skill to have, so it's not completely impossible that they are taught how to read; though that too probably depends on the world
I think there might be comment about the illiterate in the primer actually
Ogryns also dont get a primer as theyed likely eat it or soemthing i forget
on top of the fact they cant really read
I cant rememeber if the illiterate still have to hold onto the primer but can ask someone to read from it for them
And i think its even says to ask your local commisar and theyed be happy to read it for you lol
yea id imagine a feral worlder wouldnt know how to read
Given how long it might take for a feral worlder to get to a war? They might be able to learn to read at least passably.
yeah they'd need a lotta training I imagine
Imperial Guardsmen are taught how to read as part of their training, while in transport to whatever warzone they are selected for
nice
hurray!
I suppose it gives them something to focus on in the warp
Its usully that + training
Its so they can actually read their primers and any written orders
Aside from the ever lingering thought and worry of "What if the Gellar field goes out unexpectedly." which I feel like everyone thinks about while in the warp.
You assume they know what a "geller field" is and what a "warp" is
That's fair
And I guess a Space Marine doesn't care either way.
But yeah...
Well, maybe a veteran trooper or some officer might worry about it.
Feral worlders just know that big metal ship from God-Emperor's cloud people picked them up and are teaching them how to fight better for God-Emperor
indeed
Imagine that right? You have been picked up, trained and taught for several months, have been told to completely forget your past life, and right as you get into orbit your ship gets blasted by planetary defenses.
Just lisened to a podcast about the fall of cadia. Big F in chat
Mabuse lifted an object from the table in his artificial hand. It was a figurine, about thirty centimetres high, woven from straw.
'A corn-doll.’ Mabuse told them, holding it up for them to see. 'A votive object, common on so many rustic and agricultural worlds. Here on Ceres, they weave them at harvest time, one to represent each of the outlying harvest towns, and they are displayed here in the main guildhall during the Time of Celebration.’
He lifted another from the table. There was something hideous and twisted about this one, even though it was only a doll woven from straw.
'I found this... and six more like it. Khorne-dolls, if you will. I see the pun is lost on you Marines too. Whatever. Each one has been made according to the practices of various harvest townships, but the designs have been perverted to make them symbols of the cult.'
🌽
"I see the pun is lost on you Marines too" feels bad man :(

thanks dan
Hi, I'm trying to start reading War40k novels but I can't find a starting place, someone have an advice ? I'm thinking maybe Sabbat Wars from Dan Abnett but I don't know wich one to buy first
You looking for guard or space marine books?
Guard, I want to get in the mood for DT
In which case I suggest one of the following as good start points
-Gaunts Ghosts
-Eisenhorn (its an inquis book instead of guard but its great)
-Ciaphas Cain
First and only is the first book
The Founding is an ombinus that contains the first 3 books
So If I want to binge read through it, The Founding would be a better choice ?
Yes
Nice thank you, the paper backs aren't worth the 30 dollars it seems
So I'll go straight to ebook
Last chancers is prettyy good
it was one of the first series i started with along with caiphas cain
I'll check it out, Gaunts Ghost is pretty good so fzr
they're both solid series
I went through audible and got all the gaunts ghosts books that are on audible
it was an excellent choice
damn Doomguy the Infinite stole your books
He won't even read them, he just wanted to spite you.
It would be really nice to know how much Mars and Terra developed differently during the Age of Tech imo
I’ve read them and stole them to spite
Quick question, is there necromancy in 40K? Like can the thousand sons raise the dead in shit?
yes
There is a need to make some distinction, zombies are a nurgle thing, but it is know that some psykers can indeed bring back the spirits of the dead from the warp
The thousand sons are capable to do so
Ok thanks!
And it is how they bring back their losses
Ghosts are a thing
There was that one psyker from the IG who could temporarily resurrect the dead so completely it was like they never died
for the Eldar things like Wraithguard are an act of Necromancy
Yeah in short Necromancy is basically another category of psychic power
It is definitely more complex than necromancy in WHF
I wanted to try to make my thousand sons necromancy themed, so I’m probably gonna have my leader be a necromancer and everyone else ghost boys or something
and varies from group to groupp
Yeee go for it my dude
fits their motif really well
That is exactly how thousand sons are
Dreadnaughts are Necromancy in their own way
Perfect
dreadnaughts are literally shoving cables into a mauled person to keep them alive
so they arent dead lol
they are virtually dead
technonecromancy
https://wh40k.lexicanum.com/wiki/Thousand_Sons
Take a look, mostly the part after the heresy
Bjorn has a presence in the warp though he was never a psyker in life
I don’t know what to do with my tzaangors though, not sure if they should be ghosts or maybe like zombies?
Probably will do ghosts so I don’t have to buy more paint
Ah, you watched the 40K theories video too?
I try my best
I like 40k Theories because he helps explain traitor legion loyalists. Because many grognards get pissy if I tell them the evidence. But if a youtuber says it, they accept it
:u
Evidence?
owo
Hmm?
are we talking Alpha Legion stuff
No
Who then?
Chapters like the Minotaurs, Silver Skulls, Carcharadons, Raptors, Death Eagles, Sons of the Phoenix, Covenant of Fire, etc.
Ah those guys
Yeah. The loyal successor chapters from the traitor legions
The skaven had advanced bioengineering and augmentation back in fantasy time, after tens of thousands of years of progression their tech was super advanced that it was used as the basic for the emperor to make his thunder warriors, costodes and eventually the space marines.
nice meme
40k has Skaven, but they aren't from WHF. They are from the evolving mutant rats in the deep Underhives of Necromunda
So just giant rats
🎷 
Vermintide vs Genestealer uprising would be fun
And on Necromunda, it could happen, and noone would care
honestly na
everyone is too busy
id rather get plague tale with smelt rats plz
Genestealer: rise up and take over the second largest hive on the planet.
Lord Helmawr: nukes that hive so hard that the Death Korps of Krieg would be impressed. Because Lord Helmawr doesn't play games.
Rat genestealers
smelt rats where its really at
Lord helmawr is a sick mofo
You have to be to be the ruler of Necromunda
Mostly to be grimderp
Like if you were to give me the governorship of Necromunda, I'd probably be dead within a week. Because I might be ex-military, but I am not ruthless enough to survive in that position
But Helmawr has been it's ruler for most of his life.
corpse pancakes for breakfast are where its at
I have screen shots from the Hired Guns game that show what corpse starch containers look like.

Hired Gun has good map design ye
They are kinda like cans of spam, or a cardboard box which I'm assuming contains dehydrated bars of corpse starch
I'm surprised Necromunda hasnt been taken over by genestealers yet
then again it does need to survive for the tabletop stuff
So... another hive world
No. Its Necromunda. Necromunda is on a whole different level than your run of the mill hive world
Having read almost 5 codexes on it not really tbh
its just more fleshed out if anything
You could change its name and it wouldnt be that different compared to any other high industrial hive world
pretty much
Necro-FUN-da
I can show you where a Genestealer cult took over a forge world. You know those things that the Mechanicius rule over that they really dont like anyone even getting near








