#40k-lore-chat

1 messages · Page 586 of 1

arctic talon
#

there's just a few mandatory Urge incidents mostly for plot progressions

celest dome
#

The dead 3's domain aren't really personal for them, they're just tools, or steps to their real goals

arctic talon
#

yeah

dusk patrol
#

They’re also all bitches to the real god of death

arctic talon
#

but The Dead Three are also lame and dumb smh

#

which one there's like 5

#

lol

dusk patrol
#

Yes

opaque coyote
#

"bro trust me, kicking that baby into the sun is fun"

celest dome
dusk patrol
#

At least the Tyranny god is a bit more interesting though

arctic talon
#

Kelemvor? Shar? The Raven Queen? Jergal? Loviatar?

dusk patrol
#

Bhaal is legit brain dead

arctic talon
#

Bane is also the strongest of the 3

#

lol

#

Myrkul and Bhaal are both kind of weak

dusk patrol
#

Bhaal probably murdered its own brain pan.

celest dome
arctic talon
#

Yeah

celest dome
#

Myrkul lorewise is the most successful iirc

dusk patrol
#

Banes schemes at least are vaguely interesting

arctic talon
#

Myrkul is the most successful since a lot of evil necromancers end up worshipping him

dusk patrol
#

Myrkul is there for whenever they need a big zombie army plotline or whatever so yeah

#

Bane is a bit more complex to write

#

Bhaal is there for when you need a big bad guy to fight

#

It in BG3s case

#

You just use all three

#

The people of Baldurs Gate really aren’t that wise based off the plotlines of the past games

#

Not sure why anyone lives there

storm jungle
#

same reason as Gotham

#

low rent

celest dome
#

Cause it's still a rather good city to live comparatively

arctic talon
#

Baldurs Gate generally is like the Second or third best city on the swords coast

celest dome
#

Waterdeep also has its issues

rose thorn
#

Hellos

dusk patrol
arctic talon
#

Waterdeep is like Chicago

dusk patrol
#

Like why the fuck are long lived races living there

arctic talon
#

no I will not elaborate

dusk patrol
#

If you’re hundreds of years old you’ve seen legit like

#

Six or seven apocalyptic events at the city

arctic talon
dusk patrol
#

It’s like these mfers don’t actually wanna live that long!

celest dome
#

Neverwinter, basically razed
Ethuriel, sent to Hell, literally
Waterdeep, mafia, gangs and shit, as well as many Drow backstabbers
Baldur's gate, except on very rare occasion where there is a massive thing happening, it's rather quaint

arctic talon
#

Elturel is also a terrible idea if you're a Tiefling or Warlock

celest dome
#

Then there are some other big cities, like Menzo, which you don't want to life in, unless you're a Fem drow, and even then you've got better places to live in if you really wanted to

#

There is also that old Dwarf forge but I forgot if it was lived in anymore

arctic talon
#

its not even on the swords coast is it?

#

its like more inland

celest dome
#

Menzo ? It's underground

arctic talon
#

yeah

#

I'm saying like the area aboveground isn't like on the swordscoast

#

either way living there is like a terrible idea even as a Drow lol

celest dome
#

More to the north iirc, but not that far from the Sword Coast, they've got a few tunnels gunning straight at Waterdeep iirc

arctic talon
#

you know that makes sense

#

either way Long lived races living in Baldurs Gate is funny

#

but any major settlement is also kind of just terrible in its own way lol

shell mason
#

Man

#

ngl

#

Missed hitting the gym like I use too

light parrot
#

Question. How many dog breeds still exist in the 42nd millenium? Could my homebrew inquisitor have a pet shih tzu? Could the dog have some special ability or justification to be in an inquisitor's retinue?

opaque coyote
#

Died

storm jungle
#

and for a justification it can literally be anything from a pet to just "I want a genetically enhanced attack dog"

opaque coyote
storm jungle
#

We have examples of non-cyber dogs

#

any animal breed can exist in 40k on writer demand

plush mason
#

even cows

storm jungle
#

^

plush mason
#

even though the grox exist

plush mason
#

if the isenbrak horror has normal ass earth horses on that random world in fuck knows where any animal can be on any world

#

speaking of, we need more stuff on the vampires

storm jungle
#

love that short

#

took me a moment to realise what the "horror" actually was lol

plush mason
#

yeah

#

it wasnt till the end i figured it out myself

#

honestly the warhammer horror shorts are just amazing

#

the setting is basically tailor made for such stories

storm jungle
#

yeah its great, i gotta read more of them at some point

plush mason
#

ngl warhammer has been making me want a kindle or audible for a while

light parrot
#

cyber shih tzu it is

plush mason
#

that, would be perfect for the rogue trader crpg

storm jungle
opaque coyote
plush mason
#

true

opaque coyote
#

They probably do have cows but for like

Royalty only

#

Tbf to Grox tho, their meat is stated to taste really fucking good

#

But then again it's 40k, so the usual faire for people who aren't royals probably consists of Emperor's Mercy Bars and Slab

#

Maybe Corpse Starch in harder times

#

So maybe Grox Meat actually tastes bad to us.

plush mason
#

wtf are Emperor's Mercy Bars?. oh right bullets

opaque coyote
#

Essentially they're civilian relief rations

plush mason
#

ah

opaque coyote
#

"Civilian Relief Rations are made from recycled food waste or any other organic materials and are used for civilian relief in areas of intense fighting. Also known as Emperor's Mercy bars, each can just barely keep a person alive for a day. The less said about their taste the better."

plush mason
#

yup that sounds like the emperor's mercy

opaque coyote
plush mason
#

yup

opaque coyote
#

Tbh now that I think about it

#

Slaanesh cultists probably don't have to even try to attract attention

#

They just say to their recruits

#

"hey want some decent tasting meals?"

#

So what if it has purple tentacles?

#

You've eaten weirder

arctic talon
#

Just like

#

really heavily processed grox

winter vessel
#

I compare Slab to real life Spam. Except the former is pretty much tasteless

arctic talon
#

Spam is actually good

#

Slab is

#

Slab seems pretty bad lol

crystal forum
#

i bet it doesnt taste that bad

#

add some sci fi artificial flavours

#

umami situation

crisp heath
#

Are there any stories or anything about imperial governors who aren’t entirely moronic?

#

Like are ANY of them good at their job?

#

All I’ve seen are half wits

crystal forum
#

the ones who are don't make for interesting stories

#

the imperium demands a tithe of every planet, if the governor sucks at his job and doesnt fulfill the quota, he's replaced

#

they dont give a shit about what happens on the planet as long as it does its main job

#

feeding plebs is just a bonus since it keeps the factories running

opaque coyote
#

On that topic

Do Servitors require food?

They still have a "brain" to maintain

#

And that brain is important for making it function

outer wave
#

Probably liquid nutrients at best for the brain maintainence

opaque coyote
#

Tau music sounds much different compared to human music

#

This is because the Tau have different hearing spectrums

#

So to humans, Tau music just sound like a bunch of random beeps, boops, and farts

#

So basically

#

T'au be like "damn this shit is fire":

outer wave
#

Damn this T'au music is fire

echo vault
#

Behold everyone, the Tyranid Dominatrix from Epic!

#

i kinda like it, the top bit reminds me of the chozo statues in super metroid and the semi living state they inhabit

#

its just a Tyranid Gargantuan Squiggoth/Orkeosaurus but i love him nonetheless

sacred ginkgo
#

Epic scale mini on a bike base is terrifying

#

I would google it but that name is interesting at best

arctic talon
#

L a r g e

sacred ginkgo
#

That gun is like the size of a land raider

echo vault
#

I like to imagine the thing in that purple command center can unlatch and is like a tyranid hive lord upper body that orders things around it I bet I just imagine it like a chozo in super metroid waking back up and fighting samus where it like goes from solid rock to living

shadow plover
#

y'all seen this then

echo vault
#

I was about to say the heirodule was inspired by the dominatrix but its so smol

#

thats so cool

rigid dune
#

What happened to Cadia survivors? As the planet is destroyed, are cadian soldiers now a finite resource? Or sis they resettle somewhere or something?

celest dome
#

Resettled, on many Planets

storm jungle
# rigid dune What happened to Cadia survivors? As the planet is destroyed, are cadian soldier...

Resettled as said above, basically given new worlds renamed to New Cadia with numerical designations at times.

New Cadians are made through cadian parents banging constantly but the matter of recruitment has became a subject of controversy in the Cadian ranks/command due to them being an finite people until they can get back to repopulating their numbers to some degree as they treat non-cadians that get assimilated to be a part of their regiments with contempt or outright racism.

rigid dune
#

But the planet itself, did that have any importence to the competence of the Cadians? I am thinking like the Rambo guys, like they would not have been "evolved" into Rambo without thier jungle planet would they?

storm jungle
#

No its just a planet.

#

lol

#

Catachan guardsmen dont really "evolve" as much as train into what they are to survive, the planet has nothing to do with it.

fallen plaza
#

We do love cadians here in lore chat, so glad they completely survived an apocalyptic event that should have killed them but didnt

storm jungle
#

Me when planetary evacuation exists

fallen plaza
#

If only it didnt

storm jungle
#

stfu

#

before i strap your ass to an asteroid

fallen plaza
#

Nah

#

You cant do shit

#

😁

fallen plaza
#

Unfortunately

storm jungle
#

Getting told by a BL author

#

completely destroyed

fallen plaza
#

😁

fallen plaza
green loom
wintry scarab
#

Space marine 2 spoiler? ||Ive just clocked onto the fact that firstborn armour is in the game meaning that the mk7 helmet also is. Retro armour pack and my life is yours!||

#

(for a fair price otherwise im saying mean words on the internet)

fallen plaza
#

Definitely gonna be a skin pack

storm jungle
#

also thats Deathwatch gear

#

and very much based on the minis

#

hence the firstborn look

dusk patrol
#

Cosmetic dlc is gonna be their primary motivator so we’ll get everything eventually I’m sure in terms of different Mks and chapter themes and stuff

#

Assuming the game does well

#

Which I’m guessing it will

storm jungle
#

It has space marines killing aliens.

#

of course it will lmao

fallen plaza
#

It’ll definitely have a good first launch

storm jungle
#

^

dusk patrol
#

I mean it’s also good

storm jungle
#

its deffo gonna lose steam but be a good game

#

its basic enough that anyone can play it

fallen plaza
#

In the long term though? We’ll see

dusk patrol
#

That’s kinda more important, based off all people who got early access it plays well and looks great

#

And runs great

storm jungle
#

I'll believe it when i see it

dusk patrol
#

How replayable it’ll be idk but it looks really solid

storm jungle
#

not once in my life have i seen early access people say anything true about the game aside from positives lol

dusk patrol
#

I don’t trust jack frags or whoever but the gameplay speaks for itself

storm jungle
#

LMAO

dusk patrol
#

And the leaked game earlier helps it too

#

I thought it was gonna be a lot more of a buggy mess

fallen plaza
#

The delayed beta didnt help that perception

dusk patrol
#

Yeah

storm jungle
#

as long as it doesnt fry my PC ill be good

#

i legit got no idea how they'll manage the nid hordes since its a big focus point with the WWZ tech

wintry scarab
fallen plaza
#

Im not buying it until, well, a steam discount, and a proper review.

storm jungle
#

Yea i couldnt resist i just bought the base version

#

i dont need any DLC slop anyway

dusk patrol
#

I’ll pre order it, if it sucks I’ll refund it

storm jungle
#

i doubt it will

#

this is the sorta game that like

#

gets boring after near 30-40 hours imo

#

so it'll be fine

dusk patrol
#

It looks really solid, the campaign alone interests me enough, and I know I’ll probably enjoy the multiplayer enough

wintry scarab
#

Im only buying once multiple people that already has the game say its good.

storm jungle
#

prepare for a lot of that week 1

dusk patrol
#

There’s also gonna be the early access thing for people

wintry scarab
#

All of space marine 2 looks way too good to be true. Thats my only worry. There is no catch so far.

storm jungle
#

4 days early, some sick shit

fallen plaza
#

Space marines in a game!!!!!! Im soying so hard!!!!!!!

storm jungle
#

my condolences

wintry scarab
dusk patrol
#

And the main game is gonna fall apart

#

The fact that they’re letting all these people show off gameplay is more proof of their confidence in it

dusk patrol
#

Modern gaming it’s also much more obvious if something is that bad

wintry scarab
#

I guess, true

storm jungle
# wintry scarab All of space marine 2 looks way too good to be true. Thats my only worry. There ...

Its basically gonna be a good game that people will enjoy more or less. Its definitely knowing what to do to distract people from some of its shortcomings ive seen from the recent footage with spectacles and big scenery pieces among other things.

Also again people like space marines so it will probably be another good entry point into warhammer as a good form of advertisement/primaris in general.

dusk patrol
#

You can’t hide a somehow broken game this much

#

Its a higher effort World War Z with better melee mechanics

storm jungle
#

^

dusk patrol
#

Which is fine by me

storm jungle
#

Its basic and people will like it yeah.

dusk patrol
#

Plus I get to play marines

fallen plaza
#

The entire reveals and gameplay just had me feel like “i should be hyped for this, but im not”

storm jungle
#

im not really a fan of the melee combat still since its very shoddy mid 2000's but ill live with it.

dusk patrol
#

With a lot of customization

storm jungle
#

they barely showed anything and the last Skulls was just them talking about the game lol

#

nowadays we get a footage of almost everything

dusk patrol
#

They still haven’t showed the Tsons parts in action

storm jungle
#

even filler shit like a 50s video of a boltgun

fallen plaza
#

This is why game companies should just stop announcing games so early

dusk patrol
#

It’s never gonna happen

wintry scarab
dusk patrol
#

A small part

fallen plaza
#

Im sick of getting endless teasers over nothing

dusk patrol
#

Mostly cutscenes

fallen plaza
#

That is a sexy tartaros

storm jungle
#

T.Sons got proper drip

dusk patrol
#

I mean how you fight them and how they play. And if they’ll be in the PvE mode

fallen plaza
dusk patrol
#

Which I assume they will

#

The other nice thing is how many options they have to add for the PvE missions for enemies

storm jungle
#

ketchup bottle lookin' ass

fallen plaza
#

Are you fucking serious

#

Red tsons was peak

dusk patrol
#

They literally have a lot of traitor legion models already done

dusk patrol
fallen plaza
#

I am that normie

dusk patrol
#

Supposed worshippers of the god of change when you ask them to paint their dudes anything other than blue or red

storm jungle
#

like an alpha legion reaver with a grappling hook is just

#

why

dusk patrol
#

Alpha Legion is sniper nerd

fallen plaza
#

That is kinda funny in a goofy way

dusk patrol
#

Zerker is Reiver

storm jungle
#

Plague Marine is Bulwark

dusk patrol
#

Which is oddly fitting

fallen plaza
#

The alpha legion having like batman villain gear

dusk patrol
#

I do hope they’ll give options for switching legions for classes though yeah

#

Or at least some decent customization

storm jungle
#

lmao

wintry scarab
#

I just hope the chaos marines get some love. I hope its not just loyalists. I beg for at least chaos customization. Because so far, we have only really seen full sets.

fallen plaza
#

Ive yet to seen customization options for traitor legions

storm jungle
#

we need more leaks

#

i cant wait 4 weeks

fallen plaza
#

4 fucking weeks

dusk patrol
#

There was color options I believe mentioned

storm jungle
#

thats for campaign stuff i think?

dusk patrol
#

Probably just make all my dudes black legion versions

storm jungle
#

you can buy color packs too

#

just like real life

wintry scarab
fallen plaza
#

A large group of black astartes

#

Its like a….

storm jungle
fallen plaza
#

Black legion of sorts

storm jungle
#

ooh right

#

whoops

wintry scarab
fallen plaza
#

Fruedian slip

dusk patrol
storm jungle
#

the other shit is cosmetic bundles/DLC

dusk patrol
#

Each class has a bunch of gear you can unlock

storm jungle
#

no idea how the grind for it will be

fallen plaza
#

I can imagine giving cosmetic options for legion players is much more tedious work wise

dusk patrol
#

It’s like 37 games per class to get it all

storm jungle
#

yeah the more way fancier shit is things you gotta pay real money for

#

also just like real life

fallen plaza
#

Unfortunately

dusk patrol
#

I just want bionics

storm jungle
#

you get one head cosmetic

dusk patrol
storm jungle
#

be happy bitch

dusk patrol
#

And a hand

fallen plaza
#

He looks so dopey

storm jungle
#

and iron one

fallen plaza
#

Like a grimdark golfball

wintry scarab
storm jungle
#

I legit dont expect fair pricing

#

we are talking bundles here

#

also like, space marine fans will buy anything

#

turns to camera

fallen plaza
#

40 dolla for one loincloth

dusk patrol
#

I don’t expect I’m gonna want to buy a lot of it anyways, it’s more just options

storm jungle
#

^

#

i enjoy default gear

fallen plaza
#

Nerd

dusk patrol
#

Then basic look is fine for me for most stuff

storm jungle
#

if it was up to me id just slap a firstborn helmet on my marine and call it a day

rocky gale
fallen plaza
#

His profile pic greatly exaggerated his looks

dusk patrol
#

Like if I’m doing IH it’s not like there’s much crazy gear to add, mostly just bionics and maybe the tech marine armor if they add that

fallen plaza
#

Much chubbier here

storm jungle
#

im just skimming through this again

#

trying to pick/see anything i missed

fallen plaza
#

I like the bulwarks shield options

dusk patrol
#

It’s definitely ultra themed for the base stuff mostly

wintry scarab
dusk patrol
#

But that also might not be all the base stuff

dusk patrol
fallen plaza
dusk patrol
#

More akin to halo

storm jungle
#

SM2 meanwhile mostly just remained in the dark before we finally get news this few months lol

#

also its been like

#

almost 3 years since the teaser

fallen plaza
#

I’d like to imagine it was GW that insisted on the delay lmao

storm jungle
#

lol deffo

#

this is a flagship advertisement game

wintry scarab
fallen plaza
#

Sm2 is for nerds who watch lore through youtube shorts

dusk patrol
#

My thing is, there’s probably not gonna be a fomo shop

#

With how they’ve said theyre doing it

rocky gale
#

Isn't there preorder exlusive skins?

storm jungle
#

Cant wait for people to go "I dont wanna play an asian person wheres the head option swap"

storm jungle
dusk patrol
#

And it’ll probably be largely a lot of stuff I can skip

dusk patrol
wintry scarab
fallen plaza
storm jungle
dusk patrol
#

I would like alternative head options tbh

#

Not really a reason not to have them

#

Make your own dude

storm jungle
fallen plaza
#

Weird they didnt add it on this build

wintry scarab
fallen plaza
#

Especially for things like space wolves

dusk patrol
#

But I am also an extremely closeted racist so it might just be that

rocky gale
#

Where's my female head options?

storm jungle
#

Oh my god just imagine

fallen plaza
storm jungle
#

some dude going on a tangent

#

like that pronouns thing in starfield

fallen plaza
#

Dont push it

#

The pronouns one is at least funny

storm jungle
#

basically the same thing tbh

fallen plaza
#

If that got added it will just be ugly

dusk patrol
#

They’re not gonna put female space marines in lol

fallen plaza
#

That would be a perfect april 1st update though

storm jungle
#

im bored

fallen plaza
#

Just give them female heads and not even change the voice

fallen plaza
storm jungle
fallen plaza
#

I missed when i first discovered this franchise

dusk patrol
#

I already have to put up with women 50% of the time irl that’s enough for me

wintry scarab
dusk patrol
#

My brother and I went to see Twisters

storm jungle
#

female custodians is better anyway

#

literally the best option they could go for lol

dusk patrol
#

I think the female population of the US should apologize for letting that dogshit movie be successful

storm jungle
fallen plaza
#

Real talk female sm is kinda lame and not as cool as female custo

storm jungle
#

i agree yeah

dusk patrol
#

Like, ffs just watch the Sidney Sweeney Glenn Powell movie you horny fucks

#

He gets almost naked in that

storm jungle
#

female custodians at least basically showcases space marines are mass-produced genetic basic-boys

#

while custodians just can get anyone they want in because they are peak human or whatever

fallen plaza
#

The whole male custodians thing was probably an oversight

storm jungle
#

Uh

#

we do know it was planned way back

#

so its not like there isnt presedence for it

dusk patrol
#

They don’t work as well if you add women too imo without making the women basically just dudes

wintry scarab
# storm jungle female custodians is better anyway

Maybe its because im a chad that has read like 3 40k books ands gest most of my lore from videos and games, but i really didnt mind the custodes being female. From what ive seen, it makes sense for them to be at least a few. I saw how gw handled it tho on social media and imo that was not a good way of doing it lol.

storm jungle
storm jungle
#

custodians are the sub-faction of sub-factions

#

them having girls makes sense, they'll take anyone for trials since their genetic methods of recruitment is literally pseudo-psychic science alchemy

#

the controversy is just from this fandom being filled with sexist/homophobic chuds lmao

fallen plaza
#

I dont think so personally

storm jungle
#

it absolutely is

#

lol

fallen plaza
#

I just think the entire thing was jusr forced and added poorly

storm jungle
#

Nah

dusk patrol
#

For similar reasons I don’t want Sister of Battle to have dudes in this ranks, beyond like special units which aren’t actually SoB, because there is an inherent feminine aspect to them and it’s ok for that to exist

storm jungle
#

Thats literally never gonna happen tho

#

and is a moot-point

fallen plaza
#

Like i recall GW blocked anyone who complained about it on there twitter

dusk patrol
#

Just like there’s an inherent masculine aspect to marines and that’s ok too

storm jungle
#

their entire identity is being a female order

#

why the fuck would they give them dudes lol

dusk patrol
#

Same as marines yeah

#

Which is my point

storm jungle
#

Well yeah basically lol

fallen plaza
storm jungle
#

it was genuinely ridiculous

#

was it poorly handled, sure, but it didnt stop some people from being total psychos about it

wintry scarab
dusk patrol
#

I think there was plenty of reasonable reasons to not prefer female Custodes, the discourse all sucks anyways and I don’t really enjoy talking about it

storm jungle
#

there really wasnt tbh

#

again sub-faction of sub-factions

dusk patrol
#

There is, you can just prefer they remain all male

storm jungle
#

if you were this upset over a retcon like this you definitely have not seen the worst of it over the years

dusk patrol
#

It’s that simple

storm jungle
#

like at all lol

#

"oh the emperor is sexist"

storm jungle
#

since when

dusk patrol
#

The same reason I can prefer anything

storm jungle
#

So no reason

#

lol

fallen plaza
#

I like men thats why

dusk patrol
#

Like I prefer SoB remain all female, I prefer Astartes remain all male

storm jungle
storm jungle
#

so not really

fallen plaza
#

Right

dusk patrol
#

Why? They can literally just write it so it changed

storm jungle
#

Left

storm jungle
fallen plaza
#

I think we should stop before this gets worse

storm jungle
#

custodians never had a "male only" rule

dusk patrol
#

They did

fallen plaza
#

Im tired of this discussion

storm jungle
#

only some wordings like "brotherhood"

shadow plover
#

SoB being women is well explained in world and the reasoning makes sense(also the army range has like 30% of males so that doesn't even compare well), space marines not so much

dusk patrol
#

That lore got changed

wintry scarab
storm jungle
#

and a codex passage people dont pay attention to

dusk patrol
#

They were definitely all male until they retconned it recently

storm jungle
#

there isnt anything like that 30k booklet where it outright says only men can be custodians

#

Theres a difference between

  • "They take noble sons"
    and
  • "Only the genetic science of the astartes allows men at any time by any means to become na astartes"
fallen plaza
#

This again

#

I should have never brought this up

storm jungle
#

this is just semantics, its a harmless change and it doesnt matter

#

literally just get over it

green loom
dusk patrol
#

I dont care much but they’re both similarly easy things to retcon frankly if you wanted to

storm jungle
#

Not really

#

again

#

your two factions you bring up got the gender thing in their identity

#

custodians dont

fallen plaza
#

Easiest way to soft retcon it

dusk patrol
#

The Custodes definitely did

storm jungle
#

No they did not

#

You are cherrypicking pretty much

fallen plaza
#

We can say that the emperor demanded tomboys within his custodians so the boys can be less shy

#

Thats why there were no females prior to this

shadow plover
#

They just happened to only have all male cast thus far, no definitive all bros club

dusk patrol
#

I’m not, it’s fine they retconned it but there was definitely a masculine dichotomy vs the sisters of silence feminine one

fallen plaza
#

You couldnt notice

storm jungle
#

Ah yes

#

the SoS

#

the girls who literally have been mostly forgotten both in universe and by the writers

#

and gotta keep their mouth shut

#

lmao

green loom
#

Dilara how far down are we on the argument checklist

storm jungle
#

Honestly beats me

#

i hate this dumb argument

dusk patrol
#

Sisters of Silence have a ton of great stuff in novels and lore

storm jungle
#

They really dont

green loom
#

I think this is like point 5 in the category of "no one cares"

wintry scarab
dusk patrol
#

Their models range is the real issue

storm jungle
#

also like, i dont need people to speak for me when it comes to female facton representation either.

fallen plaza
storm jungle
#

probably the biggest thing i hated when female custodians were not a thing

#

"oh you got sisters of silence"

green loom
#

Ever

#

Glances at Rogal Dorn Tanks, Glances at Primaris

rocky gale
#

To think this started with a joke about female head options

raven stone
#

And the most hilarious thing is, they claim they won't complain if Sisters of Silence got Custodes Statlines...

dusk patrol
storm jungle
# wintry scarab From the research that ive done (minimal), Isnt the main issue people have is th...

Basically its the main 40k thing of always having transhuman characters be male due to the player demographic, the Custodians also got this treatment since they are pretty old as a part of the lore, in the mid 2000's they were gonna get introduced in a novel but the only reason they werent was simply because the minis for them were already produced and had male heads so the author got told this in response, so its not even about the lore either.

storm jungle
#

it legit comes off as mansplaining to me

#

as much as i hate the word lmao

green loom
raven stone
#

The craziest thing of all is they try to treat 40k lore with the same vigour as...real life archaeology.

storm jungle
#

ah yes

#

the real life archaeology

#

oh uh

#

"gene alchemy"

dusk patrol
#

You’re putting an argument in my mouth also, I’m not claiming the SoS were some replacement but there was clear masculine themes with the Custodes vs feminine ones for SoS and that was the dichotomy.

storm jungle
#

....

#

Who the fuck cares about the dichotomy

#

lol

green loom
#

As clear as this mud I'm drawing

raven stone
#

Look mate, just do what I do: if you don't like it, mentally redact it and move on.

storm jungle
wintry scarab
spring cairn
green loom
#

The only dichotomy there was that one had boobs and the other had man boobs

dusk patrol
#

Who cares about any of this, I’m just saying why people were allowed to prefer male Custodes and it’s not some inherently terrible thing

storm jungle
#

I mean

green loom
#

You do

storm jungle
#

you clearly do as much as me to talk this much

green loom
storm jungle
dusk patrol
storm jungle
rocky gale
storm jungle
#

You can simply just not care about it, its an inconsequential change to most people.

A setting filled with this many retcons and this is what people get caught up with is just silly.

dusk patrol
#

My point is it’s perfectly valid to jsut prefer one thing, jsut like I think it’s valid to what female space marines even if I think it’s a poor choice and shouldn’t be done

storm jungle
#

"Oh they ignored the wordings on this codex"

dusk patrol
#

People acting like the only reason you can prefer Custodes to be male is because you hate women or whatever is what’s more annoying

storm jungle
#

Thats the thing though

dusk patrol
#

The entire discourse was and is cancerous

storm jungle
#

the vocal majority are literally this lol

#

idk why people act like this fandom is not infested with racists and bigots

spring cairn
#

yeah it's because the discourse has been polluted by actual braindamaged individuals

dusk patrol
#

Not in my experience but the entire thing was poisoned from the start so it doesn’t matter

storm jungle
#

in your experience huh

#

i guess i just imagined all the statue/marine pfp people i banned over the years

dusk patrol
#

It’s impossible to tell because it immediately became mud slinging

green loom
storm jungle
#

^

green loom
#

It's inconsiquential

storm jungle
#

Pretty much.

rocky gale
#

Just like there's nothing actually stopping me putting lady heads on my Marines

dusk patrol
green loom
#

Just because some of them have a weaker jaw doesn't really reduce them as a faction

dusk patrol
#

That has nothing to do with my point

storm jungle
#

IS NOTHING SACRED ANYMORE

dusk patrol
#

Nothing stopped anyone from making female Custodes models before either

fallen plaza
#

I'm just mostly disappointed because this might give them ideas to do things even more stupid if this is how they retcon things

storm jungle
#

"even more stupid"

#

have you been like

#

living under a rock

fallen plaza
#

They always find a way

storm jungle
#

"We got this entire brand line of marines that were hidden under mars for billions of years"

#

lol

dusk patrol
#

That’s not a retcon though

storm jungle
#

....

#

💀

dusk patrol
#

A retcon is Indomitus

shadow plover
#

Neither is women custodians jermaDance

dusk patrol
#

And how they changed the timeline for that

storm jungle
dusk patrol
shadow plover
#

How

dusk patrol
#

It’s fine that it is

#

But it is

green loom
#

Ok so like

dusk patrol
#

There’s zero examples of them before, they’re always mentioned to only be male, they were only male before

fallen plaza
dusk patrol
#

Now they can be female too

storm jungle
#

any new mini

#

or storybeat

#

or plot point

shadow plover
#

There was zero mention of sub terrain space marines on mars before too

storm jungle
#

but of course no my bad

#

this is completely different

storm jungle
#

we simply werent TOLD

green loom
#

Okay but why shouldn't they have women

storm jungle
#

because lore

#

and retcons

#

thats the argument

#

lol

fallen plaza
#

Right I think you should all shut up now

storm jungle
#

nah

wintry scarab
#

This is all just boiling down to the fact that it was handled poorly. Just like primaris or any other stupid choice GW has made.

spring cairn
dusk patrol
dusk patrol
#

Which is fine btw

#

But it definitely a retcon

storm jungle
#

any othe retcon

#

so the Newcrons are bad

green loom
#

Brb moving the goalpost

dusk patrol
#

There’s been several retcons in 40k

storm jungle
shadow plover
#

It hasn't been established that there were zero women as custodians before

dusk patrol
#

It’s a fucking retcon though

storm jungle
#

oh my god

#

get over it dude

storm jungle
#

This is like

dusk patrol
#

It was always specifically men

storm jungle
#

peak form of whats it like talking to a guy with a space marine pfp

shadow plover
#

Literally never has it been stated that there were men and only men

dusk patrol
#

I don’t get why does it even matter that it’s a retcon?

spring cairn
#

i think a "source" should be able to settle this fairly

dusk patrol
#

Who cares

storm jungle
green loom
fallen plaza
#

Noble sons of terra

storm jungle
#

fucked up

fallen plaza
#

That was the wording I remember

storm jungle
#

yep pretty much

green loom
#

Like a lot of other things that were "known" smilecat

storm jungle
#

also "brotherhood of demigods" even tho brotherhoods can have women in them lol

shadow plover
#

And those were something along the lines of "sons of whatever" when referring to a group of custodians etc

fallen plaza
#

I should punt all of you right now

storm jungle
dusk patrol
#

Why would they need to change the wording the codex if nothing changed

storm jungle
#

I can literally

#

make this exact argument

#

about the dorn tank

#

why is it here

#

why did we need a new tank

#

it was established we had better bigger tanks

spring cairn
#

we always need more tanks

storm jungle
#

omg guys

storm jungle
dusk patrol
storm jungle
green loom
#

Sure you aren't lol

storm jungle
#

Its not my fault like

#

you are outright denying toxic fans dont exist in this fandom

dusk patrol
storm jungle
#

lol

dusk patrol
storm jungle
#

You literally said

fallen plaza
storm jungle
#

in "your experience"

#

you never saw any

dusk patrol
#

No

storm jungle
dusk patrol
#

I said that it wasn’t some vast majority of everyone against the idea were all deist and toxic

storm jungle
#

nitpicking this one stupid change out of an entire setting of stupid retcons

#

like

#

its a game of about toy soldiers

#

idk why everyone is this pent up about it lmao

crisp heath
#

When did the deists get involved

storm jungle
#

beats me tbh

crisp heath
#

Why we getting theological

dusk patrol
#

No I’m getting annoyed because you’re trying to act like it’s not a retcon for some reason when it definitely was, it’s fine that it was. GW has done this before, it’s a fairly big change for a faction.

green loom
#

(It isn't)

spring cairn
#

we can get really theological if you want

#

at least I can

dusk patrol
#

If it isn’t then why do you care at all?

green loom
#

Why do you

dusk patrol
#

Im not even against it

#

I just don’t think inherently being against it is some horrible thing

storm jungle
#

Bro why are you dragging this argument out so much

#

agree to disagree lol

dusk patrol
#

Same as I get why people want female space marines

fallen plaza
storm jungle
#

also inb4 this guy says im the one doing it

storm jungle
dusk patrol
#

I mean I’m getting annoyed cause people are trying to paint me in a bad light instead of jsut arguing in good faith and not being snippy

storm jungle
#

Yeah because you dont really paint your position in a good light either.

#

Again, agree to disagree.

fallen plaza
#

He really isnt

dusk patrol
#

When I know I’ve more than earned the right to know I don’t think that way

fallen plaza
#

In fact he is probably the most neutral I've seen people argue this

storm jungle
wintry scarab
#

I will say im siding with Eternal here. Things are getting a bit mean.

fallen plaza
#

Y'all are the ones actually being agitated by this

#

Not eter

green loom
dusk patrol
#

Anyways, whatever

#

I’m excited for space marine 2

spring cairn
#

should change topic to something not controversial like the pigmy faction of ye olden days

storm jungle
#

shut the fuck UP

fallen plaza
#

Uh

spring cairn
#

and why they should be introduced to 40k

low locust
#

The only problem I have with the retcon is that it seems to be lazily/sloppily implemented. I.e. it isn't followed up by new books/lore or similar things. I'm not a mini-guy myself, but has James even released female custodes minis?

fallen plaza
#

I like fire trucks and monster trucks

storm jungle
dusk patrol
#

I personally thought the pygmies were a very tasteful portrayal

spring cairn
#

there's no good way to retcons sadly

low locust
green loom
fallen plaza
#

I especially like how they portrayed araby

raven stone
#

Orks are joining the Kill Team Chalnath mess

dusk patrol
#

The real answer to all this is they should have done it back when they first did the heresy revamp and model line

storm jungle
green loom
#

Make a big show of Checks notes
Allowing women?

spring cairn
rose thorn
#

discover the fate of helcrown

That city is a fucking of dust with these win rates

low locust
raven stone
#

Tabletop Cathay MIGHT tempt me to join Old World

fallen plaza
raven stone
dusk patrol
#

And the dragons

spring cairn
#

TT cathay and kislev for the old world, i wanna see those models gw

green loom
rose thorn
rocky gale
#

Cathay doesn't have like old Fantasy models does it?

spring cairn
#

(don't play old world just get total war warhammer)

rocky gale
#

So if they add it to Old World it would be the first faction with only new models

rose thorn
dusk patrol
#

They were only vaguely spoken about

green loom
dusk patrol
#

Nothing established really

fallen plaza
dusk patrol
#

Same as Nippon

fallen plaza
#

The TW stuff is genuinely cool

spring cairn
dusk patrol
#

Kislev I think had a couple things?

shadow plover
spring cairn
#

thx to CA

low locust
dusk patrol
#

Or at least some concept

green loom
#

They make a short story with one, in a codex

#

I don't think that's lowkey

storm jungle
#

No comment.

dusk patrol
#

It’s something

green loom
dusk patrol
#

I wouldn’t call it much

rocky gale
#

Oh hey, did you notice they were launching a new edition of the Lord of the Rings game

storm jungle
#

fantasy minis...

rocky gale
#

People were saying it was getting shelved after this edition, so nice to see that rumour was fake

dusk patrol
#

But they’ll probably have a female Custodes in the next watcher book

fallen plaza
#

Shoutout to the 4 players who play middle earth

spring cairn
#

real heroes

dusk patrol
#

Middle Earth I think is primarily collectors based off stats

#

Not a lot of people playing the game

shadow plover
#

I know two different people who play it and both of them have their own groups playing it so it can't be too uncommon

dusk patrol
#

Is the new Rings of Power out yet? Idk if I’m even gonna watch it but

#

Maybe idk

#

First season was ugh

wintry scarab
# spring cairn there's no good way to retcons sadly

I disagree. I think there are good ways to retcon. Look at your favourite franchises. If they are old, they will most likely be filled with retcons. But those retcons are what make it so good now. Something like clone troopers in star wars. They were retconned to have personalities and have a chip in their heads when order 66 happened.

green loom
rocky gale
#

Some cool new looking Carn Dûm models though

dusk patrol
#

I’ll say it was funny people complained about the one elf dude being black when he was imo by far the most interesting and best part of that show.

fallen plaza
#

They look okay

dusk patrol
#

Probably

storm jungle
#

Raceswapping is whatever as long as the acting is good

spring cairn
#

but they're always "forced"

#

and so imo you can't do them smoothly

storm jungle
#

^

#

even smallest stuff

#

people will complain lol

spring cairn
#

it's a contradiction

wintry scarab
spring cairn
#

for sure

storm jungle
#

We should retcon you

rocky gale
#

I think I stopped watching Rings of Power after like the second episode

storm jungle
#

out of this group

wintry scarab
fallen plaza
#

Alright

#

Now for something interesting

storm jungle
fallen plaza
#

Whats your mini hottake, what do you not like

rocky gale
#

My mum looked at me and asked "Are there any more episodes out yet?" and I told her no, so she said "Good because we're not watching anymore"

storm jungle
fallen plaza
#

😁

storm jungle
fallen plaza
#

Lies

storm jungle
#

i searched "up your ass" and i instantly regret it

fallen plaza
rocky gale
# fallen plaza Whats your mini hottake, what do you not like

My first complaint about the show was them showing Galadriel being bullied by the other Elven kids and her brother tells her "You must touch the Darkness to understand it" when like this is Valinor, beneath the light of the two trees and the Silmaril, Darkness isn't a thing yet, this is before the coming of Morgoth and Ungoliant and the poisoning of the Trees, Night and Darkness and Evil aren't even concepts that the Elves would understand or know about at this point.

fallen plaza
#

Not spoilers kek

rocky gale
#

I mean it's not really a spoiler

#

It occurs within the first 2 minutes of the first episode

storm jungle
#

ruined the show

#

good job lady

green loom
#

Brb spoiling Space Marine 2

#

Titus is in it

dusk patrol
#

Next you’re gonna tell me he’s a space marine

paper haven
storm jungle
#

I was joking but still lmao

dusk patrol
#

It has some issues

paper haven
#

I haven't actually watched the show, but I do know lots of people complained

dusk patrol
#

It wasn’t the worst thing ever but yeah it’s not that great

#

Idk

storm jungle
#

if you know most stuff about LOTR its mostly just butchery

dusk patrol
#

If you cut it correctly it’s about a bunch of persecuted Vogue models with pointy ears being enslaved and attacked by the Uggos

#

But fortunately they can do complex synchronized dance attacks and arrow shots

storm jungle
dusk patrol
#

Oh sorry that’s actually leaked footage of the Battle of the Gullet

#

When Jace sees a bolt out of the corner of his eye

storm jungle
shadow plover
#

Without knowing pretty much anything beyond the movies (which I adore), the LotR show was pretty good. Enjoyed the first season more than the first season of House of the Dragon which came out around the same time

shadow plover
#

Classic Dilara moment

storm jungle
raven stone
#

Meta meme time

shadow plover
#

if we'd grow stronger from all of this, then maybe

glossy turret
#

lets see how many down votes the word tau gets fellow imperials

storm jungle
#

the what

still cove
#

What's the status of the mk 6 Corvus armor in the most current era of 40k? Banished to sanctified antiquity due to GW's money lust Primaris boys or is it still used by anyone at all? (ping me with answers and feel free to add book sources I'm just curious since it's my fav armor)

storm jungle
#

theres no reason for them to be exactly out of commission

shadow plover
#

Primaris also has it's version of it

storm jungle
#

yeah GW knows better than to expunge older armor marks

#

its the same reason they couldnt replace the terminator armor

#

too iconic essentially

still cove
#

Oh I didn't expect a fast answer

#

nice

storm jungle
#

Ye the only obscure shit is like the stuff chaos marines still wear like the extendo-exhaust pipes and other way obscure traitor legion specific shit like sarum helmets and whatnot

shadow plover
storm jungle
#

but Chapters still keep that thing of "we got 30k gear because we found a stash" among other excuses for it

shadow plover
#

Shrike also has the helmet but doesn't wear it on his model

#

it's dangling on his belt

storm jungle
#

fucking gay-ass character

#

GO BACK TO SAINTS ROW

shadow plover
storm jungle
#

Exactly, it doesnt

still cove
#

Emo never went out of style

queen laurel
storm jungle
#

I WAS GONNA SAY

#

LMAO

dusk patrol
storm jungle
#

what a twink

shadow plover
#

who the fuck remembers the names of Saints Row characters

queen laurel
#

oh that is funny

storm jungle
#

who cannot remember Johnny Gyatt

still cove
#

beaky boys can always get it from me and by "it", heh. well. let's just say... my assistance and sacred knowledge of rites of maintenance, for free

dusk patrol
#

He’s not wrong tbh

shadow plover
#

you know exactly what that means

storm jungle
shadow plover
storm jungle
#

people love dildo-masks

dusk patrol
#

All I remember is Johnny

storm jungle
#

all because hes played by that chad asian actor

still cove
storm jungle
#

NOOOOOO

still cove
#

It's the bird shape

storm jungle
still cove
#

😈

dusk patrol
#

You have ad mech pfp

#

Saying you’re a furry is redundant

still cove
#

Yeah and

#

TRUE

queen laurel
storm jungle
#

skitarii also ride dog-horses

queen laurel
#

really really hit it on the nail there

still cove
still cove
queen laurel
still cove
storm jungle
#

all furries have to be in some high paying position

#

we dont make the rules, society does

still cove
#

I'm not

storm jungle
#

or else

still cove
#

I'm in Costco

shadow plover
#

then you're too young

still cove
crystal forum
#

@arctic talon literally you

still cove
shadow plover
#

well that's still pretty young

still cove
#

About middle aged for me seeing that most of my dad's side dies between 40-60 lul

plush mason
still cove
#

I was thinking about making a space marine blorbo

crystal forum
still cove
#

That's why I asked about the armor

#

ty for help

storm jungle
#

any other questions you can just ask here

still cove
#

I don't usually go here. Maybe later

storm jungle
#

damn

still cove
#

Tried to look up stuff elsewhere but couldn't get a clear answer so I figured I'd ask here

#

Thanks Reddit (sarcasm)

queen laurel
wintry scarab
#

Is there a darktide update coming out before SM2 or is it basically joever?

still cove
#

They will break their fists upon my dense skull chadgryn

queen laurel
still cove
queen laurel
#

I win

storm jungle
queen laurel
#

But yes i'm f****** with you

storm jungle
#

I can confirm this as a playtester

queen laurel
#

Just try to ask a question that isn't too broad or something like that

storm jungle
#

we are working on nothing and just sitting in the test server playing apex legends

shadow plover
#

yeah the devs moved to france to work on SM2

storm jungle
#

^

outer wave
#

The final update is actually coming next week as a hotfix

#

Then it'll finally be abandoned, thank god.... finally...

still cove
queen laurel
#

Yes and as a reward for the loyal players we will get sent a gif of ranick twerking

queen laurel
#

Animated by yours truly notfuegonasaus

outer wave
#

Personally I hope they add in Wolfer also twerking it

#

He probably has a massive bubble ass

queen laurel
#

Or Jafon1

outer wave
#

Probably would end up being a 'too many cooks' situation but sounds cool at least on paper

shadow plover
#

yeah that sounds very likely

#

the too many cooks situation that is

outer wave
#

Yeah

still cove
#

Actually maybe I do have a high paying job for what I do.

I get paid $21/hr to touch wiener

outer wave
#

AYO?!

fallen plaza
#

THAT'S FR##KING GAY!

paper haven
#

I do enjoy the conversations that happen here

plush mason
tough haven
paper haven
#

Punished Farsight.

versed ledge
#

Venom Farsight

paper haven
#

He did break away from the main Tau empire, right? The comparison tracks.

versed ledge
#

Yup

outer wave
#

Yeah Farsight broke off from the Empire and is I think considered rogue

crystal forum
#

he pretty cool

fallen plaza
#

I liked his older model

crystal forum
#

though of course still in the neglected lore shadow realm

tough haven
#

The only section of tau society I appreciate

tough haven
crystal forum
#

they really do not care about things that aren't imperium or main faction xenos related

#

it's pretty sad

tough haven
#

I’d like metal gear more if it’s more wasn’t so schizophrenic and hard to follow

fallen plaza
#

Damn really? Sad.

tough haven
green loom
#

Idk farsight has a recent model and books unsmilecat

tough haven
#

It’s imperium first, chaos second, xenos third

tough haven
crystal forum
#

i know about the model but i didn't hear about the book

tough haven
#

Like what are they even doing now?

tough haven
crystal forum
#

which one is the most recent

tough haven
#

Uhhh, I wanna say fire and ice?

crystal forum
#

also model wise tau lack main character units so of course GW would give players farsight

green loom
#

Farsight, Crisis of Faith, Empire of Lies and then his Arks of Omen book

tough haven