#40k-lore-chat

1 messages · Page 476 of 1

storm jungle
#

but grimdark lol

#

the entire surface of the planet minus the area near the Palace is a hive city.

misty vector
#

still a bad and gross hive city?

queen laurel
#

a country

celest dome
storm jungle
#

like uh

#

they once blockaged the traffic of ship scoming through right

#

for a few hours?

misty vector
#

the so called 'holy terra'

storm jungle
#

millions died from starvation

storm jungle
#

lmao

celest dome
#

Didn't they once destroy a whole spire with all the people inside it to build something else ?

queen laurel
#

Is the horrible thing

storm jungle
#

I MEAN UH

#

yeah pretty dark

orchid lark
#

Imperial Fists recruit from this shit hole too

#

Explains why they suck

storm jungle
#

LOL

#

Kid named Fist đź’€

tulip brook
#

Considering maybe billions of people are just there waiting for their pilgrimage and not doing much else and nearly all the bigwigs in imperium set up shop there... Terra isn't a productive planet either

#

Exceptional shithole

storm jungle
#

^

#

the Vaults of Terra say this

#

it provides nothing

orchid lark
#

Theres little production there

storm jungle
#

it simply consumes

scenic bolt
#

I forget the book but one did put the earth population at quadrillions

queen laurel
orchid lark
#

Anything worth producing is done in the imperial palace or some bullshit cause custodes need their toys

storm jungle
#

Its because its spires upon spires upon spires or subterranean galore

storm jungle
#

The imports to Terra are constant

#

the planet literally makes almost nothing

scenic bolt
#

and quadrillions is so stupid because just the added mass of the people (not the buildings/food/water needed for them) would increase earth's gravity by a huge percent

storm jungle
#

Yep

#

it doesnt make sense

#

lmao

orchid lark
#

I know Baal and Ultramar are also like busy with pilgrims

#

But like those are the only two primarch planets that I know had people visiting them

#

No one gives a fuck about the other primarch homes lmao

#

The fuck is Kiavahr?

#

Im spending my life savings making it to Baal and hopefully my grandchildren by then could see the village Sanguinius lived at

storm jungle
#

its not explained

#

its just suppose to be handwaved

orchid lark
#

I hope nothing Devastating happens to Baal

storm jungle
#

LMAO

#

SHUT UP

#

đź’€

queen laurel
#

I am a firm believer that the tyranids should have eaten it

#

god damn Ka'fucka had to interfere

storm jungle
#

honestly best part with the Devastation is post-invasion the populace would barely notice the difference minus all the nid corpses

orchid lark
#

Reaches Ultramar and it got really busy,
“SOMEBODY IMPORTANT BETTER BE COMING BACK TO RUIN MY PILGRIMAGE “

queen laurel
#

this ******* who humbled sanguinius in their first round just had to save his little tiny world

orchid lark
storm jungle
#

KEK

#

its like the vatican all over again

#

including the extortion

orchid lark
#

“So if i help make most of these bolter rounds I can see where Sangunius home was?”

#

dies after two months cause of noxious fumes

storm jungle
#

Least unhappy detroit citizen

orchid lark
#

Somebody dropped an angelus boltround and it went off.
Ten people near it turned into minced meat.
Sorry but your father doesnt qualify for insurance

storm jungle
#

worst part is this really could happen

#

lmao

orchid lark
#

Promise?

queen laurel
storm jungle
#

:)

orchid lark
#

At least credit me

queen laurel
#

Just like how the imperium doesn't credit anyone

orchid lark
#

This truly is the imperium

#

The primarch Roboute Guilliman had returned baal secundus to its former beauty incredible.
No youre not allowed to even see it.

storm jungle
#

Baal secundeez nu-

orchid lark
#

Its a what kind of world

orchid lark
#

Para deez worlds

storm jungle
orchid lark
#

Sanguinius dies, Baal becomes a pilgrim world

#

Ferrus dies

#

Nothing happens

#

You love to see it

#

Iron Hands lovers deserve nothing

storm jungle
#

to be fair

#

even if they wanted to pilgrimage there i doubt IH would allow it

#

how many people even know Ferrus exists in-universe

queen laurel
orchid lark
#

It would be pretty fucking funny

#

If he was the only loyalists primarchs

#

That doesnt get mentioned in holy lessons

#

And lo 8 of the holy sons of the Emperor fought back against the evil 9 demons

orchid lark
dusk patrol
#

There’s a holiday named after him called Gorgonsday

#

And nobody does pilgrimages to Baal or Medusa or most chapter worlds

#

Based off Devastation of Baal even their successors rarely actually visit Baal

orchid lark
unborn phoenix
#

Idk where else to put this image so I'll put it here I guess

orchid lark
#

Just hanging at boston airport huh

#

Ignore the fact i recognized it that fast

unborn phoenix
#

Meh

#

Good lighting and I can put my crafting spots here nicely

#

I didn't expect the armor to be that clean

dusk patrol
#

The IH hate any sort of monuments or whatever being built in honor of them anyways, and actively discourage it. Kardan Stronos has been their defacto leader for close to 700 years and the only thing he has is a small plaque on Medusa.

#

They don’t even have a huge setup for Ferrus’s skull.

unborn phoenix
#

It says it's mark 4 armor

dusk patrol
#

Doesn’t look like it

#

Seems like Aquila

queen laurel
dusk patrol
#

This is Mk IV

unborn phoenix
#

Pre or post heresy

orchid lark
#

Or

dusk patrol
unborn phoenix
#

Ok

orchid lark
#

Congrats we named two sons of horus characters

#

The Either and The Or

dusk patrol
#

Mk7 Aquila is the first one post heresy made

#

Which is the basic armor you see most firstborn have before primaris

unborn phoenix
#

Most of the blue boys have the primarus armor from the art of seen

#

I don't have too many chapters with this mod but some good ones

#

It comes with blood ravens, blood angels, dark angels, ultramarines, imperial fists, salamanders and iguanas

#

Oh and space wolves

#

It even comes with the company markings and squad

storm jungle
#

realistically speaking a Chapter cosmetic setup would be more diverse

orchid lark
#

Space Marines picks up so much shit over the years

#

No armour is alike

unborn phoenix
#

For the heavy tactic people the dark angles one has a checkerboard left knee pad and on the right pauldron has a arrow pointing left and right and a 40k version of a 3

orchid lark
#

Got their doodads

storm jungle
#

Imperial Armor marine lineups display it really well

#

even where some marines look identical they got small changes like how they wear the decorations on their armor or chest and whatnot

orchid lark
#

Its always important to dress up your dollies

storm jungle
unborn phoenix
#

Mod also came with bolter

#

I also have a sister of battle armor mod it's really good too

rocky gale
#

According to data these are apparently the most bought Drukhari boxes.

unborn phoenix
#

People like drukhari?

rocky gale
#

All are to be expected, although the Kabalite Killteam box is a surprise

shadow plover
#

Drukhari are surprisingly popular

rocky gale
#

Like the Patrol, Venom, Scourges and Drazhar are all so high because they're all pretty much essential to tournament lists

arctic talon
#

Drukhari are in a horrid spot

rocky gale
#

But the Kabalite Killteam gives no advantage to 40k tournament players so it's surprisingly high

arctic talon
#

That team is really fun

#
  • strong
green loom
#

Figure kill team is a popular choice for people who aren't into the faction as a whole?

orchid lark
#

Dark Eldar are nice models to collect

arctic talon
#

Yeah

orchid lark
#

I think theyre pretty much a staple for collections

rocky gale
#

Damn the Combat Patrol really is good, I'm tempted to get atleast one more before it gets replaced

unborn phoenix
#

The space wolves color looking like space puppies wtf is this color scheme

storm jungle
#

nuts I know

storm jungle
#
  • markings
rocky gale
storm jungle
#

this is an emote on the SW discord too KEK

green loom
#

Good for them good for them

storm jungle
#

they are furries and proud

#

can't blame em, can't blame em

unborn phoenix
#

I forgot they also got black Templar color scheme for this too

#

The blue Bois color scheme is great

#

Iron hands and raven guard have boring color schemes I realize why they didn't put them in

storm jungle
#

Its probably because they wanted to do popular Chapters first

#

black/white is a pretty good scheme

queen laurel
storm jungle
#

BRUH

orchid lark
storm jungle
#

đź’€

#

also women exist in fallout???

orchid lark
#

Goofy fucking pose

queen laurel
storm jungle
#

I thought men produced asexually in the vaults...

queen laurel
orchid lark
arctic talon
green loom
#

Lucy is pretty based

arctic talon
#

(Thank you vault tek)

green loom
#

Vault KeK

orchid lark
storm jungle
green loom
#

Lmfao

orchid lark
#

But she has to do Jinx’s voice from Arcane

queen laurel
storm jungle
#

||Id rather kill myself than be trapped with 99 Men in a vault ngl||

green loom
storm jungle
#

Nah

#

it would be worse

#

both for the 1 Man 99 Women and opposite

#

you'd be breeding stock đź’€

queen laurel
#

They would basically run a train and not the choo choo kind

storm jungle
#

^

scenic bolt
green loom
#

It'd be a lot worse for a minute but then they'd start feuding and killing eachother probably

orchid lark
#

I want to be in a vault with 99 assaultrons

storm jungle
arctic talon
queen laurel
scenic bolt
#

vault 969: 50 volcels 50 incels

orchid lark
storm jungle
#

your only use is the thing between your legs

unborn phoenix
#

Popular chapters? The iron snakes are popular? Cause theirs are included in this mod too

arctic talon
arctic talon
#

They got a book

orchid lark
#

I am a Wallfacer

#

I say the craziest shit

storm jungle
orchid lark
#

So no one knows what i am

rocky gale
#

Iron Snakes are pretty big, they're a Dan Abnett chapter

queen laurel
unborn phoenix
#

Id figure the white scars would get a thing but guess not

arctic talon
#

They didn’t get popular until recently

rocky gale
#

Brothers of the Snake was also the first 40k book I read

unborn phoenix
#

Id be cool if they did traitors too

arctic talon
#

When r/grimdank discovered Horus heresy/j

storm jungle
#

the Iron Snakes book is pretty intense...

unborn phoenix
#

Emperor's children colors

queen laurel
# storm jungle

I am going to be honest I might have turned ada into a Sentry bot

storm jungle
unborn phoenix
#

The purple and gold is nice

#

Thousand sons aesthetic are cool too

orchid lark
#

I wish Jinx would use her passive on me

storm jungle
#

bruh

orchid lark
#

See her speed up after she kills me

rocky gale
#

11 year old me should not have been reading that book.

storm jungle
#

you aint no Vi

storm jungle
queen laurel
storm jungle
#

đź’€

arctic talon
orchid lark
#

Nah Vi is taken, im not a home wrecker

#

I have standards

orchid lark
storm jungle
#

BRUH

#

đź’€

orchid lark
storm jungle
#

well true though but still

orchid lark
shadow plover
#

Damn WHEEEEEZE

unborn phoenix
#

I also have a power sword too so I'm fighting as the emperor intended

queen laurel
#

Homie is no longer swinging but doing combos

storm jungle
#

the Emperor would intend you to fight with your co-

burnt maple
#

And he would damn win.

orchid lark
#

Dilara confirmed for killing a sibling

storm jungle
#

I got 3 older male siblings

#

its fine

orchid lark
#

How many did you have before?

storm jungle
#

uhhhh

orchid lark
burnt maple
#

Expendable resources.

storm jungle
queen laurel
#

Wardens just be staring at Lore chat like

shadow plover
orchid lark
#

Dilara literally is a warden

rocky gale
storm jungle
#

Warden from Rainbow Six

orchid lark
queen laurel
orchid lark
#

What

#

You see his moustache

#

You know its true

arctic talon
#

I’m going to sleep

queen laurel
#

because this conversation be something

orchid lark
#

Would you rather I talk like this, or you have some dumbass make dumber claims here

rocky gale
#

I had to share a bedroom with my 3 elder brothers as a kid, I saw unspeakable things staregryn

orchid lark
queen laurel
green loom
#

My sister is me but normal, and thus infinitely worse

orchid lark
#

I had three older sisters, i watched kill bill and my eldest made me listen to prodigy

celest dome
#

njot a bad deal

orchid lark
green loom
#

"Normal" here means mildly racist, vain and also kinda stupid

rocky gale
orchid lark
#

JOKES

#

THATS A JOKE

pine wedge
rocky gale
#

Hank once again ensuring Imperial Compliance

orchid lark
#

Its nice when Hank does appear, and is actually a good Mod

#

Unlike Dilara

rocky gale
#

God Emperor Bless salute

orchid lark
#

Terra watches over him

pine wedge
#

actually, dilara making imperium apologists feel stupid is an essential part of keeping this channel clean

queen laurel
orchid lark
#

Dilara is Rorschach

green loom
#

The recent popular rhetoric is "Gaslighting"

vast heart
green loom
#

Anyway here's a dumb redditor

queen laurel
# green loom Anyway here's a dumb redditor

You don't mix your real life morals with them So what you're saying is it's OK to justify bad people because they're not real and also killing babies and making them into killing machines is fine because it's a fictional thing

#

My God people are stupid as fuck

orchid lark
#

Why would I fucking escape to a shittier future

unborn phoenix
#

Imagine Reddit

orchid lark
#

Its like daydreaming about being superhero

#

I hate working

#

You think i want to fucking be a superhero

green loom
#

"Trust me bro, making the average factory worker's life unbearable will totally dissuade crime and devil worship that will literally free them and kill the people pissing on him"

raven stone
pine wedge
queen laurel
pine wedge
#

fancy new golden graphic and everything

scenic bolt
orchid lark
scenic bolt
raven stone
orchid lark
green loom
scenic bolt
pine wedge
# queen laurel LET'S GO

I also made this video to walk through and give my thoughts on all the Ogryn changes in patch 18 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TowuWgNTJ_c

I thought this video would be 10 minutes tops, but it turned into 30 minutes of me rambling. Either way, I hope you find it informative and useful. Let me know if you have any further questions in the comments.

The Ogrynomicon has been updated for Patch 18 as well, check it out here: https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=30446...

â–¶ Play video
#

(yes my clickbait game is on point, thank you for noticing)

green loom
#

I think the funniest thing about that to me is that they think it stops the devil worship/stealers

#

Like stealers literally brainwash you

scenic bolt
green loom
#

That's not a guarantee but what would they know?

#

They catch the eye of some daemon, it gives them a brief vision in their mandatory 30 minute sweat break for the day, and they're immediately radicalized

raven stone
# green loom Like stealers literally brainwash you

Stealers definitely lean hard towards brute force brainwashing, with social issues as a (admittedly VERY weak) dressing.

Chaos, on the other hand…yea, the sucky nature of 40k is such that even a benign worker’s Union can somehow be turned into a Warp worshipping cult.

vast heart
#

There's an absolutely banger quote from the ahriman books that kinda mirrors that, daemons are very enticing to humans because they're constructed out of their baser desires and subconsious thoughts

#

brb finding

raven stone
#

TBH the “nobles are uncaring and corrupt” part of 40k lore I personally find borderline Grimderp.

#

Like, the threat of Chaos actually comes across better if the managers and nobles are not horrible people.

green loom
raven stone
#

The ability to corrupt genuinely benign things would sell the threat of Chaos better as well.

scenic bolt
#

it's likely still a holdover from the original framing of 40k before they introduced chaos into when it was corrupt imperium vs corrupt power grabbing rebels lead by horus

raven stone
#

Like, rather than “Chaos approached a bunch of repressed slaves and offers them freedom.”
Is far less scarier than…
“Some workers, who got along well with their managers, asked for a short extension of their lunch break, but for some weird reason, over time they became insane and started to worship the Warp.”

#

The latter adds to the “What the fuckness” factor of Chaos, if you will.

green loom
#

In Rogue Trader the first prison planet has the Warden being nice to the prisoners and granting them more food

#

It eventually devolves into a full on cult

raven stone
#

Ah a fellow Rogue Trader enjoyer

#

And 40k society is so skullfucked they actually thought that kindness was abnormal…

pine wedge
queen laurel
pine wedge
#

Inquisitors hunting down Chaos cults directly fueled by the relentless misery the Imperium's citizens are subjected to by its rulers is exactly the sort of illogical efforts that make 40k what it is: satire

queen laurel
#

They're so insane and maniacally devoted to a master that doesn't even care about them and is a rotting corpse that they just move forward

raven stone
#

Both make fair points.
I admit some of my views are biased from “how to make 40k function without it being too Grimderp (but potentially means we have to leave the satire behind).”

orchid lark
#

If emperor doesnt care then who gave my ex the clap?

#

Checkmate

pine wedge
#

the complete and total dysfunctionality of the Imperium is essential, I'm afraid.

#

too bloated, stagnant and inflexible to change course now: if the Inquisitors stop their work then the Imperium falls to Chaos, but there is no impulse to improve living conditions that can survive being scrutinized and destroyed as collateral damage in the neverending hunt for heresy

raven stone
#

Ironically might be why I like Recongrugator Inqusitors/Rogue Traders.
They are individuals who actually have in-universe capabilities to notice the dysfunction (even if they cannot change the overall picture at the end of the day)

queen laurel
pine wedge
#

because free thought and liberalism are treated with the same brush as homicidal sedition. the Imperium believes its intolerance is its strength, incapable of understanding that it is also the source of its downfall, and any attempts to make it understand are met with further suppression and persecution

storm jungle
green loom
storm jungle
raven stone
#

I think a very short hand way of describing the Imperium is that it is still living with Horus Heresy PTSD 10,000 years later on.
In all honesty, given how the Horus Heresy has transpired, if you take the 40k mindset and apply it to that civil war, it does make sense back then.

storm jungle
#

To be fair the Imperium lives because of money

#

no real society like this would even function

#

"realistically" speaking it would fall apart the moment all the Primarchs disappeared.

#

the Rift showcases this well where THE MOMENT the Dark Imperium was created everything went to shit since most imperial worlds are always on the edge of a boiling point

#

all it takes is a little push

orchid lark
scenic bolt
#

like the custodes would not just let the imperium hang they would reenact all the worst excesses of the praetorian guard in the roman empire under some logic of 'the best way for us to protect the emperor is for us to seize total power ourselves, after all we're his chosen'

storm jungle
#

^

#

its just "plot"

orchid lark
#

That said i dont think guilliman could fix argentina

pine wedge
#

making the Imperium more functional and reasonable immediately makes 40k less interesting

storm jungle
#

so like yes

vast heart
#

I mean logistically the imperium would absolutely not function

storm jungle
#

"It doesnt work"

#

"thats whats scary"

storm jungle
#

30k Imperium i can let slide

#

since the Emperor literally exists

#

without figureheads these organisations would instantly kill each other

vast heart
#

The fact that entire planets are responsible for food production for entire other planets with absolutely no ability to produce food is....certainly an idea

orchid lark
storm jungle
#

ME

pine wedge
#

he still exists in 40k and the unified belief of the Imperium in his guidance and his goals (even if completely warped and misunderstood 10k years down the line) is what keeps the whole thing

vast heart
#

In a universe where they have explicitly said one lazy pen pusher can send a wrong shipment and kill an entire planet

pine wedge
#

somewhat together

#

*constant uprisings and rebellions aside

storm jungle
#

religion can only do so much lol

#

as history has shown us

green loom
#

Should I play Helldivers or Fallout

storm jungle
#

đź’€

storm jungle
orchid lark
storm jungle
#

YEP

#

the Imperium exists because we gotta sell space marines

#

simple as

orchid lark
#

Like think of it exponetially

pine wedge
#

40k asks the question "what if your God was real and he blasts a continuously tangible beacon of light into the Warp to keep your society going?" so

#

transposing it to real religious history doesn't really work

orchid lark
#

I kiss the wrong high lords daughter

storm jungle
#

I mean

#

the imperial creed is literalyl Catholicism

#

so lol

orchid lark
#

And my balls has caused the worst economic collapse ever

storm jungle
#

also the Imperium as per GW is a "cautionary tale"

pine wedge
#

with God sitting in the Vatican and having real measurable divine power

green loom
#

The average person probably never travels through the warp/learns of that part tbf

storm jungle
#

"My power comes from god, do everything i say"

pine wedge
#

yeah but not with really real powers.

storm jungle
#

it went swimmingly for everyone involved

pine wedge
#

it's just not fully comparable.

storm jungle
#

Its pretty much suppose to be comparable

green loom
#

To most people the Emperor, hell even Space Marines are just a myth

storm jungle
#

the super powers of Big E are rarely showcased

#

unless you are a Sister

pine wedge
#

the Astronomican is constant and neverending

storm jungle
#

The Astronomicon functioned in 30k too

#

without the throne sitting part

#

so

pine wedge
#

it functions now, with the throne sitting part

green loom
storm jungle
#

so uh, no magic powers really needed

storm jungle
pine wedge
#

it's like spice in Dune. "he who controls spice controls the universe". but in this case it's the Astronomicon. and the Imperium controls that, so they rule forever and ever.

storm jungle
#

I mean

#

million worlds < entire galaxy

#

lol

#

so not really

vast heart
#

Have they confirmed that the astronomicon is an Old Ones thing or nah?

storm jungle
#

Kinda

#

its confirmed to have been a mix of alien and ancient tech

#

to showcase again that Big E is a hypocrite

vast heart
#

Bc I've heard that it's partly Necron tech partly aeldar tech and apparently neither faction fully knows how to work it

storm jungle
#

yep

#

its true

#

its from like 1 sentence in the End and the Death

#

lol

pine wedge
#

close enough, you know what I mean. the Imperium maintains itself because the God-Emperor is real and his power is real and the amount of people that believe that unifying under his rule is better continue to outnumber the people that think sedition is a good idea and that's why the monodominant majority continues to squash rebellions

vast heart
#

5 minute conversation with Magnus about daemons would've solved the entire heresy

scenic bolt
#

emperor undefeated in own goals

orchid lark
#

The astronomican is from the future

vast heart
#

Or finding Angron first even

orchid lark
#

The real plot twist

#

Having Lorgar for a sit down would also fix it

storm jungle
orchid lark
#

Literally at any point the emperor just needs to talk to people

#

It can be fixed

vast heart
#

Imo Angron getting the nails was the biggest contributor to the heresy

orchid lark
#

Much like an actual relationship with a shitty father

#

He aint saying shit

shadow plover
storm jungle
#

Angron would have rebelled without the nails too

#

he was a freedom fighter at heart

#

and also not a hypocrite like Corax lol

vast heart
#

He was meant to be the horus and he could have fixed 90% of what was wrong with the traitor primarchs with his power

pine wedge
scenic bolt
#

emperor can construct a webway from toothpicks and spit but cant get rid of some backwater nerve nails

orchid lark
#

There needs to be a lot of speech checks to keep angron in line

pine wedge
#

if he were to die, and the Astronomicon disappeared, the Imperium would be over immediately

orchid lark
#

Guess what no time for that

pine wedge
#

but the "strongman leader" is immortal

storm jungle
#

simple as

#

the Imperium's "immortality" has never been a thing

#

thousands of authors have always said the opposite

#

"its a rotting carcass"

orchid lark
#

Also the emperor never intended to lead it this long

pine wedge
#

but it persists!

storm jungle
#

^

storm jungle
#

its not that complex

orchid lark
#

He wouldve just dissapeared at some point finger blasting erda or some shit

storm jungle
#

"Now we rage against the dying of the light"

green loom
#

He never intended to Sneed it this long

vast heart
#

I mean more like, if angron was around (and non-nail'd)

they could've dealt with Lorgars BPD

Curzes turbo-schizophrenia

Fulgrims emasculation

Pertys hurt ass feewings

Mortarions need to drink monster and hate his stepdad

orchid lark
#

Literally made plans to ensure the imperium wouldnt have been ruled by perpetuals either

storm jungle
#

you cant fix stupid kids

#

Morty especially

orchid lark
#

Malcador is his best friend, yeah for a time

vast heart
#

Like he feels like a deeply essential part to a functional group of primarchs

queen laurel
storm jungle
#

BRUH

vast heart
#

And without him the whole thing floats away

storm jungle
#

Angron was inside us all along

#

oh wait-

orchid lark
#

Thank you bad dragon

queen laurel
orchid lark
#

Only comes in XXL size

vast heart
#

There are two angrons inside you

#

you need more holes

storm jungle
#

BRUH 2x

orchid lark
#

Sounds bout right

queen laurel
storm jungle
rocky gale
pine wedge
# storm jungle Because plot

no, you are dismissing the socio-religious mania that the Emperor produces that binds the Imperium together, along with the mutual economic interests of all its major organisations and ministries and ruling nobility. the majority of the oppressed masses are kept sedated through religious fervour, allowing the rich elite to continuously exploit them for resources and wage a forever war over territory, resources, expansion and defense. it's not just "it exists because it must exist for the plot", it is as deep as I say it is.

#

which is not that deep but not completely mindless either. it's not that poorly thought out.

vast heart
#

To be entirely fair, they've had about 40 odd years to iron out anything that doesn't make sense

storm jungle
#

Also it literally exist sbecause of plot

vast heart
#

As someone who writes, quite a lot of "well written" things are just happy accidents you notice later and build on or clarify

pine wedge
#

and the power of religion in 40k exceeds the power of religion in human history because in 40k, God is real and he is sitting on a throne in the Imperium and his powers make space travel possible

storm jungle
#

same as how minis get introduced with no lore explanation

#

the lore does not matter in the grand picture

#

this has always been the case

#

I get that people dont like the "because plot" answer but unfortunately that is the reality of things lol

pine wedge
orchid lark
#

If lore mattered i would have back flipping terminators

storm jungle
#

ogryn player moment

orchid lark
pine wedge
#

you missed MY point, ogryn player

storm jungle
queen laurel
storm jungle
#

Anyway like

#

40k is legit not that deep

#

its wide as an ocean but as deep as a pond

vast heart
#

I mean it's kinda both, say what you want about the actual balance 40k nails its thematic top-down/down-up design is fuckin immaculate

storm jungle
#

its made to exist to sell toys and have fun

#

theres not really any philosophical debate to be made

#

I kinda realised this after like, you know

#

being a fan for 12 years

#

đź’€

pine wedge
#

it's Dune, and Dune is pretty deep

#

40k doesn't have to put in the effort

orchid lark
#

But I can have philosophical debates about it

pine wedge
#

Dune already did it

storm jungle
#

Yeah because Dune is not a miniatures game

queen laurel
storm jungle
#

If you wanna live in the Imperium go to China

#

bing chilling

orchid lark
pine wedge
#

so everything else is just slapped on to sell miniatures but the immutable core of the setting is based on really good scifi and actually is that deep

orchid lark
#

I dont think it should be deep

#

Because people dumb as hell

#

And misconstrue the teachings

orchid lark
#

And espouse the worst of their own projections

storm jungle
#

also yeah its really not

#

everyone is evil and does things for evil or grey reasons

pine wedge
#

it is, though. I have decreed it so.

vast heart
#

don't forget that it's a bunch of different people working on this shit

rocky gale
storm jungle
vast heart
#

Any 40k writer would immediately side with Hank and anyone who designs game rules would probably lean closer to dill

orchid lark
vast heart
#

It's a multi-faceted thing with different percentages of top-down/down-up game design depending on the given faction/mini/subfaction etc

orchid lark
vast heart
#

Some factions are just outright "that's cool as fuck we should do that" and others feel like they were meant to be a little more thought provoking or build off of more interesting concepts

rocky gale
# orchid lark Im behind the dune doing something alright

My favourite fun fact about that game is that apparently the creator stopped doing fan submitted polls because people kept voting for Shadout Mapes to get more scenes and it annoyed him because he'd only added her to the game as a joke to try and gross out the players.

#

Creator "Please stop, I was just trying to troll you" crysister

Fans "More Grandma" chadgryn

rose thorn
crystal forum
#

when they cyber my punk

chilly palm
#

who up punken they cyber right now

rocky gale
#

You forget that God Emperor of Dune asks the biggest philosophical question, "Would you still love me if I was a worm?"

vast heart
#

She cyber on my punk until I have a rough and premature launch

storm jungle
#

Its incredibly deep.

#

40k doesnt really have any sort of substance even close to it due to having way too many cooks in the kitchen

#

theres a reason Dune also shaped modern sci-fi as we more or less know it too directly and indirectly

pine wedge
forest orbit
pine wedge
#

the sequels go more into it I believe. huge parts of one of them is the god-emperor leto 2 waffling about philosophy and shit? I haven't read them but I have read a bit about what people have to say about them

storm jungle
#

Reynolds trying to kill Bile but GW saying no because toy soldiers are more important

forest orbit
#

Didn't he quit Black Library after that KEKW_ogryn

storm jungle
#

Yes he did lol

#

probably the peak example of what i was referring to

forest orbit
#

ye fair nuff

queen laurel
# storm jungle Yes he did lol

The only times I really see writers having their own fun and freedom is when they're making that story far away from the main course of the lore

storm jungle
#

It depends. BL writers dont get a lot of freedom unless they have been writing for warhammer for a long time.

#

most of their work also gets edited out amidst other stuff if its generally too lore-breaking or like doesnt go well with established canon stuff.

#

the rare examples that go against this are people like Abnett who just constantly writes prequels and has been around since like 1945

queen laurel
storm jungle
#

mfers been with Marvel forever too

vast heart
#

I'd disagree but I know in my heart of hearts they're never going to do anything interesting like make Vashtorr (or anything else) an actual chaos god

#

I wanna see the thing the Tau are cooking up in the warp

storm jungle
#

Absolutely not yeah lol

#

40k doesnt have stakes

rose thorn
storm jungle
#

it has the "illusion" of one

rose thorn
storm jungle
#

KEK

raven stone
#

I just enjoy 40k as a sandbox universe for my own mind to run wild in :p

storm jungle
#

Same

#

the "plot" sucks anyway lol

raven stone
#

Like, nothing can change the entire Galaxy, but in some odd corner of it something has to be going just a little bit right.

#

(TBH the level of firepower and the aesthetics is just oddly cool to enjoy too)

green loom
#

Drama fun

queen laurel
raven stone
#

A lot of lame shorthand hand waving, if even not just outright retcons.

#

Which…I get what retcons are there for, but from a lore building view, is just the laziest way to do it.

green loom
#

GW has creative directors, not writers

raven stone
#

The direction given being “what is the quickest way to explain why things has to be this way” I suppose.

storm jungle
#

like "oh the Imperium is split in half!"

#

"Can we read more about it?"

#

years and we still got nothing

green loom
#

You can argue Phil Kelly is a writer but he's also Phil Kelly so smarf

storm jungle
#

Imperium Nihilus may as well not exist lol

storm jungle
#

and its like

#

Written by Phil Kelly

#

but theres a text below going

#

"But most of it was done by Jes Goodwin"

#

lmao

queen laurel
green loom
#

Hey we're getting a Votaan in HaBaddon

raven stone
#

Also I do think at least most sectors, if not down to systems, are capable of some form of self sustenance, even given the weirdly specialised nature of some of the planets.
Otherwise the Imperium REALLY would not function economically.

green loom
#

Most of the planets that can't sustain themselves at all are

#

Typically

#

Hive worlds

#

or Forge worlds

storm jungle
#

The problem is the writers also just do not understand how civilisations work.

A single hive city on an entire planet would have about as many cultures as modern day earth or more lol

raven stone
#

Those would only make sense in heavily fortified sectors which…to be fair, the ones we have seen significant to lore, are actually of some strategic importance.

But yea, anywhere else, those kind of worlds would just…starve to death.

storm jungle
#

"Oh but they do have those with gangs!"

#

....Thats not how it works lol

storm jungle
#

its always the best route

raven stone
#

(But Gang culture is the only type which has guns involved!)

storm jungle
#

ignoring the wider setting is the best thing you can do in general

#

because ironically it makes the entire galaxy feel incredibly small, which is actually so impressive its depressing lol

queen laurel
raven stone
queen laurel
storm jungle
#

Necromunda is the planet in 40k with THE most lore

#

its a great showcase of what pocket-areas of the setting can actually be like with effort

raven stone
#

Cadia is justified due to…well, Cadia. lol.

storm jungle
#

Cadia has some sub-cultures

#

Fall of Cadia explores this actually

#

but like... yeah pretty much lol

queen laurel
storm jungle
#

Gerontius Helmawr

#

but uh

#

hes in a statis pod rn

#

and his daughter got ousted

raven stone
#

Actually the Rogue Trader and Dark Heresy books

#

Also had some deeply rich small-scale lore for worlds too

storm jungle
#

thats because thats side-IP stuff

#

and those always make settings richer

queen laurel
storm jungle
#

He got poisoned

#

thats why hes put there

#

since hes a piece of shit lmao

raven stone
#

Enough to convince anyone that you can just invent your small corner of the universe and have fun with that (whilst obeying the larger concepts of the 40k verse without being too embroiled in irrelevant things you don’t like)

green loom
storm jungle
#

Yep

#

she was in charge before the other houses ousted her

#

now shes working with the dwarves to get her throne back

storm jungle
#

homebrew is the best part of 40k

queen laurel
storm jungle
green loom
raven stone
storm jungle
#

its very much to showcase like

#

"Hey heres our homebrew sector, go do yours or use our one!"

#

its great

raven stone
#

Rogue Trader frontier areas pretty much allow you to draw on all the lovelier parts/aesthetics of 40k whilst ignoring the stupid parts of it.

storm jungle
#

it helps that Inquisitors and Rogue Traders tend to also be the most "free" parts of Imperial societies to a point lol

#

whenever people ask who can an Inquisitor or Trader involve in their retinue i always tell em they are entirely made to be a DnD team so literally "anyone" lol

dusk patrol
#

Almost like they’re designed to give you free rein to live the power fantasy/escapism

storm jungle
#

"escapism"

#

more like capitalism

#

but yes

pine wedge
dusk patrol
#

What am I in a freshmen year poli sci class?

raven stone
#

Well, Capitalism and State Sec supported escapism XD

#

(RT/Inquisitors respectively)

pine wedge
#

I have done a lot of pbp roleplaying in my day and my two favorite settings are the elder scrolls and 40k for that reason: both very lore-dense and richly detailed worlds and histories, but big enough for you to just get lost and do whatever in

storm jungle
#

elder scrolls lore be like

#

"Im gonna be a khajit"

#

becomes house cat

#

win

dusk patrol
#

Member that time entirety of Elsywer became so high they went to the moon

pine wedge
#

the various khajiit forms being depicted justifies the existence of ESO

#

they do really cool stuff with old/ignored lore stuff from the mainline games

dusk patrol
#

Hey now

#

It was moon dust

queen laurel
raven stone
#

It really helps that both Rogue Traders and Inquisitors are defined by their power and roles as well.
Both books put heavy emphasis on “anyone could end up [unknowingly be a distant relative to a Trade Warrant bearer/recruited by the Inquisition for some really niche reason]”

storm jungle
#

i forgot who was behind it but im sure it was some gentleman named Pawblo Meowscobar

dusk patrol
#

Khajitt lore is all shitposting

storm jungle
#

meanwhile argonians

#

swamp

#

be undefeatable

dusk patrol
#

for some dumb reason leave swamp

storm jungle
#

just there lol

#

people and modern fans especially got no idea how much the FF books helped with this

pine wedge
queen laurel
# storm jungle meanwhile argonians

they are also free of choosing what form they can be but apparently, being a reptile is it

the greatest example of this genetic manipulation is Argonian behemoths

storm jungle
#

Elder Scroll races are so good

dusk patrol
#

People who don’t know Eldar scrolls lore: Oh man the Nords sure are being mean to the Dunmer how sad

People who know: hah get fucked stupid mushroom elves

storm jungle
#

more like

#

"Whos more racist in Elder scrolls"

#

"Yes"

raven stone
#

Also arguably slightly less 40k focused, but…
…it annoys me to no end how almost every 40k crossover is “let’s randomly throw Imperial military against [X] and see what happens.”
Instead of featuring Rogue Traders, which is, you know, built exactly for that sort of interaction instead.

dusk patrol
#

Elder scrolls is competitive racism

storm jungle
#

Yep

celest dome
queen laurel
storm jungle
storm jungle
#

people go on about how great it is to have so many authors for a setting

dusk patrol
#

Killing high elves isn’t just guilt free

storm jungle
#

then complain when some books turn out to be dogshit

#

lol

dusk patrol
#

It’s actually good karma

storm jungle
#

Salamander fans learned this the hard way

queen laurel
storm jungle
#

its even funnier because when you are a high elf they are still a racist to you

#

accurate depiction of IRL

queen laurel
dusk patrol
#

High elves are phenomenal at making everyone hate them

#

Literally just the worst

storm jungle
#

false

#

Nords exist

queen laurel
dusk patrol
#

High elves ability to make nords seem reasonable is more proof of how shit they are

storm jungle
#

the nice ones are the ones that want nothing to do with the politics and are just random NPCs you can find in the world doing mundane stuff lol

queen laurel
storm jungle
#

Nords suck

pine wedge
#

high elves actually involved with high elf business are always the worst

#

random altmer are generally fine

queen laurel
#

i don't like the empire but at times they can be more reasonable than the nords

storm jungle
#

also iirc Thalmor are literally like a gestapo organisation that even normal high elf society hates

#

which explains a lot

#

lmao

storm jungle
#

deffo could be worse

dusk patrol
#

Idk about harmless but they’re definitely the best option

queen laurel
storm jungle
#

im sure they didnt hurt anyone

pine wedge
#

the thalmor were a very politically powerful faction in like, the second era. and then they got sidelined for a long time until they managed to dethrone the summerset isles royalty and effectively stage a coup and they've been calling the shots and declaring war on the empire ever since. took them about two centuries, starting in the years after the oblivion crisis

storm jungle
dusk patrol
#

Next game will probably be in Hammerfell since it’s heavily implied that’s gonna be the battle ground for the next war.

storm jungle
#

SOUNDS LIKE SOMEONE I KNOW

#

staregryn 🍺

pine wedge
#

hahaha

storm jungle
pine wedge
#

yeah pretty much. elf nazis.

storm jungle
#

yeah more or less đź’€

pine wedge
#

big gestapo/stasi vibes

storm jungle
#

you can just do an east german citizen move in markarth and sell someone out for worshipping talos

#

its so fucking funny

pine wedge
#

they consider ulfric stormcloak a sort of "rogue asset" but they dont interfere because he's destabilizing the empire

storm jungle
#

yeah the entire civil war in skyrim is pointless which is the point

#

the nords are just too dumb to see the bigger picture

#

which, tb

#

sweden

#

so makes sense

pine wedge
#

I enjoy siding with the empire just for the opportunity to shout ulfric down. you think that's the thu'um? aight bet. watch this

storm jungle
#

I join because I love Balgruff

#

ballin'

pine wedge
#

Balgruff is cool

queen laurel
#

@storm jungle @pine wedge

but also them

storm jungle
#

BRUH

pine wedge
#

oh yeah I need to go see that last movie

storm jungle
#

same

pine wedge
#

love me some dumb kaiju flicks

queen laurel
# storm jungle BRUH

What it's right though

You two would have an argument and then suddenly team up

storm jungle
#

its true

#

I love how the complaint point is
"oh my god i cant believe they made godzilla and kong goofie"

#

...my guy do you even know godzilla

pine wedge
#

right? kekw

pine wedge
#

godzilla has just been power rangers in even more outrageously bad costumes for most of his run

storm jungle
#

both equally great and horrifying movies

pine wedge
#

I missed minus one in cinemas, big sad

storm jungle
#

LMFAO

#

HE DOES THAT TWICE TOO

queen laurel
storm jungle
#

Megalon got NO mercy đź’€

storm jungle
queen laurel
#

He can be the most horrifying thing you can see to some of the funniest things you can see

#

A hero or villain an antihero

queen laurel
#

yes

storm jungle
#

unrelated gif

dusk patrol
storm jungle
#

least violent primarch fight

queen laurel
storm jungle
queen laurel
#

what

#

He looks goofy I like it

dusk patrol
#

You have terrible taste I’m sorry

storm jungle
#

LMAO WOW

queen laurel
#

anyway

dusk patrol
#

Now this guy

#

This is a real kaiju

#

You’ll note of course he has drills for hands

queen laurel
dusk patrol
#

I did when I was a kid

#

Cause I liked the idea of drilling around

#

We had that one Godzilla game

queen laurel
#

I expected you to like Gigan because both of you are Dick heads

storm jungle
#

I was resisting ngl

#

also Final Wars gigan is just 40k

queen laurel
dusk patrol
#

He’s gonna shit yourself

queen laurel
#

as if The first one wasn't already edging

dusk patrol
#

I remember when I was a kid I thought as soon as I saw mecha Godzilla had laser eyes “oh he can use those to lift someone up if he lasers them above him”

#

And then he did it

#

So basically the creators of those movies were on the same wavelength as 10 year old me

queen laurel
storm jungle
#

I hope mecha-godzilla also taught you robotics and bionics are cool too

dusk patrol
storm jungle
#

also hard to nail because like even OG mecha-g had laser eyes too

dusk patrol
#

I just know he put Godzilla or something over his head and then started lifting them up with his laser eyes

storm jungle
queen laurel
scenic bolt
#

They don’t want you to see the true Kong vs Godzilla beef

queen laurel
outer wave
#

You guys remember when America tried their hand at Godzilla in the early 2000s?

scenic bolt
#

Godzilla on ice

dusk patrol
#

I remember when we made him sick as fuck in 2014

outer wave
#

Yeah

queen laurel
#

Ohh he's not that bad especially when you saw the TV show

outer wave
#

And I think one other movie where they pitted western godzilla against OG godzilla but never saw that one

dusk patrol
#

It’s uh

queen laurel
queen laurel
dusk patrol
#

Yeah that was it

outer wave
#

Oh I don't recall the animated show

dusk patrol
#

It’s basically a cameo

storm jungle
#

^

#

he has like

#

1m of screentime

storm jungle
#

since the movie has like

#

10000 MONSTERS

storm jungle
#

little bitch

queen laurel
storm jungle
storm jungle
outer wave
#

Got fucked

dusk patrol
#

Final Wars plot is “and then this monster shows up”

storm jungle
#

you forgot the subplot

#

where superhuman matrix people fight each other

dusk patrol
#

As always, the human subplots for Godzilla movies are there for bathroom breaks

storm jungle
#

^

queen laurel
# outer wave Got fucked

Ohh yeah you know what's funny in the cartoon the one that appears is his son and his son actually has an atomic breath

storm jungle
#

the finale was also great

#

the audience is like

#

"oh wow godzilla got em all!"

outer wave
#

Damn he donezo...

dusk patrol
#

Still sad that Tony Soprano didn’t get to make a cameo

queen laurel
outer wave
#

Who was that again? King Gorath or something?

queen laurel
outer wave
#

Thank you

outer wave
#

He's going HARD on those drum headbutts

queen laurel
dusk patrol
#

I fucking love the KotM Ghidorah

#

They nailed him

queen laurel
#

Rodan and Mothra too

crystal forum
#

this is the nerdiest nerd talk i've ever seen

golden meteor
#

Realizing how badly that tech priest fucked up by destroying the STC for making phosphex

#

Tyranids woulda hated that

outer wave
crystal forum
#

why do nids hate fire

queen laurel
dusk patrol
queen laurel
#

King Ghidorah is his own thing

outer wave
#

Ah gotcha

crystal forum
dusk patrol
#

Here’s a hint

outer wave
#

I do recall seeing the transformation scene back as a kid

crystal forum
#

and nids hate cool

outer wave
#

And uh kinda fucked with my head

storm jungle
outer wave
#

I did NOT like that scene

storm jungle
#

they literally opted to virus bomb them and it did nothing after the first try lol

crystal forum
#

do salamanders use meltas

storm jungle
#

no they use fire extinguishers

dusk patrol
#

Yes

crystal forum
#

so melta guns are sorta heat weapons right

storm jungle
#

the name has "melt" in it

dusk patrol
#

They love meltas and flamethrowers

crystal forum
#

i'm not the weird one for thinking of meltas as long range flamers

storm jungle
#

They are beam weapons basically

dusk patrol
#

No

#

They’re super concentrated heat

crystal forum
#

see it's weird that plasma weaponry isn't considered heat weapons too right

storm jungle
#

I mean

#

no?

queen laurel
storm jungle
#

plasma doesnt shoot fire

crystal forum
#

plasma is literally superheated gas

storm jungle
#

đź’€

outer wave
crystal forum
#

i guess since it's blast weaponry in 40k it's more of an explosive

plush mason
#

get close and melt the fool

crystal forum
#

is there a chapter that really likes exploding stuff

dusk patrol
golden meteor
dusk patrol
#

All of them

golden meteor
#

They is not mahoraga

storm jungle
#

so yes its still more or less the same thing

crystal forum
dusk patrol
#

Idk Iron Hands I guess

golden meteor
crystal forum
dusk patrol
storm jungle
dusk patrol
plush mason
crystal forum
storm jungle
#

okay but like

#

thats "firepower"

#

not explosions

#

you aint no Mr Torque

crystal forum
#

like every chapter enjoys flamers but salamanders do it next level

dusk patrol
#

Well Jay should ask better questions then

golden meteor
storm jungle
golden meteor
storm jungle
#

bitches idk

dusk patrol
#

Got em

storm jungle
golden meteor
crystal forum
#

the unmatched power of the sun