#40k-lore-chat

1 messages Ā· Page 320 of 1

dense salmon
#

If that death was a violent one, khorne eats too

green loom
#

Read End and the Death

crisp heath
#

🤣 šŸ˜‚ now I just feel like I'm being consoled for a lost girlfriend. "Don't worry buddy, there's plenty of eldritch fish in that hellish sea!"

dense salmon
#

Lol

lapis wadi
#

I wonder sometimes if the Imperial Cult wasn't the Emperor's back-up plan
If he can't starve the warp of any worship, intentionally direct it all to himself instead.

tulip brook
#

I don't think 40k fractured emperor becoming god and 30k dark king god would be the same

green loom
#

In da nu book

#

Also Star child theory is back on

lapis wadi
#

Yeah I'm actually hella behind on my lore >>

crisp heath
#

Yup

arctic talon
#

A new eye of terror centered on terra

#

Will 100% happen

crisp heath
#

Wouldn't doubt it

storm jungle
#

an

#

Eye of Terra

#

if you will

arctic talon
#

Heh

crisp heath
#

🤣

arctic talon
#

Oh all human souls would most likely go to him lol

green loom
#

Like the Eye of Terra visible on Horus' battleplate?

tulip brook
#

emperor being offline for moments should be a feast for chaos in terra

arctic talon
#

We’ll see if uh

lapis wadi
arctic talon
#

It’s a good fate or an absolutely terrible one

#

My bet is on terrible

#

Mostly since chaos god

lapis wadi
hollow falcon
#

The question is, will it be bad or less bad for humans in general?

lapis wadi
#

Worse short-term

arctic talon
#

The imperium would shatter

dense salmon
#

There is never a good outcome to an eternity as a cruel God's plaything

arctic talon
#

Into infighting

tulip brook
#

the setting is: then it got worse

arctic talon
#

And then no more warp travel

lapis wadi
#

Long-term I have no idea honestly, too many variables and unknowns

arctic talon
#

And also the emperor might just become even more comically evil

hollow falcon
#

and for human souls?

dense salmon
#

Imagine a sparrow carving a rock out of a mountain with its beak to build a nest.

arctic talon
green loom
#

Instead of just being eaten like rn

dense salmon
#

It lays eggs, they hatch, and its children do the same

#

The cycle goes on and on for millions of years until the mountain is leveled

#

That is the first second of eternity

tulip brook
#

the guy is feeding with human souls already

dense salmon
#

That is the power you give chaos over your soul

crisp heath
green loom
#

No your soul just gets eaten

#

lol

dense salmon
#

You become a part of that God

tulip brook
#

bigger emps with bigger appetite

dense salmon
#

If you're lucky

hollow falcon
#

What aspect would then the Emps be?

dense salmon
#

Humanity

normal light
#

What is the topic?

dense salmon
#

I guess

hollow falcon
#

I thought so

crisp heath
#

The real chaos

dense salmon
#

He's be the good and bad aspects

green loom
#

He'd be the Chaos God of Ruin or something KEKW_ogryn

dense salmon
#

The emperor in life was the good and bad aspects of humanity

#

He was a warmonger, but also an artist

crisp heath
#

I think it'd just be that 10x

normal light
#

You are discussing if the Emperor is a chaos god?

crisp heath
#

Yea

tulip brook
#

what kind of chaos god he would be

normal light
#

Technically he is a Chaos god

#

His followers also are granted gifts

hollow falcon
#

and how his realm would look like

crisp heath
#

Right, but like, what would his aspect or in dnd terms portfolio be

#

Like Khorn is war, nurgle plague/death, slanesh....

dense salmon
#

Humanity

#

Just the concept of humanity

hollow falcon
#

Human Supremacy

warm notch
#

We lost a real one out in the field

#

Pour one out for Wyrmwood

#

šŸ˜”

normal light
dense salmon
crisp heath
#

@dense salmon you said this already, chaos crab was asking and I'm curious his answer

crisp heath
normal light
#

Nah, the situation just got better, we don’t need to save her Chaos

tulip brook
#

chaos god of conquest, greater demon rhino

crisp heath
#

Nw

normal light
#

And it’s good whatthefuck_heresy

crisp heath
#

@normal light @dense salmon I actually don't think humanity, because Slabesh doesn't embody the Eldar right?

normal light
#

We follow chaos undivided

crisp heath
#

Bine of the other gods embody species

normal light
#

Well Khain is also god of war

crisp heath
#

Even the Taus god embodies the Greater Good, and not the tau themselves

normal light
#

And Khain is and Eldar god

dense salmon
#

Slaanesh isn't the god of the eldar

normal light
#

Yeah

#

Just a greater daemon

crisp heath
#

But they are chaos gods, aren't they? Idk much about the elders gods. I thought that were more like weapons, similar to the Ctan

#

@normal light

green loom
#

They straight up say what the Dark King is guys, it ain't a secret anymore KEKW_ogryn

tulip brook
#

until slaanesh nommed most of them

normal light
#

Before Slaanesh eaten most of them

dense salmon
#

Slaanesh is the god of excess

arctic talon
#

I wonder if slaanesh is still digesting the gods so to speak

#

The same way they were in AoS

normal light
arctic talon
#

With elf souls

normal light
crisp heath
#

Right, but like, they arent the same as the Chaos gods, and aren't warp based right? I really don't know

dense salmon
#

They are warp based. They are the concept of excess

normal light
dense salmon
#

They were birthed by the eldar but they are a concept that always existed

normal light
#

Even Khain

crisp heath
#

Ahh ok.

green loom
#

Eldar are an exceptionally warpy race

#

They are to warpy shit what the necrons are to physical reality

normal light
crisp heath
#

So like, then again. None of them really embodied their species then. They all embodied concepts the Eldar valued and whatnot right? Life, death, wealth, magic, experience whatever

green loom
#

I think the implication is they were planted by the Old Ones

#

In like the Asurmen book or something?

crisp heath
#

My point is, I dont think the emperor qiuld flat embody "humanity"

#

It would be something about us

green loom
#

I'm telling you he'd be the God of Ruin KEKW_ogryn

crisp heath
#

Maybe a lot of things.

normal light
storm jungle
green loom
#

Brain rot

normal light
crisp heath
#

They all embody qualities and aspects

green loom
#

He'd be the Chaos God of Ruin

near wasp
#

Chaos god of child abuse

crisp heath
#

I'm dead 🤣

normal light
#

Being a parent

#

Winning a civil war

#

Restoring humanity

green loom
#

He'd be the Chaos God of Ruin because he'd ruin the mystery

normal light
#

Mystery of what?

crisp heath
#

Unpopular opinion: The Emperor is Malice

green loom
#

The Heresy and like all the speculation around it

#

He spoils the mystery

#

And thus ruins it

#

Since there's unlikely to be a satisfying ending

arctic talon
#

So can’t be him

dense salmon
near wasp
#

The emperor is the anathema

crisp heath
#

Blah fiiiine lolol

normal light
green loom
#

Malice deez nuts

crisp heath
#

Was me being stupid mostly

patent ivy
#

Shame what happened to the Alpha legion

green loom
#

Deserved

near wasp
dense salmon
normal light
dense salmon
#

Debate can be healthy and good

crisp heath
#

Honestly that's why I do it mostly lol

dense salmon
#

Challenging your own assumptions in an interest is the way we learn

crisp heath
#

I know a little about a lot and find I learn more by stirring the pot

green loom
#

It's like poetry, it rhymes

dense salmon
normal light
green loom
dense salmon
green loom
#

And then telephone game it for 20 years

normal light
near wasp
dense salmon
#

Cato sicarius had his street cred irreversibly annihilated by TTS

green loom
#

Mention ultramarines

#

The fandom:

near wasp
#

Ultramarines are the best

green loom
near wasp
#

Fight me

normal light
#

Blueberries shall die

dense salmon
# green loom The fandom:

"I, Cato Sicarius, knight champion of McCragge, claim this meme in the name of Guilliman and the Emperor!"

green loom
#

It's like, way better than the usual Nick Kyme crap KEKW_ogryn

patent ivy
#

Alpha legion wanted what was best for the universe, no?

green loom
#

God no

normal light
#

They were also traitors and that’s all

dense salmon
#

Cato sicarius recently had his stories improve

normal light
#

They wanted to achieve their own goals

dense salmon
#

Reading about him fighting the tyranid carnifex was awesome

#

Old one eye

green loom
#

They were deluded morons so far up their own assholes with schemes that they didn't have breakfast without twenty five different, unrelated handlers signing off on it

patent ivy
dense salmon
#

And their primarch only thought he knew what the emperor wanted

patent ivy
#

Ah

green loom
normal light
green loom
#

But by the Siege they're doing their own thing

patent ivy
#

I guess it isn’t a shame the

near wasp
#

The alpha legion is over estimated, when really they have no idea what they are doing anymore

crisp heath
green loom
#

The idea was that by supporting Horus they'd make sure humantiy dies

#

Thus starving chaos of it's most plentiful food source

crisp heath
#

Ah... the imperium

patent ivy
#

Or was that just wrong overall

dense salmon
#

The only real problem with the ultramarines was GW making them the paragon of all space marines

#

"What every chapter aspires to be"

normal light
dense salmon
#

And the characters were pretty overpowered

green loom
winter vessel
patent ivy
#

Ah

#

I like this chat

dense salmon
#

Like honestly reading their books in that time you'd think Cato and calgar could solo the fucking horus heresy if they were there

patent ivy
#

Very helpful

normal light
crisp heath
#

Look good sir, I do good work for you. Please keep the weird door in the back closed. The weird gurgles, moans, and slurps I hear are enough torture.

green loom
normal light
normal light
#

I still need to paint my plastic overlords

#

Servoskull This is my duty

near wasp
#

I need to finish my necrons before i order my knight

normal light
#

I am thinking about finishing my Chaos Legionaries which will be not fast

#

And getting some enemies for them

#

Maybe loyalist marines

green loom
#

I need to do art but exams suffering

normal light
#

Same squad

normal light
near wasp
dense salmon
#

Do you think ciaphas cain could have killed that world eater if he didn't have jurgen's help

near wasp
#

Probably not

green loom
#

They're older books right?

#

I wouldn't be surprised if he did but iirc in the scene he was able to just hold his own long enough for Jurgen to pop up

dense salmon
#

Even so, that's an insane feat

#

I recall getting goosebumps reading it

#

When the world eater leaps at him and swings his weapon at ciaphas

#

And ciaphas says "that was his first mistake"

#

Tingles

green loom
#

Ugghh

#

If only I could afford audiobooks

dense salmon
#

The narration for the cain series is wonderful

#

I own it on audible

green loom
#

Who's the narrator

dense salmon
#

Multiple, but the majority is Stephen peering

#

Perring*

near wasp
dense salmon
#

3 credits a month iirc

green loom
#

I can't really afford the sub either smilecat

dense salmon
#

1 credit is good for 1 book

green loom
#

Maybe once I clear my cooms loregryn

near wasp
crisp heath
#

šŸ˜

dense salmon
#

The cain series is old but only a few bits are outdated

#

Like the necron pariahs

#

And sometimes Jurgen being a blank is a blatant asspull

green loom
#

"A cup of recaf" comes to mind smilecat

near wasp
#

I could go for some recaf

dense salmon
#

Recaf is still a thing no?

green loom
#

I mean the short

dense salmon
#

Ah lol

#

Recaf doesn't sound so bad

#

Basically just super black tea

green loom
#

Sorry it's "A Mug of Recaff"

dense salmon
#

Jurgen's blankness works in ways it really shouldn't sometimes

#

But jurgen is so loveable despite his ugly mug I'll give it a pass

#

My headcanon isn't that he's actually ugly, his pariah gene just makes him physically repulsive to normal humans

green loom
#

Same

#

Like he can't be that bad

#

Being ugly is like part and parcel for guardsmen

dense salmon
#

Random guardsmen witnessing ciaphas duel a space marine and show more interest in a cup of tea than the 1v1:

normal light
#

Everything is correct

patent ivy
#

One of my favorite things to do is see if people make a custom lego minifig for x

#

Pretty cool

crisp heath
#

Random thought, it'd be cool if like, actual music was made for 40k. Not thematic music, like in universe music. I'm curious. You know with all the trauma and war and stress they have to have some awesome street musician types. I'm thinking like pipe drums, some wire strings, and synth shit. Maybe like a futuristic version of this.

#

BTW you're welcome for being dated you old bats

#

I have high hopes for the new Cavill show. I really want it to showcase more of like, the actual life of people in the imperium.

patent ivy
#

Hmph, would be interesting

#

I think I recall seeing this when I was younger, no way am I old

crisp heath
#

That's almost two decades old brudda

#

If not more

#

Would the emperor have eventually either thunder warrior treatment or some other way have phased out ogryns from human mutations(?) if he had succeeded

#

Or would he have left them as is due to their usefulness

arctic talon
#

There was a heavily implied possibility he was gona purge marines

#

As well

crisp heath
#

Kinda sad but I expected it

#

This is the correct answer, but we all know there ain't no way the lovable brutes are ever leaving

#

Actually are ogryns mutant humans or are they like their own unique species at this point?

#

They're abhumans

patent ivy
#

Purge the Marines?

#

Like just of traitors, right

scenic bolt
#

no completely, stem and root

patent ivy
#

What?!

#

Was it that he just couldn't trust them anymore after the Heresy?

wet sandal
#

No, he could just do better

#

Thunderwarrior style

scenic bolt
#

like the thunder warriors, the empire's transitional period would have progressed far enough that they would become an active threat to it

storm jungle
#

^

#

He basically didnt trust them yeah

patent ivy
#

I see

scenic bolt
#

which kinda got proven with how many chaos and traitor marines are floating about

storm jungle
#

he said humans should govern themselves

patent ivy
#

HAH

#

Sounds like a plandemic

#

Create a problem then try to reverse it

arctic talon
#

Also the emperor hates transhumans

#

A ton lol

wet sandal
#

It's like when you unlock a new unit in an rts you purge all the old ones to empty the unit cap

arctic talon
#

lol

green loom
#

The heresy proved his point pretty much lol

#

You make superhumans, there's gonna be a superiority complex brewing there

storm jungle
#

yeah like even if there was no Chaos Gods the marines would have still caused some secessionist war

#

the primarchs especially were the biggest root of the issue

scenic bolt
#

(primarchs wouldve been purged too)

patent ivy
#

When you say he wanted humans to rule themselves, is that still under his rule, or a return to 20th millenium and before

patent ivy
#

Okay

arctic talon
#

Or under malcadors

#

It’s unclear

#

He might have just killed himself or something

storm jungle
#

KEK

patent ivy
#

He is never beating the allegations

arctic talon
#

Only superhumans he liked

#

Were the custodes

#

Lol

wet sandal
storm jungle
#

also

#

in a more "realistic" setting

#

where the Emperor wasnt braindead

#

he'd have just made Custodians the generals of Imperial armies

#

but if he did that we wouldn't have a cashcow Horus Heresy series

wet sandal
#

He made the primarchs because.... uuh you wouldn't get it (all part of his plan)

storm jungle
#

It was all dat MONEYYYY BABY

#

WE LOVE THE METS

wet sandal
#

When I read 40k lore I simply pretend Horus heresy doesn't exist. I'm like "wow horus? What a mysterious character. I wonder what happens to him."

scenic bolt
#

in the best read of the setting as is, theyre the right tools at that point in time, like when you're nailing a house together you use a hammer, but once its fully assembled you put down the hammer and nails and pick up the paintbrush

storm jungle
#

Yeah pretty much

scenic bolt
#

horus heresy was better when it was an ancient event whose records have been largely lost to time

desert dust
#

It's more interesting that way tbh.

spare osprey
#

you think a marine ever called emps gramps

scenic bolt
#

(it was created so that GW didnt have to make more than one army for the Titanicus boardgame)

desert dust
#

Like trying to piece together events in the hersey from the nightlords trilogy is far more interesting then reading about how Mr nightlord boss man grabbed onto a space ship and flew into a dark angel ship

wet sandal
#

It was actually all part of GWs plan to discontinue Imperial Armour

#

Tzeentch is the CEO of Games Workshop

crisp heath
# arctic talon Under his rule

I'm really late, but I'd say it wouldn't actually be under his rule. Going off the propaganda at least, lol, he was hidden among the masses for all of human history with out taking over. Maybe after shepherding us through the storm, he'd go hands off again, and truly let humanity lead itself.

#

Maybe all of this was simply out of necessity

arctic talon
#

But we’ll never know lul

crisp heath
#

So malcador sent a planet into the warp with grey knights on it or so I’ve heard in a podcast

storm jungle
#

It was Titan

#

the actual planet

crisp heath
#

And I’m wondering, could the eldar chief super nerd(eldrad?) do the same thing to terra if he wanted to

#

Or would slanesh just rip him apart as soon as he started to flex

storm jungle
#

Possibly, because super-psykers in this setting are only restrained by plot

#

so its very Yes/No depending on whos writing it KEKW_ogryn

crisp heath
#

I feel the emperor would contest it but not sure how it would turn out

storm jungle
#

the Emperor's abilities are literally "Yes"

#

since he has DeviantArt OC tier powers

crisp heath
#

Lol

#

I wonder what would fix him, more books or information on him or ignoring his existence

crisp heath
#

Since I know a lot of dudes don’t like him

storm jungle
#

Eldrad?

crisp heath
#

That nerd

storm jungle
#

Magnus?

#

Malcador?

#

Ahriman?

#

Me?

crisp heath
#

Oh

#

No I mean the emperor

storm jungle
#

Lmao yeah theres a lot of nerds in 40k

#

but basically again, it depends on the plot

#

like 40k works on the logic of "writers wanted it"

#

"Why do we have a new Imperial Guard tank?"

#

"Writers said so"

crisp heath
#

Like... I know it defeats his purpose so bad. But some day, when Warhammer begins to inevitably die, I need to have the Emperor's actual biography released.

storm jungle
#

We already know a lot about his origin

#

the only missing bits are what he did when he was a Hittite to 30k

crisp heath
#

Right, but I want the full damn story rofl

#

I kinda want to hear the thought process behind his choices

#

All the way through

#

@crisp heath this so much tooo

storm jungle
#

he also suffers way too much from Too many Cooks Syndrome

crisp heath
#

Bleh, I still want it darnit!

storm jungle
#

Well you had 55+ books to discover it good luck

crisp heath
#

I feel like explaining him though does him a disservice

#

I'm a 40k nerd. I'm dumb. Spell it out for me

#

He is an unknowable being

#

So far beyond anything we will ever be

storm jungle
#

thats more or less entirely it

crisp heath
#

Give him the eldtrich god experience

#

Don’t explain it

#

The horror!!!!

storm jungle
crisp heath
#

Lol look, it may not intrest you, but idk... with all the theories and stuff, I'd say there's a lot we don't know about the Emperor. And also, I just think it'd be dope if it was dictated from his perspective. I want to know his actual thoughts, not the representation of them by someone else remembering what happened thousands of years ago. I want the emperors words and memories and thoughts. And in some sense, I want his justification. I think it'd be dope. But I also know that will likely only ever happen at the end of warhammer 40ks life, if that ever comes.

dense salmon
#

After the crusade

#

But that may have just been performance

arctic talon
#

Tbh

#

It could have just been purging the ā€œproblematicā€ ones

#

Anyone who didn’t take that up

dense salmon
#

Corvus was all for the idea of primarchs and marines being euthanized

#

As sad as it is, people like angron have zero purpose outside of warfare

#

He is a terrible leader and by no means a great thinker

#

Even Kurze has some merit as a peacekeeper

crisp heath
dense salmon
#

Angron being euthanized would have been a mercy

dense salmon
crisp heath
#

If that's batman, does that make Sangy boy Supes?

dense salmon
#

Mortarion didnt like the emperor and would have likely rebelled eventually

#

And tbh, he didn't seem the type of guy to thrive in peace

#

Neither did corvus

#

Corvus is like space che guevara

storm jungle
crisp heath
#

I can see it

storm jungle
#

and just any generic christian angel

dense salmon
#

Jesus/archangel michael

storm jungle
#

Venuz can probably explain it better than I can tho

crisp heath
#

So, yea... he's supes lol

dense salmon
#

With a seasoning of dracula

arctic talon
#

Sanguinius’s death day gets celebrated

#

Like Christmas

#

Sanguinala

dense salmon
#

Sanguinius is overtly angelic

storm jungle
#

Yeah the entire purpose of the holiday is also "he died for our sins"

#

Yeee

#

hes not really subtle

dense salmon
#

He represents the emperor's wrath and the emperor's grace

#

Much like angels in Christianity

#

He's a powerhouse but he didn't enjoy war

crisp heath
#

So we got batman and superman. Where's the rest of WH40K Justice league

dense salmon
#

Jesus is a messiah of peace which is why the comparison isn't exactly 1:1

crisp heath
#

Lol who's Martian man hunter

dense salmon
#

But there are Christ-like undertones

storm jungle
#

yeah Jesus didn't really uh

#

you know

#

abet genocide

#

or war

dense salmon
#

Or fly

storm jungle
#

if only

dense salmon
#

Well, he did kind of fly

crisp heath
#

I mean, he might have flown

#

You don't know how he walked on that water lolol

#

Kidding, kidding

dense salmon
#

Sanguinius is a lot like biblical warriors like Samson or David

winter vessel
storm jungle
#

Yeah even his death artwork is very "slain angel"

#

his death in the new book is much worse

crisp heath
#

@winter vessel ayy, that works too. But... I don't think Sangy boy was acending like that after what happened to him

dense salmon
crisp heath
#

My boy was brutalized

dense salmon
#

Sanguinius deserved better

crisp heath
#

Literally how I felt when I read that bs

dense salmon
#

People give the rhetoric that he knew he would lose

#

But that isn't the case

crisp heath
#

He didn't know he'd lose like that

dense salmon
#

He foresaw losing but knew he had a chance to win if he fought perfectly

crisp heath
#

Ain't no way in hells high waters

storm jungle
#

According to the new book

#

he had to face Horus and knew it

#

he wanted to defy destiny

#

and win the fight

dense salmon
#

He clung to hope that he could win

#

But it wasn't even close

storm jungle
#

He actually kicks Horus' ass and makes him drop to a knee

#

then uh

#

we learn Horus wasn't even trying

crisp heath
#

That.

storm jungle
#

and he beats the shit out of him

crisp heath
#

Fucking. That.

dense salmon
#

Horus said "light work, no reaction"

#

Starts sipping the chaos creatine

#

And gives sanguinius the most humiliating and brutal ass whooping ive had the displeasure of reading

#

Sanguinius couldn't even say his final words

storm jungle
#

Yep.

He beats him so bad his face peels off like a mask, Sanguinius cant even say any defiant words because his blood is clogging his throat.

If you want more christian imagery once Horus turns away demons come to nail Sang's body up.

crisp heath
dense salmon
#

To further the tragedy

#

At that point, Horus was dead as well

storm jungle
#

also yeah Horus is completely insane

dense salmon
#

More an avatar of the ruinous powers than himself

storm jungle
#

and extremely delusional

arctic talon
#

Sang getting such a brutal death is befitting of a warhammer character

dense salmon
#

It's a tearjerker for sure

#

It's realistic honestly

#

Real life isn't an opera

storm jungle
#

He basically beats him like a dog yeah

dense salmon
#

Many good people die humiliating and disgraceful deaths

storm jungle
#

even the book says there was no artistry

#

he just beat him to death

crisp heath
#

I mean... like... it's better than the pedestal endings that always happen... but like... they couldn't have chose a different moment to do some shit like this lolol. I'd have rathered the vampire bs to this. My baby boy Sangy damnit!!!

dense salmon
#

It's fitting though

#

Sanguinius was always fighting an internal battle with his dark side

crisp heath
#

Fitting up my craw with sadness and depression, yes

#

Lolol

#

Kidding mostly

#

I get what you're saying

dense salmon
#

A lot of the primarchs had minds suited to advancing humanity beyond war

#

Magnus, Dorn, Guilliman, and Perturabo being notable examples

#

Vulcan and Ferrus too

#

Dorn especially was not a fan of war, preferring statues, paintings, and beautiful architecture to gun batteries and fortress walls

grave sparrow
#

Fulgrim without the Laer blade would've been top tier leader post great crusade

#

Dude turning every world he could into paradise

#

same thing with Magnus

dense salmon
#

Agreed. My only gripe with him is he seems the type to make arts for aesthetics rather than soul

undone zodiac
#

Curze being judge
"Your honour! Jaywalk..."
death

grave sparrow
#

He can't make things for the soul, he's incapable of not making things perfect with his art

dense salmon
#

Curze sees all crime as equal

#

He has a completely binary view on good and evil

#

If you litter

#

To him, you're as abhorrent as a murderer

grave sparrow
#

Lil kid jaywalkin

#

gets SWOOPED

dense salmon
#

And he will absolutely flay you to make you an example

green loom
#

If you might litter, he'll get a vision about a possible future where you do so and kill you as well

dense salmon
#

Yes

#

So not only is he absolutely draconian

#

He has uh

#

The fucking

#

Whats that movie with Tom cruise

#

Where they see future crime

#

Curze also believed the other primarchs were as fucked up as he was

#

So he was not really a fan of the emperor, his brothers, or really anything

storm jungle
#

Curze was the EPITOME of copium

#

like hes right but also like

#

you literally flayed a girl committing suicide

#

you got no ground to stand on you piece of shit lol

#

cry me a goddamn river

grave sparrow
#

Curze's biggest sin was saving lorgar from corvus

green loom
#

I've met someone that defended curze before

dense salmon
#

In curze's defense

#

He was genuinely insane

green loom
#

I mean like for everything

#

Reasoning that he grew up on the street eating rats

grave sparrow
#

Insanity plea lol

dense salmon
#

Curze being euthanized would have been a mercy he welcomed

brisk vine
#

Perturabo's pursuits were pretty ehhhhh

dense salmon
#

This guy literally allowed himself to be decapitated to prove a point

grave sparrow
#

Oh no, he grew up in a city with PEOPLE

Meanwhile there's primarchs who were first exposed to the world in lava lol

brisk vine
#

He locked it all away for his own satisfaction iirc

dense salmon
#

It's hard to sympathize with curze when you read how he tortured vulcan

green loom
grave sparrow
#

Corax grew up in a prison moon

dense salmon
#

Corvus grew up on a prison planet that were serfs to a techno-aristocracy

arctic talon
#

Curze had a fucked up life

green loom
arctic talon
#

But like

#

Does not excuse flaying babies

dense salmon
#

He lead a rebellion and nuked the people who oppressed his

#

And when I say nuke I mean like

#

Giga hiroshima

green loom
#

Yeah I know he grabbed the nuclear arsenal stored on the moon and sent it KEKW_ogryn

#

Which makes him being a loyalist that much funnier

grave sparrow
#

I thought he only sent 5 nukes but knew where all the nukes on the planet were stored

#

big ol sympathetic detonation

dense salmon
#

Im sure if corvus knew that the galaxy was at peace

#

He would have elected to be euthanized

#

He's a rebel

#

And a freedom fighter

green loom
#

"I despise tyrants, fuck tyrants!"
"Omg Emperor hiiiii!"

dense salmon
#

If he has no cause, he has nothing

arctic talon
#

He still hates the emperor

grave sparrow
#

the whole bit where Corvus could see the true emperor's body cracked me up

#

like he's just normal ass lookin dude lol

arctic talon
#

The sisters of silence can’t talk bcs big E doesn’t want to do his hair

#

Or wear his armor

#

No one can know the secret

dense salmon
#

Big E and corvus had a pretty somber, fatherly relationship iirc

grave sparrow
#

ya know there was like that one sister that broke their vow, but I guess they were talking to another sister so I guess there wouldn't be a point to be like "so you've seen the emperor right"

dense salmon
#

Corvus just saw through big E and knew what his real purpose was

#

It's sad, comparatively corvus is a pretty good guy but he is a soldier and nothing else

grave sparrow
#

probably send him to another galaxy and start purging for the Imperium once again lol

#

Ravenguard got the coolest successor chapters tho

#

Space Sharks, Death Specters, Raptors

dense salmon
#

Like a vanguard during the webway project

grave sparrow
#

maybe that was step 2 for Big E, send his boys into the eye of terror/webway and just wreck carnage

patent ivy
#

Since 40K is "our" distant future, I like the thought that tanks in the modern era are looking to be replaced/phased out and then they bring them back far into the future

#

Or that swords are as big of a thing

dense salmon
#

It's parody of the British empire

#

In real life we stopped using swords not necessarily because they weren't effective, but because they gave away whoever was important

#

During a great deal of the great War, a sabre was part of a British officer's uniform

#

So a sniper would just look at who had a sword and dome them

#

Nowadays are uniforms are much more uniform and we don't salute in the field

green loom
#

"Herschel, das bootlicker across ze way has a polished svard, go and shoot him ja?"

dense salmon
#

But close quarters combat was definitely a thing in modern warfare, so knives or any fixed blade were effective

desert dust
#

Also swords, bayonets and clubs are just all over the place because one they are cool and every book makes sure to have people vs people end up in raiding buildings or defending buildings with tight rooms

dense salmon
#

Yeah the rule of cool is the real reason

#

Dune has complex lore for why most combat is with blades

#

Because duels are cool

desert dust
#

My biggest issue is why are there not more shotguns because every guants ghost book seems like if they just had a meltagun in every squad a lot of problems would be solved

desert dust
soft thunder
#

is the AdMEch entitled to all tech discovered by the Imperium or is it only forgeworlds and archeo-tech?

desert dust
#

Rn I'm half way though GG11

#

But God dam dune is so much more interesting

#

40K is literally just action movies

dense salmon
#

Authority can be argued

#

For example, the ordo xenos will handle technology that isn't known to be of human origin

arctic talon
#

Realistically

#

It’s a large majority of it

undone zodiac
#

Blood angels managed to royally piss off admech by snatching couple stc

arctic talon
#

The Lucius pattern engine yeah

#

Admech is very angry

#

Over this one

undone zodiac
#

Also the baal predator

green loom
#

They don't use widespread shotguns because the guard primarily does trench warfare or otherwise longer ranged fights

#

And the lasguns are so absurdly common and standardized that they can drop them around like dirt

soft thunder
undone zodiac
#

Usually only specialised formations in guard get shotties

#

Like krieg engineers

arctic talon
#

Veterans can also use them

undone zodiac
#

Navy uses shotties way more

arctic talon
#

But krieg engineers are def the famous one

green loom
#

Navy breachers also get them, but they have the benefit of being able to go to a planet and ask for them and get ammo

arctic talon
#

They enjoy digging tunnels

#

And well

#

Killing people in tunnels

undone zodiac
#

I kinda would belive catachan also makes decent use of shotguns

dense salmon
#

The punishment for losing equipment is death

#

I'd lug that fucker with me everywhere

arctic talon
#

Athonian tunnel rats love shotguns

undone zodiac
#

Lasgun is like ak. Perfect for conscript abuse

arctic talon
#

But they’re a hive warfare specialist regiment

#

So it’s sort of a no shit situation

dense salmon
#

In tabletop the lasgun sucks

#

But in lore

#

The lasgun is a powerhouse

#

Durable, powerful

#

Easy to manufacture

arctic talon
#

Lasgun still sucks in comparison

#

But it’s strengths

#

Are much more aparant

#

Thing is a very good weapon

undone zodiac
#

Saying lasgun is bad is like saying m16 is bad because it cant destroy tank

#

Guards enemies are just something more fierce

green loom
#

It's not good because one can kill someone, it's good because you can mass 500 of the things KEKW_ogryn

arctic talon
#

And near infinite ammo

#

And it’s durable

undone zodiac
#

And light

#

Like 2 kg or something

storm jungle
#

"Why do we do melee"

arctic talon
#

I love shields

undone zodiac
#

That is a blessing for soldier

arctic talon
#

Lol

storm jungle
#

"Because if someone shoots someone with a shield we all fucking explode"

dense salmon
#

As a soldier

storm jungle
#

genuinely so hilariously realistic

dense salmon
#

I'd rather lug around an m4 than a bazooka

#

Something not heavy as fuck

#

And also something that just works

undone zodiac
#

I mean i was able to carry 50 cal in army. I didnt as much enjoy it

wet sandal
arctic talon
#

On both ends

storm jungle
#

^

dense salmon
storm jungle
#

Yeah its fucking funny af

#

every fighting army from then on just agrees to melee

#

since you cant take the risk

dense salmon
#

Shields also attract shai-halud on arrakis

#

Due to the passive vibrations

arctic talon
#

It’s illegal to use lasers on shielded targets

#

Anyways lol

#

Beyond it being a stupid idea

storm jungle
#

Harkonnes be like

"Its fine ill use killer bee-drones."

undone zodiac
#

I really now want bolt pistol to darktide to round up my sergeant veteran

dense salmon
#

No lie

#

Bolters would be invaluable weapons in dune

#

They're basically handheld artillery

undone zodiac
#

We are getting close there

dense salmon
#

And old-world artillery is what house harkonnen uses to catch atreides off guard

undone zodiac
#

German weapon manufactorer has been building handheld full auto grenade launcher

desert dust
#

Also anyone who breaks the convention of don't nuke people is simultaneously nuked by every other great house or political force because they all own satellites full of nukes orbiting every other planet

storm jungle
#

Fallout Moment

green loom
#

@storm jungle think Daniel is taking bits from this ancient bit of Lore?

storm jungle
#

MOSTLY yeah

#

because this is the only origin point of the star child in lore

green loom
#

Oh boy, and one of the dawn of fire books ties into star child as well?

#

And Dan is also connecting these last books to the twists in Eisenhorn staregryn

dense salmon
#

Don't lasbolts cause like

#

4th degree burns

arctic talon
#

Yeah

#

They blow limbs off

#

And cause horrific burns

#

You won’t bleed out

#

But it’s gona suck even more arguably

dense salmon
#

People call lasguns weak without realizing getting burnt to your fucking bone is irrecoverable

green loom
#

They're capable of taking heads off fairly reliably

#

And I mean

#

Removing it from your shoulder

arctic talon
#

Lasguns are weak against the horrifying foes in the setting

#

But like

dense salmon
#

True

arctic talon
#

The guard don’t fight them regularly

#

They fight uprisings

dense salmon
#

Won't stop a nid

arctic talon
#

Or like weak orks

green loom
#

Lasguns are weak against marines who specifically have highly heat resistant armour KEKW_ogryn

dense salmon
#

But will absolutely stop a person

arctic talon
#

It’ll stop a termagaunt tbh

#

But a nid warrior fuck no lol

dense salmon
#

Or something of similar physicality

green loom
#

Especially a big ol firing line of them

arctic talon
#

Yeah

#

But the lasgun does it’s job great

dense salmon
#

The tau fire warrior being bisected at the waist by a lasgun

arctic talon
#

Fire warrior armor is pretty good akshully šŸ¤“

dense salmon
#

Yeah true

arctic talon
#

It’s about equivalent to carapace

#

Pathfinder armor tho

#

Yeah that guy is cooked

#

But flak can save you from a lasgun shot

#

Maybe 2

dense salmon
#

By our standards flak armor is insane

winter vessel
arctic talon
#

Tbh

#

It’ll save you from like

#

Ork guns

#

Like you’ll live lol

dense salmon
#

Save you from stub guns too

green loom
#

Isn't most armour irl not worth dick against 90% of weapons

arctic talon
#

It’s for shrapnel mostly yeah

dense salmon
winter vessel
#

Dats a lot of DAKKA there is

arctic talon
#

Or small caliber fire

dense salmon
#

During the horus heresy the legions had to modify bolters to fire powerful penetrative rounds instead of high explosive ones

#

Plasma guns trump pretty much all armor

arctic talon
#

Point being flak armor would be a life saver irl

#

Even if in 40K you might as well be in a shirt against some enemies

dense salmon
#

Be a catachan

arctic talon
#

Lol

dense salmon
#

Have muscles so dense it's as good as flak armor

winter vessel
#

So what Guard issue armament could at least bruise an Astartes? Bolters? Las-cannons? Plasma weapons?

scenic bolt
#

most everything

normal light
#

Like plasma, melta

scenic bolt
#

lasguns can kill a space marine if you're either good or lucky and hit a weakpoint like the helmet lens

normal light
#

Heavy emplacements like auto-cannons

normal light
winter vessel
normal light
#

Concentrate fire and use krak

dense salmon
#

Krak grenades, heavy artillery

green loom
#

Guard can kill marines fine

dense salmon
#

A human pattern boltgun is not doing shit

green loom
#

The method isn't the problem typically, it's more that marines are fast and do shock warfare like crazy KEKW_ogryn

dense salmon
#

But a heavy bolter emplacement would do fine

#

Yeah a marine is often described as a blur

#

And they are naturally so intimidating it has a named effect

arctic talon
#

They’re very fast

dense salmon
#

They are deceptively fast

#

Terminator units slow down a bit but

#

They have the armor and firepower to compensate

arctic talon
#

Not like bullet time fast but like

green loom
#

Actually hitting them while shitting your pans is difficult
But if theyre in a bad spot they'll go down like anyone else, they're far from invincible

arctic talon
#

They’re fast lol

dense salmon
#

Yeah marines die all the time

#

All you need is the will and firepower

#

Some of the weapons in darktide could do the trick

#

Power sword, thunder hammer, plasma gun

#

I mean you'd have to have some serious balls to try to kill a marine with a sword

normal light
#

Ogryn

green loom
#

Crusher, force swords, most of the staves, the Lucius if aimed right,

dense salmon
#

But it can be done. I mentioned ciaphas duelling a world eater to a standstill

dense salmon
#

A psyker crushes a marine like a soda can

arctic talon
#

Mmmm

#

Head burst

green loom
#

Technically the Kantrael also counts but we don't really have a power setting option

scenic bolt
#

space marine armor dont protect your head being boiled alive

storm jungle
#

if that doesnt tell you how fragile marines are idk

#

🪨 chadgryn

dense salmon
#

The astartes miniseries isn't canon but

storm jungle
#

it is canon now

dense salmon
#

Two psykers put up a good fight against a squad of marines

#

Oh shit?

storm jungle
#

GW made it official

#

then we never got Astartes 2 lol

dense salmon
#

Deserved

storm jungle
#

and the creator went off to do his own stuff

scenic bolt
#

yea when he got hired to make the new series

dense salmon
#

The first thing not the second

storm jungle
#

my guess is uh

arctic talon
#

He’s still cooking

storm jungle
#

Astartes 2 sometime this year

arctic talon
#

Prolly

storm jungle
#

then no more after that

#

because he literally COMPLETELY

#

dropped warhammer stuff from his patreon

#

which fucking sucks

scenic bolt
#

well it's not like GW doesnt already own the rights and couldnt just do astartes 3 under their own power

#

(like thatll end up well...)

green loom
storm jungle
#

yeah I meant more that the guy doing it had his own style etc

green loom
#

After Sodaz KEKW_ogryn

dense salmon
#

Space marines are a step above regular humans but someone with enough skill makes short work of them

#

Now that I think about it

#

Cain had no way to kill that world eater

#

He had a laspistol and chainsword

#

Neither of which do shit to ceramite

storm jungle
arctic talon
#

Thank Juergen

storm jungle
#

to quote Agent 47, even the strongest chain has a weak link

scenic bolt
#

inquisitors are also in the category of unaugmented human who could conceivably kill space marines

green loom
#

He could've done it with the chainsword but it was taking his all just to not die

winter vessel
dense salmon
#

The marines generally have one big weakness that anyone can exploit

green loom
#

Between marines and humans there's a gap larger than just skill

dense salmon
#

They are very comfortable fighting regular mortals

#

Too comfortable

#

They can be surprised

green loom
#

And that's them being in massive power armour and being able to leisurely tear normal people in half KEKW_ogryn

storm jungle
#

lmao

dense salmon
winter vessel
storm jungle
#

Yeah like

dense salmon
#

Redundant organs

storm jungle
#

most people expect them to dodge literal bullets

#

lmao

scenic bolt
#

space marine librarian

storm jungle
#

or move lightning fast

green loom
#

Custards also die in droves tbr KEKW_ogryn

scenic bolt
#

they're difficult to kill

winter vessel
#

I leave that to the Golden Banana Heads

green loom
#

The only things that really live up to the rep are psykers and primarchs

dense salmon
#

What if a space marine learned gun kata

#

Predicting where bullets would go mathematically and avoiding them

green loom
#

That's what custards do iirc

green loom
#

Math heavy precognition lol

winter vessel
dense salmon
#

Custodes are pretty crazy

#

But again not unkillable

#

On a scale?

scenic bolt
#

genestealer cults stay winning

dense salmon
#

If a regular human is a 2, a guardsman is a 5, a space marine is an 8, a custodes is a 12, and a primarch is a 14

winter vessel
dense salmon
#

The gap isn't necessarily linear math

#

Like im not implying a primarch is 7 humans lol

green loom
dense salmon
#

Depends on the primarch

green loom
#

The custards escorting guilliman realize they're basically just there for show, Bobby can handle himself absurdly well against non-big enemies

dense salmon
#

Lorgar and guilliman are by no means weak, but they're not the insane combat powerhouses that a lot of their brothers are

green loom
#

And a lot of daemons too

dense salmon
#

In a 2v1 guilliman was nearly killed a dozen times by curze

#

To the point he thought him being there was a detriment

green loom
#

Still way above custodes as a base though

dense salmon
#

Agreed

winter vessel
#

Khan’s a good duelist. Angron is the embodiment of a lawnmower on a grass golf course.

green loom
#

A 14 would be someone like Abaddon imo

dense salmon
#

Angron might be a physical powerhouse but he has no tactical thought whatsoever

#

Exploit a bad move from him and he's finished

green loom
#

We see in Fall of Cadia that a custard Trazyn brought just gets beaten aside by him instantly

dense salmon
#

Yeahhh abaddon is pretty nutty

green loom
#

Literally he talks to this ultramarine praetor guy, chops him in half

#

Then runs towards creed and casually beheads the custodes mid run

dense salmon
#

Abaddon wears terminator armor like it's just regular power armor for one

#

For two, he was naturally fucking huge for a marine

#

For three, he's on that chaos creatine

#

Juicing for 10k years

green loom
#

That custard was beating up black legionnaires while barely breaking a sweat, and then the floor gets wiped with him in less than a second

storm jungle
#

ALSO

#

Abnett being Abnett

#

made up an entirely new thing

#

Custodes can literally send thoughts to each other using

#

and I quote

#

"""Neurosynergetics"""

dense salmon
#

What does that even mean

storm jungle
#

literally fucking nothing

#

just mumbo-jumbo

dense salmon
#

Biotechnical telepathy

storm jungle
#

YEP

#

Not psykers tho

#

so idfk

#

gg Dan

dense salmon
#

Pheromones would have made more sense

green loom
#

Shush

#

You'll summon those guys again

dense salmon
#

Brother what's wrong

#

You stink different today

#

Bad dream from dad?

normal light
dense salmon
#

You know if guilliman is a 10 in combat, fighters like curze or sanguinius are probably like

#

30

#

Maybe higher

green loom
#

It'll never not be funny to me how weird wehraboos adore and love marines while entirely missing how fkn gay it all is

dense salmon
#

I enjoy the camaraderie of it all

#

I call close friends brother or sister and mean it in a very familial way

#

So I can relate to that aspect

hollow falcon
#

Krieg is the best Guard Regiment ever

dense salmon
#

did the kriegers pay you to say taht

hollow falcon
#

they don't pay, they demand...by force.

dense salmon
#

they're the best guard regiment until you have money to buy vehicles lol

patent ivy
#

Is Krieg really the best guard regiment?

#

I mean it seems all they are used for are bodies

dense salmon
#

i wish you could hear how hard i enunciate the f in fuck no when i answer that question

#

there is no best guard regiment, they all excel at different things and have wildly different standards and tactics

#

kriegers usually never have disciplinary or morale issues so they excel at drawn-out sieges and wars of attrition

#

they're also very zealous

#

but you can't fight every war with a trench

#

cadians are an insanely effective fighting force namely because they're trained with their squads from childhood

#

they have very high standards for their recruitment

#

catachans weed out the weak just by living on their homeworld

#

only 50% of catachans born make it to the age of 10

#

50% of those make it to adulthood

patent ivy
#

So 25% to adulthood

#

Was that 50% of 50% or just the other 50%

dense salmon
#

it's less of which hammer hits the hardest and more which tool is right for the job

#

but just being a guardsman is already being like

#

the best soldier humanity has to offer

dense salmon
patent ivy
#

Ok

dense salmon
#

now if we're talking tabletop meta

#

catachan is probably one of the worst guard regiments you can choose

#

krieg has some advantages but someone put it best when they said they're a poor man's armageddon steel legion

#

catachans just need new units and new rules tbh

patent ivy
#

I mean no disrespect, but Krieg favouritism seems like just a bunch of larping

dense salmon
#

ehhh

#

it's 50/50

#

some people really genuinely enjoy them

#

others, just the idea of them

#

they're popular for a reason

#

even people who don't know much about 40k know about krieg

undone zodiac
#

Krieg is a wehraboo magnet

patent ivy
#

That's what I meant

#

Every online interaction I've had/seen in the past month dealing with em seems like it

dense salmon
#

meet some 40k fans in person

undone zodiac
#

They know exactly 2 jokes

dense salmon
#

i know a great guy who plays krieg

#

i learned a lot about painting from him

#

as far from a wehraboo as you can be

patent ivy
#

I'm not denying the existence of normal fans, but they appear to be in the minority

dense salmon
#

i think you're dealing with a vocal minority of the fandom who have a weird love for ww2 germany

patent ivy
#

Hope so

dense salmon
#

krieg isn't even ww2 germany

#

it's more the greater prussian area in ww1

patent ivy
#

Yeah

dense salmon
#

though admittedly GW isn't doing themselves any favors naming helmets DEATH'S HEAD

undone zodiac
#

I made my vet guard kill team with as many field caps as i could and painted them bluish grey to make them look like ww2 finnish uniform

patent ivy
#

Pics? Sounds nice

dense salmon
#

i want to get a 3d printer to make my own guard regiment with morion helmets

#

probably just go with standard cadian/guard rules

undone zodiac
#

I dont have on my phone but ill put em at some point

#

I only miss that i didnt try to make them drum mags

patent ivy
#

Has had it for like 2 years now and has had a blast printing a bunch of stuff