#40k-lore-chat

1 messages · Page 318 of 1

green loom
#

"Hello Alien species, enjoy firestorm of death"

crisp heath
#

@burnt maple this I highly disagree with

burnt maple
#

Him keeping secrets.

crisp heath
#

He was not compulsive in the least, as so far as has been shown. He was meticulous to a fault, and arguably with foresight as powerful as his, every single thing has been planned by him so far

molten swan
#

He kept secrets because his sons couldn’t handle it I think

#

Some of them at least

#

Among other things

crisp heath
#

And I also don't necessarily think humanities best interests were always at his forefront of priorities. At best, it was simply the most convincing lie

burnt maple
#

His foresight allowed him to see end results, not the way.

molten swan
#

Yeah I think humanities best chance is with big E

#

As shown by the literal galaxy spanning empire he created before it fell apart

crisp heath
#

@burnt maple if they were, many different decisions would likely have been made that potentially didn't favor him but would have been favorable to the rest of humanity

burnt maple
#

Example? And please don't mention nikaea, that was bs.

molten swan
#

For example, how would humanity not simply be trapped as techno barbarians fighting for the rest of time?

arctic talon
#

They were beginning to contact their old colonies

#

But that’s a whole other can of worms

crisp heath
#

I mean but you mentioned it, so you know it's a fact. But honestly, a lot. He didn't allow for the fostering of outside thought. He didn't allow for innovation. Every decision placed him higher on a pedestal, and we know he changes his appearance and aura with the warp to suit his audience

burnt maple
#

What. Wait.

crisp heath
#

Every single thing he ever did made him a God head, even when he preached against it

molten swan
#

The admech don’t allow for innovation (Cawl still innovates)

green loom
#

My opinion is simple

#

The Emperor is Sax

molten swan
#

He is seen as a god, because he is a god, much to his displeasure

crisp heath
#

Cawl is an outlier under immense amounts of scrutiny all the time

burnt maple
#

Admech doesnt allow innovation because it is FUCKING SCARY TO THEM. History says it all.

molten swan
#

Tbh

hollow falcon
#

They just need to find a fully intact STC

molten swan
#

Like oh look, I made this cool new robot to help us robot kills everyone

#

Same reason dwarves don’t like to innovate, they like to make sure it won’t kill everyone when they pull the trigger 🤣

burnt maple
#

^

#

Admech to dismay of many a memer isnt stupid.

crisp heath
#

It also doubles as keeping the populace stupid and easily manipulable

burnt maple
#

Thry are simply cautious.

#

To a fault.

molten swan
#

Is the population being indoctrinated not for their own good? In a perfect world they’d likely not need to, but this is 40k, not a perfect world

#

In a galaxy when you can wake up a psyker, see some horror of the warp and explode into a warp portal, is extreme caution bad?

crisp heath
#

Is it for their own good, or has it been to serve one man who told them it was for their own good, who led a path so far down that now its the only way

#

Especially with a culture like the tau

#

Who might not be perfect, but show that there is a better option to the imperium

#

Culture wise

molten swan
#

I’d say it’s ultimately for their own good, the 40k galaxy is one ultimately protected by the Emperor, it’s not about control like with the Tau

burnt maple
#

Ylu kiddin, right?

#

Tau is exactly like the Imperium. Just younger.

molten swan
#

The Tau literally mindcontrol their lessers and have a strict caste system where you cannot advance or intermingle for long periods of time lest you waste time not working for the greater good

burnt maple
#

^

crisp heath
#

Like I said, not perfect. And isn't there an offshoot that separated because of that?

molten swan
#

And the worst part is the castes are basically different races, but they’re all mind controlled and reinforced by the ethereals

#

To work for the highest caste

#

The etherals

crisp heath
#

But the imperium is literally stated as the worst human regime imaginable

#

By its authors lol

burnt maple
green loom
molten swan
#

Not exactly tbh

green loom
#

Yes exactly

burnt maple
#

Nope.

crisp heath
#

@green loom pretty sure it was alluded to in one of... dammit I'm forgetting his name but he was like a really famous captain or something for them

green loom
#

You're not exempt from the tithe, so either you break your back paying it or get butchered until you do KEKW_ogryn

molten swan
#

An Agri world where you farm 24/7 isn’t a dystopian hellhole. Many worlds, like those in Ultramar are not dystopian hellholes at all

crisp heath
#

@green loom that's kinda what I thought myself, that even the peaceful ones weren't like, good planets

green loom
#

Yes it is

#

You know how the imperium does farming?

burnt maple
#

So long a world doesn't do some crucial task for the Imperium, it is calm.

arctic talon
#

There’s a ton of agriworlds that are absolute shit

green loom
#

They render planets barren within a few cycles

arctic talon
#

Where it’s just

#

Mass brutal industrial farming

burnt maple
#

Pay your tithe and fuck off.

green loom
#

Yeah but then the tithe is the problem KEKW_ogryn

molten swan
#

Yes, but compared to literally being eaten by some huge bug? I’ll farm thanks

green loom
#

And the people are still violently repressed on a good day

burnt maple
#

Makes it not a hellscape by default.

#

If managed well, the worldin question can be really cool to live on.

#

Unless you are farming or smithing.

#

Then you are fucked.

green loom
#

If they're managing well they're likely a more advanced world, so subject to the funny thing called Imperial nobility KEKW_ogryn

marsh berry
#

I sure am glad Earth today is a calm and peaceful world

crisp heath
#

How often does the imperium manage anything even half decent, let alone well

molten swan
#

Also the Tau mind control is from a few books, prob easier to just look up ethereal mind control, but it’s basically pheromones and some other theories

crisp heath
#

Actually the Orks haver their own Malum Caedo.

green loom
#

You don't even need to bs it for yourself to see what the hell is going on there

molten swan
#

Theories on how the ethereals control their lessers so well, yeah

arctic talon
#

Tau don’t have mind control

burnt maple
arctic talon
#

As far as we know

#

It’s just

green loom
#

It's just fanatacism, you know the thing common af in the Imperium?

arctic talon
#

Uber propaganda

#

Which

#

Is awful

crisp heath
#

Like, it's a real thing. I still think the tau is a better culture than the imperium, but the mind control is a fact

molten swan
#

They also have pheromones and the etherals tricks. Way more than just propaganda

arctic talon
#

🤓

#

It’s a theory

green loom
#

They have reeducation camps, why do people close in on the fucking pheromones lol

crisp heath
#

How it works hasn't been fleshed out by gw, that's why there are theories, but it is a thing

arctic talon
#

The tau are just an irl facist regime

green loom
#

We know the Nagi or whatever they're called can screw with minds

arctic talon
#

Re-education camps

#

Tons of propaganda

green loom
#

But beyond that they're pretty tame compared to

arctic talon
#

A stratified society

green loom
#

You know

arctic talon
#

The imperium makes most things look tame

green loom
#

Servitors and hypno indoctrination KEKW_ogryn

arctic talon
#

Tbh

molten swan
arctic talon
#

I would not want to be in a Tau re-education camp

green loom
#

The first tau codex?

#

Wolf do you know any retconned facts from old imp codices lol

arctic talon
#

4e?

dense salmon
molten swan
#

You can see this when Tau are rioting and the etherals walk in, everyone calms down, folks start crushing each other to get out of the etherals way

arctic talon
#

I don’t have any old Tau codex’s

dense salmon
#

With a caste system

green loom
#

I don't think that's Pheromones my guy KEKW_ogryn

#

You know who has a similar phenomenon

#

Primarchs

molten swan
#

Also, there’s a scene when Aunva tells a water caste to end her life, and she instantly does it

dense salmon
#

Primarchs have a literal god aura that forces their sons to obey

crisp heath
#

@green loom it might not be, but it's not simple indoctrination either

green loom
#

And ig marines with Transhuman dread

dense salmon
#

The emperor could mind control vast swaths of humanity if he wanted to

molten swan
#

The water caste didn’t even want to but she listened and ended her life

arctic talon
#

Tbh if Kim Jong Un told some mid level North Korean officer to kill themselves

#

They would

crisp heath
#

Probably has a few times

dense salmon
#

He used his psychic might to make lorgar and the word bearers kneel before him

arctic talon
#

Just saying

dense salmon
#

Just as an example of what serving a God is like

arctic talon
#

The level of fanaticism the tau display is possible with extreme propaganda and enforcement

crisp heath
storm jungle
#

the Emperor doesnt need to mind control people

green loom
#

Yeah anyway

storm jungle
#

he has charisma

green loom
#

"Tau are literally The Imperium" is a dumb take

dense salmon
#

He has w rizz

storm jungle
#

Also yeah lmao

green loom
#

The point is firmly above your head atm

arctic talon
#

The tau are still an authoritarian hellhole

#

It’s just less bad compared to

hollow falcon
#

Tau will get crushed

crisp heath
green loom
#

Yeah but they haven't had their funny sorta kinda destined character development into an imperium-esque shitscape

patent ivy
#

Commissar?? You must be a big deal

arctic talon
#

I don’t see why you think this level of fanaticism isn’t possible via propaganda

molten swan
#

Theres another scene when the etherals walk into two camps of tau that are fighting, they again instantly start negotiating and the book says they were "felt inexplicably compelled to act as the Ethereals wished".

arctic talon
#

Because it’s occurred irl

#

I think it’s completely reasonable

forest orbit
molten swan
#

what leader IRL makes you "inexplicably compelled" to follow their commands? @arctic talon

storm jungle
#

Literally any IRL dictator

green loom
#

Yeah lmfao

storm jungle
#

lmfao

crisp heath
#

@arctic talon because it's stated to not be fanaticism. It's literally stated as an eerie calm that comes over them all

green loom
#

It's drilled into you

molten swan
#

Not in this way, no

storm jungle
#

Like you do not understand how brainwashed humans can get

molten swan
#

this isnt brainwashing lmao

storm jungle
#

It is lmao

#

its literally propaganda

arctic talon
#

I mean propaganda is brainwashing

storm jungle
#

^

molten swan
#

its not propaganda either

storm jungle
molten swan
#

its literally the etherals controlling them lmao

forest orbit
#

Not really

#

Its left in the air

#

the Tau are as fanatical to their leaders as the Imperials are to theirs

crisp heath
#

But it's literally stated in lore that that's not what is happening, that the ethereal have this power. Idk why people are arguing a known fact in the lore...

#

This is silly

molten swan
#

they just dont knw

#

idk

patent ivy
#

I think this was the thing that got me more interested. I knew about 40k back then, but the memes surrounding this

forest orbit
#

which was written by an imperial

#

its literally all gibberish

green loom
#

You grow up, and every single day in your life it's drilled into you that your masters are the paragons of peace and sensibility
All tau are fallible, but the Ethereals are not
If you grow up accepting this as the literal fundamental truth of your society, you'll find you have a fairly extreme reverence for said group of people KEKW_ogryn

crisp heath
#

I have multiple times said it's not pheromones

molten swan
#

it could be phermones, but thats old lore from xenology and not outwardly confirmed as I said

crisp heath
#

Feel like nobody has read anything I've written. I'm just gonna peace out...

storm jungle
#

Lore Chat Moment

green loom
#

They're not brainwashed from the point where they have formed ideas

#

The brainwashing IS the ideas

storm jungle
#

Just look at America

#

I joke

marsh berry
#

Do we actually know whether Trump excretes pheremones

forest orbit
#

I mean

green loom
#

It's sorta like Death Korps or Cadians in a way

forest orbit
#

hes pretty orange

#

never trust a guy that looks like that

molten swan
#

cheeto fumes

storm jungle
#

man

#

now I want cheetos

#

but its like 3 at night

forest orbit
#

fack, same

green loom
#

I've got

molten swan
#

The phermones implication in Xenology is that the Eldar engineered the Ethereals using pheromone control biology stolen from an insectile species called the Q'orl btw

storm jungle
#

Yeah thats a wild ass theory

green loom
storm jungle
#

I remember asking it to Gav Thorpe on reddit

#

fun times

green loom
#

Also isn't xenology like

#

WAY uutdated

storm jungle
#

Yeah its non-canon

patent ivy
#

Cheetos are overrated I think

molten swan
#

yes its old as I said

storm jungle
#

its a great fucking book tho

molten swan
#

regardless still relevant, esp to tau and a lot of the xenos it touches

winter vessel
storm jungle
#

Eh no

crisp heath
#

That doesn't mean newer books haven't still informed the idea they have the power, again how it works has simply not been explained.

storm jungle
#

it gets a lot of things wrong

#

since like

crisp heath
#

But the power exists

storm jungle
#

its written by a mad man

green loom
#

Also the newer book is cooler

storm jungle
#

That ill disagree with

green loom
storm jungle
#

Xenologis' presentation is POOP

#

the artwork is not too bad

molten swan
#

Catachan Devil eating a tank, yum

crisp heath
#

Another power that hasn't been explained that definitely exist, perpetuals. This shit exists in universe guys

arctic talon
#

Liber Xenologis?

molten swan
#

ye

storm jungle
#

yep

arctic talon
#

Xenologis is much better as an actual like book

storm jungle
#

Perpetuals are fucking dumb

molten swan
#

perpeturals are basically just immortals

#

they die, come back

green loom
storm jungle
#

literally just Abnett's self-insert of Eternals, because he wrote for Marvel

crisp heath
#

That die, alot

molten swan
#

nuke them, die, come back

green loom
#

Some die and come back

#

Some don't

crisp heath
#

@green loom still exists

green loom
#

Some live forever

molten swan
#

you need to kill them with special anti perpetual weapons to make it permanent

green loom
#

Some just don't

storm jungle
#

legit playground rules

patent ivy
#

Perpetuals just a funny concept cuz in a situation like the Empire of Man, you can have the same person lead it indefinitely

green loom
crisp heath
#

But they still exist

crisp heath
#

Allll this shit talk, and they still exist

storm jungle
#

i mean yeah

#

but like

#

they dont affect

crisp heath
#

So do the ethereals, so does their power

storm jungle
#

the wider setting

#

Perpetuals are mostly relegated to HH

dense salmon
#

i look away for 10 minutes and lore chat is heatingu p

storm jungle
#

and from there to Abnett books

#

because they are a dogshit idea

green loom
dense salmon
#

i always found the tau to be kind of boring personally

molten swan
#

same

#

hated them on tabletop too

storm jungle
#

that explains it

#

lol

green loom
#

Phil kelly misses a lot of the potential to write his le epic OC Farsight

dense salmon
#

the tau have a caste system

#

there is no real world caste system like it, but india has one to this day

storm jungle
#

I mean yeah

molten swan
#

india yeah, pretty close

storm jungle
#

its fiction

#

kinda

molten swan
#

cant advance

storm jungle
molten swan
#

cant mingle

marsh berry
#

It's a good thing Imperial citizens are free to do whatever they like

molten swan
#

thought thankfully most young folks dont do that anymore

storm jungle
#

lmao

#

nice

green loom
#

I mean it's a thing that they also don't want to mingle

#

Tau are pretty like

#

Apathetic kinda

molten swan
#

nah they wanna

#

they literally just cant

storm jungle
#

Nah

#

some dont

#

they are all individuals

dense salmon
#

let's ask a tau

molten swan
#

obviously

green loom
#

No they just don't have family units typically

storm jungle
#

^

green loom
#

Like Farsight iirc has feelings for Shadowsun and it's an oddity

storm jungle
#

I mean Shadowsun is big waifu so

crisp heath
#

FARSIGHT THAT WAS THAT MOFOS NAME!!!

molten swan
#

probably because they werent allowed to form bonds in their family?

#

life* rather

storm jungle
#

wow

#

sounds familiar to my life

green loom
#

No they don't have families

dense salmon
#

is the new shop cycle tomorrow or next week?

#

i forget

molten swan
#

not just family

storm jungle
#

but the women

#

and the children too

patent ivy
green loom
#

For the premium shop it's next thursday

molten swan
#

friends cant mingle too much, cant have too much fun with another caste, gotta focus on the greater good

dense salmon
#

hallowette's my bad

patent ivy
#

Oh

storm jungle
#

no its Halloween

patent ivy
#

College has been boring

crisp heath
#

Doesn't farsight literally separate and start another faction of tau specifically because of the ethereals power in one of his books

storm jungle
#

hes the epitome rebel yeah

#

but thats more just ideals clashing

molten swan
#

doesnt like the mind control yes big rebel

arctic talon
#

He just doesn’t think the ethereals should be in power

#

At all

storm jungle
#

^

#

it has nothing to do with mind control

green loom
#

Phil Kelly keeps making him right-er too

#

Which is funny

storm jungle
#

Phil Kelly should explode

#

lol

crisp heath
#

Iideals!!?!?!?! They control your mind lol. It's not ideal clashing, is ideal inception lol

storm jungle
#

oh my god

crisp heath
#

Dude was like nope km out

storm jungle
#

THEY DONT MIND CONTROL PEOPLE

#

HOLY SHIT IM GOING INSANE

green loom
#

But DIlara it's implied

#

In this book I didn't read from two decades ago

storm jungle
#

Im gonna imply this gun to my foot

crisp heath
#

They literally do though 🤣 I don't get how you can deny it

molten swan
#

I suppose the narrator saying that tau are compelled to act around etherals against their will is just propaganda!

storm jungle
#

and its inconsistenet as shit

#

maybe thats how

#

also like

crisp heath
#

It's in farsights books!!! And I know that's not outdated

molten swan
#

this witchfinder works for the etherals

#

etheralsupporter

storm jungle
dense salmon
#

i would weigh in if i read a single tau book in my life

storm jungle
#

You shouldnt

#

at least the Kelly ones 💀

#

a writer so bad every tau fan hates him

crisp heath
#

Ehh, I agree honestly

storm jungle
#

its like Nick Kyme with Salamanders

#

and Gav Thorpe with Eldar

molten swan
#

how do you explain the funny little mind control node they found in the etheral autopsy? whatthefuck_heresy

crisp heath
#

🤣

green loom
#

Wait I can't find anything on Farsight doing it because of the mind control KEKW_ogryn

storm jungle
#

like

#

every autopsy

#

is literally him theorizing

#

thats the point

molten swan
#

doesnt matter if hes crazy, he has a literal body

storm jungle
dense salmon
#

naked tau...

storm jungle
#

also someone forgot to tell the artist how to draw tau feet

#

💀

green loom
#

Ok it's time to get silly

#

Dance off tomorrow fr

storm jungle
#

Im gonna make you explode

dense salmon
#

dad bod ultramarine with a cigar

crisp heath
#

@green loom read the books

dense salmon
#

BALDING dad bod ultramarine with a cigar

marsh berry
#

‘Tau Tau’

patent ivy
#

Its so funny how the dude with a cigar looks like Tony

dense salmon
#

tony soprano

storm jungle
#

I DONT CARE WHAT ANYONE SAYS

#

IN THIS HOUSE THE EMPEROR IS A HERO

#

END OF SUBJECT

patent ivy
#

🤣

green loom
#

DUDE

crisp heath
#

I mean... But is he thooooooo

#

Lolol

green loom
#

EMPIRE OF LIES
H

#

HAS A SECTION

#

ON HOW THE WATER CASTE CONDUCT HERO WORSHIP TO INSPIRE OBEDIENCE

storm jungle
#

Oh my god i forgot about that

dense salmon
#

"whateva happened to... marius gage. now that was an ultramarine. the strong, silent type."

green loom
#

In other words

storm jungle
green loom
#

LITERALLY PROPAGANDA

storm jungle
#

at this point

#

seeing the word "mind control"

#

makes me want to go berserk

#

maybe its working

molten swan
#

Your thoughts betray you

crisp heath
#

Thought redirection work better for you?

#

@storm jungle

storm jungle
#

No thats just what my government does

green loom
#

Do you think macabbian fans know where "Jannisary" comes from

storm jungle
#

no they dont

arctic talon
green loom
#

"They're cleaners right, Janitors?"

marsh berry
#

I feel like I saw that word in Chivalry

storm jungle
#

guard fans are mostly like european/western dudes who see a historical reference

#

and wojak point

#

"OMG ITS FRANCE IN SPACE"

green loom
#

Uhh

hollow falcon
#

Heresy

storm jungle
green loom
#

What's the Tunisian ripoff called

molten swan
#

Jannisary like those guys with the fancy hats

dense salmon
#

warhammer is for everybody

storm jungle
hollow falcon
#

Guard's the best, fuck the rest

dense salmon
green loom
#

You know some guard fans really remind me of those old action toys with built in action voicelines

forest orbit
green loom
#

Oh now I have an idea

#

"Wind up Cadian"

storm jungle
#

oh god

marsh berry
#

About to get my irl aquila forehead tattoo wish me luck guys

storm jungle
#

NOOOO

green loom
#

Dilara can you edit something

storm jungle
#

One sec

storm jungle
#

Anyway you were saying

molten swan
#

Krieg memers next

green loom
#

I've got a comic page idea, could you add sounds to it

molten swan
#

Grab your shovels!!!

storm jungle
#

Sure, what is it

green loom
#

I'll get back to you on that tomorro

molten swan
#

(Bayonet is the superior melee weapon)

green loom
#

ONce I draw it

#

But it'll just be "Wind up Guard fan"

storm jungle
#

👍

crisp heath
#

Look, I disagree heavily with the pheromone theory myself. They're to few and rare for that to be controlling the entire empire. But they are doing something. Yes, every society uses propaganda, in 40k and irl. But some of the things shown from the ethereals are actions a person simply would not take if they were rationale and in control of their own actions compared to being influenced or controlled by another. As was stated earlier, there is a procession scene where they walk through a riot and an eerie calm surrounds the entire crowd at once, as soon as they arrive. And as they walk through, people literally trample over one another, while still remaining in this weird calm state, just to clear a path for them

molten swan
green loom
#

"Watcha got there"
"A guard fan"
winds up
"The Emperor Protects! Heresy! Heresy!"

winter vessel
green loom
#

winds up
"Fix bayonets! Fix bayonets!"

molten swan
#

Wind up inquisitor

green loom
#

"Innocence proves nothing"

hollow falcon
#

So many heretic's here

molten swan
#

heresy BLAM

green loom
#

No that's Wind Up Commissar

molten swan
arctic talon
undone zodiac
#

Gasmask noise/shovel spam of kriegs fans

winter vessel
#

Felt bad for them Krieg boys in Pariah Nexus

storm jungle
#

I didnt

#

it was hilarious

dense salmon
#

i'm telling you

storm jungle
dense salmon
#

if they ever come up with a guard regiment that wears a morion helmet

#

i will start a new army that very day

arctic talon
#

All those imperial characters are gona die anyways in the pariah nexus

storm jungle
#

They never will

arctic talon
#

Lol

storm jungle
#

do your own regiment

#

break the system

undone zodiac
#

I want regiment of san marco marines

dense salmon
crisp heath
#

You know I find it funny how power creep in the 40K universe is when compared to toher universes.,

storm jungle
crisp heath
#

I mean the Darktide Rejects four recently paroled meth heads are doing a much better job than team RWBY, four ladies trained at a young age in a state of the art combat school and who have ACTUAL SUPER POWERS.

storm jungle
#

Sounds like a good time

#

oh wait-

patent ivy
#

Is RWBY still going? I never watched it myself but my neighbor when I was younger did

storm jungle
#

Holy shit is it

patent ivy
#

He had a few years on me

storm jungle
#

i gotta check

#

SERIOUSLY

patent ivy
#

Bruh

winter vessel
#

its in a tough spot with WB currently

storm jungle
#

Yeah thats fair

#

had no idea the creator died

winter vessel
#

Oum? That's old news

#

but no one could hold a candle to his level of fighting animations

hollow falcon
#

Is that show that popular?

storm jungle
#

Yes lol

#

dumb masses are easy to please

storm jungle
#

sounds kinda familiar

arctic talon
#

Lol

storm jungle
crisp heath
#

I never really understood or got into it

storm jungle
#

same

hollow falcon
#

we are still kinda niche

winter vessel
#

they finally got Yam and Bland together after 8 volumes and incessant shipping from the community

storm jungle
#

I mean being niche doesnt stop your fandom from being awful

arctic talon
#

40k’s masses enjoy their slop

storm jungle
#

i say this as a 11 year long warhammer fan

#

💀

#

Loved when back in the day 40k fans went "Ew girl."

Now its 2023, and they still go "Ew girl." ❤️

crisp heath
storm jungle
#

Truly the most blessed timeline

dense salmon
#

i can say i'm a generational warhammer fan

hollow falcon
#

To gatekeep or not to gatekeep...

dense salmon
#

my dad was stationed in the UK and got into it in the 90s

winter vessel
dense salmon
#

then i was born and he passed the hobby on to me

storm jungle
#

💀

patent ivy
#

I watched RvB back then rather than RWBY

storm jungle
#

good decision

crisp heath
storm jungle
#

Red vs Blue was great

#

was

dense salmon
#

to think my dad was around to see the ultramarine dance shit

crisp heath
dense salmon
#

and still be a diehard 40k fan

#

enough to pass the hobby on to me

hollow falcon
dense salmon
#

is hilarious

storm jungle
#

you say this like 40k is a "pure" fandom

crisp heath
#

Lol fr

storm jungle
#

its genuinely as bad as Star Wars

arctic talon
#

GW is content with what they do currently anyways

storm jungle
#

or like any other popular IP

hollow falcon
#

it isnt

dense salmon
#

star wars is much worse

arctic talon
#

They don’t care to expand

crisp heath
#

I'd honestly say it might be worse

dense salmon
#

disney isn't as protective of the IP as GWis

winter vessel
crisp heath
#

Just cause it's older I think

patent ivy
#

Beakies helmet design is better imo, although the new ones definitely look cool in their own ways

crisp heath
#

It's had more time to fester

dense salmon
arctic talon
#

GW is very aggressive with enforcement of making sure their stuff is accurate

#

It’s kind of hilarious lol

#

It can be absolute dogshit

hallow basin
arctic talon
#

But it better be lore complaint lol

storm jungle
# hollow falcon it isnt
  • Whiny sexist/racist/fascist fans
  • People that hate everything the company produces
  • Fanbase that always wants to stick to the older stuff without anything new in the setting
  • Fanbase that always wants new stuff but the moment it gets made then whine and then want to go back to old stuff
#

Star Wars and Warhammer are like brothers

crisp heath
#

Lol I mean when you put it like that....

storm jungle
#

wait I forgot the best one

  • Fans that still hate the company but buy everything they produce
dense salmon
#

nah just kidding

arctic talon
#

There’s some stuff that’s good

dense salmon
#

hammer and bolter has some genuinely cool episodes

patent ivy
arctic talon
#

There’s also dogshit as well

#

It’s a mix

storm jungle
#

Yeah dont get me wrong

#

40k has its good bits

winter vessel
storm jungle
#

but like when 40k stans think they are superior to other sci-fi IPs its lol

hollow falcon
dense salmon
#

i love 40k and every hobbyist i've met irl was very welcoming and taught me a lot

storm jungle
#

lol

dense salmon
#

40k fans are genuinely nice in person

crisp heath
storm jungle
dense salmon
#

the internet does things to people that makes them forget how nice people can actually be

arctic talon
#

I’ve met like 2 people I’d call awful in the hobby irl

#

But

winter vessel
arctic talon
#

They got bans from the LGS’s

winter vessel
#

which was...2020?

arctic talon
#

And have a terrible reputation

#

So i don’t need to think about them

hollow falcon
dense salmon
#

there is like

#

a TERRIBLE animated film

#

from 20 years ago

dense salmon
#

that was my introduction to 40k

#

my dad cut that on for me

storm jungle
#

That moment when people forget a normal wimply Star Trek crewman has a phaser that can insta kill a space marine

#

Or how Daleks from Doctor who literal trash-cans can wipe out the entirety of the Imperium

#

💀

crisp heath
#

Here's my thing with star wars. Any one movie can be criticized, but played through chronologically is one of the greatest cinematic experiences of all time. Going through the rise and fall, it's like an old greek tale unfolding before your eyes. I think people get way to wound up in the hate to enjoy stuff sometimes

storm jungle
#

Im just glad we got shit like Andor

#

absolute peak sci-fi

dense salmon
#

i didn't really enjoy mandalorian

storm jungle
#

Yeah it went downhill

#

just watch Andor

#

its great

dense salmon
#

yeah i've seen andor

crisp heath
dense salmon
#

andor and ahsoka were actually not bad

#

kenobi had like

#

two good scenes

storm jungle
dense salmon
#

in the entire show

winter vessel
marsh berry
#

But Star Trek crew always set phasers to stun

storm jungle
#

"I can't swim."

dense salmon
#

i used to call myself a star wars fan, but with all the new content i don't really enjoy i can't say that i am

#

i'm more a fan of the original and prequel trilogies

storm jungle
#

same

#

Also Clone Wars

#

boy was that fun to watch growing up

#

all that violence KEK

green loom
dense salmon
#

i like a lot of the original EU stuff too

crisp heath
#

See... I just wish we got George Lucas's plans for the universe instead of Disney. I dirt necessarily mind either, but I like how he wanted to expand more on the midicjlorians and the actual way everything worked in star wars, the actual world building

green loom
#

I'd know, I'm one and I never go out

winter vessel
storm jungle
#

and just went "fuck it i dont care"

crisp heath
#

THey could make SW Ahsoka 1000% better by just adding this guy.

green loom
#

Also Ngl

crisp heath
#

I agree honestly @storm jungle

green loom
#

The EU Is

storm jungle
#

Starkiller my beloved

green loom
#

Hit or miss

molten swan
#

I think he saw that disney check and went

dense salmon
green loom
#

The VA is everywhere in Star Wars lol

#

He voiced Maul

dense salmon
#

yeah

storm jungle
green loom
#

iirc

winter vessel
patent ivy
#

Not a big fan of Disney Star Wars, but there are definitely some diamonds in the rough from em

storm jungle
#

100%

green loom
#

I love Disney ship designs ngl

dense salmon
#

disney star wars lacks soul

storm jungle
#

actually wait does lucas still make money from star wars

dense salmon
#

is my biggest criticism

storm jungle
#

i gotta check brb

dense salmon
#

it's like

green loom
#

Save for the huge ships

dense salmon
#

they can get the aesthetics down pat

#

the sound

crisp heath
#

I'm not 100 percent sure honestly

dense salmon
#

but they can't capture the soul of it

green loom
#

But I really like stuff like the Raddus and the random tiny corvettes

storm jungle
#

Here it is

crisp heath
#

But I'd think he'd keep some royalties

storm jungle
#

Yeah there it is

green loom
#

I'm a certified tiny ship enjoyer

dense salmon
crisp heath
#

After taking the Republic Base, the Imperium of Man quickly moves their forces in to occupy it. Their sudden attack doesn't come unnoticed, as the Republic quickly sends a force to retake the base from these unknown forces. While Imperial and Republic fighters engage each other in battle for air superiority, a Jedi and his padawan are sent to le...

▶ Play video
dense salmon
#

so bad batch was probably a payout for him

patent ivy
#

Yeah I was gonna say, Lucas was paid to f off from the IP originally

#

But I mean, with that amount of money he made

storm jungle
#

Good for him i guess KEKW_ogryn

crisp heath
#

Huh, but that specifies newer movies. I bet he still makes royals off his he made

winter vessel
#

Most of my childhood was experienced through the Clone Wars series. But I was happy Filoni finished his work with S7. I remember watching the cut rough animations and thought "If only he could finish it" when I was a kid

storm jungle
#

Same

#

Clone Wars is literally like

#

40k with a Star Wars paintjob

#

its violent as FUCK

winter vessel
storm jungle
dense salmon
#

you know what i always wondered

patent ivy
#

Yeah I wish it was a little more graphic in terms of when people got wounded

green loom
#

Just wish Filoni wasn't a hack smarf

dense salmon
#

do catachans have an american accent?

storm jungle
#

British/American

#

because 40k

crisp heath
#

I believe it was closer to Scottish/British

green loom
#

Dude I can't explain it

storm jungle
dense salmon
#

there was an episode of clone wars where they set geonosians on fire

green loom
#

But hearing americans in warhammer stuff weirds me out

storm jungle
#

Yeah like uh

#

the censors are basically no blood

#

any other color tho?

#

go nuts

crisp heath
#

Feels out of place

winter vessel
green loom
#

They all feel like this guy

#

By request, I uploaded this clip of Captain Thomas Leroy, an American exile, politely defending Sharpe and offers his thoughts on one common source of the real power between Democracy and Monarchy. No need to subscribe or like, I'm just here to give you guys what you want but what I would really like is some real discussion in the comments.

▶ Play video
storm jungle
#

FUCKING EXPLODES

crisp heath
winter vessel
green loom
#

Oh that reminds me

#

One sec I'm grabbing a lin

dense salmon
storm jungle
#

Grievous had NO chill

dense salmon
#

it's perfectly in-line with the lore, making a jedi feel fear heavily disconnects them from the force

#

no force = no precognition

winter vessel
#

But I was more of a 327th Star Corps fan so it was sad I only got to see a little of Commander Bly and Secura

dense salmon
#

he combines this with being able to strike like

#

4 dozen times in one SECOND

#

if he uses all 4 arms

storm jungle
#

He got nerfed bad

patent ivy
#

Animate

dense salmon
#

to completely mentally overwhelm jedi

green loom
#

No

#

Source is in the link lol

#

But it's Tartakovsky style 40k

patent ivy
#

Bah

green loom
#

Very epic

crisp heath
#

Then there is this guy.

winter vessel
winter vessel
dense salmon
#

ARC troopers are nuts

patent ivy
#

True

dense salmon
#

personally trained by jango fett

crisp heath
#

I would love to see Tarakvosky take 40k.

#

Man I miss that show

patent ivy
#

I remember I wanted the Black Lego ARF Trooper back then

#

Limited release thing

dense salmon
winter vessel
patent ivy
#

Anyone picking up that game?

dense salmon
#

if i could watch the latest hammer and bolter episodes without paying i would

green loom
#

What game

patent ivy
#

I might. Demo was fun

#

Robocop

green loom
#

Oh nah

#

Looks nice though

dense salmon
#

i should give it a try

storm jungle
#

It has a lot of good reviews

green loom
#

They got the og VA for robocop right?

storm jungle
#

Its jank but fun apparently

crisp heath
patent ivy
#

Interesting

#

Smasher right?

winter vessel
crisp heath
dense salmon
crisp heath
patent ivy
#

Damn

dense salmon
#

cyberpunk 2077 had good writing but i do have one complaint

#

they made adam smasher way too erudite and verbose

#

in tabtletop he is a meathead psycho

patent ivy
#

Only thing stopping me from picking up other games right now is selvedge denim

crisp heath
patent ivy
#

I never played CP tt, but for what the game was worth I enjoyed it

#

Only buddies I had that played tt games did DnD

winter vessel
crisp heath
#

I wish I could play Space marines 1 but I cant get it on the x box store.

patent ivy
#

And we played some weird DnD cuz we used one of their dad's 1E and ADnD books and 5E

winter vessel
patent ivy
patent ivy
arctic talon
#

Cyberpunk 2020 exists as well

#

Except it’s like

patent ivy
#

I think there might be another

arctic talon
#

Way worse

patent ivy
#

Yeah okay so there was another

arctic talon
#

There’s Shadowrun

winter vessel
arctic talon
#

If you want cyberpunk with fantasy races

#

And fantasy stuff

#

But it’s notoriously crunch heavy

arctic talon
#

As in you spend all session rolling for explosion results

patent ivy
#

Gaming is not that fun for me anymore

arctic talon
#

And use a spreadsheet lol

patent ivy
#

Yet I still spend money on new games 😢

crisp heath
#

I do like this game though.

winter vessel
# patent ivy Yes

Man, I wish I had people to play with for "Red". I've never played it, but I'd like to. Just don't have any friends who are well into Cyberpunk outside of 2077

green loom
#

Just ping the Twink psyker guy in the fan art channel, he'll probably happily explain shadowrun

patent ivy
#

Twink Psyker?

#

That his username

green loom
#

No

patent ivy
#

If you got buddies who are into SW

arctic talon
#

Pathfinder 2e

patent ivy
#

All resources are online and free last time I played (4 years ago)

arctic talon
#

My beloved

green loom
#

I'm the least nerdy person here

dense salmon
#

citation needed

patent ivy
#

Curious

crisp heath
#

Then there is captain Laserhawk AKA the series that was created when someone played a bunch of ubisoft games on Acid.

arctic talon
#

Of course I’m nerdy

dense salmon
#

same

#

wait

#

compsci or cyber

arctic talon
#

Except I also lift

dense salmon
#

i'm cyber

arctic talon
#

Comp sci

dense salmon
arctic talon
#

I hate myself

patent ivy
#

Dude I used to geek out to SW lore but I've really pulled back from all that for the past 2 years

dense salmon
#

i was comp sci, switched to cyber after a year

#

got my degree a few months ago

patent ivy
#

Interact with it so little I forgot so much

arctic talon
green loom
#

I'm a linguistics shut in

patent ivy
dense salmon
#

university of maryland

patent ivy
#

I'm a......Business Major

dense salmon
patent ivy
green loom
#

Almost no wargames

#

I've read a grand totalle of 3 hamwarmer books

dense salmon
#

gonna play darktide while watching one of the animated barbie movies with my girlfriend

#

i'm in for a massive mindfuck

patent ivy
#

How long was the Cyber degree?

dense salmon
green loom
#

I watched fkn

patent ivy
#

Gotcha

green loom
#

Eyes wide shut while on a funky substance

#

And clockwork orange

patent ivy
#

Funky substance you say...

green loom
#

and La Haine

patent ivy
#

Top movie?

green loom
#

Weirdly I had sleep paralysis when this happened

green loom
patent ivy
#

That's your #1?

green loom
#

Eyes wide shut confused me, clockwork orange was nice

dense salmon
#

for a movie that will make you feel like you're on drugs without taking them, try La Planete Sauvage

green loom
#

The Ball room scene felt like it lasted an hour

patent ivy
#

Maybe I'll give those movies a try

#

I tried clockwork orange, I turned it off after 30 mins

dense salmon
#

kubrick films are all slow burns

patent ivy
#

Ended up listening to an analysis of it instead the other day

patent ivy
#

Is this server a mostly EU or US based one?

dense salmon
#

fatshark is swedish if that helps

green loom
#

Big enough that I can't discern

patent ivy
#

Hahah

green loom
#

But early EU is typically quiet

patent ivy
#

Man I don't really know what my top film is

green loom
#

So like 4-5 hours from now

patent ivy
#

I'm a sucker for those old comedy films

#

I like the more serious ones too though

#

Life of Brian is top 5 for me

dense salmon
#

i read more than i watch films nowadays

#

i do enjoy film a lot though

#

i recently picked up "No Longer Human"

#

finished blood meridian a few weeks ago

patent ivy
#

Blood Meridian was good

#

Take you a while to read that?

dense salmon
#

to read it? two days. to digest it?

#

weeks

patent ivy
#

Yeah

#

Lot of videos out there that helped with that last part

dense salmon
#

i enjoy a lot of renaissance philosophers

#

my favorite is mirandola

#

orations on the dignity of man

#

i was introduced to it by one of my college professors

#

and it stuck with me

patent ivy
#

Not all to knowledgeable on those guys, so I cannot relate

crisp heath
#

I actually enjoy Grimdark shit I mean look at my PFP

patent ivy
#

I thought that was Batman Beyond for a second

lapis wadi
#

Was anyone questioning that?

crisp heath
patent ivy
#

Ah, Paul from the Beatles!

lapis wadi
#

I thought it was an alright movie

cyan veldt
crisp heath
#

Do the sisters of battle have a traitor legion

green loom
#

Nop

crisp heath
#

Makes sense

stray bluff
#

Who else are 100% non traitor?

green loom
#

They aren't 100% non traitor tbf

winged jacinth
#

The grey knights are generally incorruptible i think

#

Also presumably the sisters of silence

#

Speaking of the sisters why isnt there a like... black ships level program trying to find nulls

crisp heath
#

They aren't incorruptible I believe. The sisters anyway. They just deal with their traitors.

winged jacinth
#

They're pretty darn useful

#

I feel like the grey knights being nulls instead of psykers would have been better tbh

green loom
#

It's just that most blanks fkn die KEKW_ogryn

crisp heath
#

@winged jacinth I think they had to be psychers instead of nulls for them to do what they do. Prolonged exposure to the warp burns out blanks

#

They end up becoming normal

winged jacinth
#

Grey knights are already immune to chaos taint GW can do whatever rule bending for the mary sue chapter

lapis wadi
#

With the sheer amount of anti-chaos stuff they do and have and the Ordo Hereticus Inquisitors with them at every step
There just isn't really a gap in their armor to exploit

#

Give another Chapter that level of support and I doubt you'd get any corrupted members

#

Also their numbers aren't that high, so it's all concentrated on a few astartes

#

Whereas there are so many minor Orders of Sisters

dense salmon
#

i think one cool feature darktide could have had is a "clean weapon" button like killing floor 2

lapis wadi
#

Ogryn spits on it and rubs the melee weapon with his sleeve

echo vault
#

New ogryn throwable a sponge

crisp heath
#

Psycher atomizing it off his blade

#

Basically just his power sword animation lol

lapis wadi
#

Except there's a chance for them to go "(cough) oh.. damn I inhaled that vapor"

#

Veteran wipes it down with a cloth
Zealot just kinda smears it around with their hand

#

BLOOD FOR THE EMPEROR

crisp heath
#

Would fit honestly

#

Slight chance it just insta downs them for no reason lol

patent ivy
#

I just learned an hour ago there's an inspect key

lapis wadi
#

Trying to wipe down a power weapon just has them shock themselves

crisp heath
#

I wonder what it'd be on xbox

#

Chainswords have a chance of accidentally firing lol

lapis wadi
#

Also huh Psyker's the only one without a power weapon. But they have force weapons so it evens out.

crisp heath
#

"Woops there goes a finger"

lapis wadi
#

Ogryn doesn't have access to chain though and that's sad

crisp heath
#

Lol ireally think they should get a full size Boltor and chainfist

lapis wadi
#

Give Ogryn a chainfist!

#

LET ME SLAP THEM WITH THIS

#

Heavy swings are just punches

crisp heath
#

Lol I mean, I really just see them adding that to the guns in game... I forget what their called but the ogryn pistol things

#

They'll just add a chain to the bayonet on them

lapis wadi
#

Ripper guns?

crisp heath
#

I guess lol

#

Probably

lapis wadi
#

They're kinda a 2-hand shotgun but like the closest thing ogryn get to a pistol in the standard wargear lists I think

crisp heath
#

I'm loading the game up to find out lolol

#

I hate when I forget shit

lapis wadi
#

Ogryn really don't get much options in-canon tbh

#

Probably a big reason their in-game list is so lacking

crisp heath
#

Yea the ripper guns

#

They have the bayonet fronts

#

Easily could be outfitted with chain weaponry imo

lapis wadi
#

You get ripper guns.
Sticks to hit things with.
And that's about it.

crisp heath
#

Well I prefer the Blastoom gauntlet

dense salmon
#

ogryn weapons are generally designed to be durable and dangerous in melee because ogryn will tend to just smack enemies with whatever they're holding if they run out of ammo

crisp heath
#

Grenade punches are dope

lapis wadi
#

Like.. there's a sort of autocannon they can use we're missing

#

But I think that's it

#

Anything else will be a Darktide original

crisp heath
#

But like, is there a reason they cant use Space marine weapons? Like I know they aren't quiet as strong but they can't be far behind right? Just in pure strength terms

#

Idk honestly

#

Like a lore reason I guess

lapis wadi
#

Would you give a state of the art gyrojet firing highly expensive hand-crafted weapon
To a toddler

#

Would it change things if the toddler could lift and fire it

crisp heath
#

Like I get that. But could they

#

Can they use them

lapis wadi
#

Nothing physically stopping them

crisp heath
#

Because a blastor breaks a normal humans shoulder in a single shot

dense salmon
#

an ogryn could definitely take a space marine in a fight

#

strength isn't an issue

lapis wadi
#

The ogryn would break it more likely, and canon ogryn do not understand voluntary burst fire and have to have their weapons hard-limited

#

It really, really, really is as simple as Ogryn are too goddamn stupid, and would break/lose the expensive piece of equipment

#

So nobody gives them bolters

dense salmon
#

or misfire it

crisp heath
#

Ahh, so it's more the guns aren't built with ogryn brute in mind, they're more delicate for the SMs

dense salmon
#

ogryn guns doubling as melee weapons is nearly a necessity

#

because they will asbolutely smash it across someone's face

lapis wadi
#

There is literally a keyword "ogryn-proof" in the tabletop wargear lists for the few items Ogryn can use without auto-breaking it

crisp heath
#

Lol that's actually awesome. I'm not the most versed in tabletop so I actually love that lol

lapis wadi
#

Similar reason why nobody gives them power armor

#

Although that's more a training issue I think

dense salmon
#

ogryn are pretty tough nuts without it anyhow

crisp heath
#

I gotcha. I was just curious cause I was like, they definitely have to be strong enough at least right? Lolol

dense salmon
#

i would grab my codex and tell you their hitpoints if i could be bothered

#

but they're tough cookies

lapis wadi
#

Yeah, they're cheap, that's also kinda the point. Why bother giving them the superguns when you can get 5 with still-pretty-good guns for the same price

#

..in-universe price I have no idea what their wargaming pointbuy is

crisp heath
#

Lol, ngl though, with all this said, I still want my space marine weapons to be given to ogryn in game. Would be dope, if not lore inaccurate

dense salmon
#

an ogryn bonehead might be trusted with some more fancy wargear

#

boneheads are augmented to be somewhat intelligent

lapis wadi
#

Oh, we are missing one more wepaon according to the armory
2-handed melee.

#

You can give them a really big hammer

dense salmon
#

as slow-witted as the ogryn in darktide might seem

#

they genuinely have to be boneheads with the shit they say

lapis wadi
#

Darktide Ogryn are actually pretty damn smart

dense salmon
#

your average ogryn can't even tell you what he did that day in the order he did them

lapis wadi
#

Like, kinda geniuses

crisp heath
#

They some smart big boys

dense salmon
#

they are too stupid to understand linear time

lapis wadi
#

Counting to 4 was a real achievement

crisp heath
#

Even the one who's brain is melting lol

dense salmon
#

i think one voice type does mention being a bonehead

#

so there's that

arctic talon
#

Ogryn have 3 wounds iirc

#

So more then marines