#40k-lore-chat

1 messages · Page 264 of 1

soft patio
#

You mean me 2 years ago? Yeah its literally how I jumped into it

#

Got into cheap kill team and started from there

crystal forum
#

you saw the prices for an army and you went with it without prior knowledge?

soft patio
#

Hey back then i had no knowledge of people do what they do now

#

Sure if I look back it would be cheaper to buy a you know what, but I don't regret it

#

It's just a hobby I like so I pay for what I want, new box every month or so has made quite the army

crystal forum
#

fair enough

soft patio
#

I understand what you're getting at though

#

Also if I knew facebook market place was such a banger..

#

Now thats a regret..

crystal forum
#

the current situation is just annoying to me. i didn't know about warhammer back when it was cheap so it feels like im being punished because of whales. Now it's at the point where even if the community started collectively not buying from GW anymore the company would probably file for bankruptcy before making the hobby affordable

soft patio
crystal forum
#

like what happens if the amazon original flops?

soft patio
#

Then we go play fortnite minis

#

lets go poggers

#

I also go back to what I said

silver pollen
crystal forum
#

the IP will be locked in the grave unless some company buys it

#

doubtful because GW will ask for way too much money

silver pollen
#

Well, yes, but it was stagnating for some time so it is natural.

#

Still, my point stands. With such prices as now, I don't see a single reason to buy "official" GW models when I can get whatever I wish from "non-official" sources - with comparable quality but WAY cheaper. Though, I don't play tabletop and have no plans to get into it. Books and occasional videogames are more than enough for me.

storm jungle
#

The stagnation of GW was mostly due to their old CEO and the horrible codex bloat along with the rules.

#

A lot of GW's customer base is also mindless consumers and their success has been massive during and post-covid

#

they aren't going anywhere any time soon

crystal forum
#

their success during covid is so weird to me

#

there's a lot of things about the hobby industry that doesn't make much sense lol

storm jungle
#

I mean no

#

it makes total sense

#

people are trapped at home and got nothing to do so they buy minis to pass the time.

#

its very simple lmao

crystal forum
#

but they can't even play the game

storm jungle
#

So?

#

A lot of 40k players dont even play the game, they just buy minis.

#

thats what matters at the end of the day

frosty stag
#

Hey its the lore mod

#

Hello

storm jungle
frosty stag
#

Ngl i dont think ive ever seen you talk in any other char

crystal forum
#

i can't believe the lore mod thinks ferrus manus is coming back to life

#

this must be official right since they're GW employees

storm jungle
#

like if you try to spend 10 minutes in general-chat you'll know exactly what I mean

storm jungle
#

I still look into other channels as a mod obviously but participating in em yeah no thanks

#

One step in zealot-chat was more than enough

crystal forum
#

this server really is weird huh

storm jungle
#

Nah its just toxic af

frosty stag
#

I just stay to say hi to hank

storm jungle
#

Its either hating Fatshark or hating the game

#

like it was fair to a certain point but just got incredibly old fast

frosty stag
#

And learn lore

crystal forum
#

in lore chat we hate GW.
we are not the same

storm jungle
#

Im just here because I love the lore channel lol

silver pollen
storm jungle
#

"I hate this game fuck fatshark"

#

stays for months

frosty stag
#

I like the game

storm jungle
#

I like the game so im not that iffed by its status

silver pollen
#

To be fair, I don't hate the game. I just like the game what it COULD and SHOULD be.

storm jungle
#

Oh man

#

you wait until the 4th

#

this update is gonna be great

frosty stag
#

For like a week

#

Then back to square 1

crystal forum
#

the only way to start a conversation in this channel is by asking a vague question

storm jungle
#

Nah

silver pollen
storm jungle
#

This entire update is basically the entire half of the game that was missing lol

frosty stag
storm jungle
#

Yes

frosty stag
#

Why would god emp name him that

storm jungle
#

I asked Abnett

crystal forum
storm jungle
#

he said "Because it came to him in a dream."

silver pollen
frosty stag
crystal forum
#

no no

storm jungle
#

this is 40k you gotta narrow the "evil dude" down

crystal forum
#

says something like:
did horus succeed?

frosty stag
#

Oh i get it now

crystal forum
#

and then cacti will respond with "kinda"

silver pollen
crystal forum
#

and then dilara will find a way to say no

storm jungle
#

its not my fault almost every question is dumb

#

"Why doesn't the Imperium make peace with xenos? Are they stupid?"

silver pollen
frosty stag
#

So basically lore chat is just a debate room for Dilara and cacti

storm jungle
storm jungle
#

this is like the most normal chat i can moderate

#

helps when the people that get banned here say shit like

#

"genocide is good"

frosty stag
#

Sounds fun ngl

storm jungle
#

"imperium is not fascist"

#

"imperium is the good guys"

crystal forum
#

ok but that one guy who was talking about the emperor literally being the christian jesus was onto something

storm jungle
#

GOD

#

I was literally about to mention him

#

he the ngoes onto mention how he has "roman blood"

frosty stag
#

Lot better then “dead game” “erm die” from gen chat

crystal forum
#

horus heresy lore creates the wackiest individuals

storm jungle
#

speaking of

#

re-read End and the Death

silver pollen
storm jungle
#

forgot it established the Emperor as Alexander the Great

#

man I hate 40k

frosty stag
#

I want to read the bile books

storm jungle
frosty stag
#

But they cost like 60$ more then i have

storm jungle
#

the Sons of Horus were also incredibly desperate

crystal forum
storm jungle
#

YEP

frosty stag
#

Sons of horus more like abbidon looks ugly af

storm jungle
#

aside from that theres always other ways

frosty stag
#

Basically what you are saying is “as a mod i cant condone theft but steal/pirate”?

storm jungle
#

pretty much

#

its on our rules

#

lmao

frosty stag
#

Lol

storm jungle
#

otherwise id get kicked out so lol

crystal forum
#

im pretty sure that also falls under discord ToS

frosty stag
#

Oh yeah makes sense

crystal forum
#

so account could maybe also be deleted

silver pollen
# storm jungle "imperium is the good guys"

Ok, does the fact of Imperium providing survival of Humanity in general makes it morally good in the grand scheme of things even if Imperium itself is the horrifying abomination of the regime that shouldn't have been existed?

storm jungle
#

It really doesnt

frosty stag
crystal forum
#

discord doesn't joke around. they don't even give warnings most of the time

frosty stag
storm jungle
#

god

frosty stag
#

I hate his name

storm jungle
#

GW writers be like

#

"We cant use that name"

#

"What about-"

#

opens synoym

#

"Violator?"

#

"Briliant"

crystal forum
#

wait is that actually his name

frosty stag
#

LMAO

storm jungle
#

NO LMAO

#

OH MY GOD FUCKING GOD

#

I JUST GOOGLED

frosty stag
#

LMAO

storm jungle
#

Of course

silver pollen
#

Well, makes sense.

crystal forum
frosty stag
#

Oh my god im dying rn

silver pollen
#

Like, perfect sense.

crystal forum
#

so the guardsmen suicide bombers were off the table but not these guys

storm jungle
#

To be fair

#

violate doesnt usually mean just the sexual sense

#

lol

crystal forum
#

it's slaanesh though

silver pollen
#

Yes, but we talk about Slaaneshite marines so...

storm jungle
#

💀

crystal forum
#

if it was khorne maybe

silver pollen
#

or Nurgle

crystal forum
#

actually no that would sound even worse

storm jungle
#

Nurgle writers be like

frosty stag
#

Gw writers are something else

storm jungle
#

"Where can we spam the word Pox as much as possible"

frosty stag
storm jungle
#

😩

crystal forum
#

eloquent in pustule speak

storm jungle
#

theres so many gross words for sickness related stuff in the english language i hate it

crystal forum
storm jungle
#

to be fair shes based

frosty stag
#

Is there?

storm jungle
#

Yep

frosty stag
#

Oh if she’s based then thats ok

crystal forum
storm jungle
#

^

#

Captain Kentucky AKA Sarah Cawkwell

frosty stag
#

Oh wow

storm jungle
#

shes not a big shot but still wrote for BL so

crystal forum
#

anybody who wrote for marvel is pretty big to me

#

except dan

storm jungle
#

LEL

crystal forum
#

i bet he's like 5'6

storm jungle
#

god ngl reading Death and the End was a fucking slog for me

crystal forum
#

it's sad because dan isn't even a bad writer

storm jungle
#

Hes not hes just overrated af

frosty stag
#

No matter how shitty this servers members are I’ll probably never leave it

silver pollen
#

Ok, was fun conversation, good night/evening/day/whatever to everyone here.

frosty stag
#

Im in 3 servers rn

storm jungle
#

Im in 94 mostly for emotes

#

only participate in 3 because they are neat

crystal forum
#

he's just given way too much control over such a massive IP

storm jungle
#

yeah thats my issue like

#

Abnett can basically do whatever he wants

#

its why the term "Abnettverse" exists

frosty stag
crystal forum
#

no single person can have such control over something like 40k. it's just too big

storm jungle
#

Its not that he has control over 40k

#

its more that he can write whatever he wants in a narrative

#

Abnett has never really written anything for the major lore

#

minus 30k which is a prequel so not really the same thing

crystal forum
#

yeah that's what i mean

storm jungle
#

Yeah like

#

we literally rae getting

#

3 PARTS

#

FOR A FUCKING FINALE NOVEL

#

Why?

#

apparently he wrote too much

#

and literally none of his editors do their jobs

#

lmao

crystal forum
#

it's supposed to be a huge event. it should have been a team of writers not just dan

storm jungle
#

Dan started the Heresy with the first novels

#

so its fitting that he gets to end it

#

the issue is its dragging

crystal forum
#

that's the annoying part

#

he started it but douzaine of other writers added to it

#

it's not his story anymore

storm jungle
#

its a mix of a lot of factors because Horus Heresy is such a fucking mess

#

Siege especially

crystal forum
#

i can relate it to star wars

#

george lucas made the first and let other directors make the two sequels

#

then when he was given infinite money to make the prequels it was kind of a mess

#

though he did please fans

storm jungle
#

pretty much

#

Lucas was the only victor

#

he gave them his IP and left laughing

#

now he just opens his palm and money floats down to it

#

Lucas does not earn any royalties from the newer movies or shows as a writer, director, or even creator. However, because of the Disney stock shares he received as part of the transaction, Lucas still sees a hefty payout due to the value of the stocks

#

Oh shit

crystal forum
#

now you have dan not trying to make a good story but trying to please fans of the series

storm jungle
#

Yeah Dan is a weird guy in general

#

because hes been around for a long time

crystal forum
#

i havent read the siege of terra books but i assume they read mostly like fan service

#

so many recurring characters seem to come back

#

whatever. at least i still have soul drinkers

crystal forum
#

there's something i never really understood about knights and titans

#

do they function the same in battle?

#

i don't know what a questoris knight would do differently than a warhound titan

arctic talon
#

Warhounds are faster then every knight varient but the uh cerastus

#

Knights also often time can help protect ground forces from fire with their shields

#

Titans sort of just don’t give a shit about anyone but their accompanying secutarii

crystal forum
#

mmh

arctic talon
#

Its mostly just a scale thing as well

#

The largest knight is almost the same size as the warhound lol

crystal forum
#

yes i went on forge world and saw the size

#

titans are bigger than i remebered

#

the biggest one is 2 feet tall

versed ledge
#

So what's the purpose of an emperor class titan?

#

Mobile head quarters, or just a imperial version of a bigger phallus contest?

storm jungle
#

Its just a biggier and killier titan

versed ledge
#

Fair, though one has to wonder what the heck was it designed to kill?

#

"Nobody would waste that much raw material for something like that" (the Tau)

arctic talon
queen laurel
crystal forum
#

it's so big that it will never have a full size tabletop model

arctic talon
#

funnily enough GW made the war master for titanicus

#

So they wouldn’t have to think about how the fuck they were gona do the imperator in plastic at titanicus scale

crystal forum
arctic talon
#

Yep

#

It isn’t lol

#

But they made it so they could have a bigger then warlord thing

crystal forum
#

ah

#

im sure they're keeping the imperator as a big reveal thing prior to launch

#

everybody's expecting it

arctic talon
#

Prolly

#

Epic is like the time to release the imperator

#

But I’m also not gona touch epic till I can run pure Adeptus titanicus lol

#

Let me use my “minis” GW

#

I want to step on some marine players entire army

crystal forum
#

i sense deep hatred

arctic talon
#

Not hatred

#

I just think it’s stupid GW won’t let me run pure titans

#

I want to see someone’s face when I just bring a chunk of my titanicus list to epic

green loom
#

Oh damn I missed all the fun convos

crystal forum
#

Following the fall of Cinderak City, a mysterious man known simply as The Prophet would lead the refugees on a pilgrimage to Necromunda’s religious capital of Hive Temenos, all while brandishing the bones of a seemingly long forgotten which radiated with an aura of divine power. But just who exactly was this so-called Lost Saint borne by The Pro...

▶ Play video
#

why does 40k theories have access to fredrik

#

seriously weshammer has the balls to critique theory's videos even though he does collabs with people who are three times more famous than him

plush mason
arctic talon
plush mason
#

so yeah

#

nice

arctic talon
#

Not instant kill an entire squad usually

#

But you can do some serious damage lol

plush mason
#

ofc it would OP if they could just one shot things in melee

#

and afailk most titans are mainly for heavy fire support

arctic talon
#

In Adeptus titanicus ironically titans are arguably not the strongest units

#

That award goes to questoris knights bcs they’re spammable

normal light
arctic talon
#

Titanicus is a funny game

#

You can just insta kill questoris tho

#

With some weapons

#

Issue is they’re cheap lol

#

Good thing you aren’t allowed to run just a fuck ton now, because that genuinely was boring

normal light
#

I tried playing against Loyalist Imperial Knight Player on CSM , It wasn`t funny for me staregryn

arctic talon
#

I’m talking about titanicus

#

Not 40K

storm jungle
#

hes a really nice guy, talked with him a few times, he doesn't really think a lot about it

full drift
#

I state once again, Aborderprince and Oculus Imperia are the best warhammer lore channels

green loom
#

I like Ian

storm jungle
#

Everyone has their own quality honestly

#

and yeah Ian is great

green loom
#

Maybe not AR smilecat

storm jungle
green loom
#

I require inspiration for a space marine battle

#

Wanna make a codex cover for my chapter :3

normal light
#

it`s general idea

#

which can be used to make up a scene

green loom
#

Interesting way of phrasing it

normal light
#

for cover

normal light
crystal forum
#

but i don't know what your chapter is best at

crystal forum
#

any day now....

crystal forum
#

trust

#

he's 100% coming back

echo vault
#

Give him a robot skull head if he's coming back no substitutions

#

Primarch of the iron hands and leader of the legion of the damned? The skull on the center of his armor being a flame wreathed skull with a mix of metal cogs and metal bone his backpack of servo arms and weapons belching flame and repairing other legionnaires, with a weapon that can banish demons (divining blade in lore but that's for Marines, give him something bigger)

#

I don't think he'd look good with a giant sword but that is what he made for fulgrim so maybe I'm wrong

frosty stag
#

How many primarch are dead

echo vault
#

2, counting traitors 4

#

Ferrus Curze sanguinius horus

shadow plover
#

Vulcan kinda

echo vault
#

Vulkan doesn't count he comes back

shadow plover
#

ye but currently anyways

#

as far as we know

echo vault
#

Because otherwise I'd be saying Vulkan 50 times

echo vault
#

What would be the stupidest torture for Konrad to do to vulkan when he captured him

frosty stag
#

Lol

echo vault
#

Like he ran out of ideas

frosty stag
#

Isn’t vulkan gone rn cuz he thinks his sons are pussies or something

#

They are on a quest to find the 40000 warhammers that he left for them

echo vault
frosty stag
#

Aint the number not actually known

#

Cuz Gw hates letting us know important details

crystal forum
echo vault
frosty stag
#

Oh

crystal forum
#

and GW still brought horus back as a clone just to kill him again

frosty stag
#

Lmao

crystal forum
#

ferrus manus got his head chopped off. Dorn lost a entire hand

#

leman and khan both fucked off to forbidden zones

frosty stag
#

Didn’t the blood angels guy die

crystal forum
#

oh right sanguinius

#

yeah he dead

#

and probably won't come back since GW loves blood angels and their entire gimmick is dead primarch

frosty stag
#

Yeah didn’t that fuck up all his sons

crystal forum
#

yup

frosty stag
#

Love that

crystal forum
#

they can sometimes go insane and think they're sanguinius right before dying

frosty stag
#

Yeah the blood rage

#

Or smth like that

crystal forum
#

dante is basically a primarch now anyways

arctic talon
#

Dante has been with the blood angels longer then sanguinius has lol

green loom
#

In Dante's lifetime the BA have been nearly wiped out 3 times

frosty stag
#

Damn thats crazy

tawdry escarp
#

Corax is also in the Warp, hunting Lorgar

arctic talon
#

Eye of terror

frosty stag
#

Hi lore whores

arctic talon
#

And he hasn’t been seen since the scouring

frosty stag
#

Thats rude

#

Hi people

spare osprey
#

Like my mindset in the whole thing

#

Leave dead primarchs dead

#

Konrad, sangy, alpharius, Ferrus, Horus. All of the real them’s should stay dead

arctic talon
#

It’s just a representation of the Emperors anger

#

Regarding the fire

echo vault
#

I do prefer him not being legion of the damned tho its just kinda forced

#

and also not him but that as well

tough haven
#

Any good Ork war bosses to read about? Either in books or wiki

green loom
#

Ghaz

tough haven
#

Well yeah

#

I still gotta buy his books

#

I meant beyond the obvious ones

echo vault
#

an inspiration to me

tough haven
#

/read it if I can for free

#

If it’s like publicly available but I doubt it

echo vault
echo vault
#

It also has physical copies that I am searching for

tough haven
echo vault
#

Every page probably took like 2 days to draw it's SO FUCKING DETAILED EVERYWHERE

echo vault
#

yw

echo vault
#

Do you think a stormcast would get into one of those slapping contest events with an ogor and accidently slap the ogor's head off?

#

ogre, ogor, both good

frosty stag
#

In a fists only match whos winning

#

Blueberry or storm cast

#

Both unnamed

echo vault
frosty stag
#

Yeah lol

echo vault
#

Tough to say because both have specifics that can make them more powerful like divine boons or the space marines armor

#

Plus a technology difference, that makes it hard

frosty stag
#

Both naked and oiled

echo vault
#

That's incredibly tough, I legit don't know they're both equal in my eyes, like they're both augmented humans to turn into killing machines and powerful as hell

#

Just one is through surgery and the other is sigmar forging them

#

Coolness factor its stormcast ez

#

That's why custodes are cool its (Almost) like the emperor forges them himself

tawdry escarp
#

Stormcast do have the advantage of magic backing them

echo vault
#

Yeah the magic is a point but the augmentations are the space marines equivalent of magic, they're just balanced

#

Both can be super powerful or even not that powerful in comparison to similar things

tawdry escarp
#

Can Stormcast spit acid?

echo vault
#

No but I bet a stormcasts fists can be cast in holy fire

tawdry escarp
#

Fair

echo vault
#

So a shoriyuken is possible

tawdry escarp
#

Better hope it's not a Black Templar they're trying to wrastle

echo vault
#

Plus there doesn't seem to be any difference in gender so both male and female stormcast are the same power

#

BUT here's the real fight

#

Trajaan Valoris VS Celestant Prime

#

Celestant Prime clears ez I may have made it too powerful

#

So the more accurate fight may be Trajaan vs Bastion Carthalos

tawdry escarp
#

Sanguinius vs Celestant Prime

echo vault
#

Celestant Prime has Gal Maraz tho

#

It's all so balanced, although sigmar (AOS) vs emperor would be a big hoss battle

#

Each punch shattering the arena they're in

tawdry escarp
#

Sangui has two legendary artifact weapons

echo vault
#

Gal Maraz is THE legendary artifact, the defining item of Stormcast, sigmar, and in many ways humanity in AoS and fantasy

#

That's the only thing, its like emps sword kinda but more

crystal forum
#

i think emperor wins just by the amount of power we see him wield

echo vault
#

Again I say equal because what a god can do varies in ability, sigmar or the emperor can do some insane shit because sigmar in many ways created the mortal realms with other equivalents, same with the emperor

crystal forum
#

emperor can do galactic level of psychic stuff. even if sigmar could do that too we still don't have proof

echo vault
#

He is like the sole creator of the realm of azyr, knocked out a minor god Behemat with one swing of gal maraz

#

I know its incomparable but its interesting

arctic talon
#

Also sigmar and the gods in generally regularly intervene in battle in AoS

#

They usually just throw some magic at it

#

Or in khornes case he just sticks a sword out a portal and smashes something to powder

echo vault
#

I just want the two to have a brawl like a fight in baki

spare osprey
echo vault
storm jungle
#

who dont care about civillian casulties and are also extremely brutal

#

also people forget the way Stormcast wage war with almost 80% blunt weapons is pretty bad.

crisp heath
#

Imperium ain't so bad. Sure you're essentially living as an insect, but it's better than being eaten by an insect.

#

If only Horus didn't ruin everything

storm jungle
#

Caesar's Legion PFP

#

Imperium Apologism

crisp heath
#

I prefer Great Crusade apologism as a moniker

#

and cosplaying the bad guys is fun

#

they tend to have more feathers

#

Except in WH fantasy for some reason

storm jungle
#

The Great Crusade was also bad

crisp heath
#

no ur bad

storm jungle
#

a galactic jihad that killed countless human civilizations

#

why because uh

#

"xenos cooties"

#

or

#

"you resisted"

crisp heath
#

What if humanity was disunited when the Tyranids came a-knockin?

storm jungle
#

30k has shown countless times that advanced civilizations of humans existed.

forest orbit
#

And the Emperor wiped out all of them lol

#

30k Imperium is bad.

crisp heath
#

The Imperium is advanced, just simultaneously backwards.

#

How do you define advanced

forest orbit
#

Yet the people still live in oppression and slavery

#

knock that fascist apologist shit outta here

#

You wouldnt be saying this shit if you were a manufactorum slave

#

lmao

crisp heath
#

I... haven't said anything fascist lol

#

Chill homie

echo vault
#

you posted cringe

forest orbit
#

^

echo vault
#

prepare ion cannon

forest orbit
#

Defending what is basically nazi-romans also kinda is the same thing

crisp heath
#

what are you even talking about now

#

what nazi romans

forest orbit
#

The... Imperium

#

who else lol

crisp heath
#

The Imperium are Romans? How?

#

The use of Latin?

forest orbit
#

bruh

#

Do I like

#

gotta post almost the entire 30k artwork range

echo vault
forest orbit
#

KEK

echo vault
#

plumes

crisp heath
# forest orbit Do I like

yeah and death korp of krieg means they're all ww1 infantry. Mordian Iron Guard means they're all 1890s French

#

They make cool designs for toys.

forest orbit
#

and those are niche historical references

#

lol

crisp heath
#

Rome wasn't fascist?

forest orbit
#

the larger part of Space Marine legions in 30k were entirely roman

echo vault
# storm jungle >Caesar's Legion PFP

I've only done Caesars legion playthroughs in new vegas because I have my imaginary courier takes over legion and becomes good idea in my head, but a friend a while ago brain blasted me in the head with knowledge about the true nature and culture of the CL being unchangable despite my best hopes

forest orbit
#

we are talking about the Imperium here lol

echo vault
storm jungle
crisp heath
#

You're saying plumes make it fascist?

storm jungle
#

"Enslaving women is based"

storm jungle
echo vault
storm jungle
#

you kinda asked for this kind of scrutiny the moment you defend anything the Imperium does lol

storm jungle
#

Its like being based on a society like rome is a bad thing

echo vault
#

I will larp about my non slavery legion in my corner

crisp heath
#

Neither the Imperium or CL are based on Rome in anything beyond aesthetics, one way more than the other.

forest orbit
#

Kinda is more or less

forest orbit
#

That and GW are not masive history buffs beyond appearances

crisp heath
#

The Imperium functions off whatever looks cool and is a hodgepodge from historical inferences depending on the writer

forest orbit
#

Doesnt matter

#

its still fascist lol

#

I guess the literal death camps and genetic purity propaganda is not as well known in the lore lol

crisp heath
#

genetic purity in what sense? Against mutation? I'm unfamiliar with anything else in the lore

#

I'd imagine cancer is pretty prevalent

crisp heath
#

I'm by no means a 40k expert

echo vault
#

The flexibility of genetic purity can be like

#

anything

#

DUMPASS

forest orbit
crisp heath
#

Do you go into every conversation with this level of hostility lol

echo vault
forest orbit
#

^

crisp heath
#

socially inhibited

forest orbit
#

shut up lol

echo vault
#

This is like special event 15

storm jungle
#

Alright kids thats enough

desert dust
#

Don't you know 30k horus is actually the good guy

storm jungle
#

I know I kinda started it but lets not go super off the rails now

desert dust
#

Now let me rant for 45 minutes of straight mental gymnastics to come out|| wrong||

echo vault
crisp heath
#

I've never heard the take that the Emperor himself is bad

#

Just how he was misconstrued post-heresy

forest orbit
#

Okay so ill be less hostile but

#

Its literally the point that hes a horrible person.

#

books like the Last Church actively point this out

#

"Why are you conquering the galaxy"

#

"Because I know im right"

#

spoken like every tyrant

crisp heath
#

I mean would you consider Napoleon or Alexander bad people?

#

Conquest isn't inherently immoral

forest orbit
#

Yes?

#

It is?

crisp heath
#

Napoleon liberated tens of millions of people from serfdom lol

forest orbit
#

Do innocent people ask to be conquered and have their lands ravaged by foreign soldiers?

#

lol

crisp heath
#

Violence as a means to liberation isn't bad and people != their government.

forest orbit
#

...

crisp heath
#

Unless you'd prefer us to be all living as some illiterate serfs so an incredibly inbred Austrian man can demand we worship him, you owe Napoleon quite a bit.

forest orbit
#

Thats you assuming germany was ever gonna win WW2

#

we dont owe Nappy anything lol

crisp heath
#

Habsburg

#

Not Hitler

#

Not all Austrians are hitler

forest orbit
#

Ok history teacher

crisp heath
#

You're seemingly more unaware of history than I am of 40k lore

forest orbit
#

Because not everyone is interested in reading european history

crisp heath
#

Napoleon was a liberal dictator who freed half of Europe from serfdom

#

Establishing modern law

storm jungle
native charm
#

In a galaxy filled with other species that thrive preying on humanity, minus the Tau/Aeldar, the Emperor is alright killing everything with too many tentacles and teeth

forest orbit
storm jungle
#

GW themselves have said the Imperum is bad.

crisp heath
#

I'm not saying the Imperium is good.

native charm
forest orbit
storm jungle
forest orbit
#

In Dawn of War of course not IRL

plush mason
#

what i miss?

stoic quest
#

Morals are widely defined by the dominant religion(s) and culture(s) of the setting/time we are looking at.

storm jungle
#

nothing to argue over when the subject is clear, don't drag it back up.

stoic quest
storm jungle
stoic quest
#

For example in Rome it was considered pretty progressive that you could be jailed for selling one too many of your own children into slavery. During the time they considered that a moral judgment. Though of course now we'd find it deplorable to sell any of your children into slavery

storm jungle
#

Not the chat for it

#

so kindly cease lol

plush mason
#

that is irrelevent to 40k as GW who are the ultimate arbitors of the lore and its mortality have already condemed the imperium as one of the worst factions in the setting so any convo arguing other wise is moot

storm jungle
#

^

#

Not much more to say beyond that honestly.

stoic quest
crisp heath
#

Sir this a server where we talk about a video game based on plastic army men, and then we argue about the stories some old british guys made up about our plastic army men/video game dudes. Nothing here is an important subject

plush mason
plush mason
#

nah

forest orbit
#

He really isnt

plush mason
#

your point is just moot

forest orbit
#

that lol

stoic quest
forest orbit
#

When its evil, plain and simple.

plush mason
#

the people that literally own the IP have said the imperium is one of the worst factions. thats that

forest orbit
#

That too lol

stoic quest
crisp heath
forest orbit
#

Doesnt matter

#

the Imperium is evil

stoic quest
#

My point being that it's a more fascinating discussion if you put yourself in the shoes of an imperial citizen.

forest orbit
#

The entire point chaos thrives is because the the Imperium makes its own citizens suffer

#

this is like lore 101

plush mason
forest orbit
#

you are cheap slave labor

#

there isnt a morality question

crisp heath
stoic quest
plush mason
forest orbit
stoic quest
forest orbit
#

what are you even arguing about

crisp heath
stoic quest
forest orbit
#

give me an example then

stoic quest
#

Paradise worlds?

#

A majority of worlds in the imperium are comprable to modern day earth

forest orbit
#

Oh?

#

you mean the worlds uh

#

where nobles are hedonistic pricks?

#

and any low class/lowborn suffers?

stoic quest
#

It's just that a large population of the imperium live in hives

forest orbit
#

and its rife with slaanesh cultists?

forest orbit
stoic quest
#

I thought we were discussing standard of living and not inequity?

forest orbit
#

...

#

💀

#

Being given basic human rights is not standard living?

crisp heath
#

Every world is shit for the poor.

plush mason
#

i feel like this is just a dead horse by this point Everard

forest orbit
#

Yeah fair honestly

crisp heath
#

Standard of living is material

storm jungle
# crisp heath I remember that, they never said it was near the worst.

To be a man in such times is to be one amongst untold billions. It is to live in the cruelest and most bloody regime imaginable. These are the tales of those times. Forget the power of technology and science, for so much has been forgotten, never to be relearned. Forget the promise of progress and understanding, for in the grim dark future there is only war. There is no peace amongst the stars, only an eternity of carnage and slaughter, and the laughter of thirsting gods

#

This is at the opening

#

of

#

every

#

single

#

40k book

crisp heath
storm jungle
#

what servitors are

#

or arco-flagellants

#

Or being a daemonhost?

stoic quest
crisp heath
storm jungle
#

The Imperium is bad.

storm jungle
#

Now genuinely stop this argument.

plush mason
storm jungle
#

You two genuinely need to read a 40k book or two.

storm jungle
stoic quest
#

I have

#

Multiple

storm jungle
#

Im guessing you kinda missed most of their point then

stoic quest
#

To tell a good story?

storm jungle
#

And to show the Imperium is hilariously awful

stoic quest
#

Every, and I mean every faction in 40k is hilariously awful

plush mason
#

ngl i cant see the nids as "evil" hell they dont have any form of morality

forest orbit
crisp heath
#

Tyranids are just giant space puppies in a galaxy of talking beggin' strips

forest orbit
#

mfer now is gonna be like

"Actually, being a servitor is morally correct"

stoic quest
forest orbit
stoic quest
#

What have you been doing?

crisp heath
#

"Stop this argument, unless you agree with me then feel free to pile on"

forest orbit
#

Nothing.

plush mason
#

the galaxy is just one big all you can eat foodcourt to the hivemind and imo that makes it the only faction with 0 moral anything

forest orbit
#

Was wondering when that was gonna happen

#

fucking hell my head

#

Read the goddamn lore next time you two KEKW_ogryn

plush mason
#

and is part of why i love them the most lol. none of the BS from the other factions. just pure raw and simple hunger and survival driving them on

crisp heath
#

Honestly I'm a tyranid simp but like

#

I do understand they are evil

forest orbit
#

I literally do not understand people like this, like holy fuck

crisp heath
#

They can comprehend morality just fine. The hivemind is probably the most intelligent thing in the galaxy, and it's shown repeatedly that it fully comprehends things like "society" and "morality". it simply doesn't care and only uses those concepts as weapons against their prey.

forest orbit
#

I'd understand if you wanna like argue morality with that yeah

#

but human beings that operate the Imperium tho lmao

#

"Yeah paradise worlds are so good"

#

have you ever worked on a yacht before

#

I hope you like getting abused by rich people for laughs

plush mason
crisp heath
#

Honestly Nemeton isn't really a "bad" place to live. It's basically stuck in the bronze age, but most of the terrible fascist stuff seems to gloss over it. The only real terrible thing the Imperium does to them is their local Chapter takes recruits by kidnapping, but their novel makes it clear that the chapter actually operates below full strength because they don't like to do that anyway. I'd give it a solid 6.5/10, I'd tolerate it.

tawdry escarp
#

There's no one who plays an Imperial faction that gives a shit about what the government is

plush mason
#

"every virtue is a vice and every strength is a weakness"

crisp heath
#

Narratively, I like "yeah the Imperium? absolute worst thing that ever happened to humanity. Super evil. Anyway, here's an Imperial named Cute Dan who makes dolls for orphaned children and runs a food bank".

tawdry escarp
#

Exactly

crisp heath
#

(Cute Dan eventually ends up in a Homunculi lab)

spare osprey
forest orbit
#

💀

#

too soon

plush mason
#

yeah most books just use the imperium as a dark backdrop for the story said book is telling

tawdry escarp
#

We care about the common people and the heroes that defend them

forest orbit
#

yeah the "heroes"

#

anyway so about that firing squad-

tawdry escarp
#

There are heroes in the Imperium

crisp heath
#

Why don't they just take the chunks of Caliban and the chunks of Cadia and make Caladia where everyone is an ultra-badass Daemon slayer

forest orbit
#

Uhhhh

#

thats kinda what Vashtorr did

#

only for Caliban tho

spare osprey
#

good ol

#

Wyrmwood

crisp heath
#

I do like Wyrmwood a lot

forest orbit
#

My favorite darktide character

#

if anyone remembers she even exists

plush mason
#

lol

spare osprey
#

barely

crisp heath
#

Vashtorr did a good job, he deserves a planet

spare osprey
#

man i gotta get arks of omen Lion

plush mason
tawdry escarp
#

Wasn't there something about Wyrmwood being the collective callsign for Grendel's intelligence operatives?

spare osprey
plush mason
crisp heath
#

I'm pretty sure Wyrmwood isn't a single person

plush mason
#

also if it was a collective callsign it would have a number to id the sepcific agent

forest orbit
#

Yeah also im pretty sure Wyrmwood is an IRL thing

#

i think its a mythological one? Google time

forest orbit
#

yeah nvm just "made up IRL cool name"

crisp heath
forest orbit
#

no

#

Wyrm and Worm are totally different, trust me

crisp heath
#

Wormwood is also a plant, most famous as an ingredient in absinthe

plush mason
forest orbit
#

😩

plush mason
crisp heath
#

Anyway yeah since "wyrmwood agents" are a thing it's probably a collective callsign

tawdry escarp
#

Wyrm is a discount dragon

forest orbit
crisp heath
#

Dude you do not want to get into a nordic folklore argument with me

#

So essentially wyrm and worm are obviously cognate words, meaning they have a common origin and are essentially the "same word" for most purposes

plush mason
#

who coined "wyrm" anyway?

#

wasnt it Tolkien?

forest orbit
#

Im pretty sure wyrm was a pre-existing term

crisp heath
#

Both originally referred to any animal which crawled on the ground, especially venomous animals, which of course means mostly snakes

spare osprey
plush mason
crisp heath
#

So later on "worm" came to refer to the invertebrate because they looked like snakes

plush mason
#

the y spelling came later

tawdry escarp
#

Ye olde English

crisp heath
#

while in nordic countries it became more strongly associated with dragons (although there are English "worm" dragons, like the Laidly Worm), which are typically seen as a folkloric reflection of snakes

plush mason
#

seems "wyrm" did come from old norse old high german and old saxon

tawdry escarp
#

You might want to pull back on the history talk before Dilly notices

crisp heath
#

Dragon comes from OE draca which just refers to sea monsters, so there's basically a sea serpent-dragon spectrum which we see really strongly in the germanic folk tradition (dragons are generally portrayed as water-monsters or spirits)

#

So yeah essentially wyrmwood is just edgy wormwood, and it's probably referring to the star from Revelations

storm jungle
#

or you know "conquering is a morally good thing"

tawdry escarp
#

I know, just making a joke

storm jungle
#

I dont care

#

face the wall

plush mason
spare osprey
storm jungle
tawdry escarp
#

The etymology of the word wyrm is neat

storm jungle
#

here you go lol

crisp heath
#

Deer is a really fun etymology, trust me

tawdry escarp
#

Somebody gave that Ogryn a second gun. God help us

crisp heath
#

The fact that we call them deer is a huge insult to an Englishman's intelligence

plush mason
#

the chaos fleet is just so much stronger than the imperial one lol

#

their ships are fast and have longer range more accurate guns

storm jungle
#

I THINK I picked the Fallen one

#

because Dark Angels suck di-

plush mason
#

i cant remember lol

spare osprey
#

Osmadiel is the bastard who got me into fallen

#

love him so much

storm jungle
#

Let me get the cutscene

#

time to skim a 5 hour video

plush mason
#

lol

storm jungle
#

Oh shoot found a specific one

spare osprey
#

yup

#

seriously tho, osmadiel is easily my fav fallen in 40k

#

and i hope they bring him back

#

also speakin of fallen

#

homebrew of course

#

got a wip from a dude i comm'd for art of my ravenwing leader in my fallen group. him and his fuckin robo legs

#

now i must plan his important lore

#

like how he shits

#

gotta pray twice every time

storm jungle
#

be me

#

play BFG2

#

literally have no idea who these people are

#

pick the Fallen because I hate Dark Angels and Osmiehomie sounds like a homie

plush mason
#

only campaign i ever finished as the nid one lol

spare osprey
#

"rational" for a space marine

plush mason
#

also those 2 games are why i do not trust focus home with the 40k IP lol

#

they have a bad habit of dropping games like a year or 2 in lol

storm jungle
#

Yeah BFG2 was a bit troubled

#

we were gonna get a 3rd game tho

crisp heath
#

On one hand, Arthurian stuff is cool. On the other hand, Dork Angels

plush mason
storm jungle
#

Dark Angle

plush mason
#

rationality and common sense is a sin in the imperial creed lol

storm jungle
#

also that too

spare osprey
plush mason
#

all the best SMs are heretics

spare osprey
#

plus some of the first space marines made (dark angels) were named after old terran kings and figures in myth

plush mason
#

hell thats honestly true for most imperial characters

crisp heath
#

I'm very torn between Dark Angels and Emperor's Spears because they fill like, the same niche more or less, but DA are more Celtic fantasy and ES are more historical Celts

#

I really like the druid stuff with the spears though

spare osprey
plush mason
#

all i can think of when i think of dark angels is, white bath robes lol

spare osprey
#

i got him somewhere

plush mason
#

mainly because i literally had a hooded white bath robe once that looked almost exactly why the dark angel robes lol

crisp heath
#

I like the angel naming scheme tbh

spare osprey
#

Uncrowned Prince Týr, fallen angel and child of Nordyc

spare osprey
crisp heath
#

Angels and Arthurian fantasy are just a really good combo and it works for the chapter

spare osprey
#

there's a few other inspirations in the chapter

#

Native Americans are a notable one

crisp heath
#

The gay, indigenous angels of Arthur's table

spare osprey
crisp heath
#

Almost sounds like a cut scene from Monty Python's Holy Grail

storm jungle
#

I think the Rock gaybar thing was always said to be a rumor that got debunked.

spare osprey
spare osprey
storm jungle
#

Oh yeah no Lionel Johnson thing is entirely on point

crisp heath
storm jungle
#

Yeeee

storm jungle
#

the gay allegories entirely come from the book and the author

storm jungle
spare osprey
crisp heath
#

The secret is they're boykissers, uh, I mean, half of them are traitors, uh

spare osprey
# plush mason ?

the primarch Lion el jonson is named after an author who wrote a poem about his "dark secret", his homosexuality

plush mason
#

oh

storm jungle
#

Yeah this was back in the day when it was basically a death sentence too.

plush mason
#

fitting

storm jungle
#

A lot of like

#

homosexual guys back then had no idea what being gay was

#

just that they had these unexplained urges

spare osprey
# plush mason oh

what drives it even farther home however, the poem is titled The Dark Angel

storm jungle
#

^

#

Its one of the MOST obvious historical lifts for a Primarch character

plush mason
#

most people dont know this but. many knights where gay as hell by modern standers lol. so its very fitting

viral halo
#

Are you telling me the lion fucks dudes? BASED

storm jungle
#

the dark secret thing was obviously the Fallen but this was back in the day when "gay haha" was the top humoruous thing

#

now that we are in a bit of a more progressive age its more just a silly side joke for most people lol

crisp heath
#

The lion has been passed out on a trash pile behind a gay bar for the last 10,000 years and you're wondering why he looks a little more ragged than Guilliman?

storm jungle
#

something-something silver fox

spare osprey
#

lion would prob bang a dude, just never cared to get with anyone.

#

hopin farsight changes that

storm jungle
storm jungle
#

Also @plush mason very recommended watch

spare osprey
#

big fan of this one

storm jungle
#

Killinger was the artist for Wrath and Glory too iirc

viral halo
#

Old man lion looks great

crisp heath
#

I like his younger design a lot more, just not wild about distinguished older gentlemen

#

But he doesn't look bad by any means at all

viral halo
#

hes just tywin

plush mason
spare osprey
#

straight up tywin

crisp heath
#

I am nervous about what they'll do to Russ. I really do hate the "Odin" theory, since Magnus already has that covered and did it in a much more interesting way than Leman would.

storm jungle
#

I'd say dont expect too much radical changes

#

I legit doubt they are brave enough to go full half-wulfen Russ or w/e

spare osprey
crisp heath
#

I wouldn't mind werewolf Russ, but I don't like the way Wulfen look

storm jungle
#

dont make me post the Wulfen Dreadnaught

spare osprey
storm jungle
#

Oh man

#

I got the entire lineup of those drawings

#

hold on

crisp heath
#

The one and only primarch I need to see mutated the fuck out is Corax

#

a humanoid raven monstrosity would be such a sick model

storm jungle
#

Extremely sane gentlemen

spare osprey
#

good book

crisp heath
#

I mean just look at this fanmade mini

#

We need the bird boy

#

I have such high hopes for Corax and I look forward to having them dashed uwu

plush mason
storm jungle
#

Primarch names really can go anywhere from "We came up with this in a bar" to "deep historical reference"

plush mason
#

Logos being logic and deductive reasoning where as Lorgar was just a man of pure blind idiot faith

crisp heath
#

Plato moment

#

Honestly though Lorgar being Logos would make sense if it were the case

#

It's standard practice to translate Logos in the new testament as "The Word"

#

Ergo, Word Bearers

plush mason
#

that makes a lot more sense yeah

#

because the other use for the word is something completely different to the biblical one lol

crystal forum
#

i like to believe that if lion shaved his hair it would regrow with colour again

#

people keep saying he looks older but all i see is white hair

#

and even if he did get extra wrinkles how would that makes sense? He slept through the millenia without using his facial muscles

native charm
#

I thought the collapse of the Aeldari happened long before the 30th millenium. Didn't know it happened two thousand years before the Horus Heresy.

green loom
#

Aw man it happened again nogryn

#

Stop having fun arguments when I sleep schmarf

normal light
#

They will continue

#

To have them

#

While you sleep

silver pollen
storm jungle
#

Humanity beat them to the punch by only a 7 year speedrun

queen laurel
#

i like this tech priest, spoiler because it's from brutal Kunnin

||< Interrogative: what is that? > Zaefa asked in astonishment.
< It is a miniaturised lascannon, > Addenbrow replied, as a targeting
device dropped over their right ocular implant. < It lacks a little of the
punch and range of the Mars Mk VII, but I find it quite adequate for most
circumstances. >
< It was my understanding that you were unaware of the orkoid presence
here, > Mitranda said.
< I was. >
< And yet you are equipped with the very item you declared most suitable
for the current threat? >
< In my experience, there are very few hostile threats that can’t be at least
partially resolved by the judicious application of a lascannon, > ||

green loom
#

hmmmm

#

The guy has progress shots, looks like the teaser Syama put out for A2 was a big collab?

storm jungle
#

Wait...

#

hm let me check youtube

#

yeah nah literally exactly the same scene

#

nothing even extended

green loom
#

But it's weird idk

#

Don't trust checkmarks by default

#

Apparently he did the Gaunts?

storm jungle
# silver pollen ?

Dooming the entire human race into extinction and providng the chaos gods with their greatest champions and being their greatest followers

#

lol

#

Its you know, kinda due to them that the entire galaxy is fucked and split in half right now.

storm jungle
green loom
#

Like he has super early stuff there

#

And looks like he mainly does monstrous stuff

#

Between this and Syama making a post on his patreon recently about him being alive, I am moderately sus squint

storm jungle
#

Hes also working on a personal project that he announced like a year ago iirc

#

its all very sus

green loom
#

Codex is out soon as well squint

silver pollen
green loom
#

The heresy is what was so short

storm jungle
#

^

storm jungle
#

lol

#

also yeah the Great Crusade took long, I'm referencing the Horus Heresy KEKW_ogryn

queen laurel
storm jungle
#

Or just a smart person

queen laurel
#

it's not exactly the smallest of margins

storm jungle
#

or a well written character

queen laurel
storm jungle
#

OOF

#

gonna note that one down

pine wedge
terse flume
#

it's not exactly like a mad max warband, the emperor had been watching and manipulating the direction of humanity for thousands of years by that point