#40k-lore-chat
1 messages · Page 132 of 1
He has extra custodes lol
All the things he chucked out on Cadia where from his long term storage
Of course he does it’s trazyn
Fair
And even if he only had one he could always go and get some more
I mean, wolfer got a custom helmet, he must reappear
You'd hope.
He did ?
I think that if we get named (Not random named knew it will either be for events or some type of radio antagonist
Doesn't he have a skullmask helmet in the intro cutscene?
Yes he does, skullmask with metal mohawk
Yeah, classic renegade enforcer helm
(Though I'll be using a gellerpox infected helm, more or less the same..)
What do you think is the difference between stub guns and autoguns? At least what you imagine it is at least
Personally I imagine it as the difference between a service rifle and a checkpoint rifle. A stubber focuses on bore size and typically is cased. A autogun focuses on velocity and/or fire rate, and is typically caseless.
Here’s kinda what I can describe it as is this.
The left is a .450 bushmaster
The right is a .223 Remington
This doesn’t mean a autogun can’t use big rounds, it’s just stubbers tend to be using large rounds
This could technically be a stub rifle.
But so could this
caliber
Thank u
I usually assume stubber as lower quality like ork weapons or stuff lower than what the dregs use
nah like stubbers aren't THAT shit
gangs aren't stupid
at worst they're like IRL improvised firearms
Technologically stubbers are comparable to 1860-1980’s era firearms
Citation
It just tends towards pre 1950’s tech
rebuttal macrostubber and stub carbine
both of which are used by the admech
also the Galvanic rifle is a "stub" weapon
Mechanicus is bullshit and we both know it
Still doesn't explain why we can't carry a stubber as a secondary or tertiary weapon. Ammo is damn scarce
It’s more a gameplay thing then a lore thing.
I kind of wish we could have a sidearm slot for a third weapon.
Might be tough to balance though.
Switching to a sidearm kinda makes forcing melee combat harder… unless if that sidearm was a 40mm grenade launcher
What was that saying?
There’s nothing stronger than love
Except an m32 rotary grenade launcher
Macrostubber has some kind of powered part (the blue glowing one) so it's more likely something like a high rof railgun.
Stab carbine is essencially wielding a p90 sized A-10 avenger cannon.
Eh, just make some pistol/melee dual wield weapon
Keep the current 1 hand weapon as is but give us additional weapon too (Though not against a rework on some of them):
(Melee) Sword and Pistol, Sword and Laspistol
(Ranged) Pistol and Power Fist; Bolt Pistol and Power Fist
But change the Revolver's special attack or give us a few other pattern:
Quickdraw: Stay as is
Heavy: Special attack take out a round and load in a Dum Dum Round, if an empty chamber is available load the round in it (Faster), work like a heavy plated round
Twin: 2 Revolver, shoot in alternating pattern, take longer to reload and ADS become braced, special attack to shoot both at the same time
Plus the Revolver and Power fist
There are female traitor captains? Haven't played since December
@orchid thicket not in the game, but voice recorded.
Oh I see
And in the Datamine too
Not sure if all the Scab Captain personalities are already in use (Some might be kept for the Dreg lord)
Actually none, they are just different terms that GW used making everything a mess, i often discussed this, just search for my post and the word autogun or stub, you will find many post where i describe them and why they are the same but just with different name
Totally differ from world to world and writer to writer
So the only difference is in story rather than in broad 40k
To note that there is a Stub-rifle in the datamine too
eh, i just use the "auto is caseless, stubs are cased" division and im good personally, as i always say having 10 thousand pattern makes any discussion moot when one variant could very well be a death laser powered by bullets.
also most not heavy/mechanicum stubs are semi automatic only
stub automatic is not full auto, it just has an higher rate of fire, "rapid semi-automatic mode" is called in both dark heresy and rogue trader books.
If you look at its description it mention either semi.automatic or single shot, it doesn't take a genius to understand that the semi-auto mode is intended as either burst or full auto... The fact GW didn't knew, and still doesn't, jackshit about gun operation doesn't change the fact that they state it has two fire mode, one that is single shot (which would be actually semi-auto) and another one (which is clearly either burst or full auto)
While autopistols are smg
tbf the stub automatic image doesn't even have a good place for a magazine
It is just GW going with what they thought sounded cool, but for how they portray them there are no doubts, both stub guns and auto weapons are the same, just with different name
Nearly all weapons images don't have good places for the magazine
Especially if you consider the caliber used and the amount of ammo that each weapon should have in the magazine
the stub automatic doesn't literally have a place to put bullets inside
That is how GW made weapon images, and still does for many of them...
And it is also what happen when people who know nothing about guns try to depict them
wich is funny because the other guns are kinda fine in those books
Even when they try to copy real life stuff they fail
This is clearly based on the colt 1911, but they forgot a little detail that make this weapon impossible to use unless they use caseless ammo, and even then there would be a problem in case of misfire
thing is, even without that piece, you can still go "yeah that's a gun", the stub automatic is just goofy lol
also the stub automatic has a magazine of... 9 bullets
Not disagreeing on that, it is goofy indeed, but what i'm trying to convene is that GW is shit at gun design, and because of that they used various different terms to indicate the exact same thing... We have descriptions of auto weapons being only automatic, but semi auto auto weapon exist, and the macrocannon would shoot only in single shot even though it is classified as auto weapon...
Ok, then auto weapon are caseless, but even that is clearly not, since we have seen lots of autogun with cased ammo..
And what about autopistols that are just SMG?
Also ironically speaking autoguns that we know the caliber use full power rifle ammo...
Which is even bigger than the 7,62 nato that most of real life battle rifles use currently
i mean, except the escher drum fed one most autopistols look more like well, pistols
The descriptions of stub weapons, and in particular of the stub rifle, are something of the most generic crap you could find btw
or uzi's/mac-10's to be precise
Yeah, but they are stated to be SMG, go figure if you can, i spent months trying to get a grasp of GW categorization for guns and the only result that would match everything is that they knew jackshit and went with what sounded cool, and made a mess
eh, ill just go the ttrpg route and say "stubs are mostly pistols and single shot rifles with exceptions", "autoguns are assault rifles and similar", "autopistol are all kind of automatic small weapon"
Fair, but a correction, autogun are stated to be battle rifles, assault rifles fall within stub guns for some reason
But who care, all are slug-throwers after all
And it is also a better word to refer to them imo
eh, i say ar just because of the common high rate of fire within autoguns
So, is the Psykhanium from Darktide based anywhere in actual warhammer lore? Does something like that exist? Or is it just what they made to have an actual tutorial
It's not that weird, like it's just Telepathy Discipline Psyker
Blank class when? So i can skip the tutorial and then complain about not being clearly shown how to do stuff? (Not that there is really need for a tutorial imo)
@reef kite nothing really comparable in existing lore afaik.
Loading people with MIUs into nutrient tanks is fairly common. Sharing mindscapes I'm sure has come up before a few times. Using a telepath combined with sensory deprivation booths combined with mysterious science doesn't break any lore, and is quite a cool idea.
There's always need for a tutorial because we all know that there will be that one person who intentionally doesn't understand anything because they weren't taught it word for word, step by step, and will shittalk the game because of it.
I like the tutorial because it gives me a quick idea if I like the voice pack or not.
Hearing the Ogryn bully voice pack just grunt in response and not giving af made me realize I made the correct choice.
Little detail I just noticed. The dreg ragers improvised weapon is made from an adjustable spanner
Glad to see wrenches made it to the 42nd millenium
I mean theyre british what do you expect
It would genuinely surprise me if a single games workshop writer had even held a firearm, let alone understands how they work on a mechanical level
shooting clubs exist in Europe
Not wrong, but theyre also not super common hobbies
I got to shoot a Nagant once
Based
The end point is, much like holywood here in the us, i doubt many people who make the crative/design decisions for 40k know shit about guns
The 1st time I shot a gun was with a friend who'se family hunted, was Browning or something
Then the Nagant pistol
Indeed
Guns are cool, people who do dumb shit with them are the problem, and then they ruin it for everybody else
they've said they straight up don't know how guns work
in the past lol
the goal is to make things look cool
This comes as no surprise
Oh yeah
As long as it vaugely looks like a gun
and it looks cool
it'll prolly get approved
I mean we dont play this hobby for realism
also sculpting issues and crap as well back then limited them even more
leading to uh
This lul
Truly based weapon design
Theyre guns have gottem better over the years
But like
Post Rubicon asreael
Lemme get an image
tbh his original gun was even worse
Sten bolter can’t hurt you
Sten bolter:
100%
But i was using this a modern model example of uhh
Wepon design
lol fair
Yeah, old lion'r roar was an abomination that haunts the mind of all... And it didn't even looked cool, just two guns mashed together
Yeah
This style of missile launcher is cool af
BACKBLAST CLEAR?
Yes
Brapblast
Also when things from the heresy have literally zero lore outside of the heresy (characters, specific ships) I like to have weird headcanons and stories I can come up with that make sense
Speaking of heresy era, I was wondering why Chaos navy ships look totally different from Imperial Navy ships
chaos fuckery
Like Chaos marines look at least similar but the ships are not even close
Different designs
Imperium also use those ships
It’s just that a lot of them went traitor
So they have a terrible reputation
So if there was like a 30k BFG game the Imperial side would have some of those flat dagger shaped ones but in regular colours and maybe less tentacles
Yep
Also those flat designs are still used
In 40k by imperial fleets
They’re just less common because they aren’t actively made
And they don’t fit modern imperial navy tactics

Would it make sense for the Knights of Gryphonne to be of Iron Warriors descent? And what would happen to a loyalist chapter of traitor lineage?
They have like 0 lore
So idk
Regarding loyalist chapter of traitor lineage they’d get purged
It's possible, there are SM Chapters that we (Outside of the game) know are from traitor Genestock, so nothing really stop it from being possible
^its secret 99% of the time
Like Cawl using the stocked ones for shenanigan
Is there an ultramarines successor chapter based on the nemesis chapter? (Destroyer squads)
Silver skulls are most certainly iron warriors
Considering the ultramarines absorbed a bunch of loyalist ones
The Nemesis Chapter is a Loyalist Codex Astartes-compliant Space Marine Chapter. The Nemesis Chapter is a Second Founding Successor Chapter of the Ultramarines Legion. It descended from those Ultramarines companies of the 22nd Chapter who fought alongside the then-Loyalist Night Lords Legion during a brutal purgation campaign of the Great Crusad...
Yeah they’re called the nemesis chapter
They are Iron Fist
But they revere the Severed head of their Primarch instead of his hands 

Wow very original
They are Ultramarine, you don't go to them for original names
many of the original special companies from the heresy era just used their company name as the new successor chapter name
Yeah
They’re totally not iron warriors
Trust them
And also the other ultramarine second founding chapters saying they’re ultramarines
They’re absolutely ultramarines ignore the symbol
Yeah sorry, forgot to add on the events of the first battle of paramar. Loyalist iron warriors fought alongside the War Griffons titan legion, once they lost everyone dipped and said group of iron warriors has no further lore to my knowledge. War griffons are the titan legion of Gryphonne IV, hence the knights of gryphonne seem like they may be connected in some way
Oh
Yeah that’s a lot of evidence lol
Odds are prolly
But there might not be much iron warrior geneseed left
Mostly due to the mechanicus most likely proving whatever geneseed they think is correct
If I was in the Admech I'd arange to send Traitor Geneseed to the loyalist Chapter, like Thousand Sons to the Space Wolves and such
Thousand sons gene seed straight up doesn’t work properly
Also, if you mix geneseed things go poorly
Tbh
And it would be pretty obvious who is and isnt part of the space wolves
^
Meh, see if I care, I'm as petty as the other Monitorum officers
Ok
How to get killed by your colleagues 101
Or get killed with your collegues
Knock knock it's the Adeptus Arbites
Or a Space Marine Pipe Bomb sent through the mail to my Hab
Playing with the railgun tank in BF 2042 really gives me a feel for how the Tau deal with enemies
Who’s y’all’s favorite ‘evil’ space marine chapter
Like iron hands or greater
Not counting chaos because chaos is the most chaos chaos of all chaos
black templars
I heard flesh eaters are cool but I never learned anything about them
their name is pretty on the nose
Lol
I do want to see a Malevolent PoV book where it's an ancient Dread that introduce a Scout Marine in why they are all assholes and then the Scout become a proper assholes while the Dread melow out and become better for civilians (Before they kill each others)
I don’t like saying ‘evil’ but I feel like in 40ks you gotta clarify between ‘evil’ and ‘murder Funtime Funtime fest’
Lol
That would be fun but also probably get boring after the first 5 chapters
tbf, I have heard a lot of space marine books are kinda like that
Well the thing about the silver skulls is their "founder" was one of the few loyalist iron warriors
I am aware
I forget his name, but his helmet was the inspiration for their heraldry
I am making a dumb joke
the mega chad guy?
‘We were mad, so we killed all of them’ flip ‘advertisement’ flip ‘oh chaos, murder’
If you like SM it's somewhat alright, but if you don't care about them they aren't great literature (Then again BL isn't great literature as a whole)
The only iron warriors descendants using traitor geneseed would be the Minotaurs
But the Iron Skulls likely just use Fist or Ultramarine geneseed
Probably Fists
Because of their tendency for mysticism
this guy
When you say Fist, you mean Iron or Imperial ?
Imperial
Barbas dantioch
So the geneseed actually effects your personality?
Yeah, homeboy right here
yes
That’s
Weird
It's a mix of genetic memory passed down from marine to marine and also chapter culture
that + a lot of chapters use psycho indoctrination
Ah
All
That's the most important part of marine training
Gonna be honest, I use to fucking hate space wolves
But my hate for how stupid it is, is kinda flipping on it self
It’s so dumb it’s kinda amazing????
I like the viking side of them
they have toned down the whole
wolf your wolf thing
I wouldn’t be able to tell from the upgrade sprue
they are still pretty interesting
That's just HH trying to sell models
‘They drink this magic cup that makes you Into a fuckinh werewolf’
‘And then you become a wolf’
also their booze shuts off their liver
There are no wolves on fenris and such
so they can get drunk
I also want to sorta defend the whole prospero thing,
Leman tried to contact Magnus
It's likely they are the only chapter which is lenient in their recruiting
magnus didn't pick up
Magnus shot the ship down
Bloodbath
he wouldn't even have tried to talk first
Even worse, actually
also Horus told leman that emps wanted magnus dead
Considering half of the chapter was in a civil war and there wasn't a way to know who was who things would've probably gone worse
he was just gonna arrest him before iirc
He was
Leman was less inclined to kill than his sons a lot of the time
But he also loved his sons a lot more than most of his brothers
That’s because Russ manipulated their fury and they never realized it.
So having a team of messengers killed made him fucking enraged
I like that they managed to get gulliman to get drunk
then he got a hangover
I think that's a thing at least
I don't equate going "fuck yeah go buck wild they killed your brothers" to exceptionally wonderful manipulation skills
Moment of weakness
Is the Burning of Prospero the War of Vengeance but in 40k ?
Feasting was a tradition. One more ritual among thousands, one more bar on the cage. To feast was to sit with your brothers on long benches, eating, drinking, singing. And at the high tables, where all could see them, the thegns and jarls would be doing the same. The only ones not singing and drinking were the thralls, forced to navigate a maze of fistfights and hungry wolves, bipedal and otherwise.
Lukas crouched in the high rafters of iron-hard wood above the chamber and watched it all. From above, the feast resembled nothing so much as a mechanism of many parts. He could see the wheels of influence and aggression upon which the whole of the Aett turned. He wasn’t the only one who could see them – even he wasn’t so arrogant to think that. But he fancied that he was the only one who saw them for what they were.
A trap. A trick, played on those long-dead warriors by their Wolf King. Russ had taken a legion of brutal killers and convinced them that they were heroes. He had twisted the ancient superstitions and sagas of Fenris into a cage of words to contain his wild sons. It was a chain of illusion, holding them fast, though they could neither see it nor feel it.
All except Lukas. He rubbed the back of his neck, as if he could feel the collar chafing him.
Josh Reynolds, Lukas the Trickster
No clue, not a fantasy guy
Read the excerpt.
I wasn't replying to you
ngl, I am biased, but i'd like to see Russ come back as like crazy space odin
war of vengance is the war of the beard right?
if so
Yes.
then no
This still doesn't read as manipulation, more of a cultural thing Russ had taken from Fenris
war of the beard was purely becuase of what happened to the messenger
It's hard to read as much else considering this happens with literally every other chapter too in one way or another
The paragraph with the bold says it.
And the Elf raiding several merchant caravans + Dwarf settlement
This is also coming from Lukas the fucking trickster, so
Yeah the dark elves.
The high elves didn’t do it but the dwarves didn’t understand the difference.
Morathi is the sole reason a lot of stuff went to shit in warhammer fantasy
this is a long copy paste
Aenarion should have killed that bitch when he had the chance
I’m inclined to believe him tbh.
😩
Well then just fucking say it instead of creating a diplomatic catastrophe
‘Your good health!’ ‘Your halls here are mighty, and full of great wonders. I have marvelled at the skills of your people, and I know in my heart that an alliance with you shall bring much benefit to my people.’
‘You are very fine people, if a little unwashed and short.’
‘It has been mostly my pleasure to meet you all, though I have not a clue what your names are, and all of you look pretty much the same to me.’
‘That your mouths produce as much smoke as your chimneys is surprising, and if I do not choke to death before the evening is out, I shall thank the gods for protecting me. I understand that we have only just met, but I hope that in time you will understand the great privilege I have granted you all by allowing you into my presence. There are people of my own homeland who have never been granted an audience with me, and yet here I am, sinking cupfuls of your foul broth and treating you like equals. I am assured that you are an honourable people, and you best well be.’
Know this!’ ‘It will go well for you that we should become friends. The Naggarothi do not treat idly with others, even elves of other realms. Should you wrong us, our vengeance will be sure, swift and deadly. We will burn these halls and we will pile your corpses upon pyres so high that they will rival these mountains. We shall be content to let you dwell in these rocky peaks, and we shall take the lowlands and the forests. Should you oppose us, we will have no option but to drive you before us, as we have the orcs and the beasts and the goblins. I look forward to meeting your High King, for he shall hopefully be of an almost equal standing to myself, and of intelligence enough to treat with me. But I warn you, if I am not impressed with him, I may decide simply to slay all of you. In fact, the next one of you that mispronounces my name might just get my blade through his gizzard. While we may deign to learn your crude language, please do not mangle the heritage of my forefathers and the legacy to my descendants with your ugly lips and thick tongues.’
'Long may Nagarythe prevail over you all!’
he said this to the dwarves
in elvish
so they didn't know what he was saying
Lukas also didn't speak to Leman
Ever
There's a major disconnect between most first founding chapters and their primarchs considering they're all gone
OOF that aged badly
Malekith did a little bit of trolling
The Heresy depicts a lot of marines seeing them as near divine figures which is, described by Kharn, something genetic
The later books address it as well and echo it. Specifically wolf time. Though to be fair, a lot of authors portray the space wolves as dumbasses most of the time.
This isn't the case in 40k barring maybe three ff chapters
Wolftime is egregious about making them look stupid to.
Them being stupid has always been a bit of a trait for the wolves
Maybe not stupid but certainly headstrong
Back!
The Blood Angels, Ultramarines, and kind of the Salamanders are the only ff chapters to my knowledge that have that same sense of veneration for their primarch in the current era, at least when compared to their 30k counterparts
And for the Blood Angels it's literally a spiritual divinity they see him with
But for others they range from indifference to outright scorn in some cases
A primarch should be inspiring. Our genetics should react at the mere sight of them. Think of the moments you laid eyes on Horus, Dorn, or Magnus. I’ve seen Sanguinius and Russ with my own eyes, as well. Close enough to touch their armour. Think of when you stand before Lorgar: the awe and reverence that beats through your blood. The feeling of our genetic coding reacting to the pinnacle of the human process. I’ve never felt that instinctive respect for Angron, Khârn. Not once. He is a broken thing. Devastating, unrivalled in war, but broken.
Khârn didn’t answer because there was nothing to say. He boarded his drop pod, ascending the ramp and waiting for a robed Legion slave to secure his restraint harness.
You feel it,+ Argel Tal said. +You feel it, too.
In psychic silence, Khârn confessed something he’d never said outside his Legion. "Yes, we feel the same. The World Eaters, each and every one of us, knows what you know
Argel Tal’s voice was laced with cold, seething anger. Why do you tolerate it?
"What can we do? Murder our own father? Did you destroy Lorgar when he led you into worshipping the Emperor? Or did you tolerate him in patience, hoping that eventually he’d find his way to equalling his brothers?"
A pause. A long, long pause. Khârn took it as Argel Tal’s capitulation and pushed on. "It’s our shame to bear before the other Legions, brother. Angron was broken long before he ever reached us. Why do you think we let him beat the Nails into our heads? We hoped that by breaking ourselves on the same anvil, we’d finally feel unity with our father.
There was nothing of mockery in the Word Bearer’s reply. Only sympathy. Khârn’s skin crawled. He’d have preferred mockery.
It didn’t work?
The drop pod’s sides closed in, armour plating locking to block all view of the hangar beyond. Khârn’s last sight was of Argel Tal ascending the gang-ramp into a red XVII Legion gunship. ‘No,’ he muttered, as much to himself as to the distant Word Bearer. ‘It didn’t.’
Fucked with formatting for space
As time passes the marines view their fathers like this less and less
And ten thousand years later it's not a stretch of the imagination to assume some level of spite would be formed for the equivalent of an absent father
Especially one who left with some of the chapter's best warriors chasing a fucking fairytale
Out of all of the disappeared primarchs, Russ is the one you could make the best argument for just wanting out
Next to the Khan
They're literally nothing
It's been stated multiple times that the 2nd and 11th are just supposed to be inserts for yourguys
One for chaos one for the Imperium
Well, yeah
Their introduction into the heresy story was one of the worst handled things in the series
Which says something
Honestly impressive how much BL books have gone out of their way to portray absolutely nothing for them
Not even a peep
Like an Ultramarine Successor being very distinctly, definitely not Ultramarine
Hell, their geneseed is probably somewhere out there
I've never heard that angle before
What else would they be, especially during the rogue trader days
What about those Astartes with horns and claws? Or was that a Raven Guard successor?
The entire cursed founding is interesting
Black Dragons, yeah
That's the name
This was one of the hints towards the 2nd and 11th they put into shit during the early heresy
BL writers were summarily told to cut it out
And then they did
I also remember Cawl being able to do Primaris with the traitor legions but was told not to. But who knows if he actually listened.
So here's an idea
Cawl does what he wants.
To backtrack
That’s a fact.
He's a lovable rascal
What archetypes for Primarchs are we missing? What roles could the 2nd and 11th have fulfilled?
What was missing?
No one knows
A female 
A healer.
Four out of the 20 primarchs are complete guesses for their purpose in the Emperor's plan
Angron
2
11
Alpharius
The closest idea we have for Angron is an empath who would have dealt with family issues
Alpharius was a CIA plan all along I think
Angron is alleged to be an empath. As for Alpharius it depends on if you believe his primarch book or not.
Alpharius seems obvious with duplicity and manipulation
In his book, his purpose is to be the emperor’s unseen shadow primarch.
Sorry, FBI
He's being internal to the Legions and Imperium
I don't trust Alpharius whatsoever
Where's the bit
Something something I don't trust anyone who tells the truth
If I had to guess, Alpharius was to be the primarch that watched the other primarchs.
All memes aside, Alpharius could've been the most interesting
Myeah, intelligence gatherer, fly on the wall.
I like the Astartes that aren't thuggish and brutish
As for archetypes the only ones I can think of that we’re missing is a dedicated healer and a fighter pilot.
Im not saying that’s what they are. That’s just what I thought of off the top of my head.
Some type of archivist
Maybe that's why the remembrancers were made, as a substitute
Gman is the ultimate administrator and logistics guy.
Guilliman is more of an emperor than an archivist
The Unremembered Empire shows exactly what Guilliman's purpose was
I was thinking they were all meant to be generals but idk, that kind of changed. So something non-combat works.
Sanguinius was the mascot
Magnus was meant to be the power source of the golden throne and his legion to protect it and be fuel.
That’s what I believe.
Kurze? Well I know he went batshit insane (emphasis on bat ayyyyy) but I think he was intended to be a magistrate or a judge of some kind.
I SEE YOU AS A TOOL
I AM A LOVING FATHER
YOU CAN TRUST ME
I WILL DISPOSE OF YOU WHEN THE TIME COMES
Son, your purpose is gonna be being a battery
More like the ultimate air traffic controller if they added astronomicon to that.
The fact that the Emperor was 100% going to genocide the navigators was funny
I like the bit when Guillman goes to the Emperor after he comes back to Terra and comes not feeling great about it
9 out of 10 Flight Simulator players envy this man
Of course, the Emperor sees a grand plan, a course to follow. Everyone's a stepping stone to the goal.
Custodes seem like they would've done a better job of what the Primarchs did.
Valdor wanted that
SM were a mistake
Only because of Chaos meddling
But their lot was always to be replaced, eventually.
They were just a first itteration of an idea
Nah, even without chaos meddling they were a mistake, they were meant as biological weapons to be disposed off when the galaxy was conquered
Which would've worked if the babbymarchs weren't abducted
Marines under a primarch are the ideal
Blood Angels were savage murderers before Sanguinius
Imagine not simply eating everyone.
Good direction skills from a reasonable authority figure was what the primarchs were intended to do
And in the cases where it worked it worked really fucking well
Even though Sanguinius is dead his influence on the Angels is still seen today, there's a reason they're the way they are
Same with the Ultramarines and Salamanders
Obedient and controlled
See it's funny because that style of guidance produced the worst chapters
The Blood Angels, Ultramarines, and Salamanders all have comparatively excellent morals
The Iron Warriors all became fucking sadists with Perterabo's 'guidance' with few exceptions
All of the traitor marines turned for a reason, they were all under the guidance of fucked up primarchs
Excluding the Sons of Horus, that's just a weakspot in the storytelling and always has been
Well the guidance from a bad mentor will not be good for anyone
Like Perti is quite clearly a very bad person, not in the evil/good sense but on a personal matter
What would a Loyalist Iron Warriors Chapter look like
...please more than just
"Minotaurs"
Solex Pattern Power Swords ?
“My left arm was numb and useless. I threw myself to my feet, pulling my sword from my webbing. The device is a fine weapon, of the old kind. It has no material blade like other, cruder models I have seen. It is a hilt, twenty centimetres long, inlaid and wound with silver thread, enclosing a fusion cell that generates a metre-long blade of coherent light.”
From Xenos (Eisenhorn trilogy).
Literally a lightsaber.
Yeah, they definitely moved away from that, after Abnett got the one mention in
The Eisenhorn stuff seems...strange
Fuck
I know you're right but just
Ack
So what overall would differentiate them from other Chapters
- Absolute ruthlessness
- Rude to other Chapter bois
- The Chapter engages together
More social to each other iron hands?
In separation from the traits that are made by them being y'know
High Lords Goon Squad
Large amounts of pre planning and post battle analysis
People make a lot of jokes about the minotaurs
But they’re so effective because they literally over analyze every battle to death
Moloch straight up counts how many people die and are wounded per battle
Wait wait wait
Performing a BDA is...is...not common?
I mean I get it for scenarios where it's literally not practicable
Such as, say, when you need to move on immediately
Like to the same excessive amount the Minotaurs do it no
Because the minotaurs straight up look at how bullets have penetrated armor
On everything
It’s fucking absurd
They look so closely at everything it’s insane
How much blood did someone they killed lose
How many bones broke
How long did someone stay alive after getting chopped in half
How many shots from a bolter did it take to get a kill
They never approximate
This...honestly sounds like the Death Guard
Their counters
Except without the repetition of 7
Yeah
that's less for actual analysis tho
^
Oh yeah no I get that
well, some times it is
but only for disease
But the absolute focus on detail, the meticulousness, yeah
Like scout Bobius got shot 32 times in the heart before dying
But scout joe got shot 31 times and lived
Then again, if we go "ADHD is Chaos" that's a helluva route to go
Tbf
I don’t think it’s related to their gene seed
I think it’s just the culture they Foster as a chapter
Fair
Which is similar to the culture the iron warriors used to foster as a legion
Would, or really even Could, any Loyalists from the Traitor Legions, who would go on to develop Chapters do so with a Pre-Primarch culture?
Potentially there’s loyalist chapters who have their pre primarch traditions
And pre primarch marines tended to not go traitor with their primarchs
The only ones I can consider would be Luna Wolves tbh
War Hounds are a hard negative
I feel like Alpha Legion "Loyalists", acting as a Loyalist Chapter, wouldn't actually...act as that or really reveal that they were Loyalist
...though a Word Bearer would have little trouble blending in with the majority of the Imperium
are there designated warships (like on sea) in the imperium
like official ones made by forge worlds
yes?
Yes, theyre called the greyknights (the original grey knights were formed from loyalist members of the traitor astartes)
Because they arent loyalist
The anchorite is just that

I'm curious what do you mean by this?
Most ships we see in 40k are dedicated warships?
Very few individuals actually have the funds let alone the capability to fly their own vessels
Alpha legions are of the only legions where 99.9% of them went traitor
They mean warships on water
Not in the void
Yes
There was a huge war on a planet with a massive ocean
Between the admech and daemons
like as in warships as we know them today, boats but with guns
theres a few examples, ye
just for the most part, humans settle on land, and anything a warship can do for an engagement, a voidship can do just fine
Yeah warzone charadon books mention it
But we don’t get any in-depth descriptions
Other then they have a lot of guns and are mobile
Then got rearmed and upgraded to warships
Because nothing 40K does is really small
Along with the water extraction rigs
I was wondering because some hive worlds have seaports
and that seems weird
Macro-trawlers are Adeptus Mechanicus watercraft, that are deployed in fleets to harvest a world's sea life.[1]
this is
all we know lmao
Those things are probably absolutely massive
Yeah
macro is in the name
They harvest ocean life to get folks in the Imperium fed
That's a big, beeeeeeg amount of folks
Ergo, they're big
ok but
And since it's 40k, there's some massive ocean life that tries to kill the macro-trawler
whats the skull count on that STC
Not high enough
how many skulls are on the STC
What does that mean
read it litteraly
what is the number of skulls on the macrotrawler
I was also wondering because it wouldn't make sense for there to be battleships in a sci-fi setting, but this is 40k. Plus Star Wars has combat watercraft
...
It would makes sense TBH
explain
Not all engagements can be fought on land
it would make perfect sense for a spacefaring nation to have waterborn vessels for oceanic worlds/ underwater needs
they probably have to get them specially delivered from the local forge world
yeah but wont aircraft be better for water engagements
I
what?
no?
Never in the history of ever?
also those aircraft need to land, refuel, rearm
pilots need to be exchanged
etc
all is much easier to do without having to leave a planets gravity well
so even if aircraft were the best way to fight naval warfare (which they really aren't) you'd still need larger carrier style vessels
but aircraft aren't just confined to land
so?
plus spaceships could enter atmosphere(?)
they cannot
ohhhh
imperial spaceships that enter atmosphere crash
and cannot reenter the void
best example
signus
that clears things up
It does.
Orks used submarines to attack during the war for Armageddon.
With complications sure
And in one of the Cain short stories and a BA short story the local AM and pdfs had water craft also.
A lot of the time you don't need to enter atmosphere with voidcraft
The weapons have a range of "enough" and a destructive yield of "excessive"
There’s also a knight world that has an entire mobile island that one of the houses uses a base.
An ocean world will probably have a large fleet here and there but oceanic fleets are easy pickings for orbital strikes.
The sad truth of the matter is underwater combat isn't as flashy as above ground or space combat so it tends to be ignored
Oh yeah and in the flesh tearers novel I’m reading right now there’s an agriworld with full on old timey wooden vessels.
Agriworlds are commonly technologically behind for economic reasons
Economics
Indeed. I’m just naming all the instances of boats I can think of.
the imperium has the technology and money to make big atmoshperic ships
Moving things between hives when Orks have air superiority.
why boats?
ah... that's armaggedon
The locals probably use it also.
Boats are simple and easy to produce and require minimal training to use
And in outgunned which takes place on an agri swamp world.
Flying is dangerous on a planet with an active war zone in the skies and because of the natural features of the planet with lots of really high trees and vegetation.
I hope we get to fight in Darktide on some big 40k cargo ship if atoma has a sea
I want to fight on a train.
Sea is pushing it
Hiveworlds are 100% efficiency, any water outside of a hive is likely to be just enough to fulfil its purpose
I also want to fight on a train so I can make puns. “The chaos worshippers are on the locomotive with the loco motives. We have to make sure their plans are derailed.”
But yeah there are any number of reasons why a planet will use water travel instead of air travel.
yup
Also on a planet like Armageddon, the polluted toxic water is a defensive fortification in its own right.
At least until the enemy adapts.
lol orks
Armageddon will be fine in all honesty GW doesn't want to acknowledge orks in lore more than they have to
That'd mean acknowledging the beast! Which means acknowledging the war of the beast! Which means acknowledging the krorks! Which means acknowledging the war in heaven!
A lot of the new books have been making the gsc as the disposable enemy.
They function better as that
GSC is at least interesting
There are moral implications with them
what is gsc
Genestealer Cults
Honestly GW has been knocking it out of the park with new factions here's hoping it continues
They also have a wider range of capabilities in shooting and melee since they can use imperium tech.
any chance we will fight in the ash wastes in Darktide? Like chaos wastes in VT2
If the game survives sure, who knows
natural transformation
The problems with going deep deep into hivecities is that it's genuinely fucking hell
The lower you get the more hostile to life it is
The lowest we go into atoma is pleasant compared to a lower underhive
On Atoma we may still get a chance to fight on a "Sea"
It's just that, in reality, it'd be a half-empty waste treatment vat of several trillion-whatever gallons volume
With all the debris that comes from people just chucking stuff into the vat / toilet / trash
Such that small islands are possible
...a respirator would definitely be required
Could even be a fairly simple reason for it
"We have intelligence that they're planning on causing a detonation from a barge in order to flood lower levels, intercept the barge and kill all before they can be planted"
Players fight against nurgle cultists with just prisoner rags and have no problem, respirators are just a nice thing to have
The real issue there is
"How do we make this fun for people who are melee"
We throw them offboard?
close quarters on ship fighting
I support that idea, the one to throw them offboard
Traitor fast boats boarding you
Lame, we should be the boarders
Traitor valks boarding you
share this with catfish
Just throwing people onto your barge
Some sort of Traitor AA net would be up to prevent you from doing that
yeah
They have AA stuff on their barge??!! Why we ended up having just our guns?
Traitors get all the nice stuff, mask, guns... And now even AA
No no no
Like, there's a AA net outside of the treatment tank
Potentially with our barge having to go through...hmm...
A tunnel, I think
Big friggin pipe
Vertical insertion from the space
it's misty outside
Enclosed treatment vat was my thought tbh
Ah, feth it, just give me two ranged weapons and i'm in
Which means it'd be hell and you all need flashlights
kek
No lights for u
Too spooky
Honestly Fatshark should make crafting and the like before they do this
Need a rework of all the system imo
Blessings could be replaced by a better thought system, or maybe, just maybe, remove the useless and filler one and make every one useful
fuck rng too
Yeah
Sad thing is
A lot of this could be really good
Like you could have a really organic game and it'd be great
Imagine if, as you're fighting through, you run into a PDF unit that's about to get slaughtered or a PDF unit that's actually pushing down a street with some infantry and a Chimera or something
Or even "Explosion in the distance"
This would be an amazing random encouter
Would make the setting feel more alive
You run into two different groups of Nurgle folks fighting one another
You get factionalism with the two
Instead we are the only ones around there, and then there are the heretics
A Crusher fighting a bunch of random cultists, for instance
Which somehow they always know where we are, and we cannot even shut down their exits
Maybe theres like a town square and you have to destroy the chaos leman russes
with c4 or some shit
darktide had SO much potential
Indeed, and that is also what make people angry, it has so much potential, and so much was promised... And when it released the only actually complete and working part was a real money shop
Like
You know when the Traitor PDF see you and go "Loyalists sighted!" in an actually human voice?
They sound like people
They sound like more things should happen than just them acting like random monsters
Bruh why are you guys saying darktide in past tense like it's no longer being updated
yeah, and the thing was everyone was 100% sure Darktide was gonna be the best 40k game ever
it arguably is
I was one of them
but only barely
I think at this point, people don't have much hope that Darktide will go the way it can go
Because too much has been removed, too much might never arrive, it is not the DT that many wanted, nor expected
I can’t defend it lul
This is like a smaller scale version of what happened with halo infinite I just for once in my life don't want to be surrounded by this
Like God damn
This, so much this, this is what i feel... I feel DT will never reach the grandiosity that it could have
There was just so much potential, the devs knew that they had a promising game on their hands, they had the community, the money, the resources... and then I don't even know how they messed up so badly
what were the chances
I mean at this point it's totally ok if you quit the game and just leave the server, not to be like ooh I'm creating an echo chamber but it's ok to give up on the game
It just feels like classic fatshark lol
There's a lot here that can be amazing, but it doesn't feel as though there's a driving force behind the game that will make it become great
They literally spoke about a game than never got released, and what we have is nothing great
"Just leave don't complain about it"
Yeah that'll make this a lot better
I like it but I'm not a gamer in the slightest, I barely ever play video games
Idk I enjoy the gameplay but that’s literally it
I don’t know if anyone else is in that boat
I just wanted Darktide to not only be a good game, but THE game to propel the 40k universe into a new tier
Well that's why I said I'm not trying to create an echo chamber I'm just saying if it hurts to look and play the game you should say your piece and ley it lay
That was never gona happen imo
I'm actually waiting for the dev blog, that will decide if i will join the ranks of the white names... But i must also admit i have no hope for it, and i have also no trust toward the designers, they ruined the game and they will keep ruining it i fear
With fat sharks track record
I don't think you're ever gonna be satisfied tho, GW itself is keeping Warhammer from that level
I thought fatshark would've learned by now
I mean
well the new TV show might
They didn’t learn from their pre VT games
maybe GW is learning
The entire video game industry is in a downturn and it's gonna be a long time before it gets any better
Being hyped always ends in disappointment imo
with some expections
GW already knows their core audience
And that’s the people who buy their minis
"Entire video game industry is in a downturn"
What makes you say that o non-gamer
Ironically speaking there seems to be a old post on reddit about VT that pretty much describe exactly what happened with DT, like, everything is perfectly detailed
Because I have never heard anything good about video games with very very rare exceptions
GW has said as much
oh so maybe we have a chance
On their investment reports
Elden ring being maybe the only one, and even then I see people crack and say it's "empty"
Fatshark will continue working on darktide
Is what will happen
How it goes

well yeah
Who the fuck knows
I’m already happy with the core gameplay loop
Actual progression
Needs a lot of work
No, a guy that knew FS highlighted they will never change, and since they were right on everything else, i will trust that random person more than FS as it stand now
maybe the upcoming blog will clarify some things
To an absurd amount
There’s also a bunch of unimplemented cosmetics
From the beta

The game needed more time in the oven
Hopefully, otherwise the downward fall will keep going
We're getting close to a better gaming industry and """"gamer culture"""", but it'll get worse and worse until it even gets a tiny bit better.
if theres one thing im getting for my birthday, it's the hope tha Fatshark will LEARN

We must kill all the gamers
What color do you want your dragon
Not necisarily
So in other news
I fucking hate gamers lmao
OK
again thats us
Go to #darktide-memes I guess
Why would I automatically hate u tho
👍
I hate like the Rick and Morty reddit shit your pants playing Hogwarts legacy people
ok fair
What sorts of classes do you all suppose might become available in the near/common/far future
there was a leak
Stormtrooper, gun lugger, Biomancer
Tech adept
"Biomancer"?
Dome runner
Psychic displine
Ammojack
Huh
Slopper
that showed squad leader, gun lugger, something for zealot, and biomancer
It’s the most common discipline in the imperium
Technically
Mostly since the basics of it
Are taught to every sanctioned combat psyker
Interesting
People say the iron warriors are the gamer legion but what if it's actually the night lords that's why their skin is so pale, and why they skin people (minorities)
So what, like...healing or controlling biomass or what?
it is like the ability to control living things
Interesting
or biological resources
smite
I JUST WANT A MELTA GUN
The stuff that goes between your synapses
That sounds like it could have aspects further than just "Killing people"
Yep
Like shifting the corrupted biomass that's everywhere
Melta gun
Melta gun
Melta gun
Melta gun
Turning them inside out
How would Stormtrooper be different from Veteran?
I want the promised stub rifle
Closer ranged stuff?
Hotshot weapons
hellguns
Perfect
slower
I like it already
Same
Can we get solar auxilia armor for achievements, like something super cool for busting your nutsack on those penances
thats what im saying
or like naval gear
Oi
No
Bad
I can see
Why not making reasonable penances first?
It doesn't even need to be the full suit just like parts of it
Solar Auxilia isn't fukkin Navy armor
But there’s 0 chance we’re getting auxilia stuff
naval breacher gear
Their helmets are really good
that's realistic
The solar auxilia were 1/3rd of all imperial army soldiers that's nearly billions of solar
Solar Auxilia is pre Horus Heresy Militarum
There has to be some scraps of void armor around
It's literally "No longer a thing"
^
Probably at least on saturn
Or Luna or terra
Because they’re the damn founders
NAVAL GEAR
Yeh and we're not there
Of the auxilia
I just want the dang shoulder pads auxiliary have
And they’ve always been very very paranoid
"No"
About giving it out
Man I just want different guard uniforms as well
that wont work
I want that double barrel shotgun the imperial navy models have that look like a triple decker shotgun
I want feudal guard
I want long coats
Melta gun
Also fucking optics
How will Gunlugger work now with the current formulation of enemy special units?
Even basic one
I mean yeah
I love how this just turned from watercraft to naval breachers
BIG guns
Ogryn getting a new throwable that's just a comedically large m80
maybe heavy bolters
No
Flamers for veteran would be cool
Flamers are zealot exclusive for reasons
Like a catachan version
Flamers would be for like...stormtrooper, more likely
Melta
Would meltas shoot like beams?
Normal guardsmen use them plenty
...true
cuz the lore dont say shit
Yes
Yes and it'd incinerate most things in it's way
Flamers aren't stormtrooper weapons lol
Meltas shoot near invisible beams
Of heat
The only thing you really see usually
Are the heat waves
that disperse
And the effects of whatever on the receiving end
because air
Lol give everyone rad weaponry that corrupts (gives you cancer) over time
i want rad weapons
Man
but too mechanicus
Or at least the van saar ones
You shoot it you get cancer
