Gaza Airstrike Timestamps

[full lion]

18:36 strike [evidence] the sun

18:39 strike the sun

18:48 are they flying drones? el debate

19:00 strike el debate

19:03 Flares el debate

19:05 arabic speaker[potentially call to prayer](sounds like rally/rallying call instead]el debate

19:07 strike el debate

19:09 strike el debate

19:09 strike el debate

19:10 strike el debate

19:11 strike el debate

19:11 flare el debate

19:13 strike el debate

19:15 strike el debate

[signal raft]

are all cameras down?

[full lion]

No el debate is still going:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B7r_CrUCZ8o. [It has sound as well]

19:27: call to prayer el debate[ stream ended]

19:28 stream back up el debate

19:28 flares/missiles el debate

[ancient igloo]

updated vidgrid: https://vidgrid.tk.gg/?config=eyJzdGF0ZSI6eyJ2aWRlb3MiOlt7ImlkIjowLCJ1cmwiOiJodHRwczovL3d3dy55b3V0dWJlLmNvbS93YXRjaD92PWUyUmdTYTFXdDVvIiwic3RyZWFtRGF0YSI6eyJ2aWRlbyI6Imh0dHBzOi8vd3d3LnlvdXR1YmUuY29tL3dhdGNoP3Y9ZTJSZ1NhMVd0NW8ifSwiY2FwdGlvbnMiOiIiLCJpbmRleCI6MH0seyJpZCI6MSwidXJsIjoiaHR0cHM6Ly93d3cueW91dHViZS5jb20vd2F0Y2g%2Fdj1MbklLc1ZjUURWcyIsInN0cmVhbURhdGEiOnsidmlkZW8iOiJodHRwczovL3d3dy55b3V0dWJlLmNvbS93YXRjaD92PUxuSUtzVmNRRFZzIn0sImNhcHRpb25zIjoiIiwiaW5kZXgiOjF9LHsiaWQiOjIsInVybCI6Imh0dHBzOi8vd3d3LnlvdXR1YmUuY29tL3dhdGNoP3Y9Yk55VXlyUjBQSG8iLCJzdHJlYW1EYXRhIjp7InZpZGVvIjoiaHR0cHM6Ly93d3cueW91dHViZS5jb20vd2F0Y2g%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%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%3D

I see El Debate and MARCA are the two live.

[full lion]

19:28 missiles being intercepted instead of flares looking at the movement? el debate

19:30 flares el debate

19:40 strike/fire el debate

[rare pelican]

is that a flare..?

[full lion]

Yeah I think so[but some of the tranjactories are so strange..]

19:55 strikes el debate

19:56 flare el debate

19:58 explosion el debate

19:59 fires on the horizon el debate?

19:59 flares/missiles el debate

re: 19:59

20:02 flares el debate

[viscid magnet]

Reports on social media of strike at ahli Arab hospital ||killing 200 to 300 people||

Was that maybe an hour ago ?

[rare pelican]

can you link to them?

There was one really large strike that several of us saw

[viscid magnet]

Yes ||https://t.me/PalestineResist/15445||

[full lion]

Maybe that was the fire I saw at one point.

[viscid magnet]

That's insane considering that's where people take shelter.

[full lion]

just look at the destruction here:https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/1160893738973929493/1163839743260364801/image.png?ex=65410939&is=652e9439&hm=c850ed68199a843cb2fee62f475f40b68ffc99bbad7a60ad71933557f3bc9b82&

20:27 flares/missiles el debate

[ancient igloo]

Did a strike hit a hospital?

https://x.com/youranonone/status/1714332795915436230

[full lion]

Do we know what time it occurred local time?

[sleek lion]

https://vxtwitter.com/manniefabian/status/1714330596241981763?s=20

confirmed to hit the hospital

[full lion]

I think its the hit from 19:59 which is just tragic if so

[signal raft]

Do we have a sound on that

https://vxtwitter.com/TreyYingst/status/1714336373488975882?s=20

[ancient igloo]

1959 recorded here

[sleek lion]

https://fxtwitter.com/qudsn/status/1714335703117570261 this strike maybe?

[ancient igloo]

I believe there is sound

[viscid magnet]

I think around 20:00 local time. first report I read

[signal raft]

Oh yeah, that was clear

[viscid magnet]

should be

[signal raft]

Jep, that's it

[viscid magnet]

this is devastating

[signal raft]

Under ICC statute it is a war crime

[silk rune]

oh my god

[rare pelican]

yeah I honestly wish I hadn't seen that gonna see it for days now

[signal raft]

You all take a lesson how to deal with these videos, please. And feel free to ping a mod or a senior.

[full lion]

yeah I'm very much sat here in two minds one I am glad I documented it on the other I'm tempted to seek out my human right lawyer friends..

[sleek lion]

||https://vxtwitter.com/aldin_aba/status/1714338705819783634?s=20|| CW: aftermath of airstrike footage

[silk rune]

um i guess does anyone have the coordinates for baptist hospital? i can't find it on google maps or openstreetmap (though im not sure experienced with the latter). maybe we can confirm if the strike was captured on any of the livestreams and find more information that way? is there even any value in that?

i honestly have no idea what to do

[rare pelican]

I'm looking for that now actually

[full lion]

maybe we should get a mod in here <@&941484701632307232>

[signal raft]

What for

[sleek lion]

https://maps.app.goo.gl/4NtP7JPwBd6RsPdx6 shows up as al-ahli hospital in google

[full lion]

I meant more to discuss the next steps/resources in case its affected anyone having just successfully recorded and verified the loss of 500 lives in an act of war

[ember vale]

31°30'17.9"N 34°27'41.5"E

[silk rune]

thank you

[signal raft]

Do you need assistance?

[full lion]

No I'm good thanks for the offer[its just sad and tragic]

[signal raft]

I pinged jk

[full lion]

19:03 flare el debate

[ember pike]

Yeah, I'm here reading since the Server Moderator ping.

[signal raft]

We wait for further information

[ember pike]

Yeah, you can't affect anything that's happening. I'm afraid the only choice we have here is between looking and not looking. And if you feel like looking at what's happening is affecting your own health, take a break or stop.

[ember vale]

this is a propaganda account known for spreading lies

[sleek lion]

deleted then

[ancient igloo]

It's not the first time Israel has bombed hospitals (see 2014) and the recorded strikes above around 1959 shows several Israel strikes.

[ancient igloo]

I suggest you put that tweet in the Disinfo channel for documentation.

Thank you everyone for helping to record the strikes. I know we are not capturing them all but here is an example where we can go back and show what we witnessed on livestream w/timestamps and screenshot.

[signal raft]

And please go outside, take a breath, drink a Schnaps, pet your dog, kiss your partner

[full lion]

is anyone downloading the stream? Just so we have a permeant record of it?

[novel basin]

hi sorry my recording errorred out but i can start recording a stream now, which one was it on?

[full lion]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B7r_CrUCZ8o

[ancient igloo]

Was just looking to ping you because the El Debate link changed.

Wish I would have thought to earlier.

[novel basin]

Has any stream been removed entirely? Other than the Reuters one in which ||the journalist was killed|| of course.

[rare pelican]

Do we have an in video timestamp?

[ancient igloo]

I haven't checked, entirely, but some have on some channels.

Would be good to check and download all that remain on El Debate, Reuters, and MARCA for anyone who can do this.

[full lion]

-1:27:18 the next round of vollley's start
-1:24:02[~] the camera pans back to the fire.
I noticed it was odd because of the fire.
I've seen the twitter videos of the hit and the missile did not sound like an artillery shell and there was no flight noise so I think it was fired from a drone[but I have no way to confirm it]

[silk rune]

I'm scrubbing through the el debate stream, and it could be this strike just off screen and to the left? it's very bright, which would match a large detonation, and it's at around 1959. hard to get an exact time because it's a livestream and idk about delays, etc..

that's a few seconds before we see any Hamas rockets as well. immediately afterward the camera pans left

[full lion]

Yeah I only noticed it because of the fire on the Horizon

[rare pelican]

Okay. I'm looking

the sound of the twitter video is very noticable

[silk rune]

am i right that the el debate stream is the only one up right now that's looking at gaza?

[full lion]

I've check the common ones and this seems to be the only one

[silk rune]

ok thanks

[novel basin]

I'm making a list

[full lion]

El debate offline

[ancient igloo]

back up

[full lion]

yeah Currenly watching:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qllQBDQ0ezg

22:00 flare/missile el debate

22:00 flare/missile el debate

[eternal mural]

Anybody caught the strike on livestream on the hospital?

[silk rune]

first one then camera pans to the right for the second one (el debate, looks like rockets to me, they're traveling straight up)

[eternal mural]

Would be much appreciated if someone matched to catch it and I’ll try to get you something in return.

[full lion]

USA deputy Press Secretary has nothing more to add re the hospital explosion

[silk rune]

@eternal mural maybe this one? ~1959 local, there's a huge flash to the left of the el debate stream and then the camera pans over

[eternal mural]

Do you have a screenshot or replay?

[full lion]

We have the fire

[eternal mural]

How is the visibility in the video geographically

[silk rune]

maybe? i have a screen recording from obs, but not of the actual detonation just the el debate view

[full lion]

#1160893738973929493 message

yeah the detonation is off camera

[eternal mural]

Yeah I’ve geolocated and verified the images/videos at the hospital

[full lion]

The rhetoric coming from the American press sectary is QUESTIONABLE..

[eternal mural]

(POV): 31.505019308926734, 34.46231706475516

[full lion]

this is the image I have:****

I can try and screengrab a better one

[stuck plume]

What's the ping for?

[rare pelican]

the mod ping?

[stuck plume]

Yes

[rare pelican]

I think @ember pike got it

[ancient igloo]

I'm starting to download the past (ended) MARCA streams starting with the first one. lmk if anyone else is or want to break up the job.

[signal raft]

Sone ppl had stress with the situation

[ember pike]

Yeah, there was nothing to immediately handle beyond the usual mental health advice.

[silk rune]

@eternal mural assuming this really is the strike, here's the best I have. i left in the hamas rockets firing off at the end, but the actual strike is the flash of light towards the beginning of the video. but yeah it wasn't caught on camera on this stream at least

[full lion]

The USA have no confirmation of a hamas base in the hospital

[ember pike]

But I guess this is good advice: When you ping us mods, make sure that the message contains all the relevant information. So that people seeing the notification can judge whether immediate action is required.

[ancient igloo]

Was a school also hit? CNN is reporting this.

[rare pelican]

video?

or link?

something

[eternal mural]

Important to remember with these pro-Israeli accounts like Israel War Room sharing videos of a “misfire” is that in the videos they share, you see lightbulbs from the city.

Gaza…. IIRC, doesn’t even have electricity right now.

[full lion]

The firing did occur but there's no sound [there's no plane noise and assuming the videos have not been doctored] do we know if Hamas have the capibility for that type of rocket?

[hexed flame]

fwiw you can see the same stream alongside two others with timecodes. (~-2:20:00) https://www.youtube.com/live/UtruJztXE5w?si=F_k75T1M7zvmRITg

[sleek lion]

https://vxtwitter.com/Omarfsa2/status/1714349451651719581?s=20 need to watch this better later, but could give some clues

[silk rune]

in this video specifically, you can hear an extremely loud whining/whistling right before the explosion. is a hamas misfire even capable of making that kind of sound?

[full lion]

This was my line of thinking

[rare pelican]

Right? I am trying to figure out what would even make that kind of noise

[eternal mural]

Samir says this is an explosion on the ground: https://vxtwitter.com/omarfsa2/status/1714356406894162004?s=46

And given his experience in OSINT, I do trust @eternal mural

[full lion]

Also what is the probability of a hamas misfire hitting a hospital over a random house?

[eternal mural]

And videos going around are from Jabaliya 2021

[rare pelican]

is this tweet still there

[silk rune]

to my ear it sounds like whatever struck had to have been travelling extremely fast, which to me suggests that it had to have been fired from a drone/plane in the air directly at the hospital rather than just falling down out of the sky.

[rare pelican]

it looks deleted for me

[severe sapphire]

re: electric, since Gaza is used to going without power, is it possible a generator could be involved? (Haven't watched, just don't want you making a mistake)

[eternal mural]

Like this one, for example: https://vxtwitter.com/chrisschmitz/status/1714344785677324658?s=46

[hexed flame]

Hamas' rockets have a misfire rate of ~15%-20%, meaning they land inside Gaza. (at least according to the IDF.)

[eternal mural]

Not in the amount that those videos from Jabaliya RC 2021 show.

[rare pelican]

I wouldn't take that at face value

[ancient igloo]

https://apple.news/AnoV6pPLKRo-0fCDWWTVIcw

[eternal mural]

Omar from Forensic Architecture that I work with asks on this: ah wow but it is off frame when it happens?

[silk rune]

yeah, at least as far as i can tell

sorry

[eternal mural]

No need to apologize

😘

[full lion]

What horizon Geolocations can we use to refine the strike location simply put are there trees anywhere near it?

[ancient igloo]

There are some random remaining lights but not much (way more on this location of the camera than all week).

[eternal mural]

Exactly

[signal raft]

And in film you see the light before you hear the sound

[signal raft]

Can you check your DmS tomorrow pls

[silk rune]

in the same video, you can see a very brief (maybe 1-2 frames) flash ~1.5 seconds before the whining sound and the actual detonation. could be an issue with video compression, or another strike farther away, or it could be related to the strike we're looking at?

[full lion]

really wish I could clip on Youtube again..

[stuck plume]

https://twitter.com/manniefabian/status/1714365157558624288

[silk rune]

could this have been caused by a drone firing the rocket? or whatever propellant the rocket was using igniting? I'm not super knowledgeable here

[hexed flame]

I don't think was shared: Hamas Telegram channels reported a rocket barrage had hit Sderot about 10 minutes before the hospital explosion was reported: https://t.me/httpsAbuUbaida/91

[full lion]

-2:45:16 on the current livestream you can hear the boom

[eternal mural]

@silk rune do you have a link to the livestream you send?

Of that moment?

Omar and I made have something on it.

[rare pelican]

I'm not sure you can link to it directly to a timestamp if it's still streaming

[eternal mural]

This comes 30 minutes after that same channel published a photo of the attack on the hospital

[eternal mural]

Can I replay?

I need it ASAP

[full lion]

Youtube needs it clip feature back

[stuck plume]

Which live stream is this?Can you link it pls? Just catching up

[rare pelican]

hold on

[full lion]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B7r_CrUCZ8o

[stuck plume]

Thanks!

[eternal mural]

The one on the hospital?

[rare pelican]

yeah

the one linked above

[full lion]

I believe so but it might be wrong I only noticed it because of the fire which would have been all the ambulances igniting

[rare pelican]

around 2:45:00 back on the scrub

I think you're right

not being able to link to a timestamp on a livestream is horrible

[hexed flame]

Sorry, you're right. But there are earlier messages regarding the barrage: https://t.me/Mohammedmffffmm/97488

[eternal mural]

https://twitter.com/AvichayAdraee/status/1714365455765242266

Avichay Adraee talking about a failed rocket launch, not an interception. Interesting wording.

[silk rune]

i figured it out, you can do it you just have to specify the tiemstamp manually in the url

its a bunch of math i think im getting close lol

[ancient igloo]

The other two cams are CCTV in Israel. You can see one is off.

[rare pelican]

good god, why can't google just make this easy on us

[full lion]

Yeah its the strange ones from the beach that I just kept ignoring 😂

[eternal mural]

Can you give a link to me once you got it?

Need that moment from the El Debate stream with source link

[rare pelican]

I have no doubt she'll post when she gets it

[sleek lion]

https://vxtwitter.com/Charles_Lister/status/1714367152298299750?s=20 i believe this is an AJ camera, worth checking back to the other streams

[ancient igloo]

The El Debate stream is the ONLY stream that has been up in Gaza.

[eternal mural]

I know. 😉

The building on the left

Is this building, right?

[eternal mural]

Yep

Yeah, I see Samir posted it

[sleek lion]

i dont think that guy is even close to a reliable source

||https://vxtwitter.com/yousuf_tw/status/1714367757968384106?s=20||CW: explosion

AJ livestream got a good look, seems like was a rocket interception

[eternal mural]

😂 agreed.

[stuck plume]

https://twitter.com/obretix/status/1714367204941054382/photo/1

[full lion]

AGAIN any attack on a hospital even with enemy combatants in it is a war crime

[sleek lion]

samir is a wizard

[rare pelican]

@eternal mural https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B7r_CrUCZ8o&t=18349s

try that

[stuck plume]

Deleted this, it's just a random account, no indication that this person has anything of value to say on this

[pseudo kiln]

would that Samir geolocation put it near the hospital?

[eternal mural]

1,7 km away

[rare pelican]

also @silk rune if you're still working on it I think I got it

[eternal mural]

4 min drive by car

[eternal mural]

The first smaller, far explosion is much more more visible here. So, is it possible that those are pieces of the same rocket that has been intercepted/has malfunctioned landing in two different places?

[unique ember]

This is especially interesting considering El Debate is a Spanish online Christian hard right newspaper lol (I know they just mirror AFP, but that's not a demographic I'd consider supportive of Palestine tbh 😅 )

[silk rune]

ok @eternal mural i think i have it https://www.youtube.com/live/B7r_CrUCZ8o?si=f4a0wmIHtUaqTk0x&t=306m1s

someone maybe double-check to make sure it works though lol

[lilac stirrup]

JDAMs don't make that sound

[silk rune]

oh whoops lmao

[rare pelican]

yeah, think it's the exact spot I sent 😆

[lilac stirrup]

So it is either a missile of some kind or a misfire but not a bomb, I guess

[rare pelican]

Pro-tip you can check the spot of the the cursor using inspect element

I found the spot and didn't have to do any math lol

[ancient igloo]

new stream at hospital: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T-JfZ1ltfJs

[full lion]

yeah thats the right clip

[sleek lion]

weird question, but why do so many spanish newspaper have livestreams setup

[silk rune]

oh my god yeah that's so much easier lmao

[rare pelican]

lol

hey it's a learning experience for next time

[ancient igloo]

And at hospital in Khan Younis up: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=90QEUu01-iI

[eternal mural]

Is the location of the explosion in Samir's geolocation where the hospital is at?

[stuck plume]

Not sure, I'm not able to look at this closely since I'm working on something else tonight

[eternal mural]

Because if it is, then it's reasonable to think that the rocket that we see in the video is what hit the hospital. What would be more important to know is what happens mid-air: interception or malfunction. The smaller and farthest explosion that precedes the explosion at the hospital might give some answers.

[vestal summit]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A_uwzugvv-g Sounds similar, at least to my untrained ears.

[lilac stirrup]

It's similar but not the same. Not trying to split hairs here I promise just tryin to be thorough!

[silk rune]

you can also make out these strange trails in the sky (top of the screen) when the detonation is going off. not sure what they are

[sleek lion]

probably just dust clouds?

[novel basin]

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1_TfAOF4VPWA4IVf9AB-BMgi4tfOAJTm4pzR_nJrR4ss/edit?usp=sharing

Finished the list. I went through Reuters, El Debate, and MARCA's youtube livestreams and grabbed the URL of every one that was some sort of skyline or inside Gaza (so excluding funerals in Israel etc.). I got like 100 of them but in the time between me opening the livestream tabs and downloading the metadata three streams have become unavailable (2 × El Debate, 1 × MARCA)

Please let me know or make an edit suggestion on the sheet for updates.

[pseudo kiln]

synced up the window vid with the AJ footage (or, tried to)

[eternal mural]

I don't know why you said that JDAMS don't make that sound. It's got nothing to do with what it's falling, it can be a bomb, a rocket, a plane, a mortar round or a big enough and fast enough object with. Speed and presence, and shape of fins, as well as atmospheric conditions and air density are all variable factors that might result in a distinctive whistle.

[lilac stirrup]

Because it doesn't make the same sound. Any object falling from the sky will make a whistling sound, but the explosion in Gaza has a different noise than the typical JDAM. It's a minor difference but minor differences mean things.

[novel basin]

Regarding making backups, I wonder if the Internet Archive is a suitable place...

[sleek lion]

could be the window was filmed due to the noise of the first explosion?

[ancient igloo]

What stream is that on the right? It is the same video posted in a tweet above that @eternal mural commented on and iirc this was not the correct strike on the hospital.

[silk rune]

el debate, ~2127 local

[full lion]

It doesn't take well to video footage at all

[sleek lion]

appears to be some type of al jazeera stream

[eternal mural]

What I'm saying is that it's quite impossible to attribute that specific sound to a specific object, there's too many variables that might alter the sound. Velocity, barometric pressure, weather and finally and most importantly, the device that is recording the audio

[lilac stirrup]

For the record I'm not trying to clear the IDF of fault here I'm just saying it doesn't sound like the literally hundreds of JDAM videos i've watched over the years, the sound of the whistle is usually much shorter

[eternal mural]

Those are screencaps from the full recording of the AJ stream: the first one is roughly 1.5 second before the explosion in the hospital and it shows another, smaller explosion quite further away, maybe two pieces of the same object hitting in different spots?. What is also interesting is the smoke that can be seen in the foreground. Any news on bombings earlier in the day in that area? I guess that at this point it's pretty much impossible to say, but it's something interesting nonetheless.

[eternal mural]

I get it, I myself am starting to believe that this is the result of an interception. The point that I made is that it's way too difficult to establish with certainty what was what just based on that whistle.

[lilac stirrup]

You're right, I should have said "JDAMS don't typically make a noise exactly like this" but I was sorta in a rush answering multiple chats.

[eternal mural]

Stay calm, fam

https://vxtwitter.com/manniefabian/status/1714377828131553446

😜✌🏼

[lilac stirrup]

Oh I'm calm I just wanted to be clear that I'm normally more thorough with my wording!

[eternal mural]

Fabian's considerations aside, it's another possible piece of evidence.

[silk rune]

el debate, probably flares? they hovered about here for maybe 30 seconds before going out ~2135 local

[eternal mural]

This video is giving more questions than answers. In AJ's stream we see a single rocket/missile flying from the north and possibly intercepting the missile that caused the damage, and we can tell it's coming from the north because a minute later we see the camera turning 180° to capture a new barrage. How is it possible that in this video shot from the north we can't see any trace of the interceptor/interception?

[fresh lance]

It would be helpful to line up the timing of the flashes as well. I don’t have the two side by side however.

[silk rune]

very clear sound of a strike on el debate, but not caught on camera ~2146 local

el debate, ~2151 local, flash on left side of screen

[stuck arrow]

is it possible in anyway to assess what kind of rockets these were?

[silk rune]

el debate is down i think

[fresh lance]

+1. There's a very visible shockwave in that video that is not present in the original video. As you mentioned, there's a whole 7 seconds after the proposed interception before the two explosions happen. That most recent video is still showing the stream of rockets at that time.

[ancient igloo]

AJ did not have a livestream of it to my knowledge. El Debate has been the only stream for days and the only one from this time period to mu knowledge.

[eternal mural]

Yea was jokin around

[eternal mural]

I couldn't tell you just by looking at this, no

[ancient igloo]

link to the original "AJ stream", please

[eternal mural]

#1160893738973929493 message

[lilac stirrup]

We don't tell jokes, not in this family.

[ancient igloo]

I'm not talking about a clip, I'm talking about the actual full stream on a platform like You Tube. Or is this a privately recorded AJ video?

[full lion]

I think its private

[ancient igloo]

I'm behind in this chat but I think @eternal mural 's colleague discredited this

[eternal mural]

https://vxtwitter.com/Omarfsa2/status/1714349451651719581 this was during AJ's live stream.

[ancient igloo]

That is a livestream news broadcast but the clip they are showing to the right is not recorded by them.

[eternal mural]

According to the user who posted this it comes from AJmubasher video feed

[ancient igloo]

I thought you meant "AJ" = Al Jazeera

[eternal mural]

AJ Mubasher is Al Jazeera

[unborn ibex]

Mubasher just means live in Arabic

[eternal mural]

Yep, in english that would be Al Jazeera Live

[ancient igloo]

How do they have a live feed and it not be public?

[eternal mural]

Gotta ask them

[full lion]

So I think I have the strike on their livestream

[lilac stirrup]

AJ Arabic and AJ Mubasher are different streams

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bNyUyrR0PHo

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8D5QY5gw_Xk

I can ask Omar tho he's a homie, if anybody wants me to confirm which stream it was on

[full lion]

particularly as it looks like it was a hospital AL J were at this morning

[eternal mural]

It was definitely on the AJ Mubasher stream

[ancient igloo]

post was deleted

[full lion]

literally the same image we have

[eternal mural]

Also interesting: https://vxtwitter.com/jason_paladino/status/1714386621834158137?s=46

[weak dune]

My poorly educated theory that I think works the best to describe what happened:

• explosion happening shortly after a barrage was launched
• projectile having enough payload to destroy a hospital
• it precisely hitting a hospital

Is:

• Hamas/IJ launch a barrage
• Israel immediately drops a heat-seeking bomb/projectile on launch site
• It targets one of the few places with power and heating: a hospital

[ancient igloo]

Yes, please because I have been checking AJ for live streams and El Debate is the only one during this time. AJ has mirrored segments of livestreams for their livebroadcasts but has not had its own camera filming to my knowledge.

If they have a "livestream" of their own, please tell them to make it public so we can monitor it. @lilac stirrup

[fresh lance]

"Destroy a hospital" is that confirmed? There are ways for a lot of people to be hurt that doesn't involve actually leveling the building. It seems like many people are jumping to "well the building was destroyed" but I'm not sure if I've seen confirmation.

Especially in an evacuation situation such as this, with so many people seeking help in one spot.

[full lion]

It killed most people outside the hospital so I don't know where that is on the semantic ladder

[eternal mural]

My idea is that if the rocket broke up mid-air or was destroyed by an interception it would hardly have that energy and velocity when hitting the ground. But also, if it didn't and it just misfired and it went from the launch to the hospital still in ignition, we would see that in the AJ stream, wouldn't we? Instead there is something happening to that rocket mid-air.

[lilac stirrup]

He says it came from the Mubasher feed

[neon quartz]

geolocation (found, not mine) of the hitted hospital as seen in the Al Jazeera video with a missle exploding video.

[full lion]

@ancient igloo This is the same as the one we've been watching

[lilac stirrup]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F49uYXqsbGg this MAY have been live at the same time but I don't know for sure @ancient igloo

[neon quartz]

https://www.google.com/maps/place/المستشفى+الاهلي+العربي‭/@31.5052363,34.458798,17z/data=!3m1!4b1!4m6!3m5!1s0x14fd7f635affc0c1:0x7323578897344c18!8m2!3d31.5052363!4d34.4613729!16s%2Fg%2F11qp21dw42?entry=ttu

[sleek lion]

heat-seeking bomb/projectile
heat seeking ground missiles are not common specifically for that reason, AGMs are going to be laser or optically guided to avoided general ground clutter

[gentle chasm]

It's not a question of a semantic ladder. The question is about claims being made that the building couldn't be destroyed by a single missile or a misfired rocket. Is there confirmation of the destruction of the building?

[ancient igloo]

OK so AJ mirrored the El Debate feed??

[full lion]

yeah

[weak dune]

MSF said that ceiling collapsed but we'll probably only see how powerful it was next morning

[ancient igloo]

Great, so everyone stop calling it the AJ feed.

[full lion]

Same feed different livery..

[sage urchin]

anyone has yet created a timeline of events ?

[eternal mural]

Wait wait. El Debate feed and AJ Mubasher feed are different, am I missing something here?

[ancient igloo]

Diario has only mirrored feeds to my knowledge

[idle cedar]

The El debate feed was mirrored from what I understand

[ancient igloo]

AJ never had a feed- they only mirror clips for news

[carmine cape]

https://twitter.com/GeoConfirmed/status/1714390254935851272

GeoConfirmed (@GeoConfirmed)

GeoConfirmed ISR-PAL.

A missile launched by Palestinian Groups exploded mid-air and one of the pieces fell on the Al-Ahli Arab Hospital's yard.

31.504822, 34.46169

Before reacting READ our thread.

https://t.co/qbpUGQk89o

1/X

Likes

1174

Retweets

645

▶ Play video

Twitter · Oct 17, 2023, 9:17 PM

[eternal mural]

But AJ Mubasher has a feed, which I can only assume is not public, that captured the rocket and the explosion.

[ancient igloo]

Does he admit the Mubasher feed came from the El Debate stream? If AJ has it's own public feed, none of us have found one the last 10 days

[carmine cape]

just woke up to this

[sleek lion]

was about to send the geoconfirmed link

[eternal mural]

The Mubasher feed that captured the explosion is completely different from the El Debate stream. It's in a different place, hence why El Debate feed doesn't capture the missile break up and the explosion, or does it?

[ancient igloo]

Well, I'd like to know and why not make it public? Even the El Debate went unmanned for many days due to the risk.

[eternal mural]

What was the timestamp again of the AJ livestream?

[eternal mural]

Oh god, wait, I have to see how to send a timestamped livestream

[azure lance]

I'm sorry but this is not a convincing thread. we have to be wary that just because you geolocate footage, you aren't answering key questions about the incident.

[ancient igloo]

If you can ask him if they have their own private camera or if they mirrored clips from El Debate/AFP which has been the last standing stream in Gaza to capture activity in the north.

[rare pelican]

You'll need to use inspect element to find the position and then append &6h23m2s or whatever duration from the start

[eternal mural]

???

[ancient igloo]

Please go off the original source of the video and not just off a mirrored clip on a news broadcast.

[eternal mural]

Easier than I thought. AJ Mubasher has a clock. Just go back to 15:59 / 18:59

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8D5QY5gw_Xk @eternal mural

[full lion]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wfAa1GiNdgM
The UN is speaking now

[eternal mural]

Yeah okay but what’s the timestamp?

7:20 right?

[eternal mural]

#1160893738973929493 message

[ancient igloo]

You have to determine the orginal source first

[eternal mural]

Sorry I’m a little tired but 18:59 then?

[full lion]

Yeah

Its off screen, I only noticed due to the fire. No noise from planes or anything. I've been listening to these livestreams for like 3 days

You can normally hear explosions, mortars etc

[eternal mural]

Oh yea thats what Jazeera says - what point is that in their stream though - do you know?

https://www.youtube.com/live/B7r_CrUCZ8o?si=Zq4mNUVe0cOXabEb&t=15388 here you see an explosion at 4:16

4:16:40 to be correct

[eternal mural]

Is there any chance to know at what time were these explosions?

[full lion]

Will get it in a second just listening to the UN speak on it

[eternal mural]

Neither of these 3 explosion seem to allign with the one that hit the hospital tho. The hospital one was preceded by a smaller explosion in the distance 1.5s before the impact. The 3 explosions here are separated by a handful of seconds longer

[fresh lance]

Was just going to comment that. The time difference between the second explosion at 4:16:43 is close to the time difference between the "intercept" and the first ground explosion in the other video.

But that could likely just be a coincidence

[jade sedge]

I'm stuck on how an intercepted or broken rocket could do much damage at all

[eternal mural]

By the way, now that you point this out, I think it's really important to know at exactly what time those explosions happened, because the IDF stated that they did not have planes flying at the time of the hospital explosion. So, if the IAF is not flying, what makes those explosions? Are we now looking at five misfired rockets? Is that believable?

[idle cedar]

Likewise

[full lion]

@eternal mural which side of the grain silo is the hospital?
left or right?

[eternal mural]

At this point, the only reasonable way a rocket would cause that boom is if it was completely misguided and headed full speed into the hospital. But we have a video of a rocket breaking up in the air before the explosion. So, I'm with you here.

[haughty nacelle]

Pretty easy, u just blow up all the other rockets waiting to launch

[ancient igloo]

As El Debate is now down, Diario ABC does seem to be continuing their feed as this is the view: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F49uYXqsbGg

(sorry, I'm waayyy behind in messages since 1 1/2 hours ago)

[bitter nacelle]

Why would they keep them above ground?

[idle cedar]

Yeah but that doesn't stop the missile from falling down and that's what are we discussing. How did an intercepted or broken rocket cause this much damage?

I'm tired so I might have misread/misunderstood your message

[jade sedge]

yeah, so I mean, a broken rocket still has some things that can burn or explode, so if it starts a fire, that can set off something bigger, right?

[eternal mural]

Around 7:20 IIRC

[eternal mural]

Twenty minutes after the hospital was hit, then

[vague seal]

the hospitals are running power off backup generators? there might be big fuel tanks somewhere

[eternal mural]

That was when the first public mentions were

[jade sedge]

yeah, and like...I don't know. They might have already taken a beating and closer to collapse

[eternal mural]

Public mentions of what? Of the hospital being hit?

[eternal mural]

Yep

The AJ Mubasher live stream captured the explosion at 18:59 and the geolocation seems convincing enough. Also the fact that both in the close up video and the AJ Mubasher stream you can see a smaller explosion 1.5 seconds before the impact on the hospital. I think it's safe to assume that 18:59 is the time of the strike.

[eternal mural]

Yes I do think that - the question is can we in here provide the corresponding timecode for the livestream video so I see what would have been visible from the camera?

[minor timber]

Q: I'm no expert in hospital design but hospitals are full of highly flammable material and might otherwise be stockpiling other flammable materials such as gasoline or diesel. Could that not contribute to the explosive yield?

[minor timber]

basically seconding this guy

[vague seal]

some diesel generators are “gravity fed” so they start if theres no power

that would imply they are on the roof/outside. a good photo in the day would be able to confirm that, and someone who knows more about generators

[eternal mural]

I think the issue here is that we don't have access to AJ Mubasher's feed of that camera. Which is why @ancient igloo question is relevant. What if the video of the explosion, that we can safely assume AJ Mubasher published first at 18:59, was shot by AJ Mubasher's cameras or if it was shot by someone else and published by AJM

[sleek lion]

iirc diesel doesnt catch fire easily

[tacit venture]

Would an oxygen tank or other gas that hospitals store be capable of this amount of destruction? If hit by shrapnel?

[full lion]

The hospital was tiny, it was a glorified mansion any missile would have flattened it:

[minor timber]

thats the whole hospital?

[eternal mural]

I think I found in El Debate's feed the moment of the missile mid air break-up that was recorded by AJ Mubasher

[minor timber]

like, just that?

[distant glacier]

no

[full lion]

Yeah according to google:
Their official website is here: https://afedj.org/institution/ahli-arab-hospital-gaza-city/

[eternal mural]

https://youtu.be/B7r_CrUCZ8o?t=14830

The quality is not good enough to see if there are two smaller explosions. Actually, it seems there's more, but it's really hard to see. You guys think that might be it?

[fresh lance]

It’s clear that there is no way that building could hold nearly a thousand as well.

[idle cedar]

Gotchya 🙂

[full lion]

They were outside, Its common place during this time:
here's there official statement on the matter:
https://afedj.org/crisis-at-ahli-arab-hospital-in-gaza-diocese-of-jerusalem-sounds-urgent-call-for-support/

[distant glacier]

another of the hospital buildings

it's a decently sized complex

[eternal mural]

Really?

[eternal mural]

#1160893738973929493 message Take a look, what do you think?

[full lion]

This is the other side of the building from the main website

[viscid magnet]

no, the initial report was that the lobby was bombed. not inside the hospital. afterwards you could see pacients being treated inside.

not sure how much more you have advanced in that conversation before I commented so maybe inconsistent now

[carmine cape]

https://afedj.org/rl_gallery/ahli-arab-hospital-gaza/

[minor timber]

what video are you talking about?

[carmine cape]

This would be the courtyard wouldnt it

[minor timber]

like where could you see the patients being treated afterwards

[wind swan]

Huh. https://twitter.com/emilyarielrose/status/1714406950241189986

Unclear if this is the prelude to IDF saying "Oh, maybe it was us... but we hit the parking lot, not the hospital."

[full lion]

strike Diario ABC 01:31

[fresh lance]

I agree with you. I was more just pointing out that whatever happened still has ambiguity. We don’t know how many people were outside, inside, etc so it’s really hard if not impossible to say X, Y, or Z weapon could or could not have done this.

[jade sedge]

What would that claim be, like “oh the hospital is ok?”

[eternal mural]

I think that if we stop and analyze for a second what's going on in the El Debate stream and we compare it with the AJM video we gather some interesting information.

1. As soon as the rocket breaks up in the air the camera pans down and on the far left we can see an explosion circa 7 seconds after the break up. This is consistent with AJ Mubasher's video, where the first explosion happens 7 seconds after the rockets break up and is followed 1.5-2 seconds after by the hospital explosion.

2. We don't see the second explosion (the one that in the AJM video shows the hospital being hit), but roughly 2.5 seconds after we can see two more explosions, followed by possibly a third explosion. So, more explosions in the background? Looking at the AJM video we can't tell, because as soon as the hospital is hit the camera zooms in.

[ancient igloo]

For the newly active people in this thread (hello!!) we have been using it to document airstrikes in Gaza via livestreams (mostly) so please try not to "clog" the thread with other also very important info. Do we need a new thread for the hospital which is an extremely important topic. <@&941484701632307232>

[rare pelican]

I think so

We aren't able to track strikes here because of the traffic

[minor timber]

Seems prudent.

[viscid magnet]

not a video. this was a report on telegram. now what I see on IG is videos of how that place used to look like (theres a video of children playing), and another video of the aftereffect right after the bomb hit and the air was dusty. ||dead people everywhere||

[full lion]

strike Dario 01:55

[gloomy leaf]

I don't think so, further news about it can go in #1160132507472244839 , discussion in #israel-palestine .

[full lion]

I didn't mean to reply 😅

[ancient igloo]

another strike 0134 Diario ABC

[full lion]

they're back to plane strikes

[ancient igloo]

0155?

[rare pelican]

All good

[full lion]

Ignore me.. you are correct

[rare pelican]

Sorry about the weird reacts

[ancient igloo]

Please continue! 🙂

Did we lose audio?

[full lion]

I lost both sound and visual

[ancient igloo]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T-JfZ1ltfJs

Al-Shifa

[full lion]

Yeah its at least got sound

[ancient igloo]

I guess everyone can come back j/k 🤦🏽

[full lion]

01:56 strike Marca[faintly guided by the sound of jets]

02:08 strike Marca[faint]

02:08 strike Marca

[ancient igloo]

0213 strike Marca [faint]

0215 strike Marca [faint]

another

others hear this?

0216 strike Marca [faint]

I don't want to mistake the sound

(since going off audio only)

0217 strike Marca [faint]

At least someone can go back and check

I may stop noting unless it's more clear.

0226 strike Marca

0229 strike Marca

0238 strike Marca

[warm inlet]

From my recollection, at a certain size you generally have an oxygen plant, not massive oxygen tanks (air is 20% oxygen, it's not that hard to make it from air), which I think would impose an upper cap on the amount of oxygen stored in the facility

Forbes reported here > https://www.forbes.com/sites/siladityaray/2023/10/17/un-body-warns-hospitals-have-24-hours-of-fuel-as-israeli-airstrikes-hit-southern-gaza/?sh=7292054944f2 that hospitals have 24 hours of fuel for diesel generators remaining, which isn't nothing but probably doesn't mean a ton of diesel stored onsite relative to normal times.

[rare pelican]

How are my fellow strike watchers doing

[ancient igloo]

fried but at least I finally ate

[full lion]

Its nice and quiet now

[ancient igloo]

relying only on audio from MARCA's hospital stream for strikes so idk how accurate my notes are above. (faint are maybes- for me)

[warm inlet]

This site (https://afedj.org/institution/ahli-arab-hospital-gaza-city/) says the hospital spend $1,800 a day on diesel fuel to run their generators for 20 hours a day. Retail diesel in Cyprus is $1.82 / liter according to a quick search, so as a rough proxy they probably have 1,200 liters / 300 gallons or so of diesel fuel on site at the time of the explosion. Back of the envelope math but should be ballpark. That's a tank that would fit your average 6 foot tall man comfortably but probably not allow him to take a step; not exactly mass explosion material.

I figure cyprus doesn't subsidize diesel, does have EU taxes on it, but is way cheaper to get things in / out of and is otherwise nearby, so is probably a good proxy for Gaza prices 🤷‍♂️

[ancient igloo]

Oeste, you should link your valuable comments in the October 2023 War main thread since they switched the conversation there to clear room for airstrike monitoring.

[full lion]

03:26 strike Marca

03:26 strike Marca

Everytime I'm like its gonna be a quiet night 💥

03:33 strike[faint]Marca

03:38 strike Marca

03:44 strike Marca

03:47 strike Marca

[ancient igloo]

Notice they are not showing where they place the|| dead|| bodies to the right of the MARCA stream we are monitoring.

[steep grail]

This is such an irresponsible thread

[full lion]

anything related to the incident can be discussed here:https://discord.com/channels/709752884257882135/1047898195155492895
Everything related to monitoring the strikes is to be placed here purely to keep the threads clear

[steep grail]

Oops sorry

[full lion]

I dread to think how full the morgues are

[ancient igloo]

That must be where they also try to identify people.

[ancient igloo]

@wind swan

[full lion]

03:57 strike Marca

I think this is the first time we've had people in the shot of the strikes[they look up see the strike and then look down very surreal]

[feral stump]

@full lion are you getting this from a stream? Sorry I'm so late.

[full lion]

04:01 strike x4 Marca

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T-JfZ1ltfJs

[feral stump]

Thanks

[full lion]

via sound as there is none direct from Gaza

[feral stump]

Faint hit 4:06 Marca

Another

[full lion]

YUP another note any time not specified is assumed as Israeli/Gaza time

[feral stump]

I'll listen for maybe an hour or so, I'll report in Gaza time. Thanks for the heads up.

Sounded like a clap or something.

Something dropped near the mic or something.

[full lion]

Yeah I've deleted it

[feral stump]

Gunfire with that high of a frequency means it would have been closeby, people would have reacted, and it probably would have clipped the mic.

Strike 4:12 gaza time, Marca

Faint airstrikes or wind, can't tell, 4:21 marca. Sounded like several in a row.

[modest trout]

It sounded like wind to me.

[feral stump]

BTW if it wasn't mentioned before or is somehow lost, Marca stream is referring to the Hospital Al-Shifa

[modest trout]

Are any other streams left from or toward the Strip?

besides the above mentioned hospital

[full lion]

AFAIK no

[ancient igloo]

Not that we know of yet. I just checked the main ones El Debate, Reuters, any other MARCA ones and the Diario ABC that was streaming the El Debate view but none. In a bit I will go down the Google doc to check for undiscovered streams. Any help is appreciated if you have the time!

[late basin]

there's a google doc?

oh found it, ty

[ancient igloo]

yeah, check the pinned posts

[feral stump]

(Sorry if it's the wrong spot, just want to confirm)

Artical from 6 days ago: https://www.972mag.com/shifa-hospital-director-gaza-emergency/

Attached is a photo from the headline and a screenshot from the stream. Just if there's any doubt if it's the correct location.

This appears to be the location: https://www.google.com/maps/place/Shifa+Hospital/@31.5243672,34.4411921,17.58z/data=!4m6!3m5!1s0x14fd7f1796eeeae9:0xe276215cf67a84a1!8m2!3d31.5243672!4d34.4428571!16s%2Fm%2F05c22yp?entry=ttu

That's where Marca strikes are being reported from.

[ancient igloo]

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1F8xjXKp2YhXpf8sKMEtgD7wmABpJNUPSq2crPKzQ_0Y/edit#gid=1646469794

[feral stump]

Crux doesn't seem to be mentioned on the spreadsheet. ~~https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xXie9CeKwY8~~ I don't know if it's "live" live. (EDIT: appears not to be, lots of cuts)

But lots seems to be happening on it.

No, it doesn't seem to be live,

[full lion]

Yeah its a for "clicks" livestream

[ancient igloo]

Yeah, I think I left it off for that reason

[feral stump]

Ah yeah just cut to a completely different video clip, my bad.

[ancient igloo]

more people all of a sudden on MARCA

[full lion]

seemed like an argument broke out

[modest trout]

I heard an explosion at around 4:30

[full lion]

Did we ever discover where the Al jazeera streams is from? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eksOMqVMINo

[ancient igloo]

idk I thought it was the El Debate stream but couldn't keep up

[feral stump]

can someone translate this?

I'm guessing that's the name of where the al-jazeera stream is.

[cyan star]

Google translate says

"messenger - Gaza"

Edit: I mean "Live - Gaza"

[ancient igloo]

Are these actually 6 live livestreams?

[feral stump]

Mine says "Live Gaza"

[broken roost]

copost b/c may be important for strike data purposes #israel-palestine message https://vxtwitter.com/ReneDuba/status/1714451982323269744

[ancient igloo]

They have the MARCA stream in one window.

[feral stump]

Yes

Sec

[cyan star]

Yeah, my google translate was in ukrainian mode but I thought it auto switched since it could get "gaza", wierd...

[ancient igloo]

They don't have a channel on You Tube for any of those streams and don't attribute who is streaming each window.

[full lion]

I don't know I think the top left is down the street from Marca as I saw the ambulances on there before Marca

[feral stump]

Top left: "A while ago, several Turkish cities"
Top middle: "Live - Al Shifa Hospital / Gaza"
Top right: "Live - Gaza"
Bottom left: "A while ago - Tangier/Morocco"
Bottom middle: "Live - Washington"
Bottom right: "Live - Ottawa Canada"

for reference. The top right stream seems to be their main one they switch back to and where the audio is, seems to be a live stream from Gaza

[full lion]

Yeah I saw a missile/flare from them earlier

[ancient igloo]

Okay, that went to a big screen just now when I checked again

Then we should def watch that. I wish they had that alone in its own channel.

[full lion]

I think it can be useful but not consistent

[feral stump]

The audio is at least only the main stream, which helps.

[ancient igloo]

At least with the news channel الميادين مباشر they put a red mark showing it is actually live

[feral stump]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IcPPJqKsTR8 might have some interesting ones.

[ancient igloo]

ty for translating btw

[feral stump]

Strike 4:45, Al-jazeera

Really wishing I could pan youtube right now, one L and one R...

[modest trout]

No kidding

[ancient igloo]

all of these are CCTV in Israel at the moment

[feral stump]

https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/soundfixer/ this works.

[ancient igloo]

That's the first Hebron stream I've seen. Dunno where the beach one labeled Gaza is.

[feral stump]

Strike 4:49 Al-Jazeera

[full lion]

Ah yes prayer time[time for the Israeli morning bombing(I wish I joking)]

[feral stump]

Strike Al-Jazeera 4:52

Marca as well

Another one

And a third

A fourth

Al-Jazeera

Strike Marca 4:53

Strike Al-Jazeera 4:53

Another

Another (2nd)

Distant strike, both Marca and Al-Jazeera 4:54

A large strike, Al-Jazeera, 4:54

Another, Al-Jazeera 4:55

Marca + Al-Jazeera, multiple distant strikes (sounds like many) 4:55 - might be wind*

Al-Jazeera sound stream has switched to another feed of a press conference 😦 4:57 local time

[full lion]

Yeah

[feral stump]

"A while ago - Kuweit" is the name of the stream

Strike Marca 4:58 - several, maybe 3 or 4

More.

Also btw the panning extension really works if you're working with two streams. Now if they just had an EQ so I can isolate the lower frequencies. 😫

[signal raft]

Morning Toastie. Holmes, don't forget to take a break.

[feral stump]

Morning! And yes people please take breaks. Take it from someone who got burnt out from the Ukraine war footage, it's not fun.

[full lion]

yeah I am going to sleep soon[ Normally they calm down when the morning prayer are over]

[modest trout]

I second this.

[feral stump]

Al-Jazeera seems to have audio stream back on the Gaza feed for a moment but has a commentator on it now.

It's 4am in Germany now and I need to go to bed soon, so if I go silent don't assume there aren't strikes happening. Not sure if this is even helping anyone but best of luck tracking this stuff. ❤️

[cyan star]

sleep > strike tracking

[feral stump]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T-JfZ1ltfJs and https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eksOMqVMINo are the two streams I've been watching since the first was mentioned, I'm using Firefox + https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/soundfixer/ to pan them each to a single ear to be able to differentiate which stream they came from, if anyone wants to try it. Seems to work well. Al-Jazeera has had better audio and more activity when they actually focus on the Gaza stream. The hospital stream is cruddy but consistent.

Night everyone ❤️

[modest trout]

Sleep well

Are we going to see a surge in ambulances as a result of the strikes about 20 min ago?

[full lion]

That is sometime how it goes

[onyx timber]

Director of Alahli Baptist Hospital is claiming the hospital was warned with 2 bombs the day prior and were asked to evacuate.

warning: corpses
||https://vxtwitter.com/ShaykhSulaiman/status/1714429165502361942||

[full lion]

Do you happen to know the local time?

[signal raft]

Please spoiler the link

[severe sapphire]

If you need help spoilering let me know but this needs spoilers and a warning that there are corpses

[feral stump]

(/spoiler <message> is now a standard Discord slash command by the way, spoilering inline is kind of a PITA to remember, maybe that helps)

[full lion]

strike 05:22 Marca

[ancient igloo]

I'm turning the volume off for now

(audio break)

[severe sapphire]

Gaza Airstrike Timestamps October 2023

Hopefully the title change will help explain the purpose better

[full lion]

Israel respected a prayer time for once[On that note I am off to bed] 🛌

[modest trout]

Sleep well

For those just tuning in, the MARKA stream is focused on the Al-Shifa Hospital emergency entrance. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T-JfZ1ltfJs&ab_channel=MARCA

Aljazeera Mubasher has a video grid. The upper right frame is the Gaza skyline. This feed frequently cuts away to other videos/coverage. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eksOMqVMINo&ab_channel=AlJazeeraMubasher

[late basin]

https://twitter.com/Justin_Br0nk/status/1714352303082271215

this guy is Senior Research Fellow for Airpower and Military Technology at RUSI, London. Professor II at the Royal Norwegian Air Force Academy. Pilot. Views are my own.

[severe sapphire]

Hey, we're discussing the strike here #israel-palestine

[late basin]

when i posted there i was directed here lol

[modest trout]

Things are getting sorted out as we go.

[severe sapphire]

This channel is just for timestamps of strikes as people watch live streams 🙂 sorry about the confusion!

[modest trout]

MARCA isn't live for me anymore. Anyone else?

[ancient igloo]

nope

Gaza skyline 0628

This will be our only stream in Gaza until we find another.

This indeed looks significantly north of where the El Debate camera was.

More northeast if I am right

I wish they didn't take up 1/3 of the screen with their messaging.

There is another hospital stream up.

[ancient igloo]

Looks like the AJ straem is broadcasting from the Sderot view now

okay, found two streams of Gaza that look like they might be live

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UtruJztXE5w

Full cam Gaza: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dmVwH6UhZP8

[ancient igloo]

3 strikes out of view 0751 Agenda Free TV

strike 0753 AFTV

0754 AFTV

Current Gaza skyline (or what you can make out) as viewed from Sderot

0803 strike AFTV

[modest trout]

Does anyone know the location that this is filmed from?

[ancient igloo]

Sderot

[ancient igloo]

Meant to include these in the set as well:

(should be from a pan left to right)

[rare pelican]

This kinda looks like the view from yesterday evening before the sun went down

[ancient igloo]

I hope it's not a replay. I did have to search a bunch. I did see both at different times on Arabian news so please post if it is indeed old.

[rare pelican]

I don't think it is!

Area just looks familiar

[ancient igloo]

ok good- & yeah, esp that Sderot view

[cyan star]

Always saddening to get used to places because of such situations

[rare pelican]

Indeed

[modest trout]

I'm having trouble figuring out the POV does anyone have that?

[ancient igloo]

NE from Gaza City

outside of Gaza

I think the cam is right by a road because I have heard cars drive by before

[modest trout]

They just took the camera off of the tripod and panned around. It looks like they are set up under a power transmission line.

[ancient igloo]

Strike 0839 AFTV

Strike 0842 AFTV

[modest trout]

08:46 small arms fire

08:46 and a big strike

[ancient igloo]

I can't track anymore at the moment.

[modest trout]

Rest. We will need you later.

[eternal mural]

Rest 🫂

[modest trout]

More Small arms fire on Agenda free at 09:20

Heard an explosion, but couldn't see it at 09:25

Another at 09:29

Big one at 9:32

Then another right after that maybe

I feel like signing off. Is there anyone who is willing to fill in?

[signal raft]

I'm slowly coming alive and will take over

[topaz nimbus]

will be off today unfortunately, got work and just looking at the hospital thing has totally drained me today...

[stuck plume]

Try to take it easy seannie4!

[signal raft]

biden stepping out btw

1113

big boom

[signal raft]

im afk a bit

[silent ridge]

Explosion at 1:51

[sick mirage]

Someone posted a video of 10 minutes around 19:59

(0:19) hospital.
(0:16, 4:25, 4:49) behind and to the left of the hospital.
(5:33, 5:56, 9:26, 10:46) behind hospital, most likely the same place.
(9:38, 10:51) to the right of the hospital outside of the frame, likely the same place.```
https://twitter.com/GrantSmithEllis/status/1714399186295111815?t=yO3_kNgOdM2ZiZy33ujn5Q&s=19

[sleek lion]

yup, correct ID

[gloomy leaf]

You can post this in #1160132507472244839

[novel basin]

I've so far downloaded about 16GB and 50 hours of streams:
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1_TfAOF4VPWA4IVf9AB-BMgi4tfOAJTm4pzR_nJrR4ss/edit?usp=sharing
I'm monitoring the Reuters, El Debate, and MARCA youtube channels for lives. If there are any others that you think are important to back up, please message me or comment on the google sheet. (speaking of, should the "Agenda Free TV" stream be backed up? Is it not just a mirror of Reuters / AP?)

[silent ridge]

as far as I understood, it's a mirror of Reuters yes

[novel basin]

Oh, if anyone wants to help download, please put your username next to the videos you're downloading so we don't duplicate efforts.

[full lion]

15:08 strike Reuters[Gaza]

15:08 strike Reuters[Israel frontline]

15:08 strike Reuters[Israel frontline]

15:08 strike Reuters[Israel frontline]

[full lion]

Agenda free I think is a mirror of reuters

~15:19 strike reuters

~15:27 strike reuters Gaza

~15:30 strike reuters Gaza

reuters went dark

[silent ridge]

its back up again

[full lion]

el debate is now protests somewhere[occupied West bank?] Or lebanon based on the one Hezbollah flag I see[Correction Beirut by the title]

El debate is back at Gaza rooftops

[full lion]

16:08 Gun battle Reuters

16:10 Strike Reuters

[silent ridge]

16:14 Strike Reuters

[full lion]

16:24 strike Reuters

[signal raft]

Don't forget the screenshots, folks

[full lion]

Sometimes you don't see it I can just hear the impact

[silent ridge]

this was the 1614 one

[silent ridge]

16:48 strike Reuters [gaza]

16:54 strike Reuters

17:01 reuters

gonna be afk for now

[rare pelican]

which streams are up right now?

[full lion]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I7ndAVSqhC0 [reuters]

18:00 strike reuters

[rare pelican]

Thanks @full lion

[full lion]

18:05 strike reuters

18:15 Strike Reuters

18:16 strike Reuters

[ancient igloo]

Hello all, looks like our two streams inside Gaza right now are from El Debate (facing the north) and MARCA on Khan Younis' Al-Shifa Hospital.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ABnP_BlPOwA

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tw2ePejAOR0

[ancient igloo]

Is this stream online?

[full lion]

I think It dropped there's a journalist for Wired around that I asked if he had any contacts at the AP/AFP so we can consistent footage[Setup a camera for a couple of hours and stay safe]

[eternal mural]

@ancient igloo PLMK if any expired links in pins need pruning.

[full lion]

I'll get you some screenshots for Beirut in a second

[full lion]

El debate is back [currently watching the UN speak]

[ancient igloo]

You probably shouldn't make the document publicly editable.

[full lion]

19:30 missile Reuters

Missile or flare I don't know all I know is it went upwards

[ancient igloo]

Top links updated in the spreadsheet. We have MARCA on Al-Shifa, El Debate on northern Gaza, 2 Reuters with the same view on northern Gaza

[full lion]

19:37 strike Reuters

[ancient igloo]

updated vidgrid: https://vidgrid.tk.gg/?config=eyJzdGF0ZSI6eyJ2aWRlb3MiOlt7ImlkIjowLCJ1cmwiOiJSZXV0ZXJzXHRodHRwczovL3d3dy55b3V0dWJlLmNvbS93YXRjaD92PUozOTM1Tm96eTJRIiwic3RyZWFtRGF0YSI6eyJ2aWRlbyI6IlJldXRlcnNcdGh0dHBzOi8vd3d3LnlvdXR1YmUuY29tL3dhdGNoP3Y9SjM5MzVOb3p5MlEifSwiY2FwdGlvbnMiOiIiLCJpbmRleCI6MH0seyJpZCI6MSwidXJsIjoiaHR0cHM6Ly93d3cueW91dHViZS5jb20vd2F0Y2g%2Fdj1la3NPTXFWTUlObyIsInN0cmVhbURhdGEiOnsidmlkZW8iOiJodHRwczovL3d3dy55b3V0dWJlLmNvbS93YXRjaD92PWVrc09NcVZNSU5vIn0sImNhcHRpb25zIjoiIiwiaW5kZXgiOjF9LHsiaWQiOjIsInVybCI6Imh0dHBzOi8vd3d3LnlvdXR1YmUuY29tL3dhdGNoP3Y9QUJuUF9CbFBPd0EiLCJzdHJlYW1EYXRhIjp7InZpZGVvIjoiaHR0cHM6Ly93d3cueW91dHViZS5jb20vd2F0Y2g%2Fdj1BQm5QX0JsUE93QSJ9LCJjYXB0aW9ucyI6IiIsImluZGV4IjoyfSx7ImlkIjozLCJ1cmwiOiJodHRwczovL3d3dy55b3V0dWJlLmNvbS93YXRjaD92PXR3MmVQZWpBT1IwIiwic3RyZWFtRGF0YSI6eyJ2aWRlbyI6Imh0dHBzOi8vd3d3LnlvdXR1YmUuY29tL3dhdGNoP3Y9dHcyZVBlakFPUjAifSwiY2FwdGlvbnMiOiIiLCJpbmRleCI6M30seyJpZCI6NCwidXJsIjoiaHR0cHM6Ly9uZXdzb3VyY2UtbGl2ZS53YXJuZXJtZWRpYWNkbi5jb20vaGxzL2xpdmUvMjAwNTQ1MS9pbnRsMDIvbWFzdGVyLm0zdTgiLCJzdHJlYW1EYXRhIjp7InZpZGVvIjoiaHR0cHM6Ly9uZXdzb3VyY2UtbGl2ZS53YXJuZXJtZWRpYWNkbi5jb20vaGxzL2xpdmUvMjAwNTQ1MS9pbnRsMDIvbWFzdGVyLm0zdTgifSwiY2FwdGlvbnMiOiIiLCJpbmRleCI6NH0seyJpZCI6NSwidXJsIjoiaHR0cHM6Ly93d3cueW91dHViZS5jb20vd2F0Y2g%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%3D

[ancient igloo]

Excellent work! Would you like this pinned to the thread? I am working on downloading MARCA streams.

[full lion]

20:24 strike Reuters

20:28 strike reuters

20:29 strike reuters

20:31 strike reuters

20:35 strike reuters

20:41 strike reuters

20:44 strike reuters

20:47 strike reuters

[novel basin]

Sure!

And thanks! 😇

[full lion]

21:00 strike reuters

21:01 strike reuters

[full lion]

21:20 strike reuters

21:24 strike reuters[its interesting that we are back to planes again..]

21:29 strike reuters in reply to an early mortar by Hamas 21:27

21:33 strike reuters

21:34 strike reuters in retaliation to the above

[rare pelican]

Here's an image of one of these not sure which

[full lion]

what stream is that?

[rare pelican]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JgLZx9Obics

[full lion]

21:36 strike Gaza

[rare pelican]

the retuers one, I've seen several big flashes since I started watching

they just changed cams @full lion

[full lion]

Okay cool just as I hear them on el debate and there are two reuters streams

[rare pelican]

okay, well the stream I linked above changed cams without warning so I just want anyone going back through this to be aware

[full lion]

The two reuters streams are showing the same image..

[rare pelican]

The stream above changed at 2 Hours 28 Minutes ~3 Seconds into stream

[full lion]

21:39 strike el debate

[full lion]

21:58 strike el debate

22:02 strike el debate

22:03 strike el debate

22:06 flare/missile reuters

22:07 strike el debate

[ancient igloo]

@eternal mural We are wondering if you can pin this Google sheet.

[full lion]

22:08 strike el debate

[rare pelican]

if we get in a situation where we want to link to specific timestamp of a stream, you can run this in your developer console #tools-and-sites message

[full lion]

22:09 strike el debate

22:09 strike el debate

[eternal mural]

[full lion]

22:13 strike el debate

22:14 strike el debate

[rare pelican]

hoping we don't but still better to have this option than not

[full lion]

Youtube only allows the clip feature on certain things.. smh

[rare pelican]

it's unfortunate too. would be nice if you could use yt-dlp to start and stop at a specific spot in stream but afaik you can't

you have to record all the way to the point you want to stop and then clip from where you want to start

[full lion]

I genuinely though Kick.com might have a google stream of Gaza

22:33 strike Reuters

[viscid magnet]

Bombardemnts taking place in areas around PRCS Al Quds Hospital ||https://www.instagram.com/reel/CyjSfluNXVh/?igshid=MzRlODBiNWFlZA==|| that was uploaded around 30min ago

palestineredcrescent

🚨Huge bombardments are taking place in the areas around #PRCS Al Quds #Hospital in #Gaza city- which is sustaining damages and shrapnels inside the buildings of PRCS, and constituting high threat- noting that more than 8000 IDPs are taking refuge at PRCS.
#NotATarget
#WarCrimes

Likes

559

Instagram

[full lion]

local time?

[viscid magnet]

It was uploaded on IG 42min ago

[full lion]

I saw that image on Al Jazeera[I think we have sound recognition of the strike rather than visual]

[viscid magnet]

Also here ||https://instagram.com/stories/saleemaburass/3216509701788641527?utm_source=ig_story_item_share&igshid=MTc4MmM1YmI2Ng==|| the next story after that one. Don't know if it's the same strike or another one

These are huge ones

Both shared on the Palestine red crescent IG account

[full lion]

Again likely to have notification of the blast but not visual

[viscid magnet]

Ok sorry so you mean I should not share the link ?

[full lion]

No I mean we'll have a notification of the blast I just doubt it will be able to visually geolocate it

[viscid magnet]

Ok

[full lion]

Given that gaza is currently this:

23:33 sirens Reuters

[viscid magnet]

Yes also it was posted longer ago on another account by a journalist

[rare pelican]

was reuters replaying something

this is what their stream looked like a few seconds ago

looks like they were just mirroring another stream

[full lion]

oddly quiet night it sounds like

I spoke too soon cluster strike el debate 24:29

00:29 Flare in response El debate

00:29 Fire El debate

[full lion]

Landed flare

[ancient igloo]

@full lion Did you see the cluster of smaller white lights that came right before the flare?

[full lion]

Yeah i thought that was the "cluster" strike and then the flare came after

The flashing white lights are the lights of the buildings in Israel

[ancient igloo]

No, I'm talking about the cluster that fell from the sky just seconds before the flare? They looked like the white lights of white phosphorus.

oh my bad, just saw your first sentence

[full lion]

Oh I thought that was just regular munitions I'll see if I can get a screenshot to confirm

[ancient igloo]

Were the cluster strikes very powerful?

I did not have audio on fwiw

[full lion]

They were three in a row and not overly powerful

[ancient igloo]

ah ok

[full lion]

Re:cluster strike[not cluster munitions]

If I had to guess the rhythm was flare munition flare which makes me think that more modern techniques are proving in effectual

00:45 LARGE strike El debate

strike site just behind the large building

[ancient igloo]

So Debate is the only livestream in Gaza right now, huh?

[full lion]

I think the reuters stream is being used for a broadcast but yes only broadcast

Dario is mirroring el Debate

[full lion]

01:28 strike El debate

01:28 strike El debate

01:29 strike El debate

01:31 strike El debate

01:31 strike El debate

[all the above sound like artillery]

01:32 artillery El debate
01:32 artillery El debate

[ancient igloo]

Did you happen to go back and look at this screen? I did not mistake something falling from the sky for building lights. I saw thinner streaks of smoke trailing the lights which fell in an arc across the sky.

It fell slowly-ish but still I did not have time to screencap it

[full lion]

yeah just below you last message @22:36

[ancient igloo]

and then the flare came down a few seconds after

[full lion]

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/1160893738973929493/1164316661185265724/image.png?ex=6542c563&is=65305063&hm=128fc4f72514220dbc277ac01ba3e0795480c0278b708da478c284865b471987&

[ancient igloo]

ok but that screenshot is not what I saw nor what it looked like

In that screenshot, the "cluster" is falling from an arc in the opposite direction from what I saw and the lights were white not orangeish

Is it not there for you?

[carmine cape]

I've got some time this evening, what streams are not being watched?

[full lion]

I think it was glitch

[ancient igloo]

I think only El Debate is up at the moment.

[carmine cape]

right, thats the one I have on another tab

heard a thud just now

[full lion]

I can just see the dust cloud:

[carmine cape]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IcPPJqKsTR8 is this livestream any good? How can I tell if the livestream is actually live?

[ancient igloo]

There are a few different ways to tell if a livestream is actually live. First, if it has a chat, it will give you the option to hide the chat (live) or hide the chat reply (not live) but that won't work alone if it is a multistream. That's also not an accurate determinating factor if a channel rebroadcasts "live" and old stream.

Try looking for the red line that runs across the bottom of the screen (progression bar) and/or a red dot and or a red "live" mini rectangular indicator. These are good signs it is live, but not in every single case.

Check to see if there is an end amount of time on the video before you press start or when you press pause. If so, it's probably not live.

[full lion]

If it happens to be over visual[there are the occasional visual strike] but on the whole they are just a sound and explosion.anything else is probably reused footage

[ancient igloo]

Yeah, if you see spectacular strikes and explosions every 5 seconds, it's probably not live.

If it's a multistream, you can check each mirrored cam with the original source.

This multistream has its sound on the Tel Aviv cam. Are you sure you heard it from this stream?

[carmine cape]

I see, thanks for the correction will delete

[full lion]

02:09 airstrike El Debate

[ancient igloo]

If you have multiple streams open in multiple tabs, check each video and also check each tab. You can mute individual videos and also individual tabs.

[full lion]

I avoid multi streams and typically just listen to one

[carmine cape]

oh reuters has two lives streams

[ancient igloo]

Are they both live and are they both the same?

[carmine cape]

theyre not online

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xXie9CeKwY8 lots of booms on this one, don't know if its live or not

but heard multiple consecutive booms in a row

[ancient igloo]

I wouldn't waste your time looking at that channel.

Now is your chance to try to determine if it is live. You tell us!

[carmine cape]

oh the pressure

[ancient igloo]

😉

[carmine cape]

definitely not live

[ancient igloo]

w/o looking, I agree w/you

[carmine cape]

this livestream is literally just arma 3 footage

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qBTD01l_-eA

[full lion]

Evidence of a strike? But I didn't hear anything its like dust in the light of the mosque

02:35 strike el debate

02:39 strike el debate

02:39 strike el debate

02:44 strike el debate

02:49 strike el debate

02:53 strike el debate

02:55 strike el debate

02:56 strike el debate

02:59 strike el debate

03:00 strike el debate

03:00 strike el debate

03:01 strike el debate

03:01 strike el debate

03:01 strike el debate

03:01 strike el debate

03:03 strike el debate

03:03 strike el debate

03:03 strike el debate

03:03 strike el debate

03:03 strike el debate

03:03 flare el debate

03:03 strike el debate

03:05 strike el debate

03:05 strike el debate

03:05 shouting el debate [Potentially battle noise]

El debate is down

[ancient igloo]

oh no

[full lion]

its back and the camera is unmanned which is nice

03:13 strike el debate

03:14 strike el debate

03:14 strike el debate

03:18 strike el debate

03:18 strike el debate

[ancient igloo]

7 strikes, El Debate 0338

[full lion]

Off to sleep 🛌

[ancient igloo]

Enjoy your rest

ty for the monitoring!

0342 strike, El Debate

0355 strike, El Debate

0355 strike, El Debate

(sirens)

0401 strike, El Debate

0402 strike, El Debate

0403 strike, El Debate

0404 strike, El Debate

(sirens)

0413 strike, El Debate

0413 strike, El Debate

0418 strike, El Debate

(rooster crowing)

El Debate down

j/k back up!

0427 strike, El Debate

0428 2 strikes, El Debate (may have been return rockets)

[rare pelican]

Not gonna do any monitoring tonight just gonna read and get some space

[ancient igloo]

enjoy

0431 strike, El Debate (very large)

0433 two return rockets, El Debate

0438 strike, El Debate

0439 strike, El Debate (VERY large)

0442 return rocket, El Debate

0443 return rocket, El Debate

0444 strike, El Debate

0446 return rocket, El Debate

0450 return rocket, El Debate

(I might have missed a faint one in between these two.)

0452 strike, El Debate

0453 strike, El Debate

0454 return rocket, El Debate

0456 return rocket, El Debate

0459 return rocket, El Debate

0500 return rocket, El Debate

0502 strike, El Debate

0503 return rocket El Debate

Feel free to jump in here, anyone

Gaza skyline right now 0505

0507 return rocket, El Debate

0511 return rocket, El Debate

0511 return rocket, El Debate

[silk rune]

el debate, ~0517 local

[ancient igloo]

0517 strike, El Debate

[ancient igloo]

That was the first I've seen since monitoring right now.

[silk rune]

oh wow

so the rest are based on sound?

[ancient igloo]

all so far for me

yeah

They must have been bombing out of camera range.

call to prayer

[ancient igloo]

(or far behind the smoke up north)

The smoke is pretty thick- I can only see two small light blobs on the left at Ashkelon.

0522 two return rockets, El Debate

[ancient igloo]

Let me know if you disagree w/something I write (re: strikes, return rockets)

[silk rune]

sounds good

[rare pelican]

Sorry to interrupt but I can't confirm this but this looks like it looks like this would have been posted around the same time and I think it's likely the same strike if the video is real 1https://vxtwitter.com/ytirawi/status/1714703569742422201

[silk rune]

ill take your word for it on these though, im having a lot of trouble making out distinct sounds in the stream (might be my internet connection?)

[ancient igloo]

0524 two return rockets, El Debate

like this one I'm not 100%

[silk rune]

el debate, ~0523 (very faint, top right of screen in the sky)

[ancient igloo]

nice catch

[ancient igloo]

This could have been one of each.

0526 strike, El Debate

The further away they are the harder to tell/distinguish (of course)

0528 strike, El Debate

[modest trout]

This camera belongs in a museum some day.

[ancient igloo]

0540 two strikes, El Debate

(I think I'm missing some here.)

0551 strike, El Debate

[silk rune]

something? el debate, ~0553 local

[silk rune]

a clip

[modest trout]

I didn't know what to make of that. it wasn't just a flash.

[silk rune]

starting to hear the rooster now. i find him oddly comforting lol

[modest trout]

I love the rooster.

Was the area in the distance just right of center lit in white light in previous nights?

[ancient igloo]

yes, all nights. idk what it is

Gaza skyline 0618

[silk rune]

alright im heading off

[ancient igloo]

thanks for the screenshots & stuff

[ancient igloo]

(sirens)

0724 strike, El Debate

(faint)

0727 strike, El Debate

0728 strike, El Debate

Do others hear these?

[modest trout]

I hear more than I can keep up with.

[ancient igloo]

(sirens)

I hate to over estimate but also a lot go unreported.

[modest trout]

Oh, I thought the sirens are outside my windows.

I've changed my mind about where I think the El Debate stream is filmed from. It's not far from where I originally thought, but I feel that I should correct myself, because I was wrong.
I now think it is here: 31.524424°, 34.436871° I can add some imagery with notations to back it up, but I don’t want to clutter this space more than I already have.

[ancient igloo]

0740 two strikes, El Debate

[ancient igloo]

0817 two strikes, El Debate

0823 strike, El Debate

0823 strike, El Debate

0824 strike, El Debate

0823 strike, El Debate

0825 strike, El Debate

0825 strike, El Debate

(I'm not sure if some of these last few are return rockets or not)

(sirens)

0832 two strikes, El Debate

(may have missed some before that- I stepped away)