UNABLE TO SELL PLAYERS FOR GOOD VALUE - EVEN FOR IN FORM PLAYERS AND NOT MANY OFFERS COMING🤞🏼

[smoky briar]

Our players in form and having high potential are not able to be sold for any good price. In simple throughout 4 or 5 season I played I haven't got any offer for any players except may be 1 or 2 that too for base value. I sold to buy players only after transfer listing them for there less than base price or very less even for inform players like half the price. So, unable to buy many new players for the new tactics or system building. Which is highly frustrating. Kindly rectify the transfer issue. Even in my manager trait I have unlocked slightly higher fees of selling players and other related traits unlocked still players are sold for very undervalued

I HAD ATTACHED MY 5 SEASONS OF MOST IMPORTANT TRANSFERS - ALL ARE TRANSFER LISTING ONLY AND YOU CAN SEE THERE VALUE AND FEE RECEIVED : WHICH IS VERY LESS IN MOST CASES

[tall matrix]

We're aware of this and it's actively being looked into 🙂

[smoky briar]

Thank you

[lunar solstice]

After 3.1.6 beta update my transfer listed players (first team good players and reserve team players too) aren't still attracting any bids...maybe 1/2 buds in a month!! Wherein there was 2/3 bids everyday before!

[lunar solstice]

@tall matrix bug reported before too...and I had to spend my valuable golds and money tokens to get my team's finance going, but, it's been 2 waves I can't progress like that...if I want to progress with even the first season, Either I won't be able to buy players or go bankrupt or spend all the golds and kills the fun of the game like that

[smoky briar]

Yeah same problem

[smoky briar]

"The problem has worsen even more now. Club finance is going so worse that even the selling of small players also didn't able to maintain and further unable to buy any one. Kindly rectify this issue AS SOON AS POSSIBLE. AS UNABLE TO CONTINUE THE GAME PLAY"

URGENT!!! KINDLY RECTIFY THIS IN NEXT UPDATE

[lunar solstice]

Yes! Same here

[smoky briar]

Kindly update yourself too!!!

[rose kayak]

"Urgent" 😭

[pastel arch]

It kinda is bro

You can't buy players for less than their value or their value exactlt

Exactly*

But you have to sell for less than value or same?

I sold Yamal (80.5m) for 70m

And bought palmer (70m) for 85m

It doesn't make sense

[shrewd obsidian]

You can.
For transfer listed players or those at last year of their contract.
So it goes same way for your players.
It's cheaper because you transfer list them.

[pastel arch]

I never get bids for unlisted players

[shrewd obsidian]

Yeah currently it's rare and the team are fixing it.
But still when you transfer list and get lower offer, that's normal, and no need to moan about it.

[pastel arch]

Alright thanks for the heads up, it just felt frustrating either not getting any offers for listed players or getting 10m less than their value

[hushed bone]

i must say that getting a max of 45 million bid for a player worth 100million even if transfer listed is dumb

[shrewd obsidian]

Show it

[hushed bone]

i gotta get a new offer, but will take screenshot then

[shrewd obsidian]

Ok.
Because 45% of mv is unheard of

[hushed bone]

can you check out another thing i posted just now. new report abt a minute ago

[shrewd obsidian]

Shot accuracy?
Yeah it's known and already being addressed.
I suggested to reduce the number of shots because it's too many and unrealistic.

[hushed bone]

this is on another save, silva and stones are old so their current value has decreased but the lewis one hurts that too as he has 92 pot

meanwhile what i had to pay, a couple of guys have increased their value rn but even then they have not achieved the transfer fee

[shrewd obsidian]

15.5m out of 22.5 is 70%
Seems normal

[shrewd obsidian]

Are they transfer listed?

[hushed bone]

well for olise i did pay 130% something

no lewis wasnt but it was the best offer i got when i was going to bbe bankrupt

[shrewd obsidian]

He wasn't transfer listed?

[elfin compass]

Looks like this issue won't be fixed in the upcoming release.
I didn't play SM26 because I was waiting for the fix. It makes no sense to play 4-6 seasons and then stop playing because of this bug. Is there any chance it will be fixed in 2025m

[pastel arch]

This issue NEEDS to be fixed, especially with the unfair budgets other clubs get when u dont manage them (50m-150m)

[smoky briar]

Yeah I am completely lack of selling anyone except may be one or 2, even after transfer listing after 5 seasons.... It's like big bug need to be fixed to further continue🤞🏼🤞🏼🤞🏼 @tall matrix .... Please, kindly check and consider this for many users facing this problem... ✅

[tall matrix]

Does this happen even on new saves in 3.1.9? 🙂

[fervent radish]

It does

[latent aurora]

Yes. By me the same. I play with the new update over Steam 2 Seasons. Only a few players are sell. I have now 70 players

[pastel arch]

Im finally receiving bids, but its still frustrating. I only got 14M for Asencio (24.5M MV), even if a player is transferlisted they should go for the same price

[fervent radish]

Yes man we receive offers like almost half of the market value and it’s unrealistic

[shrewd obsidian]

It should be 70-80% imo
Beyond or below that is too unreasonable.

[smoky briar]

Yeah as they say below 50% also happens @shrewd obsidian 🤞🏼

[shrewd obsidian]

Haven't seen top bid being less than 60% myself

Except on transfer listed 12 month left contract players.
Which is justified in this case.

[smoky briar]

Yeah!!! It's happening for certain players as I had observed while playing FC HANSA ROSTOCK Save for fairly number of players recived top bids less than 50%

And mostly players never receive even bids even after transfer listing after 5 or 6 seasons (90% of the time).... May be one or 2, even if we transfer list almost 20 players

[shrewd obsidian]

You should've shownl it as proof for bug report imo.
Because all the images sent here, all are reasonable.
Except that Trincao one.

[jolly bane]

I sold my 5m Fitzgerald for 2.3m cuz I wasn't getting any better offers
V3.1.8

[smoky briar]

👍🏼

[crimson oar]

Has this problem been fixed yet? or do I have to wait for the next update? I don't want to enter the game because there are still many players that can't be sold

[fervent radish]

Same I’m waiting for it

[tall matrix]

How has this been for you guys on 3.1.9?

[crimson oar]

Thank you for always developing the game for us, but I really don't want to play the game right now because there are too many players who have been through many seasons and still can't be sold. I accept that the price will be much cheaper, but I want to liquidate them so that I can manage the team's budget better. Buying and selling players is the main foundation of the team's budget, so I hope you will reconsider this issue so that I can freely buy and sell players. Thank you

[steady nimbus]

hes a staff

not a developer

also

i feel like they fixed it

in the 3.1.9 version

i used it and the offers are comign great

[shrewd obsidian]

He's a developer

[steady nimbus]

oh

mb

[smoky briar]

@tall matrix I transfer listed players in mid of transfer window but unsold

It's my 2nd transfer window in 3.1.9 and after first week of transfer no offer came and none of them tranfer listed got any offer after that

Let, me check next transfer window and will report you @tall matrix

[smoky briar]

These players got sold towards the end of that season . Players who remained unsold in the transfer market got sold only at the end of season.

[crimson oar]

so they fixed this problem right? now players for sale get offers sooner?

[shrewd obsidian]

Yea looks like it's fixed

[smoky briar]

Actually, Tranfer listed players sold at the end of season with transfer fee for mostly 60% or above

[smoky briar]

Kinda fixed but still when you tranfer list the players in mid of transfer they get offers mostly at the end of season but we are getting very lately

But not at the time of transfer listing or transfer window.

I'll be checking again for a check ✔️

[crimson oar]

nice

[smoky briar]

I'll check for the transfers again in next season and will post here 👍🏼

NEW BUG FOR YOUTH ACADEMY RECRUITMENT - NOT GETTING GOOD POTENTIAL PLAYERS AFTER UPDATE @tall matrix

"But, before update I was getting like min one 80 to 90+ rating player with this training facility and now the youth academy player for recruitment or signing looks unchanged with lower potential"

[crimson oar]

tybro

[shrewd obsidian]

It's worked as intended then

[smoky briar]

I'll check for one more transfer and let you know 👍🏼

[crimson oar]

I just went through the early season transfer window and saw that the situation was not very positive, only 2-3 player purchases, I hope tonight when the middle and end of the season come there will be more offers

[crimson oar]

I just went through a generation of young players and there is still a player with the highest index of 90.

[smoky briar]

Actually, just after update in 3.1.9 version only I'm facing this issue....before it was working fine

[crimson oar]

I think not yet

i still cant sell them

[pastel arch]

I finally got an offer without listing, Vini for 105M which is still bad, since the AI usually rejects 120m+

[smoky briar]

My players were transfer listed on 12th Jun: 2nd week of transfer window

only 1 or 2 were actually sold who were transfer listed ❌

[crimson oar]

Me too

[smoky briar]

It needs a seriously a better update along with youth academy bug

[smoky briar]

OVER-ALL TRANSFERS IN SEASON 2 AFTER UPDATE:

1.) Received Good offers for 3 players in total.

2.) got the only 2 offers for transfer listed players with in tranfer window.

3.) For remaining transfer listed only only recived offers towards the end of the season 🤞🏼

---

OVERALL SUMMARY OF NEW TRANFER UPDATE IN 3.1.9 AFTER 2.5 SEASON (5 TRANFER WINDOWS):

1.) RECIEVING OFFERS FOR 2 OR 3 PLAYERS IN THE BEGINNING OF TRANSFER WINDOW ✅

2.) RECIEVING RARELY OFFERS FOR TRANFER LISTED PLAYERS ✖️

3.) FOR MOST OF THE TRANSFER LISTED PLAYERS RECIEVING OFFERS TOWARDS END OF THE SEASON AFTER TRANSFER WINDOW CLOSES (WHICH BECOMES OF NO USE AS WE CANT SIGN PLAYER WE NEED ON TIME AND PLAYER WE DONT NEED TO BE SOLD IMMEDIATELY)🤞🏼🤞🏼🤞🏼✖️

@tall matrix KINDLY, GO THROUGH AS THIS IS THE OVERALL SUMMARY OF LATEST UPDATE 3.1.9 ON TRANSFERS WHICH NEEDS SOME TWEAKS AND RECTIFICATION FOR BETTER GAME PLAY. TQ 👍🏼

[pastel arch]

I've gotten ONE bid for unlisted player

It was a 34 yr old Connor Bradley

[crimson oar]

my players started leaving after many seasons of not being able to transfer. Now I am losing them for free. Please fix this soon so we can have a better experience, please

[dense pulsar]

I’ve experienced this since SM18 to be fair lol

[shrewd obsidian]

You can remove them from TL and renew their contract btw

[crimson oar]

Not just one or two players, but many players who have not had any offers for 4-5 transfer seasons. I am not talking about the price, I am talking about the timing and quantity of offers. I think no matter what level the player is, there will still be big and small teams that will have offers for the players. I need to sell them to be able to turn around capital and restructure the team. I do not want to be entangled for too long with players who will not be used in the future.

[shrewd obsidian]

Ok

[smoky briar]

Yeah!!! I reported my whole thing in this channel... By spending most valuable time over to counter this issue.... Hope they rectify this issue soon ✅👍🏼

[jolly bane]

I haven't had problems with this

all my players sell within 0-1 seasons

[crimson oar]

u so lucky bro

[pastel arch]

Brooo your lucky as hell

[smoky briar]

Then you might not have sold many or you aren't needed to sell most of them from your team

[lunar solstice]

Exactly! Also, in the 3.0.12 version of the game. bugs were relatively low, specially these transfer bud and many other major bugs weren't there...now with every new update or additional feature, new bugs age generating continuously!!

[smoky briar]

You mean there are new bugs now in your update?

[smoky briar]

REGARDING 3.1.9 UPDATE: ACTUALLY GETTING GOOD OFFERS FOR SOME OF THE PLAYERS IS A MAJOR BOOST BUT COMPARED TO PREVIOUS UPDATE TRANSFER LISTED PLAYERS AREN'T GETTING ANY OFFERS DESPITE I UNLOCKED MAJOR MANAGERIAL TRAITS (ACTUALLY BEFORE UPDATE I GOT PRETTY DECENT ALMOST WITH IN 1 WEEK OR 2...). @tall matrix KINDLY RESOLVE THIS IN UPCOMING UPDATE