#can someone help me with my haymaker deck

1 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

gentle raft
#

i would personaly prefer help with my deck over dm's

solid bobcat
#

Can you post the list here first?

gentle raft
solid bobcat
#

OK, so, I know that you said you'd prefer being through DM but, I think my read is you're trying to do too much

#

You have it as both a hare apparent deck and as a general rabbit deck.

#

Even with Baylen's mana generation I also think some of the more expensive spells are optimistic.

#

What are your problems with the deck currently?

gentle raft
#

want it optimized

#

and there are just not many good rabits that makes tokens like hare apparent

solid bobcat
#

Is your main plan to win by going wide?

gentle raft
#

yeah before i gave all the focus on baylen but failed

#

also i have a friend groupe who is good at helping but when it comes to decks they just say i need to make it better but never say how

solid bobcat
#

OK

#

I'm working on a version on my Moxfield atm

#

I've got it at 102 cards

gentle raft
#

i see you kept my feel of the deck

solid bobcat
#

The considering section are just cards I've cut from your deck

#

I think the most expensive card I've added that isn't a land is [[metallic mimic]]

cold lanternBOT
gentle raft
#

why remove long ear tho

solid bobcat
#

Byrke is a card I was mixed on

#

I'm trying to figure out how much he's "win more" in this deck

#

He's adding counters to your creatures but is that good when you're casting him later in the game if it's just when he enters.

#

Metallic Mimic, in contrast, means all your creatures that are rabbits enter with a counter.

gentle raft
#

But long ear also doubles counters

solid bobcat
#

Yeah, that's why I was saying I was feeling mixed on it.

#

If you really want him in though, I can add it back

#

[[growing ranks]] doesn't do enough since most of your tokens are 1/1s

cold lanternBOT
solid bobcat
#

Outside of your offspring tokens

#

Cathar's crusade is just... a headache in a can

gentle raft
#

But finneas gives everyone counters also tokens

solid bobcat
#

Yep

#

That's the other thing, Finn comes into play earlier and can draw you cards

gentle raft
#

Cathars crusade that bad ?

solid bobcat
#

So he's helping you establish a board presence

#

Cathar's crusade means you have a lot of cards/tokens with a different number of counters on them.

gentle raft
#

True

solid bobcat
#

And, either people scoop to it and you reanimating a full graveyard or they make you play it out

#

I also worry about it costing more than Baylen. It's good for rebuilding I guess

#

So if you think about it as something you do after your board has been wiped

gentle raft
#

In the end you know more then me

solid bobcat
#

But thrumming stone and cathar's crusade can do something like:
Hare apparent->1 counter (2 hares, #1/2)
Hare apparent 2-> 2 counters (1 hare, #3)
Hare apparent 3-> 3 counters (1 hare, #4)
Hare apparent 4-> 4 counters

Then you have 1 HA with 10 counters; 1 HA and 1 token with 9 counters; 1 HA and 2 tokens with 7 counters; 1 HA and 3 tokens with 4 counters

gentle raft
#

Yeah but isn't it better then having none

solid bobcat
#

As I said, I can see leaving it in, it's my own preference

#

There's also [[starlight spectacular]]

cold lanternBOT
solid bobcat
#

Which is only triggered on the start of combat rather than a static counter

gentle raft
#

Yeah it really seems goofy

solid bobcat
#

OK, so, based on the feedback, it sounds like we put byrke back in and cathar's crusade and then find 4 cuts

#

I need to go have lunch

#

Take a look at the current list I made and see if there's anything you're interested in cutting

#

Or aren't convinced on.

gentle raft
#

is season of gathering worth keeping ?

solid bobcat
#

Sorry, I'm back

#

I think it is

#

It does a lot of things for you that your deck seems to want to do

gentle raft
#

But would silvan library be better?