#Umaru’s Decklist Thread
1 messages · Page 5 of 1
We don’t care about combos, we be manually drawing our deck
Makes closing out a game that much harder
We’re still winning with thoracle/lab man/jace
If you go comboless then maybe you want to go with [[Galadriel of Lothlórien]]?
Legendary Creature — Elf Noble
Whenever the Ring tempts you, if you chose a creature other than Galadriel of Lothlórien as your Ring-bearer, scry 3.
Whenever you scry, you may reveal the top card of your library. If a land card is revealed this way, put it onto the battlefield tapped.
"I pass the test. I will diminish, and go into the West, and remain Galadriel."
3/3
How much scry would be enough to make it worth it though? I’m not doing it regularly
Or do you mean as the commander
Either?
I saw a disgusting Galadriel deck that refused to have any deck search mechanics
There are a lot of incidental scry effects for green and blue though
[[retreat to coralhelm]] or [[season of growth]]
Season of growth with this new era of targeting and making tokens in simic has certainly popped off lol
and draw a card off each pump spell making them also cantrips
Galadriel does seem pretty nuts though
Also best art is still [[!season of growth|wot]]
Unfortunately she doesn’t draw the card if it isn’t a land though
This is the one I play ^^
Hot
[[Elligeth]]?
No card found for “Elligeth”
[[eligeth]]
Yeah, my finger spasmed when typing
Okay, if I wanted to play OG Nadu how would I build it?
[[spellskite]] effects?
Lmao
I love that
Here’s this for reference
Oh no, I just realized spellskite is like turbo nadu in this deck
I could do “oops all problems”, sorta simic stompy? So like they target my stuff but I always get something out of it
If I was to just care about the flash half, how would I want to build him? I guess he doesn’t lend very well to a theme
I did it
It’s legendary typal for the funsies
¯_(ツ)_/¯
I like it though seems fun to me
Nuts is what it is
I like it because once Nadu is out my deck is 100% draw-go
It’s like slightly better tatyova in terms of effect
Only sorcery is Ezuri’s predation
Yeah, Aesi is generally accepted as better than tatyova
Just bc extra land drop is way too good
aesi is ridiculous
even the precon is what i consider the second most powerful precon of all time
entirely due to the commander
nezahal is a real card
im not so sure on the arixmethes as every single time i played it someone killed it before i removed the last counter
Eh, for me it’s more of a legendary ramp spell that can maybe eventually turn into a threat
could just play stuff like three visits. farseek, harrow etc tho
If they're killing it before you remove the last counter it means they used land destruction on it instead of something else.
I love harrow and will forever advocate for it
I could, but that isn’t a legendary i can flash in with Nadu :3
Harrow is fantastic
Yep they were often in red and had just a card that happened to destroy target land
Plus harrow doesn’t have a 12/12 attached to it
it does only cost you 1 mana and a card to get two landfall triggers though
which is big
This deck doesn’t super care about landfall tbh
Like it runs tatyova and aesi, but really only just because they’re insane draw engines on their own
Simic...without landfall...its an outrage, its a scandal.
Yeh
I do
43 really isn’t that many
Above 40 and we’re starting to get a theme going though!
Usually when I say I’m doing a theme, I’m actually doing it, not half assing it and filling the rest with staples
My jeskai walkers deck (before it was cool/mainstream) had 32 planeswalkers in it
My 'creature' decks have like 25-30 creatures at most. I think bumbleflower was the most creatures ive played in a long time
Just go the Scry route. It still provides true Simic Sublimeness.
Why would you pick Nadu!?!??!
Original, tested, Nadu.
Yeva rolls in her grave
Tbf if Nadu had been printed that way I’d never play it. I could just play Vedalken Orrery/Leyline of anticipation along with generic simic value commander.
I'm still shocked that they claimed it was adjusted for power for edh because it was too much?
I mean jamming half of Prophet of Kruphix and half of Leovold together IS a dangerous place to be at 3mv, I understand the hesitation
I think if it was a commander legends set it would have been costed at (3)UG with original nadu text and been fine but since it was modern horizons they pushed the cost
That’s a good sign for a cards power I think
I guess? I've just never had "when your opponent targets a permanent" rules text that draw cards actually matter. But then people pay my rhystic study triggers so my experience in play is weird.
Okay but let’s be real, Leovold’s second ability was basically just gravy
That was NOT the issue on that guy
Holy hell [[rayne academy]]
Basically bannable /s
Rayne is one of the "dies to elesh norn" period cards for me
Lol, yeah dies to elesh norn is definitely a real problem
But now you have [[elrond master of]]!
Legendary Creature — Elf Noble
Whenever you scry, put a +1/+1 counter on each of up to X target creatures, where X is the number of cards looked at while scrying this way.
Whenever a creature you control with a +1/+1 counter on it becomes the target of a spell or ability an opponent controls, you may draw a card.
4/4
What are your thoughts of running [[hakbal surging]] in OG nadu?
Legendary Creature — Merfolk Scout
At the beginning of combat on your turn, each Merfolk creature you control explores. (Reveal the top card of your library. Put that card into your hand if it's a land. Otherwise, put a +1/+1 counter on the exploring creature, then put the card back or put it into your graveyard.)
Whenever Hakbal of the Surging Soul attacks, you may put a land card from your hand onto the battlefield. If you don't, draw a card.
3/3
So uh
The new zimones are nuts
The 4 drop one is 100% going into Nadu
But I wonder if the three mana one is good enough too
It is far and away the cheapest Maro thus far
[[Zimone, all questioning]]
Legendary Creature — Human Wizard
At the beginning of your end step, if a land entered the battlefield under your control this turn and you control a prime number of lands, create Primo, the Indivisible, a legendary 0/0 green and blue Fractal creature token, then put that many +1/+1 counters on it. (2, 3, 5, 7, 11, 13, 17, 19, 23, 29, and 31 are prime numbers.)
1/1
She seems pretty mid to me?
Still as mid as she was yesterday to me.
There’s also [[zimone mystery]]
Legendary Creature — Human Wizard
Landfall — Whenever a land you control enters, manifest dread if this is the first time this ability has resolved this turn. Otherwise, you may turn a permanent you control face up. (To manifest dread, look at the top two cards of your library. Put one onto the battlefield face down as a 2/2 creature and the other into your graveyard. Turn it face up any time for its mana cost if it's a creature card.)
3/3
So, the thing with the 3 drop Zimone is the play pattern for her is feeling really fiddly for good or ill. A lot of sacrificing lands and sacrificing Primo.
And it's just better handled by Pir/Toothy
Who also draw you cards?
he guys, what do you think about the new [[valgavoth, harrower of souls]]?
is it as good as ob nixilis or no?
I would not call it as powerful as mat ob nix but that is by no means a bad thing
Higher floor, lower ceiling
The 3 drop zimone seems funny
the 4 drop seems like a coaster, cant see much use for it outside of that.
This seems sick for [[be'lakor]]
Man Im so glad I already have a demons deck. Getting a few new toys in duskmourne
The 4 drop zimone? She insanely good
She’s not, like, tatyova levels
But she cheats out permanents like nobody’s business
She can take infinite turns with wormfang manta which is always appealing
Its not really cheating them out as you need to flip them or pay their cost to flip them.
[[Ashaya]] takes care of that
Whatever comes in off the first trigger will trigger the second when it etbs and flips itself
Yeah, butt triggering her twice a turn when you’re building around it is trivial
i don't like the rest of the legends spoiled besides those two as much. I feel like aminatou is just not very good (miracle cost only being reduced by 4 is too many hoops for too little pay-off), and precon winter seems just plain bad. other }Winter seems to be annoying in the way that nekusar is, but a single land beats it so...
wdym? being reduced by 4 is HUGE - throw in some flash enablers, some [[scroll rack]] style effects and BOOM you're off to the races
Miracle is a flash enabler
ehhhhhhh
scroll rack is the only repeatable way to put cards from your hand onto the top of your deck
i do agree with the flash part
but what enchantments are you even playing?
sigil of the empty throne?
what else?
omnisience just makes your commander terrible
also 6 mana omnisience that requires some setup. Is it really that good?
there are over 600 enchantments with mana value 4 or greater which could likely have their cost reduced by aminatou
sure. Most of them have multiple pips, and the ones that don't aren't really that good.
[[Doomwake giant]] among others
I would gladly pay only UUU for a thought reflection
doomwake giant lol
What's wrong with doomwake giant?
what makes aminatou any better than any other enchantress deck though?
why are you lol'ing doomwake giant? its cracked in bx enchantress decks
nothing
i like it
i forgot about it
We have entered the reduction by four mana on drawn enchantments and surveil on upkeep bad era
thats why i said lol
indeed we have :(
You can also use her with surveil payoff stuff like Mirko
She spends the story of Duskmourne keeping surveillance on the heroes iirc
So no
It’s a flavor win
Also a lot of esper enchantments reanimate
OOH [[disinformation campaign]] would be a lot of fun in Aminatou, yeah?
bruh you gonna reduce its mana cost to 2 instead of 3?
It’s the surveil lol
it being in esper also removes a lot of payoffs
from the enchantress theme
i just feel that it could be a lot cooler
Half the enchantment payoffs are in white
cost reduction is still good?
Disinformation campaign is gas
I feel like when people tell me I'm wrong to play esper artifacts because red exists.
wish they had made it reduce by colored mana instead
you're not wrong, im just dissapointed
i know
i feel like if they made it reduce the cost by esper instead of 4 colorless, it would be a lot cooler of an enchantress
No, that would be awful
A lot would only get one reductjon
by better i mean more fun
imagine it with disinformation campaign lol
i honestly just don't like the keyword miracle at all
so i guess it kind of makes since that i don't like the aminatou
i also feel like they shouln't have desparked aminatou
that removes the point of your commander
and is a 6 mana omnisience even that good?
So? You have omniscience nothing else matters
with a bunch of set up?
...yes?
its easier to cast omnisience with some rituals and call it a day
You can see aminatou as a ritual
a really wierd ritual with a ton of set up
She rituals four colorless mana off the miracle’d enchantment
also, regardless of liking miracle or not, it is a PERFECT fit for the fate-twisting aminatou
Pretty much zero setup, actually
Yeah not sure how many they’re thinking are tri or even two color
it has nothing to do with anything to do with the story
It reduces the generic costs too, unless it would say otherwise
E.g. [[eluge shoreless]]
Legendary Creature — Elemental Fish
Eluge's power and toughness are each equal to the number of Islands you control.
Whenever Eluge enters or attacks, put a flood counter on target land. It's an Island in addition to its other types for as long as it has a flood counter on it.
The first instant or sorcery spell you cast each turn costs
(or
) less to cast for each land you control with a flood counter on it.
*/*
she has nothing to do with enchantments in the story and more to with fate
and the ability to say "nope. No dying for you"
so aristacrats would suit her better
14 @ azorius https://scryfall.com/search?q=t%3Aenchantment+ci%3Dazorius+mv>%3D4&unique=cards&as=grid&order=cmc&dir=desc
20 @ orzhov https://scryfall.com/search?q=t%3Aenchantment+ci%3Dorzhov+mv>%3D4&unique=cards&as=grid&order=cmc&dir=desc
2 Magic cards found where the card types include “enchantment” and the color identity is BUW and the mana value >= 4
14 Magic cards found where the card types include “enchantment” and the color identity is UW and the mana value >= 4
11 Magic cards found where the card types include “enchantment” and the color identity is BU and the mana value >= 4
lol
what he said
what are you talking about? aminatou's whole thing in the story is she condensed her magic down into tokens which offer about a 10-second re-do on someone's actions - both surveil and miracle are spot on representations of avoiding fate
but enchantments?
Fair enough 🤷♀️ lolol
also its not a miracle is it?
she did it
miracle represents "divine" intervention
Anyway this is enough of this
it acts like a miracle
i guess
anyway, i just don't like aminatou and you're not gonna change my mind
also both winters are terrible
I mean the best representation would be like. aminatou creating [[mask | tc18]] tokens, but cest la vie
fr
oh I love Jund winter. I've had a jund group slug/nekusar deck for a few years now and the closest thing jund had to a card-draw-caring commander before now was Darrigaz the igniter
[[winter, misenthropic guide]]
is the first commander to get literally destroyed by a single land ever
...what?
[[reliquary tower]]
oh I don't give a shit about his delirium ability
you like group hug?
Did you not read what I said? I've got a jund group slug/nekusar deck
nekusar is not jund
Nekusar style deck
it is a jund nekusar-style deck
[[darigaaz]]
Multiple cards match “darigaaz”, can you be more specific?
never thought i would find that
[[darigaaz the igniter]]
he's. fine?
Hmmm
hes terrible lol
Winter is better for this I’d think?
the deck itself is cool
Depends how you’d build it
yes absolutely
that's why I'm v excited
@misty geyser hes not using the delirium at all
thanks
That’s not required
i was trying to tell you the plan
no hate
i would do the same
i thought you were confused
have you guys seen my tymna ninjas deck?
I'm also gonna swap Mob Nix for the RB Valgavoth when he releases. No hate to the kingpin, he's just a little too strong for where the deck wants to be
yep, i completely agree. I also feel that valgavoth is honestly just better
in the deck
yup
draw a card instead of exile
i think there was a new "whenever an opponent draws a card, deal 1 damage to them" printed in like bloomburrow or something
I know there's [[razorkin needle]] in duskmourn
Therr’s one coming in duskmourn
sry i mean duskmourn
i gtg now
but check out this list:https://www.moxfield.com/decks/fzu8capDP0uUXYT5gEQqhg
[[winter|dsk]]
@hushed tapir so what does jund give you that rakdos or even grixis doesn’t?
Mostly stuff like [[jolrael, mwonvuli]] [[runic armasaur]] [[heartwood storyteller]], [[cindervines]]
Legendary Creature — Human Druid
Whenever you draw your second card each turn, create a 2/2 green Cat creature token.


: Until end of turn, creatures you control have base power and toughness X/X, where X is the number of cards in your hand.
"Humans bring nothing but suffering and deceit. They are not welcome in my forest."
1/2
Ah, so making it hurt to not only draw those cards but use them
Running [[ruric thar]]
?
This deck started off as a $50 budget deck with [[xira arien]] and I was trying to stay at least partially in theme with that
Plus ive already got a Prosper deck and I’m hesitant to build another RB deck (which is ironic since I just finished blinging out lord windgrac)
Ooh. Tempting. I might have too many noncreature spells for that though
Mm good point. To be fair I often wind up with a lot of mana. Maybe I cut some mana rocks and add stuff like that
It’s definitely leaning more group slug when you go that way but not a bad idea
Feed people cards so they can kill themselves casting them
All I’ll say is pack more than a few fogs lol
What does jund have in the way of protecting your permanents?
[[heroic intervention]]? I’m sure there some other green stuff but not a lot in r or b I think
There’s like [[wrap in vigor]] but that’s only creatures
I was just thinking of a way you don’t die to board wipes tbh
Fair! Honestly wrap in vigor would do a ton, I do have a lot of creatures
I love the addition of [[karazikar, the eye tyrant]]
Legendary Creature — Beholder
Whenever you attack a player, tap target creature that player controls and goad it. (Until your next turn, that creature attacks each combat if able and attacks a player other than you if able.)
Whenever an opponent attacks another one of your opponents, you and the attacking player each draw a card and lose 1 life.
5/5
thanks
there's a bit of a goad sub-theme isn't there?
Anyways I think Aminatou is very solid.
And certainly if one was to commit to building her, I think there's ways of getting a lot of value for her.
Finally caught up on this
Yeah Omniscience for 6 mana is pretty good, are you crazy?
you can even set it up with like [[enlightened tutor]] during opp end step
Getting omniscience off bant tamiyo emblem for 4 mana and like 4 turns is wild everytime I resolve it. This would be even faster.
I think Omniscience is "better" in deck Zimone but that's only because there it has the possibility of being free. The floor of it in Aminatou is still really high.
With omniscience in play with aminatou, aminatou is worth nothing lol
also you don't have the card draw to fuel omniscience
With omniscience in play with aminatou, aminatou is worth nothing lol you win the game because it’s omniscience.
how do you win the game?
what cards do you play?
its not infinite mana lol
what cards do play?
are you creating a deck simply to win with omniscience?
in that case, aminatou is not for you
You play your entire deck? We’re in blue? You trying to tell me that you can’t just draw everything with omniscience in play?
dude your playing an esper enchantress deck
Yeah?
how many card draw spells are you playing?
I’m in blue so likely at least 10
omniscience doesn't win you the game lol
Yeah ok we’re done here
rhystic study and mystic remora don't do anything lol
I shan’t be replying to you after this.
Hey gamers, let’s not
Shirtless men finally arrived in the mail
Let’s discuss ways to improve that
I need better ways to win the game with it
Hell yeah funny decks
im being quite calm and just saying that i don't believe that omniscience will win you the game
I'm trying to remember what colors Shirtless Men is in
Non black
New Tyvar?
since you have a mono-G one
He's basically Magic's Saint of Shirtless Men at this point
this is incredible
So, Pulse of the Forge and Hanmer of Bogardan unfortunately, though somewhat expectedly don’t do much
I haven’t seen him
[[tyvar|dsk]]
Legendary Creature — Elf Warrior
Tap another untapped creature you control: Tyvar, the Pummeler gains indestructible until end of turn. Tap it.


: Creatures you control get +X/+X until end of turn, where X is the greatest power among creatures you control.
"They just keep coming and coming—perfect for my morning workout!"
3/3
how did you find all these shirtlesss men?
Crowdsourcing
lol
“atag:bare-chest” helped a lot
Eh, people that know me know that this isn’t completely out of left field
I like doing goofy deck ideas
Tyvar is in, hanmer of bogardan is out
imagine somebody who doesn't play magic...
Well, if they wanna judge me then they can either get to know me first or they ain’t worth my time lol
lol
I’m noting that [[fire//ice]] isn’t too fantastic
barely shirtless
But unfortunately our pile of efficient removal isn’t very big
Nah fire and ice is terrible I only play it in pauper because it’s flexible and pings down flying 1/1s
I wouldn’t play it anywhere else at all
Oh! So I made changed after ordering the deck so I ended up having to make a couple audibles with the paper list
its helpful in pauper for tapping lands to prevent combo decks
Currently, Tatyova and Nadu are in
I might keep Taty, but I would like to replace Nadu
Are there not shirtless men that can exile until it leaves the board?
Like banishment type effects
There might be!
Coz that fits the theme and is removal
good idea
Oh!! [[!banishing light|scd]]
Hell yeah
guys is it just me or is the best way to spend infinite mana phelddagrif?
[[chained to the rocks]]
nice
[[!citizen's arrest]]
[[chained to the rocks]]
Oh man you beat me to it
already found
I was chuckling away to myself for too long
OH [[!Grasp of fate|CMM]]
[[burn from within]]
[[anzrag's rampage]]
Sorcery
Destroy all artifacts you don't control, then exile the top X cards of your library, where X is the number of artifacts that were put into graveyards from the battlefield this turn. You may put a creature card exiled this way onto the battlefield. It gains haste. Return it to your hand at the beginning of the next end step.
[[rout]] ?
Does this count?
[[!mageta the lion]]
[[jazal goldmane]] is another alternative pump creature
[[!blasphemous act|sld]]
[[root grevil]] for enchantments?
Rout 100% counts
HELL YES
Jazal is already in there
I do love mageta
you playing my favourite one [[brimaz, king of oreskos]]
I love this card so much. its nostalgic for me and I need to play it more
No but he’s not bad
Maybe a bit low impact on his own
How about ways to remove all nonland permanents, or maybe just artifacts/enchantments? I have Filter Out but I wanna have at least a couple so I have my bases covered
Fortunately Ghost Quarter is able to be in the deck
[[!break down]]
So we’re good on LD
Ooh, with card draw attached. That’s in
[[cleansing meditation]]
Oh, on the board wipes, [[desolation giant]]
That's a kill switch more than anything else.
Mutually assured destruction?
[[Time Wipe]] ?
[[essence filter]]
it doesnt have a man on it tho
[[gorilla shaman]]
[[mass calcify]]
lol [[rapid hybridization]]
I mean, hes not shirtless though
They're in the process for sure
but id argue more than half of that shirt is still on
Same issue with [[!chaos warp|2x2|359]]
alright fair enough i guess were allowing it becuase the deck needs some good removal cards
its a shame we dont have black coz [[damn]] would go hard
Ehh, I see tiddy
coz if its a skeleton, theres no way there is a shirt involved
I do think it's funny that people are saying the otter that untaps all frogs is a sign that Pongify is the better version of the spell because it makes an ape
Cause like [[werebear]] is in the deck too
That’s like the fact that snow covered basics are “strictly” better
YEp
It’s only better in a way that’ll literally never matter
Oh shoot, wrong one
There is a werebear that his shirt is being ripped off as he’s transforming
[[extraplanar lens]]
Yeah
I have a friend who uses exactly this in a mono blue deck and it really is relevant there.
Even when people do run mono colored decks it’s not always even ran
HEnce why I think it's funny.
Okay so another thing, I wonder if there’s some better ways to buff my creatures and/or give evasion
I could stand to go down on removal slightly, since I’ve got 22 removal spells currently lol
theres that enchantment with flash that gives your creatures +2/+2 from a theros set
I really like stuff like [[contortionist troupe]], just building up counters
I forgot its name.
[[Dictate of Helios]]
[[Beastmaster Ascension]]
Oh wait, I was thinking [[Titanic Ultimatum]] art, nvm.
Nah tbf there is a shaman lookin dude in the back of beastmaster
cant tell if they're shirtless though
[[Gaea's Anthem]]
I think those guys are wearing chest pieces
The pecs are extremely angular compared to the rest of their chest art
Heh, nice
Okay, sorted there
How about card draw? Any spicy ones come to mind?
My current list is decently strong but maybe I missed some real good ones
I've been thinking about it, Aminatou might be an interesting Room commander
Since each seems to have an expensive and a cheap side you could miracle the big one in
True! Maybe that was the intention? I know they typically design commanders to work really well with stuff in the set to entice people to get cards from that set as easy upgrades
Maybe. I just know that eerie is focused across UW and BU
And then with Victor
So, coming back over here. Maybe the way to build Aminatou is so that it doesn't matter what enchantment you draw and miracle?
Like, the idea is the majority of the cards you draw are going to be good to cast whenever
So you're casting threats not answers
Like is it Esper stompy?
Esper enchantments with specifically 4 in their mana value https://scryfall.com/search?q=commander%3Aesper+format%3Aedh+t%3Aenchantment+mana%3A{4}
So instant speed draw would be good
Rhystic study is… real good here
Could also run the other stuff like [[compost]]
gotta have [[starfield of nyx]] and [[extinguish all hope]] no?
Enchantment
At the beginning of your upkeep, you may return target enchantment card from your graveyard to the battlefield.
As long as you control five or more enchantments, each other non-Aura enchantment you control is a creature in addition to its other types and has base power and base toughness each equal to its mana value.
@misty geyser I just found a copy of soul of windgrace in my pile of random stuff and though I haven’t tried to build jund in ages. You got a list for him or actual windgrace. I think maybe lands as a theme will keep me interested.
(I'm not Umaru but I've got a lands Lord WIndgrace lands list if you're interested)
I haven’t done jund lands, it was one of those deck ideas that was more or less solved
Lands in general is a big meh to me
I've liked Soul of Windgrace a lot but I also built it with an artifact subtheme
I could probably come up with one
Ah I thought you’d have one for sure given your status/message thing about jund haha
I’m wanting to go into a fill the yard with lands and [[splendid reclamation]] angle I think
I need help... Im trying to make a grixis storm deck with Sol'kanar
That's ~sort of~ my list
its not going well
mardu storm? Isn't sol'kanar grixis?
Yeah ok fair. This is pretty close to where I wanna go. I just don’t want extra land drops is all. Will steal a fair chunk of this list and add the cards I wanna run
One thing I've found with soul of windgrace is you want the lands to go to your hand
Which is why i've got more things like the [[pair o dice lost]]
my understanding is that Umaru likes Jund, but has never really found a jund commander deck they love
what do you want the win con to be
just thought up a cool idea: Marchesa storm. It uses Brain Freeze and tendrils of agony to target opponents and bunch and stormkiln and archmage emeritus to do cool stuff i guess
changed the commander :D
lifegain is boring
gotcha
Have you looked at [[cormella]]
No card found for “cormella”
[[cormela, glamour]]
oooh it thats cool
reanimator storm...
goryos vengeance goes crazy
you just need a sac-outlet
seems very powerful
[[thermopod]]
a bit too powerful for the deck im planning, but still really cool
you're gonna want [[urabrask // the great work]], [[aetherflux reservoir]], [[embrace the unknown]], [[ashling flame dancer]] and [[party thrasher]]
Legendary Creature — Phyrexian Praetor
First strike
Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, Urabrask deals 1 damage to target opponent. Add
.
: Exile Urabrask, then return it to the battlefield transformed under its owner's control. Activate only as a sorcery and only if you've cast three or more instant and/or sorcery spells this turn.
4/4
The Great Work
Enchantment — Saga
(As this Saga enters and after your draw step, add a lore counter.)
I — The Great Work deals 3 damage to target opponent and each creature they control.
II — Create three Treasure tokens.
III — Until end of turn, you may cast instant and sorcery spells from any graveyard. If a spell cast this way would be put into a graveyard, exile it instead. Exile The Great Work, then return it to the battlefield (front face up).
Sorcery
Exile the top two cards of your library. Until the end of your next turn, you may play those cards.
Retrace (You may cast this card from your graveyard by discarding a land card in addition to paying its other costs.)
"Everyone's gotta die somehow. I'll be damned if I meet my end cowering in some cellar."
Legendary Creature — Elemental Shaman
You don't lose unspent red mana as steps and phases end.
Magecraft — Whenever you cast or copy an instant or sorcery spell, discard a card, then draw a card. If this is the second time this ability has resolved this turn, Ashling, Flame Dancer deals 2 damage to each opponent and each creature they control. If it's the third time, add 


.
4/4
Creature — Lizard Wizard
Noncreature spells you cast from exile have convoke. (Each creature you tap while casting a noncreature spell from exile pays for
or one mana of that creature's color.)
At the beginning of your first main phase, you may discard a card. If you do, exile the top two cards of your library, then choose one of them. You may play that card this turn.
1/4
Sorcery
Exile the top two cards of your library. Until the end of your next turn, you may play those cards.
Retrace (You may cast this card from your graveyard by discarding a land card in addition to paying its other costs.)
"Everyone's gotta die somehow. I'll be damned if I meet my end cowering in some cellar."
I've got a Prosper Storm/Artifact Pinger deck which I've v much enjoyed and storm in v cube is one of my favorite archetypes
i like the artifact idea
what if i use a bunch of relic of progenitus's to constantly trigger my commander and add to my storm count?
and turn it into more of an artifact deck?
Which commander is this now?
Here's my current list if you're interesting (sorry we're taking over your thread umaru) https://www.moxfield.com/decks/qTsylPCPKkiTKBpMuLAwAg
[[marchesa, dealer of death]]
Legendary Creature — Human Rogue
Whenever you commit a crime, you may pay
. If you do, look at the top two cards of your library. Put one of them into your hand and the other into your graveyard. (Targeting opponents, anything they control, and/or cards in their graveyards is a crime.)
"You should have folded when you had the chance."
3/4
My complicated relationship with jund is that it’s my favorite color combo but haven’t found a commander that isn’t
- turbo broken
- total garbage
- really “clicked” at all
ah yeah artifact pingers would be sweet for her
Modern Jund midrange is my favorite deck of all time
no that's absolutely fair
Soul of Windgrace is the only one I've enjoyed so far.
But the “representation” we got is absolute shit
So I know that pain.
yeah, and no one would ever be able to play an graveyard deck against me...
me @ jeskai, abzan, and sultai
Coram is cool, but I need to redo him
I like soul of windgrace as well
Umori companion just isn’t quite doing it for me anymore
sad ;-;
I’m thinking jund spellslinger/control is next on the docket
I know the feeling - I used to have a Jarad list which became too combo-y and all the fun was lost
i like [[zangief]] the most off the top of my head for jund
Legendary Creature — Human Warrior
Maarika, Brutal Gladiator must be blocked if able.
As long as it's your turn, Maarika has indestructible.
Whenever Maarika deals damage to a creature, if that creature was dealt excess damage this turn, that creature's controller sacrifices a noncreature, nonland permanent.
7/4
Combos make me literally miserable if I have them
I like winning by doing actual work
like storm?
I was going to bring up them too. I've seen a lot of people enjoy it as a commander
like attacking
the only combos that i'll put up with is patron of the moon
Umaru is a based facebeating fan
Zangief is cool but just feast or famine because he either keeps EVERYONE down or does nothing
My issue with spellslinger control is simply “how tf do I win”
zangief is just a big thonk...
Combat is fun ok. Me punch face.
tendrills of agony or like pingers i guess?
it's only feast or famine to me if i'm relying on zangief but i want most of the deck to be threatening
I am the sort of person that uses Llanowar elf to do damage. If I don’t need the mana on turn 2
Always hit.
Not a bad idea, big fireballs and whatnot
Same. Have you tried building Breena yet?
That’s the orzhov bird right?
Yeah. If you like hit she is turbo hit
I have not tried her yet but I’ve seen others play her at my lgs and for that reason I don’t really want to you know
I don’t like having same commanders as other people at my lgs or in my friend groups
With the exception of yuriko because me and a friend are unhinged and have 5 yuriko decks between us with two more on the way
That 4 drop white mouse with valiant is such a good fucking card in that deck
[[marionette master]] doming target opp for 4, and marionette aprrentice doming each opp for 1 is v good
also chaining spells together with 3abrask puts in WORK
Creature — Human Artificer
Fabricate 3 (When this creature enters, put three +1/+1 counters on it or create three 1/1 colorless Servo artifact creature tokens.)
Whenever an artifact you control is put into a graveyard from the battlefield, target opponent loses life equal to Marionette Master's power.
1/3
i also kinda like the idea of running [[sek deathkeeper]] and [[ognis lash]] together sometime in an aggressive kind of haste typal
I think you two must have stolen all of my yuriko luck.
Yeah…it’s getting out of hand. We played a yuriko pod once
There's also the simplicity of [[kresh]]
Multiple cards match “kresh”, can you be more specific?
[[kresh, the blood]]
I considered kresh [[pyroclasm]].deck
I love these types of effects
Or even doom blade.deck
Both are good
It also lets me run the goat [[electrickery]]
For the pyroclasm style, [[indoraptor]]?
Legendary Creature — Dinosaur Mutant
Bloodthirst X (This creature enters with X +1/+1 counters on it, where X is the damage dealt to your opponents this turn.)
Menace
Enrage — Whenever Indoraptor, the Perfect Hybrid is dealt damage, choose an opponent at random. Indoraptor deals damage equal to its power to that player unless they sacrifice a nontoken creature.
3/1
[[whip flare]]
maybe it's weird but i thought about running [[golden sting]] as kill people the deck
Funnily enough my jund group slug deck started off as an og Xira deck before becoming a Darigaaz deck and now a Jund Winter deck
very focused on removing opps board presence and maintaining a grip of cards
ooh, neat
I figured Coram would be good for that since his attack trigger is basically impulse drawing the top card of each player’s library
mm true
Coram is strong no doubt, just doesn't really inspire much in me when i look at them
[[Meathook Massacre II]] Is a great include in your indoraptor deck
Legendary Enchantment
When Meathook Massacre II enters, each player sacrifices X creatures.
Whenever a creature you control dies, you may pay 3 life. If you do, return that card under your control with a finality counter on it.
Whenever a creature an opponent controls dies, they may pay 3 life. If they don't, return that card under your control with a finality counter on it.
In small doses it's great, but not in the same way no
So I’m considering doing Jund lands
Coram isn’t really doing it for me
If I do Jund lands I kinda wanna go the burn route
[[Iridescent Vinelasher]] and co
Then just scapeshift, splendid rec, Lumra and digging to the core of the earth
And it turns out there are only like 5 of this burn effect
So apparently we need to go to plan b
tutors
Blech
I can run the burn effect
But then just add some other stuff too
Maybe some group slug stuff
Like [[burning earth]]
Nonbasic hate
Why not like specific tutors though? Like [[green suns zenith]]
Gsz can’t grab any of the burn effects, so idk what it’d grab
I mean thats an example, you get what im saying though.
[[finale of devastation]] is a better example.
Coz its not jsut a generic tutor to grab whatever, its specifically a second copy of a burn creature i nthis instance
I also would definitely wanna do some kind of nonbasic hate stuff
And looots of basics
Laughs in [[blood moon]]
I should, tbh
I prolly will
https://www.moxfield.com/decks/WR9HdOYHB0SoPAYyKyl5xg
Here’s what I’ve got so far
I think the last 15 cards need to all be removal and card draw
And I’m terribly unfamiliar with lands decks nowadays
Oh! I need more mill
I’m thinking chucking Coram into the 99?
Also, thoughts on [[conjurer’s closet]] for the additional land stuff?
It's just another in the line of not as good as harrow
There's also one from zendikar rising
What was that one called?? I was racking my brain trying to remember it
I scryfall is being dumb
[[roiling regrowth]]
It’s not bad, especially for this deck
Thats a nice ramp spell
I'd get [[realms uncharted]] first
over roiling regrowth really
Eh, currently the deck’s land base is just gonna be fetches and basics
But it puts them into your hand?
soul of windgrace wants to discard?
Wasn’t there another card similar to [[valakut exploration]]? Where it like mills cards for lands and deals damage if I don’t use them
Enchantment
Landfall — Whenever a land you control enters, exile the top card of your library. You may play that card for as long as it remains exiled.
At the beginning of your end step, if there are cards exiled with Valakut Exploration, put them into their owner's graveyard, then Valakut Exploration deals that much damage to each opponent.
Came out recently I think?
Legendary Creature — Bird Dragon
Flying
Whenever Dragonhawk enters or attacks, exile the top X cards of your library, where X is the number of creatures you control with power 4 or greater. You may play those cards until your next end step. At the beginning of your next end step, Dragonhawk deals 2 damage to each opponent for each of those cards that are still exiled.
5/5
Ohh right
Well he isn’t bad here either
Him + my commander is two
What should I do for the removal package here?
I’ve got two board wipes and no real targeted removal currently
I count blood moon, winter moon, lord windgrace and vorinclex as removal but only technically
[[tear asunder]]
Like resource denial
Ooh, yes
So I’m gonna be pretty defenseless to aggro, ideas for that?
Constant mists for sure
[[world breaker]]
That is so slow
[[tiller engine]] taps things or untaps your lands
[[bonds of mortality]] is funny when you can't afford a shadowspear
One card you don't have in here that has been amazing for me is [[mina and denn, wildspeaker]]
No card found for “mina and denn, wildspeaker”
[[mina and denn]]
Like hugs they're an additional land drop but also can give trample
i did notice that jund will struggle to control the board vs aggro unless you play [[damnation]] and co
and I dont really wanna kill my own dudes
There’s ways around it
Since we’re basically playing turbo ramp I threw in [[in garruk’s wake]]
My thoughts were [[dictate of erabos]]
with stuff like [[fleshbag marauder]]
But that will end up in every creature but yours dies on etb
which isnt a very fun play pattern
Right
Alright, 39 land special lol
I added in [[braids nightmare]] because nobody’s sacrificing lands other than me most of the time
Legendary Creature — Nightmare
At the beginning of your end step, you may sacrifice an artifact, creature, enchantment, land, or planeswalker. If you do, each opponent may sacrifice a permanent that shares a card type with it. For each opponent who doesn't, that player loses 2 life and you draw a card.
3/3
I’m thinking my card draw suite will be a lot better than I think because of soul’s activated abilities
I need one more basic fetch
I got fabled, terramorphic, prismatic, evolving wilds, twisted landscape, three on color fetches and riveteers overlook
I guess myriad landscape?
what about the bad commons from MH3
I wouldnt play them outside of pauper personally but eh
i dont even know what theyre called
Already have that one
I actually really like this one tbf
I suppose lotus field technically works lol
Ah! I can run Cabaretti Courtyard and Maestro’s Theater
Aight, deck’s done
The rest of Nadu is coming in today, so that’s exciting
Gonna have to post my mail day
HAVE I GOT A LIST FOR YOU
Ah I see you already put together a list lol
I sure did but I’m not opposed to more ideas
Hm my lunchbreak is almost over, you mind if I take a look at your list/shoot some suggestions once I get home? (4:00pm CST ish)
Works for me, I’m off at 5pm CST
Though I’m at work rn and just on my phone all the time lol
(I'm so sorry this is coming a whole day late, I forgot I had a memorial for a recently deceased teacher last night)
Here's my current junds lands deck fwiw. More focused on ramping/doubling mana and jamming a massive x spell ftw but I can see myself cutting that gameplan eventually tbh https://www.moxfield.com/decks/DXVXMQycf0GIzy-Mni6vhA
I've personally been a fan of [[nahiri's lithoforming]] esp with all the crucible effects lands decks run it just read "trigger all your landfall effects + draw a card for each land you control"
[[overabundance]] is a real gnarly one if you're okay with everyone getting double mana (but you make the best use of it.
I know you're going for a ping-style/groupslug deck but six mana for [[akoum hellkite]] to only deal 1 maybe 2 damage is ROUGH
With all the fetchlands you have you're probably going to want [[lotus cobra]]
also what is [[vorinclex // the grand evolution]] doing here? sure he tutors two forests to hand but...meh? With all the ping effects you have, I feel as though you're better off running like. Mob Nix or something?
Legendary Creature — Phyrexian Praetor
Trample, reach
When Vorinclex enters, search your library for up to two Forest cards, reveal them, put them into your hand, then shuffle.


: Exile Vorinclex, then return it to the battlefield transformed under its owner's control. Activate only as a sorcery.
6/6
The Grand Evolution
Enchantment — Saga
(As this Saga enters and after your draw step, add a lore counter.)
I — Mill ten cards. Put up to two creature cards from among the milled cards onto the battlefield.
II — Distribute seven +1/+1 counters among any number of target creatures you control.
III — Until end of turn, creatures you control gain "
: This creature fights target creature you don't control." Exile The Grand Evolution, then return it to the battlefield (front face up).
[[ob nixilis, captive kingpin]]
Legendary Creature — Demon
Flying, trample
Whenever one or more opponents each lose exactly 1 life, put a +1/+1 counter on Ob Nixilis, Captive Kingpin. Exile the top card of your library. Until your next end step, you may play that card.
Stranded on New Capenna without a spark, he faced five families out for blood.
4/3
I forgot to report back, but I played OG nadu yesterday and it does REAL good
Nadu usually doesn’t even matter until I have the combo up with seedborn muse and co.
I thought about your deck this weekend!
Because I saw a "conspiracy theory" post about Nadu.
That original Nadu is similar to but obviously stronger than [[kianne|dsc]]
And whether or not he was changed to be different from Kianne
Because it would be a "problem" to have another commander come out a little before this one that's significantly better than a precon commander.
True, that is a really good theory.
Both are very powerful, I honestly might run kianne in the 99 at least
It would make a heck of a lot of sense
More than "power level concerns" on a generic level
I mean, i’d much prefer simic to have an identity in giving things flash than the BS it currently does
Absolutely
Flash is at least interesting
Not to mention seedborn flash shenanigans are my favorite thing :3
I was able to deck myself in a single turn rotation on Saturday
Speaking of which, I need to find a slot for spark jace
Umaru, how do you feel about [[enduring curiosity]] for Errant/Giada? (I'm going through DSK/DSC rn to see if there are any upgrades the deck wants)
Enchantment Creature — Cat Glimmer
Flash
Whenever a creature you control deals combat damage to a player, draw a card.
When Enduring Curiosity dies, if it was a creature, return it to the battlefield under its owner's control. It's an enchantment. (It's not a creature.)
4/3
nvm, I found a spot for it in my list
I'm down to 32 lands (33 with sink into stupor) BUT my mana curve ~effectively~ stops at 4mv, and I've got 9 mana rocks, and 2.33 lands in my average opening hand
that feels like it ~should~ be ~fine~?
I still haven't put the list into paper yet (trying to finish blinging/foiling out my existing decks before starting a new one, but moxfield goldfishing has feel ~fine~ so far
Enduring Curiosity also proc's Jackdaw Savior, which is nice
I think it’s a real good include, especially for you can top your curve at 4 you should be fine
Yes, intend to add one to my Errant and Giada deck as well.
Along with the Azorious power 3 or greater Boardwipe and Permanent Hexproof Room.
I think those two would be fabulous includes.
I really need to reinvent my e&g list, it feels like it struggles against precons let alone normal decks
I suppose a fair question to ask is, what is the goal of your version of the deck? What do you want to be doing?
Also answering the pregame chat questions might help figure out what direction you want to go in
!pregamechat
Does it not work in threads? Cringe
Yeah i know about that
I don’t really have much of a theme
Just cast fliers and swing
But limiting myself to flyers and flash stuff as much as possible makes the deck inherently pretty weak
(Not that I assumed you didn’t know about it, just that its useful to keep in mind)
The issue with the deck is basically “if you play into e&g the deck is weak” vs. “if you play into fliers and better flying support just run kangee/kestral”
Like I wanna do e&g because the effect is cool
But damn if it isn’t a weak theme
Maybe opening up the theme a little more might help? If you add in some card selection that would help mitigate the downside of not being able to cast the top card with e and g
Like some scry or looting effects?
Pretty much every card I run that isn’t flash or flying is topdeck manipulation
Is there some way to put counters on fliers en masse?
Its not counters but [[rally of wings]] [[dictate of heliod]] [[force of virtue]]? Maybe?
Rally isn’t bad
Force of virtue I’ve considered because of high card velocity
Dictate of heliod is so fucking bad
Also its not fliers specifically but [[unbreakable formation]] is +1/+1 counters
Thats fairrrr but a surprise +2/+2 is underrated imo
Maybe i could do cathars crusade
Cathar’s’d be good, its a strong card
Idk, i just feel like as soon as someone has a flier with any amount of toughness I’m just dead
Fair
[[archetype of imagination]]?
[[nils discipline]]?
Legendary Creature — Human Cleric
At the beginning of your end step, for each player, put a +1/+1 counter on up to one target creature that player controls.
Each creature with one or more counters on it can't attack you or planeswalkers you control unless its controller pays
, where X is the number of counters on that creature.
2/2
[[web of inertia]]?
Those are the "cheapest" options based on MV
Nah I mean I wanna crack in and can’t
[[midnight pathlighter]]?
[[serra's emissary]]?
I always forget about that dude
Serra’s emissary is actually nuts, forgot about it
I like [[Thraben Watcher]]
Giving your creatures an anthem and vigilance and being a flier itself is just easy value.
True, and vigilance is extremely nice to have
Oh right, [[Inquisitorial Rosette]]
You like team-wide menace in azorius right?
Yes
You said azorius, so im in regardless of what flavour
@raw osprey
Here’s what I got so far
Kindred Sorcery — Shapeshifter
Changeling (This card is every creature type.)
Create an X/X colorless Shapeshifter creature token with changeling and deathtouch, where X is the number of land cards in your graveyard.
Retrace (You may cast this card from your graveyard by discarding a land card in addition to paying its other costs.)
The demon one won't do much for your deck I think
Ooh
[[demonic covenant]]
Kindred Enchantment — Demon
Whenever one or more Demons you control attack a player, you draw a card and lose 1 life.
At the beginning of your end step, create a 5/5 black Demon creature token with flying, then mill two cards. If two cards that share all their card types were milled this way, sacrifice Demonic Covenant.
I’ll have to look up the kindred stuff, I’ve just been trolling edhrec currently
Yeah that one’s not great
The deck’s tagged fwiw
I think I wanna fill out my removal suite too
I got some wipes in there but targeted removal is lacking a little
I want them to be two types, ideally
These are all the kindred golgari spells https://scryfall.com/search?q=commander%3Agolgari+t%3Akindred+format%3Aedh
Yeah, there isn't much for spot removal
[[lignify]]
That and [[eyeblight massacre]]
Sorcery
Non-Elf creatures get -2/-2 until end of turn.
"I've already seen so much evil, so much darkness. Why do you insist on adding more?" —Nissa Revane, to Dwynen
there's the changeling one that gives -3/-3 for 1b and removes all types
That one can be really strong
Even if it's not a strict destroy
I definitely considered that
Removing types being the important part
Hm
@rich pilot https://moxfield.com/decks/L1y4xrUFmE6wsJCmFncHjA
here’s what I got so far fwiw, I actually need help on a few removal options since I’m not terribly familiar with equipment decks
It’s sort of got an infect/toxic theme paired with general equipment, might pivot off to straight infect
Skrelv for meme?
I hate that I sort of like the Jeska/Sakashima idea too
It’s SO COOL
Any creature in your 99 can “be” your commander
Plus, it’s got redundancy through the magic of having two of them! (Multiple cookies for understanding that reference)
[[mindskinner]]
Legendary Enchantment Creature — Nightmare
The Mindskinner can't be blocked.
If a source you control would deal damage to an opponent, prevent that damage and each opponent mills that many cards.
It slices away the most precious memories first, then the mundane, until all that remains is blank, formless fear.
10/1
: Change a target of target spell or ability to Spellskite. (
: Exile any number of cards from your hand face down. Put that many cards from the top of your library into your hand. Then look at the exiled cards and put them on top of your library in any order.

.


: Thermopod gains haste until end of turn. (