#Sigarda Commander, looking for tuning advice.

33 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

bitter mica
#

This looks pretty close.to my own Sigarda list which is really tuned. I can share a link.

#

In my experience, you have to pick a lane, either auras or not auras and go with that. Mine is more non-auras

#

I'm also voluntarily not running artifact package, so you can change that if you'd like

glossy thicket
#

gotcha, thanks

sweet root
#

He's used Colossification more often to tap something if there's only one blocker.

glossy thicket
#

I've made lots of changes/cuts to my deck. Still need to cut a few cards though. Anyone have any suggestions on what cards I should cut? the land is just in a place-holder slot atm.

bitter mica
#

Some of my comments from my time with the deck:
I think you have too many "enchantress"es. You may just be sitting there spinning wheels without getting good threats.

Calix was pretty bad IMHO
I tried the 6-drop WG Ajani for while too. It was better but still not stellar.

Some cuts could be like drannith and grand abolisher.

#

Depending on how your meta does with those

#

You probably want at least 1 wrath/sweeper in there. Maybe ond the ones that let you keep a single creature or blows up all but commanders.

glossy thicket
#

Thanks for the feedback. Also, do you like Dueling Grounds or Ghostly Prison more?

bitter mica
#

Probably dueling grounds.

#

One note, I found Starfield of Nyx to be worse than it sounds. Your enchantments being creatures is actually decently bad, makes them vulnerable to sweepers and such

#

You may want an alternate wincon to sigarda in case something pretty bad happens like getting [[out of time]]

wicked finchBOT
#

https://scryfall.com/card/mh2/23/out-of-time?utm_source=discord

Out of Time <:mana1:292901508373282827><:manaw:1007102126813610074><:manaw:1007102126813610074>

Enchantment
When Out of Time enters the battlefield, untap all creatures, then those creatures phase out until Out of Time leaves the battlefield. Put a time counter on Out of Time for each creature that phased out this way.
Vanishing (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter from this enchantment. When the last is removed, sacrifice it.)

bitter mica
#

Whether it's Luminarch Ascension, Sigil of the Empty Throne, or similar

#

I just always like having a backup especially in voltron-y decks

glossy thicket
#

Good call, I was leaning o my empty throne and starfield as alternate wincons. I can remove the starfield, what would you recommend as the most competitive alternate wincon I could use?

bitter mica
#

I'd say Luminarch is faster, with the caveat that it can get you archenemy early if you drop it on 2

glossy thicket
#

Yeah, I had Luminarch in the deck originally. But my friend said it causes to much agro to quickly lol.

glossy thicket
bitter mica
#

Then do sigil. Or the white Court

glossy thicket
#

I currently have empty throne in the deck

bitter mica
#

Usually your first creature tutor is Argothian Enchantress anyways.

#

Prioritize the enchantresses with any ability on top of draw a card

#

So verduran, mesa would be first cuts imo

#

Another "pet card" I found for the deck was [[mana bloom]], cast for x=0. Lets you trigger all your enchantresses every turn for manag

wicked finchBOT
glossy thicket
#

Awesome, thanks the help!

#

Do you think I should use something like Mask of Law and Grace, or perhaps Benevolent Blessing instead of Commander's Plate?

bitter mica
#

I like commander plate here