sudden moth
hi all i got a isseu that all my bedrock clients are disconnected pretty quick and I'm trying to search for a solution but i feel more noob every second. I can't find it so I made a dump
https://dump.geysermc.org/FN65fsYN9hfQm8NXavYvEENkNxss0M7s
Is somebody able to guide me the correct way to solve this issue
median sinewBOT
hi all i got a isseu that all my bedrock clients are disconnected pretty quick a...
tropic hatch
hi all i got a isseu that all my bedrock clients are disconnected pretty quick a...
does that happens when the player types "/" for a command?
sudden moth
No, just wallking around, or chopping trees, or digging in sand, I've tested myself and it happens around 10 seconds after they are logging in
tropic hatch
No, just wallking around, or chopping trees, or digging in sand, I've tested mys...
show us the kick message
sudden moth
how do I do that?
tropic hatch
how do I do that?
join with bedrock and wait tell you get kicked
sudden moth
I dont see a message, the client is crashed when i'm disconnected
tropic hatch
I dont see a message, the client is crashed when i'm disconnected
oh really
any lag before that?
sudden moth
No lag at all
median sinewBOT
No lag at all
sudden moth
A piece of the log
[23
42] [epollEventLoopGroup-3-1/INFO]: /xxx.xxx.xxx.xxx:53559 tried to connect!
[2343] [epollEventLoopGroup-4-2/INFO]: Player connected with username MiWaMedia9345
[2343] [tcpClientSession-7-2/INFO]: MiWaMedia9345 (logged in as: MiWaMedia9345) has connected to remote java server on address xxx.xxx.xxx.xxx
[2343] [pool-3-thread-2/INFO]: Floodgate player who is logged in as .MiWaMedia9345 00000000-0000-0000-0009-01f3cbdb9845 joined
[2343] [Server thread/INFO]: .MiWaMedia9345[/83.87.121.126:53275] logged in with entity id 3140 at (-64.69999, 72.0, 60.45317)
[2343] [Server thread/INFO]: Floodgate player logged in as .MiWaMedia9345 joined (UUID: 00000000-0000-0000-0009-01f3cbdb9845)
[2343] [Server thread/INFO]: .MiWaMedia9345 joined the game
[2343] [tcpClientSession-7-2/WARN]: Downstream packet error! Cannot invoke "com.github.steveice10.mc.protocol.data.game.recipe.RecipeType.ordinal()" because "type" is null
[23:17:31] [Server thread/WARN]: Mismatch in destroy block pos: class_2338{x=-64, y=68, z=56} class_2338{x=-66, y=68, z=57}
[23
11] [tcpClientSession-7-2/INFO]: MiWaMedia9345 has disconnected from remote Java server on address 149.102.134.182 because of Bedrock client timed out
[2311] [Netty Epoll Server IO #65/INFO]: Floodgate player logged in as .MiWaMedia9345 disconnected
[2311] [Server thread/INFO]: .MiWaMedia9345 lost connection: Disconnected
[2311] [Server thread/INFO]: .MiWaMedia9345 left the game
[2311] [Server thread/INFO]: [voicechat] Disconnecting client .MiWaMedia9345
tropic hatch
hmmmmmmmmmmmmm
sudden moth
do you hava a clue? or do you want to know more?
tropic hatch
do you hava a clue? or do you want to know more?
i don't know this exactly, but i think it's because of other plugins, that's all what i can help you with
sudden moth
i don't know this exactly, but i think it's because of other plugins, that's all...
yeah, thats something i was thinking too but how to find out which one...
tropic hatch
yeah, thats something i was thinking too but how to find out which one...
there are some plugins that might relate to your problem, weak anti-cheats are one of them
sudden moth
i"m to noob to this matter... is there a wat to find out which one that is?
tropic hatch
i"m to noob to this matter... is there a wat to find out which one that is?
because it's a crash, no i don't think that you might know what plugin it is, kicks kicks will show the plugin that caused it
sudden moth
kicks kicks is a mod? command?
tropic hatch
kicks kicks is a mod? command?
no no not that, i meant the player getting kicked from the server and getting the kick message with an error or something
sudden moth
ohhhh ok, i need to figure that out...
tropic hatch
your problem is wierd and am not an offcial support :D, you may wait for a developer or try to figure it out
sudden moth
i hope somebody else have more tips and trucs too, I cant believe i'm the only one
sudden moth
your problem is wierd and am not an offcial support :D, you may wait for a devel...
ohhh really.. dang!! i need to search than i guess
sudden moth
I've remove almost all my mods but the issue is still going on... I give up! This is not working I guess
sudden moth
Nobody else has a clue to my issue?
median sinewBOT
Nobody else has a clue to my issue?
cosmic escarp
The client is kicked, or they actually crash?
sudden moth
The client is kicked, or they actually crash?
the client actual crash indeed
cosmic escarp
Could you send your server IP and what to do to reproduce the crash? I'd link to join and try to capture some packets
sudden moth
Sorry for the late reply... Working night shift is messing my live a bit
Address: 45.85.250.88
bedrock Port: 26567
Java Port: 26565
Just dig a dirt block with your hands, your clients will crash, walking around after 5 mins, your client will crash
sudden moth
@cosmic escarp did you succeed with logging in on the server?
cosmic escarp
I have been busy this weekend updating to 1.20.70 so haven't had a chance to join. ill take a look now
yep that sure does instantly crash my client
cosmic escarp
<@138054594595913728> did you succeed with logging in on the server?
when i try to join with standalone i get...
I'm of course even more confused given it says you're running geyser fabric
sudden moth
EUHMMM..... How is that possible, i really use FABRIC indeed, no forge for me
sudden moth
I have been busy this weekend updating to 1.20.70 so haven't had a chance to joi...
No problem, i was just curious of course.
sudden moth
when i try to join with standalone i get...
Looking in to it
cosmic escarp
i put this ip: 45.85.250.88 and port 25565
sudden moth
i put this ip: 45.85.250.88 and port 25565
Thats the Java port, pure fabric, i checked all the mods ๐ฆ
cosmic escarp
this is what happens when i try to join with a vanilla java client so
cosmic escarp
and on fabric:
if vanilla clients cannot join your server then bedrock won't be able to either
median sinewBOT
cosmic escarp
@sudden moth you're sure that's the correct ip?
sudden moth
if vanilla clients cannot join your server then bedrock won't be able to either
Ok, so thats a start to find a solution
sudden moth
<@695927014779125771> you're sure that's the correct ip?
Yes. 100% I'm logged in on the hosting party and that's what it said
cosmic escarp
seeing as its giving 1.20.1 as the version
sudden moth
otherwise this is also possible:
eu6285856.g-portal.game
nexusepulum.g-portal.works
sudden moth
This is not my server
cosmic escarp
well... thats the ip you said: 45.85.250.88
are you sure the port is 25565 and there's not an srv record?
sudden moth
yes, I see that but in my client I use: 45.85.250.88:26565 and I'm logged in on my server, so I really don't understand it (this is JAVA)
median sinewBOT
sudden moth
For bedrock i use: 45.85.250.88:26567
sudden moth
Oh, I was so confused about what went wrong... After years of playing, I thought I could do this, but it's harder than I expected.
cosmic escarp
well using my own geyser instance im not crashing immediately like i was on bedrock using yours
oop nevermind there i go
just took longer
sudden moth
Looking forward what you think what the problem is
median sinewBOT
Looking forward what you think what the problem is
cosmic escarp
idk this is a tough one since now im just not crashing
sudden moth
On java everything works without issues, what ever you choose to do...
on Bedrock everything goes wrong as soon as you start mining resources
cosmic escarp
well ive gotten past that part somehow... twice i joined broke blocks crashed right then
sudden moth
ohhh thats even more weird I guess
cosmic escarp
yeah idk im just not crashing anymore on my standalone instance
median sinewBOT
cosmic escarp
on yours though i still crash
sudden moth
java is reachable on 45.85.250.88:26565, is that the issue?
sudden moth
ohhhh ok,
sudden moth
I guess I did something wrong
cosmic escarp
and on yours as well I'm not after joining a few times
so idk if it only happens when the chunks first load in or something
sudden moth
so idk if it only happens when the chunks first load in or something
it happens the whole time with the bedrock players, so i wonder what is different with your version and theirs
cosmic escarp
im not really sure. could you try leaving so the spawn chunks unload when i leave?
sudden moth
i'm gone
cosmic escarp
yeah idk what to really do then... definetely did crash a few times but most of the time i dont
sudden moth
That's so weird. I want your bedrock client instead of the one I have because it's crashing the whole time as soon if i'm breakiing some block, even when i'm waiting for a few minuts it happens. And not only with me but also others from multiple locations...
cosmic escarp
what platform is yours?
sudden moth
But if you dont know it... I guess we dont kwno it either
From the Windows Store using the Windows 11 x64?
But I've got apple players too ans also phone users
cosmic escarp
doing my best to crash but its not happening xD
hmmm wait
do you have a mod that messes with tress?
sudden moth
haha, that's something different... Let me login to see if it happens to me too att his moment
cosmic escarp
because when i broke one the whole tree dissappeared and that crashed me
sudden moth
there i went ๐
cosmic escarp
hmm i see a pattern maybe but im not entirely sure. seems to happen only when i pick up items that are new to the geyser instance
yep... thats it
thats... really odd lol
sudden moth
yep... thats it
you found the reason, so thats amazing already!
very impressive , haha
I think it will make no sense now but hope you will find a reason for this strange behaviour
cosmic escarp
yeah thats a tough one... seems to happen right when the item is picked up though
cosmic escarp
@sudden moth could you try with this build and see if you crash? basically try to pick up as many new items in survival as possible
sudden moth
Sorry, I fell asleep yesterday! It was 4AM for me ๐
But I've removed the snapshot version, installed your version, and rebooted the server, so if you want, you can give it a try ๐
I've tried a few times to log in, log out, break some blocks, and walk; for now, I have zero issues! So, whatever you have done, you have found the solution!
Is this coming in the upcoming updates too? Or Should I never update till further notice?
cosmic escarp
Sorry, I fell asleep yesterday! It was 4AM for me ๐
But I've removed the snap...
it's already been updated
sudden moth
Your amazing good!! Thank you for that...
cosmic escarp
the issue was the server sending empty recipe update packets which apparently crashes bedrock
note i still was not able to craft anything on bedrock (not sure if that's intentional or not)
cosmic escarp
and on fabric:
but i wasnt even able to join java and see if that's the case since this
sudden moth
ohhhhhhhhhhh? Really... Euhm... I wasn't aware of this... On Java, you can craft things... Let me have a look at that.
median sinewBOT
ohhhhhhhhhhh? Really... Euhm... I wasn't aware of this... On Java, you can craft...
sudden moth
note i still was not able to craft anything on bedrock (not sure if that's inten...
Thats not intentional, so next issue ๐ฆ
cosmic escarp
well if you can get joining on a purely vanilla client working id check if thats the case on there as well
sudden moth
well if you can get joining on a purely vanilla client working id check if thats...
Yes, thank you for the tip! I will try to get it working like that
sudden moth
So I found out what it is; as soon as I've put in a mod that does something with blocks (any till now, it doesn't matter which one), then it will not work in bedrock. Is there a way to get those recipes in bedrock or to disable those recipes within bedrock via geyser?
cosmic escarp
cc @shrewd sage ^
shrewd sage
are all recipes broken, or just those that output these custom blocks?
cosmic escarp
All
cosmic escarp
ยฏ_(ใ)_/ยฏ
cosmic escarp
and on fabric:
.
shrewd sage
!!logs gonna need logs for this one.. if the client aint getting any recipes, geyser should be complaining about that
median sinewBOT
!!logs gonna need logs for this one.. if the client aint getting any recipes, ge...
sudden moth
are all recipes broken, or just those that output these custom blocks?
Euhm... i will clarify these a bit,
Situation 1: No mods. Java and bedrock both allow you to craft things with all recipes.
Situation 2: Just one mod (for example, "integrated-circuit") Java works, but bedrock doesn't have any recipes anymore.
shrewd sage
^ send a full log please for the second case
sudden moth
!!logs gonna need logs for this one.. if the client aint getting any recipes, ge...
I'm trying to get you all the logs! Because I don't know how I did it, but it happened!
Here you have a few uncensored ones
If you want to login @shrewd sage the details are here above mentioned
shrewd sage
well, the issue is fairly clearly seen here - you have a mod that's sending recipes without a recipe type, which fully breaks geyser's recipe translator
in other words, a vanilla client would also complain about the unknown recipe type
Geyser isn't designed for a modded server, since we don't know what mods do and don't do - if a vanilla client can join (which it doesnt seem to able to here), Geyser should work too. No idea how you're in a situation where a non-modded vanilla Java client cannot join but Geyser can; but that's ultimately what's causing the issues here
sudden moth
in other words, a vanilla client would also complain about the unknown recipe ty...
You can try to login with a vanilla client, that works, even with the mod there and its working, but instead of a mod, it's a data pack, so I guess i need to find a solution with that I guess
shrewd sage
this is what happens when i try to join with a vanilla java client so
^ kastle wasnt able to join with a vanilla client...
sudden moth
Geyser isn't designed for a modded server, since we don't know what mods do and ...
Thank you for the clear explanation tho! That makes sense
sudden moth
^ kastle wasnt able to join with a vanilla client...
I know but I 'm using a vanilla client and it works
thats why it make no sense for me
cosmic escarp
I know but I 'm using a vanilla client and it works
Can you send a screenshot of your F3 screen?