#Looking for critique

62 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

sonic pasture
#

I kinda finished this drawing but my rendering is always so bad x( im looking to take any critique about any part of the piece, the colors, the anatomy, the shapes... just anything you think it could either be improved or that i can have in mind for future pieces.

There is one thing in particular I kinda dislike and its that the face looks rather uninteresting compared to the rest of the piece but i don't know what more i can add to it, my eyes are always so boring x.x

#

(also i appreciate it a lot if u ping me when u answer so i know :3)

mortal oak
#

@sonic pasture hi!! Would it be okay for others do draw over your art, or you'd prefer not?

sonic pasture
#

ill post the refs

mortal oak
#

@sonic pasture Heyy truthfully I think the back was rendered rreally well. Ive just fixed up some things I noticed were off about the face, like Ive moved some things around I just uded liquify select and airbrush

#

Discords compressed it a lot you may have to zoom in

sonic pasture
#

Wait is my eye really that far high 😭

#

It was even higher before...

mortal oak
#

The little shadowI put to the left of the hair and the right of the eye maybe you should add an ear there or cover it up with hair

mortal oak
sonic pasture
sonic pasture
mortal oak
#

I mean in my one I cut off her face/ upper jaw at a point left of the hair like right around here I think is like more anatomically correct?? 100% im not an expert tho

#

Im not so sure how to draw an ear from this position tho sorry

sonic pasture
mortal oak
#

You have a couple good reference photos tho Id give it a shot

#

ye ye

sonic pasture
#

i just wasnt sure if the hair was covering the whole of it

#

hmm i understand how i messed Up the nose yeah

mortal oak
#

Yeah I thought the lower plane of the nose was a bit upturned. Ive also moved the jaw upward a lot so it looks like her neck reads a bit better too

#

I hope I was able to help!! Keep it up it looks real good

#

If you have an IG i can go ahead and support you too

sonic pasture
#

i dont really upload much but ty its theleletales and ty for help:3

maybe i try a better position for the eye while keeping It big i kinda wanted a semi anime eye, like semirrealism but.. It turned out boring

chilly gyro
#

She has a really realistic body and anime face I feel

sonic pasture
#

but i never get it to be good

tight oyster
sonic pasture
tight oyster
sonic pasture
#

the ref i was using had the lowest value shadow on the right scapula and I see you didnt even shadow that part but yours looks good not sure

tight oyster
#

Add some bright light's spots on the face to make it more 3d

tight oyster
sonic pasture
#

but the back part does or ar least thats was the attempt maybe i did It Wrong ;-; like It should be at least a bit darker or not?

tight oyster
#

Also women's body is more soft didn't has these sharp edges which men's body has

sonic pasture
#

that is true maybe the ref just has an extreme lighting set Up that my drawing doesnt really have so i didnt have to go that far

tight oyster
sonic pasture
#

like the biggest diff between your drawing and mine would be the huge shadowed area between the right scapula and the center of the back

#

the back pose is intended to be the one of the ref

#

i feel like a middle ground between both drawings would be more accurate? idk

#

not sure Cuz i basically tried to recreate that specific ref with just the head turned but maybe because the lighting isnt as dramatic in my drawing as It is in the reference i went too extreme when shading that part

tight oyster
#

But the shape itself

#

From my point of view that was sick back 😅

#

Like phiscaly that shadow u added on the right side of the back is way to strong

sonic pasture
#

yeye thats what I meant

tight oyster
#

Like a bone try to get out from her back

#

Darker part allways in intersections between surface's

sonic pasture
#

i was confused too when analyzing the reference maybe the sense i found in It was Wrong xD

tight oyster
#

And shade grade has to be divided by shape

tight oyster
#

Also when u rise the head to get that posture the back posture it's changing slightly

#

So the ref can't be fully the same

sonic pasture
#

maybe i shouldnt use refs that extreme so i can see the Bones and muscles better v.v but thanks for the input ill have everything in mind (:

tight oyster
#

Feel more free to experiment with it u can try to draw once again new art from scratch and after a while u can return to this one and rework it A_A_stars

sonic pasture
#

oh no i cant draw a single square without reference

#

not from stratch :c

tight oyster
sonic pasture
#

its always hard you know, first someone tells u, back is fine, change the face, Then someone tells u the exact opppsite.. But i think i got both points both can be improved a lot