which one is better

[vital goblet]

According to the lighting the first one should be accurate I think but the second one just looks right smh

[vital goblet]

which one is better

I'm talking about the shadow of her neckless btw

[shrewd wasp]

I think that you should bring the shadow much closer but on the right side

Also if you don’t mind, I have an anatomy tip

I went through and edited some of the changes that you can use for reference if you’d like

So here’s yours that you sent

And there’s the edited version

So by bringing the shoulder down, it creates a more natural feeling, and I’m sure you noticed the proportions on the face changed, along with the hair

Now they are both symmetrical

I brought the mouth further over to the left as well to line up with the cheek bone, and pulled her left eye slightly down, along with that cheek

I also edited the shadow on the necklace of course

[shrewd wasp]

I also cropped a bit off the bottom

[vital goblet]

Thanks but honesty i didn't wanted critique on other parts

[queen frigate]

I feel like you made the shoulder to broad in this edit

The OG looked fine

[trim nebula]

i think the first one works best since it follows the light source, but the shadow for the necklace itself should be softer since its not directly on top of the body

[oblique summit]

2 but only because it uses more shadows, the light has a dulling affect on the face and hair.