#questions-and-help
1 messages · Page 135 of 1
1.5m is 155.07?
yes
oh wait is it that number system I heard about where a million is a thousand thousand
or wait no
that's how it is normally
was it billion being a million million..
its 萬 not K
this feels like a made up concept to me
150k = 150,000
150W= 1,500,000
1k = 1000
1W = 10,000
this kanji stands for ten thousand so yeah
but yeah xD my point was at least block cant full auto
they can't?
nah its actually pretty bad on auto
I don't auto so I have no idea 
based
as far as i remember auto missmanages ur energy or smth at least in S1, but dunno never playd it
:( wow
you make so much energy in the first place it doesn't matter if you mismanage it
unless you end up in a bad situation
but that's the risk you run using auto in the first place
Semi auto is the way to go with most classes anyways : D
yes we do
oh no it does
we dont make that much energy until raid set either
you can auto on block and live somewhat, but dps drops off because of poor energy management
and when we get raid gear only around half our damage is shattered
you only use energy for countercrush though
i call sand crystals energy too
mf
xDDD
you only use it on granite though
hey its just 2 energy systems
how do you mismanage that
it's literally one button in your entire kit
idek
i never tried it just know general consensus was
Block can auto but decent dps loss, EF can't auto at all and if you wanna auto go block and accept the loss
yeah earth cant auto thats true
auto doesnt stack up the crystals, but yeah dunno how much loss you get on block, tho i think it cant be too much.
moonstrike can yeah but i wouldnt reccomend it
and beam is just
BEAM
go get some coffee or something
come back press 2 buttons
BEAAAAAM
its better if you only have those 3 on auto, or even deactivate scythe wheel if u rly want full controll for every situation xD
is it that bad if you dodge cancel scythe still
WHAT THE HASTE
yeah i havent crafted rorola yet, im not a whale haha
and i changed class on S2 release so yeah
i just quickly grabed those 2 to have perma 80%+ speed
cuz i had enough mats left over x`D
but no i dont activated both of them together
that would be a waste in 90% of any cases
the other 10% is just burning raid dragons or unstable
its not bad, its just you dont wana have the automode activate ur burst mode while a mechanic or huge aoe comes up
I agree but just because.. auto doesn't press skills as fast as it should for some reason..?
Hey… So quick question… 🙋 How do we earn luno on an alt with zero unbound luno?
wait what do you, you wana earn unbound luno?
if so then just use the crafting system
and sell ur stuff xD
WHAT ABOUT FOX
daily quest gives 6k
guild Cargo, daily activity box, monthly card free tap
woww
monthly card gives bound
idk never tried auto LMAO
Is that the guild quest? Alt isn’t in a guild…
im only repeating what i saw
yeah IK I just tried it
EWWWWW AUTO PLAYER
moons auto is a lot better but it's still pretty eh
decent dps loss either way
maybe it changes with raid gear later in the season
Ahh, Okay… Gotta actually do something with this alt before I can… Do something with this alt
i could if i wanted to, but nah thanks, im going for Rorola anyways, maybe i get her to S3 somewhere in the future so yeah
the only auto I accept is thundercut + basic on auto
or even better, just thundercut
to save people from getting hand problems ✨
it can still screw you up though just don't auto 🙏
i never rly tested it with a dps meter but it just feels wrong regardless.
I had full auto in S1 when i used moonstrike as secondary class for skin farm and it felt just wrong like i said : D
scythe wheel on auto is "okay" but yeah idk i might take it out when new raids are up
basic + thunder will stay on tho, dont wana screw up my hands again as i did back the days in Blade & Soul on Warlock Shadow spec -.-
the window to dodge is kinda small so unless you activate it yourself goodluck cancelling it
ok fair
how does this make u feel
ur class is the new wolf
that is true
why is their thundercut on 2 
lmfao
did more dps full autoing late game
yeah THATS ME at the end of S1 for dungeon skin farm on normal mode kekw
iaido got cooked that badly in the ocean huh
to quote this one cn player loosely
also have S3 MC rdy for the case that critmoon becomes a thing again later on x`D
early and mid game Iaido is competitive or in some cases stronger, the problem is late game it runs out of stats to stack and has very little increase
If a Iaido gains 10,000 DPS a Moonstrike gains 20,000 DPS from the same thing
they also blamed luck and haste being better than crit and mastery
its similar to how in s1 moon won at leviathan levels
but not f2p levels
Iaido runs out of stats to stack
MS keeps gaining then multiplies that if they can stack crit
Iaido gets enough mastery just from raid set
crit too
we stack some haste and vers and it doesnt scale as well
MS stacks luck and haste then has good scaling on mastery, good scaling on crit, can also build vers
Hahaha
makes sense
....xD
because they don't change scaling per class
we basically reach 100% crit rate too soon
so its like
max crit same issue as wolf
moon can't really stack crit unless whale though
yeah crit is kinda expensive but i mean at least it works x`D
36 mastery
without stacking any at all directly
if we use 6 pc raid ( cn saying 4 pc is better though, need to test why ppl saying we do 6 )
i get 6 early game
I'm gonna do 6 so I don't have to farm :D
but not in 160
that reminds me
how the iaido going
:D
it's
not going too good
I don't wanna put sigils on because they are too expensive
this sigil BS is making me consider just moving back to moon already
come back to tha dark side, the thunder void is calling you!
"the dark side" I was born in that shit
relatable
as someone who
wasted sigils on full set
says the guy with full purple sigils
another reason I'm considering just quitting doing content
I don't wanna afk at shit
droprate is way too low to bother
What's the max amount of field per homestead?
20 per player
NO
DONT DO IT
WE NEED U
thankfully another person who just hates that afk BS
u carried me in dungeons
💀
Uh I think I placed 21
havent farmed void in S1 and i defo wont farm cocon in S2 aswell.
ts isn't carrying
tyfc
i had so much excess i even sigil for my tank x.x
this rly is afk season but
its not mandatory
u will catch up its just early game it seems big
yup : D
best lifeskills to sell now for unbound luno?
I'm considering playing the game as my side game now
which means dropping the game
Nvm
cause I don't keep side games
its only worth for the flex but thats about it, in the end the only real diference will always be whale vs f2p
this is the only "dry week"in s2 dw
How do we delete a field from inventory
what
they release master dungeons yeah
then you max out, then m6 (the same exact thing but again)
and then it's done
o lemme see brb
Apparently they'll add pvp
I don't want pvp
Huh
it changes a lot
ye its just S1 all over again, some things are better in S2 some are worse. Theres a lot of stuff that they couldve changed with S2 but they didnt, maybe S3 will finaly a game that feels complete xD
season 1 was way shorter though
I'm playing for the story
so the dead weeks were okayish
see and that's why there's no point in playing
story is over until s3
Real
ye i know what u mean
I wasn't really that offended at the start of the season since the story was there but now the story's over and it's back to feeling like the end of s1 with absolutely nothing to do
Who's your favourite character
ye its rly sad ._.
airona
Airona + Rorola for me, rest of the cast is idk decent but sometimes just annoying idk
yah lazy to math but looking at gems selling mats alone is higher profit lol
it's kinda impossible to like any other character much more
unless you only care about their appearance
since airona is the only one who ever gets screen time
Paimon from genshit impact. after that experience you never gonna hate any character ever again cuz you lost your ability to feel hate below anything that isnt on paimon's level.
so i personaly dont rly hate any character in this game, i simply just dont care about them at all
and yeah no screen time anyways thats also a thing
The game’s story is pretty basic ngl
I don't like Airona very much....
indeed as it is the case with literaly every anime style MMORPG
That and personality
Personally I don't like Darya
Why
Likes to take the praise, unknown background and doesn't tell us much about herself.. lets us do all the dirty work [but that's like everyone lol]
fair point tbh
Does Starshine oil replace potion of they can be stacked together? asking because they both have same duration
They can be stacked I think
I guess I'm gonna commit the "fudge around and find out" phase
Hmm I'm not sure she likes to take the praise and we'll find out about the background later tho she has a good personality and care about us
Who's your favourite character?
Don't really have a favorite .. for personality .. for looks it goes to Boyce lmao.
They dont stack
Lol
And which character do you like the least
Did you try
Yup, you?
Where do we check if they stack or not
your buff bar
Ok ty
I mean.. other than the obviously evil ones.. the 'good' characters I don't have a favorite or one I hate. :p
What about Darya
She rob people and beef with Boyce
I like her design but she's sus. Need more info on all of them anyways.
Thank you
Question for the tanks… What stat do you guys prefer for your food? Armor or Endurance? (not considering DR bonus)
Are you by chance a HG
This a good chart
This is the only "dry" week
only thing happened this week are the lvl 2 life skills 😔
yeee thus the dry week content wise
oh btw this chart have the gear refinement dates wrong
gasp
Just wait for 140 gear
been 3 hrs
569560 before
700k after
so roughly 44k per hour full afk

i dont see how this is different than what I said
I don't see it as not having content o.0
Sigils get higher drop rates so it won't really matter if you farmed early
I see it as having more content than s1
It's the same gameplay loop but more content
I don't see the problem with that?
Besides the weekly selector
Isn't that every mmorpg
m1 is the exact same as m20 except for hp/damage
unless they changed it this season, which is doubtful
Ehh M1 you kinda ignore all mechanics no?
But
I don't see the problem with that either
it's difficulty modifiers
many games, even the old ones like WoW or Dragon Nest had difficulty modifiers
I don't either o.o
as far as Im concerned, we have 6 dungeons and 3 raids upcoming that get slightly harder versions over time
for like, 6 months
It's pretty much s1 you just get roguelike like an extra
And content a bit harder
Mechanic wise
If you waiting for feedback to be implemented
That's s3
yaa
yay more cosmetics to buy for a limited time
That's what global ask for so
No, I’m asking from an economic/trade perspective. Supply and demand
Giv more cosmeticsTM
i suggest not making food if you want money
Sell rocks if you want money
I think the main differing in opinion is, some people see harder difficulty modes new content and some people don't.
To me 6 dungeons and 3 raids with varying levels of difficulty is already enough content, that's plenty especially for a new MMORPG ( more than many of them ) not even going into events or the roguelike.
i can be fine to say raids are new content but m1 being the same as m20 aside from hp/damage is just ridiculous
While yes, ores are good money guaranteed… My analysis is showing far superior options (at least early on)
why dont you ask the hg and sk channels what they prefer

Nah, long term the markets Fd
Does China have the next part of the story and Master tier of life skills?
As in the 3rd tier like with Season 1
I made quick money in gemcraft in s1 then dipped to smelting n now I dig rocks
Do w/e you think is best
i crashed the emerald market asap
Food is high rush high reward but low demand
Ocean users ain't getting food until like m20, unless they carry friends or do sub minute farm runs
And that's your major target for food
Yeah, Might just throw out some bait.
If it sells, maybe I restock, if not I just won’t make more (not gonna hurt to see)
did they fully scratch out the dark mist one
how do i get far sea as an f2p?
which one is better veno or BL ?
I mean in m1/m6 you're allowed to ignore a lot of mechanics and less punished for not knowing or doing things and things just die fast
So plenty of people when I helped for m16 clears, didn't really know what actually doing the fight entailed.
i just wait for a better gear?
be very smart about your luno and imagine progress
for my shield knight
ideal progress is to flip everything on the market and not spend your luno otherwise
you can get the 100 version for looks eventually but to actually be usable? doesnt happen really
relying on people to carry you for your things
10 hours of afk'ing today. 331813 xp total [excluding the exp from dailies]
and then when you amass 100m luno
you convert that into your farsea

for context that will take you approximately 20 months on just focus
assuming you max out luno income
90 day timer on resales w/that GL 
i mean
there are ways to flip around and there are items that are always in demand
just because there's a 90 day doesn't mean you can't do it
just saying
main thing is buying cheap gacha out and sell later but like
w/o monthly card perks
your gains might be eh
gains is gains when you're gated by daily focus as an f2p
otherwise just pretend ocean doesnt work
and just t5 your stuff and 666 purple and then call it a game
I mean more so the problem as f2p is despots on things that dont sell high when time to flip
praying we actually get a valentine event let me swipe for cute heart theme'd weapons and/or outfit pls
a cupid outfit
probably
you will find out on the 9th/11th when CN gets theirs
do you think it will be that late?
its confirmed to be those dates
on the cn server notifications
yeah I saw that not my type of outfit, I'd rather get current gacha outfit or next
I dont have funds for 3 gacha outfits w/o massive luck
but pretty sure I burned my luck on the idol outfit
ocean weapon, majority t5 imagines, 6/6/6/6 modules
you spent money

pay 2 win generally is a large margin
but basically paying enough to have a significant advantage
6 module? like, gold?
This, to me M1/M6 is the same as "hard" difficulty is right now
Idol fit was worth it

Ohhh
I mean like spending only difference maker realistically for m20 try-hards
its more like p2fashion 
reallll
you can get 6/6/5 modules w/luck though as f2p
but 6/6/6 is a 
I have like 5 different EF combos that one step short of 6/6/6
I just life wave through content since s1

unless am on heavy guardian
then am kinda just winging it

sadly those are cooked on my modules
they give me 10 but with shitty random stats that doesnt even work
life wave alone provides so much stats that I just run it as the only lv6
so this is the only one that beats everything
i mean you are with 2 level 6
thats the s2 upgrade
s3 am getting 2 lv 6s
after I get my dmg stack for my sub specs

playing 3 specs pretty hard with this module economy

sooo trueee
no
people say that cause there are no players but in reality they are only looking on steam
and not on other platforms
the first BP died cause the gameplay & game systems were lowkey ass & too generic
but the way it looked
LORD HAVE MERCY
that would be too good to have those graphics again
it doesn't take THAT many players and spenders to sustain an MMO
omg is that kinich
they are the parent company
cyrene?
Yeah my icon is her 
game borked x-x restarted computer, reinstalled steam, reinstalled bpsr.. nothing
might be steam that's borked x-x
it might be steam again
yeah I think it's steam x-x
it's okay.. I didn't need to do dailies or anything.. x-x
simply dont log off
I didn't have a choice.. it froze on me lol

well I think that's why.. though why Seattle is bugged out.. uh..
you have to change them to members
but
if you drag the bar where you see the thing you can remove them
its hidden
oh lets see
yeah it was something I dont understand why that happens
@tawdry pier drag it
it can act up sometimes
trust me even I have to deal with this as a sub leader for my guild xD
im no getting any loot or exp if in coconn party, bug or feature?
i can use healer but whats the point in party then?
i mean look in system log....
oh yeah let me just log in to your account real quick
just show pictures xD
even a video would be nice
if u want comparison, i am getting exp
cursed video, there you go
well cuz its i hit it
ehm, point of party?
guess its "fixed" now, kek
I know it was already answered but just adding additional context
You need to either heal someone who hit it, hit it yourself or have the enemy target you
Being in a party does nothing ( Monster hunt doesn't even work for cocoons )
To this day I don't understand why people party for these things
i can think only of jumping back on needed line when cooldown off, but maaan
You know what it's time to do...
party leader accepted you that means he agree to share xp and loot, isnt that enough of consent for contribution
LMAOO
are u rly 67
pls tell me where u afk
LOL NO I WISH
dang you that old?
this is from last season getting people to 3650
i hate this system. almost everyone is a lifebind now
would have been better if it was like other games where if you are in proximity and in a party, you get loot and exp
Pov: you submit to the new raid boss
I'm level 60 and finished main quest what do i do now?
It's a guy that's dressed a guard. He should be to the left of where you're facing in this photo (near the black elevator thing)
Hidden among these, there are proper healers... don't underestimate the power of Smite
ye smite turbo broken but i think i see lifebind skill casts only 
Hello I'm new here and in - game are there and other redeem codes the still work?
I'd bet you can see these waves. They are quite similar to LBs ones
anyone know how rorola imagine effect works? is the dmg % part of alll the other dmg% or is it separate final dmg %
naw not looking for the wave
their hands
lifebind is dead giveaway'
Well, the people up on the rock are only lifebinds... Smite just moves no matter what you do xD
or it could be smites with LB skills
but you still have an occasional marksman between all these
but look, here's two more smites 
Hey yall quick question !! How do you increase your illusion strength? Is it through getting better gear and reforging it? I'm just a little confused, I'll take any tips I can get 🙂
Afaik the only sources of IS are:
-Deep slumber psychoscope (through the imagine slots)
-Leveling up the season level (+7 per level)
-Gear reforging
Okay and one more question (probably an obvious one) but how do I level up the season level? Is it through quests?
You get season level exp by doing daily season hub activities, gaining exp from completing monster hunt log and completing s2 quests
Your biggest source of exp to level up the psychoscope tree will be the daily activity exp
Afk farming is super tedious and not worth it for the exp alone imo
You should be afk farming for factor drops and sigil shards not the exp as it's super inefficient
Youll gradually level just playing the game daily, and everyone will be similar psychoscope tree level once new area/quests come out
So dont feel the need to afk grind with your pc on 24/7
thank yall very much!! ❤️
say that to the level 64's

wtf this game keeps crashing and when it does it force closes my browser and deletes cookies so i have to relog in everywhere....what in the hell....
( I have no such settings in place )
Literally just happened again xD
Game is freaking out - sat doing nothing and cpu is 25-50%, games using 6gb ram and gpu at 80 % xD
chrome is about to crash again as its struggling to load a new tab....
how do i see which type of verdant oracle i am
ty ty
is there a macro i can use for auto boss farming? auto lines and all
How the heck there is already +60/+65? i tried to afk for 8 hours - didnt even get 1 lvl
oh season pass i see how to win stimen 30 now
season pass dailies give you 800k per day
you gotta afk farm the rest
i mean its supreme boost + 10 lvl of pass
supreme only adds 10 lvls to your battlepass level, not your dream lvl lol
what is activity merits +20%? its not exp?
this thing
basically its useless since its so easy to hit 500 merits per day doing regular shit anyways
so its its really only afk farm?
yup
its like in meme, while you fishing - your "enemy" gets stronger
Oof -- that's one is going to be harder to get one. Got to tell the players that quit to reinstall the game
wha
nah
Oh my bad, I had just woke up and was so confused haha
guys im at lvl 60 now how do i progress?
SEA server or GLB server
what do toys do?
what to do with old jank like this
nothing. itll stay in your inventory forever 🙂
they cause special effects just for fun
what BP gb size now?
damn mine 50
might need to reinstall
steam or their launcher?
launcher
yeah you need to go inside the game folder and delete the older versions
u can erase the game 1.8 version
since they for some reason dont do it when you update
oh i see , just need to delete that then , TQ TQ
thanks👍
did these events give gear boxes in global? i want to min max my purple lines but boss farming is kinda boring and slow while finding an m6 spam team is hard cause everyone else is chasing mastery points rn
but it took longer to buy the full price one via loom, and the option to run with bots is available for SEA next week
theres limited amount that u can buy with half price, was 10 box or something
We had 5 level 80 select box for 400 flowers each I think ? Then unlimited for 1000
With how little the event dungeon gives, not really worth it unless you plan on running it many times
how many days for the returner event to appear?
game/steam still borked 
are we getting 140 gears this monday?
Think you need be offline for 14 days
yes though dungeon roll out gradual
why crusade give reputation to s1 area? any way to farm rep for s2 area?
Is this correct? the only difference between the recipes is a 2% chance for extra shards
it does seem like it's correct
you get 0.01 more shards on average ✨
finally got it fixed t-t 13 hours later.. a complete steam uninstall [again], reboot, fresh install from website, then reinstall bpsr [again... ]
the main difference is that it's a guarantee of the drop you wanted
if you needed both from a dungeon, then it's faster to run through it a bunch of course, but if you only need one piece loom is faster
even so, you can semi-afk loom and you can't with dungeons (aside from kanamia I suppose)
Is anyone else having issues with mob grinding, where 5 minutes after starting the grind, (either steam or launcher), the game decides to just stop responding?
I’ve had no issues leaving my PC on continuously since S2 launched, so why the issues now???
you need to smelt hundreds of ore before you notice the savings. 😂
fr
Not true… You should be getting 40xp per ingot
huh
we're talking about output, not xp values 
refinement mats give me x120 exp iirc
Ohh, Just 1? I haven’t tested focus smelting yet so I guess I’ll shut up 🤐
no its not 1
i dont bother with focus smelting anymore. i just use free mats to lvl my refine lvls
it shows they increased the rate to get more but on average you still get a bunch of 1x

thats what we were memeing
whats the current percentages for the new ore now? i havent checked it. i simply just sell all the ores i mine
Where can we actually get a value for that data? Aside from just estimating an average from our own results…
No, that’s outputs for non-focus life skills. I meant focus related life skills
You sure?
I’ve been helping him collect S2 data for that guide, so I’m sure
@plain valley I get the game hanging in the big afk areas too - Shaman in particular.
Crept up in frequency over time, seems to be when the cameras close and theres a load of things going on at once.
Game using 3.6 ram now but goes to 6 there
Hmmm 🤔 So maybe if I turn off all effects and set the graphics to min… ? Worth a try tonight at least
how do you guys farm friendship points now
50 per with bots after capping stones - any other idk, I always have absolute minimum of the currency since day 1.
I don't really bother with friendship points
but running w/ bots is probably best way to farm.. [makes no sense]
Even better way, party up with an alt of yours (preferably one with a sprout) and boot up a normal dungeon with the bots…
Get yourself friendship points, and complete some challenges while you’re at it
I'm going to be dragging my returnee alt through some dungeons at some point soon here for hidden achievements X'D
Running with bots is also mind numbingly boring and buggy/broken xD
Nah it's not that bad :p Except for ones where not doing the mech = you die.. that's kind of annoying.
Did you get one of those hidden trophies as well? I thought I was losing it when I received a previous non-existent trophy achievement
Not yet but I know there are 2 for running with returnee's and my alt qualifies for that so x3
Yeah, I got the returnee #1… Then I noticed there’s supposedly 3 other achievements hidden under the same tab
Yeh you have to aggro stuff for the bots to wake up/turn on. X3
There's 2 I think. 3 non-hidden ones for newbies and 2 (possibly 3 though?) for returnees.
I wonder if one of those hidden ones is worth a gold trophy… 🤔 maybe?
there's a serious lack of gold trophies so far so I hope so T_T
There’s enough to max out the season title without spending on the will, and without farming 320 dungeons with a friend… but yeah, there’s not much of a margin there
S2 still lack gold tropies? Yikes.
Should have different options. 
16 by my count
Yes, 16 we know about, 14 needed to max out the season title without - correction, 13 needed
pretty sure there were more last season
so you had more options
and I'm not a fan of hidden achievements
I think it’s cool to have hidden achievements in single player games, if those achievements require you to do something normally players would never do (resulting in funny gameplay moments)
I wouldn't mind them so much in a single-player
but when they're part of the season armband.. please don't hide them XD
Wait there were hidden achievements last season?
no, this season
They are preparing us for the future where our only friends are bots
if im to afk gloomy cabbage, is 1360 the minimum? or can i do it at 1311 with a party
0 is the minimum
That's what we did when we were severely under the IS
rip that sacrifice below
LMAO
is this afk or did you just stay until the elite died
afk
o.0
I am so confused
Why is
Meowlux card
1.5m in the shop
when
You can just buy a random costume head / back
for 1.3m
and dismantle it
And get the same x1 card
Or buy a costume / mount for 4.3m and get 5 cards
Manipulation and deceit
players are bad at math
anywho i think the trading center is kinda cooked for f2p
prices on focus goods keep bottoming out
86% gpu to stand still xD
my ore farming is dying T.T
is this on high settings?
players arent holding the line. they keep trying to undercut one another 
i need to look into whats profitable later
im pretty sure its still ore but it sucks lol
DAMN IT MY PARLAY
surely best profits dont suck
it sucks that profits are dropping steadily is what i mean lol
Where can i submit Level 1 or 2 Starforge crystals for higher level one?
class change npc
Is there some sort of exploit going on that is allowing people to put things on the trading center less than the allowed price? It is ruining competition
check under the boss's hp bar
nah its just the devs injecting shit
they'll deny it of course
this one ?
yeah
so only boss I can track q wq
Injecting wills is kind of evil lol
no, there is an undertalked about feature in the pricing system is tied to orb consignment sales
so variations occur due to median price of that shifting
so basically inflation
but in a game
smh
more so counter against it I think since luno to orbs is taking luno out of the economy
This
there is no dev injection
lol
Each item on the trading center has an internal "rose orb" cost, and then the Luno price is obtained by multiplying that by the consign exchange rate (probably the median of the orbs sold over some timeframe).
For example, the max price of a Meteorite Mech Shard is "21 orbs" or 498 x 21 = 10,458.
However, if the median price of an orb goes up to 499, then the max price will increase to 10,479 and so on.
This feedback is uninformed:
#feedback message
#feedback message
We really do need downvotes or at least threads to refute some of the dubious feedback given there. Doesn't do devs or players any justice to have low signal-to-noise in that channel. Any chance <@&1372169443110813706> could modify?
community notes needed for feedback
While every piece of feedback is seen and valued, not every piece is implemented. Devs know bad feedback when they see it (usually)
But also that’s channel permissions so it would need to go further up the chain than us, so I’ll propose it to the bosses for you
"every piece of feedback is seen and valued" > I'm referring to feedback like this, that is factually incorrect:
STOP INJECTING STUFF INTO THE MARKET
The Trading Center NEEDS to be CONTROLLED BY THE PLAYERS and NOT the Developers... It is so annoying when we are unable to sell any of our stuff because your undercutting us. I'm forced to sell it at 28,685 while your undercutting me at 28,628 and added basically 9,999 stock so now I won't be able to make a dime off of these orbs for the foreseeable future. YOU ARE KILLING YOUR GAME.
Even Twitter/X has "community notes"
Every piece of feedback being seen and valued just means the devs DO read the feedback and people who submit good feedback are appreciated.
But, again, devs can usually see bad feedback and won’t implement it
Just because someone types “Tina is too tall, she needs to be 3’10” doesn’t mean the devs are gonna say “well it’s in the feedback channel so we gotta do it”
I just feel like people shouldn't be able to throw 💩 down the laundry chute, even if someone is down there to clean it up
Well I passed it along to introduce threads st the least so yall can dunk on eachother
As per request
looking forward to verbal pvp 
True endgame
I'll be ready with the popcorn
how often can you water hydrangs
3'10"? she needs to be 6" so she cant fit in the pocket xD
I know I am blocked but lmao believing that there is no injection in this game is just willful ignorance at this point
If you want the most damning example, it’s mist chests being printed nonstop as soon as nightmare ice dragon released, ~45 being listed all in the same time window
Dev injection has been known since the betas and CN talked about it 😭
Even consign is manipulated to some degree
PVP happening?

Mist chest is 100% Devs injected. It never down 45 and stay around 50 consistent
Week 1 of launch I (and others) had orders for millions of luno being fulfilled extremely quickly despite the extreme improbability of that much currency legitimately existing in the game
It wasnt dev injection though
It was fisherman injection
devs actually had a statement saying they didn't inject anything
Bokura never has stated they don’t inject. Only Aplus has and it was widely considered to be laughably false
I don't remember them making a statement like that
respectfully, I don't think APlus has anything to do with this game on a technical level
Global had like what, less than 10 people banned for 10 years of exploiting?
Definitely them printing mists 
Not to mention that you only have 1 unstable a day to rig
They mostly copy whatever Bokura does, so them claiming that they (APlus) don't inject could just be on a technicality (Bokura's system does)
Thanks for this detailed explanation
There is no other explanation for ~45 mists being constantly listed on the market 24/7 since they were available in season 1 other than the system artificially generating them
The droprate isn’t remotely high enough to support it even with 1 million players
And you can only rig unstable once a day, on top of the exploit to do it being known by very little players
Also, didn’t people get access to the test server in global and the market there was also printed to hell and back with no players

as a market speculator, there have been 3 major items that were clearly injected. The first was within the first few weeks when skill books were injected (especially for popular dps classes like stormblade and marksmen), where up to 500 books were just put into the market at once, the next was with the ores used for refinement, and lastly the wills back when we had shortages
Those were all early on in the game, so it was easier to see when they zeroed out and then got topped up
There's a statement for the "500 books" already that debunked it
what's the statement?
For sure I have always believed that Mist Chests are injected by devs, since suspiciously, they've been removed from Notice - Growth Items.
However, I have yet to be convinced that other items are injected beyond Mist Chests
Was in news channel or something back then, they said they had nothing to do with the books and the system instead threw a bunch in at the same time listed by actual players
Nobody who actually understands how the game works believes Frankie’s statement, not to mention that the publisher nor the developers will obviously never come out and explicitly admit injection exists
Books were very blatant at launch
Even happened in beta
oh I didn't believe that statement because when I was doing the same book one after another, they would get listed at different times
If anything this has the best evidence backing it yeah, everything else makes no sense for me, just people screaming injection xD
I just assumed Frankie was making stuff up bc they didn't know the internal systems
You don't think books could've simply been due to tens of thousands of players opening Basic Star Chests?
oof
its always that one dude with the trust me bro source lol
sry Frankie 🙏
No, not in the quantities and time frames books got listed
Beta was the most egregious
@.franki-
furthermore, it was very clean numbers
Like we had 10k beta players and that’s not even concurrent?
whole clean 100s
But suddenly hundreds of books started appearing at once
I never saw clean numbers, I saw many many random.
Plus
clean numbers would be odd regardless of how you look at it
Because it means nobody, not even whales bought any
Mists and throne golds came in consistently clean numbers
So that doesn't really explain anything either
yes, that is why it is especially suspicious
Everything else has a set range
Well I saw something completely different xD
and then you see like 57 sniped in the first 5 seconds
Modules for example definitely got injected but the number wasn’t consistent
I remember day 1 of modules, I cleaned out every tank module, and suddenly like 200 got listed at once

Ores used for refinement was botted unfortunately
I have evidence of that too
oh yeah I've seen the ore bots recently
the new accounts all mining
Ore botting exists but I doubt it’s enough to budge the market as much as injection, nor does it explain injection below min price
You can't "inject below minprice" that's the price of the orb inflating
it happened in CN, even when taking the inflation into account
Also mists got removed from notice due to a recent update to make it harder for people to script them
I know a lot of players in #feedback are kind of dumb by saying, "OMG the old 17 hour ones are 1 luno less"
Do you have a screenshot?
but in CN, it was actually true that newer quantities had lower prices
let me find in the database server
There's a really obvious and logical explanation for everything people claim is injected besides possibly the ocean weapon material chest, so yeah I agree with that being plausible but everything else is just heresay and extreme speculation/doomge imo.
At least, I haven't seen any solid proof of there being any actual injection going on, and we even have a developer statement saying it's not so... I'd rather have some faith in that rather than cope with a conspiracy with flimsy evidence at best.
Frankie is not a dev
Frankie is more of a community role
oh
He’s a member of an understaffed publishing team who almost certainly doesn’t have the complete know how of what’s going on with the game’s systems
ok I couldn't find screenshots in database quickly, but I did find other reputable CN people who have stated it was true
this is from Chishiya
There are no devs here, the devs are all in China and do not communicate directly to global
dang me using Chishiya as evidence 😭
To be fair
that just sounds like people getting and selling it
lol
Omg next day ( reset )
Unstable dropped let me sell
they've also talked about other items
People noted injection happening even after they increased trade cooldown from 7 days to 30 days
In the first month of China launch
It’s also not the first time a Chinese game did this
regardless, I'm not going to argue too much with friends about injection. I think there are a lot of other issues with the market that makes it clear that they want players to spend money in the game for most aspects, and not enable regular means of earning currency

lower trade cooldown 🙏
I feel like the timing and volume of stuff arriving on market does not definitively prove injection. Other than Mist Chests, I'm still not convinced.
For all you know, they could implement the market in batches / waves of neat amounts, so it's more efficient to send updates to all the players.
For reforge stones, if 5000 players do 2x unstables, that's 10k rolls, you would only need a 10% drop rate per unstable to see 1000 stones listed on market...
I’ve said it before that the systems are deliberately designed to frustrate you into spending
It’s not to “prevent burnout” from grinding
Not enough reforges? Swipe. Behind on refines? Swipe
Missing a bit of luno to get something because daily life skill and guild turn in only gives so much? Swipe
Some of the stuff they simply don't need to inject, like refines, players craft plenty of those.
Some of the things that could be injected, like Muku Chief wills, are seemingly not. Although, you have a gacha avenue for swipers for that, which makes them more money
However, will and imagine materials have other avenues of acquisition
They inject the starforges
By injection, Bokura would directly compete with their own will gacha and 400 rose orb imagine mats
This is why they barely inject wills if at all
Furthermore, I have not gotten a single imagine mat mystery store appearance (with reroll from the season pass) for S2 thus far
It's very clear that they've either removed or lowered the rate for those appearing in mystery store significantly
also on a side note, I am cooked by everyone making meteroid mech shards. It's the 2nd day we could've made them, and they're at min price already
gg
everyone and their grandmothers saved >50 lifeskill pots and saved 2000 focus
ive got 5...
I highly doubt it, I think players are selling starforges and not enough people are buying
😠 give me 2
This, theres no point in buying anymore with converting
why bother injecting starforges when there's already thousands from players?
do you guys think it's because they want me to spend my rose orb savings
like u can buy a lvl 2 for 28k
or
you can make one for 4k and useless mats
omg fund me
omg 15 mil unbound luno
no but ud get it way sooner!!
40?
yeaaa
LOL
I could increase it by 50% right now
but if I sell them for 6.3 mil in profit, I can double it with the newer outfits only
Because tradeable ones don’t drop often enough and the bound ones you get aren’t enough to max the system out, not to mention the droprate is weighted towards level 1 lol
And refining is not 100% success
Nor is it mathematically worth trying to make it 100%, so people don’t do it
So the devs inject starforges at the bottom of the price range?? Doesn't make much sense to me, they make less money injecting at the bottom vs at the top
And all the starforges are minprice for a while now. Pretty sure its high supply and low demand
and the anecdotal evidence is you can look at players like #feedback message who have bags with many unsold starforges
Anyone who says they are injecting starforges is just flaming.
Like it's just an insane lack of critical thinking for anyone to come to that conclusion
I refuse to believe anyone is actually thinking that and instead choosing to flame and fake being oblivious
Only way I can beat mirth now is if outfits start getting reruns lool
Any Chinese knowers have an idea how "roguelike" = "meat pigeon"?
HOW DO YOU HAVE SO MUCH
Hoarding since day 1 + battle pass and monthly card
Sob
60k 
It's nothing special lol I've just been mining and selling my ores since day 1.
cough nerd.
a community mod saying this is wild 😭
They were injecting them at the start when people needed them in mass quantities
And at max price
Obviously now there isn’t a need to mass buy level 1s and 2s
Like, have you not paid attention to starforges in s1 selling out when refine uncaps got raised, and suddenly tons more would get listed at max at the same time
u got me, i was farming then and selling it 

If by "injecting" you mean the devs can look at their metrics and see they have XXXX number of players who are rolling for drops, and they can set the drop rate on the backend at Y% so they can be confident that a certain number of drops will be listed on the market, then yeah I agree they could be "injecting" starforges
What
i’ll come clean too. i was fishing and sold all the glints for whales. your welcome
Unstables, boss keys, and elite keys drop tradeable starforges. If you play multiple alts that do unstables, boss keys, and elite keys, you'd see just how high the starforge drop rate is (relative to demand)
You severely overestimate the number of people playing alts
Sweaty players, especially f2p sweats, fill their homestead with alts for food and potions
Also this does not explain starforges being immediately listed in mass quantities after they got sold out post-weekly resets where refine cap got raised in s1
Do you think devs were injecting Meteorite Mech Shards too? Or just player supply vs demand?
….and how many f2p sweats are there with multiple alts doing all possible tradeable starforge content lol
Meteorite definite injection
Idk if you all have played sea.
I don’t get the mental gymnastics some of you are coming up with to defend an unscrupulous developer doing something that the entire Chinese server unanimously acknowledges as happening
watched a friend buy the mechs out and it'd just get injected with hundreds more
But I was playing sea and everything on the market there is min price.
No no no, it’s just the alts!
and then itd sit at that same amount consistently

like growth doesnt just spike back to a flat number and stay there
same with mists and etc;
Also like 150 meteorites listed day 4 or so of s2 when you couldn’t make them
you would see a consistent growth in mists and not plateau at 50

I mean if it’s not injecting then what is it?
and if a whale dumpster bought all the mists
There are people here claiming it’s not injection but real players and their alts lmao
Do you realize you're playing an MMO with thousands of players (even at lowest population) and many of those players are crafting lifeskills to sell...
then the market should stay at 0
No other way to explain why 42 glints always would reappear on the market whenever they are sold out. In the exact same quantity.
Life skill =/= to shit like starforges
Or stuff you can’t even make like meteorites at the start of s2
meteorite mech shards before you could craft them is the argument
Mists I can see an injection argument
Meteorite Mech Shards, ain't no way
And the meteorites when we were unable to craft them. Being put in the market.
not now
You literally could not make them before week 2









