#questions-and-help
1 messages · Page 23 of 1
Yes
What to buy with rose orb?
Stuff in mystery store or imagine gambling
Ello
What is 3+4?
Buy will wish coins
Until you get the SSR you want
but I can only go once a week
And everything good for your progression
you do normal and hard each week
3+4
3 raids
21
oh, you count the 2 new raids too
You do all the raids and you should have 50 throne
oh wow reclaim only give 2
Sad
yeah no there's absolutely no way u get 35 throne gold WITHOUT any raid in a one week old account, i dont buy it
no
let me check, it seems TW server hasn't opened 2 new raids yet
im trying to figure out the other guy saying he get 35 throne gold without doing any raids on a 1 week account
just lying
yeah pretty sure its a lie
You can get 50 throne from a new acc
By doing all the raids
You also get stuff from reclaim shop
nuru just looked
The loot gives 2 but you get more than 1 loot
in 1 week is impossible no? Reclaim hub barely gives enough
no
Weird I made a new acc like 4 days ago and it already had 50 thrones
People used new accounts to somehow get the 70 wep before everyone else
theres no way
where the hell did people pull out the thrones from
How long does it take to go from legendary level 60 weapon to level 70 mythic weapon.
i feel like im missing something
Lol I believe I got the 70 weap before new accs
Not long, if you do all the raids
I'm definitely forgetting something but like, I can corroborate getting a fuckton of throne golds on a new character (not new account)
Can I just randomly join those or need to know people?
u sure u didnt miss a few days and started on a sunday?
New char = new acc
Don't think so
@subtle hound just remember majority being at 43 with 2 days before reset and a minority had them then.
12 people 15k AP is enough to clear the first raid on hard mode @grim mesa
yeah well, I've only done ice and bone norml
i dont believe this is true without evidence
yeah
You can randomly join those but they have AS req
why are u tagging me? 😭
12 pro*
nah dont need that much
12 randoms 15k definitely can't
2-4 people that know mech to explain
What AS do I need?
Hmm maybe because I used to do it with full 17k and these randoms didn't do mech and got wiped 3x
cuz they suck
are pros the only ones that dont suck
Yes

If you know mech you're a pro
normal modes you can basically outgear the mechs
ok guess im pro then
Yes
except maybe light dragon
LIGHT
Because people are fucking stupid
MY GOAT
If you don't die and people has to use Airona you're considered a pro tbh
light dragon is the best raid
Easiest
based
yeah
Mech only
i dont care about easy or hard
DPS req is higher than bone
its the best raid
light dragon is how i get my vitamin b
it's funny now that all 3 raids are out I dread Ice Hard the most
100%
bridge is just annoying
i dont dread any of them
not even enjoyable
Huh, Ice stays the easiest for me
if bridge is annoying stop forgetting you can double jump
literally
the only reason you find bridge hard is cuz you dont jump
yeah but the problem isn't me, it's everyone else xd
literally jump
i did not say its hard?
i say its annoying
like anyone
out of all the mechanics on all the dragons
thats the most annoying one
its just a long ass bridge
you can literally just jump over the obstacles on ice dragon
Then it's not because of Ice, if you had people failing ice at bone you would fail too
my guy im not saying its hard
think of a mechanic
that's more annoying than ice bridge
im not saying you are saying its hard
Bone is a bit of a DPS check but I don't find that as terribly annoying
there's literally none
Ice is annoying
ah ok
why am I not allowed to dread something because it's annoying
you're allowed
cuz i hate ice too
It's not really because of that
Oh
Then ig I'm always playing with pros
I find all raids easy now
ok this is ridiculous, 24 world bosses not a single drop
Just need to wait and see which is harder in Nm
how is that ridiculous
Drop of what
normal in my experience
Huh
normal
Muku King?
a bunch, right now Tempest but I'm still filling out my slots with not Purple
jusat so I can get enough AS to get into hard modes
Tbh Muku King drops his weap box every seconds
18k AS?
they changed after lvl60 gear release
Wait you don't have all gold gear yet?
Did you start recently
I'm on my alt
they did not change after lvl 60 gear release
Instead of boss farming
it was only kings
still isn't enough lmao
it must have changed soon after
they did
i noticed first day
they did not
does deaths affect your master rewards?
a line before ogre
yes
it prob doesn't
I got to 18k AS from a new acc within 3 days because I rushed to lvl 60, unlocked all talents, did all M1, then started raids to unlock rune gears, obtained lvl 70 weap
i believe you lose 15 score per death
30 deaths
doing all M1 only gives you like... 5 pieces of gear
Lol
on M1!?
Yes but it doesn't matter you fill it up with rune gears
taking too much time. just reset
And I was lucky since I got bane lord for 3 of my M1s
this is just m1 you get 100 score in m1 max it doesnt matter
this is auto queue I guess its understandable
smite for larger raids, lifebind for everything else
pick what u want
smite does damage, lifebind does not
you get 6 golds of 6 first clears on M1, one of which is weapon
so 5 armor pieces, really
oh
Yes and you should get some bane lords
So more than only 5 pieces
I have yet to get any banelords in Master
like... since Master dropped.
there is a cap on banelords
yeah like 5 banelords
You should get 5 bane lords per week
And your whole team shouldn't have done bane lord yet
But this shouldn't be a problem if you matched
i dont think nourish is the skill im referring to
doesnt oracle also use nourish
er
smite
also 589 kanamia runs
almost at 600
Once you get like 7-8 gears, start the raids
To unlock runic gears
And it'll complete all your slots
With gold
no
yeah but I'm short gearscore
How much
I'm 2pc already.
Oh?
and fuck if I'm doing hard modes at 15k
Lol
you can do hard rin with 15k
If you know mech it should be fine
@vapid valve Go in - get experience of the fight and maybe even get carried. Nothing to lose.
another non-backreader, this is an alt
If you play well as a 15k it will perform like a 18k
not with shit substats I'm not performing on iai lol
Alt or not is irrelevant i guess
Are focus potions worth buying from the mystery store if you the orbs?
no
If you already have the experience definitely get in content as soon as you are able to.
if you dont mind spending money then always get them
if you do not spend money then dont
It's unbound rose orbs
you make more money by converting your orbs into luno
than the most profitable focus activity
@subtle hound 50 bound for me
its exp
spending 50 orbs on 1 potion
Then buy it 100%
Definitely worth it
@subtle hound No im confusing the fing names again xD
also its definitely unbound rose orbs
Oh lol
focus pots are unbound in the mystery shop
the cost anyway
mystery shop scam on the right
never buy
they sneak in unbound luno as the cost
its not a discount
Yes I always get the words confused
Lol
chaotic evil
Should be locked/unlocked
the same as bound/unbound
I did the DPS thing of running ahead of the tank and dying instantly, nice
Yes but bound also means money for me
wdym
what
where are you from
I'm french
a
So it confuses me
wait you guys money = bound?
isn french using euro?
In some games
Yes
then how is your moneyu bound
what
then that's your problem i guess?
Ye
what game does that..?
i dont think any game calls money bound
oh ok - does she go to another school, perhaps in canada so i wouldn't know her? :)
Lol
ok so, i was right, no games do that
lost ark has the same thing as blue protocol
bound gold
but no games money is called bound
I'm sure some games call their money bound
why would they do that
Idk
ngl you are confusing as hell
i don't think it matters?
Locked
locked works yes
well id rather have luno than gold or euro
Same
locked and bound are very similar words
Yes
But I wouldn't get confused with locked
then call it locked luno
i pref bound


locked luno sounds liek you can't use them
Can't trade
character bound
We made questions and help into chat lounge
or maybe just remove the bound unbound shiit
its literally always been #chat-lounge2
Bone mech for beginners
Yes
anothger mechanic trivialized by double jumping
Even jumping once works
And the waves don't even kill us
no reason to jump once with latency
It's more about the lasers
they do 50% your hp in dmg
We have 2 healers so it should be fine
healers arent healing during wings
Their heal stays for like 5s even if they don't heal
wings lasts longer than 5 seconds
Ye but we can survive 1 more wave
Yes
I easily jump through with only 1 jump
But I still double jump
You save stamina
Not with 60ms
you are not running out of stamina
I know
you have full stamina double jumping and dashing once per wave
Unless you placed yourself on the cross
if you placed yourself on the cross you spawn dead
Lol you could still run and avoid it but it would drain your stamina
you will not run out of stamina
Idk lot of people complained about their stamina?
a lot of people complain about the boogieman
I never died from this so
but he doesnt exist
Lol
Lol
if people die to wings, and say "my stamina was low" then theyre just making excuses. blaming the controller.
Lol
Bone hardest mech is portals
Once you're out of portal it's a piece of cake
You can not run out of stamina going against the spin (and you need to triple jump, cos the beams have fucky colliders)
you literally cant triple jkump
You can't triple jump lol
Had a player try and do the Guild Dance before midnight central time and wasn't able to. Does the Guild Dance not go all day?
We can't triple jump in raids

Yeh, I got that from the two previous mentions
It only goes from the time said
Lol
the point is... the beams can be jumped over too, but it's really close on timing
does anyone know how the instakill mechanic works for the first enemy in kanamia
No you can't
much closer than the ground waves
cuz ive instakilled it in master
by just ulting
does anyone know how it works
is it a bug
Not M5
ive done it in m5 too
Which is what?
There surely is a way to do that, as we had a moment where I jumped over one and died to a second beam running from a wall
wut
For me it's from 7pm to 3am
Idk... maybe ping was so high I was on one side one frame and on the other the next 
US Central time?
might be
I think it's said on the guild dance event
But I can't access game rn
Maybe it was a lag like slow death
Like you think you survived but then internet comes back and you die from nothing
how do i craft the level 70 weapon? i seem to have all the resources
Unequip your weapon
Haha this is def viable with the power of my lag
unequip your weapon
If it's reforge 100
nah... I definitely died to a second wall 
Lol
on run 599

is this just luck or its random
its the same every time
33
oh
this is uhhh patently not accurate.
you will play like an 18k on auto
I haven't really checked my damage output but gotta say, the difference is uhh.. drastic to say the least
because you know how to press buttons
especially when I'm missing a whole buncha things that have made people 18k
and also you do the most damage of all classes
so its not even remotely fair to compare
I'm missing 70 wep and runic pieces, I doubt I'd be performing to spec against a similarly brain-alive 18k stormblade
why missing 70 wep
I'm short 6 throne gold
raid
yeah, just finished normals
do 2 hards
just need to be carried through ice and bone I guess
unfortunately it's...
late at my guild's peak hours.
just join parties
is there quest to unlock raids
some flying island quest
you don't neeed the quest but you should at least go to the floating island to get freebie stuff
t0on of chests on those islands
is it wise to spend bound on will imagine
Depends on the class and how the person plays, I'd say globally you can do as much as a 18k even as a 15k
Because they don't really know the mech etc
Same for a 17k who can perform like a 20k
All depends on how good the person is
ou can play as good as a 20k who doesnt press anything
Ofc a 15k would play as a 15k if he don't fully know the mechs
Yes
And cycle are important too
"Some" people just use auto battle
Which makes them lose 60% of their DPS?
Or something like that
so... no, a 15k won't play like an 18k "if you're playing well enough"
more like a 18k will have the damage of a 15k if they slack
like, it doesn't take much to do most of your damage potential, frankly. So something is extremely wrong if a 15k is catching up to someone 3k above them
or theyre just using a modded apk
Ah I'm not seeing it like that
like clydana or whoever
the conditions are not the same
Like there's wayyyyy more 18k doing 15k dmg than 15k doing 18k dmg
So I consider 18k = 15k
I'm not gonna pursue this, that's... not how it works.
Like there's more people doing auto battle
So when I accept a 18k I don't look at them like an actual 18k
the difference may be true for like 18k vs 19k given where sources of AS are
but like, 15k vs 18k is a whole bunch rune gear difference
While if I know a friend of mine with 15k, I know they'll perform like a random 18k I'll get
auto battle works for some classes, like marksman, but also i dont think people who use auto on a class that cant auto properly are counting as "doing the bare minimum" in content you would dps compare in.
liek you literally cant say if youre 15k and you outdps an autobattle frost mage that you are "doing 18k dmg"
you are doing 15k dmg the frost mage is just bad
Ye
Technically we couldn't say 15k doing 18k damage
a 15k doing 100% of their damage potential, is not doing the damage potential of an 18k.
which is similar to an 18k not doing their own damage potential
But statistically 15k are doing 18k dmg if they play well
no it's not
youre literally comparing to people who dont play well
Yes
But isn't that 80% of the players?
a full party of 15k players are still going to struggle more than a full party of 18k players
The point is, a bad 18k player is not transitive to a good 15k player
No. A full party of 15k can clear ice hard if they play well while a full party of 18k can get wiped 25x if they don't know how to play

I shouldn't have pursued this

I can wipe on normal ice woth a full group of 21ks if we try hard enough 
No I know your point
Silvers actually on another planet
Like if a 15k does a 18k dmg. It means the 18k is actually doing the 15k dmg and not otherwise
if everyone dies they wont clear
which means a 9k is playing like a 23k
like this is your point
That's your point
No
yes it is
This ain’t it silvers
youre saying a 15k is operating at the same capacity as an 18k because a party of 18ks might wipe in a raid
My point is since globally 18k are doing 15k dmg. Then I consider 15k as 18k if played well
a corpse on the floor is performing like a 24k if the 24k is dead
there is no logical construction where this could make sense
YES
o_o
That's the point
yeah youre stupid.
Dude this is so autistic
so... 18k becomes 27k? I am getting lost here
It just doesn’t
this is like listening to a jessie lee peterson show thinking youre going to learn anything
I get your point saying it's not the 18k performing as a 21k but the 21k performing as the 18k
This is some "Financial Advice" ted talk type shit
Lol
its just factually illogical
No I mean like since the majority 18k is doing 15k damage, for me the well playing 15k = 18k
stop
Omg my point is
stop trolling
Yes you can do hard raids if you're 15k
we literally did hard raids as a 15k
I don't care what AS you are... but if the verdant deals more dps than you, you are out 
Well that was the point
no thats not your point
Fr
It was
the Dissonance dealt more DPS than me
No it isn’t
smite actually deals damage
i feel like a good player that's 15k should just get up to 18k pretty fast anyway and call it a day.
kinda true ngl, but I'm rather stuck on Reforges and raids
He was saying his dmg would be too low for hard raids, but statistically he can perform as well as a 18k in a hard raid even as a 15k
Make it stop
nobody was saying that
that's so not what I said
it does, yes... but I don't think most smites should be able to outdps any damage class on comparable AS 
but what do I know... I run pug raids
They can't
i had a smite the other day that did 6m dps in tower m5
6m total damage
about 30k dps i think
I can do like 450k dmg in 5s
pretty solid
oh yeah , how do yall set this effects visibility up
Burst
Sounds like he’s operating on a 18k but doing a 22k dps 
Real
and that's decent, ye
but on M5 level, all DPS classes should be at least 50k ish
Is the boss respawn tied to the time you kill it or its fixed?
wha
Fixed
oh respawn timer
Anyone know if there is a cooldown for leaving and then rejoining a different Guild?
Means when you kill it. It can respawn in 1min
which is why I said if the dps is not outdpsing the oracle, it gets yeeted. Nobody cares about the tanks damage. If we remove them, we die xD
its not fixed
Ooh thats great
its the time you kill it
there is not
It is fixed
there is a cooldown for guild changing

it literally is not fixed
It spawn every xx:00 or xx:30 depending on the boss..
its tied to the time you killed it
about... 30seconds or so?
There is I see.
less than 5 minutes for sure
left a guild, joined another one 30 seconds later 
For leaving then going to new?
Oh xD
yeah, it's a 30s cooldown lmao
I see, Is ee
What are you talking about lol
are these auto opening or am i missing something
Don't worry it's fixed
yes, they are

do you mean like muku chief
Yes
those spawn on the hour
but its offset a certain amount we havent been able to calculate or account for
theres also half hour bosses
and muku king seems to respawn randomly in the 10 minutes after its timer pops up
dont know why that is
It's written in the monster hunter book

No.. it spawns every xx:30
ye but popup menu dopamine man
sometimes muku king does not spawn on on the multiple of 30
It always spawned xx:30 for me
so there is likely a lockout after its killed
if its killed close to respawn
thats the running hypothesis
Maybe like they were killing it and killed it at xx:30 then respawn time came but boss didn't respawn
I had several kills where the boss respawned before I got to the chest 

like within 10 seconds of the kill
how long till chest despawns
Boss chest?
30 minutes?
yeah
Um I don't really know I never checked
is there aguide on how to download and install a dps tracker, can't seem to find it in community guides or any links.
I believe it's 15 minutes for elites
are macros against tos?
yes
sadge
I think it's because it's against tos
you get 2 keys per day right
Or idk
2 keys per day
doubt they are
max of 6
Yes
Same
ok ill just use 2
in the extent that you have a program doing your inputs for you
any1 got information on where to download dps trackers?
been seraching for 15 min on the discord and i legit cant seem to find any trace of a guide
I don't sorry
just ask yourself "If I use it, do I have an advantage against a person who doesn't use it?"
If your answer is yes, don't use it.
I just hope the Devs will add DPS count official in game
answer would be no for the case im looking to use it in
¯_(ツ)_/¯
Answer would be no
tbh i dont care about what you have to say youre getting blocked for your clan tag
what are you macroing emotes? 
toxicity rise up
What a macro guy can do that I can't?
macros are against tos
is it always 2 per key?
No
very rare
was a discussion not an argument but if u wanna take it personally be my guest and bite me LOL

They don't have to be there. That's their advantage
I don't have to be there to click on H
yes you do
What
H is not a macro, thats just an ingame thing
everyone has that 
you have to press h
I mean they don't need macro if they click on H
Lol
LOL
macro on fishing
Crazy
but for example fishing macros... 

just add auto fish 
they are not
What are they used for
silvers
Yes

guild cargo, food...
mm
bro said fish are useless
That's useless you can submit anything else for cargo
Ok
exactly... I never paid a single luno for items in my guild cargo
Or you can just buy the stuff in the trading center
for... unbound luno
how long does it take you to get the fish?
Lol
uh.. idk... I don't count fish based on cargos
yeah i think this guy is a troll
ah you fish because you like it
It does feel like talking to a brick, indeed
No, rich people does that
i tried fishing for cargo, couldn't hack it past 20 and started spending the luno lol
waste of time
I fish because it's something I can do while watching anime 
and doing more than one thing at a time is efficient
yeah no fair enough
I'm not
i literally play two fishing games at once while fishing =w=
guy is self centered probably think the sun spins around him too leave him be lol
pronouns are in bio btw
Lol
just fish... it's nice
thought i was blocked
not that you care, your clan tag is literally against the TOS
dayum
what do you mean.. they drop like every fourth fish
No like to get a 5 star one
stop trolling ashen lol
insane fisherman
Lol
bro is the trainer with 6 magikarps

look, they asked how long the fishing of that fish takes... not how long the prep took

holy ragebait
Lol
dont worry the two others i blocked are ragebaiting more
ashen is only like 2/100 guilty
🥀
Miyu block people for no reason
i think anyone with fishing lvl more then 8 is just botting 
I am just not providing details, that's all 
lmao
Or no lif
like these details
i like life
just get lvl 15 4head
or these
Did you get all the fishing achievements
why do you chart it
Wrong ping
Did you get all the fishing achievements
I like data 
its pretty crazy that like 2 weeks ago we had lvl 20s
whats the fastest gold trophy to get from fishing
isnt each fish give like 2 xp???
10k fish fished in first few weeks is reallty crazy
3 weeks ago
MORE CONTENT ALLDRAGONS DEAD ALREADY
Get 50 5 star
EOS before more content!
yeah those takes x2 long to get it in tho
@icy river it hasnt even been a month chill out
It's really easy to fish 50 5 star fishes
2xp is not too far from the truth

does bait quality from higher fishing lvls improve star odds
yes?
research does
also is there no way to tell which 2 colors i'm missing? x.x
I believe it increase rarity
bait doesn't matter
Precise bait (green) does not collect trash, special bait (blue) allows for mythical fish
Research improve star odds
so essentially i just grind research lvls by spamming fishing and they'll come a lot faster
Yes
ok like when do we catch this whale?
Never
when the event comes
the only researches you will use are stellar squirrelfish and lantern fish
0.001% chance
it better be a mount after i catch it lol
Lol
Why
is there more quest that gives this one or its just 1
Hmm only raids
u get them from weekly shop and dragon raids only
honor store
Reclaim shop/honor shop/raids
Or you can do raids
waiting for my guild to do raid
Good luck
You can do the easy ones with random if not already done
Im excited
if you learn the mechanics beforehand its quite chill
yeah you really need to find guild that dose it, i'm just glad our guild runs two raid nights a week
What spec has the highest dps ceiling if you are theoretically going to whale like there no tomorrow after the stormblade class?
never done a guild raid except once to get the title
I already know ice and bone
wind knight
havent seen light
vang spec i think?
That's bad
Stormblade
Oops sorry
there is just too many stormblade edgelord out there we dont need anymore of them
Marksman imo
I like that there is so many... easy to do targeted marketing
wind knight has the highest dps ceiling
Probably mm
Hmm idk
range dps vs melee dps melee always comes on top, bow is just easy to use to get the good dps but not a high ceiling imo
did someone i blocked say marksman lmao
Light has easier mech than bone you'll see
marksman does not have a high dps ceiling
im crying rn
it has a high floor
WOAHH
IM FREEEE
You're gonna be rich
It almost looked like an argument...
and then they said "idk", invalidating all their points

i want icicle mage to have more dmg 
I see a lot of different opinions after the stormblade class, I guess there is no definitive answer for 2nd place after the stormblade class in terms of dps ceiling 🤔
its
winbd knight
its wind knight
the answer is wind knight
and its first place
over stormblade
Really? A whaled out wind knight beats out a whaled out storm blade at the very highest peak of dps?
Lot of people saying marksman
here is a solo Muku King on a very low paying WK 
take whatever you want from it
LOL no
Stormblade is no.1
wind knight -> stormblade -> marksman -> frost
In terms of whale
yes absolutely wind knight whaled out fully makes way better use of crit
which scales the best
That's because you've only seen early game stormblades
quick question what makes a master run perfect, just finishing it fast?
isnt stormblade's potential like rly capped rn
Ye
gonna skyrocket w endgame stuff coming out
Yes
yes and its under wind knight
Don't die and finish it fast
yes. For M5 it's under 6:30 for everything but Kanamia, for which it is 5:00
Yeah, AFAIK at least 6 minutes or less will net you a 375 perfect score at this current moment
finishing fast and without deaths
each death is 15 score
i was full gear iaido but i geneuinly just scrapped all iaido shit went moonblade and coulnt have been happier
Yes
It's not
got it. thanks for the quick answers
In end game stormblade and marksman will do more damage than wind Knight
iaido burst dmg is nuts but the gameplay cycle for highest dmg is so unbelievably stale
its not:
(the source, this random ass vtuber doing a tier list)
for chest piece and helm, is it only armor there on purple line?
and what is mastery?
stop talking to me
what imagine to whale for wind knight vang?
I mean if 99% of the community knows stormblade does more damage than WindKnight in end game it's for a reason
Can't really speak from a whale perspective...
but I am running Goblin King and Celestial Flier.
If I had higher crit, I'd swap one of them for Muku Chief most likely
the fact that this vtuber has wind knight in A clearly means theyre not ranking by whaled out optimized dps setups
is it possible to reclaim all the Comission rewards through the reclaim hub every week?
It's not
bro literally looked at this tier list
and answered marksman
for the highest dps ceiling next to stormblade
just disregard his entire existence
hes a troll
Mastery = whatever it is your class do, it now does it better
Versatility = generally better stats but not specific to your class
so missing commissions means you just miss all the rewards?
respect this tier list, dissonance on top
You're the troll atp. Saying wind Knight does more dmg than stormblade whale
He’s doing 30k AS dmg at 22k that’s why
dissonance is literally not on top
in that tier list
its just in the healer tier above the other healers
cuz sense make?
disso a healer? good meme
Here's a tier list for you:
S: Whatever I am playing right now
D: Everything else
Because swapping classes sucks
You're not gonna take 2 healers for dungeons
Erm
god
ok thanks
Say that to the dissonance player who did 4 disso 1 rank
its so annoying
Tank*
You had conflicting answers with a few people here but i just wanna know your opinion, so just to confirm, it is clear Wind Knight vanguard spec after the stormblade class in terms of peak whaling out dps ceiling??
Lol
the top two wind knights currently outdps the top 2 stormblades
like i dont know what to tell you
Currently*
if you wanna ever confirm something about "whaling out" you should have the utmost certainty and get takes from as many ppl as possible if ur plan is to drop that much money
WERE TALKING ABOUT CURRENTLY
a questions channel with 2 ppl wont suffice
but why talk about just currently if we're whaling
We're talking about late game whale stormblade
WERE TALKING ABOUT CURRENTLY
but like it's not like you can whale on s2 imagine in s1 now can we?



