#Petition to take off clanless immunity on CVC & recommendations

325 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

vestal sinew
#

There is so many exploits to come with CVC for unclanned person's. As well as work arounds of helping a clan and causing traps to happen as well as growing. Exploits can be but are not limited to: Spying on clans for growers/numbers, spying on nesting spots of clanned dragons and sitting there until their clan arrives. A unclanned person can get close enough in render to lead clanned players into a trap and flying away once the fight begins to switch to a clanned account or join the clan. Unclanned players can pick up babies of anyone and go un-punished. CVC should be as the way legacy was for PVP but keep the needing to log out to join and leave clan ONLY. The red eyes are un-needed because you take away the stealth of the clans ASD's. Give it to the unclanned if anything to determine differences. Since solo-pvp has their own server there is no need to protect them on CVC.

grand vault
#

big yes to these changes.
if someone on a CVC server wishes to spectate they need to be okay with dying or getting caught in crossfire.
CVC is not the place to chill and grow and elder etc
you dont go to a battleground and just whip out a campchair and expect to be left alone.

clever dew
#

So necessary

fast parcel
#

i agree

silent ether
#

AGREED

delicate cypress
#

facts

charred matrix
#

100% agreed, there is no point in protecting solo players on server made for clans. Just turn off the solo's protection.

unkempt frost
#

Could change the solo eyes to blue or green glow

spare quartz
#

Agree

mild root
#

AGREED

cedar obsidian
strange oxide
#

AGREED

tame furnace
#

Best course of action on both accounts

strange oxide
#

more attention to this pls

vestal sinew
#

if a clanless is baiting you, you cant do anythign anyways

grand vault
#

would a "peace mode" be a good thing?
a blue eye glow with attacks disabled- could also be used as a guns down peace meeting mechanic.
like raising a white flag.
something to give the user a huge disadvantage but not immunity

vestal sinew
#

if someone logs before you ctach it like it always has been, you just take the L

vital breach
#

Could not agree more with this, CvC is a great concept but with this it's going to be HEAVILY exploited. Spying, Scouting, and much more will be possible with CvC the way it is planned. Look at how much people exploit meshing and glitches in legacy right NOW.

cedar obsidian
vestal sinew
#

so there rlly isnt a reason to change it

stiff cape
#

I do agree that the unclanned immunity will cause a big issue to clanned servers.
As it will be used for clans to grow the most important hatchys safelty or even in battles. If an elder is low, all they have to do is leave clan and bam, they get away without being killed.

I think there should be alittle change to it such as maybe immune till Juvi stage then from there you can be killed or ect,
Or just get rid of the entire CVC unclanned immunity thing.
Many clans will use this to a huge advantage

vast meteor
#

Territories will be a thing in this new update, right? Why not have a radius around the clan's home 'base' be a PVP zone? Meaning, doesn't matter if you're clan or not, you can die.

cedar obsidian
vestal sinew
#

all unclanned should just be targeted

clever dew
stiff cape
vast meteor
vestal sinew
grand vault
#

i dont see a way of getting around any of the issues without AT LEAST taking away the immunity.
maybe half the stamina of the unclanned as well, like a status effect?

stiff cape
#

Legit XD
Jao needs to try and sort this out before it drops as there’s gonna be a lot of arguing for it

unkempt frost
clever dew
vast meteor
#

Or- maybe have some semblance of like.
Clanned will all have glowing red eyes, right? So you can spot enemies easily.
Why not give unclanned glowing blue eyes, so you can know who is an enemy, but know who to recruit?

#

Still allow people to be killed, regardless of clanned or clanless.

charred matrix
#

the red eyes is another thing thats should be removed

vestal sinew
clever dew
vestal sinew
#

would make it easier to tell too if clans are nice enough to leave them alone

charred matrix
#

why would anyone want to have a glowing eyes on pvp server

grand vault
#

there will be way more unclanned on CVC servers- they need the marker more than clanned

clever dew
#

And there are people who will kill those who are unclanned just to be mean, they already do it haha

grand vault
#

what about player tag will show on unclanned?

vestal sinew
#

like how admins names show above their heads?

#

tht would help to report them but thats it

charred matrix
#

there is no need to mark anyone at all, maybe make it an option that unclanned ppl can turn on glowing eyes but thats it

vital breach
#

I wouldn't mind a red glowing eye effect if you kill a clanless though, for the shame >:D

charred matrix
vital breach
#

everyone will know what you've done haha

cedar obsidian
#

Or maybe here's an idea... like how Path of Titans prevents you from logging if you're in combat... what about the prevention to leave clan if your CLAN is in combat for whatever duration of time? That's to hoping not all targets are lost.

Idk, grasping for straws at this point. 😭

charred matrix
cedar obsidian
#

But then again, it's just generally just exploited anyway if someone leaves an account OUT of clan to then join.
I suppose the only other options to that would be making it so the Chieftain or multiple TCs have to approve a join?

Or SOMETHING. wheeze

cedar obsidian
charred matrix
#

just turn this off, let unclanned ppl turn on glowing eyes and thats it.

naive shore
#

preach

safe grotto
#

Another exploit unclanned can probably do (if it's not fixed in 1.0) is using a ss to shoot at a clan member trying to log and stand them back up. It's something you could do in us4/legacy, even though you don't take damage you can still get stood up and prevented from logging. I could see clanless using this exploit to keep clanned members from logging out while their actual clan comes to kill them, or follow the clanned dragon around while giving the position away to the clan. Too many loopholes

crude scaffold
#

and equally another potential exploit. group of unclanned flying together to body block clanned players from another clan, say youre an ss trying to get a kill shot on an fs a group of immmue ss get in your way what can you even do?

i wouldnt want to split up my clan just to avoid immunity trying to play on a pvp server.

not to mention the glowing eyes are just not how id want to play a server to fight others

pallid swallow
#

if you really want to make the clanless to be safe from the clanned, then make the 'hub' part of the map a safe zone (like BR) with a cooldown before becoming protected again when reentering the save zone

and red eyes absolutely kills the joy of having a variety of skins

sour orbit
#

Didnt we already have a suggestion like this with almost 1000messages and the devs didnt care

rapid haven
#

assuming most clanned people have more than one account.
Maybe this could be solved by unclanned dragons being able to damage other unclanned ones but not having a hitbox for clanned so they could't be body blocking but the clan still have a counter to them with allied but unclanned players?
If worst comes to worst we could just throw clanned/unclanned in different instances of the same map where they still can hear/read each other but not see or otherwise interact

vast pawn
#

Ah hound finaly woke up. Sadly to late the game is done.

#

We could Change something earlier, because we talked about this 1-2 months ago.

Ah i forgot it was us and there are some personal Problems.

torn mirage
#

Tbh it’s not that deep

#

We got PvP

#

I like the damage on

#

It increases the skill gap

silent ether
silent ether
edgy halo
#

Ok how about this for CvC. Instead of letting solos get attacked. (Which would inevitably lead to groups just ganking solos like in legacy.)
Just make it so clanless peeps cant grow. Then pretty much the only people that will play on CvC are people already in clans.

So if growth is disabled for Solos, they can reach out in global to get a clan or go to regular pvp server.

Eldering and nesting is already disabled for clanless people. Might as well just disable growth to. Then there cant be any scouting really as youll be a hatchling and inevitably a fresh spawn.

charred matrix
#

solo players already have solo pvp

edgy halo
#

But if picking up a clanless hatchy is disabled

#

Then its not a problem

charred matrix
edgy halo
#

What? Its not protection

#

Disabling everything for a clanless person in turn fixes all problems. As they cant do anything and neither can clan people do stuff to them.

Disabling growth and pick up. Elder and nesting is already disabled

charred matrix
#

but then again why would anyone want to be a hatchie that cannot grow and do anything

edgy halo
charred matrix
edgy halo
charred matrix
#

so they can just turn the protection off cuz it makes no sense

edgy halo
#

At that point sure. Because then it will only be clans killing hatchlings. Or hatchling killing hatchlings. Obviously disable pick up for ungrouped hatchlings and have fall damage so you cant just drop a hatchy for spying

#

But from view i think this helps CvC as a whole. As only people who want to play CvC will join

charred matrix
#

There is just not a single logical reason to protect solo players on a server made for big clans. If the protected solo player is supposed to stay forever hatchie then the protection makes no sense cuz pvp can help u with that cuz what difference does it make if u gonna stay forver hatchie by getting killed or by the server settings (if u wont join clan)

charred matrix
vestal sinew
edgy halo
edgy halo
vestal sinew
#

The only answer to all of this like I said once again is to get rid of immunity all together. There is no good compromise for this.

edgy halo
#

But at that point its just regular pvp

#

So get rid of CvC

blazing notch
#

Exactly lol

charred matrix
vestal sinew
#

Other than as you said a "safe zone" but if that happens anyone inside the safe zone needs to have their names above their heads like admins do to report for exploitation when they're not on by starting fights then running to the safe zone.

edgy halo
charred matrix
vestal sinew
# edgy halo So get rid of CvC

We've been saying that, only reason we want to fix CVC is because it's made for large clans atm and PVP servers are not.

edgy halo
#

Ah i see

vestal sinew
#

Basically you either play a PVP server where you don't get what you asked for. Or get forced to play a exploited server off the bat but you can get 3/4 of what you had in legacy.

charred matrix
#
  • there are supposed to be additional clan futures on CvC than wont be included on pvp
edgy halo
#

Heck just make it so your dragon dies if you leave a clan haha

charred matrix
edgy halo
vestal sinew
edgy halo
vestal sinew
#

Shoot I've been in 6 diff clans myself on US 2 in the past year & 1/2

edgy halo
#

Anyway it was a joke lol

blazing notch
#

I been rocking w the same crew since day oneeeee

crude scaffold
#

i still dont understand why solos want to play on a cvc server when they have specific servers MADE for no clans/little clans

charred matrix
crude scaffold
charred matrix
#

ik right its just not logical at all, they should just make another CvC made for actuall big clans not some noob solo players imma be honest

crude scaffold
#

only options is split clan to have a sense of normal in pvp or suffer in an extremely exploitable cvc

robust tundra
#

I 100% agree. CvC should be catering to the big clans playstyle, not new players without clans. That is what the PVP servers are for etc etc. You can STILL survive in cvc just like players did in the legacy officials. You can still join clans. But giving them protections like that is just going to cause so many issues.

At the end of the day - just make CvC the way it was before. No glowing eyes. No solo protection/clanless protection. Large clan limit. Group dmg off. Its that simple.

#

Either that or make ONE CvC server this way. Like. You can have multiple servers with diff options 🙄

So why not have a CvC server with these to allow normal play.

#

Another issue with the clanless protection is DRAGON PEARLS. People gonna be clanless while clans fight to snatch pearls safely.

charred matrix
#

they will probably disable that for clanless, but then again if u cannot do ANYTHING unclanned they what is the point of that at all

crude scaffold
#

if cvc stays the way it is currently its going to be a useless server

robust tundra
#

Tbh i might not come back to dod if pvp and cvc are as they are.

People forget about one of the biggest killers in this game: LAG. NOT DESYNC. LAG. People wont get kicked for lag as its usually the server falling apart.

Now with group dmg enabled, no matter how "skillful" you are, you cannot beat lag. You have a high riske of dying.

charred matrix
#

im gonna abuse the solo options just to prove a point and kill randoms just after they join clan, idc

robust tundra
#

Dont forget if you get a niiice critted dragon you can just leave clan and grow it safely 🙄

placid shore
#

Unless they add a mechanic that you gotta be E blood as clanless

#

Plus even if you do, you can't breed or fight with it so

potent viper
#

that wouldn't make sense though

charred matrix
#

u can stil spy and abuse it in many other ways, some people listed it, just completely remove clanless protection they have their own server

placid shore
#

Or maybe just don't have an official CvC sever?

#

Have it beusable by private servers

charred matrix
#

big clans wont go to private servers

placid shore
#

My clan is almosy a hudred strong we live in a pric server

gusty sandal
placid shore
#

almost*

charred matrix
potent viper
#

i feel like an official cvc server could be great but it would still have chaos, what bothers me most is that clans will be antagonizing every single other clan which is also bad, plus then again the clanless protection will make things worse when exploited

placid shore
potent viper
#

i mean cvc being on official is a good idea

woeful meteor
potent viper
#

what foils the plan are the abusers of it

charred matrix
#

but thats part of clan pvp yall

potent viper
#

plus clan members can just leave and join back and gather info like that

#

especially for very greedy clans

placid shore
#

CvC has a join/leave cooldown

#

That's been confirmed

charred matrix
placid shore
gusty sandal
#

CvC is meant for that. For how clans truly treat each other. For how we truly participate as a clan and fight as a clan. CvC can allow such toxicity without disrupting solo/new players who wish to improve and practice before joining such clans or those that just don't like being part of a clan.

potent viper
#

plus they can still keep in contact with the clan through discord and stuff

gusty sandal
#

No one will want to host a private server which requires us to pay for if our devs have already been kind enough to offers us our own official server

woeful meteor
gusty sandal
#

Why cant big clans have one on PvErs, PvPers, and solo PvPers can have one?

woeful meteor
#

PvP has the clan cap. CvC is way bigger for a reason

placid shore
#

So that clans can take in solo players

#

Who are ready

gusty sandal
#

Even if PvP has a clan system. You won't really see clans like GRAND, ANBU, 1337, GAIA, or any of those that most players complained about.

#

We would have our safe space which is CvC

#

Once a solo player is ready, they can just move to CvC. That's why we have clan recruitment in this server. So communicate we're ready to be part of a clan.

potent viper
gusty sandal
#

But that's how clans work. Try to be the best. There is no equality in clans. There is no such things as "let's let this clan grow and we can calm down"

charred matrix
gusty sandal
#

NO clan thinks that way

charred matrix
#

like trust me regardless of anything clans will dominated both servers that enables clans

potent viper
#

true

charred matrix
#

and all we ask for is to have our own space and they refuse to give it cuz they wanna protect solo players on cvc which makes no sense

placid shore
#

Y'all forget

charred matrix
#

bro, if my clan will get 10 people on Solo PvP we will still dominate any random group of people

placid shore
#

CvC means Clan versus Clan

gusty sandal
#

Plus that's the whole point of CvC. Clans fight each other and compete for dominance. If not then what's the point of a clan? It's not a happy place of equality

placid shore
#

Not Clan versus Solos, or Player versus Player

gusty sandal
#

Exactly!

unborn falcon
#

Would be cool if all clan dragons will be invisible for solos?sly

gusty sandal
#

Clans will focus on clans and being better but solo protected players will get in the way and it can be exploited by the other clans for spying

placid shore
#

Maybe just add a timer on CvC for solo players

gusty sandal
#

Imagine I'm on my elder fs nest and have a bio that I can't kill somewhere near me waiting for their clan to come kill me off

charred matrix
placid shore
#

You get X time before you need to join a clan before you get marked as PvP

#

Problem solved, then if you already joined a clan and left ur still PvP marked

#

If you haven't joined yet you got X amount of days to fnd a clan before u also have to PvP regardless

robust tundra
#

CvC is meant for the bigger clans. It allows for different playstyle how us1 used to be. Us1 had LARGE clans running it and small clans couldnt really survive. Pvp allows for the smaller clans, while cvc allows for the big clans to go at it.

Enabling PvErs by putting on clanless protection is useless and honestly it needs to be removed. The ability to scout and not get killed ruins the whole CvC aspect. The eyes glowing ruins any aspect of ambushing.

SIMPLE FIX: KEEP CVC BUT REMOVE PVE ASPECT (aka clanless protection/glowing eyes)

frozen flame
#

CvC is actually more designed for PvE solos to learn how to play in a clan.
Clans will play PvP, but it can be hard for a player to get into already established clans, particularly if they are only just getting used to PvP.

With CvC they are basically getting PvP light, where they can make friends, form groups and then brand new clans.

charred matrix
robust tundra
#

Or i dunno, mayhe have DIFF SERVERS with different options since people are going to whine. They have several servers with diff options. Idk why they want to take away from large clans that have been keeping this game alive in legacy by shooting us in the foot with this. When instead, just let us have what we had. No changes needed

charred matrix
#

and if so why big clans dont have official server made for them

#

pers already have so many things done for them

frozen flame
#

What sort of clan needs that many players anyway?

robust tundra
charred matrix
gusty sandal
#

New clans can always be formed in PvP. Id they feel like they're growing then they can go ahead and move to CvC to continue their expansion and now compete against other clans.

charred matrix
#

10 of the biggest clans have more than 200 ppl on

placid shore
gusty sandal
charred matrix
#

we will be forced to make 4 clans to keep all the ppl in them

placid shore
#

She knows what the devs r talking and doing

robust tundra
gusty sandal
#

People have multiple accounts as well

placid shore
#

Just add an off server with no clan cap and group damage disabled and keep CvC how it is

frozen flame
robust tundra
#

The devs are playing on PVE aspect ONLY

crude scaffold
#

then play solo pvp luse?

robust tundra
#

Literally just make a CvC server with no solo protection and no glowy eyes and honestly there would be no issues

placid shore
#

Maybe add glowy eyes to the solo players

unborn falcon
placid shore
#

Not the clanned players

crude scaffold
#

pvp is just punishing big clans. cvc is punishing clans for existing

gusty sandal
#

But that issues we had it when pvp had big clans. CvC removes big clans from those PvP and allows those that wish to practice, a better chance.

frozen flame
#

And it's hard to join clans because most clans are worried about spy's and don't want to deal with a newbie

woeful meteor
robust tundra
placid shore
#

Maybe... just maybe

gusty sandal
#

Like I said. Clans can be formed in PvP. Once they grow they can move to CvC. No EVERY clan will reject someone new.

placid shore
#

They're trying to encourage smaller clans

frozen flame
placid shore
#

Not mega clans

#

Ever think of that? CX

peak jetty
#

Then why make grandparents part of upstatting lol

frozen flame
#

We should be happy the Devs are trying to think outside the box

robust tundra
#

If we had CvC without the cons it takes the large clans out of PvP. Then newer playera can use the pvp to practice.

gusty sandal
placid shore
#

As it technically should be cuz it's powerfl

robust tundra
gusty sandal
peak jetty
#

Needs more accounts in a clan to upstat

gusty sandal
#

I'm sure we want to make sure this is a game we can enjoy as well

woeful meteor
robust tundra
#

Fr with grandparents being added to upstating, you NEED more accounta or more members

#

So put clanless protection in PvP

peak jetty
gusty sandal
#

Thinking outside the box is nice but played opinions and feeling should be considered. Majority of players that is while also making is enjoyable for the minority.

robust tundra
#

Not CvC. Esp since pvp is MEANT for the smaller clans.

clever dew
#

Clans are recruiting new people all the time

gusty sandal
#

Yes exactly!

charred matrix
#

But mega clans will exists anyway do yall u derstand it 😭😭 like i will kill every random every hatchie every solo player on any server if a want to and not giving big clans their own space wont change that

robust tundra
#

Fr ANBU recruired several new people recently.

Like i said they have an easy fix that HELPS new players

gusty sandal
#

Now ofc if your acc looks sus then anyone would question it

charred matrix
#

If yall are not part of big clan why yall wanna destroy the experience for us if there are servers for you already

clever dew
#

Everyone who is in a big clan now had to start fresh at one point and learn to grow and stay alive and fight. So why are new players being pampered to do it without being killed, at the expense of the pvp community’s enjoyment of the game, when we all had to go through the growing pains of learning ourselves?

peak jetty
#

The reason big clans will avoid cvc is because of the utilization of immortal scouts/ground tracking/ baby camping.
Cvc servers will primarily be filled with pve clans that want to “occasionally” pvp

robust tundra
#

CvC is meant for large clan fighting. Keep pve aspects out of it. Remove the solo protection and glowy eyes.

Pvp is meant for small clans. Literally. Put in clanless protection there. Now you dont have large clans in pvp and you STILL have the aspect of safely learning pvp

placid shore
# clever dew This isn’t true at all.

I tried playing offs after not being on it for months. Got killed for being a "clanned spy playing clanless" cuz I had over 1.5k hours... they didn't believe me when i said private servers exist

#

Official clans wil lalways have issues

woeful meteor
robust tundra
robust tundra
#

If they did what i suggested EVERYONE WINS

gusty sandal
#

Guys pick that what Necro said

#

They have a huge point

placid shore
gusty sandal
#

Necro put that as a suggestion PLEASE

#

I BEG

robust tundra
#

Big clans stay out of the pvp small servers, pvp servers have small clans that learn to fight together, and newbieslearn on the sml clan server whwre they can join a small clan and EVENTUALLY grow big enough to go to cvc

#

Okay i wo
Ill xD

#

Omg will*

clever dew
#

I’ll also say a lot of the time big clans only kill fresh clans when they’re bored, most of us would rather fight other large, skilled groups. There’s not a lot of fun in destroying some new guy who can’t fly yet

gusty sandal
#

Can we all just appreciate Necros suggestion? It actually make a lot of sense ngl.

gusty sandal
placid shore
#

See a hatchling? ehhhh lets kill it cuz why not

#

See a juvie faceplanting learning to fly? bite it

gusty sandal
#

At least big clans can only focus on other bigger clans. There is no satisfaction of bullying a smaller one when we can compete with the big ones for dominance.

placid shore
#

Official servers are like that, you can't deny it

clever dew
# placid shore They still do a lot wym XD

Sure people did it I’m not saying they didn’t. But with people being active again in 1.0, new dragons to use etc., a lot of the skilled pvp base will return to the game

gusty sandal
#

Allying is a thing as well, let's not forget that.

placid shore
#

True that Moon

charred matrix
placid shore
#

TBh a clan with n allies will always be weaker than a clan with them

gusty sandal
#

And most clans respect allies as well

clever dew
#

Alsoooo isn’t the whole point of the official pvp servers that there are no rules? I’m sorry to be so blunt but truly, it’s pvp, and there are no rules. Yes it’s very mean when people kill hatchlings and new players but that’s how the official servers are built. Unofficials exist if you want safe zones and rules.

placid shore
terse scroll
#

There is no need to make things so accommodating for solos when this game isn't meant to be played as a solo/progress as a solo.

placid shore
#

Don't NEED rules if GAME mechanics prevents something

clever dew
#

Yeah and there’s no reason to accommodate people in multiple server modes when one would do lol

placid shore
#

You can't progress solo in CvC, u can't elder, breed or nest

clever dew
#

It doesn’t matter and you’re missing the point we’ve made a million times dude

robust tundra
#

Suggestion has been made :3

terse scroll
#

CvC Servers
Clan vs Clan is PvP but designed for big clans. - Jao's words.

You can't make a game mode entirely made for the mega clans to play in and yet not actually have it accomodate them.

clever dew
#

It’s not about nesting or eldering it’s about how clans will abuse it

terse scroll
#

No disrespect just saying

gusty sandal
#

Guys let's please wait for Necros suggestion. A PvP won't protected pve.

placid shore
gusty sandal
#

GUYS CHECK IT OUT

clever dew
rustic wigeon
#

W hound for this make the server hardcore af and let the big clans slaughter each other

next terrace
#

Petition to get shrooms a new pc

terse scroll
silent ether
next terrace
rustic wigeon
#

Smort

#

Start your eldering service shrooms

fossil thunder
#

Agree the red eyes no need. Gives you away. Maybe something else. The red eyes look really bad and they glow is way to much. Cheesy 🧀

#

Can hear really well that's a good indicator.