#lore-discussion-spoilers
1 messages · Page 216 of 1
Isle youngest kid to grandpa in vault
đ” Toss a heart to your Skykid
O Valley of Triumph
O Valley of Triumph đ”
And Wasteland/Vault are related to the Forest kid?
Wait
Iirc the Wasteland guy was Forest kidâs dad
from the looks of it perhaps so
Uhhh so are the Valley and Wasteland parents not related to each other?
They should be related
hmmmmm should be, would be interesting if they arenât related
Huh
Yeah I agree
I guess the Isle kid took after their mother since heâs so young
Def seems like forest is the oldest of the siblings and thus in a âgothâ phase lol
Taking after their dad
Suits the angst themes of forest
Oh yea u reminded me
I didnât rlly get an emo vibe from the forest teenager
And the grandparents are the leaders of the family, with Grandma evidently being the matriarch
I got the kind of rebellious teenage vibe from the forest teen, since he locks the dad out and goes to play an instrument on his own for a bit
Thus Vault matches capes with her
Wait thatâs what was going on? I missed parts of the story cause I wasnât fast enough lol
I was wondering how they got to all those higher places and islands in Pineswood
Or whatever the new areaâs called
I missed the story a bit bc a lot of people rushed to collect it and Iâm over here like âWHAAA WATS GOING ON, WHY IS THERE AN UKELELE ON THE STONE THINGâ
Yeah same
Oooo yeah the cape colors match the generations
Yeah
mhmm
Thatâs so neat
Skymii is typing...
maybe some other spirits decided to give up the ukulele and hence letting it rest on that stone thing

Well it was picked up after
I replayed it a few times and I thought of it like
âHey son come with me through this gate, u see that ukelele, itâs urs nowâ
Sulky boy
Oh
and that the gate closes behind him
mhm
idk
Yeah
Teenage year, dad arguments
I donât want to learn how to play the stupid ukulele dad
He enjoyed playing it at the end tho
Wait the boy doesnât seem to have a cape there
He does
Wait so
his dad didnât appear until you reach to the very end
like when he gave him the head pat
âAww u learned that song I taught u long ago, nice
â
Well they prolly got in an argument
Oh likely
maybe the father was giving his son some time before reaching him with the head pat
Oh yeah likely
Yea
And then thereâs sad teenage boy playing his lil ukelele and his dad catches him
But my bigger question is how on earth they climbed those nearly vertical outcrops
Yeye
_tell us your other methods, spirits _
jus bc itâs not in their spirit memories doesnât mean they didnât kno how to fly
climbing
They had their capes
Do you think the butterfly lift them up as well?
Not one spirit with a cape was shown to be able to fly tho
When they honk
Yeah
those butterflies ....
They used boats to transport the pots
Spirit s canât fly, aid just guess the capes are a thing of fashion to mimic the skykids
They used boats for normal transportation as well though
Mhm
And the spirit memories are there to show their stories and to show a certain emotion
Not to show their abilities
I mean the telekinesis emote shows off their abilities for that
mhmm
But it was important to their story
To bring down the knowledge thingy
Or whatever they were doing with it
Itâs the vault, who know s what theyâre doing 
Yeah but wouldnât at least one spirit have flying important to their story?
Like thereâs emotes that show spirits climbing
If there was an emote that involved flying than ofc it would show it
I think theyâd just, climb, yknow
Thereâs an emote that involves a bow and arrow but itâs not something sky kids can do
Thereâs probably just, not a lot of gravity? That or the spirits are just. Hey I can jump really high watch this
pffftt perhaps so
Some people think she accidentally shot the whale and it crashed to a building and that crash caused the rocks to fall on the cry spirits friends
Wow butterfly effect
And that stress emote was like âahhh I jus shot a whale Iâm so stupid â
I never really think about it but whales were probably super abundant before sky kids appeared
I wonder what that was like
Most likely they were
Skykids....well they arenât rlly civilized at all, they were jus put on the world for the mission
Sky kids are feral
(Sorry, not related to the above topic, but) In wasteland where Beyoncé resides, did the devs take the roof off the little area on the left??
Or was it always like that đ€
Ooooh
Like right before the graveyard part of wasteland
Yeyeye I know what ur talking about
Sorry, I thought Beyoncé was a universal name for that krill hehe
But I hardly payed attention to that roof part so idk
Same here. Thought it might be preparation for a seasonal spirit in that room or something.
funny enough you mentioned of that room cos, thatâs originally where the Gratitude Spirit used to be at before the season ends
( aka two seasons ago )
Ooooh
Whats the theory on why they were transporting those pots full of butterflies that recharge you?
@real flint They were supposedly used to power the diamond things that are seen around the world in boats and such
Ok. Thats my train of thought too.
So then, what was going on with triumph and waste?
The pots has been delivered from Prairie to Forest, judging by the murals that in the first tunnel at the Forest
hmmm if you mean by the power diamonds or the pots?
The elder in forest basically forges the power diamonds right?
Yup
The power diamonds could be seen at Forest Temple and the Wasteland's Shipwreck
( hope you don't mind me slipping this but )
About the whole Battlefield shenanigans at Wasteland right?
With two different types of the shields and weapons in display, especially at most the closer you get into the Temple?
What if different type of technologies been used for two opposing side, with one of them having the ultimate death omega death weapon essentially, or more appropriate, advancement to their items? Like what if the ones with the diamond shields and the long swords are connected to Eden and Forest, especially with the whole Forest been the powerhouse to making those yellow diamond things that might be the light sources

ooooo
When people help people go home alone
Aaah how do you can get the dragon dragon mask and you can see how it can work
Haha
Haha
@real flint ur new to the war theory arenât you?
I'm verrry late to the isle elder speculation party, but here's what I think. The isle elser died when the power diamond in eden exploded and started spewing rock everywhere. Isle was scarred, almost featureless, but Isle elder could have sacrificed himself to the power diamond (like skykids at orbit) because he could have bben a wimpy bb skykid, too baby to go through eden, until he braced himself, over came his fears, and made the ultimate sacrifice for his land. And thats all i have for now haha,,,,(he also has no cape because he lost it all or smth)
In the livestream they said the elders arenât related to skykids, they are their own race
@sly kestrel yes but im guessing its valley vs waste yes? Why though?
slides in
It all STARTED when I saw 2 different types of shields in wasteland. There were diamond shields and then there were sun shields.
Skymii help me out
Ok so two prominent shields that can be found in Wasteland, especially in the Battlefield.
We don't exactly know if these of the two opposing sides
if so what kind of reasons for the opposing sides to fight, hence the Battlefield to be, well , Battlefield
But anyways, I noticed 2 different shields and I saw that some of them were pierced by spears and I wondered why would they do that. And then I saw that those symbols are in different realms so I canât really say which side was which. And then I noticed that there are no krill remains in the battlefield or any creature remains at all. At the graveyard, there wasnât any sign of a battle there at all, just a bunch of dead bodies
I looked at the lookout spiritâs stories and noticed that when he looked back, he freaked out and blew the horn indicating the he couldâve saw an army coming and he was warning them
There's some connections here and there when looking closely to the shields' symbols
Remember that krill donât have bones, but exoskeletons instead
Now the 2 sides are kinda confusing. The sun shield and swords can be found at eden
mhmm
And the diamond symbol is found at valley, and forest. Oh and I forgot to mention, the sun symbol is in prairie too
The diamond symbol is also on the masks of the gw spirits. AND it was all over the buildings and especially the cathedral at the end
The Diamond symbol from the shield could signify the power diamonds at both the Forest Temple and Eden
Oh and of course the ones in Shipwreck
Alsoooo
The forest has diamond symbols as well, on the forehead plate of the elder and at other places. I knew both realms were connected not jus bc of the symbol but bc the model of the forest temple is found at the first krill area
So this could mean, Forest and perhaps Wasteland fought each other
Buuut that's seem to be a stretch....
We donât know if it is the same temple or if it is jus the same model remade in a different realm
Hmmm might be plausible to be the similar model in different realm
Lots of churches have the same layout, so it seems reasonable for the temples to have similar appearances
mhmm!
Hereâs proof they are the same model or possibly the same temple but in a different time, but thatâs a stretch
With the diamond symbols on both wasteland and forest and with the temple model, and helmets, I can say they were on the same side. But then thereâs the sun symbol, found at eden.
mhmm, don't think I saw any diamond shields in Eden
Especially in my recent trip there
Egggsactly
Soo mostly the sun shields and longswords been presence over there
Damn, y'all are so observant
Well the swords and spears, it was hard to tell who had which. Who knows, maybe they both used swords and spears
perhaps so....
also yeah! we like to see if there's anything interesting to speculate
To confuse u guys even more. The wasteland elder is seen with the eden shield. But the wasteland mural is seen with a diamond shield
Weâve mentioned the similarities between the rooms before, and there were too many inconsistencies in surrounding areas and parts of game continuity it would break, so it really comes down to them simply sharing architectural designs, being made similar to each other, which isnât uncommon
true that we do have to keep in mind of the game ( since sometime we kinda get carried away to the point that theory might as well be a simple bug
)
But yeah the confusion for Wasteland elder.....is high
like...question to this day, which side is he on?
Henceee the potential inconsistency right there
or is it


Ok so no consensus as to why there was war but is there a genral theory? Maybe something related to vault?
Though in scenes like the mural cutscene, the elders all seem to still get along, at least enough to all be close together in one room and not try to continue a war from when they were alive
Well there could be this reason that Vault need some protections since its technically the tower filled with knowledges, hence having potential alliances with Wasteland
( i mean, Wasteland and Vault are pretty close )
I donât think it needed one, other than the now-scrapped king
Since itâs less of a kingdom and more of a small grand place
Rip that tall scary king
Like where the king could sit by himself with his family, with his kingdom being all the different places
Maybe the eden elder was some sort of conduit to reach actual eden or whereever it is you go after you die
@sand abyss the mural cutscene has all the elders, though, not just vault and wasteland
Hmmm could be that the symbols used to be used all across the realms, but a splinter group formed and decided to use one of them as their symbol?
Hence the symbols being found across the the levels, and elders getting along
And do keep in mind most, if not all, of the shields, spears, and swords in wasteland are far too large for the spirits to wield, only someone like Orion or the prairie elder would be large enough to carry them
But even then some of the swords right in front of the wasteland gate look a bit too big, even for Orion
Well there was a theory earlier that the isle elder is the king. It actually made sense to me and overtime I started finding evidence about it
But thatâs a different topic
The spirits, who would be pretty much everyone who werenât the elders back in that time period, are far smaller
And take a look at the isle spirits, theyâre moving heavy objects but clearly are having to exert their full strength for it (see the clap, wipe brow, and yawn spirits), they definitely couldnât handle those massive weapons
maybe the elders had kids with the people on the ground so they evolved and became huge like them
Idk actually
Iâm jus wondering what hage jiisama is gonna say about everything
Do u ever wonder if the devs read our theories?
Like HEY THIS PERSON FIGURED EVERYTHING OUT, LETS GET HIM

HEâS TOO DANGEROUS TO BE ALIVE
THEY KNOW TOO MUCH
Maybe they do, just to see if the story is being received well or if its super confusing
Maybe they're like, oh its not confusing enough
âLetâs change the story again just like we have been doing for 5 months, thatâll keep em thinkingâ

Forgot to mention
The story of this game kept changing throughout its development. Who knows, maybe theyâll keep changing it đ
One day they gonna be like
âAlright, this whole game was a dream, and ur jus a kid staring at a burning candle from the credits. Thatâs it folksâ
I was in soft launch for maybe about a year, there wasnt much talk about the lore though đ
Sneaky sneak

( like that longswords and sun shields at Eden )
( those aren't there before until someone here pointed out )
Yessss
Pines and Ginsy from what I remember
Me too but I never mentioned cuz I thought I was CrAzY and that they were always there
.v. played this game since global launch and I don't remember seeing those weapons in my first eden run ( or second ) at all 
This is all so interesting, thank you for sharing with me @sly kestrel @sand abyss
I dont have friends who ever talk about this stuff with me in game Dx
Hehehee anytime Magic Nat!
Most people donât
Offt don't worry, you're just in a right place to have a chat about!
We kinda need this chat, we were given this awesome game with an awesome concept but not much explanation
They wanted us to figure everything out
After all, us Lore Seekers ( or Sky Theorists how ever you like to call ) tend to go nuts with theories/lores
Pffftt probably not everything
but just something interesting to point out from the game

That and sharing info on other details like the heights of Skykids, Krill, spirits, and elders 
lol and that too
Right after an update comes out, people like us be like
ALRIGHT LETS GO THROUGH ALL THE REALMS AND CHECK FOR ADDED DETAILS
could be!
i hope they add more voices because id like a soft jellyfish voice but yeah accents (or maybe dialects, if sky kids have an actual verbal language of sorts) would be a good interpretation of the calls
wait, if the language of sky ppl seems to consist of mostly body language and non verbal sounds like sky kids (being that you learn the calls from spirits) then how did that evolve into a system of writing?
no, more like the writing seen on the bells in prairie and on the walls of vault's new area
systems of writing are typically first created to keep records of something in most civilizations, after evolving from the spoken language, so i was wondering how that would happen
Thereâs also writing on the vault elders head piece too
I think the song that plays in the beginning of isle and our ascent during after Eden might be what the spoken language was like
xD
wait... do sky ppl even have mouths? i know sky kids dont
Yes, and they need to eat as well, as the season of belonging and cry spirit have shown us
could partly be a visual/technical choice not to have mouths, since no one talks or has a mask it's kind of unnecessary
No, TGC includes small details like that on purpose, the skykids specifically have no mouth when unlit or wearing no mask
hmm
Just because calls are learned from spirits, it doesnât mean that was their language
And some of the call spirits (like whale and cosmic manta) arenât from spirits at all, but the creatures themselves, with the spirit using the base model that acts like the spirit equivalent of a placeholder
The Eye of Eden resets once per week.
Next reset is on Sunday December 29 at 00:00 PST (In 5 hours 35 minutes 2 seconds)
Why....
can you please use the command on #general-sky-discussion or #eden-spoilers channels, thank you! @hushed steeple
I donât know if this has been discussed or not or if itâs really an important detail but why is the home area the only area that isnât surrounded by clouds
Itâs complete clear sky in the middle of the ocean
maybe it's on the ground?
Maybe
If Iâm not mistaking I donât think Eden has clouds either. That or Iâm just not observant enough to notice them
I saw a theory somewhere earlier in the chat which was that the spirits werenât able to fly. And another one that Eden was the original home. Itâs almost impossible to fly in Eden- because of the wind of course but- random detail
Probably unimportant
The wind is from the storm and the storm wasnât intended when eden was built
Also there are clouds in eden
Hard to tell bc of all the to rocks flying everywhere and itâs not safe to venture around
there's clouds in the second section
you see them a lot better in oob pictures though
cue me trying to make sky fanfiction, and trying to decipher what the beginning poem means
@proven sigil mood.... also if u finish ur sky fanfic and want to let people see feel free to link me!!!!
Vault is the only place without clouds, other than the ceiling of the gate room that leads to the office portal room, and then the clouds in office itself
Both of which are non-canon locations
The vault is a very confusing place
Devs really made us like headless chickens when they said that maybe it was just a memory or dream and then the shrines at the top of vault is seen at orbit so honestly
I give up on making theories on vault
What about that place behind the home portal in the wall
That leads to the office, jaybird. That place is non-canon.
What if the forest elder caused all pf this?
Cause her area is the first place to have dark areas prop up with proper dark plants, and has crabs in it.
Well its rain there
It isnt supposed to be much Sun Light
Plus youâre in a forest
So light shines through which is why thereâs a rainbow
the mantas are there
Thereâs even light birds and butterflies
but darkness can still be found
Take too much light away and youâre left with darkness. If theyâve been harvesting the light to forge their diamonds, theyâve left space for darkness to fester
But for a dark infection like that to take hold, how come we only see dark crabs, plants, and krill? There's no dark ghosts, mantras etc at all. I mean, children can go dark when they lose light, but they dont behave badly.
But what if crabs were once light creatures?
Wait, eden.. isnt there a pipe that sucks up birds?
Also, what eden originally looked like is shown on the dawn temple, and it seemed to be big, the biggest.
Sky kids are just stars that fell from the sky, Elders are just the embodiment of multiple spirits, or protectors of constellations, spirits are stars that make up a constellation, our job is to find them because like the stars, they fell with us, when we complete them our elders reward us with gifts they deem important because we finished important tasks. ||Eden is a collection of lost or âdeadâ sky kids, we collect light and give it to them to release them from being entrapped in darkness and restart over to free our kind|| Krill/Crabs and other dark creatures are creatures that existed on this land before we fell and simply just do not like us or our light
Which is why when itâs dark thereâs a lot, or menacing, which is why thereâs like 40 in the graveyard
And when they see us they try to remove it from us and when weâre not holding any flame/light to us they dont bother us. if you lose all your light you can walk in and out of a krillâs vision
I dont see them as contaminated, they just see us as an invasive species
Then what were the remains? The fallen, or someone else? Cause if it were the fallen, then they would of found it extremely hard to live, and build in such conditions.
What remains?
Unless there were many, many warriors.
So the buildings, temples, walls, all tyat stuff
Shrines and rooms too
Idk about that, itâs just a big colorbook essentially
The spirits are dead
Most of them dont tell stories of fighting, itâs just a story of something
But if you said the elders were a collection of people, the wasteland elder is a warrior, so..
Yea but that doesnât mean he necessarily fought, but idk there is a battlefield but none of the spirits show any battling
there's shields being pierced by spears, just saying
the play dead spirit literally dies, though admittedly not in battlefield
Yeah and so does the one in the forest
Whoâs in the cave
And thereâs also pipes, thereâs no plumbing spirit though
lmao
but the difference with the play dead spirit is that he kinda looks like he's been injured in a battle of sorts
who knows
but a battle field lore doesnt even matter if we dont even get that aspect of the game lol
Thereâs not even a competitive feel to the game
I think it's a good clue into the history of the kingdom, while not necessary to the player's story it's certainly significant to what was once there
I think it's a good clue into the history of the kingdom, while not necessary to the player's story it's certainly significant to what was once there
I guess
The stories are usually just up to whatever you can make of it.. Journey had a more concrete story that you lived through
that's true
It didnt give off the light feeling that sky kid did
While Sky Kid is like a run off stream of Journey.. but it doesnât maintain how itâs actually âsadâ
Like itâs confused.
Like ||in eden, youâre taught that youâre giving your light away to free imprisoned children, you die doing this and must fall back from the sky because so|| But throughout the rest of the game they want no violence and all buddy buddy
So the lore is a bit... frenzied.
Haven't kept track with the speculations here but has anyone noticed the new hidden room in vault changed? The last I remembered it was not as broken, was much more litted and used to have stairs but it has now been beaten down
I heard the Vault was a dream scape type of thing where its not real, but does this imply that maybe the Vault is getting maybe "corrupted" or some sorts?
Corrupted as in like maybe the intent of why the Vault is built is slowly fading, and it itself is kind of eroding?
Yeah
If I recall correctly , the initial entrance was a clean cut out square like an actual hole to get in, now its replaced with a square but a hole punched into it
Base on this long hallway that's being digged into like a tunnel, it feels like a krill or the long fat dragon has smashed into it or some sorts
Or I guess someone, like an elderly super saiyan through or something, just spuwwing garbage now
Iâm the livestream it was said it was just in ruin and aging or something like that. I canât remember but i know they didnât mention anything about a creature breaking in
Guess the tunnel forever be a _myyyyssterry _

Saw people talking about the different shields in wasteland and wanted to see them for myself. Someone said the diamond shields could be from the forest kingdom. But what do the symbols actually mean? Maybe itâs two different ideologies about how light should be treated. The diamond clan thought light should be used as a power source to create the power diamonds and power new technologies , while the âsunâ clan thought light shouldnât be trapped in diamonds and should exist freely and therefore shine like the sun. The power diamonds allowed the spirits to make new technologies at the cost of the environment, as seen by the trees that were cut down in hidden forest to make power diamonds, butterflies were also collected in pots from prairie and used in the production of the diamonds. The sun clan could have seen the damage this caused and wanted to stop the diamond clan. At some point the argument escalated into war. It seems the wasteland elder was part of the sun clan as their sun shield is laying by the meditation spot, however we donât see it in the cutscene. I donât know who won in the end, maybe the diamond clan, and after that they created the red diamond seen in Eden?
Someone else mentioned the diamonds had more advanced weapons, which would make sense as they had access to better technology than the sun clan
I wonder which side each realm aligned to? Forest was diamond? Vault too? But prairie and valley were sun? Obviously wasteland was sun. Eden was... diamond?
I think prairie was diamond too as they trapped light (butterflies) in pots
But in the cutscene the prairie elder releases the butterflies so maybe he didnât agree with it
Valley has a bunch of diamonds too, on the bottom of the floating structures you see in the flight race
If Eden was sun, why was the big diamond there? Unless no one knew the dangers, and Eden was the big power in the kingdom so it made sense to put the biggest and best things there, and it was only as the big diamond collapsed and spread corruption that the two opposing forces fought?
Yes it does doesnât it? So valley was diamond probably.
Wastelands temple seems to be fortifying Vault, which serves as a way up to Eden. The large diamond in Eden and the pipes makes it seem like it would have been all for the whole tech at the cost of the environment thing
Possibly the people against using the tech was a small group of spirits not aligned with any one of the individual realms
Hmmm yeah all the spirits seem fine with it from Isle-Valley, maybe the anti diamond thing was only against the one in Eden?
That could justify the line âif only they had listenedâ in the intro, with a small group being against the construction of Eden, which seems to have been what led to the downfall of the spirits.
Individual spirits... where would they have aligned themselves? Cry would have gone with sun, having lost loved ones to the darkness...
The black cape in wasteland... sneak? That one would have gone with sun too I think
Thatâs what I think. ^^
Ooooooo
ooooo yeah maybe
Yeah maybe because the pipes in Eden could be leading into the Black Sea in wasteland
Yes!!
We need granny pigeon and/or skymii ... they have been examining the shields all over. Does anyone know off hand which shields are found in Eden?
X'D just for the some relaxation hehee
Which shields did you guys find in Eden?
Sun Shields
No diamond shields at all?
there's no sight of the diamond shields in Eden
So that would fit, boop!
nope, currently sun shields in that building
( pretty sure ginsy found it first few months ago about that shield )
whats a sun shield
@tribal knoll scroll up just a bit, there are photos
Boop, that the war started after Eden was destroyed. Oh... wait. I still have it in my head that Eden is diamond. đ€Šââïž
Wait. Iâve thought about it again. Eden and wasteland are sun. Eden gets destroyed so diamond faction storms wasteland since thatâs the fortress guarding Eden...? But why would diamonds storm wasteland and not the other way round?
Iâm getting in a middle.
Wasteland is diamond, the diamond symbol is all over the buildings and the cathedral. Itâs also on the masks of the wasteland spirits
But the big shield in the temple has the sun on it?
Yes but the wasteland mural has diamond shield
And the soldiers as well
Thatâs whatâs confusing, the elder is seen with 2 different shields
Where can I find the wasteland mural?
Itâs a wasteland, it only looks different bc itâs in more ruin than the other realms
Next to valley, wasteland is one of the biggest realms
I can connect forest to wasteland in a lot of different ways but
No one believes me đ
There mustâve been conflict at wasteland and thatâs why the battle took place there
Not bc they simply needed a place to fight
Wait
What is ur full theory?
I jus heard u say that wasteland was just a place to fight
And that didnât make sense to me bc why would they build a huge kingdom nearly the size of valley just for a fight
Yep. Diamond shield. I had to hunt through my photos.
And the vault mural. I mean, they started off just packaging butterflies... look what they are doing in vault! đ±
How do we know thatâs the wasteland elder and not just another big diamond guy
Maybe thatâs why there are only space (ghost) mantas and whales in there. Theyâve already been harvested.
But they havenât been corrupted because vault is protected.
Looking at it closely I can see the light creatures being used
It is light creatures. Itâs the mantas. Itâs the big whale (sea slug thing). Their light getting trapped in containers
Harvested.
Itâs actually horrifying.
what if when their light is taken they can become corrupted
and a large mass of them forms a krilll
Ooooouuuuu u can see the vault elevator on the mural
like i mean that massive centipede-manta in vault,,, what if if it lost its light it wouod become a krill
If itâs called vault of knowledge they must have been using the creatures for something other than taking their light
true- unless that light was used as energy for like... a supercomputer or something
That looks like a constellation on the central figure.... like the firework stick perhaps...?
I was going to ask for old beta screenshots of vault but then I removed that tgc likes to change the story every now and then with updates đ
is there actually a lore to the game or are we just making up theories im genuinely curious
U must be new
Yes... why?? Why is isleâs constellation on the central figure?
If u want confirmed lore
Go on pinned messages
maybe its why isle is a desert
Wait what
What isle constellation, all I see is the vault one
Wait where are u guys looking at
Notice how the spirits have constellations on them just like the mantas, maybe theyâre looking at their dna or something. Gathering as much information about light creatures in case something like Eden happens
what if they created eden
OOOHHHHH I SEE IT NOW
Itâs the isle staff

Does anyone have a screenshot of the isle mural??
No the mural for it
Maybe isle staff was a device created in vault of knowledge to control light creatures
The one u see at the top of vault
Where are u finding these murals, at the top of vault?
From the Vault Elder Cutscene
annnnd yes, OOB there as well
Ahh ok
Yes!!! For sureB
I only needed 1 person
We should have them all pinned
There are a lot of mysteries on the isle elder đ
Old beta showed him as a dude who gave u wings and put u on a flying boat to see the rest of the world
mhmm mhmm
But
Now
He leads butterflies with his staff on his cutscene and on a certain mural it is seen that he is leading them to the sun symbol
The same sun symbol.....from eden
Oh
Birds
Ur right
Well
He
UGHHH I FORGOT
WAS IT BIRDS OR BUTTERFLIES???
Birds for the Isle Elder Cutscene
Prairie harvests them
Especially if you look carefully at one of the spirits at the Three Bell Towers
( wellll not really )
Yea u can see then using the staffs to collect butterflies
Well the fact that isle is leading the creatures to eden, it also explains why there are flying birds at eden as well
Havenât been there in a while but I do remember them being there
Butterflies collected at prairie then shipped to forest, where theyâre made into power diamonds đ
^
Isle has no business with pots
They were born from light
They donât have a natural habitat or place where they come from
Groups of butterflies arenât just seen around boats
Okokokok
Prairie takes the butterflies and uses them to put in pots. Those pots are shipped to forest
Perhaps they are traded in valley for gold and riches, which is why valley is such an opulent place
Once u open the first gate in forest thereâs a mural showing them arriving by boat with pots
Well valley is seen with the use of power diamonds
Valley is so wealthy, they can afford to use diamonds for their games etc.
Maybe thatâs why they thrived so much
But then again, just like the livestream said, the diamonds were their downfall
They took light for granted thatâs why they played games etc
Thereâs a lot of gold in wasteland too. Perhaps wasteland was richly decorated and wealthy too before it was destroyed?
Of course it was
It is one of the biggest realms
And valley had a chance of being wealthy with the diamonds, they thrived and had rich civilization so of course they will use them for games and other fun uses.
In wasteland thereâs that area with the first krill that looks like another diamond making machine just like in forest. I think the sun gang đ destroyed that place because they were so against more diamonds being made
YESSS I WANTED TO BRING THAT UP AS WELL
ok so
Legokid Logan likes to crush my dreams
But the first krill area is almost identical to the forest temple
And this is how I connected wasteland to forest
Yesssss it was
There are many theories in this
Yh to me itâs less of a temple and more of a factory đ đ
Yea thatâs what I meant
Itâs the same thing, but instead of on the ceiling itâs....on the ground
Thatâs the one
Lots of ppl believed that they simply just used their same architectural design and thatâs it
The windows on the left open to allow light creatures in, to convert into diamonds đ
Where u getting platform lighting?
And that is why ppl believe that it is the same temple
Thank you for posting those photos Jay, thatâs remarkable! I had noticed similarities but I hadnât really looked.
Jus redesigned from the future, and thatâs another theory. The realms arenât in a straight timeline
That is also why some people noticed that the weapons used in the battlefield are way too huge for spirits and in the future, the spirits had an evolution period to a point where they became huge
Wait wha
Well it doesnât have that door anymore, there are instead 2 statues next to it with spears
Itâs okayyyy
No theory is too crazy
A little late but a Japanese twitter user made an amazing compilation of shots that really shows the similarities between the forest temple and wasteland temple
https://mobile.twitter.com/Nashineko_sky/status/1183326994399809536
With the canonical ruin of the real vault,
What if everything was destroyed and is just a memory? 
Literally what I posted earlier but heyyy someone should pin that because why not
My goodness those are amazing shots!
Sorry Jay
Iâm glad I wasnât the only one who noticed tho đ
This is really weird though
Why are they identical
Is it the same place?
I donât KNOE
The surroundings are jarringly different though
I think itâs more of just similar design
Yeah but vault shrine can be seen going to orbit
Memories donât NEED to be in the same place, right?
After all, they are just memories.
One of the live-streams hinted that
i like to think the Vault is a combination of Sky kid memories and Vault elder pulling some strings but i dunno
because it seems like Vault elder was expecting you but thatâs just my take
Isnât it weird that at both of those temples the worlds have something that makes you loose wings?
Forest has rain and wasteland has krill and both of them have crabs
0.0
What if they are the same world and all the water in wasteland is the flooded rain
@lilac talon Sorry to pop in late, but Krill will absolutely still spot and attack you even when you have lost your light. I can attest to this having used Krill to go capeless last week
I havenât been here in a few days, Is it safe to ask what Iâve missed?
Valley has me confused the most, they have so many devices, the rings that float and spin, the floting portal thingy in race, that we never see anywhere else. Are they using the same diamond tech to power those things up?
Yes
Ohh thats also the general consensus? I really gotta keep up with this thread hahaha
Iâm p sure yeah. Most things are powered by diamonds
@last wigeon to enjoy the wonderful mayhem of being capeless, get pics to measure krill while getting hit by them, and to find a way to cross the forestâs jellyfish bridge capeless without make use of piggyback, hand-holding, follow, warp, the table glitch, etc
Uhm okay, so I just had a moment where I realized something was similar to what I once saw before in the prairie
I donât know how canonical it may be to the story, but that symbol of a butterfly in a jar is an old myth
Itâs called Pandoraâs box
The jar actually contained evils and diseases, and is an idiom similar to âopening a can of wormsâ
The one butterfly that the elder kept is a parallel to Zues closing the jar to keep Hope inside of the jar
The prairie end scene and the story of Pandoraâs box are too similar to not be intentional, so I believe it does mean something
Especially since itâs foreshadowing the following destruction and power famine following immediately after the prairie
probably the later one ?
@spare sonnet thatâs actually very interesting, I havenât looked at it like that before
Okay so
:)c
Iâm not good at theories
Gib. Iâll enjoy regardless
But what I like to think happen is that among the elders there were also sort of gods
And basically
They got turned into light creatures
And dark creatures
When something happened
The end
A little snippet from my wild ramblings about the origin of the krill.
Makes sense, really cool theory!
so basically the krills are now in a battle for survival
2 things
Whatâs this about clans and diamonds
And why do the children of the light have to continuously die?
I understand to shepherd the light (spoiler?) during the storm but why did the cycle of dying and rebirth start in the first place?
And isnât the point of rebirth to try learning from your mistakes or a second chance?
Our mission is to bring the elders back to their home. And when we come back to life itâs not that we are stuck in a cycle of dying, itâs jus that we are done with our mission and now we can go and enjoy the game. It would suck if the game ended after eden, but no they are letting us continue to play and now there are other missions such as bringing grandmas family back.
And that âclanâ part u were confused about. Idk if u are talking about the sun symbol and diamond symbol but it is highly unlikely that they are clans
Ooh that's interesting, I was seeing the sunburst as societal fighters (army shield in wasteland and navy piers in prairie) and the diamonds as creators (such as the diamonds on most buildings and pots)
Would a change of diet change the krills back to their original form and what would that look like?
Also I think if I have seen both sun and diamond shields
Also thinking on the diamond as an emblem of knowledge (or capturing knowledge in vault) the diamond at the end of Eden from a Abrahamic viewpoint "Eden" could be symbolic of the nature of good and evil. Though I don't like that interpretation, as it pulls a bit too much from outside the game itself.
@last wigeon ooh could krill look like the whale like in forest or start if wasteland?
Also where were the diamond shields, I'll have to look out for that.
Right I'm off on a photo taking mission
slides in
And yes krill to whale
Good luck finding the diamond shields!
Which means that the 3 whale left need protecc
( not really a hint but the diamond shields are mainly found at ||Battlefield only|| )
I can't think of shields elsewhere tbh
hmm... same here tbh... the most prominent places you could find shields, even just one type of them, and that would be in Wasteland and Eden. That's it
Nowhere else you'll find these shields anywhere else beside those two worlds
Right Iâm back here are the pictures and I have questions about spears now
The elder in the the cutscene has a sun on the shield but a diamond on the spear
Also the banners attached to the spears have stripes any significance to whoâs spear was whose ?
Hmm I seem to remember most of the banners being the same, but I'll have to take a closer look, any spears with sunbursts on in your travels?
Just stripes I think. I was planning on pausing for a look around at spears but some ejit opened the gate and then got hit by 3 krill sin succession and I wanted to got pick him up and dust off his cloak. Maybe I look ing the quieter beta
The banners may have different thicknesses of stripes. Further study is in order
@last wigeon from what I can tell all banners on spears are the same 2 chevron pattern
However there is 1 close to the gate without the chevron, but may just be clipped on the stair
Excellent sleuthing! @cobalt palm
Interestingly, the same banner is shown from one spire of the broken temple
As another point I didn't previously notice, the ones without banners appear as large one sided swords, the first of which is next to the diamond shield, whereas the spears are almost always near a sunburst buckler style shield
Though this one has a spear in, this diamond shield is more obviously a "kite" shield style, which would be more associated with sword fighting
As apposed to the buckler/round/octagonal sunburst shields
Also the blockades display a duel stripe pattern
Possibly a clue is the direction some shields face, though there is little data, all the sunburst shields face outwards from the last temple, some diamond shields face inwards.
So itâs suns versus diamonds?
I'm not sure about that per se
Odd, because the emblem of the forest elder was a diamond
There are indicators that could be true so not ruling it out
But the wasteland elder does present both symbols
Though that could be a "war of the roses" like symbol, that red vs white ended with the duel colour rose in the tudor house in the English civil war
Iâll have to look into what that was, donât know about that war
It was basically Lancaster vs York houses, representing red rose and white rose
Just as my first thought to the outcome of a war combining both symbols as we see in the wasteland elder
Another interpretation of direction could be the diamond shielded were the vanguard, and so further out than the round shielded guard. So if the battle turned against them, as it appears, they could be in retreat back to the temple.
Kite shields generally giving better protection than round shields (despite their awesome size)
Another factor is the diamonds are on the broken and main temple within that area
Do we see sunburst designs on any architecture than the piers of prairie?
Eden
@sly kestrel ooh where?
Itâs in a lot of places actually and itâs not much of a created symbol like the diamond one. The sun symbol was seen in the intro, the isle elder is leading butterflies to the sun symbol, and on its on the cosmetic closet.
Constellation plate in orbit has it too I think?
I would show you the mural of the isle elder leading the butterflies to it but I think itâs only accessible if u relieve one of the early spirits, and we canât do that anymore sadly
Oh i think that's slightly different, that has 5 up shoots and 1 down like a horizon
I believe it is seen 3 times in isle......I canât remember
Ok I need to know what is that antler thingy on our head, there should be a closet for that
Any theories?
@cobalt palm In one of the buildings in eden, to the left is dual swords, and those are the same swords that were used in the battlefield. To the right of the building, u can see the eden shield (sun shield)
@sly kestrel like this one?
hmm that reminds me of that one scene in the opening cutscene
Yes
you know, the one where there's a mural of a skykid with the six constellations
that one!
Is it this isle mural?
Like this? @sand abyss
And I say eden shield bc there are so many murals and scenes where eden is and u can see that the sun shield is on top of it
And
Wow u got one
something like that!
Damn I always used to think it was butterflies up to the sun symbol but now itâs the sun symbol up to....stars
Haha I took many screenshots when we could relive the spirits, theyâre in an album pinned in this channel! I hope TGC lets us relive them in-game again tho 
Wait wasnât there another mural like that from the no spirit
Maybe what we are calling sunbursts are the star glair, like when se find star children in the distance
This one looks like mantas
Yeah there's a mural in the nopecave
Lol
Oh @crimson grove posted the nopecave
4 smaller characters with a taller with staff (possibly isle elder)
Question is, are the larger stars going up or down?
As we see some other shooting stars in that mural too
Ohhh I was wrong they were mantas
Oh that's the pointcave not nopecave sorry
Just a thought, they look similar to this glair
The glares are called dog stars I think
DOG STARS??
Itâs a sun dog

âïž 
I was close 
well either ways work since star and sun are technically the same
im sorry Jay
Haha, association at its best. (I lost the game BTW - association)
Octagonal switch, makes sense
Seems the numbers 4 and 8 are important in the lore here
I donât even know anymore
The sunburst symbol would look a little like the formation to summon Oreo
Sun dogs are a real thing, but would be cute if itâs related to oreo in game 
Ooh I took a screenshot of that the other day
The teamwork emote
Oreo IS the sun dog

A sundog is a concentrated patch of sunlight occasionally seen about 22° to the left or right of the Sun
Ty Google
I was
3 seconds away
From sending that picture
But yessss they look just like the glares in the game
Yupp
Seems so
Also i kinda found out that there is 2 different sun symbols that look sorta the same and I always got them mixed up
I learnt a thing today
Almost everyone got them mixed up actually
One of them is the symbol you see on the shields and the other is the symbol seen from murals and on the tip of Eden. And maybe, JUST MAYBE, that symbol could be an interpretation of a sundog
Yeah I always previously described it as lense flair, but it seems its not just lenses causing it
Or rather is a lensing effect of ice or fog
One of the symbols has 8 lines that are long and the other sun symbol also has 8 lines that are shorter and represent something else. Iâm too lazy to explain why those 2 are different but all I know is that they are different
Yes, the one on the murals does appear different to those on the shields
Could be a mutation of the original, or could be representation of something different
Hmm Hage pointed that out when I mentioned about the sun symbol been the same
And on the constellation table u see that symbol again
Does anyone have a pic of the constellation table in orbit?
Really? One time hage crushed my dreams and said the 2 sun symbols look different. And I was focused towards my theory and I never believed him......until now
Constellation table?
Constellation plate?
When you first start the game u see that symbol
Oh like the shop?
The one you view constellations from,,,
I think I do
Yeah!
Plate, table, whatever I wanna call it
noicee
About the shields, my sister suggested that the diamonds symbol may have been used to power up weaponry, like how you give light to the elder there and it goes into the diamond on his spear.
Yess that one
Thanks Mirian!
Itâs the same symbol as the one in home right
Hmm
Yea itâs the same
You know when you relieve spirits the first time, it turns into a sundog and flies to the temple
Wait....
Nvm, I was gonna say something about the isle mural but itâs too crazy
We love crazy, go for it
No theory is too crazy
Just spotted a similar chevron pattern to the spears in valleys banners
Though the spear banners in wasteland have the chevrons further inwards, pointing in, and there's no bars on the sides of the banner
They simply happen to share two chevrons in their designs, nothing else
Alright! I've finished measuring all of the elders! In a moment, I'll compile the heights into one message for easy access. However, as you look at these, don't take them as my final word just yet.
As you may notice, these sizes (particularly when you look at the wasteland elder compared to the others) are much different from how the elders appear in the vault mural cutscene. The sizes used from the individual cutscenes are larger, but makes the elders vary from each other much more (ranging from 5â2â to 15â5â individually), and those sizes put the forest elder at second tallest (right above wasteland) and the vault elder as the shortest.
I have already taken multiple screenshots in the mural cutscene oob that lets me take measurements from there, so, I ask everyone, should I use the individual measurements that are from each elderâs cutscene, or make new heights from the mural scene and stick to those instead?
@sand abyss the lads are here
Ah that reminds me, in the museum of wax, the Wasteland one shows spears with the kite style shields going towards a ribcage, so cannot entirely see who they are fighting.
For the sake of simplicity, why not try a reaction vote?
1ïžâŁ for using the individual cutscenes
2ïžâŁ for using the vault mural cutscene
Cool. Now I know valley elder one is the size of my Christmas tree.
đ

Next year I should just buy a whole cardboard cut out of the valley elder and then put some lights on it and call it a day
https://drive.google.com/open?id=1AjO_2JGnhIJb93c8Fl66nzdIIRK0nxWO here's a drive folder with all the measurements I've made so far for Sky, complete with the images used and a doc with the heights in text
And, welp, looks like you all resoundingly want to keep the current heights, so for now,let's stick with those
but my goodness the Forest and Valley elders concern me with how tall they are compared to the others, I'm going to try getting into the forest elder cutscene with her standing and maybe fiddle around with the valley cutscene if possible because these are really concerning 
Wow
Though, of course, if we could get a dev to bless us with the knowledge of whether the individual cutscenes or the group cutscene in vault is the better representation of the elders' canon heights, that'd be pretty great... 
wink wink nudge nudge
Hey, what if the elders are actually shapeshifters and they can change their size and shape, but they always appear to skykids in their preferred shape, but they change their height to suit the situation?

heck I completely forgot about that
I don't have any elder hairs unlocked ngl
This has probably been said but forest lady seems to be based off a kumiho/ 9-tailed fox!
9 locks 

Me neither
This whole time I thought the 9 tailed fox was just something made up from Naruto
NDBDJFHJDBD
@paper matrix where did u find that first picture??
one of the recent live-streams has the theme entire to Elders
hmmm should either be on youtube or twitch
@sand abyss do u have the link by any chance đ€
Hmm sadly no
but there are screenshots flooding some where here of the elders concept arts
ooou
Well I seen all the pinned messages already
Pretty cool stuff
But.... I wanna see the livestream tho đ
Woowwww im taller than the vault elder
I can't stop imagining all of the elders standing around the Vault elder, t-posing to assert dominance while she cries for being so dang short
somebody save me
The longer I imagine that scenario the worse it gets lmao
oh god it's becoming deepfried no please AAAAAAAAA
poor vault elder
too bad iâll have to t-pose at her too cause iâm taller than her aaaaaa
also if you want i can take a pic of the isle elder at orbit
donât have the rest done hhhhh
Vault mom small!!
that'd be lovely, Lyst
though make sure you're using either no-hair or default male hair, and either use a chibi mask or know exactly which of the sizes your skykid is, use the default stance, and make sure to stand close to the elder with a clean, horizontal angle, as those are all required for accurate measurement pictures
alrighty
time for another trip to eden
iâll just use a shrink spell instead btw i donât have chibi mask
It's probably just a weird coincidence, but the mask I'm wearing looks exactly like the tip of some towers in the wasteland. I guess you can share your thoughts.
I imagine it was definitely intentional, with it being some symbol important to a group in the old civilization
It's just a bit questionable to me. The mask is found all the way in the hidden forest but it's just appearing in the wasteland all of a sudden.
diamonds in general show up all the time so i think it makes sense
while not that pattern specifically thereâs certainly plenty of diamonds just like it
the kumiho/ 9 tailed fox theory getting some proof đł
saw this at the front of her temple đł
also her concept name is teth apparently

hhh so hard to take a pic without light suddenly shining through
heâs sort of kneeling
Tall grandpa
so many sky kids can sit on his lap
i think his height is still the same as what logan measured though
about 5 chibis tall
The English Livestream on Elders (November livestream) is currently unavailable, but Japanese one is still on YouTube and iirc that month they showed us more pictures than the English stream.
https://youtu.be/12iKbUJRiy0?t=2085
oop heâs patting my head now
i should work on completing the prairie constellation just so i can see big butterfly uncle
reminds me of a lynx!
They said in the livestream that the forest elder was based on lynx (bobcat), but I do agree it also looks like a nine-tailed fox, and it is fairly possible that they also had that fox in mind when drawing the elder with multiple tails.
btw the nine-tailed fox is originally a Chinese mythical creature but is also widely known (used to be believed) in many other Asian countries which have historically been deeply influenced by old Chinese cultures.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fox_spirit
ooh!
you're right Java!
I can really see the lynx elements though, The concept art feels like the nine tailed fox mixed with a lynx.
indeed indeed
I wish I could see the pictures of other animal elders too
I wonder if there'll be more story, The game is in beta?
yeah! same!
the earlier like sprite for the forest elder looked super fox-y
Iâm actually curious if thereâs one for Vault Elder đ
đïž
đïžđđïž
Im two of the sprites/art thingies i see an extra kid.. maybe a scrapped second vault elder?
vault elder started out very hunched over
no,, I mean like
from the stream
i wonder if there was supposed to be an eden elder.
cause at the very end of one of the concept art things theres this seventh very large guy
:(
darn okay
Well, I came to the conclusion that maybe concept (early?) vault elder was based off of a crow?
Seems like it atleast, though I cant pinpoint what now vault elder's animal if there is one is.
well i mean the crows are very intelligent and are knowledgeable about their surroundings
the king and prince no longer exist in the current gameplay
there was a prince :0
yeah!
also yeah i was looking back at the concept art vault elder was pretty hunched over
raven vibes
I don't feel like there'll be any extension to the main story but what about,, the prince,,
mhmm long gone
i really want/wish there was a continuation where we search for the prince and then see what truly happened (or get transported to the past?) Kinda crazy and unlikely but i think it'd be a cool idea to get more forward insight into what exactly.. happned
but he long gone so eh
unlikely
I during the first playthrough i had didn't really catch the lore too well, It was all abit too vague.
RAINNY AUNT !!

I saw something super different
my eyes are dyiinnnggg
yES rain aunt
she lowkey looked like a krill for a sec
oooo!
the old prairie elder mask and the gold thing above the temple gate look kinda similar
darn isle elder was a skinny legend at one point
vault elder was so short

isle elder is already a skinny legend
vault elder is t e e n y
vault elder is still very short apparently gfjhg
look at them. absolutely incredible
And they got tall when the king next to them disappeared?!
ooop
gasp
elders: the king is gone. now we grow 
like the small people in one coat sorta thing but with one kiddo
also GDBFHFHD TINY KING
vault elder consumed the king/prince and became younger and taller
tyutytrjtykyt
he look so intimidating and stuff in the concept art, all tall and mighty
but reality....
he babie......................
I usually imagine the king to be humongous but for some reason, when thinking about him been timy
_timy tiny _
heâs basically a bean really
i love forest elder concept artt ghhgfgh
she really said fox
that umbrella looks so cool
they r e ally wanted to keep the umbrella lmao
Imagine all of us beta testers pre lightseekers looking at forest concept art and going

I remember seeing someone with an umbrella post lightseekers (I joined after that season,,,) and i was like aeaeae

"How do i get umbrella?"
"Its from two seasons ago."

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1F0MQ8T8yc_5OrBXF5OtD4M2W0zg_n_HrtnUyq1C8d2E/edit
Here's some notes of what they said in that livestream
Hmm, Honestly the Valley and Vault elders look very ambiguous in terms of like gender.
I honestly thought the twins were both boys and that the vault elder was a young man or smthn.
I feel like i had the first impression that the vault elder was:
- Some sort of scholar?
- A prince of some sort.
tbh i can see that the forest elder lacks heart






