#REVERSED! (EDH) Assistance!

1 messages ยท Page 17 of 1

sweet ember
#

Oh already have that

deft belfry
#

there is a cave that does the same thing

#

do you have that too

sweet ember
#

Can I post a few promising ones and ask which ones you think are worth it?

deft belfry
#

and it is really just a panorama land

sweet ember
deft belfry
#

yeah a basic island is fine in place of coral

sweet ember
#

[[Stormchaser's Talent]] [[Jace, Vryn's Prodigy]] [[Metallurgic Summonings]]

shrewd zealotBOT
#

Enchantment โ€” Class
(Gain the next level as a sorcery to add its ability.)
When this Class enters, create a 1/1 blue and red Otter creature token with prowess.
mana3manau: Level 2
When this Class becomes level 2, return target instant or sorcery card from your graveyard to your hand.
mana5manau: Level 3
Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, create a 1/1 blue and red Otter creature token with prowess.

#

Legendary Creature โ€” Human Wizard
manat: Draw a card, then discard a card. If there are five or more cards in your graveyard, exile Jace, then return him to the battlefield transformed under his owner's control.
"People's thoughts just come to me. Sometimes I don't know if it's them or me thinking."
0/2

Jace, Telepath Unbound
Legendary Planeswalker โ€” Jace
+1: Up to one target creature gets -2/-0 until your next turn.
โˆ’3: You may cast target instant or sorcery card from your graveyard this turn. If that spell would be put into your graveyard, exile it instead.
โˆ’9: You get an emblem with "Whenever you cast a spell, target opponent mills five cards."
Loyalty: 5

deft belfry
#

i cant say [[$stormchaser's talent]] is worth that price tag

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

utility wise i think it is okay with all the extra things you can do with it

#

maybe $5-6

#

since it is a "singleton" format, the game allows for high curve cards that doesnt come out too early

#

it is just 3 cards in 1 with lv 2 and lv 3 as the overcosted version

#

jace if flipped... you can definitely get back something from grave

#

that depends on what spell you want to cast a second time

#

because a 1 drop cantrip is kinda meh to get back

#

the -9 is very tempting if you can get there

#

and could become a hidden win con

sweet ember
#

Stormchaser's Talent is a cheap one to level up to 2, and also it's 1 mana cost serves as yet another candidate for a Hullbreaker Horror combo, though any of my HH combos already make infinite birds with Hermes so the otters may be redundant, but the third level is gorgeous if I can pay it w/o getting removed

Jace, Vryn's Prodigy is a 2 drop looter that transforms into a PW that can get me an Instant/Sorcery as soon as it drops and another in 2 turns, three if I decide to keep enough Loyalty for him to stay on field

Metallurgic Summonings will definitely take the place of [[Shark Typhoon]] in my deck. It has more limited triggers (Instant/Sorcery vs Noncreature Spells) that give less evasive Creatures that dont have flying, but its cheaper by 1 mana and lets me bring back my entire Graveyard, since I run enough Artifacts and spells that the six Artifact requirements should be fairly trivial

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

if you want the otters as your pet card, i cant argue with that. but in commander i dont think its value is as high as it could be where was it standard that runs all the copies of it and form loops

#

yeah jace being repeatable makes it look nice

sweet ember
deft belfry
#

i think with your card draw, you can get more from getting new cards to cast assume you got the mana

#

Jace is not bad since you can also block the things coming your way

sweet ember
#

I wanted to use the otters after so many times getting fucked by them, but then you posted the price tag and thats a hell no for me, $15 better be a wincon or something like High Fae Trickster/Valley Floodcaller that enables an entirely new dimension of play. Gonna cut it

deft belfry
#

metallurgic maybe on par with shark nardo typhoon

#

but sharks is flying, which i doubt you need

#

i favour having that second ability on metalic over shark more for that reason

#

yep, we basically said the same thing

sweet ember
# deft belfry metallurgic maybe on par with shark ~~nardo~~ typhoon

No no thats true, in most games even in my currently jaky deck thats hafway between the initial construction I made and the current decklist I usually make enough birds to handle enemy flyers and trigger card draw unless Im doing something like 1v1 against a Simic who gave all his Timmies Trample (True story), but yeah

#

So Jace and Metallurgic Summoning can comfortably slot in

deft belfry
#

yes

sweet ember
#

MS wont need a cut since its just taking over from Sharknado, but I'll need to choose what to cut for Jace, and a bunch of the new spot removal spells I added after your earlier rec

deft belfry
#

well i am going to make some food before work but i will be around after work for sure

sweet ember
#

I decided to add:
[[Reality Shift]]: Cheap Exile is preferred over Pongify because I ave Counterspells to make the difference
[[Ravenform]]: Exile is same, and sorcery speed is fin for me when I can make up with Counterspells, I added it cuz I like Foretell and its kinda funny to turn an enemy threat into a lil 1/1 birb like I have
[[The Phasing of Zhalfir]]: Just like Season of Weaving, its a multi-purpose Boardwipe for relatively cheap, since the read ahead ability lets me choose between nullifying threats for a turn for two turns, leading up to an indiscriminate board wipe that usually helps me more than my opponents, or immediately use the board wipe if I need it

shrewd zealotBOT
#

Enchantment โ€” Saga
Read ahead (Choose a chapter and start with that many lore counters. Add one after your draw step. Skipped chapters don't trigger. Sacrifice after III.)
I, II โ€” Another target nonland permanent phases out. It can't phase in for as long as you control this Saga.
III โ€” Destroy all creatures. For each creature destroyed this way, its controller creates a 2/2 black Phyrexian creature token.

sweet ember
#

Also put [[Aetherize]] in the sideboard, to be used specifically against big stompy creature decks, go wide decks, or both

shrewd zealotBOT
sweet ember
#

Also decided to replace one of my counterspells with [[Narset's Reversal]] because that card seems like yet another fun, cheap, and multipurpose card

shrewd zealotBOT
sweet ember
brave dragon
#

Found this little guy and I wonder if he has a potential place in zombies

deft belfry
#

Narset's Reversal, one of my most mentioned counterspell, because unless you are certain you need to keep something in grave after that counterspell, narset reversal basically does the job better almost every other time
sometimes, it also have alternative synergy with the commander or value pieces, in this case, the copy will trigger emeritus

deft belfry
#

4 mana 2/2 overcosted, body allows for repeatable recursion but with scarab god... you can just use scarab god instead

deft belfry
#

[[test of talent]] is a potential counterspell i would want to try if i ever come across one ๐Ÿ˜› its like a nerfed [[muddle the mixture]] that can see my opponent's hand and library

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

iirc, since it counters a spell from the stack > which should put that spell into the grave, it should also be able to exile said spell from grave afterward? [[?test of talents]]

shrewd zealotBOT
#
2021-04-16

Countering a spell normally puts that card into the graveyard, so that card will be there to find and exile.

2021-04-16

If the back face of a modal double-faced card is countered, you will not be able to exile any cards, including the one that you countered, because those cards have only their front-face characteristics (including name) in the graveyard, hand, and library.

deft belfry
#

Yep

#

i guess this relevant to those who tried to do spellslingers @wicked gust i think this simplify things down?

wicked gust
#

I mean I won the first game with it after we made those few changes, so lol

#

Was a very explosive turn

deft belfry
#

Xp how did you lose all the previous games?

wicked gust
#

....i think i only lost 1 and won the other 2 games with the eris deck XD

#

i think i played legit onl,.y 2 games wiht it, first oner was a loss, 2nd i won supert hardcore, than we made changes and i wont he first game with it XD

#

so

deft belfry
#

ah so it was okay

#

you just have tooooooooo many decks to cycle through all of them

#

[[$white lotus tile]]

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

[[$wizard class]]

shrewd zealotBOT
wicked gust
deft belfry
#

how many weeks* to play each one at least once ๐Ÿ˜…

gilded timber
sweet ember
#

So I managed to cut the deck down to 100 cards with the new additions (By removing two of the new removal spells and my only counterspell that cares about card type), but got drawn into a new rabbithole of "Give all cards Flash" effects

#

Im already running [[Valley Floodcaller]] and [[High Fae Trickster]], but I was thinking of either adding in a third for extra redundancy or replacing High Fae Trickster (Valley Floodcaller is locked in because both effects are perfect for the deck)

shrewd zealotBOT
sweet ember
#

The two candidates for the third slot or to replace HFT:
[[Tidal Barracuda]]: 4 CMC, same as HFT, but lacks Flash, and the ability to Flash all spells also applies to my opponents. Upsides are that 4 Toughness makes it much less squishy than HFT, and it stops players from taking advantage of Flash on my turn, which combined with the symmetrical nature of the first ability does give room for fun politics
[[Leyline of Anticipation]]: 4 CMC same as HFT, but lacks Flash. Upside is that it's an Enchantment so its much harder to remove, and if I get lucky with my draw/Mulligans I can cast it turn 0 for free

shrewd zealotBOT
sweet ember
#

So any thoughts on if I should run three of these, and if so which ones? and if not, should I replace HFT with any of these two, or is Valley Floodcaller+High Fae Trickster enough?

deft belfry
#

so plan seems to be T3 kona and tap it for second main cheat

#

whats the problem you ahve encountered

#

too straight forward? not enough consistency?

gilded timber
#

Either i cant get Kona early enough or i ended up with nothing to cheat early game.

deft belfry
#

lack the piece to tap kona

#

ah

gilded timber
#

I like the gameplan even if its straight forward

#

But its a difficult balance to have consistency to ramp/tap AND have something to get on the battlefield

deft belfry
#

i think kona on T4 is fine, as long as there is a way to tap right away

#

the simpliest way to fix consistency would be more card draw let me see what is here

#

thinking about [[smuggler's surprise]] for back up effect if kona isnt ready

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

the "draw" is risky but is one of the modes to get 2 cards

gilded timber
#

I think i already put it in here

deft belfry
#

okay, will have to finish looking throught the rest

#

is [[shigeki, jukai visionary]] there

shrewd zealotBOT
gilded timber
#

I may not have put it in the draw section tho since i mostly use it for protection

gilded timber
deft belfry
#

ok i will look at it again after lunch, mainly trying to get the early game smooth out

#

some of those draw spells like [[!return of the wildspeaker]] & rishkar experitise really need your game plan to be ready to deploy. so if that first part didnt work, having to spend 5+ mana for a small draw will be really hard on the deck

deft belfry
#

[[beanstalk giant]] modal spell, [[elemental bond]] while those can be added, the overall "fix" is just having things that can be played even if kona is not ready

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

i see two sides of the deck

#

one is where you want / can only hard cast

#

and the other side are things you basically never want to cast; which need kona to cheat into play

#

having cards that can suit both side allows for the flexiblity in case something goes wrong

#

so i would swap out the ramp that doesnt actually synergize with the commander

#

those can explode into an early game start but they dont provide any card advantage or mana ramp without playing more cards of your hand

#

i think it is actually worse than [[worn shaku]] in this case

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

[[arbor elf]] can untap the enchanted land

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

big thing that add fuel into the engine [[regal force]]

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

simple but effective

#

if you insist on the "enchantment" side of green, which i doubt is the case here, [[eidolon of blossoms]] & [[sanctum weaver]] are some of the powerhouse in a semi-enchantress deck which i believe is where burgeoning and exploration belongs in more

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

[[hunter insight]] is a budget draw payoff that i really like in green stompies

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

to turn all draws into what you need [[abundance]] combos with svylan library as the ultimate draw replacement effect

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

but even by itself you can skip all the lands to get to your big stuff

#

this is curve rn before all the changes

#

i can somewhat expect the 3 cmc curve to go up and the never cast 6+ cmc to curve to go up as well

#

taking away from 1-2,4-5 etc And having 5 mana ready to play Kona and tap is the best timing

#

not a big fan of [[stone hoof chieftain]] because it comes down after second main, so attack is kinda over already. by itself an 8/8 indestructible is solid. yet most of the time, no one is going to try to destroy something with 6+ toughness with burn/combat damage

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

unnatural growth is a good example of the "both category" middle ground as it can be hard cast for the buff before combat, or just simple valye cheat if comes out after kona

#

mono green can completely ignore the 4 manag colour pips

#

more draw [[war room]] not here, i run that in almost all my 2 colour decks

#

yet to have a colourless deck yet

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

and budget utility lands that i would run are [[ash barren]] [[myriad landscape]] [[blighted woodland]], because as some point in the game they just reduce my land count in the 99 so i have more gas left to draw into

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

i dont need $$ fetch shock to thin my deck as long as i am willing to pay some mana into it

#

essentially draw 1 or 2 card, ramp my land count by 1 turn ahead

#

i think i would probably cut rampant growth to get more utility for the 5 mana play, instead of 4 mana Kona that doesnt get tapped

#

the most ?expensive $mana ramp permanent that comes with card draw [[throne of eldraine]]

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

actually no, the most expensive [[$the great henge]]

shrewd zealotBOT
#
Avatar: The Last Airbender Eternal

$49.45 โ€ข โ‚ฌ40.56 โ€ข 0.76 TIX

Commander Masters

$59.76 โ€ข โ‚ฌ45.40 โ€ข 3.43 TIX

Commander Masters

$86.46 โ€ข 1.82 TIX

Tales of Middle-earth Commander

$84.60 โ€ข โ‚ฌ74.15 โ€ข 2.93 TIX

Tales of Middle-earth Commander

$170.95 โ€ข โ‚ฌ175.23

Throne of Eldraine Promos

$64.98 โ€ข โ‚ฌ43.33

Throne of Eldraine Promos

$89.64 โ€ข โ‚ฌ53.77

Throne of Eldraine

$59.31 โ€ข โ‚ฌ42.19 โ€ข 0.68 TIX

Throne of Eldraine

$84.82 โ€ข โ‚ฌ56.73

deft belfry
#

$$wise i think it is absolutely not worth

#

utility wise it is a one off in the game, not just format

#

getting your early land drops + tap utility then -> big permanents to cheat out is always the challenge without the proper card advantage or filter like Abundance

#

the most land cards are filtered out of the deck, the more consistent it gets to your big fun stuff, or the extreme opposite is run only big stuff so its always going to be big stuff. I think that route is too dumb even for a giant Hulk style deck

#

but it would be interest to see lot of janky creatures on a budget such as [[krosan tusker]]

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

which is just a inefficient cultivate on a body

#

battlecruiser without trample will hardly get through any lethal damage

#

i thought of running that in a cycling theme reanimator deck in sultai or something

deft belfry
#

i dont think i can do more than 3 from my experience but having redundancy sort of depends on how much card advantage is in the deck

#

its like drawing 2 or 3 lands but if you drew 15 cards, 2-3 of the same card is nothing

#

if you only draw 4-5 cards, more than half of those draws are the same card makes them a lot worse

#

tap and utility lands also changes that % slightly as it gives an option to play the tapped for a later turn or untap to keep up with the tempo

#

my verdict on redundant Flash effect would be... if my whole deck depends on it and i can win with a single one (combo deck ?) i would put basically every version in there, if i only want 1 on board, i would rather play tutor or something after the 2nd/3rd copy

#

so because of how tutor usually has restriciton, leylone of anticipation is hard to make the cut into the best 3 with synergy, Barracuda is usually going to cost 4, but playing at flash speed i am not too concern about my creature getting destroyed

#

floodcaller at 3 cmc is easily the best one, high fae still better than fish just for having flash. toughness doesnt matter because destroy doesnt look at toughness

#

good enough draw and ramp and room for the flash enable is what matters

#

[[teferi time raveler]]

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

oops

#

[[teferi mage of zhalfir]]

#

so many teferi in the game

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

๐Ÿ˜ตโ€๐Ÿ’ซ

#

even without typal synergy i think being able to flash itself in is worth the 5 mana. so if it doesnt have to be 4/lowest cost, i would pick that as the 3rd one

#

if you are doing non creature i guess this choice is also off

deft belfry
#

and i finally recall the main reason why decks dont usually run soul guide lantern nor tormod's crpyt; simply because black has bojuka bog and non black has

#

[[scavenger grounds ]]and now [[Abstergo Entertainment]]

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

when that only takes up a utility land slot, there isnt a reason to play a non-land unless they give you a free card, a deck like [[jhoire, weatherlight captain]] which often become a combo storm deck using cheerios artifact anyways so the grave-hate is an afterthought

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

atm you have 3 ways to play at flash speed

#

because of the combo potential and non creature matters, i think i am more interested in [[Tidal barracuda]] to stop my opponent's interaction on my turn for that ...[[voice of victory]] effect i literally forgot the OG verison of that whats the name of it besides dramoka

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

inb4 it may not even be the first printed card with that effect ๐Ÿคž

#

yep, grand abolisher would have been a better guess, it is indeed the first of its effect

#

M12 at least 13 years ago

#

around first time i heard of commander

#

and another reason why i hate white ๐Ÿคฃ "This is NOT a combo deck but I will combo you to win on my turn and you cant respond to whatever i do"

gilded timber
gilded timber
#

@deft belfry so i understand that the global message is to get more card draw and ways to filter what i get at the right time ! I think i can cut some things and put more utility lands to get better versatility

#

Thanks again for taking the time ! Helps alot !

#

Would [[Adventure Awaits]] be something good also for filtering cards?

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

synergy beats > good stuff

deft belfry
#

i run [[ancient stirring]] in one artifact deck (not a common thing in green)

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

it cost half the amount of mana, can grap land and basically all the good pieces of artifact in my deck, even the boardwipe like [[all is dust]]

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

so the idea is that it can grab almost whatever i want and it digs 5 deep

#

back to awaits, it also dig 5 deep, 2 cost is acceptable too, but it can only grab creatures limits its potential and worst case it is a draw 1 after not seeing something you want from the 5.

#

so it can get as far as the 6th card but thats also means you didnt get the piece you want

#

i think it is better than the common green draw like [[harmonize]] that lot of people would run in commander

shrewd zealotBOT
gilded timber
deft belfry
#

worth testing out, let me know if you like that card

#

i will be in await

gilded timber
#

Yeah ! I'll tinker a bit and goldfish a bit. Got a commander night tomorrow so i will test that in a real game also !

deft belfry
#

Nice

#

gtg ๐Ÿ‘‹

gilded timber
#

Thanks again

deft belfry
#

๐Ÿฅฑ

#

lurking again

#

while this might be off from the colours, it somewhat shows what those filter/top deck card selection cards looks like [[reality heist]]

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

1)expect some form of synergy with rest of deck, maybe even spellslinger

#
  1. reasonablly costed and works along side game plan (blue may care about instants more since they can hold up open mana to do other things vs green playing more creature spells)
#

3)look for certain specific pieces but can dig deep, i think 7 is about as far as it goes without looking through the deck same card type polymorph style

#
  1. then the number of cards it gives back (1 for 1 is cantrip thus using mana for no increase in card advantage)
haughty frost
#

Hello @deft belfry! Been a minute since I needed some help on a deck but here I am again requesting assistance. I need help cutting out 9 more cards for my Sibsig Zombies list helmed by The Ghoul. The main plan of the deck is to get the sibsig ceremony on board with the commander and some sort of aristocrats payoff to go insane with value, with the B plan being more incremental sacrifice plus payoffs. I've been trimming away at possible cards for days and I just can't figure out how to get to a clean 100. Thank you so much in advance!
List: https://archidekt.com/decks/19071865/ghoul_zoombies

deft belfry
#

[[sibsig ceremony ]] not a common card to see in commander XD

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

@haughty frosti think you didnt set it to be public

haughty frost
#

shit i forgor

deft belfry
#

which is why it doesnt show a link preview

haughty frost
#

lemme fix

#

should be updated

deft belfry
#

k

haughty frost
deft belfry
#

i will restrain myself from too many adds in this case esp with a maybe pool that big

haughty frost
#

those arer all prior cut cards ๐Ÿ’€

deft belfry
#

if sibsig ceremony triggers and sees nothing

#

do it still create the token?

#

[[?sibsig ceremony ]]

shrewd zealotBOT
haughty frost
#

yes!

deft belfry
#

๐Ÿ‘Œ

#

so at worst it is kinda like [[heartless summoning]] cost reduction

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

so the triple black pips from [[ayara first of locthwain]] is kinda odd

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

do you mainly put rad counters on yourself

haughty frost
#

yeah putting rad counters on opponents is a late game thing

#

i want the ramp for sure

deft belfry
#

for now maybe dont need some of the sac outlets, using it on non token is card advantage neutral

#

[[village rite]]

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

i can see potential loops with aritfact creatures but we will stay off that until i figure out whats going on

#

tutor for main piece in the 99 > try to create big board of zombies

#

lot of death triggers

#

abuse cost reduction for etb ability

#

i think some creatures will get cut if they dont offer enough card advantage

#

especially the bad top decks

#

[[nine-lives familiar]] not sure how i feel about this one

shrewd zealotBOT
#

Creature โ€” Cat
This creature enters with eight revival counters on it if you cast it.
When this creature dies, if it had a revival counter on it, return it to the battlefield with one fewer revival counter on it at the beginning of the next end step.
Her master gathered the bones to resurrect her, only to find her purring on the altar.
1/1

deft belfry
#

like i consider [[not dead after all]] timing on your own turn to be restrictive enough

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

since it is also being used against your own effect

#

[[kaya ghost form]] face an even bigger problem at sorcery speed

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

checking for zombie counter in the deck for [[diregraf colossus]]

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

maybe not worth because it is like a big beater with no evasion

#

if it stays around to create more zombies, then its okay

#

potential tribal support [[cryptic gateway]]

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

5 is very high cost tho but can get around ridiculous high cast cost

#

most important card i dont see here [[drivnod carnage dominus]]

shrewd zealotBOT
haughty frost
#

so you'd recommend cutting village rites, nine-lives familiar, ayara, kaya's ghostform, and diregraf?

deft belfry
#

atm yeah, if you find a place for them they maybe able to stay, currently i dont think they affect what the commander do that much or help with the "instant speed" sacrifice -> zombie tokens

haughty frost
#

i see

#

any other cards that should probably go?

deft belfry
#

i am curious where is your sad golem

#

2 mana land ramp cantrip

#

i thought i used the filter search incorrectly XD

shrewd zealotBOT
#

No card found named โ€œsolemn simulacrumโ€ in โ€œ837โ€

deft belfry
#

[[!solemn simulacrum|who|837]]

haughty frost
#

i cut the sad robot cuz i was in the mood of cutting ramp cuz my commander ramps me but that is an excellent point

#

may put it back in

deft belfry
#

[[the ghoul gunslinger]] but its also treasure

shrewd zealotBOT
haughty frost
#

that's true

#

yeah will prob put it back in once i have the space

deft belfry
#

i think that amount will always be less than what [[black market]] offers you

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

the mana shouldnt be the biggest concern because you will have all the death triggers, the problem i see is how much cards you will be losing

haughty frost
#

i see

deft belfry
#

like, [[altar of the wretched]] can come in with no nontoken on board

shrewd zealotBOT
#

Artifact
When this artifact enters, you may sacrifice a nontoken creature. If you do, draw X cards, then mill X cards, where X is that creature's power.
Craft with one or more creatures mana2manabmanab
mana2manab: Return this card from your graveyard to your hand.

Wretched Bonemass
Creature โ€” Skeleton Horror
Wretched Bonemass's power and toughness are each equal to the total power of the exiled cards used to craft it.
This creature has flying as long as an exiled card used to craft it has flying. The same is true for first strike, double strike, deathtouch, haste, hexproof, indestructible, lifelink, menace, protection, reach, trample, and vigilance.
*/*

deft belfry
#

ofc you wont cast it, so it get stuck in hand

haughty frost
#

my ass did NOT read the nontoken part

#

welp that card's out for sure

deft belfry
#

:c but that could be big draw ... i guess thats a dream scenario

#

it also cares about power

haughty frost
#

it's an awesome card but this isn't the deck for it unfortunately

#

any other cuts?

deft belfry
#

with both "commander" out, failgree familar and [[circuit mender]] can be zero cost cantrip

shrewd zealotBOT
haughty frost
#

unfortunately the commander only makes treasures when a zombie or mutant dies

deft belfry
#

ooh right i forgot about the zombie part

haughty frost
#

else i would not be playing so many zombie synergies lol

deft belfry
#

[[species specialist]] will have that synergy

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

anthem effect [[patchwork banner]] [[heraldic banner]]

shrewd zealotBOT
haughty frost
#

ic

deft belfry
#

i expect lot of the things to die anyways. unless you get out lost monarch of ifnir]] before the enchantment, its cant survive

#

and if it is about reanimate.. i think you only want the best creature

#

afflict 3 is powerful, but only if it stays on board

#

are you making the cuts mentioned above, because i still see 6 cards there

#

village rites, nine-lives familiar, ayara, kaya's ghostform, diregraf, altar wretched

haughty frost
#

making them once i've gotten your feedback lol

#

thank you so much for your advice! you're a massive help as usual

deft belfry
#

are you playing with proxy [[$yawmoth will]]

shrewd zealotBOT
#

No card found for โ€œyawmoth willโ€

haughty frost
#

this deck would prob be full proxied

#

cuz of a bunch of expensive cards like the aforementioned yawgmoth's will

deft belfry
#

its normally a big value piece idk if its going to work here but i guess its worth trying

#

meh on bloodartist since its never going to be the reanimate target

#

unless you have [[wake the dead]]

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

may as well cut zulaport too for being non zombie

haughty frost
deft belfry
#

XD

#

that explains all the tutors

#

i want to cut from that pile but not sure where to start

haughty frost
deft belfry
#

yeah i know

#

just so many

haughty frost
#

tru

#

i may cut one of the beseech's or a grim tutor

deft belfry
#

i find the replacement for monarch of ifnir

#

[[cove of darkness]] iirc the name

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

Yes i did

#

[[$cove of darkness]] one of my favourite tribal card i will never own ๐Ÿ˜ข

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

hmm maybe i can find a reasonable copy

haughty frost
#

perhaps

deft belfry
#

assass in has 3 version

haughty frost
#

or just proxy it

deft belfry
#

i will first look through my LGS with the biggest inventory

haughty frost
#

yk what fair enough

deft belfry
#

now i think the cuts and swaps is in the creature and sorcery

#

things that cares more about non token,

#

or single use etb

#

[[massacre girl]] for sure kills your own board ๐Ÿ˜…

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

without a coat of arm idk how you survive your nonbos

haughty frost
#

massacre girl is in there for when i desparately need a boardwipe and i want to do it in style

#

may cut her anyways tbh

#

okay cut out a few more cards and added in the sad robot to get down to 100

deft belfry
#

i think i perfer flare of malice over

#

not dead after all

haughty frost
#

ye fair

#

not dead after all is mostly there for commander protection tbh

#

may make the swap after some testing

deft belfry
#

tru

haughty frost
#

tysm for the help!

deft belfry
#

np

#

and you know i am still eyeing at that sorcery pile

haughty frost
#

yup

#

i love me my tutors tho

deft belfry
#

oh i dont mind the secret commander search

#

[[!torment of hallfire]] i find it turn games to be more salty

deft belfry
#

torment of sea water XD

haughty frost
#

torment of sea water is crazy lmao

deft belfry
#

or if not salty, antidramatic

#

X spell problem

#

game is too easy to make mana i guess

haughty frost
#

true true

#

i like the consistend finisher/mana sink but then again i usually also have other wincons

deft belfry
#

can always get some post game opinion on those type of things

haughty frost
#

real

deft belfry
#

it really dependso n the length of the game

#

longer game = more mana = anyone can win suddenly

#

one card + big mana is the out of nowhere win con that defy expectations

#

but there is a first time for everything

haughty frost
#

mhm

#

random question but what's your favorite brew you've ever done?

deft belfry
#

depends on requirement

#

because some commanders/decks are so broken or oppressive while i am able to put the deck together to a point i am satisfy with before taking apart... the deck and the game play is not fun to play against for my opponent

#

so the expectation meets reality yet is not the most comforting

haughty frost
#

fair point

deft belfry
#

but if the idea is too far out in the field, it never gets to a point for a functional deck

#

i think i like a commander that feels flexible and can have many workable unique and personalized 99

#

hard to judge when it is revealed, not overly powerful and become archenemy on sight

#

and is fun/funny to see for the table regardless of who is winning, as everyone somewhat stands a chance in that game. which is perhaps more of a power level match up more than the commander itself

#

maybe [[niv mizzet reborn]] ?

shrewd zealotBOT
#

Legendary Creature โ€” Dragon Avatar
Flying
When Niv-Mizzet enters, reveal the top ten cards of your library. For each color pair, choose a card that's exactly those colors from among them. Put the chosen cards into your hand and the rest on the bottom of your library in a random order.
6/6

deft belfry
#

but i upgraded that one too much so it kinda gotten a bit too strong

#

5 colour good stuff problem

#

[[rakdos the defiler]] match my energy but it doesnt have the ideal game play as it somewhat leans into king making. And i openly admit that it is a bad creature/bad commander

shrewd zealotBOT
haughty frost
#

cool commander tho

deft belfry
#

if i can give it away then goad it

haughty frost
#

that sounds hysterical

#

bracket 1 as hell but hysterical

#

rakdos would approve

deft belfry
#

nah its not B1

#

its disregard safety measures, and put on maximum turbo overdrive mode

#

"I can put on a seatbelt, but i take this feature off, i have lighten the weight to go faster"

haughty frost
#

Lmao

deft belfry
#

i turned [[kykar wind's fury]] jank into [[vadrok apex of thunder]]inconsistent combo loop into [[gandalf the grey]]random jank combo

shrewd zealotBOT
#

Legendary Creature โ€” Elemental Dinosaur Cat
Mutate mana1manawumanarmanar (If you cast this spell for its mutate cost, put it over or under target non-Human creature you own. They mutate into the creature on top plus all abilities from under it.)
Flying, first strike
Whenever this creature mutates, you may cast target noncreature card with mana value 3 or less from your graveyard without paying its mana cost.
3/3

#

Legendary Creature โ€” Avatar Wizard
Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, choose one that hasn't been chosen โ€”
โ€ข You may tap or untap target permanent.
โ€ข Gandalf deals 3 damage to each opponent.
โ€ข Copy target instant or sorcery spell you control. You may choose new targets for the copy.
โ€ข Put Gandalf on top of its owner's library.
3/4

deft belfry
#

while i prefer the 4 cmc slot more, gandalf gives me 4 different direction to do similar things

haughty frost
#

Gandalf sounds awesome

deft belfry
#

if i have 6 copies of [[maddening cacophony]]

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

i believe it was enough to half everyone to 0

haughty frost
#

silly wincon

deft belfry
#

90
/2 45
/2 22
/2 11
/2 5
/2 2
/2 1
/2 0

#

yep it was 6 copies

#

i have [[radiant performer]] to [[imprison the moon]] to turn the entire board into your first gf [[thats rough buddy]]

shrewd zealotBOT
haughty frost
#

wow

#

that is truly vile

deft belfry
#

you just need mana rock or one new land drop

#

so fix that colour

#

i run my favourite rock [[gilded lotus]] which can be untapped

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

[[heed the mists]] worst type - arcane

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

even 5 mana draw 5 is pretty bad

#

with [[juxtasposition

#

i can give commander to someone else with that last mode left

#

[[juxtasposition]]

shrewd zealotBOT
#

No card found for โ€œjuxtaspositionโ€

deft belfry
#

[[juxtaposition]] comeon close enough

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

same for [[sudden substitution]] which can be copied since split second doesnt affect trigger abilities

shrewd zealotBOT
haughty frost
#

this list has some jank my god

deft belfry
#

never played an elephant gift in my life XD nor the most generic double blue counterspell

#

beast within, narset reverse, muddle the mixture, arcane denial is the closest i have reached

#

[[pyroblast]] got one opponent salty with that one and he fully deserved it XD

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

it was his game winning iconic rift pre-bracket days

#

"what you expect me not to counter that blue spells thats going to wipe my board?" and then following turn opponent beat us all with those cratherhoof I win button win con

#

what i learnt is that: most efficient removal is board wipe but too efficient aka board wipe tribal is same as stax, too much removal essentially becomes stax and stax brings salt

#

unfair and unfun cards are one thing but i prefer low salt and unknown janks so i have my reason to not run many removals to ruin someone's game plan

#

and not run all the problematic cards that demands remove on my board

#

the more removal wasted on me = less on my opponent

#

if my cards are bad enough, theres really no proper reason to target my over some obvious threat

#

if i am the threat, then its just karma to draw all the hate

#

so i need extra protection and defensive spells

haughty frost
#

makes sense

deft belfry
#

i think i dont even run more than 1 of [[swiftfoot boot]] [[lightning greaves]][[lavaspur boots]] in 95% of my decks. it feels too generic

#

and too much focus on protecting commander

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

really want to make my [[progenitus]] work

shrewd zealotBOT
#

manawmanawmanaumanaumanabmanabmanarmanarmanagmanag
Legendary Creature โ€” Hydra Avatar
Protection from everything
If Progenitus would be put into a graveyard from anywhere, reveal Progenitus and shuffle it into its owner's library instead.
The Soul of the World has returned.
10/10

deft belfry
#

but i didnt pick up [[command becon]] so idk if i can get it out consistently

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

and without haste, cannot be targetted, its really not a good voltron option just out of lethal range

#

i reread [[yawgmoth's will]]

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

it counters* your death trigger the turn you use it

#

so all your creature spell arent going to the grave

#

cant cast and expect commander rad + treasure

deft belfry
#

@haughty frost may remove it for that reason but overall its a really powerful piece

sweet ember
shrewd zealotBOT
sweet ember
#

When it comes down to it, BUW can slot in as a Cantrip and EZ is a Land, so since VFC is locked in itโ€™s between HFT and TD

#

And while HFT has advantages, I agree that TDs protection is super good, and the symmetrical buff just seems like fun for the whole table

#

I also cut Ghost Vacuum, since itโ€™s taking a slot when I can replace it with two Lands that donโ€™t, while keeping Stone of Erech since the passive ability seems useful by itself

#

Now though Iโ€™m wondering if I can cut anything to slot in cloners

#

Itโ€™s between:
[[Storm of Saruman]]: A six drop is expensive but it sounds like fun to have a constant clone engine
[[Irenicus Vile Duplication]]: As a quick and dirty clone that works on Legendaries
[[Quantum Misalignment]]: Essentially the same as Irenicus, but with a drawback of 1 CMC in exchange for a free cast next turn

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

those abbreviation confuses me

#

๐Ÿ˜ตโ€๐Ÿ’ซ

#

okay i matched each one

#

HFT is high fae

sweet ember
#

I can cut one card to run 1 of the three or cut 2 to run two of these clone cards, with Irenicus as my first choice to cut

#

What do you think?

sweet ember
#

BUW Borne Upon the Wind

deft belfry
#

irenicus >= quantum > sarumanstorm

sweet ember
sweet ember
deft belfry
#

i consider it better or equal

sweet ember
#

Oh ok

deft belfry
#

i think one cast is often enough

#

if i have cost reduction then they are pretty much the same

#

if i can cast with ignoring mana cost then the effect is the same and cost doesnt matter

sweet ember
#

Is the six mana for Saruman really that bad if itโ€™s a sustained engine?

deft belfry
#

and i still have to wait a full turn to attack anyways

#

its not that bad but unecessary, i ran it with a control deck with 2nd spell theme before so i can reach that curve

sweet ember
deft belfry
#

6 mana matters because it affect how much mana you have left over for the following spells

sweet ember
#

Hmm I see your point

#

Wait

#

Imma bit stupid

deft belfry
#

being a sorcery naturally means you may tap out on your turn

#

blue cares about open mana a lot

sweet ember
#

If I wanted to clone spells consistently I already have [[Rimefire Torque]]

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

less resources usually end up with more open mana and give a sense of urgency to in coming threats. tap out means you dont have a respond

#

yes you have that

sweet ember
#

And any time I wanted to clone a Creature instead of a spell I can just use Irenicus or Quantum

deft belfry
#

so saruman is worth even less

sweet ember
#

Yeah

deft belfry
#

even tho it is the second spell each turn, for potential flash creatures legendary clones

#

but it is such a niche case

sweet ember
#

Well with Saruman gone I can run two clones with one cut, or run only a single one

#

Which one do you think would be better

deft belfry
#

the difference would be like [[twinning staff]] and [[primal vigor]]

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

copy spell vs create tokens

deft belfry
sweet ember
deft belfry
#

perhaps you should try quantum

deft belfry
#

[[parallel lives]]

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

doesnt say counter but is the good part of doubling seasoning

#

[[anoited possession]]

shrewd zealotBOT
#

No card found for โ€œanoited possessionโ€

deft belfry
#

[[anointed possession]]

shrewd zealotBOT
sweet ember
# deft belfry perhaps you should try quantum

So I shouldnโ€™t cut anything to make space for two? I feel like Jace Wielder of Mysteries real value comes from winning on empty library, and after some time I realize that without an engine to work for infinite card draw he loses his main value since my only other way to win with him is to stack multiple Coastal Piracies and attack with a loot of birds over several turns, but at that point if I canโ€™t win with the cards I draw then the deck has failed

deft belfry
#

process process process anointed anointed get this card name wrong every time i hate the card lol

sweet ember
#

[[Mondrak, Glory Dominus]]

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

i think the order they were release is doubling season -> parallel lives -> anointed procession then much more recent mondrak

#

because smoothering tithe not busted enough

deft belfry
#

should be able to win before decking out

#

ofc there are things like [[glacial clasm]] but at that point nothing will help you

shrewd zealotBOT
#

Land
Cumulative upkeepโ€”Pay 2 life. (At the beginning of your upkeep, put an age counter on this permanent, then sacrifice it unless you pay its upkeep cost for each age counter on it.)
When this land enters, sacrifice a land.
Creatures you control can't attack.
Prevent all damage that would be dealt to you.

sweet ember
#

It doesnโ€™t stop attacks, just damage, so [[Twenty-Toad Toad]] works as normal, same with my other win cons

shrewd zealotBOT
sweet ember
#

Anyways, thanks for the help man

#

Thanks to you Iโ€™ve been able to shape up my deck

#

Knowing me Iโ€™ll hear about some beautiful effect and begin trying to cut cards to slot it in

#

But

#

Right now I think I can go and build this deck

#

Wait

#

[[Flusterstorm]]

shrewd zealotBOT
sweet ember
#

Is it worth it to replace a more universal Counterpell for Flusterstorm, exchanging a generally useful piece for a more situational card that guarantees a win in a counter war?

#

Nvm way too expensive, Iโ€™ll look to it as a Sideboard option if I play against other Blue players once I finish this deck

deft belfry
#

i think that one is closer to high power staple [[$flusterstorm]] i wouldnt go for it

shrewd zealotBOT
#
Mystery Booster 2

$8.24 โ€ข โ‚ฌ4.38

Modern Horizons 3

$6.62 โ€ข 10.91 TIX

The List

$13.99

Modern Horizons

$8.70 โ€ข โ‚ฌ3.17 โ€ข 0.64 TIX

Magic Online Promos

0.69 TIX

Iconic Masters

$8.64 โ€ข โ‚ฌ4.89 โ€ข 1.80 TIX

Legendary Cube Prize Pack

2.39 TIX

Vintage Masters

1.31 TIX

Judge Gift Cards 2012

$82.17 โ€ข โ‚ฌ39.30

Commander 2011

$10.28 โ€ข โ‚ฌ5.35 โ€ข 4.26 TIX

deft belfry
#

i dont think [[!mana drain]] the counterspell with no real downside need to be in most games of commander either

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

[[$mana drain]]

shrewd zealotBOT
#
Breaking News

$42.31 โ€ข โ‚ฌ36.97 โ€ข 2.99 TIX

Breaking News

$231.50 โ€ข โ‚ฌ144.50 โ€ข 0.40 TIX

Magic Online Promos

5.17 TIX

Double Masters 2022

$52.97 โ€ข โ‚ฌ41.23 โ€ข 6.00 TIX

Double Masters 2022

$62.85 โ€ข โ‚ฌ46.72

Double Masters 2022

$98.99

Magic Online Promos

5.63 TIX

Commander Legends

$52.54 โ€ข โ‚ฌ38.24 โ€ข 5.09 TIX

Commander Legends

$61.19 โ€ข โ‚ฌ56.20

Iconic Masters

$44.86 โ€ข โ‚ฌ40.48 โ€ข 5.55 TIX

brave dragon
#

Mind taking a look at my friends 1st deck?

#

I gave him some suggestions I could

#

No need to write an essay just give some insight what's wrong and will not work

#

Decks goal is to make clues and most likely win by attacking with them

sweet ember
deft belfry
#

card choice dont have issues

#

there are potential for things like [[armed with proof]][[merchant of tru]] find it in the deck just now but overall, would just like low cost cards/hitting land drop on curve

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

i may use [[warfarer bauble]]

shrewd zealotBOT
#

No card found for โ€œwarfarer baubleโ€

deft belfry
#

[[wayfar bauble]]

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

there is one more copy of [[thraben inspector]] that idk the name of

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

okay i see that one in the main deck it is there [[!novice inspector]]

deft belfry
#

i dont see the importance of [[crygen relic]]

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

i am more inclined to look for synergy to create more clues, even at the cost of missing out on some of the best removals

#

i think [[tangletrove kelp]] cost too much and it doesnt make clues

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

[[tribute mage[[ currently lack options. it can find mana rock or etherium sculptor and crystal barricade. its not bad just not flexible

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

potentially [[saphire medallion]] upgrade

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

[[Wojek Investigator]] more impactful and aligned

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

[[junk winder]] can be a high cost win con

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

idk if this is the perfect card [[James, Wandering Dad]]

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

important to note that the interaction with manufactorer is investigate are all seperate instances of creating token

#

budget upgrade can be [[rosie cotton of south lane]]

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

[[stridehangar automaton]] would be the slightly higher $ upgrade

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

[[Bennie Bracks, Zoologist]][[$Bennie Bracks, Zoologist]] also a decent draw engine since reprint

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

i couldnt get one when it was at its lowest

#

waiting for the next future reprint

#

[[master transmuter]]

shrewd zealotBOT
brave dragon
#

I believe most of what you suggested were in the deck at some point but it's a long process for him to be satisfied with the deck XD

deft belfry
#

i think its pretty good as it is, i would perfer higher chance of land drop tho

#

dont really want to miss any of the first 4 lands and the ramp is not guarantee

brave dragon
#

Thank you ๐Ÿ™‚

tall willow
#

got some new cards since last time, but I haven't added two all-star cards yet, those being [[boggart trawler]] and [[witch enchanter]]. should I cut lands for them, or spells?

shrewd zealotBOT
#

Creature โ€” Human Warlock
When this creature enters, destroy target artifact or enchantment an opponent controls.
Shilgengar's famine once starved Stensia into embracing vampirism. The Dawnhart Coven would not let the same happen to Kessig.
2/2

Witch-Blessed Meadow
Land
As this land enters, you may pay 3 life. If you don't, it enters tapped.
manat: Add manaw.
"Ghrin-Danu will not let her people go hungry." โ€”Katilda, Dawnhart Prime

deft belfry
#

cant say every time but most of the time MDFC (land) cuts out a land

empty bison
#

Hey @deft belfry working on my mono red deck. I need to fill a few more slots but also maybe anything im missing. The curve is stupid high so not sure if I need to adjust for smaller spells. https://archidekt.com/decks/19697270/red_warp

Archidekt

Tannuk, Steadfast Second - Commander deck

(1) Commander โ€ข (18) Artifact โ€ข (29) Creature โ€ข (3) Enchantment โ€ข (5) Instant โ€ข (38) Land โ€ข (4) Sorcery

deft belfry
#

๐Ÿ˜„

#

let see if this is a surprise build in mono colour

empty bison
#

Lol! Pretty standard from what I've seen. This is just the 1st rough draft.

deft belfry
#

yea... even blightsteel is in there ๐Ÿคฎ

empty bison
#

Just too mean, huh?

#

I have most of all those cards in my collection already. Seemed like an auto include, but a mean one at that.

deft belfry
#

its probably fine

#

B3 sudden death, more of a social thing

#

ramp out Tannuk -> cheat out biggest thing -> Fun

empty bison
#

My favorite way to play is cheat out big things.

deft belfry
#

may need ways to reduce land count or something to be sure there is a valuable enough thing in hand

#

but the core of the deck is definitely there

#

maybe fine tuning and tutors for consistency

#

the middle ground is always the awkward part

#

"do i warp a 5-6 drop or do i hard cast it"

empty bison
#

100%. Seems feast or famine currently

empty bison
deft belfry
#

[[spawn of thraxes]] is one of those, probably only playable in this type of deck but

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

its quality is much lower than the average card in the deck with all the big stuff

#

esp when the best is more like [[!ancient copper dragon]]

deft belfry
#

find the one [[terror of mount velus]]

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

fits that slot more if you want damage

#

which also double combat trigger

#

but card wise, i am more bias toward blast furnace and ofc the crappy avatar of slaughter because of its symmetrical chaos

#

if does "goad" your own board so the downside is a relevant self sabotage ability

#

blast furnace can cheat itself out with thing you are about lose so i find that interesting

#

[[desperate ritual]] add unused storm count

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

i guess its functionally the same as [[simian spirit guide]]

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

i think it is somewhat interchangable if its just for the result. if there is something that cares about instant sorcery, or someone decides to [[helm of awakening]] for some reason, then obviously ritual is better. i like simian since its an ability and harder to interact with.

shrewd zealotBOT
empty bison
deft belfry
#

maybe in the unlikely case where you want to hard cast a creature, it is there. but its overall the same card

#

so tannuk is very straight forward, Timmy Style deck

#

get it out early as possible, untap for big stuff
sort of kill on sight? then your plan folds

#

if you are paranoid about it dying without doing anything... it would take 7 mana to do a single sneak attack turn which is overcosted

#

and suffers with reds biggest weakness of losing card advantage

#

and even when the plan works, there is always a high risk involve with no blockers

#

always glass cannon RPG build

#

so i would focus hardest on getting more cards no matter what

#

since it would negate some of the downside if i am low on cards, commander getting recasted, land drop each turn

#

over going even faster with acceleration and pure ramp

deft belfry
#

weird enough, its looks more interesting to me now since it allows for all those big mana rocks to get the curve right [[gilded lotus]] [[!coveted jewal]], where warp kinda bypass the downside a little as well

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

the 3 open mana also storm off making itself mana neutral

#

in this deck specifically, i can see [[jeskai's will]] having a much higher chance of whiffing but it is always a powerful card

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

really liking the artifact in here

empty bison
#

Get RPG'd baby!

empty bison
#

Possible turn 3 kill with blightsteel is NOT ok in a bracket 3 spelltable game. I may have to sandbag that if it comes up. In my home pod, they will get it full force. Hahaha.

deft belfry
#

XD sounds about right, i think i only ever saw 2 blightsteel pre bracket and one of them i got that pseudo [[tragic slip]] removal on it

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

it may have been tragic slip but idr putting that card in a deck. it was enough to get rid of the blightsteel is what matters

#

if the card advantage issue is solved, haste blightsteel + a fling effect (i think the sorcery version is a 1 drop and the MDFC is a 3 drop) can KO another player

#

i wonder if sad golem belong in the list at all

#

feels like a wayfar bauble with extra steps

empty bison
#

Same. Sad golem is meh in this case

#

Wait, if you fling an infect creature, it deals infect that time as well?!

deft belfry
#

do you build deck based on "feel" or more on logic and math?

#

[[fling]]

shrewd zealotBOT
empty bison
#

Totally feel, and regret I didn't do more math mid-game. Hahaha

deft belfry
#

oops not fling

#

i think it is something similar

#

more like [[self destruct]]

shrewd zealotBOT
empty bison
#

Ohhh I may want to add that.. I was wondering if I should add fling

deft belfry
empty bison
deft belfry
#

internal monolog: "they may have an aetherize ready for my alpha strike but if they don't, I win

empty bison
#

For sure

deft belfry
#

[[soul's fire]] similar

shrewd zealotBOT
empty bison
#

Ahhh yeah

#

Ive been dying to add a fling style effect to a deck. Maybe now is the time.

deft belfry
#

find it with google AI ๐Ÿ˜“

empty bison
#

Lamo

deft belfry
#

self destruct is basically the "best" one

#

the AI failed like 3 times

empty bison
#

Hahaha

deft belfry
#

as a chaotic neutral, we should put our lives under the care of AIs ๐Ÿ˜„

empty bison
#

Man, I probably should. I would yell at my kids less...

#

I forget they are kids too often. And try and treat them like an adult.

deft belfry
deft belfry
#

replace yourself with a voice recorder to yell at the kids automatically

empty bison
#

Hahahhhahahagagaga

deft belfry
empty bison
#

Hahaha perfect

#

I made a [[urbrask]] deck that was stupid and need a new mono red deck.

shrewd zealotBOT
#

No card found for โ€œurbraskโ€

deft belfry
#

which one

empty bison
#

[[Urabrask]]

shrewd zealotBOT
#

Legendary Creature โ€” Phyrexian Praetor
First strike
Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, Urabrask deals 1 damage to target opponent. Add manar.
manar: Exile Urabrask, then return it to the battlefield transformed under its owner's control. Activate only as a sorcery and only if you've cast three or more instant and/or sorcery spells this turn.
4/4

The Great Work
Enchantment โ€” Saga
(As this Saga enters and after your draw step, add a lore counter.)
I โ€” This Saga deals 3 damage to target opponent and each creature they control.
II โ€” Create three Treasure tokens.
III โ€” Until end of turn, you may cast instant and sorcery spells from any graveyard. If a spell cast this way would be put into a graveyard, exile it instead. Exile this Saga, then return it to the battlefield (front face up).

deft belfry
#

the impulse draw?

empty bison
#

Yeag

deft belfry
#

ahh lowkey my favourite one

#

thats not the impulse one

#

thats the spellslinger and past in flame

#

its so hard to flip so i want to use it as a commander just to flip it once

#

but i like OG ubrask. although its just haste and blind obedience so its kinda boring

empty bison
#

The OG one is a bit boring.

#

I still have the deck put together. I have so many decks with 90+ cards that I need to just take apart.

#

Some day come the the states and dig through all my cards. Hahaha

deft belfry
#

we now have [[rising of the day]] so i only run it when i really need that haste and more creatures

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

take apart?

empty bison
#

Yeah, just don't play enough. I have an Urabrask, a Wilhelt, a Edgar, and a few more I just have taken cards out of and they are just sitting there. Also a Kaalia that was wild as well.

#

I struggle with building decks off of impulse and not play them enough.

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

i think [[$frevor]] was also more expensive too for the longest time

shrewd zealotBOT
#

No card found for โ€œfrevorโ€

deft belfry
#

[[$fervor]]

shrewd zealotBOT
#
Avatar: The Last Airbender Eternal

$1.25 โ€ข โ‚ฌ1.76 โ€ข 0.41 TIX

Magic 2013

$5.85 โ€ข โ‚ฌ3.00 โ€ข 0.02 TIX

Seventh Edition

$5.34 โ€ข โ‚ฌ2.86 โ€ข 0.02 TIX

Seventh Edition

$57.35

Classic Sixth Edition

$4.42 โ€ข โ‚ฌ3.84

Weatherlight

$4.47 โ€ข โ‚ฌ2.79 โ€ข 0.03 TIX

empty bison
#

Free vor

#

Lamo

empty bison
deft belfry
empty bison
#

I stared around M13 and then have been hit or miss since. Started back full steam about 6 months ago

deft belfry
#

gwen from spiderman is too straight forward imo but its is probably the closer to those effects

deft belfry
#

M13 was the first commander cards i brought

empty bison
empty bison
#

And ofc Avacyn.

#

Different times. Slower games and not as polished.

#

Now all the randos I play with on spelltable have ultra polished decks.

#

My next commander is 100% [[grimgrin]]

shrewd zealotBOT
empty bison
#

My friend gave me a Grimgrin deck as my first deck and I want to rebuild it.

deft belfry
#

enough time and number of turns to do something less efficient to get to the finishing line

#

luke warm take: stax is good for the game , especially when the game is getting too fast out of control

deft belfry
deft belfry
empty bison
#

Not quite. I have sooo many zombie cards. I would take apart my Wilhelt deck and add most of it to it.

empty bison
#

Also, working on Maralen. ๐Ÿ™‚

deft belfry
#

because sac engine in commander zone + counters on a single thing, could lead to some fast infinite

empty bison
#

Told you, I just dive in deep and only sometimes finish them.

deft belfry
#

i think there are many maralen builds since it was a face commander

empty bison
#

[[Maralen, fae ascendant]]

shrewd zealotBOT
#

Legendary Creature โ€” Elf Faerie Noble
Flying
Whenever Maralen or another Elf or Faerie you control enters, exile the top two cards of target opponent's library.
Once each turn, you may cast a spell with mana value less than or equal to the number of Elves and Faeries you control from among cards exiled with Maralen this turn without paying its mana cost.
4/5

empty bison
#

That one?

deft belfry
#

yeah

#

that was the maralen you mentioned right

empty bison
#

Yeah, it was a face commander?

deft belfry
#

unless i got out of my way to build a [[morophon boundless]] tribal tribal deck i doubt i will get close to that one

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

is it not

#

oh i must have confused it with the other one

empty bison
#

I think it's the blight one and the absolutely wild Ashling.

deft belfry
#

right theres only 2 precon this set

empty bison
#

Everytime I've played Ashling, I've been dominated

deft belfry
#

i must have mixed up the past faerie precons

#

dominated? not dominating? wait that meant the same thing lol

empty bison
#

Dominted. I should say they were not precons.

#

The etb triggers multipled.

deft belfry
#

yeap its one of those explosive decks

#

i think seeing the face commander and what i remember about elemental was enough to turn me away from getting it

#

as much as i would love to play with double cascade 8 drop

#

having it telling you to play it on the commander is a bit much on the nose

empty bison
#

For sure.

deft belfry
#

and thats not even the most broken elemental

empty bison
#

I played a game here on this discord and 2 of the 4 people were playing upgraded Ashlings...

#

It was not the greatest.

#

Hahaha

deft belfry
#

[twinflame traveler]] is a thing i want to get for my 99 of a not so elemental focused deck

#

[[twinflame traveler]] budget roaming throne

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

just waiting for a single copy to show up in my LGS

empty bison
#

Ohhh wow. Fun card.

deft belfry
#

price tag, colour identity "limitaiton", good body

#

just fits all the bill

empty bison
#

It really does

deft belfry
#

not so broken as [[roaming throne]] "yep all and any type"

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

if only "colourless" is a colour identity

empty bison
#

Lol for sure. I need (4) of that card. Just not yet. Hahaha

deft belfry
#

Cost mana3 manac. Must include colourless pip in the commander identity to play this card

#

broken format will remain broken ยฏ_(ใƒ„)_/ยฏ

#

its a personal choice not to spend $50 for a card nor to play a broken effect

#

i do wish i can own and causally run an [[ancient tomb]] in my self inflicting pain deck

shrewd zealotBOT
empty bison
#

True that.

deft belfry
#

maybe i will pick up the pokemon copy instead

empty bison
deft belfry
#

acutally i think i have this card

#

2004 pokemon

#

sounds about right i guess i have to look through my pokemon cards now

empty bison
#

Do it. That is the best proxy possible

#

Alright, off to dinner. Have a great night and I'll let you know once my Grimgrin is ready lol.

#

Appreciate you as always my friend. ๐Ÿ™‚

deft belfry
#

so far i only tagged half of the tunnuk stuff

#

still making comparison and swaps. the pricey powerhouse are the most flexible slot as expected

#

have fun at dinner

#

@silk cairn why didnt you merge Tunnuk and rocket Raccon ! the double commander with artifacts sneak attack ๐Ÿ˜„

#

maybe [[bloodthirster]] as win con

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

the 0/0 haste attacking part is nice overlap

#

looks like that deck no longer exist?

#

maybe the middle ground can be [[zealous conscripts]] which may have synergy with the self destruct type of cards

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

gtg to work

empty bison
sweet ember
#

After using so many Utility Lands, I realize that [[Vedalken Shackles]] has stopped being worth it

shrewd zealotBOT
sweet ember
#

Any recommendations on a removal piece to use in replacement?

storm fox
#

[[helm of possession]]?

shrewd zealotBOT
sweet ember
#

Oooh

#

Six mana is pricey

#

But I only considered Vedalken Shackles because it sounded like it would lead to fun shenanigans in politics anyways

deft belfry
#

i run [[chamber of manipulation]], which is little less janky than your shackles

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

but my has discard synergy

silk cairn
cold quartz
#

triumphant return to rakdos

cold quartz
#

it doesnt feel super inspired for bracket 2 but its not a bad start

deft belfry
#

guttersnipe-generator the commander if i didnt have so many projects tp brew i probably would have got myself one

#

not quite guttersnipe itself [[death waltz 2]]

shrewd zealotBOT
#

No card found for โ€œdeath waltz 2โ€

#

No card found for โ€œdead waltz 2โ€

deft belfry
#

oooh lol i am a No behind

cold quartz
#

yeah the idea for bracket 2 was to not have too many additional pingers and just get additional value from casting good spells/bad spells that are now better because they deal 6 dmg

#

so i think black waltz and the otter are the only additional pingers, i do have a few dmg doublers rn though

deft belfry
#

did you played [[mage contest]] in your pod

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

how did that go

cold quartz
#

it was fun, got a lot of laughs so im including it again

deft belfry
#

nice

#

i think a maybe consider land is [[witch 's clinic]]

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

easy way to gain a lot of life with damage doubler so even in rakdos there is a lot of sustain later in the game

cold quartz
#

do the abilities gain lifelink if the commander has it? or do you just mean for when its bigger turned over

deft belfry
#

where as [[whip of erebos]] will take up a slot but will probably do really well if you are slightly ahead, so clinic is easier to fit

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

the flip side mainly

#

whip is really good but without a board it is much worse

#

a land is easy to include

cold quartz
#

true, yeah i like that

deft belfry
#

i got myself a [[!fire nation palance]] but i am bad at using the mana XD

deft belfry
#

[[dragon rage channeler]] ... not a wizard

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

it does get doubled by harmonic prodigy

#

was hoping it is a better [[fandaniel telophori ascian]]

shrewd zealotBOT
cold quartz
#

yeah i do want more value from casting instant and sorcery cards i think

#

that arent direct burn

#

idk if rakdos has many of those

deft belfry
#

dance with calamity is tough, i cant predict how well it works with all these mana value

cold quartz
#

yeah idk either, figure its worth trying out

deft belfry
#

just value from spell cast like blue's [[emeritus archmage]]?

shrewd zealotBOT
cold quartz
#

yeah something like that

#

or a token creator for something to block with

deft belfry
#

[[virtue of courage]] is the closest i can think of off the top of my head

shrewd zealotBOT
#

Enchantment
Whenever a source you control deals noncombat damage to an opponent, you may exile that many cards from the top of your library. You may play those cards this turn.

Embereth Blaze mana1manar
Instant โ€” Adventure
Embereth Blaze deals 2 damage to any target. (Then exile this card. You may cast the enchantment later from exile.)

cold quartz
#

might be too strong for bracket two tbh if i got my wizards out and am flipped

deft belfry
#

[[judith scourge conno]]

shrewd zealotBOT
#

No card found for โ€œjudith scourge connoโ€

cold quartz
#

just impulse draw half my deck ๐Ÿ˜…

deft belfry
#

but without the mana its not that powerful

#

its 0-turn impulse

cold quartz
#

true

deft belfry
#

all the new impulse are at least 1 full round 1-turn impulse

cold quartz
#

something more unique though maybe, it feels too burny for me and i kind of want it to be burn from valueing, more spellslinger

deft belfry
#

[[!light up the stage]] love this, and it doesnt get powercreeped out of my red decks

deft belfry
#

do your proxy

#

have foils

cold quartz
#

hmm?

#

no proxy, all online, sometimes i do foils if they look cool but sometimes they look wierd on tabletop

deft belfry
#

i find all the "fire" or "light beam" foils to look the best with a good focal point

#

i guess online wouldnt always show

#

if anything i think birgi will be the storm problem

#

idk if it will be too strong here

cold quartz
#

yeah i was thinking that too

#

like why do bergi in b2 when i can hit everyone for 6 because i got [[hot soup]]

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

birgi, stormkiln, runaway, that one ashlin, electroc, same thing

#

COMING THROUGH! whats your chant

#

when you play that

cold quartz
#

i havent played that card before ngl lol

#

do i need my own chant

deft belfry
#

XD

cold quartz
#

prolly "hot behind"

#

but loud af

deft belfry
#

hot behind sounds like someone sat on a hot potatoe but i guess that works too

cold quartz
#

hahaha naw its kitchen call outs

deft belfry
#

[[judith carnage connoisseur]]

shrewd zealotBOT
#

Legendary Creature โ€” Human Shaman
Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, choose one โ€”
โ€ข That spell gains deathtouch and lifelink.
โ€ข Create a 2/2 red Imp creature token with "When this token dies, it deals 2 damage to each opponent."
"I don't make my living hiding the truth, detective. I shout it from the stage."
3/4

cold quartz
#

for when your slinging around 10 gallons of hot soup

deft belfry
#

that was the card i forgot the name

cold quartz
#

ooh yeah, im also building a b3 list with her that is burn

#

thats why i want this list to be more spellslinger

deft belfry
#

i see

#

then the draw is probably the most important part

cold quartz
#

so yeah i might drop the generically good cards and throw in some funny 1cmc noncreature spells

#

yeah i got my generic midrange decks so now im branching out into different archetypes, hitting up some burn now, got control and want to throw a combo list together after these 2

deft belfry
#

blockers?

cold quartz
#

ooo yeah

#

thats a good shout, lemme scryfall magecraft

deft belfry
#

as much as i avoid using [[skullclamp]] in my own decks, its still one of the best draw engine in all format

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

its like a reusable [[village rites]][[corrupted conviction]][[desperate measure]]

shrewd zealotBOT
cold quartz
#

im a degenerate, i run a lot of skullclamp lol

deft belfry
#

i think i ran skullclamp in like 2/20+ decks? so less than 10%

#

i avoided it when i did my battlecruiser Teysa Karlov

cold quartz
#

i didnt include it in this deck so far because it is a generically good staple but also it takes so many turn cycles to flip kuja so i wouldnt want to sac wizards off early

#

and unless i include a lot more token gen, which i dont want to do, then it would be pretty unreliable to sac a nonwizard

deft belfry
#

right i need to put more focus on [[!kuja, gnome sorcerer]]

shrewd zealotBOT
#

No card found for โ€œkuja, gnome sorcererโ€

deft belfry
#

[[!kuja, genome sorcerer]]

deft belfry
#

wow i was 1 letter off

cold quartz
#

thats fucked lol

#

oh could i include a 2nd end step card? what colors are those

#

isnt there an artifact that does that?

deft belfry
#

is it additional end step?

#

i dont recall that but i know that one unique card that

#

reverse the turn order

#

an interest way to "Flip" the game

cold quartz
#

ooh thats better

deft belfry
#

[[stonic resonator]] can double the end step trigger

shrewd zealotBOT
cold quartz
#

yeah blue has an additional end step card, not too many of those

#

reversing turn order sounds very b2

deft belfry
#

if you make copes of harmonic prodigy then it can also add triggers

cold quartz
#

yeah strionic sounds good, couldnt double the commander trigger when flipped too

#

could*

deft belfry
#

whats that EoE card

#

[[devesatating onslaught]]

shrewd zealotBOT
deft belfry
#

double X is rough