#Cutting cards in my Frodo+Sam deck
1 messages · Page 2 of 1
As long as I get a dual green/something
oh isee
i forgot you dont have fetch
so shocks are not alwyas there
city of brass all the expensive stuff can be direct upgrade
[[isolated chapel]] one of the best t2 land
do you own the trium land
no
thats alright, [[indatha triome]]
its always tapped so it deoesnt actully speed anything up
whats your thought on darksteel ingot nowadays
in general
Alright, lands should be fixed now
Murmuring bosk is the outlier methinks
technically sandsteppe is worse
may as well ask for your opinion about chromatic lantern along with darksteel ignot, the land colour fixing is nice too but i never have one and it feels useless unless the lands are budget and the deck run like ultimatum, there s no point
costs too high. ramp on 3 mana is useless, I've rarely had problem with my colors anyway
For one extra cost you get Thran
depends on commader i guess
Honestly Thran would be much better to re-cast my commanders after they get killed, or eat 3 food.
I went ahead and tagged every cards in deck to have a better view
lands sure went down a lot
but it does match the curve
i think [[access tunnel]] is a direct upgrade instead of rogue passage
with the exception of feasting hobbit (already unblockable) and Guest (trample)
I don't have it in hand. It's on my list though.
Everything in considering I do not own, some would be easy replacements (Like Deadly Rollick or BMco)
ALso why does [[Enduring Tenacity]] seems so much better than [[Sanguine Bond]]?
Am I missing something?
Multiple cards match “vito”, can you be more specific?
(╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻
but it can die to a path/sword, so it is more so a better card advantage rather than strictly better
idk whats the best play here
5 mana turn 4 before attack land drop
eeverything makes token so idk whats the best sequence
part of it is not knowing how close academy manufactor is near the death door 🤣
lotho then peregrin (missing the additional token this time) looks like the safe play while manufactor into cola is the greedy play? which can be done next turn
if manufactor and peregrin stays and get farmer cotton ...
[[meriadox brandybuck]]
Legendary Creature — Halfling Citizen
Whenever one or more Halflings you control attack a player, create a Food token. (It's an artifact with "
,
, Sacrifice this token: You gain 3 life.")
"My dear old Hobbit, you don't allow for the inquisitiveness of friends. I have known about the existence of the Ring for years."
2/2
this got to be one of the most mediore halfling legend, as much as i dont like it, it is cheap and has food, stats, and legend synergy
and no other replacement
i think there are probably stronger draw than phyrexian arena so i am looking into [[tocasia's welcome]] not ideal if it is still once per turn but its better, [[tenuous truce]] has political effect on the table and at least one less opponent trying to remove it, [[dawn of a new age]] just cheap, i think this one is kinda meh but i also dont play white so... i may just be bias, [[loran of the third path]] more politics and modal cards
weird ass stuff i find are [[pursuit of knowledge]] and not worth using [[secret rendevous]]
stick to the classic [[ archvist of oghma]] if you are up against the tutoring power level
[[euduring innocence]] is the welcoming vampire/tocasia upgrade
Enchantment Creature — Sheep Glimmer
Lifelink
Whenever one or more other creatures you control with power 2 or less enter, draw a card. This ability triggers only once each turn.
When Enduring Innocence dies, if it was a creature, return it to the battlefield under its owner's control. It's an enchantment. (It's not a creature.)
2/1
since the food part of the core of the deck is probably perfect
i can only see changes in removal/interactions, and draw
otherwise it will cut into the ramp and mana part of the game
oghma is especially sad if no one doing any unfair magic
so i wouldnt want that in bracket 2, but usually good payoff beyond that?
and i forgot about caretaker's talent
i think almost all of those beats phyrexian arena
[[sunset revelry]] interesting
Turn 4 usually rarely has board wipes but from my experience, anyone taht understands Manufacturer will be gunning for you hard the instant it drops.
With 6 mana, you still need to eat the food so Lotho+Peregrin is the play imo
You can try academy+lotho to try farmer cotton afterwards sure, but you don't have any follow up to all the ressources you're about to get
academy + cola 6 mana make food make treasure
cola then sac treasure to make food make treaure
sac need new food for life
cola make tapped tokens
that was the 6 mana greedy play for instant payoff
and i do that assuming i will miss land drop
on the following turn
first food from sam second food from cola, first treasure mana on cola so second treasure mana to eat food
You're right. I guess it depends how the board state looks like. Becoming arch enemy with no followup is going to be rough
food so powerful idk where to change 😅
I played a couple games yesterday, still no Delney but I won 1 and lost vs 2 hp that I couldve killed if I played better (AKA reading his lands)
The one I lost I started horribly, guy blew up Frodo and took control of Sam for 3 turns and I still almost got him
The one I won was playing solitaire vs an Ur-Dragon and Eowyn
MVP is Definitely Sorin. I took control of The First Sliver, had a white perm on board so it had Lifelink, and had Vito on board so I swung for a massive 14 damage
Honestly, the only changes I'd do is to find space for [[The wind Crystal]] and [[Aerith gainsborough]]
Legendary Artifact
White spells you cast cost
less to cast.
If you would gain life, you gain twice that much life instead.


,
: Creatures you control gain flying and lifelink until end of turn.
"I give unto you the last of my light, and with it, the last hope of a fading world."
I'm looking at Pippin and maybe a removal
[[Eowyn]]
Multiple cards match “Eowyn”, can you be more specific?
[[Eowyn shieldmaiden]]
Human tribal aggro deck
oooh
yeah that one is weird
if they lose the commander with no better set up
they are screw
but go wide go fast perfect textbook example of aggro
maybe humans with hatebear type of effect is the strongest but lot more unfan to play against
XD finally onto pippin
I mean, merry is already out
Multiple cards match “merry”, can you be more specific?
but pippin was something i wanted as one of the cuts long ago
My experience with Merry is vs either boardwipe or flying so he's useless then
[[Pippin warden]]
Legendary Creature — Halfling Advisor
Partner with Merry, Warden of Isengard (When this creature enters, target player may put Merry into their hand from their library, then shuffle.)
,
: Create a Food token.
, Sacrifice four Foods: Other creatures you control get +3/+3 and gain haste until end of turn. Activate only as a sorcery.
2/2
if you need anymore cuts i think it will be the "do nothing" type of cards that resemble doubling season in the deck since you can only run so many in a single deck
[[Merry, Warden ]]
Legendary Creature — Halfling Advisor
Partner with Pippin, Warden of Isengard (When this creature enters, target player may put Pippin into their hand from their library, then shuffle.)
Whenever one or more artifacts you control enter, create a 1/1 white Soldier creature token with lifelink. This ability triggers only once each turn.
1/4
they are more like additional replacement to make more tokens? [[chatterfang]]
Multiple cards match “chatterfang”, can you be more specific?
will see both tokens from merry and perregin
Chatterfang easily replaces merry
Yeah it was
pippin somewaht has a place
I made the change today actually
you have better memory than me looking at 30 decks a day XD
Merry's job was to fetch Pippin most of the time
and i can say this is easily the top 5 if not the top 3 out of the 30s
Thank you lol
[[Astrid peth]] fun bit with this, you can Turn 3 combo without Sam with Astrid
and a lot like you, he plays it multiple times per night
Legendary Creature — Human
Whenever Astrid Peth enters or attacks, create a Food token.
Brand-new Sky — Whenever you sacrifice a Clue or Food, Astrid Peth explores. (Reveal the top card of your library. Put that card into your hand if it's a land. Otherwise, put a +1/+1 counter on this creature, then put the card back or put it into your graveyard.)
2/2
so it is kinda hard to match the power
yeah peth is like a commander of her own in that regard
the underwhelming halfling i mention also do the same
doesnt it
Whenever one or more Halflings you control attack a player, create a Food token.
No
Because Frodo's effect only activate if you got that 3 life before he attacks
ah
You need to eat the food before declaring the attack
didnt notice that much befoer
Im so used to having Sam I forgot food cost 2 when he's not there
lol
yeah peth still need 4 mana so the one mana ramp is needed
otherwise you are stuck with mox/fast mana / [[$elvish spirit guide]]
$1.18 • €1.22
$1.11 • €0.81 • 1.10 TIX
$1.37 • 1.06 TIX
$18.15
2.26 TIX
2.83 TIX
$3.42 • €2.75
cheaper$ than i thought
i think 6 one drop ramp is enough
each one will only incerase that by a few %
better of with fetch lands at that point?
Yeah, thats the next upgrades
infinite reservelist cards
i doubt i will ever own or find a reserve list card unless i turn magic into my career
so if i really need one i will have to proxy those
[[Battle Menu]] Interesting card
[[Machinist's Arsenal]]
Artifact — Equipment
Job select (When this Equipment enters, create a 1/1 colorless Hero creature token, then attach this to it.)
Equipped creature gets +2/+2 for each artifact you control and is an Artificer in addition to its other types.
Machina — Equip
(
: Attach to target creature you control. Equip only as a sorcery.)
i like the 0/+4 mode XD
item sux but
can be cluth
T3 Combo works
turn 3 fordo
yeah
but at the cost of a card
so its desperate life gain
i think its more when you are at 6 lifes and everyone is trading blows
It would be mainly for +4 and Destroy effect anyway
-x/-x spells are deadly against this deck
good card regardless
yeah i like the +4 a lot
i was thinking of [[defense tower]] for this edck at one point
but it doesnt stop blasphemous act
or that untap 0/+2 castel wall thingy awful anthem
No idea
5 initial cost is kinda brutal
just a really bad old card that looks interesting in a Doran big butts deck
5 is a lot but it comes with a 1/1 attached
without artifact equipment synergy i cant really find it worth while
Should usually be around +11+11 on board with 5 artifacts, which is not a lot for this deck
Yeah, it's just a big dude
since you are better of tutoring for the frying pan
which is not that big anyway
The Fat Hobbit Proudfoot is usually +11+11 with 3 food
anyways i will be leaving soon, i will ttyl
and he has evasion
eexactly
cya
Dusk looks more and more useless as a Board wipe.
Multiple cards match “dusk rose”, can you be more specific?
[[vito dusk rose]] ?
Multiple cards match “dawn dusk”, can you be more specific?
i mean, it is the ideal one sided wipe for the deck
unless you dont want 3 wipes
and never use dawn to refill hand
then 4 and 5 mana isnt really worth the utility
i love this one sided wipe in Doran siege tower, not that i actually got to play it since i never put the full deck together but as a design/brewing it just clicks right. in actually games i can see lot of counters and indestructible i really only use sac/exile/tuck/ other form of value gain rather than mass destroy
ideally a reveberate at the top of the stack to counter the heroic or Tpro
as rakdos i also have chaos only one lives randomized wipes, threaten into group edict etc
so i think it is kinda of a meta game plan if you know people has the right counter to protect their board
how you get around their counter
[[split up]] 3 mana but no refill hand
in conclusion, i dont think dusk is useless, but it is how powercreep making older cards feels weaker and less effective when players keep on upgrading and using new cards
i can see [[savvy hunter]] being too weak and not synergistic enough some years down the line
it will probably get haste, 3/4, has goad, draws 2 cards with 3 food or something. who knows what it will become
either way, i aint buying it, both the physical copy or mentally prepare to get the newest best version
almost forgot, give it like 3-5 more creature types cause it need that support
/s
I've never been able to cast Dusk/Dawn without damaging my own board in the process, and the graveyard version has been useful once: when I was able to discard it with Frodo then it was miraculously useful late game.
I've added a ton of cards in the considering section, if you wanna look and if you see something that stands out
Also I have a Marsh flats, Windswept Heath, Boseiju who endures, Takemuna abandoned mire and Black Market Connection coming in the mail. So I need to find space for them
yeah i think the grave refill hand makes the card look better than it is when there are better things to do with the mana, its more for cheating commander tax
esp with 2 commanders
going to check your new considering cards, is [[slaughter the strong]] in theree
one of my favourite 3 mana one sided wipe of all time
and thematic too
since white is usually about meek
Then a card like [[Ascend from avernus]] could cut through the bullshit and get me exactly what I want if my stuff is in the grave
7 if there is a win con in grave
yeah since you dont care about total cost
but it isnt one sided
and destroy can sometimes fail
No sadly. [[Harsh Mercy]] could be one-sided provided I only have Halflings on board
depends on how much of the archenemy is ready with a full grip of cards
slaughter gets around heroic intervention is my main reason
i like that one you said for sure
Last thing is [[Invasion of flora]]
Bataille — siège
(Au moment où un siège arrive sur le champ de bataille, choisissez un adversaire pour le protéger. Vous et les autres pouvez l'attaquer. Quand il est vaincu, exilez-le, puis lancez-le transformé.)
Quand l'Invasion de Moag arrive sur le champ de bataille, mettez un marqueur +1/+1 sur chaque créature que vous contrôlez.
Face à la volonté implacable de Phyrexia, les dryades de Moag dressèrent un bouclier d'été vivant.
Defense: 5
Dryades porteuses de floraison
Créature — dryade
Parade
(À chaque fois que cette créature devient la cible d'un sort ou d'une capacité qu'un adversaire contrôle, contrecarrez ce sort ou cette capacité à moins que ce joueur ne paie
.)
Au début de votre étape de fin, mettez un marqueur +1/+1 sur une créature ciblée que vous contrôlez.
3/3
[[Invasion of fiora]]
Battle — Siege
(As a Siege enters, choose an opponent to protect it. You and others can attack it. When it's defeated, exile it, then cast it transformed.)
When this Siege enters, choose one or both —
• Destroy all legendary creatures.
• Destroy all nonlegendary creatures.
Defense: 4
Marchesa, Resolute Monarch
Legendary Creature — Human Noble
Menace, deathtouch
Whenever Marchesa attacks, remove all counters from up to one target permanent.
At the beginning of your upkeep, if you haven't been dealt combat damage since your last turn, you draw a card and you lose 1 life.
3/6
although it can miss on one, so there maybe politicking wiht opponent to remove the one biggest threat
and less effective if you are the threat yourself
oh yeah i forgot about fiora, love getting it
i have it in a control deck that can indefinitely bounce it so it is repeatable
and it is one OR both
It's a nice package for 1 card
also if the spell resolve, it happens on ETB
so technically it allows "lying"
about not using both modes to someone that say they can counter it
but it will create all sort of problems down the line if done that way
i like the potential mini sub-mind-game
if you get what i mean
Legendary Creature — Human Citizen
The first legendary creature spell you cast each turn costs
less to cast.
At the beginning of combat on your turn, if you control two or more other legendary creatures, you may transform Serah Farron.
"Our own private heaven."
2/2
Crystallized Serah
Legendary Artifact
The first legendary creature spell you cast each turn costs
less to cast.
Legendary creatures you control get +2/+2.
L'Cie who fulfill their Focus for their fal'Cie master are transformed into crystal and granted life eternal.
the fact you can also get the backside by telling your opponent you can instant kill the planewalker is some good political power
Easy -2 cost +2/+2 to everyone
oh i havent seen this one b4
art looks so pretty, too pretty for the universe of magic
looks like it came from a dressup game
Its a story card
First the hand on the left seems tender
tranformed the hand look distressed
I played mostly all final fantasy except this one
very, 3 mana anthem powercreep hard
[[Apothecary White]]
I mean. Tokens galore for 1 white mana
the hand on the back looks like the opposite hand from the front
Probably the protagonist of that game
"Life eternal didnt have the same ring in my mind, turn back"
insane value but less overlap with main strategy to go wide? good for building a board
and good multiple ways to make tokens
[[Hazel's Brewmaster]]
i think it would be something on the haymaker list, forcing another one to get cut
good gravehate, a little bit hard to combo with it tho
This one is just insane to me, all food get the abilities of every exiled cards
Great Toolbox imo
4 mana for food isnt worth, so it is all about giving the most broken effect
high ceiling for sure
""Activatd abilities"" mind you
yeah i know
its like that
super pricey card from return of eldraine
find it [[agatha's soul cauldron]]
Legendary Artifact
You may spend mana as though it were mana of any color to activate abilities of creatures you control.
Creatures you control with +1/+1 counters on them have all activated abilities of all creature cards exiled with Agatha's Soul Cauldron.
: Exile target card from a graveyard. When a creature card is exiled this way, put a +1/+1 counter on target creature you control.
Yeah
and since food dont have the same creature summoning sickness
Anyway I'm off to my LGS, ttyl
its a matter of finding that second piece in a graveyard
ttyl 👋
back from LGS last night
lost every thing XD
Happens lol
first time hearing this word "galore" This maybe the haymaker/win-more equivalent word added to my dictionary
3 games 3 losses. didnt have the cards at the end. Almost won first one, lost 2nd to infinite combo turn 4 and lost last game to no one dealing with a 18mana Black Market
Things of note: I finally drew and used Boromir for the first time ever (About 30 games played with this deck, never drew Boromir)
Archivist of Oghma sat in my hands for 5 turns, then drew me 6 cards and I still lost because my turn never came up. I'll probably change it to a [[Loran of the third path]]
close game, infinite happens in bracket 3 and above so its unavoidable without that blue or whatever fast interaction, black market is at that overkill spot that either ran out of interaction or poor threat assessment
now that your local got used to your deck, the strength and weakness also becomes obvious as it is harder to deal the killing blow
those 3 games sounds out of your control
I'm sure I couldve won the first one if I played more accurately. I full swung without counting twice
AKA I couldve split the damage
[[boromir]] i forgot all the text on it
Multiple cards match “boromir”, can you be more specific?
[[Boromir warden]]
and ring tempts you with single use protection?
ohh not no spell
no cost spell get countered
The indestructible part is the most important
the white counter spell closer to [[void mirror]] or the bauble
yeah i think the indestructible is the only relevant part other than legend synergy
it does 3 things but only 1.5 really matters
and it still matters nonetheless
i do that every freaken game lol its in my blood to swing and get myself killed as a rakdos player i guess
is it better than flawless manu then?
I full swung with [[motivated pony]] on board so I wasnt threatened
[[Archivist of Oghma ]] is a sad card when that happens
But last guy had the Angel that gives protection vs creatures and he added Hexproof on top of it
idr how i played this since i dont own it, or maybe it was a similar effect
bit basically i have no chance of using it the entire game
because it was too "fair" of a game
no fetch or repeatable stuff
would a boardwipe worked?
Yes, already used two that game tho
it is a nice target player lose effect
XD
i did mention gyome at some point
savvy hunter is in the weird spot because it makes food
[[Smeagol helpful guide]] is a freaking MVP tho
Legendary Creature — Halfling Horror
At the beginning of your end step, if a creature died under your control this turn, the Ring tempts you.
Whenever the Ring tempts you, target opponent reveals cards from the top of their library until they reveal a land card. Put that card onto the battlefield tapped under your control and the rest into their graveyard.
4/2
and draw
What a card
Insane card
what draw/food maker can you replace savvy with
It triggers on every Ring tempt
XD tell me more
yeah
i wish i have a smeagol focus deck but i cant do it with what i own in green black
Triggered 3 times on my turn, discarded almost 20 cards from one dude
He was quite pissed and wiped my board twice in a row lol
i think 5 triggers was the most i got per turn, also the only game ever i have gotten the ring to tempt me 4th times
I couldnt use it on the other guys cauz they had graveyard Recursion out the wazoo
i made clone of [[bilbo thief]]
No card found for “bilbo thief”
[[bilbo bugur]]
No card found for “bilbo bugur”
[[bilbo burgler]]
No card found for “bilbo burgler”
The only bilbo I know is [[Bilbo birthday]]
and each etb ltb give me all my off colour plain basics
[[bilbo, retired burglar]]
edhrec the name
i think i may have done myriad on it or something
so blade of selves + smeagol own end step trigger
5 in total
nice
didnt mill too many and plains is the off colour i didnt need
but it was still fun and good ramp
archivist has high ceiling
Lots of options tbh
yeah i dont give savvy a good look, in case you havent noticed XD
need some major powercreep on that one to break out of the jankiest
Its not a bad card but its not stellar either
Everytime I have to discard something it goes
I mean I was looking for space for [[Serah Farron]]
Legendary Creature — Human Citizen
The first legendary creature spell you cast each turn costs
less to cast.
At the beginning of combat on your turn, if you control two or more other legendary creatures, you may transform Serah Farron.
"Our own private heaven."
2/2
Crystallized Serah
Legendary Artifact
The first legendary creature spell you cast each turn costs
less to cast.
Legendary creatures you control get +2/+2.
L'Cie who fulfill their Focus for their fal'Cie master are transformed into crystal and granted life eternal.
the draw seems a bit desperate at 3 mana and 2 food, i assume it doesnt really make that much food on its own since i doesnt have vigilance
The Cost reduction would be incedibly useful when my commanders inevitably die
It transform the same turn I cast it
i want it as my first green white commander because the flavour seems nice
but its going to be too unaffordable
She will be cheap I think
if the table see it and have the interaction i mean
hopefully
Oh then its fine, I'd rather have my 3 mana cost countered
FF product are skyrocket inflated price
Instead of Elspeth who seems to be impossible to cast
i dont see too many artifact removals in lot of game, what about yours
Yeah but no ones gives a shit about Serah Farron
From one of the worst FF games ever made
red decks struggle too much to play vandalblast imo
lol
didnt know about most of FF so
idk who serah farron is
FF7 is the big boy
now... just where did i put my childhood... oh crap
How old are you lol
as far as i know anyone over 26 is old as balls
do i guess i have to identigy as old as balls?
identify*
I guess I am old as balls too then
MTG in a nutshell
children gambling is not affordable for children
I'm still pretty young in my LGS compared to most of the white beards
lol
Oh no, MTG gambling is Casino level
the youngest is a few teen, i am in between with those who collected before i was born
most are middle age/ less than 30
the new players are usually the youngest since they got into the game with universe beyond commander product
not know hoew greedy wotc are, have all the money and nowhere to spend and willing to get their favourite IP at all cost
also dont care about the direction of the game and lore with what is introduced into the game over recent years
yeah that 30 yr anniv was so bad
I dont care much either but I'd say you won't see me play Spongebob cards ever
official proxy almost as expensive as the original
XD
spongebob is both funny meme as a one time thing and really bad joke
jodah unifier with legends in the 99
automatically a fake bracket 2
it will beat up bracket 3 with no GC cards
5 colour good stuff build around so basically mindless and generic for the most part
and gary, is too much as a card in the game
-4 per turn cycle with all hte overloaded extra abilities on it
Counterspell tho
thats perfect, not a broken card in the format, (maybe broken as a card in the game) but the i CaSt My CoMmAnDeR will be memoriable.
nO yOu DoN't
Yeah
I'm gonna sleep on the Hunter change
It needs to be draw tho
Could just be Black Market COnnection
or [[Vraska Joins Up]] is also interesting
Anyway, good night.
good nite
i will. check for some of that draw replacement
i came across one in my cards right away
name is [[hardened tactician]]
bennie is still a really good one imo
or its down to the pricey [[caretaker's talent]]
Enchantment — Class
(Gain the next level as a sorcery to add its ability.)
Whenever one or more tokens you control enter, draw a card. This ability triggers only once each turn.
: Level 2
When this Class becomes level 2, create a token that's a copy of target token you control.

: Level 3
Creature tokens you control get +2/+2.
Ill probably go with Bennie for now
I just dont make a lot of tokens when its not my turn
Nuka cola vending machine or Pippin, The Shire and Lotho
I guess adding [[Minas Tirith]] could be an arguement
Oh hell no. 4 mana is way too much
yeah if you need more draws and utility in lands, thats one of the good rate, i only have war room in my colours
4 mana too much, need some powercreep upgrades
but your goal is card draw so....
i think tactician is fine with the 2/4 body
its perfect if you have Jaheira out
bennie was the considered legend before so i think one token per round isnt that bad, same rate as idol which used to be in the deck
legendary still more synergy than desperate card draw by sacing all the food
if the goal is multiple draws, than bennie doesnt do it here
always thought of this thingy but i dont own one, saw it again just now [[mirrex]]
slightly less cost, token cant block so i think its not going to cut it and that one time colour mana
[[roadside reliquary]] is nice to trade 1 lands for 2 cards, i didnt check your rate for getting out an enchantment tho
Meh, Bennie will be good enough
XD back to square one
this is like my exact line for the deck build half a week ago
let me go take a [[peek]] and [[predict]] the future adjustment to the deck
tbf, it is way less pressure than brewing my own deck
and i only have to somewhat simulate what are the likelyhood scenario in a real game instead of playing out the real game with potential misplays and salt from opponents' attitude
anything beyond that it will be the perfect optimization to the nearly .1% of increasing the odd of drawing the exact card for each moment
i cant do that in my decks with no tutors
Tbh Bennie will be there until I find a suitable enchantment or artifact instead. Board wipes are too common in my pods to fill my board with creatures with barely any protection
For the lands. No reasons not to play the Pathways lands right?
[[Bonecache Overseer]] first time seeing this card, i like this type of jank
i mean, if they help with turn 3 Frodo Sam food
thats no downside as long as you figure out turn 1 Green pip
I am still waiting for some of those FF to drop and see who bad it is to go up some of those, that [[Fabled seph soldier]] is screaming aristocrat + gravepact lock, boardwipe? how about instant speed non-stop stax lock
Legendary Creature — Human Avatar Soldier
Whenever Sephiroth enters or attacks, you may sacrifice another creature. If you do, draw a card.
Whenever another creature dies, target opponent loses 1 life and you gain 1 life. If this is the fourth time this ability has resolved this turn, transform Sephiroth.
3/3
Sephiroth, One-Winged Angel
Legendary Creature — Angel Nightmare Avatar
Flying
Super Nova — As this creature transforms into Sephiroth, One-Winged Angel, you get an emblem with "Whenever a creature dies, target opponent loses 1 life and you gain 1 life."
Whenever Sephiroth attacks, you may sacrifice any number of other creatures. If you do, draw that many cards.
5/5
i dont think any amount of defense is enough when one of those games happens, you just cant really deal with everything. Just have to find that right timing to deploy the game plan knowing when that board wipe may happen. If 3 boardwipe uses to be the lowest amount needed in a deck, I am slowly raising that number to 5 and maybe 6 with recursion. Just harder to find all the onesided ones. And that Dawn after the dust settles is the ideal moment to rebuild. This is why I find [[Dusk Dawn]] so thematic and fitting both flavour and mechanic wise
as a card, it is definite lot worse than it used to be. 4 mana used to be the best rate in the best boardwipe colours. and one sided in the right deck on top of that. What has powercreep came to be
I feel like medallion or some storm synergy/ saves it a bit by lowing that casting cost. Whats the new crystal card you are waiting for?
find it
[[The darkness crystal]]
Legendary Artifact
Black spells you cast cost
less to cast.
If a nontoken creature an opponent controls would die, instead exile it and you gain 2 life.


,
: Put target creature card exiled with The Darkness Crystal onto the battlefield tapped under your control with two additional +1/+1 counters on it.
need all that gravehate for the dictate pact lock XD
i may look into and you gain 2 life. more to see what may help 😩
why is this deck so far off from my colours, tbf i need some life gain for my own deck as well and i still dont own a [[whip of erebos]], even precon cost so much nowadays
Legendary Enchantment Artifact
Creatures you control have lifelink.


,
: Return target creature card from your graveyard to the battlefield. It gains haste. Exile it at the beginning of the next end step. If it would leave the battlefield, exile it instead of putting it anywhere else. Activate only as a sorcery.
i think most of those are really just medallion upgrades since it is pushing toward cutting lands for cost reducers and MDFCs for less dead-card-draws
if a low curve deck wants medallion, the high curve fun commander big stuff wants both
oh great more harden scale added to the game
3 cards in one card at 4 mana rate, can it get any better Yes it can and it will
i think upgrades may also have a point of stopping, otherwise it will never end. finding that comfortable sweet spot is [[chiefs kiss]]
knowing that that journey and this thread may soon comes to an end?
Indeed. I do have a 2nd deck in Gruul that I'll be hitting soon if you are interested
perfect, i need to get some of my paper decks online too to share
i will be heading to my sunday LGS in less than an hour, i will come check what you got in this thread
actually we can just keep chating here for the guurl deck dont even need a new thread
Alright, so I've tagged the cards, put everything that I'd like to put in with the ! x2 Icon
Bello is a commander that needs a ton of Ramp and a lot of protection to run well
A guy playing Bello at my LGS just told me "Leylines man" and I just had to add them to the deck
I wanna switch up my Ramp from Raccoons to Elves for better T1 consistency (And they do the same for less mana anyway
I need more interactions too. Playing Hobbits made me realize the importance of Interactions even in Gruul
Also getting my Bello blown up all the time kills the deck
Deck is weak to getting rushed when all your stuff arent creatures so I need Fog effects too
Or tokens to block with
Alright, I think the list is solid
Solid enough for a few games at my LGS
Draws seems low but Bello is a draw engine himself, as long as he stays alive I won't have any problems there
Landbase is fixed with cheap cards. I didnt wanna spend too much here.
dang that optimization on opening leylines XD
glad i didnt finish reading to the end before i checked the list
i dont remember all the best cards with this commander but i iam sure we will find them all if not already in the list
[[woodland guidance]] may have a place in this deck but it is also janky
Sorcery
Return target card from your graveyard to your hand. Clash with an opponent. If you win, untap all Forests you control. (Each clashing player reveals the top card of their library, then puts that card on their choice of the top or bottom. A player wins if their card had a greater mana value.)
Exile Woodland Guidance.
worst case its a bad regrowth
i dont like gruul signets unless there are additional artifact synergy; mostly because it makes the deck even weaker to aritfact wipes
it may not ehappen in most of the game but that one time with an artifact land and your opponent happens to be able to kill all, those hurts
if it is farewell then you just have to suck it up and take it
I am perfectly fine with turn 3 overlapping commander's curve because he may not even come out on turn 3
overall, very aggressive ramp into multiple big drops and refill hand, not missing land drops, everything going well togetehr
then it just comes down to, how much fun stuff you can fit in, my own would probably be like [[city on fire]]
nevin disk + [[darksteel ingot]]
will do deeper dive when i am done my shift
your LGS has no bracket 2s? XD remind me of what my used to be
yeah, playing against bello, i think we destroyed it like 4-6 times but it was turn 1 sol ring so missing land drops eaerly didnt stop him. and it was 3 player pod too that didnt help
so, more effect like threefold thunderhulk, i think there are vehicles like that but idr if they cost 3 or 4
havent play tested, will do later
Few cards of note would be [[Roaming Throne]] which is pretty incredible in this deck
No card found for “bellp bard brambles”
[[bello bard brambles]]
Legendary Creature — Raccoon Bard
During your turn, each non-Equipment artifact and non-Aura enchantment you control with mana value 4 or greater is a 4/4 Elemental creature in addition to its other types and has indestructible, haste, and "Whenever this creature deals combat damage to a player, draw a card."
3/3
oh wow i didnt even realize
attempts mutate
elemental getting mence is something i rememeber a lord could do
oh you are also in Canada?
🫳
🫴
couldnt find a high five emote
🤦 <closest there is
Best way to play combat aggro strategy as a Canadian "i aM sOrRy. Swing as you for 16 damage."
XD
Yeah Bello transform every enchantments into Elementals
[[Molten echoes]] It makes this card pretty much one of the strongest things
ttyl
i guess ther are many other molten echoes effect too, but with side conditions. i really want to make the coin flip one work in my decks
[[Mirror march]]
Yeah it's very strong too
but it can be 0 which is a major issue at 6mana and 50% rate
i draw it once, my next big creature got countered, then the smaller one also got countered in the same turn
In bello its still fine since everything is a 4/4 haste indestructible creature that draws if you do combat damage.
yeah bello is broken during your turn
its so hard to change that playstyle just to get defense for yourself XD
its like "I dont like blockers and I live will die on that hill if I have to am going to die aint I." type of bold statement every game. I like it too much to fix that issue
all it takes is a good fog effect
i havent gotten much time to look more indepth in the deck but i will get back on it
Well the old version of the deck was just "ramp like crazy, then kill people asap" I played around 25 ramp cards. It works well enough but it's cut short by the entire table trying to kill you.
exactly
~~minor issues ~~ the whole problem with that strategy
so it really depends on how "greedy" you want to be or you can be
weird optimization, may need the calculator
on card types and stuff
yeah, deck looks solid. Unless they hate you out of your commander with some spiteful targeting play, the aggro plan with all leylines is going to go fast and smooth. Idk how many speed bumps in your local areas though XD
We'll see, lots of players and lots of different decks
i think all my mentions are either ramp/untap related, or just bigger and stronger "creatures"
all 4=> enchantment artifact is always fun
you have that one raccon with expertise 8 right?ee
is that what the mechanic is called
spend 8 or more mana that turn
for spells
Its on the sideline right now
yeah i dont have those bloomburrow cards to test
Im trying the elf ball just for consistency T1
but they dont draw much attention and good value in high mana value decks
makes sense
my prediction for this deck
[[Trailtracker scout]]
is probably getting those tempo turns -> commanders and perfect curves
add gas to get to the finish line
leylines has a small chance of getting cut
because rn, none of their effect really matters
they are just
beaters
With Bello the only thing that matters is that they are 4 mana enchanters yes
Usually means that I'll get at least 1 draw from them as soon as Bello hit the battlefield
the "No bad cards in this grandpa's deck" with 4 mana value is a fun build around. I may try to brew one online non paper copy
bello in the 99 is how far i am willing to go
and all the super old janks
At least 4 of those Leylines can be useful tho
[[monkey cage]] is definitely getting in here
Abundance with Elfball
were there only 7, not an even number
[[leyline abundance]]
i love abundance but i wish i own a svylan library
oh you meant leyline one
yeah.... i like that one too >.>
nowhere nearly the card draw replacement one
[[Leyline punishment]]
XD fits my playstyle
Lifegain decks can just f off
but it is self destruction
Kill my hobbits thats a given
[[Leyline Vitality]]
awwhhh i want bello in the 99 even more just so i can do many other colours 😩
resonance what for
protection?
only remembered like two green spell in the deck
If I target Myself, then Resonance activated
Can I choose another option for the copy?&
it probably works
but not 100% sure since the wording isnt the same as feather / zada
[[zada he grinder]] i forgot the middle word and this sounds a little gay
Legendary Creature — Goblin Ally
Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell that targets only Zada, copy that spell for each other creature you control that the spell could target. Each copy targets a different one of those creatures.
"A hedron holds magic for a thousand years—or less, if need be."
3/3
No card found for “feather redmn”
No card found for “feather redemn”
Nothing that starts with Feather
[[feather, the redeemed]]
you have gruul identity set so moxfield is annoying
doesnt fit anyway so its fine
i like archidekt more user friendly or just straight up google
was checking for ruling
so feather doesnt say "only"
[[Leyline of vitality]] lets Bello dodges 3 damage spells
if a spell targets 1000 things and one of that is "creature oyu control"
or the Tribal -3/-3 board wipe
feather will trigger
OK
zada on the other hand sees only spells that target zada regardless of how many times it targets zada
because the wording on resonance seems to be referring to targeting only one creature rather than a creature
i think it is very much what Zada is doing
so you can only copy the model spell if you target your own artifact enchantment hexproof indestructible all on the same target
and with that order, it will destroy before giving indestructible making it pointless
if you have regenerate, that gets interesting
Well Bello makes every artifact and enchantments indestructible so it could work no?
and still gets the destroy part
I mean I would cast the spell to protect bello in the first place
interesting combat trick to say the least
but then you cant destroy anything
so that hexproof indes is just doing the normal thing
resonance is doing extra and it kinda works
cOmBo
/s
Big Bracket 2 plays
double collective resistance, isnt bad at all
its a card from MH3
big powercreep trash design wonderful* card quality upgrades
Indeed
Meh I'm ok with it.
$ to design to perpetual chasing powercreep to turn the jank format into a rotational format
toooooo toooo tooo much to talk about
i dont mind the tapped lands mdfcs at all since lands is a core part of making the game more playable
but 3 life untapped mono colour mdfc
those are removing the downside of mdfc too much
so they are like the auto include in the 99, sol ring , arcane signet problem
i want 1+ the 99, not 1+ the 90 after putting in every staples of the colour
I get it. I'm back in MTG after 12 years so I'm discovering a ton of cards
so from a unique and good design perspective i very much avoid MH3 cards, game play* and powerlevel perspective i think you HAVE to play those cards
but watching a 2 years old video feels irrelevant now because some of the suggested upgrades just got outclassed already
[[Sanguine Bond]] being a good example
lol
vs [[Enduring Tenacity]]
yeah
"buu.. but it can be exiled with path and swords" "shut up, you are also the one playing white at the table"
when more typings isnt a real downside for delirum or whatever dies triggers
but duskmourn imo is still more fair of the bunch
i like the tenacity cycle
with the exception that for higher power, they are just redundancy to the two card infinite
Oh yeah, playing them all feels cheap
It just add more consistency to the most boring combo of MTG
it really breaks that "tutoring breaks the spirit of the format" by playing singletons
so its really tutor+ extra 2 cards infinites
i will do a quick play test on bello now
looking at war storm surge, i wonder if you can do pandemonium
the symmetrical one
dont know it
say as war storm surge ability
but for creatures on all sides
i think it is triple red cost maybe
1 less mana
yep i spelt it eright
[[pandemonium]]
bello is a very high target for target removal tho
Theres chaos and theres "Just fuck my shit up fam""
gotta refresh the list
Honestly its more Mana base fixing, with all the pathways lands and a few more
make sense
[[Kambal profittering]] added
No card found for “Kambal profittering”
[[Kambal profiteering mayor]]
i have that card, havent put it in a deck
it either does nothing or it does everything non stop
Its a better Nadier's nightblade for me
I mean it works for any token
[[Nadier's nightblade]] was this ever mentioend in this thread
Mirkwood never left the Precon
yep
Played 3 games Monday and lost all 3
yeah i put too much attention on profiteer kambal s first ability
I hate [[Meren of clan nel toth]]
Legendary Creature — Human Shaman
Whenever another creature you control dies, you get an experience counter.
At the beginning of your end step, choose target creature card in your graveyard. If that card's mana value is less than or equal to the number of experience counters you have, return it to the battlefield. Otherwise, put it into your hand.
3/4
i kinda forgot it does the mirrored part of nidiersnightblade
Yeah and I'd rather keep the tokens until they are needed
how bad is the meren oyu faced, is it the most generic crap
Lucky enough to get my board wiped every turn
forcing me to sacrifice my commanders
Could get anything out
couldnt*
Whats the creature that forces everybody to sacrifice a creature on ETB
better learn to play some stax /s
Merciless killer or something
[[no mercy]]
No its a creature
Some armored dude with a Battle Axe
the new FF card sephi fabled soldier
kinda leans super heavy into sac 4 creatures gravepact lock type of deck
so all the marauders are super synergistic in those decks
even if not built or played well
only my higher power decks can deal with a gravepact lock properly without relying on 2 +card combo/creatureless win con
Yeah. so that was the first 2 games. 3rd game the loss was on me
to counter the "you cant play any creatures type of stax" the real counter is "you cant play at my table/ or else I wont let you play magic in general" deck
because I didnt realize the guy could do over 60 damage to everyone when his commander blew up
Couldve interacted
i think i dont have any proper bracket 4 decks that have no resources denial/ heavy interactions in them
Yeah I'm thinking on adding more MDFC lands that interact
i bring chaos with lot of collateral damage
[[Fell the profane]]
Instant
Destroy target creature or planeswalker.
"I can think of no fate more fitting for one so foul as you." —Aryel, knight of Windgrace
Fell Mire
Land
As this land enters, you may pay 3 life. If you don't, it enters tapped.
: Add
.
"The Nethermire is all the salvation you deserve." —Aryel, knight of Windgrace
yep thats auto include its from MH3
[[Witch enchanter]]
Creature — Human Warlock
When this creature enters, destroy target artifact or enchantment an opponent controls.
Shilgengar's famine once starved Stensia into embracing vampirism. The Dawnhart Coven would not let the same happen to Kessig.
2/2
Witch-Blessed Meadow
Land
As this land enters, you may pay 3 life. If you don't, it enters tapped.
: Add
.
"Ghrin-Danu will not let her people go hungry." —Katilda, Dawnhart Prime
ideally in a bounce deck
but at worst single use is all it needs
this one got expensive too iirc
yeah, 15$ CAD
not getting one since at bracket 4/Cedh i will just proxy for colours i dont like to play/own/not rakdos
so far i havent proxied at cards
My next deck will have proxies for sure
I'm already 1700$ deep into this shit lol
thats 2 decks
if you got some salty games/ cards you think no one deserves to see, let me know. i want to proxy those in the highest power level against disrespectful and dispicable opponents
lol my average deck not counting my 10+ years old somewhat optimized decks is like $50-75 CAD
There's a treasure version of my hobbits deck in Red/green
i spent not more than 1k per year and usually $50 avg per month on singles
cant afford any precon even if i want them
ohhhh thats fun
Other guy I might wanna make is [[Ketramose]]
Legendary Creature — God
Menace, lifelink, indestructible
Ketramose can't attack or block unless there are seven or more cards in exile.
Whenever one or more cards are put into exile from graveyards and/or the battlefield during your turn, you draw a card and lose 1 life.
Let the past die so the future might live.
4/4
The ultimate anti Graveyard decks
"Oh you got recursion? my bad bro"
With a ton of flicker cards to proc Ketramose
so i have seen people use void leyline with ketramose which is a nonbo
instead you will need [[planar void]]
to get the triggers properly
yes
i dont like any build path that optimize ketramose so it doesnt interest me that much in the commander zone
if the 99 can function without it, i think it will be more interesting
Hobbits has been upgraded on Moxfield
farewell to draw back 1 card really doesnt make it good
but people will put farewell in all their decks
okay i will check it out now
same link at the top?
Sort by tags to see the untagged new cards
i think that works just fine
Like I said Its mostly lands
i see the newly added battle
Ill try it instead of Dusk
I also bought Slaughter the strong in case
Super cheap and stil pretty good in this deck
I'm only missing [[Verdant Catacombs]] and my lands are pretty much set, except the MDFC lands I could add
I still need to find 2 cards to remove for Wind Crystal and Aerith
Gyome is next on the chopping block so that might be him
Maybe an interact if I add the mdfc lands
[[$slaughter the strong]] is cheap right
$0.11 • €0.22 • 0.05 TIX
$0.15
$0.13 • €0.21
$0.15 • €0.17 • 0.04 TIX
$0.95 • €0.86
$1.68 • €0.77
$0.30 • €0.19 • 0.02 TIX
if i have more copies i wouldnt mind giving those out to ours, one of my top recommandered one sided wipes that get around heroic
[[Aerith Gyome]]
No card found for “Aerith Gyome”
interesting that you pick stroke of midnight over beast within or genelephant gift
1/1 is more inconsequential
just running around my house doing some errands and stuffs
side boards are the cuts?
Yeah
rip midnight snack i really like that card guess it didnt make it
getting to fat with all the late night calories
too*
you really hate bennie and rather do idol lol
looks like good cut with replacements, hardly able to tell what the land changes were so it should be fine /ideal
going to try put some of my cards online and play test before my LGS tomorrow, taking decks apart to rebuild into other things gotten lazy with that
still not sure how to give myself the protection/ shroud effect for my chaos pandemonium
not even sure if hexproof can get around it
because the source is my opponents creature but the ability is my own enchantment
but i like [[bedlum]] type of effects in general, like coat of arm, they are the game ending turn caterhoof big drop so there should be a crack back
No card found for “bedlum”
shouldn't be*
actually bedlam may work in bello for that game winning turn
if they aetherise, bedlam goes away too
but it is more expensive, i have my copy from decade old
Im creature heavy and I dont have a lot of protection. Board wipes fuck me up a lot
yeah i can tell
is the interactions you play enough
or need more protections
idk if there are any good reanimate for hobbits / just white protection that are weaker teferi's pro
i think protection is always something the hobbit deck seems to lack, but its not like you have too many good counterspell options
[[lapse of certainty]] is one that people overlook a lot
and no synergy since there are no white spellslinger if you exclude jeskai
I mean, depending on the players.
Newer players tend to play more ""fair" and conservative
I feel like I am the one policing the table most of the time
and I get hit for it
Hell, even having 2-3 more life than the rest makes me a target
The Meren deck that fucked us up? Couldve died 2 turns ago but the 2 others wanted to make the game last as 4 players as much as possible
when they shouldve killed him the moment he had his loop
If I ever plays GCs, Teferi will def be one of them
Instead of Protection I could also run some recursion
newer players, often has really bad threat assessment and remove anything that "maybe" a potential threat to them like it is a 1vs 1 game
and not pay into consideration of any future bigger threats as the game progresses into the late game
"I have the mana, might as well use it"
policing the table or politicking with the table?
Being the dude casting interacts to remove threats
Feeling like I'm the only one with interacts in the deck
new player are scared of fast decks and doesnt know what combos decks can win late or got no interactions against midrange which are probably the most powerful decks in free for all multi player turn based games like commander
there is really not perfect "optimization" at that point
perfect mana based makes your own 99 playable
yet other players who dont see the value and connection between mana base and the non mana cards
have no idea what maybe coming at them
One thing of note; [[Jaheira]] changes the way my deck runs so hard
Multiple cards match “Jaheira”, can you be more specific?
If I had to play Tutors it would be exclusively for her
make sense
thats why i want her as the commander in my build
just hard to balance out the tokens
Yeah, her and Agent of the Iron Thronw
.)

.
