Yes, No, Maybe So

[midnight rampart]

A collaborative script with Spy, No Dashii, Mayor, and Artist. (IYKYK)

so uh

nothing too jank here actually

[bronze rover]

alia...

[midnight rampart]

what

[bronze rover]

The script doesn’t exist

[midnight rampart]

i know

the idea was that other people would help

[bronze rover]

Oh

[midnight rampart]

it's a meme from general

kind of

[bronze rover]

I’m stupid nvm

Ok

[midnight rampart]

let's see

acrobat

[bronze rover]

I don’t know

[midnight rampart]

yeah

here i'll show you:

*role yes

[dense vale]

Spy (Minion) - Trouble Brewing

Each night, you see the Grimoire. You might register as good & as a Townsfolk or Outsider, even if dead.

**Affects Setup: **False

[midnight rampart]

*role no

[dense vale]

No Dashii (Demon) - Sects & Violets

Each night*, choose a player: they die. Your 2 Townsfolk neighbors are poisoned.

**Affects Setup: **False

[midnight rampart]

*role maybe

[dense vale]

Mayor (Townsfolk) - Trouble Brewing

If only 3 players live & no execution occurs, your team wins. If you die at night, another player might die instead.

**Affects Setup: **False

[midnight rampart]

see now

[bronze rover]

Makes sense

Are we actually creating a script?

[midnight rampart]

yeah

[bronze rover]

Ok fun

Where should we start?

[midnight rampart]

currently i have this

quiet minions, droison demons

[bronze rover]

I prefer Math to Acrobat here

Because it makes demon detectable but isn’t too powerful

[midnight rampart]

that's true

acrobat is possibly op

i'd maybe want another droison source so math isn't "you start knowing the demon type"

[bronze rover]

Yeah that’s probably a better idea

[midnight rampart]

i'd say widow but widow is loud

[primal flower]

what about general for the “yes/no/maybe” theme

[midnight rampart]

oo yeah

wait yk what

we should make it a 10/3/3/3

because 3

[primal flower]

hmmm

[midnight rampart]

actually nah

full scrpit is betetr

[primal flower]

vm is a weird choice but you could do it

[bronze rover]

Poisoner/Recluse/PM

[unique wolf]

savant fits the maybe theme too

[midnight rampart]

nah then it's math 0 n1

[primal flower]

PM and lleech?

[midnight rampart]

poisoner is too much, pm is too loud

[primal flower]

vort

[midnight rampart]

recluse is fine

[midnight rampart]

i don't wanna make an snvlike though

[bronze rover]

I’d be fine with just drunk

[primal flower]

allows for some misreg too as long as you have YSKs

[midnight rampart]

not with lleech

[unique wolf]

pukka legion as other 2 demons?

[primal flower]

why legion?

pukka is nice on here

[bronze rover]

No legion

[midnight rampart]

legion...

pukka is nice here

[bronze rover]

I’m not making a legion script 2 consecutive days

[primal flower]

what about plain old imp

[midnight rampart]

pukka is, like lleech, constant math 1s
although finding the poisoned player won't find the demon

[midnight rampart]

math 0

[primal flower]

but we have cluse

cluse can cause a math 1

[midnight rampart]

true

but a 0 still confirms imp

wait

[bronze rover]

VI?

[midnight rampart]

oo fun yeah

[primal flower]

is that another person’s ability?

*role math

[dense vale]

Mathematician (Townsfolk) - Sects & Violets

Each night, you learn how many players' abilities worked abnormally (since dawn) due to another character's ability.

**Affects Setup: **False

[bronze rover]

Yeah

Cos village idiot adds a drunk character

[midnight rampart]

ah vi won't proc math

[primal flower]

“another character” VI’s setup ability affects itself

[bronze rover]

*role Village

[dense vale]

Village Idiot (Townsfolk) - Experimental

Each night, choose a player: you learn their alignment. [+0 to +2 Village Idiots. 1 of the extras is drunk]

**Affects Setup: **True

[unique wolf]

wb xaan instead of baron

[bronze rover]

1 of the extras are drunk

[midnight rampart]

could be interesting

[primal flower]

wheres your o-mod then

oh right

xaan

dumbass

[bronze rover]

Real

[midnight rampart]

real

ooo

what if

monk

and then

summoner

[bronze rover]

Add a Sentinel in case no xaan game

[unique wolf]

oh add amne cuz "?" is perfect for the theme

[midnight rampart]

tru!

[primal flower]

and theres your o-mod (JOKE)

okay whats the script look like now

[primal flower]

is mario enough “good player doubt” for the script

[midnight rampart]

wdym

[bronze rover]

Yeah

[primal flower]

tb has drunj

bmr has lunie

snv has mutant

good sided misinfo

[bronze rover]

Philosopher?

[midnight rampart]

agree

especially with math

[unique wolf]

other outsiders could be between heretic, lunatic, mutant, poli

PM

[midnight rampart]

i like heretic

[primal flower]

heretic??

[midnight rampart]

wait no

spy

sorry

[bronze rover]

Heretic is a no IMO

[midnight rampart]

i vote mutant

one thing about mutant is that

you need to make all the townsfolk difficult bluffs to keep up

[bronze rover]

I vote Mutant

[midnight rampart]

like, ongoing info roles

all of ours are good with mutant

[bronze rover]

Savant and Amni make that a good start lol

[midnight rampart]

i like politician

[bronze rover]

Kinda real

[primal flower]

poli, mutant, recluse, and something else that looks evil af

[midnight rampart]

lunatic maybe

i like claiming lunatic as the demon

[primal flower]

just needs to look evil

[bronze rover]

Klutz?

[unique wolf]

saint?

[midnight rampart]

oo saint yeah

[bronze rover]

Mutant
Poli
Recluse
Saint

[primal flower]

poli’s gonna want to lie

[midnight rampart]

yes

[primal flower]

mutant will lie too

[unique wolf]

how many tf are left?

and should we add the 4th demon or no cuz 3 is fine here imo

[midnight rampart]

we need 5 more

[midnight rampart]

i think a functioning script is more important than having 4 demons

[bronze rover]

Real

[midnight rampart]

i do kinda like acrobat

but it'd be the only positive deathmod

so nah

[bronze rover]

Confirms No Dashii too easily

[midnight rampart]

i kinda wanna axe summoner

what do we think

[bronze rover]

Same

[midnight rampart]

and then take off monk

[bronze rover]

Yeah

[midnight rampart]

balloonist is fun

[bronze rover]

I like it here

[midnight rampart]

especially given our outsiders like to hide

[bronze rover]

And can frame outsiders as evil

[midnight rampart]

yeah

also spy + balloonist is fun

[unique wolf]

yea and having math makes it not too hard to solve that

[midnight rampart]

yeah

chambermaid?

[bronze rover]

Post script and I’ll see

[bronze rover]

Thanks

Add another minion that wakes up and I’ll be happy

Are we adding Savant?

[midnight rampart]

maybe

i think boffin is cool here but it doesn't wake

cere is too loud

[bronze rover]

We don’t need chambermaid

[midnight rampart]

yeah fair

in that case, boffin?

[bronze rover]

Sure

[midnight rampart]

so finishing out the townsfolk we wanna keep in mind

we want them to be kinda rough on the mutant

and we want them to be good boffin abilities

the obvious first choice i think is farmer

[bronze rover]

Or Banshee

[midnight rampart]

especially cause we don't currently have trap characters

or banshee

yeah

which do you prefer here

farmer confirms 2 players while banshee is only 1

[bronze rover]

Banshee

[midnight rampart]

agreed

[bronze rover]

TF are powerful enough already with possibly more coming and tw confirmed characters is a bit much

[midnight rampart]

yeah

[bronze rover]

*two

[midnight rampart]

i think evil might need to be stronger honestly

but idk how

[bronze rover]

I agree

[unique wolf]

boomdandy/OG?

for the 4th min

[bronze rover]

With this set of outsiders Marionette is a bit 😬

I’m not sure about Mario basically

[midnight rampart]

fair

organ grinder could be interesting but it is loud

so i vote boomdandy

[bronze rover]

Mezepheles?

[midnight rampart]

mez + poli is 2 extra evils

[bronze rover]

My Minions Would Be:
Spy
Xaan
Boomdandy
Mez

Oh damn

Yeah

Ok what minions are we going for

[midnight rampart]

i have boffin as the 4th minion

[bronze rover]

Yeah Boffin Is Good

Spy
Xaan
Boomdandy
Boffin

How many TF do we still need

[midnight rampart]

4 more i think

[bronze rover]

Ok

1 More Constant Info, Savant/Preacher/Seamstress/Engineer, 2 YSK roles

[bronze rover]

Pukka is the only reason for no deaths

Lleech is the only way a character can survive execution

[midnight rampart]

this is fine

[midnight rampart]

this is less fine

[bronze rover]

lol

how do we fix that issuer

[midnight rampart]

remove pukka

[bronze rover]

simple fix lol

do we replace it?

or 2 demons fine

[midnight rampart]

2 demons maybe fine

[bronze rover]

I agree

[bronze rover]

I think Dreamer works pretty well as our final constant info?

[bleak canyon]

Lunar Eclipse /thread

[midnight rampart]

dreamer's really powerful

but maybe

especially cause we have a good amount of misreg and misinffo

so sure

[unique wolf]

can we just add sailor to fix both of these or is it too risky to allow the possibility of sailor hosting?

[primal flower]

sailor host is fine…?

[unique wolf]

sailor host can end day 1 if they try to test themselves

[sleek stirrup]

yea, also sailor is a horrible lleech bluff

[midnight rampart]

i vote remove pukka tbh

[bronze rover]

Same

I don’t like pukka tbh

[unique wolf]

why is bluffing sailor regarded as worse than playing outed evil? if ur outed u cant sell worlds or claim u drunked ppl

[sleek stirrup]

because if you bluff sailor you're going to be executed and proven sailor/lleech immediately

which is not good

lleech wants to be a demon other than lleech candidate

or even a lleech host candidate

if you're getting outed you might as well replace a better execution

[unique wolf]

alr that makes sense

[bronze rover]

3 More TF left and thats it

[bronze rover]

also have a spy and boffin

[midnight rampart]

yeah

[bronze rover]

we have no YSK characters atm so we should probably fix that

[midnight rampart]

true

[bronze rover]

You Start Knowing-12:
Bounty Hunter
Chef
Clockmaker
Grandmother
Investigator
Knight
Librarian
Noble
Pixie
Shugenja
Steward
Washerwoman

I like 2 of Noble, Shugenja, Pixie

Maybe Librarian

[unique wolf]

yea i was thinking pixie also

[bronze rover]

im fine with just pixie but id prefer at least one more

[midnight rampart]

librarian and pixie seem nice

[bronze rover]

yeah id be fine with tghat

and its still difficult for mutant to bluff as

We Need One More TF

[midnight rampart]

librarian seeing a mutant is always a thing

[bronze rover]

yeah ig

we could do with another passive/OPG role

[unique wolf]

juggler could be fun?

also lets add a question mark to the title for amne 😆

[bronze rover]

I would throw in pacifist but it would make the game unfun sooooo Juggler/Seamstress

Or Savant

[olive badge]

!Sharkly (He/Him)

Final Character cos I can't decide

1⃣ Juggler
2⃣ Seamstress
3⃣ Savant

[bronze rover]

A Vote! We Have A Savant