#Clockwork Cyborg
1 messages · Page 2 of 1
idk I haven't seen enough xaans I think
xaan is a risk with arbitrary outsiders but so is godfather
build some widow (cere scarlet) pm Xaan (2) bags and see how fucked up good gets
I like og here for several reasons but it's too divisive a role for me to want to put it on my Script That Got Big
Xaan has the gf problem except it swings way way more
But yeah re. tc I want a minionfinder on here and tc is a lot better than invest
Oracle is sort of also a minionfinder, dreamer is sort of also a minionfinder
Noble is sort of also a minionfinder (let's be real) and it makes the info landscape a bit more frontloaded without murdering the kazali immediately but I like being able to build around both demon pings and minion pings
TC is also one of the roles that poli functionally misregisters to which I like
Though poli in noble pings is cool
what about Shugenja or Empath?
Shugenja was here for a couple versions and I noticed I wanted to droison it every game
Is evil twin that bad?
Oooh balloonist is fun
I worry a bit about Chambermaid potentially having overlap with FT but at a glance the waking patterns are fun
Balloonist with hidden outsiders is always a plus
Where is the current version of the script
^
I've finally admitted that I need to replace Godfather
I'm trying to find a replacement and work out knock-on effects
In that it doesn't do enough?
I think Organ Grinder just is a bit miserable online but is fairly cool otherwise. Of course the Minions on this script can be pretty varied and flexible bc the Outsider mod is linked to the Demon!
Is xaan too much w Widow?
Is it kinda bad with kaz?
My instinct is yes
For both
The thing I like about GF on this script is that it incentivizes outsider bluffs and makes them way scarier to chop into
I also notice that GF is a quieter minion which hides Scarlet Woman well
The issue w evil twin is that there isn't enough misinfo to support it
Assassin is fine
I think getting rid of an execution or skipping f4 for an unwary team is strong
Assassin is loud to the point where I think it probably either stabs the banshee it saw on the widowgrim or just holds it to f4
Because a doublekill narrows worlds so much
to the point where the juice might not be worth the squeeze?
Yee
Organ Grinder is similar
It can spend the whole game being quiet and framing SW before a big reveal
xaan is probably too strong
You can't balance a bag around a xaan 1 for example
And kazali might get unlucky and pull the dreaded xaan 0
Hmm, tricky to replace GF with the current minions available
Would it be reasonable to assume MC is also going?
I mean, you could just add a spy lol
I was thinking but it has quite the overlap with widow :P
Wdym? Double the grimpeeker = double the power?!
Reasonable tho
I honestly do think Organ Grinder works here. It's main weakness of giving away outsider count doesn't exist here.
But it's also organ grinder 😭
ye
maybe a DA
No
But DA + SW is a bit much
DA+Scarlet Woman is asking for trouble.
And DA just isn't as cool here as on BMR.
If a Minion is a shadow of its self compared to a base script, I don't think its a good fit.
MC as solo death mod here is actually fine as it’s intended to be considered a TF on this script
As someone who has only run with OG in person, what makes it worse online?
Ok, so you are in the middle of a vote
Everyone is speaking with a slight delay bc thats how online communication works.
Also imagine that when Organ Grinder was released, the unofficial app didn't have a clean way to implement it
result - a very chaotic and not very fun release for organ grinder
What about now tho, unless you are saying it is mostly just lingering first impressions?
how did votes work back then? did people just close their eyes and pinky promise?
It's difficult to put on scripts (I think this script is kinda one of the best homes for it) meaning it's really underutilised by script makers
Well this was when I was still using .online but you DM votes
Well also ye, it's quite a loud Minion and it's hard to put on any script
I don't mind playing an Organ Grinder script
But I am sure that I have suggested to some to take off organ grinder bc it's such a loud effect that confirms outsider count (like putting it on a script where Minions do the Outsider mod isn't ideal).
Which is most scripts
Bc it's hard to build with, not many scripts with it are made
So ye, first impressions are more powerful on something which doesn't make it onto scripts
if you add an Organ Grinder to a script, it usually turns into an Organ Grinder script, regardless of what it was before
I don't think CC is a good Organ Grinder script
Does adding any character X to a script not make it a X script, or do you believe OG has an outsized influence on a script?
Organ Grinder is much more of a script centerpiece than, say, Washerwoman, for example. like Legion, Atheist or Wizard
well sadly there isn't much else that works that well?
I mean, personally, I really like Goblin or Assassin instead of GF on the script
goblin is alright. Good definitely can solve the goblin
An assassin can't cook
It can cook on BMR in a way that totally throws off town
As well as on a lot of other scripts
ye assassin here isn't as interesting as it could be
This doesn't have real death mod
So the assassin can't hide, and deaths don't have other things that they also mean
ye
I do get vati's worry that Goblin might be too easily solvable
Still giving a chance for your chaotic teammate to just be a goblin is fun
i'd argue the other way around, actually
it's tc/alsaahir/dreamer that help w that?
hmm savant ft general all do too
ok never mind
Fortune Teller, Town Crier, Dreamer, Alsaahir
Savant, ye, General ye
Goblin is interesting, but this town can distinguish it
goblin definitely fills a different niche than gf
And in many ways
I don't think this is a problem?
Savant also notably doesn't have to
I think its better than good having nothing to distinguish it
And for a Kazali script it p much ensures good probably has some way to figure it out
Wasn't PD the actual problem
oh yeah someone unsolvably having the goblin ability
or the goblin having the sw ability
Swerenovus 👍
Swoblin 👎
"has the goblin ability but isn't the goblin" - those detectors are just savant/amne/alsaahir right
Goblin is a pseudo safety net
sw/goblin is just a lot though
Yeah
if you aren't exactly speedy nights it's so so rough
tbh i really see the vision for godfather here so it's tough to suggest a replacement
I see the vision with gf however it's a character that needs its setup text to work
I get it but sometimes experience wins out over intuition
what experience? nobody actually picked it :P
arguably half of godfather's effect is that you're not executng outsiders
(that's the experience)
Perception of characters matters disproportionately more in kazali, and even more in solo kazali
that's fair
it's a shame that it does get picked kinda rarely. maybe if people picked it it'd be cool
just rolling grims at 15p, godfather feels really really good as a pick from the grim tool
or maybe it's telling that no one is bothering
but i get that in lower playercounts you basically always would rather have a witch
esp since the bag balancing is a little different at high playercounts compared to low ones, plus that it's dependent on how many base outsiders you have to begin with
(in a 13p game i'm never picking gf since the average amount of outsiders post-setup is 1; i can get way more than 1 witchkill in a 13p game)
did we discuss if Boomdandy worked here? I remember it coming up
is that not kinda similar
ah, right, boomdandy with pd-scarlet
in my experience with boomdandy vs goblin it's less of a safety net since good wins boomdandy countdowns reasonably often
just add saint
like even on d1
replace pd with saint. Now you have a mini safety net (the saint bluff)
no it's not
but it is usually a big discourager
can't get much worse than 'lose the game'
It's pretty core
It obscures between semi-loud minion abilities and serves as a safety net in games without a starting scarlet, and it's an outsider with reasons to live and interesting consequences to bluff
yee
To be fair maybe Godfatehr is just the type of thing to try out from time to time
It might even work
As in, Godfather does have an indirect effect (making Outsider claims less appealing to execute) which might not directly be seen
It's incredibly funny, I can't deny that
It calls to me from the void
scarlet/twin is incredibly tanky, may or may not be an issue in practice
a smart kazali can utilize a good ET play
widow poisoned TC bullshit amne “twin solver”
my one worry is that if a Kazali makes someone they don’t know an ET they’re kindof a dick
twin/damsel is a painful interaction in the wrong group but just be very clear on what guesses you consider valid, maybe not enough though because the good twin is still socially obvious (different to psycho or vizier that way)
I mean Vizier is an interesting minion too I think
it’s one I might pick a bit
-# def doesn’t have a strange attachment to 🅱️izier
this script feels very tight these days, if I try pare it down to "roles that don't feel, with released roles, that they could ever be removed" I get...most of the script
pixie and damsel became core very quickly
why name change
not a name change
I wanted a pun for "the roles the script will ~always have"
(there are unreleased roles I think would work here and can swap some of these)
||Coachman|| would go extremely hard
vizier also calls to me from the void
every group has a Vizier Guy so it gets picked sometimes
and it helps with the script being evilsided 😎
TC is a thing but it's less big a deal than psycho because you don't pick vizier just to poison the tc
did the update happen
no we're working on it
#1 boomdandy supporter
just considered the implications of vizier/pd-scarlet and they're super funny I think
i think that might be unfun
but it does make vizier stronger
although consider alsaahir
oh yeah
the jinx doesn’t really do much with loudish minions and solo demon
"guess the demon type too" but it's a solo demon script
viz is always a bit of a thrall though
if you're picking viz it's not to maximize winrate it's because one of your friends wants to be the vizier
uh sure ig
but yeah hm
it just feels really wacky on this script
it does play more into the kazali meta tho which is cool
boomdandy!!!
at that point you may as well keep godfather if there isnt a good replacement
I don’t like this as an option becuase like 13/6/5/1 is so iconic
in a way that 13/6/4/1 isn’t
agreed
Add imp
This is one step away from "add Heretic"
Or one step closer to “get TPI to release another Minion for CC”’😎
maybe vati could fit The Big Barnacle on CC?

Turns out the answer to "what's the secret behind ||Ringmaster||" is Kazali
(I am not adding that)
Turning over a lot of ideas in my head and a weird thing that keeps coming up is how many minions serve to disincentivize executions
If there's one thing that's a minor issue on this script that I don't think is resolvable with the premise, it's the intersection of:
- d1 is somewhat aimless because Kazali works with "stretched-out" info landscapes, and that means there aren't strong early evil pings to work with unless the seam got lucky (and I don't want to strongly incentivize good player executions out of #2)
- It is bizarrely hard for town to kill into minions because kazali socials break many of the ways town identifies minion candidates, so disproportionately many games get banshee-saved or have 2 evil f3s
I like a lot about Boomdandy here but I don't like its interactions with those -- it makes it very hard for town to kill into evil pings, or to kill at all
Psycho similarly is cool in a lot of ways but one of the things it does is tank executions
Psycho can also "just kill the banshee" like Assassin can but this generally implies widow/psycho which lol
Evil can kill a known banshee but they're leaving a known farmer to rot every time
+2 evil votes
banshee is the one bait role you can proc on purpose because you can make it work for you
well just widow poison the farmer and fake a strawpass 😎
you can kinda proc rk on purpose but it's riskier
also a banshee dying is probably voting on the guy with the widow ping lol
(this is why I don't like giving widow pings to bait roles, it feels obvious but it cuts off a lot of evil's strategy space)
i would say that assassin killing the banshee confirms the assassin but when the only deathmod is assassin and MC that’s not really that necessary
also a lot of the time evil's hand is just forced
Assassin is interesting
in forcing executions on 4
and removing problems but also like
if you're the demon on the f4 night and the last living [non-poli] good is the banshee you usually have to kill that banshee
which is intended and also based
this has happened a lot >:(
other bait roles can't do this
just kill the banshee earlier so you can build up trust with them :)
unless a very commonly picked minion was picked
well if boomdandy is a nono then i support assassin
the banshee thing is annoying tho
in which case that doesn't matter at all
yeah assassin is a no because of that
so then why is Cerenovus here?
there are still often better things to do as the living cere in f3
boffin 😎😎😎
wait yeah can i see the tf suite again i forgor
I have won all evil final 3s bc I maddened the banshee
wait ok yeah boffin might cook here
yeah this has happened at least 3 times
silent PM
conveniently scarlet is popular 😎
"boffin amne is unsolvable" run better boffin amnes
also
consider
recluse boffin amne
librarian, general, dreamer, Savant, amne, and banshee are all good boffin TF abilities
also since kazali can custom pick their team they can do cool synergies with Boffin SW
no widow ping goes out
the devious self poisoning widow:
and you get another minion
eh fair on that
although it doesn’t drunk a damsel
but you shouldn’t give a librarian or dreamer ability in a damsel game lmao
boffin lib poli 🔥
ok so boffin absolutely cooks here in the best way possible
eh I think that there aren't enough good abilities
4/6 of the outsiders are also good boffin abilities provided you have a scarlet for 2 of them
i heavily disagree
and damsel is a good recluse boffin ability
librarian, general, dreamer, Savant, amne, and banshee
also savant can be way more than a grim peeker here
banshee barely counts
general is great
I don'tagree
also a sufficiently insane and unintended reading of the jinx might permit giving the recluse boffin poli
PD Moonchild Recluse PM
hermit at home
Moonchild and PD just needs SW
but the widow ping doesn’t go out
that doesnt poison anyone
but then there can’t be a poisoned player
sure
yeah lmao
widow pings barely matter
anyway I really see the boffin vision I think
the humble team customizing kazali:
it's just whether it has enough to not be widow
oh? boff?
exactly
i haven't backread at all what's goin on here?
so the boffin can't be given pre-made boffin abilities
discussing replacing GF with boffin
boffin SW team plays are not possible with a widow
@floral moon u wanna talk more on boffin being bad here :3
req thinks its too similar to widow and doesnt have enough good abilities
everyone else is arguing against req
I finally admitted that no one except me sees the vision for godfather but all other minions are even worse so we're finding the least bad one
decide the boffin ability after the kaz picks 100%
yes I agree
organ grinder gang tbh
kenoboi will never play it again
so if they pick Boffin SW you can do some cool on death synergies
the only roles that let it do something that widow doesnt are recluse and amnesiac
i agree with requiem that specifically Dreamer Boffin is worse than widow
everything else i see a vision for
I think this being a kazali script with a damn widow on it means every available minion option out of the ones not currently on the script is going to have some issues just because widow does unusually many things
even librarian since (provided you don’t SHOW the damsel), this allows a damsel to be sober and in play with some level of grim peeking
evil twin trust
smh
I think that I liked boffin but your arguements have convinced me its nto that good tbh (your = kenoboi)
I said this
I'm happy with the issues boffin has
compared to e.g. the issues boomdandy or assassin have
boffin only really opens up boffin puzzledrunk tbh, which is a bit of a mess tbh
???
it's an option, I like it less than boffin
Librarian General Savant Amne Recluse, and with SW, Banshee Moonchild and Plague Doctor
If I'm boffin general I'm mad
also don’t even forget all the recluse boffin shenanigans
I don't believe Boffin general is ever good
yeah i know, its pretty good
actually i got boffin general as the al-had once
I think this is just a philosophical disagreement
when i made my choices and got told "good is winning" i'd be like "shit, fuck, dammit!!!! guh..... how could it have ended up like this........"
I like it and it's on both the good boffin scripts
the amount of times i thought i was cooked and needed to starpass only to discover i was the most trusted player on the grim
or vice versa
I have never been evil and been surprised at the general info
evil players generally know whos winning
("both the good boffin scripts" being Final Nail and Ride the Cyclone)
and then when i made my choices and got told "evil is winng" i'd be like "heh.... looks like i'm back in the game after all........ time to cross this finish line!!!!!"
see above
how many was that?
more than 1
2...
plague doctor doesnt feel like a valid choice at all tbh when you can just pick a better minion :3
The ST will know exactly what ability the evil team needs at that point which is big
immortal minion tho
delayed tho
that too
you cant have the early cerelocks and witch snipes and widow poisons
scarlet is the strongest minion on here but pd scarlet is stronger than it
N2 pseudo-starpass 😎
smh why kill myself when i can kill the fortune teller
…for a cool PD ability
and social cred or something
also everyone knows there’s no FT, they always get kaz turned 100% of the time on this script
this is such a rare occurance that I do not think that this is like a good arguement
anyway this is hilarious and I'm going to use this tortured interpretation now
it’s just an example of evil team not knowing who is or is not socially trusted
why wouldn’t it be allowed
from the ST seat this happens constantly
the intention of it is so the demon doesn’t just auto win with good
if your argument is skill issue i think we should have the boffin
the jinx prohibits "the demon" from having the ability but if you reg the recluse to the boffin but not to the djinn there's an argument I think
also i think we play with very different groups
yeah i think the spirit of the jinx would also allow it
what does a good boffin amne ability look like, assuming you have a widow
plague doctor wizard with a good ST
I've played in like 7 different "groups"
it has been clear whos trusted in all of them
i want to group myself
i think boffin has enough that some people will definitely want to utilize it. and if you think it’s a worse widow just…don’t pick it as kazali 😎😎😎
you can see who has the info, you can see who's being chatted to a lot, you can see who's noms get votes
7 < the amount of groups that play BOTC
this is true
yup I just stand by my disagreement
kaz goblin seems not that bad
town crier
from the ST seat, high-info high-weirdness scripts often have a lot going on the evil team misses -- they tend to panic a bit about the info implicating them and miss its interpretation, or alternatively overestimate how well the info they're putting out is influencing anything
Is that a problem? Good needs some way to be able to solve it
HHR has Goblin + TC
it has dreamer/tc/sav/ft
and there are lots of levers in terms of how madness is playing out, if and where droison is being identified, etc
plague doctor scarlet
yeah that’s the only thing i see
Goblin is solved 6 ways to sunday
just dont let the plague doctor die smh (or give a better ability)
true tho
or as hystrex put it
mhm
me when no fearmonger organ grinder combo
I think Vizier is a good fifth
vizier is pretty ew i think
genuinely i agree
oh
vati has good reasoning for this above
why
i had SNV open instead of CC LMFAO
i saw flowergirl
.
still dont like vizier too much here
like Vizier is good becuase good on this script cannot agree on executions
i think they all agree to execute the demon
they don't
i’m still boffin’s strongest soldier but vizier could be cool
i think boffin is better than viz tbh
most devoted ✅
strongest ehhhh
vizier removes a lot of bluffroom imo
I think that a lot of the good team might
:(
until the one player tunnelling badly harvests 3 slams in a row and evil wins
:3
Vizier nerfs evil a lot just by being on the script, let alone in play, so that's arguably useful
that does not happen at all with vizier in play
There are a few things that make it much less viable for me than boffin
I think I'll almost definitely do boffin
Have we considered that vizier happens to be vizier
I think that from storytelling and playing VASMR
Vizier is better than people think bc people don't know how to vote
VASMR?
nerdguy
teensy script built around Vizier
have you never seen the art of VASMR
I think vizier on janklike teensies is not really comparable to vizier on cc
Maam I’ve never seen vizier be helpful
sir?
fuck mb
:3
this is fair
i think vizier would be the weakest minion on CC for sure
Vizier should jsut not have "all players know who you are"
I think this script needs organ Grinder
at least it would get picked
YES
I think this hurts evil more than it helps it
i need to give the "an evil player voted yesterday" savant with organ grinder
we are currently replacing the weakest never picked minion
hystrex do you see the boffin vision
witch isnt being replaced?????
Nah I’d win
godfather is stronger here than witch when actually chosen
Isn't that what widow is for? Lemme look over the script again
witch > godfather :3
i see witch get picked a lot ngl
GAAAAAAH
People pick witch
WHAT DID I SAY
im merely joking, as god's unluckiest witch
the only witch kill i've ever gotten is myself
i've rolled witch about 6~ times
Pick loud people
i do
@dapper carbon
oh right I remember that game now
rip
amne, several of the outsiders, fucked up recluse shenanigans, evil info with sober damsel
witch is cracked, it has synergy with town crier
im a solid amne boffin hater
Half of these are easily widow bluffable
Boffin is like
thank you Hystrex
Banshee???
Quite weak here
not to mention that over half the grim nominated every day
exactly what i said :3
how
I WAS TRYING
i mean yeah librarian
but it allows sober damsel with grim peeking
general is for socials and i will die on that hill
Yeah boffin banshee doesn't work outside phantom detectives
mf when i can custom pick a SW
also recluse boffin shenanigans
Me when the boffin hecking dies
hystrex you gotta see the vision
Kenoboi there is no vision
there's no vision kenoboi
this is a problem with most minions
recluse is the only argument for boffin that i like tbh
there 100% is
There's like 40% of a vision
Y’all
I'm never picking Boffin here
guys i literally laid out multiple examples of when boffin isn’t widow-
then don’t
but i definitely would
we’re trying to get rid of the least picked minion anyway
But can I have the option for godfather back 🥺
Ah
godfather is gone buddy 😔
It should be 4 minions
There is not a fifth minion that fits on this script and lacks widow overlap. Widow does too many things. This is a problem the script has. It will always have this problem. There is no solution to this problem. Conditional on this, what is the fifth minion?
Add legion
big if true (miniscule)
go psychopath for no reason, fuck banshee
Evil twin?
Vizier should just not have "All players know who you are" >:(
idk why that's nesc :/
Yeah it should be like psycho
the problem imo with ET is that if you make someone you don't know the ET you're a dickhead
vati you should do your favorite minion ever harpy
Also exe survival bluff
so then if they solve the ET you are kinda outed
The slept on exe survival bluff
It's a solo kazali script what's new
faking ET with your minion kinda peak tbh
well yeah that's the problem with et
What?
it's an outed minion
says the lady suggesting vizier
ET is not outed what
Possibility but worse than boffin for several reasons
No
you say was as if it was ever good
ET puts people into social conflicts and is one of the most hated minions because of that
all my supporters went offline and all my haters rose up 😔😔😔
There's about 95% I do it
This like
we’re so back
Vati you should add mez :sotrue:
Isn’t the case in not livetext
what
I have considered all the other possibilities and I find their shortcomings worse than boffin's shortcomings
you know I don't play majority livetext right
REAL
People enjoy ET 85% of the time
All backed by Big Monkey 🐵
I don’t see you on app enough
People notoriously loathe et
Therefore must be livetext
who are you playing with
App randos
I have IRL groups <3
People like ET
I find it entirely fine for CC to be a 4 minion script that additionally has godfather on it
Especially for moonchild reasons
there’s on average 0-1 players in a game who dislike ET
alright i’m gonna dip for now, boffin stay strong for me
I don't think this is true
like
someone in my irl group runs SnV with ET -> Boomdandy bc of how little they like ET
and multiple people agree with the change
ET is very divisive yeah
Everyone on the app except exactly the two of us hates et so much they keep running Fearmonger SnV
I think it's insane to put it on SnV but that's a different story
Hey at least it's not fearmonger
Vati fearmonger SNV never existed
I have 0 clue what you’re talking about
I assure you it did
I haven’t seen any heresy of the sort
Vati I think this is a joke
There's also goblin snv and harpy snv and mez snv
I am also not sure tho
This is less surprising
i like snv but only tb roles to avoid ET
besite
Jesus Christ this is new
No Parker has this thing where he like envisions how people play and I have to remind him I play in the same damn place and it's not true
I’ve seen like
2 people hate ET
I don’t understand
Anyway I think this has been demonstrated over time to not work
😭
Is this because I never join TB lobbies
What about it doesn't work
That it sucks and it's a problem for introducing the script to people and that "script presence" roles don't work in Kazali
(i would unironically suggest wizard but then it'd become a wizard script tbh)
It would be an ideal minion here if there was a second demon
But a lot of minions would be ideal here if there was a second demon
Add pithag smh
Boffin is in the box
iconic
idk what these words mean in this order
ET's kinda annoying tbh... :/
hard social conflict like that is frusterating
My whole worldview is crashing down before my eyes
if I am playing CC and turned into ET
and like
someone I don't know very well is my demon
ET doesn’t work on CC
I'm annoyed
we already know that
does it not? D:
we only have 6 outsiders including poli tbh
It's one of those things people tend to express in nuances that are less obvious if you haven't yet worked out what people mean by those nuances
Because like
I mean
Skill issue legion ET scripts
This works
It’s weird that I hate a role everyone likes and love 5 roles people don’t like
we should put legion on CC
No
its an okay ish minion
just pick your own demon smh
Le no
if they can pick you, you can pick them
Engineer Legion moment
Don’t do this
Actually ET snv might’ve been a mistake
ET GoS
But consider ET GoS
yeah no
I know leviathan
But like
It’s better in leviathan
Oh wait riot nvm
ET is fine on SNV
also
but no one gets the vision
ET is too loud
Why are we speculating about GoS here now
#speculation-and-spoilers
Moment
Anyway ||Riddle Fiend|| GoS
That’s my counterpoint
i come back and we’re discussing GoS minion suite
I admit I didn't read the 9000 messages that have been written here in the last two hours, but I hope somewhere among those vati decided that Boffin is not a good replacement for GF 😬
i think we should just keep GF
Was there any particular reason for having five minions besides "vibes"?
Kazali options at 13+ players?
just pick witch thrice
witch hunt moment
GF can potentially by an okay PD ability, but even at 13+ I wonder how often someone would pick Godfather
hey brain are there stats on CC
It's by a significant margin more viable than anything else I can think of
It is not perfect
Nothing will ever be perfect
It is legitimately not possible to have a perfect fifth minion on a script that also includes a minion that was consciously designed to do like five different things at once
I don't really want to drop to 4
That's probably the second choice behind Boffin because all other options have sticking points I genuinely dislike
i think GF is picked exclusively at b2 outsiders
Probably. Haven't checked yet though
bra1n you should read those 9000 messages
i really don’t wanna type up my entire boffin essay again
I know, I know, but then my other work will suffer... 
true…
Across all versions and formats I've now recorded 51.7% good wins so it's finally balanced but now I gotta add 6 bra1n games to the stats
i guess closing statements is yes widow can do a lot that boffin can (BUT NOT ALL), but there aren’t really any actively bad aspects of boffin on this script (no virgin, no NWM etc) so there’s really no harm in adding it if nothing else works
And also it does some really based things and offers a way to get evil info with a sober damsel
also Boffin PM is technically a new form of misinfo on this script
since it’s drastically different from regular PM
Still a worse widow
disagree
The auspicious amnesiac:
but i really don’t wanna type it all out again
@noble folio mostly this
Also you can give the recluse the damsel ability
Or depending how you interpret the jinx the poli ability
yeah recluse shenanigans are mentioned below
also you can do TINMBH and do recluse amne with an outsider ability
Which are also both very interesting ways to balance Kazali picks
Yeah I already have some abilities in mind from Final Nail
My players are not advanced enough for that, don't forget not everyone has played hundreds of customs yet.
"they're 6/6 evil"
oh my days
Just sub widow for spy and poisoner :sotrue:
REAL
Nah, the last two were won by good I think
i mean, if your players arent experienced enough for it, then dont do it
meanwhile, people with players who are experienced enough for it can still enjoy it
alright, I checked and I can only see 12 games that have been played with v5.2 on the app
48.6% 😎
(there are 35 games across all versions where I know how they ended, but I know there are more that have been run)
the 12 on the app had 7 good wins
smh no fun and whimsy
the GF was picked ZERO times by the Kazali in those 12 games
how many times out of those 12 games was it b2 outsiders?
each role that was in play at the end of the game in those 12 rounds
15 Kazalis means 3 of them were SWs originally
SW 7, cere & widow 5, witch 4
although one or two of the finishing Kazalis might have actually been PD SWed other minions
oh right pd exists, true
the one or two must've been godfather 🔥 /j
I think based on synthesizing both the games I ran in this period and the games I saw other people run (off the roles I can remember some individual games lol) none of the app games specifically were pd scarlet
yeah, seems likely, given 5 games had a PD
also math at 2 reinforces my argument that it's not a good fit on this script 😄
That's because people hate running it
sure, but there has to be a reason
I didn't run most of these games and when I talked to the other STs about bagbuilding it was very "not wanting to run math or savant"
Is Math not relatively easy to run here?
do your hands have at least one finger? 
you keep pointing to this list as if they are all good boffin abilities and not 90% worse widow or “work only on SW Boffin”
I don't think this is a boffin script
Maybe without widow, it is
can you send the livetext stats speicifclaly, curious ant smth
how is savant amne recluse PM “worse widow”
librarian general savant are
and banshee!
librarian allows grimpeeking without drunk damsel as i have already said many times
widow is extremely not general, it lacks reactivity
“works only on SW Boffin”’
Banshee is disabled after a bit tho?
don't die
and we disagree on general but i think it’s good for socials
After the boffin's inevitable death
REAL
you have +2 evil votes why is the boffin getting executed
+1
Not disambiguated by format unfortunately

boffin =/= grimpeeker
"mostly evil"
either a feelsbad or useless
Unless Poli outs the demon and instantly wins
evil won the one game where that happened 😎
Lol
for that matter they also won the game where the demon outed to the pd bluffing poli
Love that for them
v3 was pretty evilsided
All of my ideas are just "budget widow" lol
This is "recluse with boffin-amne" not "demon with boffin-amne"
Oh
The fun "This is not my Beautiful House":
EXACTLY
When you put Recluse into the bag and then the Kazali never chooses Boffin and picks that player to become a minion
I don't think Boffin fits the vibe here
uncommon axo W
what does lol
axo Ws are very common
Godfather
evil cannot have an easy way to deal with banshees
^
GF in base 1/2
the devious cerenovus:
yeah but the vibes are off
The cere has to live, notably
The assassin doesn't
means you can't lock the savant as pixie to back up the poli's bluff
And also you're using the fucking cerenovus ability to deal with a banshee of all things
it's a strategy, it's not a breaking strategy
You could be cooking with it
the only time when you need to deal w a banshee is f3
thank you, thank you
Gave +1 Thanks to @sudden tendon (current: #412 - 105)
I'll be so real, I don't think there's a good 5th Minion released yet
I don’t even like regularly playing savant, that game was something alright
especially considering the caveat that I hate fun, whimsy, and 60% of minions
Boffin is a trap for boffin lovers that will cause them to lose
embrace Vizier as the fun fifth
oh it's like how widow is a trap for widow lovers that causes them to lose
Yeah, I don’t think anything fits the vibe well while also being great, but I’m also not really a script builder
I mean Organ Grinder but also hi It Comes At Night welcome back
We thought you died after the Kaz release
that would produce a new script I think
me when assassin is used to help evil bluff gf existing and nothing else
(the second outsider gets exed and town immediately realizes it's not a gf game)
I'm still going to try Goblin in place of GF and nobody is going to stop me 
Improvement on the time people tried to replace it with Poisoner
Tell me how it goes
godfather is so much better than boffin here imo
godfather adds dimension in a way that boffin doesn't really
boffin also needs a bit more bagbuilding than most minions imo
like if you happen to put puzzlemaster and amne in play, and the kaz makes a widow and a boffin what are you gonna give as the boffin ability
the best case is you give the recluse the plague doctor ability and then the boffin is a blank token until day 3 or whatever, when they get the sw ability or something
absolute HATERS
vati it’s me and you against the world
luckily you’re the script creator 
savant 😎
general 😎
Recluse 😎
Fisherman oh wait that’s not on here 😎
i agree it has anti-synergy with widow
however i think of it more as a widow sidegrade than downgrade
but yes as a kazali i probably would not pick widow AND boffin which does lower kazali combos
but like what synergies did GF have in 1-2 minion games
I am unconvinced
I am unconvinced
yeah i know 😔
you can have this one
good question
@sudden tendon you said no one else but you saw the gf vision
what is the gf vision
i saw an argument that godfather was here to partially prevent outsider from just being exed
disincentive executing outsiders
but if gf is never picked (due to kazali being a picking demon)
then the fearmongering is kinda, gone
also for bluffing outsiders
i mean only 2 out of 6 of these outsiders actively want to be executed and 1 of them can’t say why
i guess moonchild too
you normally already have a bluff as a kazali'd minion
and it's an arbitrary bluff too
widow does this better 😎
yes
but like, with risk (of low outsider count)
Makes outsider bluffs terrifying to execute into because of gf kill
it does quasi confirm them tho
it's a witch sidegrade depending on base outsider count
it confirms the outsiders as good, but this isn't always bad
right but
what happens when the first GF kill happens 😨
fringe game 🔥
Honestly, I'd prefer an in play recluse picking up the PD ability over savant/general. Recluse is fair tho
Is Boomdandy off?
vati doesnt want it so yea
yes 😔
that was a lot to read
the real question is after reading allat, are you pro or anti boffin
Any thoughts on recommended travellers?
Travellers that have worked: Apprentice, Judge, the voting travs but there's an extra evil on script so that's contentious, Harlot, probably Barista (least tested of the set and inherently super swingy)
When running travellers on here, assign their final roles and alignments after the Kazali picks
(Apprentice legitimately works here because it can mitigate rather than intensify swing)
I think Bone Collector and Scapegoat would probably work too
also a gangster shot the demon in f3 once
longtext cc ended, damsel win on 5
demon bluffed a widow ping that everyone hard trusted 
(anieta shouldn't be marked dead I think)
dire just hates the town crier
Yeah, Anieta was alive
noted :3
i was robbed of my give-random-bullshit-to-savant chance by early death smhh
confirmed widow game
extremely fun to watch
also assuaged my concern about solo kazali longtext
was more concerned about social meta but it turned out fine
at least externally
would want more player feedback
but also yeah I've become confident over time that kazali setup swing is (while significant) less of an issue than people who don't run the demon a lot tend to worry
mm damsel too broken just gets guessed by evil /j
so true
Damsel is rough, but fine probably
good revealed too much
this is the first sober damsel game I've heard of where the damsel guess didn't solve the game for good 😭
that's it
Godfather is a choice here but I'm sure you've already heard that advice a million times.
would you like to backread the 1000 post discussion about what to replace it with
i like GF
i need to find more kazali scripts
eh
alternatively you could just run this one always
other kazali scripts do feel like Clockwork Cyborg but worse idk
i was considering running this one again ehe
oh yeah how'd livetext Project go I missed it
you should
i think there should be a 15p kazali script that works somewhere tbh
evil won off the klutz
cc's been played fine at 16
i said "i hope i dont roll sweetheart" then i immediately rolled sweetheart
and then got picked as DA
first successful execution on d3
and protected every single execution
until klutz which picked me
and game over :3
also i was bluffing politician btw
unironically
They don't exist
ill just have to make some then
ill run CC but 15 next time maybe
it comes at night and back to basics:
ping me
also @reef plinth congrats on first longtext demon win 🔥 happy to have it be on my script
I must keep my CC winstreak
I've made a bad kazali script
longtext organ grinder 🔥
i havent seen back to basics, what is that?
dm it to me plss
i have made the kazali teensy of all time :3
just don't run it in long text
ooh wait i can run steward strikes back
Sentinel? 😭
its not even that bad trust trust trust
NO lol
Oh ok
damsel is such a damaging character holy shit
also who was ceremad?
that's one of the versions from before kazali came out
dire has his own script named steward strieks back actually
oracle as fortune teller, then self cere
it's funi
(kazali was made by the guy who made that script)
this literally isn't it
steward was the original
welll hold on
Got it
req gaslighting campaign
they're just two scripts with similar names
it is, zets started public work on btb before the kazali release so he released semi-fake versions with only imp
oh wait really?
this is TB but bad
noway
All scripts are TB but bad
No. SnV is gos but bad
based
is it tb but bad?
this isn't my fault
Evil Twin the move :3
Godfather but better