MitHotD Vibes Script - First Impression Feedback?

[dapper seal]

I decided to have some fun and cobble together a script out of experimental characters and some of the leaked playtest characters which can be found at https://www.bloodstar.xyz/p/piglix/Full_Unreleased_Characters/almanac.html.
I do know there are quite a few alignment changers, but I think removing them would detract from the style. I haven't made any homebrew scripts before, so I'm not really sure if its playable or not. I'd love to hear what people think!
https://www.bloodstar.xyz/p/IClaimGoblin/MidnightMadhouse/almanac.html
None of the characters or artwork are mine, but I did tweak a few of the playtest demons.

[acoustic oracle]

Goblin and Sicilian don't work together

Sicilian can pick the Goblin and the Goblin claims Goblin and wins

[supple parrot]

very loud minions and marionette dont usually work that well together

also poppygrower and marionette are jinxed

a lot of overlap in making evil communication harder to a point were it detracts from each individual one

marionette alchemist is a bad interaction

scholar and alchemist do similar things'

and as you mentioned extra evils is bad

also gangster harlot and beggar work very badly in legion games so dont fit well on the script

[dapper seal]

I’ll get rid of marionette and Sicilian for sure then, but I’m not sure what to replace them with. Maybe Cerenovus would be good?

[dapper seal]

yeh I didn’t think very hard about the travellers so I think I’ll come back to them once the base script works

[dapper seal]

I get that they both learn something of what the evil team can’t do, but alchemist gets to do it and scholar learns the demon (and specific minion/s), so is that similar enough they shouldn’t be on the same script? That being said I have doubts about how interesting it would be to play scholar, particularly on this script

Also ty very much for the feedback both of you, I missed quite a few big issues

[supple parrot]

It was more a thing of loud minions also don't play very well into this dynamic as it kinda confirms the alchemist and makes the scholar not feel like it has much to help out with

[dapper seal]

Oh I see

[supple parrot]

Also loud minions and legion play badly together

[dapper seal]

Would good alchemists and legion bluffing being affected by minions cover that up though?

[supple parrot]

It can confirm to a lot of individual people that it's not a legion game

This makes scholar seeing legion a very hard bluff

[supple parrot]

As well as it takes away a lot of the paranoia