okay some notes on individual characters:
butler - vastly overpowered. unbluffable, detects if it's drunk or poisoned, and is an extremely effective evil detector at the same time. oh and if it chooses an evil on n1 it dies n1 which is absurd
drunk - this ability does nothing. if it was just "once per game at night, choose a player: they are drunk" that would at least do something. making it so either you or they are drunk makes it meaningless
spy - i think this ends up being an overpowered juggler, but i don't think it's insanely powerful
recluse - this feels very weak. it would feel weak as an each night, and is even weaker as a once per game
savant & philo - why are these outsiders. these are positive abilities
sage - kind of fun, but they can always just be executed on day 1. not a terribly impactful ability though, evil learning one character is weak for them
virgin - this is incredibly powerful, and again I'm not sure why it's an outsider. it hard confirms itself nearly immediately then can just have people nominate it until someone survives
investigator - why is this an outsider
poisoner - interesting, but again, not terribly impactful
chef - what are they supposed to be mad about?
fang gu - fairly weak, causing one player to misregister as a minion for one day is not much of an effect
ravenkeeper - on the weaker side
empath - i don't fully understand the text here, is it just a worse no dashii?
cerenovus - is the madness permanent? because that's not fun. it also has no kill power
pit hag - likely pretty weak, nothing hear is doing all that much dead player detecting
inland cloak
prime finch