secret thing

[keen crescent]

but then it turns out that I had to do that, as they were executed that day

then I switch to myself, there's a night of no deaths as the assassin actually hit the pukka poison on accident

we wake up on the exact same final 4, 3 evils 1 good

and the assassin locks in and convinces the good player to nom me instead of the demon

was a weird ending

the weirdest part was they were claiming sailor, I was claiming pacifist, and with both of us alive, nobody belived the da save the previous day was legit

in fact, several people were building the correct demon world

we were just fortunate that the last living good player is kinda not that good at the game, and we were able to convince them to nominate correctly

though it took a lot of convincing

[foggy grotto]

TB, the confirmed virgin disconnected and the evil team (with me in it) got exactly enough votes on the frame that they could only tie it. If the virgin has connected they could have won (but we also didn’t know who the virgin would vote with)

[barren sun]

Gaslighting the good Judge into thinking the Saint was the center of a Typhon line and that it was very likely the final day.
(It wasn't, the Saint just happened to neighbour a bunch of evils and a suspicious Farmer, I was a dead evil demon-virgin)
If the Saint wasn't executed, the Demon was very likely next on the chopping block

[uneven field]

I'll be riding this high forever

I had two voice games in a row a while back where I drew washerwoman, saw a role that wouldn't want to be confirmed, didn't speak to my pings, claimed a completely different townsfolk that ended up being a demon bluff, didn't back down from the double claim, was trusted more than the evil player, and dismantled the evil team accordingly

in the first of those games, I bluffed librarian and cold called the saint, which was very unfortunate for the evils bluffing librarian/recluse, and in the second game, I double claimed the imp as the soldier, causing town to want to execute into us, causing the imp to have to starpass and invalidate their soldier claim because they had no scarlet woman

both of these were TB, I love TB

washerwoman is the most op townsfolk on trouble brewing (when I'm playing it)

[fiery sleet]

Playing Trained Killer. I'm the Fortune Teller and fully aware of both the correct world (LM with a dead boffin-monk and living spy), and that I'm the frame going into f3. I have a hunch I'm gonna wake up with the baby, and I do. But then I die that night because of how that script works, so I don't need to convince town that I'm not a Minion lifting from the other person who was gonna claim they're good and holding the baby :)

[dusty thistle]

I had a BMR game where I prided myself on a perfect plan. It did not go as planned. I (the po) got myself into a moonchild ping late in the game and overnight went from one of the most trusted characters on the board to about to get exed. I only got away with it via a series of events where I convinced town to execute someone else and a piece of social credit from earlier. Lucky I got a quick triple to finish off the game late.

[grizzled marsh]

TPOT game (8p). I was the fang-gu claiming alsaahir. D1 the mutant gets into a DC with my minion, and gets executed. D2 the snake charmer gets in a DC with me, and gets executed. D3 the snake charmer claims to be the pixie confirming me (with the intention of baiting a demon kill onto me), allowing me to fang-gu jump to the outed outsider without it looking weird. My minion got executed in final day

[fallow rapids]

snv, i‘m dashiing. two steps away from me are both the good and evil twins. clockmaker is in play. pithag has to make a good demon for a bit, then turns me into witch, then turns themself into a fang gu

skull

[fiery sleet]

2/4: Middle/high school movie set in Ravenswood Bluff, what is each character doing?

is the jock who turns out to be a pretty chill dude

[finite wigeon]

is studying

[hollow oasis]

the extras

[supple dirge]

Is in a dramatic love triangle with and , and by the end realize even though was rich and popular was her soulmate all along

[junior knot]

you know exactly who it is

https://tenor.com/view/veronica-mars-kristen-bell-wink-finger-pistol-gif-8135816

:

[barren sun]

wrong show, was meant to be in teen wolf

the main female character who's discovering her true self by other means that just dating boys as others do

school director

kid who gets in trouble when teaches religion

[versed junco]

only getting by because they keep mooching off their friend's work

[dusty thistle]

Is supposed to be in the elementary school movie.

[supple dirge]

2/5 What would the perfect valentine's day date be like for different characters?

[lost thistle]

The Honorable Judge

[versed junco]

oh good, it's toxic yaoi

[dusty thistle]

I'd say more outright hentai

[junior knot]

:

:

[fallow rapids]

everyone knows i ship

but have we considered

[fiery sleet]

is spending Valentine's Day in a parasocial relationship with da boss ()

[valid garden]

Is it just me or have most of the answers not actua;;y answered the question

[fiery sleet]

I reject the question and substitute my own, cooler idea of what the question is

[valid garden]

No no I think you have

[fallow rapids]

mostly because we‘ve done this question a few times before lmao

[valid garden]

Ahhh

[junior knot]

i think its just different interpretations of the question

whether you are talking about the event, or the other person

[lost thistle]

pre submitting a 2/6 even though its still 2/5 here
What's your favorite question that's been asked multiple times?

dont answer this until 2/6

[warped urchin]

Its the 6th for me though

So can I answer it

[junior knot]

The honorable judge

oh and horse

[lost thistle]

horse?

in the evil and intimidating variety?

[valid garden]

Truuuuu

[junior knot]

is there any other kind?

[finite wigeon]

and ...

The hostess kind of gave us an awkward look when we admitted it was a romantic reservation for 10. However, she sat all 9 of us in our places as we waited for that...rebellious goody-two shoes to strut all in like they own the place. It took them a while, but when they came it felt like the ground itself was shaking from their sheer girth and aura. They shot the hostess a command to seat them, and they were placed at our table. Hochi mama whoo waa yee, we're in the gold zone babycakes. Our love, our simultaneous, comunally shared love had finally shown up to the date. The badass stroked their cross necklace, looking us in the eyes and asked, slowly,

"So, do any of you come here often?"

We were all stunned. This was our first time here, because the Heretic is the only lover we've ever--

Fuck this

[warped urchin]

No no, keep going

[hollow oasis]

wha

[lost thistle]

just backread the origin and i cant stop laughing at every character

[junior knot]

this should be the first script on the site, hands down

this may actually be my answer to the prompt, ngl

we should honestly do it again

ykw how do we feel about reserving [4/1] for it annually?

[lost thistle]

that would be amazing

[wicked zodiac]

yesss

my ideal date is probably we yap about clocktower

[junior knot]

@fast anchor you need to come up with the other varieties of horses

[fiery sleet]

Weevil and Incriminating Horse (Minion)

Each night, choose a player. Chosen players are Weevils and may be arrested. You're immune to Weevils.

[junior knot]

no you cant come up with the ability yet

its gotta be via the prompt

we just need to have different horse character names locked and loaded before then

[supple dirge]

The good and welcoming horse

[junior knot]

The slimy and drunk horse?

[fiery sleet]

The studious and fastidious horse

[uneven field]

your statement is incorrect, on the grounds that "most" implies that at least one of them has when really none of them have

[6/2] Make a Minion with a you start knowing ability. It doesn't have to be YSK as the entire ability, as long as part of the ability's dynamic is the Minion starting knowing something, like the Godfather

I'm using secret thing as a vessel to get more of you 1.into making homebrew, and 2.better at and more creative with making homebrew

[junior knot]

theres already a feb 6 question cass

[hollow oasis]

I feel like we need to reopen secret thing timeline B

[junior knot]

Anti Poppy (Minion): You start knowing one of one players is a specific demon and up to 3 players are specific minions.

[hollow oasis]

https://discord.com/channels/569683781800296501/1367732311654666270

You opened the rift

[uneven field]

it was submitted early and that's not fair

I don't recognise it

[hollow oasis]

well

there are people who post that early in their actual timezone

its only fair

[uneven field]

we have so very few rules here, that we submit one question a day when it's that day is sacred

[hollow oasis]

well yes

ngl

I think we're hitting capacity anyway

we should

use the rift

[uneven field]

this isn't what happened here though, it was explicitly stated that it was presubmitted

[low umbra]

Am I blind? I can’t see the 6/2 question if Cass’ isn’t the first

[warped urchin]

.

[uneven field]

this is because the "one that was already there" was posted on February 5th

[hollow oasis]

in fairness, it's still february 5th for me

so like

[low umbra]

That first one was submitted on the morning of 2/6 my time so ig it counts. Though it’s been done so many times so idk

[hollow oasis]

yeah i'm not entirely against posting early because it's literally the only way I can beat yall

[uneven field]

well I'm in the future so mine is legitimate

[hollow oasis]

and even then

I don't

[junior knot]

also we have reserved questions in the past like its not that huge a deal

[hollow oasis]

I mean yeah

1 secret thing is not enough

This town ain't big enough for 1 a day

[uneven field]

what if we standardised an official secret thing timezone

[junior knot]

it is if people are more patient

[hollow oasis]

I've wanted to post a question for like

3 months

[junior knot]

a lot of times people just post when discussion of the previous q has died down

[uneven field]

nerdguy in the last three months there have been so very many days where no questions were posted

[hollow oasis]

those were days I didn't check secret thing

I mean I'm usually here to run a gameshow

(I miss the chipotle riceposting)

[uneven field]

I genuinely don't get it, it baffles me, there are days with nothing and there are days when we are scrambling to get questions in before one another and posting questions over each other

do we all just collectively induce ourselves into a shared psychosis and take the same days off?

[hollow oasis]

... ok

[low umbra]

We tried doing that. It didn’t work, as you can tell

[hollow oasis]

it is a thing

and I'm pretty sure it was set like

[uneven field]

did we?

[hollow oasis]

when that was posted

[uneven field]

oh, dip

I feel like Greenwich mean makes intuitive sense

[hollow oasis]

ngl y'all have just been going at my 6pm

so like

that's... 3 1/2 hours ago

[uneven field]

that do be midnight in Greenwich

I think

ye

[hollow oasis]

I'm central standard time

do with that

what you will

[uneven field]

it's 4:30 am here which means it's 3:30 in the UK

so three and a half hours ago is indeed midnight in Greenwich

[warped urchin]

I'm not even going to ask why you are awake at 4:30am

[uneven field]

I mean you kind of are, by making this statement

[dusty thistle]

What? You're up so late for CST. I say, the massive hypocrite.

[hollow oasis]

938????

tf u on about

[dusty thistle]

I've routinely seen you up at around 11

[junior knot]

is 11 that late?

[hollow oasis]

... dude I've been here until 1am

[dusty thistle]

-# which I know because I'm also in CST

[uneven field]

yeah dude, you have to get your eight hours in and wake up at 5

[hollow oasis]

I wake up at 8

[uneven field]

which is in 20 minutes for me

[junior knot]

7

[hollow oasis]

8 feels good

I eat a waffle

with peanutbutter and jelly

[uneven field]

9:30 is not a crazy time to be up at lmao

[hollow oasis]

no it's not

not even 1am considering when I get up

[dusty thistle]

I was accommodating for Nerdy's age.

[hollow oasis]

7 hours is fine

[junior knot]

its like pm

[hollow oasis]

shame

using my real name on the internet

tsk

[uneven field]

there are people waking up to catch the morning ferry right now where I'm from and I haven't even gone to sleep

[dusty thistle]

I mean, I know you've already pubclized it, but I went and covered it back up.

[hollow oasis]

I'm joking

[dusty thistle]

I know, but you have a point

[uneven field]

Nerdguy is his real name

it's like, Russian, probably

[hollow oasis]

tru

[junior knot]

ricky gervais in muppets most wanted

[uneven field]

I don't get that joke

[hollow oasis]

what is this "muppets"

[tough silo]

Hatred: You Start Knowing 5 players, if 3 are executed, evil wins, even if you're dead.

[fallow rapids]

hi

[junior knot]

https://muppet.fandom.com/wiki/Dominic_Badguy

[uneven field]

hi!

[hollow oasis]

ok ricky gervais is

one of the comedians of all time

[tough silo]

Came up with this guys

[hollow oasis]

but genuinely what are muppets

[uneven field]

you forgot the word worst

[uneven field]

HUH?

[dusty thistle]

This script makes no sense with the assignments.

[junior knot]

plz tell me you're joking

[hollow oasis]

uh

[dusty thistle]

Really? Scooter minion? Miss Piggy demon?

[hollow oasis]

I will neither

confirm

nor deny

the allegations

[uneven field]

no the thing is I can believe it, I once had a friend that had never heard of ABBA

[fallow rapids]

Multivector (Minion)

On your 1st night, evil players choose their character. All players start knowing 1 player who is not the Demon.

[dusty thistle]

Nerdy, this is like not knowing about the Beatles...

[hollow oasis]

Ok the beatles are real

[fallow rapids]

i‘m like sick rn so this is minion ability is kinda ass

but whatever

i‘

m going back to eep

[uneven field]

nerdguy, Kermit the frog, elmo, Bert and Ernie

[hollow oasis]

??

what do those have in common

[dusty thistle]

Fun fact, also Yoda

[uneven field]

THEY ARE MUPPETS

[hollow oasis]

WHAT'S A MUPPET

[uneven field]

sobbing

[fallow rapids]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Muppets

[dusty thistle]

Look up Jim Henson

[warped urchin]

Wow Nerdguy really is an itty bitty baby huh

[hollow oasis]

All I see is a lego frog

and some old dudes

[dusty thistle]

This is like not knowing about Mr. Rogers...

[fallow rapids]

are you unable to read wikipedia

[hollow oasis]

my parents keep saying he was peak

[hollow oasis]

||no it's ragebait||

[uneven field]

nerdguy you don't have to answer this but how old are you

[hollow oasis]

you could find that one out by backreading

[dusty thistle]

||I think it's somewhere like 14-15||

[hollow oasis]

But uh

[uneven field]

12, got it

[fiery sleet]

Who /srs

[hollow oasis]

Mr.Rogers is some TV kind person

according to my parents or smth Idk

[uneven field]

Mr. Rogers is the universe's ultimate fighting champion

[dusty thistle]

If anyones to know, the Muppet Show apparently got revived btw.

[hollow oasis]

somehow I doubt that

Ok I know what muppets are

I was

joking

[uneven field]

no it's true, he won

[dusty thistle]

Oh thank god

[hollow oasis]

I watched sesame street

and craggle rock I guess

[fallow rapids]

Multivector (Minion)

On your 1st night, evil players choose their character. All good players start knowing 1 player who is not the Demon.

[dusty thistle]

And any of Star Wars?

[hollow oasis]

watched every one

[junior knot]

its a special, that im suspecting is an attempt at a backdoor pilot to a reboot

[hollow oasis]

unfortunately

[uneven field]

well you're young enough to not know Mr. Rogers or the ultimate showdown of ultimate destiny

[fallow rapids]

actually this minion is kinda ass

[hollow oasis]

the sequels suck

[fallow rapids]

kjafaskjldfakl

[hollow oasis]

and I hate jarjarbinks

[uneven field]

i wasn't going to say anything but

[dusty thistle]

I haven't seen them. I've just seen the originals and Phantom Menace.

[hollow oasis]

good

don't

watch the sequels

[dusty thistle]

Phantom Menace I have no memory of

[hollow oasis]

It's the worst plot

[dusty thistle]

And I don't plan to remember it

[hollow oasis]

to ever be created

and all recordings of it should be burned

it's literally just "Lmao have powers with no effort also good person + evil person love plot"

[dusty thistle]

If Phantom Menace is anything to go by, it can't possibly be worse.

[hollow oasis]

they are.

by

a lot

[dusty thistle]

I'll avoid them, got it.

[hollow oasis]

"The sequels make the prequels look good" -some random person

[uneven field]

I don't give a fuck about star wars or whatever but that's certainly a statement

[dusty thistle]

But yeah, Yoda is a Muppet. Fun fact!

[uneven field]

usually when someone says "we need to destroy all copies of this piece of media" it's very very bad

[hollow oasis]

did I stutter

They're really bad

[uneven field]

"it" referring to the action and not the media to be clear

[hollow oasis]

aw.

oh you meant

ah

it's just like

why did this make money

[uneven field]

I like bad movies

[hollow oasis]

It sucks in the context of "being star wars"

[uneven field]

bill and ted 2 fucking sucks, it's so good

[uneven field]

awful horrible movie, 10/10

[hollow oasis]

I think episode 9 ends with "My name is Rey Skywalker"

notably: this is a bullshit ending

[dusty thistle]

Actually, I lied. I have seen The Force Awakens.

[uneven field]

genuinely might be the single worst film I've ever seen and I loved it

[dusty thistle]

It was corny. Very corny.

[hollow oasis]

well yeah

the sequels are worse

[dusty thistle]

That was one of the sequeld

[hollow oasis]

oh

yea

[uneven field]

I need to watch more bad movies

[hollow oasis]

right

[hollow oasis]

does dodgeball count?

I feel like it does

[uneven field]

like the sport?

[dusty thistle]

Oh man that movie is so bad

[hollow oasis]

it's a movie

[uneven field]

what's it about

[hollow oasis]

my favorite growing up

[hollow oasis]

A gym about to go bankrupt going all in on a dodgeball tournament to win the prize money to stop them from going broke

It's

so so bad

but funny

[uneven field]

oh Ben Stiller's in this

[hollow oasis]

"If you can dodge a wrench you can dodge a ball"

[dusty thistle]

I watched it once, loved it. Watched it again, realized all of the jokes are horrendously homophobic.

[hollow oasis]

^ absolute cinema

[hollow oasis]

really?

fuck

I hate nostalgia

[uneven field]

(2004)

yeaaa

[hollow oasis]

Dodgeball was like... the first movie I liked ever...

[dusty thistle]

I mean, they even fit a god damn racial slur in there.

[hollow oasis]

oh COME ON

Down Periscope is fun

[dusty thistle]

I'm so very very sorry nerdy

[hollow oasis]

it's no longer my favorite movie

no that's now "Tag"

[uneven field]

it's a 2004 sport comedy starring Ben Stiller, it is to be expected

[hollow oasis]

"tag" - the movie about a 30 year long tag game

where we are fully willing to crash a wedding to tag this one guy

whos "untaggable"

what

a plot

[uneven field]

I should rewatch some of the old comedy movies I watched when I was younger and see how bad they hold up

does anyone remember Rat Race?

[hollow oasis]

wha

Also

hot take

"The Diplomat"

yes the netflix show

is good

my friends couldn't follow it

[uneven field]

I'm pretty sure there's a scene in that movie where one of the characters puts on a hitler moustache

[hollow oasis]

huh

[uneven field]

2001

[hollow oasis]

sounds about right yea

damn

[dusty thistle]

Well, regarding Dodgeball, I am willing to give credit where it's due: Jason Bateman was actually really funny

[hollow oasis]

was that the enemy

[uneven field]

I think in that same scene he gets beat up by a lesbian biker??

[dusty thistle]

No, he was one of the announcers

Bold strategy Cotton

[hollow oasis]

I liked the enemy's arc

[uneven field]

am I hallucinating this?

[hollow oasis]

Fat guy-->Ultimate Gym Bro-->Fatter guy

[uneven field]

damn it I need to rewatch rat race

[hollow oasis]

because of some random legal clause causing the dodgeball tourny loss to...... lose him his whole company somehow

What a movie

[uneven field]

no yeah I looked it up and it's actually worse

[dusty thistle]

I don't think I want to hear the details but I cannot bear to not know how it's worse.

[hollow oasis]

this has got to be good

[uneven field]

||https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=4dsgQb3jkk4||

trigger warning: the 2001 comedy film rat race

[hollow oasis]

LOOOOL

holy

shit

[dusty thistle]

That is something

[hollow oasis]

DAMN

what kind of movie is this????

[dusty thistle]

My question is how the hell did they find themselves in that situation in the first place. Wait actually no, I don't want that answered.

[hollow oasis]

miscommunication^(Yes)

[uneven field]

your two questions have the same answer and it's that it's a 2001 comedy film about a bunch of assholes competing for money

[hollow oasis]

oh

so like

pulp fiction-esque

[uneven field]

I haven't seen that

[dusty thistle]

Ok, that's a problem

[hollow oasis]

It's a Tarantino

[uneven field]

I don't like Quentin Tarantino

[hollow oasis]

valid

[dusty thistle]

You need to see that one. One of the best films ever made.

[uneven field]

I know, that's why I haven't seen it

[hollow oasis]

best Samuel L Jackson ever

[uneven field]

I'll live

[dusty thistle]

Frankly it deserved an Oscar... is what I would say if Shawshank wasn't made the same year

[uneven field]

I also haven't seen that

[dusty thistle]

Your 90s movie culture is severely lacking.

[hollow oasis]

wtf is the 90s

[uneven field]

not big on prison break movies

[dusty thistle]

It's not

It's more about friendship.

[uneven field]

no, I'm just into better 90s movies

it's not my genre

[hollow oasis]

https://youtu.be/GcOXdd6XEbg <---- This is basically Pulp Fiction

[dusty thistle]

Shawshank is the best one, and arguably the best movie ever made.

[hollow oasis]

this movie is weird now that I think about it

... that pawn shop

[dusty thistle]

It's beautiful though. Wonderful story.

[dusty thistle]

That is admittedly an odd point.

[uneven field]

the word arguably is doing some heavy lifting

[dusty thistle]

Well, it's impossible determine best one for certain, but I think it is.

[uneven field]

I'd probably disagree if I saw it

[dusty thistle]

I promise you, it's not a prison break movie. It's set in a prison, but it's not a prison break movie.

If you don't want to watch it, it's fine. But I do genuinely want to shill my favorite movie.

[uneven field]

I also don't like the google synopsis, so

bummer

[dusty thistle]

You need to see the actual movie. Trust me.

[uneven field]

see I hear that about so many movies and I don't have the time to watch one billion movies

and when I do cave to that, the movie is usually like, decent at best

it's not my genre, I'm not going to care for it

[dusty thistle]

It's interesting, 1994 had three timeless classics come out of it

Shawshank, Pulp Fiction, and Forrest Gump

[uneven field]

not that I give a fuck about it either, but I'm pretty sure some people would take issue with you not mentioning the lion king

[dusty thistle]

That was 1994?

[uneven field]

yes

[dusty thistle]

I stand corrected, 4 timeless classics

[uneven field]

and little women

[dusty thistle]

You know what, 1994 was just a good year for movies

[uneven field]

oh, and Leon? agh

[uneven field]

I'm going down the list and this is the only one I really care about in any direction

I have very mixed feelings about Leon

mostly because the person that I watched it because of is...

there is no polite, concise, and easy way to finish that sentence

I watched it and it was interesting to watch, I like media that makes me uncomfortable don't get me wrong but it made me uncomfortable in ways that I don't appreciate

like, not in a "I'm uncomfortable because this movie is meant to disturb you by exploring this topic" kind of way, in a "that's certainly a very interesting writing choice to do that" kind of way

now 1995 had Jumanji, that was a good movie

[uneven field]

the very first time I open youtube after this conversation I get an ad with Ben Stiller in it LMAO

[modern plume]

As in why the family is driving H****r's car? Too bad, gonna tell you anyway.

The father of the family was invited as one of the participants to a race where a bunch of rich people are betting which participant will win the race and claim the millions of dollars. The father roped his family pretty much against their wills into going along with the race; to appease the daughter, he agreed for a stop to a Barbie Museum during the trip, only it turned out to be a museum honoring Klaus Barbie, a N**i. While they were there, other competitors sabotaged the family's car, so to continue in the race the family steals the car at the museum, ending up driving that monstrosity.

The bikers are otherwise completely unrelated to the race, and just happened to be there when the father gave one the middle finger and horribly miscommunicated.

[uneven field]

truly a wild movie

[sinful ingot]

Imp: 44
Drunk: 33
Poisoner: 26
Fortune_Teller: 24

Those are also my top 1 to top 4

But it is also only ending characters

[tough silo]

Fortune Teller, Cannibal, Amnesiac, Imp, Monk, Witch, and Ogreeeeee

Thats as far as i remenber my most pulled characters

[next vault]

I pull the Chambermaid and Grandma a lot in BMR

[vale oxide]

A little late but thanks

[barren sun]

Shadow (Minion): A player (even if drunk or poisoned) has all outsider abilities. You know who. [-0 to -1 Outsider]
Lightness is but the mere absence of Dark
Technically all you know characters are you start knowing

Wow, y'all yapped a lot more than usual; anyone gonna take today's question?

[fiery sleet]

2/7: Create a character that pairs with an existing character, like the Huntsman does with the Damsel

(this has probably been done before but idk, and we're apparently in our homebrew arc)

[dusty thistle]

Steward-ard (Townsfolk): You start knowing the Steward. [+the Steward]

[fiery sleet]

Village Dumbass (Outsider):

You have the Village Idiot's ability. 1 Village Idiot becomes evil. [+Village Idiot]

[junior knot]

how many village idiots?

[fiery sleet]

up to 3

as normal

[junior knot]

Squire (Townsfolk): The Demon cannot change players. [+ the Knight]

or should this be non-demons cannot become the Demon

[dusty thistle]

Deckhand (Outsider) The Sailor might survive execution while drunk [+the Sailor]

[junior knot]

the sailor is now an outsider

too

[fiery sleet]

Jester (Outsider)

[+Fool]

[junior knot]

The Don (Demon): EN*CAP, they die. Outsiders that are "mad" about being outsiders might be executed. [+ the Godfather].

[hollow oasis]

this is a TF

and makes fool a TF

literally only because it confs the fool

[fiery sleet]

Ringleader (Minion):

If an Outsider died today, choose a player tonight: they die. [-1 or +1 Outsider. All Outsiders are Mutants]

[fiery sleet]

I originally had it randomly poison the fool, but I just wanted to do a lil slandering

[hollow oasis]

hey woah

Fool is an outsider

[dusty thistle]

Geist (Demon) EN*CAP, they die. All minions have the Wraith ability, in addition to their own.

[hollow oasis]

but you're confirming the bastard so it isn't

[coarse fern]

This type of homebrew daily prompt thing exists already btw

https://discord.com/channels/569683781800296501/1176132734150787093

Just so y’all know

[tough silo]

Nurse: When an outsiders ability activates you learn who it affects [there are "when you die" outsiders in play]

[barren sun]

Baroness (Minion): There are even more outsiders in-play. [+2 Outsiders. +Baron]

[fallow rapids]

what i‘m learning is that some of y‘all aren’t homebrewers

[tough silo]

Yeah

[fallow rapids]

Nimrod (Townsfolk)

Other players might register as Outsiders. [+the Huntsman]

[dusty thistle]

Outsider (Outsider):
You are an outsider [+1 Evil Minion]

[junior knot]

AA (TF): Once per game, choose a player: the Drunk, if chosen, becomes the role they think they are. [+ the Drunk].

[uneven field]

but what if in secret thing

[supple dirge]

2/8 If you had to make another secret channel for daily prompts what would it be about?

[warped urchin]

Daily affirmations we should give to lil monsta about how cute they are

[uneven field]

I think we've peaked at secret thing honestly

[versed junco]

Imagine a cube, perfectly spherical.
Inside are two squires, waiting for their knights to return from their crusade.
To the left of the cube, the knights have been trampled to death by horses.
Not their horses. Other horses.
Above the cube sits the Green Zone, where nothing happens, unless you get past The Pendulum. The Pendulum. The Pendulum.
Beneath the cube is the court of honour, where gluttony is ruled upon and deemed repetitive. This is where the squires will go once they realize the truth.
The truth is what all things want to hide from.

it'd be sorta like that

[acoustic chasm]

@fiery sleet

[fiery sleet]

hello autumn

[acoustic chasm]

Hi

I have now learnt my lesson

Never put my phone in my pocket

It will do stupid things

Like this

[next vault]

huh

[fiery sleet]

You even mis-ping me when you aren't trying to 😭

[acoustic chasm]

Pff

[next vault]

you see, wrendel ping was misregistering due to the masque

[acoustic chasm]

Ah of course of course

[lost thistle]

its because of The Pendulum

[fiery sleet]

Call me the Pendulum the way I swing both ways

[tough silo]

Savant information repository

[finite wigeon]

Rating every botc character based on attractiveness until I finish

UNTIL I FINISH RATING THEM ALL, YOU VILLAINS

[barren sun]

Program some kind of software / bot that calculates a ranking of all characters based on a popularity poll from most to least liked by the community, that also allowed updating the ranking every time someone would change their answer

[low umbra]

That sounds more like a database thing than a secret thing. Would be interesting to see people’s opinions though

[supple dirge]

Once its done we can make the perfect custom script with all the characters people like and none that they don't like.

[next vault]

honestly

it'd be cool to see a poll like that

every tf/outsider/minion/demon ranked

[low umbra]

Didn’t NRB try to do that and it’s a rather abysmal script?

[versed junco]

Isn't that just this https://clockfaceoff.com/global

[low umbra]

I mean one thing with Clocktower is that everything is so highly contextual so a character in a vacuum has very little inherent quality?

Like, obv a character can’t be fully in a vacuum cause the near-vacuum is the rest of all characters released, but it’s little enough context compared to how players actually interact with them that the two don’t translate at all

[valid garden]

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/720010349587202200/1394817463148875787/VacuumsSuck.gif

[low umbra]

Thats actually so funny

[valid garden]

Thank Luis lol

He made most of these

[lucid crag]

all of them

[lucid crag]

how is this an outsider, this is just stronger bountyhunter lol

[fiery sleet]

2/9: Tell me about a botc character whose personality and/or appearance you headcanon differently from what's obvious/conventional

[junior knot]

@uneven field this has you written all over it

[uneven field]

wizard I swear

your shared delusion is neither obvious nor conventional

[fiery sleet]

I like to imagine as a very well-dressed businessman in a suit and tie, who then unhinges its jaw and stretches its neck like a slinky to devour someone whole while they're still standing

[uneven field]

cooking

I imagine shabaloth a big lovecraftian dog

I imagine many of the demons as some flavour of depressed twink

zombuul is specifically transmasc in my headcanon

vigormortis listens to radiohead

[junior knot]

typhon is a bulls skull floating in like a DnD gelatinous cube

[uneven field]

typhon is dario agger

[barren sun]

Po is actually a human; it is society who made him a demon.

[barren sun]

This is actually the question I had prepared for tomorrow lol

[tough silo]

Guys its an ST evil team winrate a reflection of how good an ST is?

[uneven field]

?? a panel of Dario Agger?

[uneven field]

if evil is winning a suspiciously high or low amount it may be an indication of bad STing

[next vault]

I imagine Vigormortis as a Katrina-like skeleton

[dusty thistle]

The shabaloth has very good table manners.

Either that or "clean" assassin stabs look like the victim was eaten alive.

[craggy hearth]

I remember when this was a script 😔

[craggy hearth]

mutant is a normal human and mass hysteria happens or smth like that 😔

[grizzled marsh]

Librarian is a geek during the 90s
Mutant is trans, town is transphobic
The gossip's gossips are reponsible for 80% of the suicides in this town (the remaining 20% being the gambler)
Mezepheles is blackmailing

[dusty thistle]

The gambler canonically gets whacked by the mafia btw. So that means that the gossip is actually responsible for more.

[modern plume]

The Mastermind takes care of birds and is an avid amateur ornithologist.

[hollow oasis]

Possibly intentional if that’s a common occurrence

[dense moat]

One I borrowed from someone else (Temporary I think?)

Evil Twin is not a sibling. It’s an eldritch shapeshifter who is bound to someone. Where the original dies, that allows it to fully manifest

Tho my closest “original” one is still that the Leviathan who actually votes and plays the game isn’t the giant fish. It’s the person summoning that creature

But that’s a bit more conventional

[hollow oasis]

The savant is simply really good at racing their grandma around in a wheelchair

[uneven field]

mutant is just a transfem who is double jointed

[uneven field]

canonically?? source???

[uneven field]

the politician is not right wing!

or like, not overtly

she's an annoying both-sides centrist liberal

[fallow rapids]

i‘m at least 3 of those things

i‘ll get better soon

[uneven field]

three between she, annoying, centrist, and liberal?

I don't know what your involvement in politics is, but for the record, I mean the kind of centrist that is actively entrenched within electoral politics and not the guys at home who don't really gravitate towards a side

[fallow rapids]

oh those people

yeah those people suck

i self identify as she, annoying, centrist, and liberal actually but “both-sides” gives me a staunch grimace

[uneven field]

I mean Bari Weiss

[fallow rapids]

who on earth is bari weiss

[uneven field]

stay uninformed, you're good

[fallow rapids]

understood 🫡

[uneven field]

or like, Keir Starmer

[barren sun]

Yes, exactly.

[fallow rapids]

suspiciously specific

[barren sun]

I couldn't think of any answers to that daily question but I also think the Leviathan player is the Summoner, and the Leviathan is awakening from the depths of the sea, and will we awaken early by a dark ritual this player performs on the second good executee

Any other characters, I think I just imagine them as most people do

[10/2] Summon into the chat a famous media character (real or not) that is a copy paste of a BOTC character

https://tenor.com/view/squidward-meme-looking-out-the-window-sad-missing-out-sad-squidward-gif-5401562831942688207

[tough silo]

[uneven field]

Dario Agger

[fiery sleet]

I 100% agree with the leviathan one

Leviathan is a Great Old One who kills everyone the instant it shows up. It doesn't kill at night because it isn't here yet. Your only hope is to kill its summoner without spilling so much blood that it will awaken prematurely.

[uneven field]

The ever-lovin' blue-eyed Thing

take your pick

[barren sun]

I thought about Schnitzel from Chowder

[uneven field]

when I draw golem I say it's clobberin' time before I punch

[barren sun]

https://tenor.com/view/shrek-go-gif-1439566740965012887

[fiery sleet]

https://tenor.com/view/breaking-bad-chemistry-experiment-scientific-walter-white-gif-17820266

[dusty thistle]

Just going to take the low-hanging fruit...

[zenith lotus]

hey look, its the marionette

[dusty thistle]

No, they aren't pictured.

[zenith lotus]

smh they're right there

[dusty thistle]

No, Moe Greene is the marionette. Can't find a picture of them

Here we go

[dry sluice]

Maria Ushiromiya from Umineko is the Atheist.

It's a murder mystery visual novel. When members of Maria's family are murdered one after another, Maria insists that there is no culprit; this isn't a logical mystery; everything that happens is the work of a powerful witch; and everything will be okay as long as everyone believes that.

[cold veldt]

omg umineko

ever since reading it I’ve thought like “can I make a homebrew botc character inspired by umineko” but you just can’t do better than atheist at capturing the vibe

[dry sluice]

yessss
I'm trying to make a sequence of Umineko-flavor BoTC puzzles themed around (1) an Atheist claim in every game and (2) the solution has something weird happening, like explaining 3 successful Virgin procs

But idk if they'll ever be public

[fiery sleet]

does boffin-virgin on LM passing around the baby create new instances of the virgin ability?

[cold veldt]

i've been working on somewhat of an opposite thing actually, a BOTC-flavour Umineko puzzle. i haven't made much progress on it lately though. hopefully i get it done one day

[dry sluice]

that's extremely cool
needless to say I'm very excited, if you ever want a playtester or anything
(but I'm currently on chapter 6 of Umineko so I don't want spoilers)

[barren sun]

Isn't that like the complete opposite?

[barren sun]

Yes, but you might not wanna give Virgin every time the babysitter changes or it will be obvious what's happening

[fiery sleet]

wait does boffin on LM give different abilities every time?

[barren sun]

Yep.

[fiery sleet]

wow

[barren sun]

https://tenor.com/view/virgin-mary-mother-of-god-gif-12306527

[dry sluice]

Flavorwise it's the opposite of being an atheist, yeah. But mechanics-wise it's totally a match. Actually, I never understood why the BoTC character who believes that everything is the work of an all-powerful god is called the "atheist."

[barren sun]

Cause it allegedly is all an illusion/trick/false created by the towns local Storyteller, who's gone mad and started killing everyone and faking his own death

[dusty thistle]

If anyone knows what this is from, I will be incredibly surprised and impressed.

[fiery sleet]

Looks like sonic

[versed junco]

Ace Attorney Apollo Justice spoilers || ||

[low umbra]

RAW yes

I like my RAF ruling where how I’m ruling the LM/Boffin interaction depends on the game. Sometimes it’s a single persistent ability, sometimes it’s a new instance of an ability each time the babysitter changes

This isn’t announced or anything, but explained if theres a bunch of new players etc

[low umbra]

The cybrex is the kazali? Hmmm

I can see it ig

[valid garden]

It can be a single persistent one (kinda)

[dusty thistle]

Well it's the Contingency actually, but I'm shocked you know the Cybrex in the first place.

[low umbra]

Yeah I haven’t played the game in like 4 years lmao

But yeah you’re right

I technically played 3.14 for a while but 4.0 has meant my favourite mod hasn’t been updated so I’ve stopped playing entirely

[dusty thistle]

I'm stuck on console.

So I'm still in 3.14

[low umbra]

Rip on both fronts, no mods, nor 4.x

4.x is better vanilla than 3.14 imo

[dusty thistle]

Well I wouldn't know, but it's cool to see someone else who actually plays Stellaris.

[low umbra]

But yeah the more I think about the Contingency the more it aligns with the Kazali (though tbf 90% of the time they fail to do actual assimilation, so a Driven Assimilator would 100% be more fitting)

[dusty thistle]

I was mostly thinking about the Ghost Signal, and how it messes with synths, sapient combat computers, and the Caretakers.

[low umbra]

Yeah exactly

[dusty thistle]

Yeah, assimilator would probably be better. But then again, I feel the one that anyone would know would be Cetana, and she's definitely not like the kazali.

Kazali only hijacks few and then stops, so it actually does fit the Contingency now that I think about it. They grab a few allies then kill everyone.

[low umbra]

Yeah. Now re-reading ghost signal stuff, it isn’t assimilation of entire planets but that’s just more fitting if anything cause it’s a fraction of the planet but definitely enough to cause huge infrastructural issues

[barren sun]

https://tenor.com/view/ty-thank-you-alice-in-wonderland-gif-26832236

[hollow oasis]

[2/11] Pick an outsider: what are they doing when they get fang gu jumped to?

[supple dirge]

Mutant - normal townsfolk things like walking around town and being normal

[modern plume]

Lunatic: Stalking the Fang Gu, thinking they were gonna jump to them...
The two may have been chasing each other's footsteps for half the night.

[junior knot]

https://tenor.com/view/playing-on-the-mirror-viralhog-who-are-you-curious-touch-gif-18273645

[barren sun]

embraces it

[fiery sleet]

punches the fang gu, only for the physical contact to allow the FG to begin the possession

[barren sun]

doing her makeup; then saw a strange fog from behind her through the mirror and it was too late

[next vault]

They were serving the Fang Gu and the Fang Gu asked them to jump to which the Butler replied "Of course, master"

[fiery sleet]

slips on a banana peel and falls into a comically obvious pit trap, where they perfectly land in the middle of the fang gu's pentagram chamber at the exact moment they were trying to kill someone else

[next vault]

died before being jumped

[fiery sleet]

just needed to be bribed with a new yacht, and they agreed to the jump immediately

[versed junco]

"Boss please"
"It's too much pressure Boss"
"BOSS-"

[dusty thistle]

Their friend.

[pastel prism]

Draws more inverted pentagrams all over their house to try to make themselves register as a Minion or Demon and die instead of get jumped (it doesn't work) because they are already too suspicious to succeed as the demon

[barren sun]

Is genuinely terrified and scared of becoming an evil being so starts begging for their death instead and letting them ascend to the Heavens

[analog idol]

The ogre has an emotional crisis over betraying their friend :,(

[keen crescent]

alternatively, the ogre gets to become their friend :)

[dense moat]

Beating up the Seamstress with their bare hands

[fallow rapids]

Dying to the confused Fang Gu.

[versed junco]

The implication that people aren't able to use their abilities when they choose the goon because they're drunk but because the goon starts beating their ass

"YOU'RE THE NIGHTWATCHMAN? WATCH MY FIST HITTING YOUR FACE"

[modern plume]

The poor Butler, still having to do their job after getting their ass beat. 😭

[versed junco]

Feck it
[12/2]
How would the Goon react to X character visiting them in the night?

[warped urchin]

Goon works with godfather to take care of business

[valid garden]

DA gives them a lengthy contract. Goon decides 'It's full of big words, so it must be good' and signs it without reading

[dusty thistle]

The goon tries the normal thing where he fights the attacker. Unfortunately, while the goon is strong, he's not better than a trained assassin, who gets one good stab in the back, killing the goon instantly.

[modern plume]

Goon sees the Ravenkeeper: "OH GOD, A GHOST!!"
Somehow manages to beat a ghost's ass??

[fiery sleet]

The Goon manages to drink the Sailor under the table, by pretending to drink and then pouring it on the floor. Luckily the increasingly inebriated Sailor doesn't notice, but the Innkeeper gives the Goon a lifetime ban.

[valid garden]

Not a ghost, a raven

The ravenkeeper sends their messenger ravens after someone

[fiery sleet]

Why don't they do that while alive? Are they stupid?

[valid garden]

SO I imagine the goon getting in a fight with a cat-sized bird

[modern plume]

gerryjunior's prompt specifies the character visiting. For Ravenkeeper then, this would be the Ravenkeeper rather than their raven.

[valid garden]

I assumed it was 'visit' as in 'being chosen by' c.f. ToS

[modern plume]

That said, it'd be funny for the Goon to just grab a messenger raven for no reason and proceed to go out drinking with it

[fallow rapids]

“Dear, I need you to clean your room.” “nooooooo o ”

[finite wigeon]

[2/12] -- Ravenswood Bluff is robbing a bank. Who's doing what?

[uneven field]

we have a question today ice

[fiery sleet]

Da goon

[uneven field]

picks , is ready to do some complicated trapeze bullshit, runs up to and plants a hand firmly on their shoulder, looks them square in the eyes and says "No."

[finite wigeon]

Mike, tear down me

and are a buddy cop duo kinda deal. The Goon doesn't want the Ogre around, but can't really stop the Ogre from sticking by their side anyway

[pastel prism]

i wonder why the Goon becomes the alignment of the guy they beat the shit out of

[modern plume]

Respect.

[dense moat]

The person they beat up pays them to stop and join the team

But phones don’t exist, so if you wanna pay the Goon, you gotta approach them

And that means getting beat up

[dense moat]

Comes to attack but the Goon gets into an epic wrestling match and pins the Lycan, causing them to go unconscious early and turn back human

[pastel prism]

the Goon after they get brutally murdered by the Assassin (they were also given money so they must help evil as a ghost):

[fiery sleet]

I think that instead of making people drunk, the goon should introduce a new status condition called "injured" that does the same thing. Just for flavor (and to make people say droinjured)

[versed junco]

'Concussed'

[fiery sleet]

(Goon voice) Ain't concussin' the kinda music dey make from da drums

[versed junco]

https://tenor.com/view/metal-gear-rising-raiden-senator-armstrong-punching-indomitable-gif-14166479420035208375

[barren sun]

Hey! You! Whatcha lookin' at?
*Dead stare
'm takin' to ya! Ya deaf?
*Silence
Ya think ya funny? C'me here, imma teach ya something. *prepares his fists
30 seconds later, wipes off the blood of their blade with the goon's cold to the touch face, specifically the moustache, and leaves without a word.

[supple dirge]

'hey heard you might need some protection'
'I don't need nothing from nobody bub, but tell your friends I got your back now you seem like a cool guy'

[fiery sleet]

"Reality is an opinion. My opinion."
(fully immune to the cerenovus on account of having 0 undamaged brain cells) "Aw yeah dat sounds right, let's go boss"

[versed junco]

the goon's just a jamboree buddy from mario party

the second someone new shows up they're best friends now

[keen crescent]

"Wanna go gamblin'?"
"So long as I can be the house."

Alternatively, "Come on over to the winning side!"
"I have commitment issues"

[uneven field]

call that Trouble Committing

[next vault]

14/2 Send BOTC inspired Valentines

[supple dirge]

My wish already came true when I met you

[keen crescent]

Not mine, but someone posted a bunch of good ones on the subreddit a few days back. https://www.reddit.com/r/BloodOnTheClocktower/comments/1r20f59/made_a_bunch_of_blood_on_the_clocktower/

for something original,
I'd die to be with you.

[fast anchor]

my set from last year

[keen crescent]

the djinn 💀

the widow 💀

[barren sun]

is a great fan of the Fierro Golpeador de Parejas Felices.

I'd never vote on you and be privately shamed at night by the ST :3

Id beg the St to make you my twin

I'd always execute the other neighbour

[versed junco]

The Argentinian Piledriver of love ❤️

[next vault]

Fernanfloo refference? In 2026?

[barren sun]

German Garmendia lol

[next vault]

same vibes

[lucid crag]

hmm...

Smash.

[fiery sleet]

I could never forget you

[dusty thistle]

I'd like you to jump on you.

For something a bit less creepy (granted fang gu is a demon) We're cut from the same cloth.

[acoustic chasm]

Me and you are a yes

[next vault]

Sorry but that just sounds like you're evil because the Seamstress cannot choose itself

I saw you as my Sweetheart

[fiery sleet]

You'll always be my King

[versed junco]

You were a mistake I made intentionally ❤️

[fiery sleet]

Everyone knows we're on the same team

[dusty thistle]

Eww, no. You're like 10 years old.

[fiery sleet]

Who's to say the king isn't?

[dusty thistle]

We're family here.

[fiery sleet]

Shouldn't that be

[dusty thistle]

No, no, this is what your boss gives you on Valentine's.

Godfather is strictly business.

[fallow rapids]

I’d love to be you

[fallow rapids]

(requires your death)

I’d love to be you

[dusty thistle]

I've bet on you.

(they're dead)

[fiery sleet]

You have shown me the secrets of the Council of the Purple Flame. We have lain together in fire and in lust and in beastly commune, and I am forever your servant. But tonight, my dear, I am your master.

[dusty thistle]

Happy Valentine's Day. Drink the love potion or I'll kill you.

[dry sluice]

The safeword is "wildebeest."

I love you so much! I love you, I love you, I love you!

[barren sun]

I'm pretty sure England had an 8-yeat-old as a King somewhen in history

[modern plume]

Henry VI was King from 1422 to 1461 (and 1470 to 1471). He was born on December 6th, 1421, and became king at 9 months old.

[fiery sleet]

2/15 Send BOTC inspired breakup texts

"It's like I don't even know you anymore"

[tough silo]

"Im going to break madness. i have never loved you"

[fiery sleet]

"Nuffin personal, see, I just founda new boss and I think we really got dat special connection"

"..." (just ghosts you)

[barren sun]

I'm sorry guys, but I have to rat you out

[shrewd cloud]

I’m choosing someone else, sorry

[acoustic chasm]

I just can't carry on pretending to be someone else.

[versed junco]

d-doin your mom d-d-doin your mom

[fiery sleet]

I'm correcting my mistake

[supple dirge]

I just don't believe we're going to work out

[fiery sleet]

you always saw me as a demon

I'm not saving you anymore

[finite wigeon]

I don't have faith in you anymore.

[dense moat]

I found someone more important to me

[uneven field]

trauma dumping on main let's gooo

[dense moat]

you dated the Dreamer?

[uneven field]

this person is the artist

[dense moat]

huh, i thought that was you doing the wall of text

[uneven field]

I am the wall of text

the person I texted it to was the artist

I was inspired to write that by them (and their awful horrible shitty behaviour)

[dense moat]

i thought the point is that the person who sends the text is the botc character, not the reciever

but i guess I interpreted it differently than you did?

[uneven field]

I saw "something something breakup texts," got a flashback, and went digging through my old texts, I wasn't thinking about it too hard

[dense moat]

okii

[uneven field]

and Laurie is someone I very neatly associate with the word "artist" so it fits

[dusty thistle]

I'm dumping you.

[severe raven]

It's like you're a different person from when I met you

[dusty thistle]

I just feel like I can't trust you.

I don't think we can go any farther with this. This isn't a healthy enviroment for you. It wouldn't be one for our children.

[supple dirge]

I'm leaving and taking the baby with me

[finite wigeon]

"It's like I don't even know you anymore"

[pastel prism]

looks like someone has amnesia

[versed junco]

"Please stop messaging me"

[fiery sleet]

"I can't put up with your lies every day"

[dusty thistle]

[2/16] I have come into the head canon that the Al Hadikhia plays the pipe organ. What instruments do other characters play?

[shrewd cloud]

Banjo

[hollow oasis]

their throat

The honorable judge The phonograph

[fallow rapids]

the Choirboy

[fiery sleet]

the lyre

[modern plume]

Is Mayonnaise an instrument?

[tough silo]

no village mayonnaise its not an instrument

[modern plume]

... Raises hand

[tough silo]

horseradish its not an instrument either.

[modern plume]

... Lowers hand

[modern plume]

Also plays an organ!

[zenith lotus]

also plays an organ

[modern plume]

Other people (in spontaneous Disney musical numbers)

Beethoven.

[dense moat]

Banjo

airhorn (in public)

i'd also accept kazoo for Goblin

[modern plume]

(in the middle of the night)

[dense moat]

Drums

Forces someone else to play

[fiery sleet]

your mom

[modern plume]

(Has standards and requires someone Good to play it)

[dense moat]

who plays piano, im wondering?

[modern plume]

[dense moat]

like a regular non-organ piano

true

Is an entire orchestra

(theres probably more Legions who dont come to Ravenswoord who form a full one)

[fiery sleet]

is a capella

[dense moat]

actually yag might do different vocals

[fiery sleet]

yag does that thing where you make non-vocal sounds using your voice

[dense moat]

Uses AI to make songs

[modern plume]

Kazali seems like the kind of person to really want to form a band.

[dense moat]

true

who's a lazy character...

[modern plume]

Lord of Typhon also wants to form a band, and is real lazy about who they invite

[hollow oasis]

it's simple really

[dense moat]

Plays saxaphone to their own cases

[hollow oasis]

zombuul

[dense moat]

too lazy to use a computer

[hollow oasis]

zombuul uses ai

[hollow oasis]

he asked someone to do it for him

[dense moat]

fair

[hollow oasis]

A soundboard

[dense moat]

the wolf howls like in this

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FJgRlbjzsrs

[barren sun]

and Tambourine

doesn't like music

Maracas

[uneven field]

his page-turner

[finite wigeon]

Synthesizer

[fiery sleet]

acoustic guitar

[lost thistle]

some sort of…
banjo kazoo.. ie…

[dry quiver]

its okay

[keen crescent]

otamatone.

[fallow rapids]

[Feb 17]
Very carefully, choose two opposing characters.
||Who’d win in a rap battle?||

[versed junco]

and evil
||gossip's fecking screwed||

[fiery sleet]

||I don't know who's winning, but my ears are definitely losing||

[versed junco]

||you'd be surprised the things that rhyme with 'mongering fear'||

[low umbra]

||’ow my ear’?||

[fast anchor]

good bureaucrat evil thief
||coughing baby vs hydrogen bomb||

[versed junco]

||...'elongating rear'||

[hollow oasis]

+
||Hydrogen baby vs Coughing bomb… wtf they’re on cocaine||

[versed junco]

and evil
||King K. Rool's theme from Smash Ultimate vs The Complete Works Of Smash Mouth||

[fast anchor]

||gang-plank galleon is a bop, though, I think the King has this one||

[versed junco]

||oh yeah it's not close||

||it's preformed by the Choirboy||

[pseudo fulcrum]

||I feel like Gossip is 100% winning this, no?||

||You have so many goon jokes to make||

||and they know and can use all the rumours||

[fiery sleet]

||also "gooner" and "rumor" rhyme, goon isn't coming back from this||

[versed junco]

||I just think goon has that Rhymezone in em||

||Though I did not consider the gooning tech from Gossip||

[heavy sundial]

||fearmonger token is kinda giving eminem's worst freestyle||

[junior knot]

|| also since goons are just henchmen, or in other words minions, you can also make yellow tic tac jokes ||

[severe raven]

||the former forgets what rap is; the latter cheats and is disqualified||

[dense moat]

and
||Politician would throw and recieve a generous donation from Mez. Then she'd take the word and get Mez arrested for illegal donations while she keeps the money||

[barren sun]

|| , not because he's better, but because the audience/jury are scared of execution. Queen of hearts croquet situation is what I'm thinking||

[finite wigeon]

and
||Legion has better crowd work, but Heretic...||

[fiery sleet]

||Legion completely rolls Heretic in the rap battle itself. However, due to the Heretic's ability, whoever wins, loses & whoever loses, wins.||

[low umbra]

||I feel like heretic could do well if they chose to, but they’d just refuse to||

[karmic rose]

2/18: Stealing an old one! Choose two characters, and jinx them in a way that is subtly bad.

[warped urchin]

Is this the part where people just write jinxes that already exist they don't like

[modern plume]

No, those are not subtly bad.

[modern plume]

So, a jinx where at first it sounds interesting and good... until you think about it for a second and realize a major problem?

[karmic rose]

yep!

[dusty thistle]

x If the plague doctor dies and the storyteller would gain the baron ability, two players become outsiders.

[karmic rose]

If the Leviathan and the Mayor are alive on day 5 & no execution occurs, good wins.

This one is official but very sad for Evil Mayors -- the Mayor ability should, imo, always be a "your team wins" rather than a "good wins"

[hollow oasis]

If good solves an evil mayor that’s impressive

[dusty thistle]

This jinx is good on Spin Doctoring specifically since it has drunk. Without it, you have a problem of bluffability.

[modern plume]

If the Damsel is chosen by the Summoner, the Huntsman becomes the Demon instead

"Oh hey, cool, you aren't left with Huntsman with no Damsel. That's better and more fair, right? Right?"

[dusty thistle]

Ah

[hollow oasis]

Uh

Oh

[dusty thistle]

Huh

I see

[hollow oasis]

That’s

Devious

[modern plume]

Amy asked for subtle

[hollow oasis]

They did

[modern plume]

[hollow oasis]

No it’s really good at that

[dusty thistle]

x A new instance of the lleech ability must choose the original lleech's host.

Hey guys! We fixed the unsolvable lleech host problem!

[junior knot]

X The typhon doesnot have to be in the center of the line, and can be added to neighbor the magician

[dusty thistle]

eye twitches

[junior knot]

x The lycanthrope instead picks a player who cannot die tonight if good.

[dusty thistle]

So aside from the first problem, you're a worse monk?

[junior knot]

ish?

[karmic rose]

the monk, famously a useful role in al-had games

[sinful onyx]

monk

[junior knot]

i cannot tell if this is sarcasm

lol

[karmic rose]

(it is)

[junior knot]

bc the target can choose live?

[karmic rose]

it can turn a triple kill into a double kill, but

[warped urchin]

Doesn't matter what the monk protected player picks, they are living regardless

[junior knot]

can also turn a single kill into a double kill of the other picks

[karmic rose]

yeah, you want to have a choice in Al-Had games

[sinful onyx]

: If the butler becomes an evil Fang gu, they keep the butler ability.

[junior knot]

although there kinda should be a lycan/alhad jinx ngl

[karmic rose]

I suspect the jinx is called "make better scripts"

[dusty thistle]

x If the fool loses their first life to the al-hadikhia ability, they do not die but the al-had ability thinks they do.

[junior knot]

x /: The dreamer cannot see spycluse as a Townsfolk or Demon

x : If Yag kills during the day, it does not proc demonsbanes

[dusty thistle]

That's not bad

How is that bad?

[junior knot]

it makes them mechanically indistinguishable

[dusty thistle]

Sage and farmer shouldn't be on yag scripts anyway

[junior knot]

farmer is at night

you are thinking of banshee

[keen crescent]

why is that bad?

[modern plume]

-# Sage is fine if you're using it with 'Golden Border' tech

[warped urchin]

I love daytime banshee announcements

[karmic rose]

I mean... don't use the Yag to daykill bait roles?

[fallow rapids]

If the Storyteller would gain the Mezpheles ability, a Minion gains it and learns this.

:)

[dusty thistle]

That's also not bad.

[karmic rose]

oh that's awful LMAO

[fallow rapids]

lemon...

[dusty thistle]

I mean, SOI but not a huge issue

[junior knot]

also could be good minion ig?

but yeah not seeing it either

[karmic rose]

bonus midgame mez in Evil's hands is gonna be more evilsided than bonus midgame mez in the ST's hands

[junior knot]

eh you are already adding a bonus midgame mez

[dusty thistle]

That's true of practically every backloaded minion

[karmic rose]

yep!

[junior knot]

like ST has already decided to be evilsided

[dusty thistle]

Yeah it's mez, but it's not that bad

I think the real problem is that mez is on this script

[zenith lotus]

:
A vigorkilled Fearmonger may nominate.

trust

[dusty thistle]

That's not even that subtle.

[karmic rose]

/ - If the Demon dies to the Slayer (ending the game), play for one more day. If a player is then executed, their team loses.

[junior knot]

x : If the vigormortis kills the scarlet at night, when they die, a good player becomes an evil vigor

[keen crescent]

If the summoner picks the goon, the storyteller chooses who becomes the demon.

[karmic rose]

better than what we have ngl

[zenith lotus]

fair enough

[junior knot]

this is still better than the alternative

[fallow rapids]

If the Vizier forces the execution of the Saint and there weren’t enough votes to put the Saint on the block, the execution fails.

[junior knot]

make it banshee announce

[karmic rose]

it's funny tho

[keen crescent]

hmm wait no sorry I messed up

If the summoner picks the goon, the goon chooses who becomes the demon.

fixed

[junior knot]

better

[dusty thistle]

That's still better than what we have lol.

[junior knot]

but like 90% of the time they just choose themself

[karmic rose]

it's really funny how the solution to goon/summoner is to stormcatch the goon

[modern plume]

Doesn't specify that the Goon hasn't already been picked.
Still Good Goon just makes a dead player the demon.

[keen crescent]

nah like 90% of the time they pick literally anybody else, then beg to be turned good.

[junior knot]

its ok, they were making a zomb anyway

speaking of

[dusty thistle]

That is still better than what we have.

[fallow rapids]

The dead Fearmonger that still has their ability may nominate as many times as possible. Only the Fearmonger’s target may also nominate.

[junior knot]

x : A summoner may pick dead players to be a once-killed zombuul

[zenith lotus]

:
If the Cannibal eats the drunk VI, they are drunk.

[fallow rapids]

BISHOP!!!

YEAHHHHH

[dusty thistle]

What the OH. OH GOD

[karmic rose]

oh that's a classic

[dusty thistle]

That one is mean

[zenith lotus]

you'll notice the lack of a time limit

[keen crescent]

a vigorkilled evil twin registers as alive to its own ability.

[sinful onyx]

: The 1st player chosen by harpy is mad that the 2nd is evil & is not the boomdandy.

[junior knot]

x : a poisoner who selects a heretic becomes drunk, and learns this

[dusty thistle]

I don't think that's too bad, right? Oh. Oh, I see. I don't get it.

[karmic rose]

awful

[keen crescent]

dw I tweaked it to be better

[junior knot]

sorry did i violate the spirit?

[fallow rapids]

that’s not subtle at all

lmaooo

[junior knot]

whoops

i was trying to think of droison + heretic ones that were subtle

and failed miserably

bc the area seems rife with possibilities for this

[modern plume]

The Lleech host registers as the Demon

"Fixed it! That should clear up the issue"

[dusty thistle]

x A preached minion who is then vigor killed does not have its ability.

[keen crescent]

/ x : If a [widow/spy] is or has ever been in play, the heretic is poisoned

[sinful onyx]

what does this even do

[dusty thistle]

Take a long hard think on it.

[junior knot]

preacher dies

[karmic rose]

x - When the Shabaloth dies, the new Shabaloth must regurgitate their (the old Shabaloth's) most recent choice tonight.

[junior knot]

there is no...oh

that their is unclear

[keen crescent]

The scarlet woman is immediately told their yagababble phrase.

[junior knot]

tbf

[fallow rapids]

The Mastermind’s ability is only in affect when both the Demon and Evil Twin are dead.

[dusty thistle]

Not just that, but the minion never gets the ability back

[junior knot]

no yeah thats the part i was referencing

[keen crescent]

that's raw, no?

[modern plume]

||So Shabaloth basically wants to kill themself to be regurgitated and have two Shabs?||

[dusty thistle]

Oh dear.

[karmic rose]

exactly

that's it

[fallow rapids]

really pushing subtlety on this one

[keen crescent]

is it that it triggers off executing the evil twin?

[dusty thistle]

x The scarlet woman does not have their ability day five.

[keen crescent]

hm. I might need more explanation on some of these.

[modern plume]

Which ones?

I think we're not explaining some of them out loud (or using spoilers) to let people realize on their own.

[keen crescent]

fair lol

[sinful onyx]

: If the engineer makes a Kazali, minions become good not-in-play good characters & the kazali choose minions again.

[modern plume]

Since the question wants jinxes that sound initially good, but have a 'oh no..." realization to them

[junior knot]

x : Demons do not know marionettes if poppied

[keen crescent]

A demon with the fool ability loses their ability on the final day.

[dusty thistle]

changes them back

[junior knot]

i feel like this isn't subtle either

[modern plume]

||This becomes funny with LM. Congrats, you made Group Hug||

[keen crescent]

||I love it when nobody knows my alignment||

[dusty thistle]

||Honestly, not too bad period. You give the minions a hatter swap basically||

[junior knot]

x : Neither devils advocates can choose players chosen by a DA ability the night before

[sinful onyx]

: If the boomdandy explodes but no one dies today, the mayor's team wins.

[fallow rapids]

||this is bad in the way that you are severely incapabable of telling what happened as town||

[junior knot]

like mayors ever survive a boom

[sinful onyx]

You realize it's bad when you see it doesn't say "dies by pointing"