#The Vampire Farm - Prologue

1 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

vivid phoenix
#

At 1-page, it's hard to get a strong sense of what's going on or have solidly formed opinions about the work. The prose and the (small bit) of dialog were well written. It read quickly and was easy to follow.

I am also glad you avoided exposition -- if there's going to be too much context or too little, I'd rather have too little!

That said, I felt like there was too little context. and I found I was struggling to get a sense of where this was taking place. A room with bunk-beds (I think), so a group house? And Anne was a bit of a cipher. Is she a child? A young woman? She seemed scared and childlike (and had a 'little' body) but I wasn't sure.

Tom seemed undead (cold-lifeless-looking skin? Fangs on gray flesh) so I assumed this was the vampire farm and these were the vampires (but I wasn't sure).

Getting the level of mystery right in the opening of a story is a difficult thing, especially if the setting is unusual. It's going to mean explaining (dreaded exposition) or throwing novel information at the reader and trusting them to catch up.

I think throw-and-trust is best, but it risks being confusing and hurting reader engagement. I find that when I have to parse sentences very carefully for clues about who I am reading about, where they are, what's happening, why, etc. it takes me out of the emotion and immediacy of the story.

I think -- you can tell me if I got it right -- I was able to follow things correctly, but it didn't leave me with much of a sense of who Anne is or all that engaged with her fear.

On the other hand, your prose worked well and moved quickly. Despite not having much of a sense of the broader scene (I was imagining a somewhat rural group house) I felt like I could easily visualize the individual actions and personal responses.

All this is a LOT of feedback for a few paragraphs of story. I wasn't immediately gripped or emotionally engaged, but I wasn't turned off either. It's a beginning.

#

I also liked the title! A vampire farm, eh? Is that... a farm run by vampires? Do they sew and harvest only at night? Or is a farm where vampires are grown? Do they raise a crop of vampires each season and sell them at market? Are there large, industrial vampire farms that small family concerns have to compete with? Do they get vampire subsidies from the government?

I'm kind of joking here, but I was honestly intrigued and amused! It's a good title!

eternal nymph
#

Admittedly, the title is still changing because I am not happy with it

#

But thanks for the feedback, will think on how to best implement it

#

But yeah, the farm is run by vampires and it's a cattle farm with humans as the cattle

vivid phoenix
#

Got it. Nice and horrific!

eternal nymph
#

and yeah, this would be a small, free range farm with like space for around 24 to maybe 32 people

#

there are definitely more farm types Imma make reference to later, but they wont matter much to the main plot

#

admittedly, my main goal with the prologue was establish the main conflict, being Anne's instinctual fear of Tom

#

as for set the spooky tone, as I'll be ignoring that for act 1

vivid phoenix
#

Yeah, I mean, I think I got Anne-is-afraid, so that worked.

eternal nymph
#

yay

#

but yeah, will have to think on how to implement your advice

#

thanks again ^^

vivid phoenix
# eternal nymph thanks again ^^

Glad it was helpful -- just make sure to really read my caveat: I'm reacting to literally 1 page. Everything I wrote could be overturned on page 2. Honestly I do think it's good advice, but at this point I'd recommend writing more of the story versus spending a bunch of time on a prologue that is basically solid

eternal nymph
#

fair

#

I did write Act 1 already, tho it is currently being worked on to maybe help me write act 2