hearty hedge
Hi,
I've upgraded to Appwrite 1.5.2, and want to try out Appwrite Messaging with my SMTP server. I've tried Gmail SMTP relay and Mailersend.com, but both give me SMTP connect() failed. Which is kinda weird, because if I use the same credentials in the project settings in the SMTP tab, Appwrite sends out confirmation and sign-up emails just fine.
How can I debug this?
Kind regards,
Bas
tropic flicker
Hi,
I've upgraded to Appwrite 1.5.2, and want to try out Appwrite Messaging wit...
Is SMTP set up in the server .env, or just in the Project settings?
hearty hedge
Is SMTP set up in the server `.env`, or just in the Project settings?
in three locations, the environment variables (which work, Appwrite is sending out emails to admins), the project SMTP tab (which works, Appwrite is sending out emails to site user signups and such), and in Appwrite Messaging, which doesn't work with the error SMTP connect() failed. All settings are the same server, same credentials and same TLS settings. I've tried both Gmail and Mailersend, all works except Appwrite Messaging.
ionic fjord
in three locations, the environment variables (which work, Appwrite is sending o...
Any chance you can test without tls?
hearty hedge
I've tested it just now with a localhost nc -l 25, and it looks like it at least connects and sends SMTP commands. Looks like something with TLS. Might it be something to do with the worker container? How can I debug further?
ionic fjord
I've tested it just now with a localhost `nc -l 25`, and it looks like it at lea...
are you able to test SMTP provider with 25 through appwrite?
hearty hedge
yes, that seems to work. I am not able to actually test mail sending, as no sane SMTP provider without encryption exists, but it at least connects, which I guess is one step further than SMTP connect() failed
ionic fjord
yes, that seems to work. I am not able to actually test mail sending, as no sane...
i can suggest a patch...
this is the line you need to add: https://github.com/appwrite/appwrite/blob/33b4ee5c0f41b5919ae1dac1fb86572667062f29/src/Appwrite/Platform/Workers/Mails.php#L53
hearty hedge
Ok, let me try that out
hearty hedge
@ionic fjord just to be sure, which container do I exec into?
ionic fjord
<@462046107556511744> just to be sure, which container do I exec into?
Messaging worker
jovial sparrow
I did that. The mailing process does not fail directly now, however it does not complete either and hangs at processing, This is for both mailgun and my own smtp as well as googlemail smtp.
ebon kelp
Even I encountered issues via TLS, not sure if thats related.
misty brook
I'm also getting the SMTP connect() failed error. I don't see any logs in the worker-mails container.
Did anyone manage to resolve the issue?
jovial sparrow
Sadly not I followed the advice posted by Steven above and exchanged the lines of code. I found one solitary email in spam but could not for the life of me figure out why this worked
ionic fjord
Here's the issue for this: https://github.com/appwrite/appwrite/issues/7914. Please make sure to add a 👍🏼 on the issue.
jovial sparrow
Done! Thank you Steven
tropic flicker
Done! Thank you Steven
If your issue has been solved, you can mark this post as closed by adding "[SOLVED]" to the beginning of the title