#Was the ussr good debate
1 messages · Page 4 of 1
I have a lottttaaaa time
Yeah
Been a long time,show it again.
Also the ussr existed for like only 70 years that's an unfair comparison
I mean i'm sure you have a lot of free time in a gulag or a reeducation camp
Yeah
Im one of the few who isnât on it every second
Yeah
And i donât have it
Guantanamo bay is still running fyi
Thatâs an American problem
No it isn't, Taiwan was under a brutal dictatorship before it became a democracy, Japan was bombed into the ground, same with germany
Go outside and do what?
đ
And touch grass đ€Ł
wow, 1 prison against the hundreds of gulags
I'm not your mom to go tell you to play with the neighbor's kids
Both of them had space for scientific development,especially during war
Also why are you so focused on the USA? They aren't the only democracy in the world
again, BOMBED
wtf you mean had space
BRO IT'S 2023
Hell South Korea was a dictatorship till like the 80s
russia and china still have them too...
And we still have guantanamo bay
Okay???
Whataboutsim
What does a prison on cuba have to do with this?
Again, it's nothing compared to the crimes against humanity the USSR committed
^
No it isn't
He also denied the holodomor btw
1 prison in cuba vs hundreds if not thousands of camps
This is genocide denial
For every bad thing the USSR has done,America has done it 4 times over
Its the other way around genius
When did the USA run tanks into protesters?
Maybe
I don't think he even knows basic crimes against humanity
everywhere the USA intervened there was soviet intervention and again, the USA isn't the only democracy in the world
There's a big difference to running the gulag back then and shutting it down in the middle of the ussr life span to still having it running after directly acknowledging how bad it is
start simping for social democrats, not genocidal maniacs
The gulag is essential for the soviet union
Name all the soviet foreign interventions
They still had penal colonies
Afghanistan
The USA is not a democracy
Cap
but the soviets are?
The very fact that you don't have an FBI agent at your door right know proves you wrong
I don't see USSR corporations having bought politicians
It isn't, but it's a liberal democracy
Politician simp
Lobbyists are literally paid by corporations to lobby in their favor
You really trust politicians so much
no, they shot, jailed, murdered, coerced, squashed (literally) any oposition
MY GUY
THE SOVIETS WERE SHADY AS HELL
YOU CAN ASK THE DAMN GERMANS!!!
During what timelines
My brother in christ, do you prefer a makarov to the head or a bag of cash?
I don't think he's heard of the NKVD yet

Man the Soviets put a clock in the Presidents office
Either way the democracy is compromised
I just realized
but it still is there
I can't react on Paladin's message
I think he feels threatened by me
To do such censorship lol
Nope.
unlike in the soviet union, where it never existed in the first place
hey i can do a graph too
Wheel it up
đ€Ł
It's more like an aristocracy or something
Iâm afraid the graph has been denied by the council
What kind of graph is this bruh
Nah
It even comes complete with a volume setting đ
Rich people stop you from voting now?
The rich people who have intentions to hurt the working class for money control all politics
Yeah he's that stupid
do they throw coins at you when you vote for bernie?
The American vote doesn't mean shit
Representative Democratic and direct democratic
Kind of chooses the president but hey
He doesn't believe in freedom
If that was true, switzerland would be a massive gulag
He's that much of a smoothbrain
And then there's the electoral college
Not a bad idea
at least america has real elections
Yes
The elections is between drowning and burning to death
Sounds like a US problem
^
Yeah
Both presidential candidates are working against you
America was doing better than the USSR
So donât vote
^
then vote third party
Vote for the 3rd party
You are complaining about not having a choice even though you have one
Yeah the green party doesn't even get enough money to be acknowledged
then vote for them
make them relevant
Yeah that doesn't really change anything
because everyone has your mentality
Because nobody knows. They just think you're weird and move on
THEN VOTE FOR THEM
Sounds like a you problem
votes make you relevant
Yep
You're too afraid to be judged by society lol
^
And yet you want society to force shit on you
also since when are you green? the USSR was terrible for the environment
Bro you really are funny
If everyone in America had my mentality we'd have already overthrown the country
Because...every one was back then???
How are you gonna overturn 329,999,999 million people?
In what
No the Military would probably restore order, or a NATO coalition
^
Yeah
And in case you havenât noticed
I think you're just hiding your insecurities behind socialism, because that way you can at least force your ideals on other people through the guise of "For the betterment of humanity"
Our tanks got the uranium shit
You're pathetic, really
What milatry?

everyone in the country would be like me including the military
Nah
We call that Ingsoc
I'm not the one who thought of the scenario
Funny fantasies, such amazing copium
also you are going to use evil western military equipment? not pure and divine soviet tanks?
"Everyone should be just like me!"
Never gonna happen
Such childish banter
because debates are useless
A gun is a gun tbh
Donât matter
Honestly guys, we shouldn't take idiots this seriously
The guy said everyone is of my mentality
So you are willing to exploit the labour of swedish, canadian, british, french and israeli engineers? nice morality
I'm out of here, I see no more need to polish a smooth brain
And thatâs not the real world
Never gonna happen
I'm aware
yeah obviously
Same
They literally destroyed the Aral sea
Reason: Rule 1(Genocide Denial)
When did I deny genocide?
That's not an objection to the warning,just a question.
Also this video summaries my point extremely wellhttps://youtu.be/HVzgtRp_YtI
Peace, Land and Bread. This was the famous slogan promoted by Vladimir Lenin in the wake of the October revolution of 1917 in Russia - the Soviet world summed up in three words. Now contrast this with the slogan of the French bourgeois revolution of 1789 that proudly proclaimed Liberte, Egalite, Fraternite.
Notice any difference? If you ask me,...
Also now that I think about it Umberto might have committed genocide denial IIRC when talking about Vietnam
Don't put a reaction, just watch the video
Can we get a VAR on this(where)
What even is a VAR
It's wayyy up
đ€·ââïž
What genocide did he deny? Just curious
Holodomor
When did I deny holodomor
But yeah there easily was genocide in North Korea and Vietnam
What did the DPRK do?
It was about the Kulaks
Man doesnât answer me
He's talking about the south koreans/americans 
no i mean he thinks the south genocided the north
Its the other way
that's what i said
Either way both Koreas were brutal
true
Damn
I'm pretty sure he's trying to say the Americans committed genocide in NK
Thats fair then
Get their country FUBAR with bombs because they defended themselves
No,I mean America genocided the north
No,they invaded SK for doing cia led sneak attacks against Nk and then the USAF came in and literally went out of their way to kill (every) north Korean to the point where they also killed South Koreans because the entire campaign was a racist genocide
And even if they did start it that doesn't justify trying to kill every South Korean
Wait hold up
That's better

Anyway it's impossible to blame Nk for hating the west
That's genocide denial
Actually we can
Not denial because it never happened
Bc the entire commie block hated the west
There was no genocide, there's no proof of genocide
https://youtu.be/fE9MUwAbFQI there's literally a whole video
I NEED YOUR HELP! - PATREON: https://patreon.com/gdfofficial
CASHAPP: https://cash.app/$gdfofficial
PAYPAL: https://paypal.com/paypalme/gdfofficial
This channel relies on Donations and Patrons! Join my discord server where we can chat and talk about ideas for videos by joining my patreon! And if you have the means to do so please consider...
A questionable bombing campaign â genocide
Like are you racist or ignorant
QUESTIONABLE???
Genocide: the deliberate killing of a large number of people from a particular nation or ethnic group with the aim of destroying that nation or group
The US was not intentionally trying to kill every north Korean
Ah yes, Wikipedia
Seriously "questionable bombing"?
Bombing â genocide, the UK bombed Germany a ton during ww2, but it isn't genocide. Not saying it's OK for the US to do that, but it's not genocide
That's like calling
s -trafficking questionable intercourse
No it's not lol
Mass bombing of civilians to cripple the country is genocide
@keen wind yes it is.
You're actually racist..okay..wow
And you still haven't read the article or watched the video
Nope, it's not. It was not done with the aim of wiping out the entire population of North Korea
Genocide is when you intentionally try to wipe out an entire group of people
Yes it was.
Bombing your enemy is just war
It's sad, and killing civilians is a side affect of war
Do 300,000 NK citizens sound like the enemy? Does 300,000 deliberate civilian deaths sound like a side effect?
I'm pretty sure any adult,or even a 5 year old can distinguish a city and a military base
Or maybe you're one of those country bumpkins always complaining about "city slickers" and that's why you don't see it as genocide cause' it's urban bombings
Both sides lost similar amounts of Civilians during the war
If the US was committing genocide, the death toll should be much higher on the NK side
Unless both sides committed genocide
And? The USAF still went crazy
It still shows that it wasn't genocide, the US could have killed many more North Koreans if they wanted to actually commit genocide. I'm not excusing the civilian deaths the US did cause, but it wasn't genocide
They digged up 400,000 bombs in one city after the war ended even though the war Ended...
Also you cleary didn't watch the video,why is this?
That's usually how it goes, you find bombs after the war ends...
- 400k!!!
2 they literally planned and selected villages to bomb
I did, he basically uses some quotes and says that's proof of genocide
Do you have an attention deficit? He pulled up a whole interview of am official saying we destroyed 10-20% of NKs
You're ignoring my previous arguments
Which
.
Does that matter when the facts don't match it?
And if that's just in Pyongyang,think about the ones they dug up elsewhere
Remember,those bombs were meant to GO OFF
400,000 additional bombs meant to destroy Pyongyang and its people
300,000 north Korean civilians died, that's just 2.7% of NK's pre-war population
Attempted murder should still count
Where did you get this number? From NK?
Not to mention the number,despite of who claims it,adds up to the already existing bombings
Why would us commit genocide on koreans???
Racism
Racism??
It was the 50s in America,I'm not justifying btw
They did
So tye interveen on one side after invation starts
The south actually preformed cia lead sneak attacks before
And commit genocide on both sides
NK got bombed for defense of itself
For racism reasons
So basically North invaded
You can watch @hybrid iris
Why didnt they commit genocide before the war started than?
Who
"North Koreans claim 400,000 bombs were dropped on Pyongyang " the North Koreans CLAIM, their source for this article comes from the NK army and NK news. Of course NK will exaggerate about this stuff
Besides
I tought this discussion was about ussr
How does us being evil make anything ussr do good?
This is what happens 3k messages later
He got in trouble for denying the Holodomor, so he tried to accuse the US of genocide in NK
HE WHAT?!?!?!?!
.
Yeah, basically he believes the USSR was the best country and that capitalism is evil
Next thing im gonna hear is about how red army gloriousley relived eastern europe
And how they totally didnt rape tousands of innocent women on their eay
Of course they dint shoot any polish partizants,
And KatyĆ is a myth
The only good thing about the rest is its slow collapse
I wish we had a time machine, so we could go back to the USSR and show him what it was really like
I know numerous people who remember the times of communism in poland
It may not be ussr directly
But none of them feels bad about its collapse
And that is basically most of adults i know
Exception are only really yong adults
To be fair it collapsed like 30 years ago so a bit of time has passed
Imagine that in polish peoples republic having a fricking toilet paper was luxiourous
There was shortage of everything in shops, except for ocet
And to get anything good you had to stand in long ass lines
It eas so bad that sometimes people would pay someone to stand in line for them
Sometimes youd have to stand entire day just to get something
Try telling that to him
Youd have to pay with a thing called papers which determined how much of what you can buy
I've lost brain cells arguing with him
Honestly if my dad could speak english, than id let him speak instead for me
After all how could he argue with someone who lived trough it
He says his (I believe) grandfather lived in the USSR has told him how great it was
What did he tell him?
Specifically
Idk
@frosty spoke
What specifically did your grandfather say was "great" about ussr
My opinion is that the USSR was evil
Whether or not it was as evil as NatSoc Germany is a whole different debate, but it was awful
Damn
Seriously this is some next level copium to defend North Korea
Even if I was a communist, North Korea os obviously the one thing I'll never bring up for my arguments
Everyone knows North Korea attacked the South first
And like holy shit man
North Korea is the perfect example of a failed communist state
When was there a successful one?
There's none
Hmmmmm
But at least the goddamn soviets actually got themselves an industry even if how stupid the means were
Somewhat quick as well
Sounds cap to me
US bombs usually are around a ton or less each
Wait
Lmao I think I fucked up my math XD
Ah no no
I got it right
It sounds absolutely cap that 400,000 or more bombs didn't explode lol
Besides, that's nothing
I think he's forgetting that when ww2 started air forces around the world don't have a mature strategic bombing force yet
Bombs at the time are still dumb too so saturation is the norm
It's quite funny really to think that the US did some secret operations to antagonize North Korea when they barely even arrived just in time to save South Korea from destruction
And that North Korea was the people who fired the first shot ultimately
That's the funny part, he doesn't believe that lmao
Of course he wouldn't
His arguments are so bad ngl
Joker comes in trying to redeem himself after he gets called out
Or should I say, herself
And then gets ridiculed for it
I've heard commies who can reason far better
And expects clout
Man honestly I have no idea how tf is his ego still intact even after weeks of everyone disagreeimg with him
Talk about disconnected from reality
Because Communists are apart of a cult
He also thinks money; yes the paper bill itself is oppressive
People who follow the Communist faith are a cult of those who are Nationalist Purists, I can attest to this because I was a Communist myself
Aren't communists anti nationalist?
They claim to be
But in reality they are the upmost in Nationalists
Well at least on paper
They are purists is what they are
As usually the case with extremists
The are essentially National Purists who see anything and everyone who doesn't follow their viewpoint of thinking as "Enemies of the Revolution"
But seriously what I cannot understand with this guy is doesn't he realize that the communist states he so loved eventually opened up to world trade and decentralised their economies
Like man, that says a whole lotta how command economies just wouldn't work
Sometimes i feel like the inly difference between nazis and communists were their goals
They're actually crazy similar
This is the problem with Communists as they constantly deny what they are doing is inhumane, while at the same time promoting genocide of undesirable individuals at random
Ik
If Nazis call for one race to rule them all
Communism calls for one class
Or in this case a classless society
They essentially apply to contradictories and hold them in equal value
Boty hate poland đ
Which is exactly what George Orwell pointed out in his book 1984
great book btw
And why the book was illegal in the Soviet Union
almost as good as the Communist Manifesto
The 1984 book was essentially a step by step playbook of how Communist Nations operated, which is one of the reasons why it was banned in the USSR
Honestly if communists wanted to eradicate a race, it would be way more brutal, and way less xlean if you could say that
tho my best read was Mein Kampf
Well that's the worst part too, the communists don't even pick on race
They pick anyone
Communists I wouldn't say want to eradicate a race, but that ultimately is what ends up happening in their so called "Classless Society"
Im not saying they want.
Im saying if they wanted to
It's way easier to label someone as bourgeoisie to execute them than labeling someone with race
Because what Communists essentially want is a society where they have a collective way of thinking
No wonder the communists killed so many of their own
Essentially a Theocracy just not in name
MAN
Man do I love to hear this guy defend Pol Pot
Like holy shit that's gonna be crazy if he does that
Pol Pot was the most evil man in the history of man kind
I'll defend his South African lookalike
If he does that that should automatically be a banable offense
Istg man if he even defends Pol Pot đ
Just because he's a "socialist"
he's been resurrected as Elon
Like shit man this guy is biased af
Socialism and Communism are essentially the same thing
Just their names are different
Pretty much
And the ironic thing is they hate eachother
Really?
Yeah
Lvl 1 socialist vs lvl 100 communist
Communism is where the state owns everything
Socialism can exist within states, it's pretty much the state afterall
Socialism is where everyone shares everything allocated by the state
Whereass communism is stateless, but ironically attempts for abolishing the state results into another state lmao
The question is
What, or rather who is the state
the government?
The government
That is?
Usually authoritarian
But states are more overarching compared to governments
Who does the government consist of?
It's basically the mesh which holds a nation together
In essence states are a myth which everyone subscribes to
nvm, Socialism can work with liberty and democracy
Communism works with authoritarianism
Maybe not liberty, but democracy definitely
Communism is basically the extreme version of socialism
Libertarians dislike the idea of forced cooperation brought to them by the state
I mean, at least they say it does
Socialism is democratic, and that's why I don't like it
Democratic Socialism is like the most stupidest ideology I've ever heard of in my life
anarcho-primitivism
Yes this actually exists
It's a bit funny how both sides don't like Nazism
It's literally in the name that they are centrists
Imagine having to live between biggest communist state, and greatest national socialist state
Its even funnier as over half of them can't even properly describe what Nazism or Fascism is in its full historical context
And both of them equally hate you
And the context that they do give is either complete bullshit
Or its the Westernized version we are taught in our schools
Poland 1939
Why the hell are there so many different types of socialism
If you are gonna hate an ideology, at least know how it works to understand why you hate it
Well Nazism isn't Socialism
It's funny how the American who never experienced communism likes to argue with people who did experience communism
yeah I know, but why do many different types of socialism
Sounds like an oxymoron to me
why is Irish Republican Socialism a thing
Lmao
Why do ideologies even exist at all
People like making their own interpretations thinking that theirs is unique, when really at its core they're all the same
idk, that's why irl, I say fuck politics
History ig
Yeah ideologies are a bit dumb
Ideologies all follow the distinct trend in that they are Utopian Fantasies
Imagine making a theory on what's the best way of organizing society instead of just actually organizing it
And Utopia's are impossible fantasies that can't be achieved
Theres as many ideologies on earth as rhere is people on the planet
Some of tyem just happen to be similar
Ideology replaced religion
No nation on earth follows a single ideology and constantly shifts
It's a bit sad innit
somewhat
Oh man not just somewhat
A hell ton XD
Remember back in the day when everyone had a religion
Really, ideologies aren't that different from religions
man people here don't even care about religion, unless ur old
If religion has god, ideologies have an idea
It's pretty much the same thing
You worship an object in dreams for utopia/heaven
Communists didnt like religion in poland very much, so they did all they could to discourage that, like making work days during sundays
And communists still like to tell they have free time đ
But religion has been keeping polish nation together since a long time so trying to fight it now was a lost cause
Istg man it's absolutely hypocritical to be able to proselytise people in the internet about communism and complaining that you do not have free time in the capitalist society which you live in
Especially since polish pope
bottom text, we have a lotta free time
Communists are seriously that daft in comprehending just how much time a person spends their day resting
Like can you believe it man
Paladin says that they don't have free time because of work
But at the same time also saying they watch netflix 3 hours everyday
Bruh
ngl 3 hours everyday is a bit ridiculous
You know what I like about religion
Even if people think that God doesn't exist
It still works
Really?
Since the truth is, God doesn't play a huge part in the real world
Unlike ideologies
Which are very real
And can actually cause harm
https://www.youtube.com/@GDFofficial This channel is one of his sources
It's the most anti-american channel I've seen
I NEED YOUR HELP! - PATREON: https://patreon.com/gdfofficial
CASHAPP: https://cash.app/$gdfofficial
PAYPAL: https://paypal.com/paypalme/gdfofficial
This channel relies on Donations and Patrons! Join my discord server where we can chat and talk about ideas for videos by joining my patreon! And if you have the means to do so please consider...
Lol and he also criticizes the algorithm
I just clicked the Link
From the channel that he cited...
and I see the top video
This is from the channel that he cited...
PATREON: https://patreon.com/gdfofficial
LINKTREE: https://linktr.ee/gdfofficial
INSTAGRAM: https://instagram.com/gaddafiofficial
TIKTOK: https://tiktok.com/@gdfofficial
#youtubechannel #youtube #youtuber #youtubers #subscribe #youtubevideos #sub #youtubevideo #like #instagram #follow #video #vlog #subscribetomychannel #gaming #music #explor...
"How Iraqis Got So Good St Smoking American Soldiers"
Another one...
I just picture an Iraqi soldier holding a tiny American soldier and smoking him like a cigar
The fact our Government tolerates people like this for the "First Amendment"
Even though its simply pure hate speech
Its amazing
But then we are getting into Rule 3
Imagine hating on hate speech while also at the same time hating on americans
But yeah the fact he cited this person of all people, basically his entire credibility is
Dead
Fair is fair, if we start restricting certain types of speech, what stops other types of speech from being restricted? (I shall now end this topic due to fear of rule 3)
!1984

Okay
What this country needs
USA needs: representative democracy with a hint of socialism
Try not Rule 3 this
It is what it needs
Because of legal reasons (as to not get my ass hounded by the mods) i shall not say anything else
!1984
Nineteen Eighty-Four (also published as 1984) is a dystopian social science fiction novel and cautionary tale by English writer George Orwell. Thematically, it centres on the consequences of totalitarianism, mass surveillance and repressive regimentation of people and behaviours within society. Orwell, a democratic socialist, modelled the authoritarian state in the novel on Stalinist Russia and Nazi Germany. More broadly, the novel examines the role of truth and facts within societies and the ways in which they can be manipulated.
I was just checking up and that claim is yet to be proven
Also other articles aligned with the information provided in the video
I'll start debating later anyway
why start again if you got clapped, grilled and burned numerous times?
He's a hardcore fanatic
No different from those KPOP stans
the BTS army
One day we will all live to see the day of Paladin starting a country
**The Glorious State Of Paladin 𫥠**
The claim has been proven already and therefore a warn was instilled. Also itâs hard to debate with someone with little to no credibility
Considering that YouTube channel ainât a valid source
I donât trust chicagoans anyways
Watch as he makes a counter argument that the system oppressively delegitimizes his sources
He never made it into my books
Please Paladin please reply 
Paladin shouldnât be a paladin if heâs this bad at debating
Oh well
Where the fuck is roland?
Heâs a real paladin
Paladin thinks we are stupid
He's Joker just under a different name
Or should I say she as Joker was the imposter as a genocidal maniac who I had fought with for over two years
The fact remains this
If there was a genocide in North Korea, why isn't it Internationally recognized?
Why do no nations recognize there was a genocide by the UN in North Korea. Even North Korea denies there was ever a genocide...
If no nations recognize there was one, that means it didn't happen. Simple as that.
Genocide is only recognized by the UN when it fits their narrative
Can't prosecute a man who's not in court
It will only get worst
i thought chicagoans were smart?
Ig not
they defined the term for a reason, plus war crimes doesn't equal genocide
Genocide denial time
I applaud you Paladin for having such a woke opinion đ
HOLY SHIT
Are you one of those woke americans! đ±
Genocide denial time
And banned
A US General at the UN even said how "The problem of avoiding the killing of innocent civilians and damages to the civilian economy is continually present and given my personal attention."
Not just any US General
Fucking MacArthur
By your own logic
The Soviets killing Two Million Afghan Civilians was a genocide
And it went unrecognized by the UN
damn
One of which was them bombing an Afghan Children's school
Then going in and executing the survivors
By your own logic that was a genocide and it went unrecognized by the UN
That 3 Million wounded tho
Ofc he's gonna dismiss that statistic like some madlad
He's probably gonna also dismiss the statistic that Communism didn't kill 100 Million people
Actually I recall him saying that
Of course he would
Like how he downplays the gulag just because it only existed for a few decades
Even though the Soviets had a MAJOR smallpox outbreak in the 1970s
And covered it up to the point we only have four people that they recorded who got the deadly diseas
They're just a continuation of Lenin's Forced Labour Camps
Oh oh that one too btw!
Smallpox is too deadly to the point it would've just stopped at four people
He actually supports forced collaboration!
The fact that Paladin is beating a dead horse is just
And nobody has banned him yet?
While also at the same time saying slavery is bullshit
How hypocritical oh my god
Those 18 million who went to the Gulags rly makes me think
Lol I might get demoted at this point with the amount of insults I bombarded him, but really this man deserves it
The 18 Million on record I might add
You probably won't get demoted if you screenshot what we has said
If you screenshot what he has said then you have evidence
and yeah
Oh boi do we have everything
The Bot sees all
Griffbot records every deleted message anyways, even if he deletes it
The fact that Paladin unknowingly went against 2 sents and 4 peeps makes me laugh
Man everyone in this forum disagrees with him
I legit got here like last night
What do you expect, his name is Paladin
He's some brainwashed ignorant dipshit
A game that is a blatant rip off of overwatch
Fair đ€Ł
Not to mention
A south side chicagoan
That or he is intentionally doing this
And he is sharing it with another discord server
I don't think he's even a troll, he's actually dead serious lol
To try and discredit Griffin's Credibility
"Look at me going off courageously against dozens of people who disagree with me!"
A death wish ngl
He's literally acting like a Crusader
As expected from a purist
The moment he mentions Michael Parenti
Then we ban him
Michael Parenti is a domestic terrorist
Especially since 300,000 dead North Korean civilians is enough to count as genocide
I mean if he attributes all of that to the United States and the UN Coalition
Considering the Chinese counter offensive that took place
that means me killing millions in HOI4 is Genocide
The 300,000 North Korean Civilians dead was the total amount that was lost after three years of war. In that three years A LOT happened...
So I highly doubt ALL of it can be attributed to the UN Coalition
And that isn't some genocide denial, that is just common sense...
Just because the losses are North korean civilians, doesn't mean the North Koreans have no play in it
But of course since he is a Communist and North Korea is a "Communist State"
He is gonna deny they had any role in it
The excuse being "What kind of nation kills there own civilians"
I don't know much about the Korean war, but I'd guess it's fairly similar to how scorched earth tactics left many civilians in the axis occupied territory of the soviet union without any food
He says the US did it with international bombing strikes on civilians, attempting to do genocide
And does he have proof of that?
Preferably from a Primary Source that isn't a .com website
And preferably a source that is written by a scholar that isn't biased
This: https://apnews.com/article/international-news-asia-pacific-ap-top-news-north-korea-dd6256bad51e458cb2e8a1bf64b5c2b6
And that extremely anti-american channel
That isn't a primary source
The source for this article is literally the NK army though
That means its completely biased
And therefore means its invalid in debate
Exactly
I showed him that the SK and NK civilian death tolls were similar, which wouldn't make sense if the US was committing genocide, the NK death toll should be much higher
I mean by his logic North Korea shouldn't exist
Speaking of tracks, @heady jungle paladin needs a fuckin lesson jn american railroading
Yes i was here when the chat started
but how did it turn into north korea
Honestly i dont know
I look here ocasionally
And say some view things, but usualy i dont commit much to the duscussion
Paladin argues that usa commited genocide in korea, because it was racist
But i dont know how that makes ussr good
Alright theres a 95% chance paladin plays the anthem of the ussr on the school bus everyday, bought the communist manifesto and never read it once
denied by saying it wasn't a genocide or that it didn't happen at all
.
Here
Alright
let me test one thing
@frosty spoke Explain Appropriation of Surplus Value from a Marxist perspective (You could if you knew what you were talking about)
I can find a whole video "debunking" vaccines, doesn't make it true
J-just leave him be, he already lost his crusade
USSR stinky
I can still smell it 30 years later
Ok,whatever yall wanted to say to me during this convo,say it now,because I'm not reading this 500 message conversation that I wasn't here for
You can live in your little world, we donât care
USSR was bad
So you're a nazi?
I know that isn't the entirety
Of course you would say that
Answer the question
No I'm not a Nazi
Then don't cite that book
I'm not citing that book
I am being a realist
The Soviets covered up A LOT
In fact don't even bring it up here unless you're criticizing it
You are the one who brought up a channel that said the CIA killed Kennedy
Don't talk to me about bringing up sources
You didn't watch the entire video,and don't change topic
Your right I didn't as its blatantly not true
Don't try and hide yourself Joker
We know it's you
The author not only admits to being desperate for the 100 million figure, but he also sympathizes for nazis by counting them as deaths. He also counts Vietnamese people who died during the war
Actually better yet just admit you are Hoxah Cat already trying to redeem yourself
Bro is this an argument or a LARP?
Just admit you are the Joker guy
You aren't gonna prove anything by hiding it

I am
Also you didn't even watch the video so you don't even know what the guy says ik the video
That's not a surprise
Yeah cus Iâve always joked about that
Your right as I am not gonna watch a video that is from a channel that preaches American Genocide
Ban for saying something you disagree with?
No
You are being banned for violating the rules
You can't just choose to ignore a source you don't like
I can if itâs invalid
Which rules?
When it comes to preaching genocide
Yes I can
Preaching which genocide
Don't act stupid dude to redeem yourself
You know who you are Hoxah Cat
This forum is around 3800 messages long
That YOU started
There's lots of mention of genocide,so which genocide did I "preach"?
So you expect me to memorize all 3800 messages?


No we expect maturity is what we expect
^
Especially the ones I wasn't here to see?
Just text a screenshot of me preaching genocide
The fact you cited a YouTuve Channel
You literally just accused me of being the joker
So every source I post that means I magically agree with everything the author said?
Ayo lemme see that
Unless its argumentative, yes you agree
Damn
Not to mention,I was just posting because I thought he didn't know about the bombings
Ik chicago education sucked, but damn
Your right because you are the user "TheJoker" that fled from here after he was called out
What is this American Genocide video
Bro who even is that
There was a user here "TheJoker" who was disguised as a YouTuber that goes by the name Hoxah Cat
Hoxah Cat is a devout Communist who believes that to achieve Communism all Americans, Jews, Arabs, Muslims, and Christians need to be killed
How about EVERYONE here find EVERY source they used and see if they agree with ALL opinions of ALL the authors that made the source
You know who you are Paladin as you talk and act just like Joker did
The Internet
Yeah you don't even know what communism or socialism is
Yeah I do
You are just trying to hide everything
There is no saying in any Communist literature saying that people of a specific race,gender,or religion should be killed,especially not without aggravation
This isn't even mental gymnastics anymore,this is mental aerobatics
No its not
You know who you are
You've already been warned once
Bro is this elementary school?
Okay prove it's me.
And given that you tried to evade warnings for violating the rules
I Cleary stated that I wasn't objecting to the warning
But you weren't even there to see I don't think
You probably just took these other guys at face value
I mean it's not hard
Anyway I gotta consume sustenance, catch y'all later
Ah yes because everyone should believe in every bullshit
Being open minded doesn't mean consuming and believing every information you encounter
It's such a shame mother nature gave you a brain that you don't even use
Message Number 3800
@robust zinc as in,you can't disprove the source without even knowing what they said
Also I just thought he didn't even know what i was talking about,so I just linked a video about the bombings,you're twisting my words
You can disprove a source by looking at the type of arguments he is throwing at
By looking at the other claims he has made
You didn't even see what he was saying in the other vids
For example his claim that the CIA killed John F. Kennedy, which is blatantly not true, kills all his credibility
Yeah you didn't actually watch that vid
I'm not going to watch a video that is not true
Especially a video that is promoting sedition
If you actually took this seriously,you would have watched and noticed that he actually leaves you to answer for yourself at the end and throughout the video he only suggests multiple suspects
How were you a communist?
Look at the title again
As it tells me you didn't watch it either
He never actually accused the cia of doing it,only telling you that there's reasons to suspect them
He literally says in the title of the video
The CIA killed Kennedy
If the title says it all then the video is promoting that idea
Its that simple...
A thumbnail+titleâ the actual video. He's just click clickbating because nobody would click to see what he says.
Its that simple...
That isn't what he is doing
But ok
And plus here you are admitting that is what the video was about
Do you have any idea of how you tubers operate?
some of them don't clickbait lmao
He isn't clickbaiting
Yes,he never actually accused anyone in the video
He's trying to promote revolution
Yeah it's completely obvious you don't know anything about what your talking about
Says the guy who sourced him in the first place
If I were President the guy you sourced would've been arrested
And brought up on Federal Charges of conspiracy, hate speech, etc.
So would his editors and his associates
That would actually go against free speech
For this source, I would not use it as the only 2 options are for reform or no reform. Those that would rather have the soviet union disbanded would still vote yes as having a reformed state is a safer bet than a revolution.
Free Speech does not promote sedition
Just saying...
Freedom of Speech doesn't promote civil disobedience to the law
You'd be violating the constitution
You're just saying what you want it to be instead of proving it to be what you want it to be
that's normal
You'd still be violating the constitution
How many times has the constitution been violated in American History
And like nobody gave a sh*t
Because its happened A LOT
That's not helping your case
Kennedy getting JFKed by the CIA is a conspiracy theory
Yeah
He provided reason of multiple people and organizations on why they might have had incentive to kill him
This is petty as hell
incentives, it doesn't mean they actually wanted to
Dude
EXACTLY
The Soviets had the most incentive to kill Kennedy more than the CIA did
The guy who killed Kennedy was in fact a Communist
HE NEVER EXPLICITLY SAID IN THE VIDEO THAT THE CIA DID IT
But you wouldn't know because you wilfully choose ignorance
Says the guy who denied the Holodomor Famine
Don't change the topic!
You brought up ignorance
Watch the video
I thought I would brought up your ignorance
So what's the point of the video
I'm not gonna watch a video from a person who probably is apart of an organization that has me on their hit list
Yeah,and you choosing it,how hard is it to watch a video???
Ain't nobody got time for that
How hard is it? Let me explain
Cleary your mom ain't had time to raise you@pallid vigil
I was once a Communist
she's had enough time, lmao
I did not ask,it's just a video
I am currently on a hit list that was comprised of a group of some of the most prominent Communist Parties in the world
I would suggest that you not insult your opposition even if they are rude please.
How hard is it to go on YT and watch a video?
I get stalked and harassed by the people I once affiliated with on a daily basis
Not rude?
That video is probably baited to log my IP address
Then give the location of where I live as well as everything I have signed under my name
It's being used in a disrespectful manner
no, it was being used in a meme matter
And then its going to give those people who are currently hunting me down for betraying the Communist Faith
So no I ain't gonna click on it
For the sake of my own good
If you were worried about your location being tracked you lost that battle long before you were born
You do realize that... you can use the discord third party YT viewing feature, right?
So you are admitting that that link you posted here is baited
You never actually had to leave discord
Bro what
So when we click on it
You can see our IP address
That is what you are saying to us right now
I would not describe you as rude as per the standards of the internet. I apologize for insinuating that you are rude. However, I would not describe you as kind in that message either, and Palandin feels insulted from it. It was an advice to Palandin
You can search up the video yourself if you want bro..
You posted a baited link
That you are using to grab our IP Addresses
Out of spite...
How did you become a communist?
lore
Not now dude
noted
@pallid vigil
I think its ban hammer time
It's morbin' time
is it morbin' time?
Always has been
Morb
rip
morbius is a capitalist invention
Not Morbius
mon dieu!
Fun fact https://youtu.be/qtujD-AdQGo
Star Wars Creator George Lucas said December last year, that he left retired to do unpopular movies.
Help fund this program! http://patreon.com/MaoistRebelNews
Maoist Rebel News book store: http://lulu.com/spotlight/MaoistRebelNews
Read more news at: http://maoistrebelnews.wordpress.com/
Follow me on Facebook: http://www.fb.com/MaoistRebelNews...
Well, certainly the U.S. military promotes certain kinds of movies by providing subsidies to those that depict the US military as good guys like in monster movies, soviet movies are not exactly free from material constraints either.
Well I can imagine
Anything that went against the state in the Soviet Union was banned
Punishable by death
I would also not recommend Maoist Rebel Radio as a reliable source as he does not understand Marxism. For example, he states in the debate with Muke, "Marx doesn't necessarily stand against profit". However, this is factually wrong as the Gotha Program has Marx explicitly oppose profit seeking enterprises like worker co-operatives.
I was saying fun fact because I found it interesting and the film industry came up
I see, thank you
Nah m8 thereâs da supremacy clause, look it up
oh wait, chicagoans dont know how to bc they too busy getting hit by metra trains
!rules
-
Conduct yourself in a civil manner, do not be rude towards other members. There is no tolerance toward any kind of bigotry. Racist and sexist slurs are not permitted under any circumstance.
-
No suggestive, NSFW, or anime content of any kind.
-
No discussion of modern politics or events past the year 2012.
-
Advertising of non-historical content is not allowed unless given express permission by an admin.
-
Do not spam in this server.
-
Do not add alt-accounts to this server.
-
No unsolicited pinging of Armchair Historian team members, including The Armchair Historian.
-
Images and videos posted must be directly related to the channel its posted in.
Oh hell nah I don't live in Chicago
I think it may just be too late.
Just a thought...
you put yourself there
I think it's a good example of the average American city
It ain't
better late then never, so Abide by the Rules
Or Atleast the best
Minneapolis is much better
What do you stand to gain from talking to the people of this server? They are not really open to have their minds changed and you are not exactly popular amongst them.
I know ur new here n all. But this has been going on for a month
Thank you for the information
Damn,for real? I feel old
đ
You don't have to act tough. Sometimes, it is best to walk away. I understand that you are enthusiastic; however, from my limited perspective, I do not think these actions might be most fitting to your goal.
