Java 23

[still nest]

I think there should be an option to choose the java version, because some mods require java 23.

[gentle topaz]

there are no fabric mods that require java 23 iirc

[warm yarrow]

All mods should work fine on Java 11, 17 or 21 as they're LTS versions. Any mods which require a newer version of Java should be removed or downgraded to support one of these versions.

[gentle topaz]

some people say that c2me requires java 22 but thats not true and lunar doesnt even support c2me

[warm yarrow]

go to fabric loader issue #984

it's not related to the mod

[gentle topaz]

ik

i didnt create this post

[warm yarrow]

i was referring to this

[gentle topaz]

yeah ik

but i mentioned c2me as an example

so they know it can happen with other mods

and it also shows that lunar doesnt have to add java 23

because its a fabric loader issue that can happen with some mods

[still nest]

SeedMapper requires it

[warm yarrow]

I mean if you're using mods with lunar, you're doing something wrong as lunar is known for having awful mod loader support

Just use normal fabric or forge which tend to work a lot better and don't have restrictions lunar implements

[still nest]

Well i personally really like the intigrated mods and would appreciate if they added this

[warm yarrow]

There's a very low chance of them actually allowing custom runtimes due to various reasons such as less optimised, errors due to specific versions, and user error.

[still nest]

I mean i dont need a custon runtime

They could just add java 23 as an option

[warm yarrow]

that's what I meant by custom runtime, it most likely won't happen

[still nest]

A custom runtime would mean being abled to use your own java installation

[dull ferry]

Hello, I am the dev of SeedMapper and it's indeed true my mod only works with Java 23

[dull ferry]

Using a newer Java version is mostly fine

All major launchers support custom Java runtimes, so I don't think it's too crazy of a suggestion

[warm yarrow]

please make it support a LTS version

[dull ferry]

I would have if it was possible

[warm yarrow]

Why is it not possible?

[dull ferry]

It uses features only available in Java 22

FFM to be precise

[warm yarrow]

what other language do you use

[dull ferry]

C