#paleontology

1 messages Ā· Page 247 of 1

runic heart
#

Huh? I said which ones

charred hearth
#

🤄

outer tusk
#

oh I mean idk if even have a full list of the dinosaurs for SE to say

runic heart
#

Kinda excited to see what the megalodon looks like

tough parcel
#
There's another Kem Kem composite skull that does have brow bosses, but it's unclear what's real and what isn't.
Wouldn't surprise me if there's a Baryonychine in Kem Kem.```
Just as an FYI
runic heart
#

Thinking this is probably guizhouichthyosaurus?

full lagoon
#

The color took me off guard ngl

willow anchor
#

Got to see Zuul at the royal Ontario museum today, thought I’d share here since it’s pretty cool

mental cloak
#

Oh god why they did that

queen oar
#

Tarascosaurus too

queen oar
# tough parcel ```We don't have any confirmed spinosaurine with brow crests on the lacrimal and...

tbh it's a bit stupid to say " We don't have any confirmed spinosaurines with brow crests ", when it is sorta of believed that those bones were likely mostly cartilaginous in nature. Which is why we rarely find them in Theropods, despite most theropods already showing lacrimals and postorbitals that would support the presence of such structures. Which Spinosaurs, despite being as derived as they are, don't seem to be exactly too different to not be a possibility ( Not saying this directly to Falcon, just to be clear. )

charred hearth
#

choose your generic paleo horror antagonist: azhdarchid or megaraptoran

balmy oyster
#

Or a tyrannosaurus with ā€œā€scientifically accurateā€ā€ calls (it’s just super slowed and reverbed chicken noises)

charred hearth
#

i wonder why megaraptorans are more used for horror then dromeosaurids

queen oar
#

claws.

#

It's kinda the closest analogue to slashers who use hand-weapons, for example... Despite almost every Theropod having that

charred hearth
#

i guess that makes sense

#

is it possible to make animal horror content without demonizing the animal?

vernal fable
#

More than likely there is definitely ways

#

I think there was a series called Weird Birds or something I can't remember but alot of the beings done some were puppets too like hand made

balmy oyster
vernal fable
#

Funnily some Jurassic Park Analog Horrors Actually don't demonize them^^

vernal fable
paper parcel
vernal fable
#

Ngl I feel like chimps also somewhere fall into that category lmao Sometimes chimps genuinely choose violence for no reason

Hippos definitely

vernal fable
paper parcel
vernal fable
queen oar
#

@hallow spear Where the f#ck did Justice even get this long ass femur and tarsal from?

hallow spear
#

It’s all figured and measured

queen oar
#

Where?

hallow spear
#

One of the papers I sent him, I’ll find it tomorrow

#

Most likely Galton 1985 if I had to guess though

queen oar
hallow spear
#

Its prolly in here

#

Very happy with how it came out justice did an amazing job with it

#

@queen oar in case you didn’t see it I linked the pdf

queen oar
hallow spear
#

It is under a different specimen catalogue I did check and the figures are in there

queen oar
hallow spear
#

Do you have any other questions?

charred hearth
#

why are its plates so SPIKEY

hallow spear
queen oar
#

Not really, surprised that they have put it Lexovisaurus as big similar to how I've reconstructed it, kinda suggesting the material does support the size. Otherwise, I have I don't like posture, but it's a personnal nitpick that generally wouldn't expect many to be convinced of

@hallow spear Also, yeah, what about the plates, exactly? I thought Marsh kinda said that those were likely fin bones from Leedsichthys, unless it's referring to different bones and specimens entirely.

hallow spear
queen oar
#

Of course. I have forgotten you are the " Stegosaur Guy ā„¢ "

hallow spear
#

As for the plate it’s based on Cf. Loricatosaurus priscus [CAMSM J.46874] an isolated plate of unknown placement, and uncertain affinity to Loricatosaurus but since it was found close by, and was iirc reffered to it at one point, it’s likely fine for it to be used as a reference, it’s not like that’s much better to use. I would say this is the most parsimonious option

charred hearth
#

closer to stego or dace?

hallow spear
#

Stegosaurus

#

Phylogeny of Stegosauria (Based on SƔnchez-Fenollosa et al,. 2025 for taxa included in their Dataset) (Not all unnamed taxa are included)
Kentrosaurus placement is the middle ground for what it’s most consistently recovered near or around

queen oar
queen oar
hallow spear
#

And it is still tenatively reffered to loricatosaurus so it’s still reasonable and in this case, best reference for the plates

queen oar
#

Tbh, that is kinda playing with fate a bit too risky. Not that I do not admire it, really, that's the fun in Paleo. But, otherwise, given how there is nothing that really gives substance to it belong to Loricatosaurus, it's ultimately unwise to use it. Doesn't mean you can't, just that you would have to be aware of what using it would mean.

hallow spear
#

Yep we were aware of that, but ultimately we thought it was the best option as the partial plates that Loricato does have best fit a structure of similar build to said isolated plate

queen oar
#

Would doubt that, but hey, you do you, stego boy.

hallow spear
#

I mean the 3D scans I have of the plates agree with that interpretation, it is still speculative but not impossible or too unlikely, which is the point of using it.

#

Plus it’s agreed with in literature well enough for it to be used with some backing even if it’s tentative

queen oar
#

I mean, but that doesn't make any sense what you said. Like, if it's speculative, you are admitting both to the case that it might be possible or impossible. Like, see, I'm not really trying to argue accuracy or veracity here, just so if it's really a good idea, given how this may stick to the image of the animal and we don't know how this may age in future.

#

But then again, you did say that Stegosaur remains are hard to find well-preserved, so that may take some hmmmm... 500 years or so. So you may not have to worry.

#

See, Stego is smart, he is playing the gamble where he will not even see the result of it!!!

hallow spear
#

Though I’d like to add, even if it’s not Loricato there’s only really one other named stegosaur it could be, and that’s Lexovisaurus, and even if it’s neither of those 2 it would phylogenetically place inside of Stegosaurinae which makes it reasonably useful to depict Loricato/lexovi from, about as equally as the rest. It can’t be from Dacentrurus since the plate differs enough morphologically to be distinct in literature

queen oar
hallow spear
#

Probably not unlikely for that to happen but as far as Oxford clay formation goes I’m pretty sure material indicates only one Dacentrurus species throughout it that I’m aware of

#

I think Stegosaurus however needs to be split into multiple species

queen oar
hallow spear
#

I mean it’s good enough, not perfect but good enough

queen oar
#

@hallow spear You both are gonna have to forgive me, cause I'll draw Loricatosaurus as a Dacentrurinae as I originally intended.

hallow spear
#

Tsk tsk

queen oar
hallow spear
#

The tail should be held high as per the Stegosaurus osteology and Kentrosaurus rom study but hey you do you

kind bane
#

Me when I ignore all literature on Stegosaurs for my own Aesthetic basis or something

queen oar
queen oar
hallow spear
kind bane
#

I’ll do it!

I won’t that sounds horrible.

hallow spear
#

The main issue is that Stenops holotype is entirely inaccessible and still unprepared

mental cloak
#

Could stegosaurus in general like
Move their plates a lil bit?
Like
Clap for a bit em to make sounds

#

No clap
Just kinda move em that they could touch eachother to make some lil sounds

true juniper
mental cloak
#

Idk the word for that
They like
Touch and make plate sounds

true juniper
#

Like when The Psittaco mod it has a Dance where it shakes its tail
A similar sound to that?

woeful falcon
#

Clacking I think is the word you're looking for

light osprey
woeful falcon
#

Perhaps not in moving the plates themselves but rocking back and forth making the plates hit each other and clack

queen oar
balmy oyster
#

Surprisingly it hasn’t disintegrated yet

queen oar
balmy oyster
hallow spear
queen oar
queen oar
paper parcel
queen oar
#

Being a Carnosaur and Sauropod enjoyer, is realizing that after you explore every potential of soft tissues on their faces...

You'll never appreciate a conservative reconstruction of them again.

runic rover
sudden wind
runic rover
rare bough
#

styra is to small in the game

brave nova
steep atlas
#

I want to see all the ingame dinosaur models compared to a human in-engine

brave nova
coral forge
rare bough
coral forge
#

pretty much everything that hasn't gotten a recent tlc
even some of the playables that got a tlc remained oversized, like Achillobator, Sarcosuchus, Concavenator, ect

paper parcel
#

Could cotylorhynchus survive today?

steep atlas
runic heart
rare bough
tulip dove
#

Sauropods for example have been found to have multiple types of scales (Such as in Diplodocus and I think in some titanosaur embryos)

But most of the time they are either given elephant like skin or only one type of scale in media

rare bough
#

titan beats t rex

warped peak
#

Whomst

steep atlas
rare bough
true juniper
#

100 assasin bugs beats rex
Bugs Bite, bugs poop in wounds rex dies of infection 2 months later W

green helm
#

whats the most up to date spinosaurus aegyptiacus

paper parcel
coral forge
paper parcel
coral forge
#

ik, but I wanna see their reasoning lol

green helm
#

titanoboa can squeeze a whole eiffel tower!!

paper parcel
coral forge
#

well yeah, thats kinda what they're built to do

fossil ingot
paper parcel
#

Nothing solos the Cotylorhynchus

fossil ingot
#

Paleoxodon is an issue on itself regarding its size
Elephants aren't the best vs Carnis close their size anyways

fossil ingot
#

Anky is a Weird Dude
Giga is Larger by like 3t but then again
Anky is so short Giga is not having an easy time
Then again both would prob be like
"Idk what that is so ima just ignore it"

warped peak
fossil ingot
# paper parcel Tusks

Tusks can be useful as long as you know how to usr it effectively
Best they have is prob Paleoxo vs Paleoxo
But Elephants aren't that Great Comparatively vs Theropods of Similar Size
Hell its Main Instict is very likely run away as soon as it sees Giga

paper parcel
fossil ingot
raw frigate
#

Is it true Pycno was bigger than Carno? The largest abelisaurid? Also... It's true Majungasaurus is also of the same family?

paper parcel
stiff osprey
#

there's several specimens from south america and africa that would be larger than pycno but are unnamed due to being single bones, teeth or footprints

warped peak
warped peak
fossil ingot
#

Majunga mogs all

fossil ingot
paper parcel
#

I wish the permian extinct never happened but genuinely.

green helm
paper parcel
steep atlas
coral forge
steep atlas
#

I think they could be effective

#

But I think elephants are at a disadvantage vs giant theropods

paper parcel
full lagoon
steep atlas
full lagoon
#

Even if the elephant is heavier it's going to be outlasted and outjuked badly, especially if we are talking about a T.Rex that hunted prey that requires this approach

steep atlas
full lagoon
#

I love elephants but that doesn't mean that I'm going to glaze a large one as a rex killer because it's stupid quite frankly

paper parcel
#

I imagine palaeoloxodon would just stab large theropods to death with its tusks via rearing up

warped peak
undone rapids
full lagoon
warped peak
#

If only Palaeoloxodon had more than a 1 ton advantage over Tyrannosaurus it might be fair

full lagoon
#

I'm not saying the elephant would never win but it seems silly to put them up against a predator of that caliber that's experienced at taking down large prey

warped peak
#

Yeah its not exactly a fair setup. You'd need at least an elephant with robust tusks, and at least a 50 - 60% weight advantage over the theropod to hold its own

warped peak
#

Unfortunately, there is no elephant large enough for that

paper parcel
warped peak
#

The closest we got is Zygolophodon as the largest Proboscidean, but it's massive, long tusks would be terrible into Tyrannosaurus

paper parcel
warped peak
#

Yeah outside of sauropods, the largest is currently

  1. Shant
    2/3/4. Zygolophodon/Paraceratherium/Dzungariotherium in some order (too close in size with too little information)
  2. Edmont
stiff osprey
#

slander campaign against palaeoloxodon was so effective it went from largest land animal that's not a sauropod to barely larger than rex

paper parcel
warped peak
#

The consequences of your entire identity as the "largest mammalian herbivore" being based on a single unmeasured bone fragment when the rest of your genus is notably smaller (the bone was lost)

stiff osprey
#

maraapuniloxodon

full lagoon
#

We should all know by now that stuff like this is almost always initially hyped up out of proportion

coral forge
warped peak
#

Oh? Who's the #2 largest hadrosaur then? Even by keystone specimen

queen oar
steep atlas
#

Big paul?

warped peak
coral forge
warped peak
#

Is X Rex indeterminate?

queen oar
#

Maybe.

coral forge
#

afaik edmont tails arent diagnostic but its still considered annectens anyway

warped peak
# stiff osprey maraapuniloxodon

I henceforth dub this: Larramendiitis

Because giant Palaeoloxodon, Bruhathkayosaurus, and giant Marapuunisaurus are all lost fossils with mass estimates yielded by Larramendi that would be pushing the limit of their respective group

queen oar
ionic linden
stiff osprey
#

Maraapuni wasn't his fault he actually was notably more conservative about it than everyone else

paper parcel
coral forge
stiff osprey
queen oar
coral forge
#

same thing

queen oar
#

Me and Doog were looking at a " Trachodon " mandible Marsh allegedly described from there, and it's pretty long.

coral forge
#

could you send it here?

queen oar
#

Sure, let me kick the pc

queen oar
#

and I measured it, it's like 106+ cms

coral forge
queen oar
coral forge
#

no like
it is E. annectens
YPM 616 is Edmontosaurus annectens

coral forge
#

Which is Edmontosaurus annectens

rare bough
#

your welcome

coral forge
#

what

paper parcel
thorn grove
coral forge
#

its labelled as YPM 616 twice and the tag says Anatotitan lmao

thorn grove
#

I'm blind ok I can't even read chat I just assume what people are saying and am correct

warped peak
coral forge
#

is the 13t sub adult the largest verifiable P. namadicus?

sullen cairn
#

Fortunately for annectens ypm 616 is a nomen dubium which is probably for the best given it has priority over annectens anyways

mental cloak
warped peak
coral forge
#

larramendi has it at 12.5t, idk if thats accurate or not

warped peak
#

No clue

charred hearth
ionic linden
#

i think everything else is just really big idk

true juniper
#

I remember how pre tlc spino was Kaiju sized

charred hearth
#

funfact, alberta and eo are the same size irl

charred hearth
#

not weight, i meant height, i apologize for bad wording

#

well 🤄

queen oar
charred hearth
#

well, i put the big nose emoji because its suppose to be pinnichio , The nose growth was intended as punishment for his dishonesty because his father didnt want him to lie because he wamnted to raise a honest son and thats why i put that emoji because its nose is long because i lied šŸ™

charred hearth
#

if eo was renamed to trike, how accurate would it be to trike?

queen oar
#

There is some Triceratops specimens that some alleged to " Look like Eotriceratops ", but how much weight that holds, it's pretty subjective. Specially if it's basing on reconstructions that had no thought in mind about how well-preserved the material is.

charred hearth
#

be honest, which one does PoT eo ( base species ) look like more

coral forge
queen oar
#

You could also say, that maybe Alderon asked some of their artists " Hey, make Eo look more like Trike " and that's why it looks the way it does. But ultimately, it is more Trike-like in game

charred hearth
#

funfact, trike was chosen over eo in a poll but eo was chosen anyways

sudden wind
coral forge
charred hearth
#

isnt that what happened with hatz and metri?

queen oar
coral forge
#

ig

#

the skull doesnt look too bad imo
its kinda just the horns and shape of the frill

charred hearth
#

why does metri and hatz look so distinct while eo looks like trike on a budget?

queen oar
#

It's a bit weird to limit Eotrike to only species that are clearly referencing Triceratops specimens, when Eotrike kinda of gets the title around of being the " Triceratopsini ancestor ", so like idk... Maybe put a species referencing Torosaurus or Ojoceratops.

charred hearth
#

what i mean is what i mean and what i meant is what i meant

coral forge
#

ok but like what did you mean

queen oar
charred hearth
#

hatz and metri are able to visually look distinct besides barely having any material, if im correct, even less then Eo iirc

Eo just looks like trike, its not visually distinct in anyway from it

queen oar
coral forge
charred hearth
#

did it run out for eo

queen oar
#

Me when I remove any potential of a animal to have it's own identity, and rely on traits from the identity of a more famous animal. Somehow that is " Creative Liberty "

#

I mean, reconstructions are like that. But also like, on many aspects this is just Triceratops.

balmy oyster
queen oar
#

" Eotriceratops xerinsularis? More like... Triceratops xerinsularis "

coral forge
queen oar
coral forge
#

Eo's skull literally has not changed. The only difference between old and new reconstructions is the size of the skull proportionate to the rest of the body

queen oar
#

See, I'm not gonna mention my reconstruction, because then it sounds more like a ego thing, which I do not want it. But trust me when I say this, Eo's skull material, definetly preserves a lot of the skull, but how it's preserved, it's definetly not good, and reconstructions who do not even remotely doubt how well the material is, will not age well. So at the end, I would've definetly preferred if Alderon did a skull reconstruction of their own.

queen oar
runic heart
#

Ok so it’s cymbospondylus and dongusuchus. Also just realized that the eyes aren’t actually that big, there’s just yellow rings around them. Still creepy though.

icy lagoon
outer tusk
#

that's not nitpicking

queen oar
#

It just needs a new skull rec.

mental cloak
#

Dinosaurs

runic rover
#

Today I saw a Nile croc scratching like a dog... Since when do they do that?!

#

Would a Deinosuchus ever be able to do that?

mental cloak
paper parcel
mental cloak
#

Yeah thats possible

little mauve
#

Birds use their feet a lot to scratch, I've seen bearded dragons do it too. Seems a relatively common behavior for sauropsids in general

paper parcel
#

100% real image of camarasaurus taking mudbath

balmy oyster
#

New lancian apato

charred hearth
#

it made it to the late cretascous???

queen oar
balmy oyster
#

Yes, lancian’s been pumping out a lot of skeletals recently

outer tusk
#

he's very good

queen oar
runic heart
hallow spear
queen oar
woeful falcon
#

Oh laaaancian! Stego's disrespecting your work in PoTcord! šŸ“¢

queen oar
#

he's not even here.

light osprey
hallow spear
woeful falcon
#

I figured as much lol

queen oar
light osprey
hallow spear
woeful falcon
#

Factual

queen oar
#

The Real OG was Paleoking ( idk )

light osprey
hallow spear
queen oar
light osprey
hallow spear
queen oar
tough parcel
hallow spear
woeful falcon
#

Some of these requests have been.... arranged already.

queen oar
tough parcel
#

ATP it’d be a mercy, I’m so tired dude, do NOT wait until the last day to do your final project! Bad idea! misfortune

hallow spear
deft shuttle
queen oar
#

Ask Dilo, not any of us. They are the real expert on that topic ( allegedly, idk really )

deft shuttle
#

Im just curious because I found it interesting. I'm not no paleontologyst

stiff osprey
#

Trust me the final answer on if spinosaurs had lips is not coming from the path of titans discord

balmy oyster
deft shuttle
balmy oyster
#

Facebook will show you a ai generated image of a sailed jp tyrannosaurus then claim it was 20 tons

light osprey
deft shuttle
light osprey
#

If you mean Dilo, they said something to the same affect, with the additive of lips being a plesiomorphic condition for amniotes in the absence of evidence for the secondary lack of them

queen oar
balmy oyster
#

Not sure

paper parcel
brittle veldt
#

Did dinosaurs have a wishbone? Are birds Dinosaurs? Good questions.

Thanks for watching!!!

Please consider subscribing.

ā¬‡ļøā¬‡ļøā¬‡ļøā¬‡ļøā¬‡ļøā¬‡ļøā¬‡ļøā¬‡ļø
https://dinosaurpark.org/

If you like dinosaurs, paleontology, T-rex, or fossils in general, check out our other videos!!! Because the Ogden Dinosaur Park is a park full of d...

ā–¶ Play video
vital mist
#

Anyone know ab a server with only Dinosaurs from a specific period of time like Triassic, Jurassic, or Cretaceous?

#

Ik the base dinosaurs are from different periods, but is there a server that dosnt allow u to play a (for example) a Triassic Dino in a creataceous server

queen oar
tough parcel
mental cloak
#

Could springtrap survive in the late cretaceous period?

queen oar
#

The entire Late Cretaceous or one specific point of the Late Cretaceous?

mental cloak
#

Hmmm hell creek

mental cloak
charred hearth
#

thoughts on the new colossal news?

balmy oyster
queen oar
charred hearth
#

what exactly is the goal behind reviving these prehestoric animals, i never got that

mental cloak
#

Idk,money laundering

queen oar
dense scroll
#

Hello folks!
I wanna make a suggestion about Geostenbergia hand orientation, can anyone check if my silly illustration is correct?
Thanks.

queen oar
#

@little mauve your field, I guess.

cloud dagger
vital mist
scenic flame
dense scroll
scenic flame
outer tusk
true juniper
#

If a pteranodon attacks you can you just grasp its Beak shut
Theyre not exactly the heaviest

steep atlas
#

i'd be scared of that thing

lavish frigate
# charred hearth thoughts on the new colossal news?

Weird choice but sure go for it

They founded a de-extinction company, I’m fine with them de-extincting things (if they actually do it instead of being like ā€œwow we injected a gazelle with blue buck hoof genes this is the same as reviving a speciesā€)

true juniper
#

Look at how thick it's arm bones are
Imagine if it got fussy and wacked you with it's wing like some birds do

queen oar
#

@zealous ravine Hey Dilo, the other day you mentioned evidence of small sauropods making herd with juveniles of larger sauropods, could you show that real quick?

zealous ravine
#

I didn't?

queen oar
#

.

zealous ravine
# queen oar .

Oh I meant smaller sauropods make herds and juvenile sauropods make herds, not necessarily together

zealous ravine
#

Idk if it's been published yet but Mother's Day Quarry is a big one. Edit: found it, just waiting for cooldown

queen oar
#

I'll ignore the voices.

zealous ravine
spice latch
queen oar
#

@zealous ravine do you potentially identify yourself as a Sinosaurus?

velvet burrow
#

Bajo de la Carpa was mentioned and i didn't realize, i'm so sad

#

Also about this. I don't think that's a rule, because in Patagonia we also have Portezuelo from the coniacian and Cerro Fortaleza from (probably) early maastrichtian where the local predators were around the same sizes as the ones in Bajo de la Carpa but some sauropods like Futalognkosaurus, Dreadnoughtus and Puertasaurus still reached quite high levels gigantism

#

IMO the simplest answer is that there's a size cap (relative to the local predators) sauropods have to reach in order to use it as a deterrent and from there they're free to reach higher sizes depending on other environmental factors such as food availability

primal coyote
#

Random hypothesis I had: Would Maniraptoran Dinosaurs taste like Gamefowl? (Ik it’s probably a bit off topic but my brain won’t abandon it)

little mauve
balmy oyster
little mauve
#

De-extinction itself is a pretty ethically fraught idea. A private startup with who knows who funding it, plus the nods from the Trump regime and others. It's a bad scene, these guys are shady

balmy oyster
#

The issue isn’t blue antelopes or big wolves. It’s whatever the government & other powerful groups & people are wanting to utilize this genetic modification for.

little mauve
#

It's not about it hurting ecosystems necessarily, even then ecosystems can and do change as rapidly as within years, decades, or centuries

#

The primary issue is that it's fluff. Startups generate hype to generate investment to drive up the potential value of their stock. Achieving on stated goals or promises is secondary. Thats the phase Colossal is in right now, and theres good reason to be skeptical of their achievements and goals

#

Secondly the logistics of what they propose beggar belief. Are they really going to clone a sustainable, genetically diverse breeding population of thousands of individuals? And secure habitat for them?

#

I doubt it personally

#

The endgame goal is for their stock to be worth a bajillion dollars when they go public based on some photos of white mutant wolves

balmy oyster
#

I doubt that’s the ā€œendgameā€ tbh, more so just a bug benefit.

little mauve
#

If they ever got big enough, certainly they would become just as shady as those sectors. But their science isn't really impressive, it's not scalable, it serves no real function. This is pure hype

queen oar
little mauve
little mauve
paper parcel
queen oar
balmy oyster
queen oar
little mauve
#

Sea lions too, a rep in Washington is proposing it

paper parcel
#

The fear of death is a big part, they think if they allow genetic testing and other stuff related to dna, they think they will be able to artificially extend their lives since genes slowly decaying overtime is a hugepart of aging. Since Telemeres(which contain dna) slowly break over time as cells are replaced

little mauve
#

*for the wealthy

paper parcel
queen oar
#

Tbh, the worst thing about Colossal is how, even if you argue that they have genuine intentions, it's only performative in nature. What the f#ck does a species extinct for decades or centuries even contribute to modern ecosystems who have established members on the brink of extinction? And mind you, it's totally possible to acquire more samples with those, because it's live specimens, instead of dead or decomposing specimens in a collection or in the wild.

little mauve
#

There's that and also what actually are these animals they're creating? How do we define them? At best they're something new and not a recreation of anything. You can't de-extinct just like you can't raise something from the dead, it doesn't work. Mammals are taught their behaviors by their parents and sometimes extended families, who is fulfilling that role in a new creation with no prior generations? I can think of nothing sadder than a "resurrected" mammoth doomed to be an orphan forever, no matter how many more mammoths they clone

paper parcel
charred hearth
#

how would you even transform a ressurcted mammoth to the enviorments it suppose to live in? it has 0 to none prior knowledge of it and would only know tropical enviorments for its life

little mauve
#

Exactly

paper parcel
#

You would have a legit easier time building a warp drive to go back in time, and just seeing the prehistoric mammals that way and setting up a prehistoric colony to preserve their genetics then undoing any human environmental damage.

little mauve
#

Jurassic Park is literally about the fact that it's sheer arrogance to resurrect an extinct species, assuming things about its ecology, and only unscrupulous carnival barker billionaires would ever even attempt it

queen oar
little mauve
paper parcel
charred hearth
#

i heard they wanna bring back quagga's, literally what is bringing back quagga's gonna do??? their literally just less flashy zebra's

little mauve
#

https://pleistocenepark.org/ pleistocene park is an actual non profit scientific endeavor concerned with ecology and climate change and has never gotten the hype colossal has

Dedicated to the restoration of high productive grazing ecosystems in the Arctic.

queen oar
paper parcel
#

I don't think they understand that most species went extinct because of people, not because it was some magical preordained event, resurrecting doesn't just magically undo the problem

queen oar
little mauve
#

Sure go for it

paper parcel
# little mauve Sure go for it

Deal, what if we just turned people into extinct species(preferrably mesozoic reptiles) using some nano machines and made humans go extinct while not killing them at the same time.

queen oar
# little mauve Sure go for it

So, I was discussing to my friends, how: if I did a Jurassic Park, I would use the technology to help species on the brink of extinction. The only exception being animals such as whales, who cannot be housed in a Zoo/Park in any practical way, and probably would've accounted for multiple offenses of Animal abuse. And one of those ideas it's how, since most Cheetahs are inbred in some form of another, the idea was to experiment with the concept of taking older species from the Acinonyx genus, and try to breed them with modern Cheetahs to see, if introducing more basal traits would help them with their genetic diversity

I think it wouldn't work.

paper parcel
mental cloak
little mauve
mental cloak
#

What if they did what [REDACTED] did with the chickens..but
Better

balmy oyster
mental cloak
balmy oyster
#

Ig when it became clear horner was going to be booted out from the science field sometime soon they went for option B which is Colossal

mental cloak
#

Yeah bcuz ofc they did

mental cloak
#

I think all ratites are more close related (and yeah that includes kiwi)

slow trench
queen oar
mental cloak
#

"Chicken aint nothing but a bird"

mental cloak
rare bough
zenith rose
#

Paleontology people… I can’t find refs for sauropod feet. Which one is these are backwards??

stiff osprey
#

The claws face away from the center of the body, and the innermost one is the biggest

zenith rose
mental cloak
#

Its like
Tortoise feet
That had tooth back facin claws
I mean some of em have those

zenith rose
#

Sauropod feet freak me out! I’ve got horrible aphantasia so when looking for references of such unusual features, it can be rather difficult to ā€˜manipulate’ those forms in my mind, if that makes sense. I’m grateful for this chat where those who know more than me are able to help šŸ˜…

mental cloak
#

Also there this refence here i found

zenith rose
#

Goodness. We have aliens on earth! Thank you!

mental cloak
zenith rose
mental cloak
zenith rose
runic heart
stiff osprey
#

At least one species had the claws mostly buried in flesh, yeah

runic heart
stiff osprey
#

I don't remember when are the footprints from

runic heart
#

Or opisthocoelicaudia. Some kind of nemegt Titanosaur.

stiff osprey
#

Oh more reasons for saltasaurids to be horrible. Cool

runic heart
stiff osprey
#

Alamo is a wastebasket made of probably two or more taxa which may not even be close relatives. But yes at least one of them is a saltasaurid

runic heart
stiff osprey
#

We only have a forelimb and tail from the saltasaurid, and only a neck described from the lognkosaur form, so who knows

#

My suspicion is the lognkosaur has a shorter tail and a longer, wider neck

queen oar
#

Additionally, the fact that literature stucked up the idea of " Alamosaurus being the only Titanosaur in Late Cretaceous North America ", also contributed to why many authors were reckless or confident that any material belong to it.

runic heart
stiff osprey
#

lognkosauria is just Patagotitan, Futalognkosaurus, Argentinosaurus and friends, saltasaurids are mostly small taxa with very robust limbs. Some have short necks and are grazers/low browsers but most lack neck material

mental cloak
#

How diferent are both velociraptor species?(mongoliensis and osmolskae)

runic heart
stiff osprey
#

In some phylogenies yes, or close to them

little mauve
little mauve
charred hearth
runic heart
#

Surviving earth wrap party poster showing what we have seen in the trailer, and stuff we have yet to see. Seems like the nanuq’s chasing the edmontosaurs are either juveniles, or the poster just shrinks their size.

charred hearth
wintry sluice
#

The Baby Eater 3000 bit or the anti genus name bit?

exotic flare
#

Genus?

coral forge
#

Canis

sudden wind
#

Canis

steep atlas
#

Goblinus

coral forge
#

Canis lupus unfamiliaris

velvet burrow
tough parcel
ionic crescent
still prairie
#

Yeah

runic rover
#

Tbh Morgan Freeman or not they started this trend of "Ah, yes, a herd of unnamed Hadrosaurids you don't care because they didn't appear in any major Paleomedia" started back in PhP, so I kinda agree with that tweet.

Also I don't care of Azdarchids eating babies being repetitive, we had Rex in every documentary ever since forever, so idk why people should get annoyed by any other recurring trope.

tough parcel
#

Rex appearing isn't a trope airfrier it's a charismatic animal that everyone knows

Azhdarchids being reduced to one thing is an overused trope

still prairie
#

I guess the argument of ''ecologically its all they could do'' but like ehh its a bit weird esp since PhP 2 gave em much more to do(for better and worse)

peak jetty
tough parcel
#

How?

#

I don't think T. rex is a significant or recurrent theme; a motif thinkingkitty

#

A heavily reused trope is "T. rex is a (good) parent actually"

peak jetty
# tough parcel How?

At risk of going off-topic, a trope is any kind of depiction, idea, or whatever that can occur in media. It is a much more broad thing than just "x doing x".

Fanservice (for lack of a better word rn), like Rex appearing in nearly all paleomedia, is a trope.

tough parcel
#

Ok then has anyone called Captain America a trope? Optimus Prime?

No, they call the actions of what they do a trope airfrier hence the inclusion of Tyrannosaurus is not one, but what they do with it is such as being a tender caring parent

peak jetty
#

... Characters in and of themselves are not tropes, nor did I ever suggest that.

But this is decidedly off topic, so I am dropping it.

tough parcel
#

The T. rex is a charcter, your argument failed already

peak jetty
#

reading comprehension is dead.

tough parcel
#

Then tell me why it isn't, curious that you gave up after agreeing with me airfrier

charred hearth
#

people always become defeatists as soon as the arguement dosent go their way, stand on buisness

tough parcel
#

The point of all this is that azhdarchids only did something besides "eat baby" in PrePlanet and even then, "eat baby" was 75% of their screentime

coral forge
charred hearth
#

explain more?

coral forge
#

iirc the Amurosaurus bonebed showed that for that species at least, herds were age segregated, meaning babies kinda just had to fend for themselves and couldn't join the adults

charred hearth
#

oh alright!

little mauve
#

Hypacrosaurus shows more precocial young than Maiasaura as well

coral forge
#

kinda funny how for 2 sister clades, one of them actually cared about their kids, and the other just used the sauropod method

thorn grove
# coral forge iirc the Amurosaurus bonebed showed that for that species at least, herds were a...

There's multiple Hadrosaur bonebeds that showcase age segregated herds but interestingly it's inconsistent

E. annectens has the Hanson Ranch bonebed which is just adults but the RMDQ has adults subadults and adolescents

Shantungosaurus has the Kogou quarry bonebed which is just adults but the Zangjiazhuang quarry bonebed has a mix of adults and much younger individuals a fraction their size

runic heart
#

This does make me wonder what the concept art for the nanuqsaurus looked like…

queen oar
# runic rover Tbh Morgan Freeman or not they started this trend of "Ah, yes, a herd of unnamed...

tbh, yeah. I think if documentaries reuse animals already shown before, they have to offer something new and refreshing in return. Tyrannosaurus as of recently, hasn't had anything new explored beyond what we've already done in past documentaries. Same thing for Azhdarchids

But we can't explore new things either, because then it ALSO gets negative feedback in some way, cause it's " Too Speculative ".

#

And yes, Tyrannosaurus re-appearing constantly in documentaries is a trope. Less on the regards of Tyrannosaurus itself, but more so, as said already, often it's inclusion is " Purposeless ", it's not exactly a " New Character " from the world of paleontology that people aren't aware of already, and it's inclusion often comes without any exact payoff

even in PhP, where Parental Care and Display behaviour were shown, this is not exactly something new, and has been explored as far as Walking With Dinosaurs. And ultimately in Season 2, the only thing explored with it was Hunting Behaviour, which we already have seen with some frequency, if anything... It is something that Tyrannosaurs did since their first apperance in the first paleomedias

This is not to say that more unique dinosaurs haven't been as, equally, disappointing in the introduction and conclusion of their narratives. But this feels more like an effect from these documentaries simply not wanting to be bold and creative, to not pass an impression of " Inaccuracy "

coral forge
charred hearth
#

do you guys think azdarchids will ever escape the trope of them hunting young and will be bodied by the larger therapod to show it as the bigger threat?

thorn grove
# coral forge I imagine the shant situation could be an example of different subspecies behavi...

Maybe, though I also suspect herding behavior could have varied depending on the time of year as a consequence of changing dietary options. I've seen it suggested that the age segregation was the result of ontogenetic niche partitioning between adult Hadrosaurs and younger individuals but if said niche segregation was only true for part of the year then herd segregation would have only been beneficial for part of the year as well.

outer tusk
still prairie
#

Esp since WWD 2025 had 2 entire sequences of azdarchids getting wrecked by tyrannosaurs

little mauve
fallow mulch
outer tusk
#

SIW made the original the, pose was edited by Tableseating

undone rapids
#

SIW is SpinoInWonderland

paper parcel
topaz shell
#

Technically they aren’t mammals

paper parcel
topaz shell
#

Still aren’t true mammals

charred hearth
#

Which kentrosaurus is more accuarte? : PoT vs the Isle

light osprey
steep atlas
charred hearth
#

it didnt have cheeks?

exotic flare
exotic flare
steep atlas
tough parcel
#

Are you sure?

charred hearth
#

someone summon stego

bleak rose
steep atlas
#

well they lacked the jaw closer muscles that attached far forward on the jaw, like we see in guys who were probably cheeked

#

and by "cheeks" i don't necessarily mean exposed muscles, i just mean skin that extends forward of that

bleak rose
steep atlas
#

it has the jaw closer muscles, but they attached more typically, sort of like theropods or lizards

runic heart
steep atlas
runic heart
steep atlas
scenic flame
runic heart
steep atlas
bleak rose
steep atlas
#

some i had on hand. i believe it was from a second paper by the same authors? got one more hold up

charred hearth
#

so it didint have cheeks?

steep atlas
hallow spear
#

@tough parcel what do you want lil buddy

tough parcel
#

I said cheek discussion on stegosaurs, get workign!

charred hearth
#

we're discussing two things

Who's more accurate , PoT kentro or The isle Kentro

and if stegosaurids had cheeks or not

steep atlas
#

from what i posted it looks like stegosaurids and pachycephalosaurids would both have a much more restricted "cheek" region compared to ceratopsids and hadrosaurs

queen oar
#

Lips.

steep atlas
runic heart
steep atlas
hallow spear
runic heart
steep atlas
little mauve
#

Birds have the same musculature but also a rictus of skin that can form a cheek of sorts. Possible that ornithiscians had the same

runic heart
steep atlas
#

i think that the shape of the jaw margin along the tooth row could give us hints as to whether or not there'd be skin "cheeks" too

runic heart
#

Scale covered rictus in all dinosaurs is definitely most likely from what I can tell.

queen oar
#

Lips on Ornithischians.

steep atlas
#

the skin/rictus appears to terminate roughly where the extent of the muscle terminates. but in stegosaurus and pachycephalosaurus, there is still a lot of mouth length after that point, whereas there's much less with ceratopsids and hadrosaurs

little mauve
#

Snapping turtles have a fairly pronounced fleshy rictus as well, terminating at the base of the beak

steep atlas
#

i have always hated how jurassic park did it, basically a flesh tube right up to the tip of the snout. really ugly and weird, unnatural

cerulean elbow
#

We love the stego vacuum cleaner

little mauve
#

Very dinosaur renaissance, mammalian cheeks

steep atlas
queen oar
cerulean elbow
#

I thought it was Dr doofenzmirtz....

little mauve
#

No lol, it's from a comic called The Eternaut

queen oar
#

See, the G stands for " Gregory " so he is " Doctor Gregory Bones "

paper parcel
zealous ravine
#

Funny name animal

queen oar
paper parcel
# zealous ravine Funny name animal

Dinosaurus is an extinct genus of therapsid of controversial affinities. Its type and only species is Dinosaurus murchisonii. It is only known from a partial snout from the Permian of Russia. Its taxonomic history is intertwined with several other poorly-known Russian therapsids, particularly Rhopalodon, Brithopus, and Phthinosuchus.
Dinosaurus ...

zealous ravine
queen oar
queen oar
zealous ravine
balmy oyster
peak jetty
zealous ravine
peak jetty
zealous ravine
zealous ravine
# peak jetty Oh cool

It’s a really interesting topic when you look into it. Uteodon, another species formerly assigned to Campto, might even be an obligate quadruped

peak jetty
zealous ravine
peak jetty
zealous ravine
paper parcel
#

I love the morrison formations sauropod diversity

#

Also Jonkeria, the fact its the first megaherbivore is pretty impressive, it may not be the biggest but it was the first and still is bigger then alot of modern animals. Horses and tapirs for example

queen oar
zealous ravine
sudden wind
sudden wind
#

Ankylosaurs can chew.

undone rapids
queen oar
balmy oyster
#

One’s a bobblehead and the other’s a pinhead

queen oar
sudden wind
#

Beak should probably only expand to the premaxilla and even the maxilla, as seen in birds and turtles.

balmy oyster
paper parcel
balmy oyster
#

Anteosaurus mogs it

misty scarab
#

What’s the size range for parasaurolophus?

paper parcel
queen oar
# balmy oyster well there’s skeletals for the two that show this

I mean, yeah, definetly. If it wasn't for the fact that most Dilophosaurus skull reconstructions are composite reconstructions including specimens of different sizes, which should definetly be factors to put into consideration. But, also I don't know anything about " Dilophosaurus " sinensis, so I can't comment much on that guy.

balmy oyster
outer tusk
#

unironically both dilo and sinosaurus (both species) have some AMAZING skulls

stiff osprey
paper parcel
#

Anteosaurus basically had a trex skull shape and the same crushing bite while not being related to tyrannosaurs at all.

queen oar
balmy oyster
outer tusk
#

though I be it seems unlikely for the sexual dimorphism part

stiff osprey
#

big tubicen is big

balmy oyster
queen oar
balmy oyster
#

Then yeah, even still it’s pretty different to S. sinensis

queen oar
#

Should probably revisit Dilophosaurus a 4th time, if necessary. I just wouldn't have the collection photos

balmy oyster
#

I’d argue there are other species that could use a revisit more than dilophosaurus honestly

queen oar
paper parcel
#

Dumb question but what would be the most dangerous sea or land creature in the permian if you visited it

balmy oyster
queen oar
balmy oyster
#

It is also a 1:1 match with sinosaurus so I’m inclined to believe him

delicate salmon
#

@elfin pulsar
All dinosaurs lay eggs because none of their living relatives gave birth and there's been no fossil evidence that any of them gave birth to live young.

queen oar
balmy oyster
#

The skull is really curved sure, but that doesn’t change how some elements are still 1:1 to sino and it can still be restored

balmy oyster
queen oar
balmy oyster
#

Regardless it would be nice for it to get looked at again though. Would be good to remove the banana condition from it

tough parcel
queen oar
queen oar
# balmy oyster Regardless it would be nice for it to get looked at again though. Would be good ...

Considering they showcased the fossil like this, it is fair to assume that it is so heavily compressed together, that the bones cannot be extracted without potential damage to the entire fossil, which is why I suggested that maybe it's possible to determine how unique or not it is, via the usage of Scans. But given how there are multiple crushed specimens from China who have not been granted such luxury... I wouldn't be so hopeful.

queen oar
# balmy oyster Same level of study on something like fragilis or jimmy specimens would be monum...

Oh yeah, that would be cool. But by revisiting Dilophosaurus, I mean myself revisiting and maybe do another skull or two skull reconstructions again ( Would be a downgrade if I didn't include a individual skull reconstruction for UCMP 37302 again )

But yeah, definetly. But we know why that's never gonna happen, if you touch Allosaurus, you gonna have to address Stegosaurus, Triceratops, Tyrannosaurus, etc. And there aren't many researchers available to do that, if there are they would believe that would be too much of a headache for them, or straight up don't wanna do it.

outer tusk
runic heart
#

Ok weird question, how do we know for sure that dinosaurs didn’t close their mouths to the point of teeth overlapping the lower jaw, when we have fossils of this being the case? Unless those are just crushed.

queen oar
charred hearth
runic heart
charred hearth
queen oar
thorn grove
charred hearth
#

i was questioning why edmonto seemed larger then shant

balmy oyster
#

It’s a funny sizechart because it’s almost all lambeosaurs and the two saurolophines aren’t scaled properly and there’s a non-hadrosaurid dinosaur there

thorn grove
# charred hearth i was questioning why edmonto seemed larger then shant

ngl even outside of x-rex/becky's giant edmonto is kind of just systematically oversized

every single museum and like science communication thing says it's 12-13 meters even tho that's still well above its average size and there's maybe like 2 specimens that scale to that size

also for some reason regalis gets scaled to 12+ meters even tho that estimate is like 100 years old

#

it's almost always described as the largest or at least one of the largest hadrosaurs when it's like 1-2 meters longer than most Lambeosaurines

balmy oyster
#

The average annectens specimen is still rather large at about a 6 ton estimate but trying to argue for it regularly being a 14 ton animal when its upper end for a few large specimens is ~9 is sort of silly

queen oar
#

Edmontosaurus has insecurities about it's size šŸ˜”

light osprey
ionic linden
#

isnt ouranosaurus pretty large?

thorn grove
# balmy oyster The average annectens specimen is still rather large at about a 6 ton estimate b...

it depends on the bone bed

average late adult from the RMDQ bonebed is only about 4 tons or so

6 tons could be plausible for late adults from Hanson Ranch if you just assume it's a mix of late and early adults + some subadults but there's not really histological work there so that's uncertain and the overall average is closer to 5 tons

I'm also just like 99% sure x-rex and becky's giant aren't even edmonto at this point so you can't even argue for rare huge specimens

Hanson Ranch specimens are a bit on the big side for Hadrosaurs, but tbh RMDQ material could easily work for most other Hadrosaurs, which is kind of what I'm getting at cuz Edmonto really isn't even that above average, let alone one of the biggest

queen oar
ionic linden
#

ah

balmy oyster
little mauve
#

RMDQ and Hanson overall seem very similar, so the difference in average masses is intriguing. Could definitely be different species, could also maybe represent some resource dependent size plasticity in differing populations

#

The previous discussion on the bonebeds got me to reading relevant papers and the hypothesis that edmontosaurus was seasonally age segregated seems fairly strong. Adult dominant herds appear to be associated with the winter/low productivity season which is interesting and evidently when these catastrophic incidents tended to occur

mint spindleBOT
#

check Case #9862 @olive imp has been warned.
Reason: Invite link.

patent mist
queen oar
#

Observation using the most reliable tool of human history... The Eyeball Mk. 1

patent mist
#

Looks like a standard edmont tail to me?

hallow spear
#

Sexually mature does not quantify as an "adult" though

patent mist
hallow spear
#

🤷

outer tusk
#

WAIT IS THAT THE REAL PALEOP

queen oar
#

Alternatively, if we have any data on the teeth, we can compare it to crocodiles to determine the correct age. Since that is an comparable thing between Crocodiles and Hadrosaurs, you can use their teeth to determine how old they are.

patent mist
# hallow spear 🤷

Fair point, although i still disagree with calling the average edmont full grown in that case.

kindred night
hallow spear
#

I mean, im pretty sure the averages estimated by table all have an EFS present which was like4-6t

queen oar
runic heart
#

Asked this earlier, idk if anyone can answer it now, but what’s the general consensus on theropod jaw closure? I’ve seen that it’s impossible for them to close their mouths all the way without the skull breaking, but at the same time we have theropod skulls with the upper jaw teeth overlapping the lower jaw.

sullen cairn
#

there are legit some really small skeletally mature maisaura from the bonebed

#

ie 75cm tibia with 3 Lags in its EFS whereas the largest is about 1m

sullen cairn
thorn grove
# patent mist What specifically is convincing you x rex is not an edmont? Afaik its never been...

I noticed X-Rex appears to have rather tall neural spines as they approach the sacrum which afaik is inconsistent with most other Edmonto tails

the bigger point is that hadrosaur tails arent super diagnostic to begin with afaik and since becky's giant has been suggested to have potential saurolophin affinities rather than edmontosaurin, it's a deduction on whether the only other giant hadrosaur element belongs to the other hadrosaur that's already a similar size or the one that isnt

queen oar
sullen cairn
#

regalis and annectens did used to have a few postcranial characters distinguishing the two from prieto-marquez's thesis but shockingly they all ended up kinda sucking

little mauve
sullen cairn
paper parcel
#

How would the morrison formation play in Path of Titans if the roster was only made out of dinos from the morrison or jurassic sea dinos

sullen cairn
queen oar
charred hearth
#

randomthingy vs randomdinos who wins

stiff seal
#

any big dino lovers know any dinos that look like what i just made lol, i just went with the flow on this sketch XD

stiff seal
queen oar
#

@little mauve I have a video for you

stiff seal
paper parcel
queen oar
stiff seal
paper parcel
little mauve
stiff seal
charred hearth
paper parcel
# balmy oyster 80% would be sauropods

I mean, You don't have to add all the sauropods you could just add 1 or 2 for each size range, plus it would be fun af seeing the carns have to use their brain. The jurassic is very underrated

charred hearth
#

" this jurassic is very underrated " why are we lying

balmy oyster
paper parcel
charred hearth
#

what isnt a bleeder, everything makes you bleed

balmy oyster
paper parcel
balmy oyster
charred hearth
#

do you ever see artwork that obvious is just hate art of a certain prehestoric creautre but you must keep silent to not get jumped

balmy oyster
paper parcel
balmy oyster
paper parcel
balmy oyster
#

I mean a basal one sure, but everyone knows tyrannosaurs have small arms

A torvo-like tyrannosaur would be awesome though

paper parcel
balmy oyster
#

Coelurosaurs took over the world

runic heart
#

Could a bird technically be considered a coelurosaur, or is that going too far?

balmy oyster
#

You can’t escape a clade. This is why every vertebrate animal is a fish.

runic heart
#

Welp dinoguns4

queen oar
paper parcel
#

Im kinda sad sauropods somehow didn't survive to the cenozoic, like why must the kto take the greatest of creatures.(last image is lusotitan)

thorn grove
#

i mean as much as it sucks the largest land animals ever are kind of the last thing id picture surviving a mass extinction

stiff seal
paper parcel
balmy oyster
balmy oyster
#

Or frogs. Apparently they were barely affected

paper parcel
stiff seal
balmy oyster
outer tusk
#

nanqusaurus is def not making it

stiff seal
runic heart
light osprey
balmy oyster
stiff seal
light osprey
balmy oyster
#

Ima be so fr nanuqsaurus probably just looked like a daspletosaurus/lythronax grade thing

outer tusk
#

indeed

outer tusk
stiff seal
outer tusk
#

or just looks like a random pterosaur that became a flightless pterosaur

stiff seal
paper parcel
stiff seal
light osprey
stiff seal
#

what could have been..

paper parcel
# stiff seal ah so we are now just raptors

Crows today are really smart, even compared to chimps, if mammals never got their chance and probably went extinct since the kto never happened, I imagine a theropod like them or another raptor would evolve intelligence

paper parcel
stiff seal
stiff seal
stiff seal
#

cool allo depiction, i dont know who made this but it looks amazing

stiff seal
balmy oyster
runic heart
rich vessel
stiff seal
balmy oyster
rich vessel
#

Yeah it can’t be allo

queen oar
#

Me when ragebait used to be believable.

charred hearth
balmy oyster
stiff seal
charred hearth
stiff seal
rich vessel
# balmy oyster Folk?

I have a lego tiger that I would love to turn into this but I don’t know how I would

balmy oyster
queen oar
# balmy oyster Well I fell for it. This is what I get for using the internet less.

Well, here's something more entertaining: I believe Folkes responded to someone, that Siats could still be a sister taxa to Neovenator, even though the last paper that remotely discuss phylogenetic placement, finds Siats having more diagnostic similarities to Aerosteon, which the paper discuss it as it somehow meaning that Megaraptors are Neovenatorids, even though that just means Siats is a Megaraptor.

stiff seal
balmy oyster
stiff seal
#

speaking of allo depictions tho, wow this looks so good

queen oar
stiff seal
queen oar
balmy oyster
#

There’s a good blog that talks about the recent baharia identification as a noasaur, and how cau basically just fanfic’d a random specimen to justify not only noasaur baharia but it being synonymous with delta (technically the opposite, delta becomes baharia I think? Still bizarre) and it ignores most of the material.

#

It goes over how flawed the noasaur assessment is, and proves that bahariasaurus at the very least is anything BUT a noasaur.

#

Siats could still be some weird stem-megaraptora but baharia being noasaur is no bueno

charred hearth
#

what would've happened to paleontology if the great american bonewars never happened?

queen oar
# balmy oyster There’s a good blog that talks about the recent baharia identification as a noas...

See Delta I think it's just a Ornithomimosaur, and the GOAT ( Beagliam ) has already showed how possible that interpretation was, actually, I was suspecting that even before he posted his Delta

But Bahariasaurus does not look a Megaraptor, it does not even fit among Coelurosaurs and Carnosaurs, regardless of how doubtful Cau's own words are ( Which are, doubtful, 100% of the time, but a Broken Clock can be right once, I guess )

I've imagined before that it could be a Deinocheirid, but the features are more convergent rather than Ornithimimosaur-in-origin. It looks more close to what we have on Ceratosaurs, effectively meaning it's either a Elaphrosaurinae, but given the time period and convergent features, it's probably a Berthasaurid.

balmy oyster
#

This blog goes over everything as to why baharia can’t be a noasaur, it has everything I could ever say about this topic but better. It can’t be a noasaur because that would make no sense.

light osprey
balmy oyster
#

Nanuqsaurus started it so it could justify cosplying as yutyrannus

queen oar
# balmy oyster If you would look at the blog, not only does baharia’s vertebrae do look basal m...

I thought the same thing, but it does not mean anything. Baharia's vertebrae look similar to a ton of other theropod groups, making such argument ineffective, since really, to isolate it to one group, you would need to do a lot of cherrypicking, believe me when I say this, I've had interest on Bahariasaurus, and a lot of these arguments are not effective as they seem to be

It has such generalized traits, that it would need to be a basal branch among Theropods, Coelurosaurs and Carnosaurs wouldn't be fitting for it.

hallow spear
#

I was gonna say something then I realised who cares about Bahariasaurus, because it’s not me

queen oar
#

Neotheropods is not going to work for Bahariasaurus given time period, Ceratosaurs is going to work better.

balmy oyster
#

If you want to believe it is a giant noasaur then do so, but everything we know about it goes against it being a noasaur. There is even an entire matrix and phylogenetic comparisons proving this, but if you claim to be more knowledgeable than the person who’s done all this then I suggest discussing with them about why they’re wrong.

queen oar
#

As if Megaraptor Bahariasaurus wasn't tried multiple times in history, with similarly doubtful results. But, whatever you say.

balmy oyster
#
  • similarly doubtful results
  • posts blog proving it works
  • ignores it and says ā€œI know betterā€
  • ???
  • argument won
queen oar
#

Tell me this, why it works?

balmy oyster
#

The blog explains it…literally everything there is explained.

charred hearth
#

brick wall vs car

queen oar
#

I want to hear it from you, as a reader from that blog. Why it works?

balmy oyster
#

About how none of the material aside from a single pubis with superficial similarities is like that of noasaur grade dinosaurs, with good analysis on known material and matrix coding provided.

But you seem to understand the material than this person, so I do wonder what conclusion you came up with to prove it’s a noasaur that’s within similar level to what the blogposter has done?

#

Go read the blog it’s pretty well made, if you still disagree then honestly that’s fine. This IS decades old bombed nonexistant material that could’ve even ended up being a sauropod for all we know.

queen oar
#

See, if something works or is elaborated in a way that does work for you as a reader. It's expected that at least in some way you are able to pass that information, maybe not word by word, but in a way that knowledge is passed down to more people. If you can't do that, there are multiple alternatives: You didn't read the blog, you forgor, the blog fails on elaborating it or it's just straight up wrong. What alternative interpretation do you think I should take here?

charred hearth
#

is bahirasaurus really this serious

queen oar
#

Apparently, it is.

little mauve
#

The presence of sacral pleurocels and caudal pneumatization is one good point the blog makes, both together are only present in megaraptorans. I personally haven't thought much about Bahariasaurus before but the blog is pretty strongly argued. It's an interesting idea at least, these massive basal megaraptorans possibly kicking around.

sage lantern
#

if i just kiss all of you good night will we be friends

glossy lagoon
restive crag
#

Mega Baha

lavish frigate
#

Shoutout to all those little guys and gals who stand beside dinosaurs in these images so we can know how big they are, doing a public service

restive crag
#

That’s meāœ‹

queen oar
#

@restive crag show the snake skeletal.

restive crag
stiff seal
restive crag
#

Palaeophis colossaeus a large extinct marine snake

stiff seal
queen oar
#

@restive crag you doing Nanotyrannus?

coral forge
#

Looks fine though. Tsintaosaurus and Shantungosaurus could probably be bigger and Secernosaurus smaller, but that's about it

waxen jewel
#

I’m really upset that brontoraptor is a nomen nudum because it’s a pretty sick name ngl

waxen jewel
#

Apparently

I just wish it could actually be used for something instead of being wasted pensivestego

paper parcel
waxen jewel
#

Also unrelated question but how is jimmadseni supposed to be pronounced

queen oar
waxen jewel
#

Weird

Also who’s the GOAT a. jimmadseni or a. fragilis (there is a correct answer)

queen oar
#

A. jimmadseni, if I had to guess.

waxen jewel
#

Incorrect (I am not biased at all)

queen oar
# waxen jewel Incorrect (I am not biased at all)

Fair enough. I was gonna say, technically A. jimmadseni material was the one mostly used in most paleomedia appearances of Allosaurus, so A. fragilis would've been weird. But then again, most of those appearances were intending to be A. fragilis

waxen jewel
queen oar
waxen jewel
waxen jewel
#

Other than the landscapes I guess because it do be pretty gorgeous here

queen oar
#

tbf, the only dinosaurs here, I don't like a whole lot. Not a Pterosaur person either, but Tapejarinis are pretty cool

coral forge
waxen jewel
waxen jewel
queen oar
waxen jewel
queen oar
#

Kinda the only taxa that I have some sorta of attachment to, due to reading too much into Bone Wars literature. It's Camarasaurus and Epanterias, and Epanterias has seen " Better days "

queen oar
waxen jewel
queen oar
waxen jewel
scenic flame
runic rover
runic rover
#

Oi, how's?

queen oar
runic rover
queen oar
runic rover
#

Tbh whatever you're going to do to it will definitively be an improvement to the otherwise infinitely boring depictions we had of it, you may even make me like it more.

queen oar
runic rover
#

Idk maybe lmao

queen oar
#

Mf has the same opinion on Sauropod and Carnosaur facial soft tissue potential being wasted, and Dromaeosaur depictions being the same flavour

waxen jewel
dense spindle
#

credits to yoofilos for the skull placeholder.

peak jetty
#

Unenlagiine supremacy

sudden wind
outer tusk
#

~~tbf there's like 2 formable ecotypes that are hunting sharks actively ~~

slow trench
#

Amazing theoretical fight:

Who do you think would come out on top, a large jaguar or an average sized deinonychus?

I know deinon is a bit larger but their weight ranges are pretty similar

runic rover
#

Tbh I agree, I love troodontids, however that won't be much to call it troodontids soon if we keep on going like this.

turbid smelt
slow trench
#

You know it's interesting, some paleontologists reconstructed deinonychus legs accurate to their fossils to test how powerful their kicks were and found that they weren't necessarily strong to the extent of disembowling in a single blow. They certainly cut deep, but I do feel that it wouldn't necessarily be game over for the jaguar unless the kick hit a vital point

Honestly I'd say they're evenly matched, the claws of Jaguars are no joke either, and they're specialized for inflicting damage because they're kept sharp, meanwhile only one claw on deinon would likely have similar sharpness while the others would be comparatively more worn down

turbid smelt
#

Even then it's still in the jaguars favor bc cats are terrifyingly quick when they want to be, it's going to get outgrappled and dropped lel

slow trench
#

Yeah big cats are absolutely potent predators

Though I will say a deinon would likely be able to outstam a jaguar, givem the latter is built for short bursts of high energy

Even if the deinon pinned a jaguar on its back, the jaguar would still be able to kick out with its legs and claws the hell out of the deinon's stomach

turbid smelt
slow trench
#

Oh yeah, their bite is the most potent weapon, but their claws are their most versatile one

slow trench
turbid smelt
turbid smelt
slow trench
#

Valid, valid pop_cat2

Honestly while Jaguars would be knocked down the food chain i bet they could survive decently back then just because of how good they are in their niche

turbid smelt
restive crag
sudden wind
# outer tusk ~~tbf there's like 2 formable ecotypes that are hunting sharks actively ~~

The offshore of north east pacific, the population in south Africa does too, so does the Crozet island killer whales in the Indian ocean as well as the one swimming around the galapagos, the Caribbean and Australia. But as you mention these preys do not make the bulk of their diet and are more like generalists minus for the 2 firsts. Other population close to Brazil coasts also hunt elasmobranchs such as giant Mantas

sudden wind
paper parcel
mental cloak
#

Do megaraptors could pronate their wrists?

runic heart
true juniper
wintry sluice
eager creek
wintry sluice
# mental cloak Oh i see

Theres a nice paper on the RoM of specifically Australovenator, it should be freely accessible!

runic rover
# true juniper Whats the difference between achillo and utah that makes you like one so much mo...

Tbh this is a more "factionary" preference, as the entire of my favoritism toward Achillo is how Utah is usually portrayed and how Achillo is. For example, BOTM has a vulture-headed Achillobator, which made it stand out and make it interesting.

Aside from that, I tend to also like "asian versions" of dinosaurs.

PoT came after my original interest, and while I think the design is BORING AF, I like how it was meant to be played in concept, not realistic of course but still very amusing.

true juniper
#

I like pot achillo except the gross eyes

sudden wind
sudden wind
# mental cloak Do megaraptors could pronate their wrists?

They could but it was actually quite limited and not like what we or some other mammals are capable of. It is more than what Allosaurus or T.rex was capable of but still similar to what Dilophosaurus and Bambiraptor were capable of.

icy lagoon
#

did shant finally get described???

turbid smelt
turbid smelt
mental cloak
sweet wagon
#

This is not really paleontology but does anyone know if the shonisaurus mod is good(strength and health wise) I was ignored on the other chat

turbid smelt
sweet wagon
#

Okk

woeful haven
#

purussaurs vs tyrannosaurs rex, fight happens near water with puru lurking the rex, based on pure paleontology and reality (yes, i’m aware they didn’t live during the same time period) without bias who is winning this

undone rapids
#

Theres no real point for rex to go near it and vice versa. If there's a body then they probably try to pull it to their respective side but puru can't walk probablyso it's not gonna try too much

stiff osprey
#

if Purus ambushes rex from the water and manages to grab onto a leg it could kill it, on land it probably isn't going to try it

queen oar
thorn grove
runic heart
turbid smelt
queen oar
#

Me when Purussaurus dislocates the Tyrannosaurus' leg.

outer tusk
runic heart
#

Me too

willow bolt
full lagoon
#

Honestly it seems like it could go both ways but there's going to obviously be a huge bias towards purru near water

woeful haven
full lagoon
#

On dry, flat land the tyrannosaurus's height and agility could probably turn the tide though, but that seems more like an instance of catching the purru off guard basking or smth

ashen wedge
charred hearth
queen oar
full lagoon
#

Also, wouldn't the face be another pretty likely spot for purru to attack in ambush?

wind prairie
tough parcel
#

Angry

queen oar
light osprey
sudden wind
elfin pulsar
#

I genuinely cant unsee it as them just nuzzling and not fighting now

charred hearth
#

ava question but in a race instead of a fight

would a Ornithomimus be able to outrun a cheetah?

cheetah starts 300m away and will begin pursuing at 108 km/hr.

the ornithomimus immediately starts running at the maxium speed it has , which i have no clue what that is

is it fast enough to get away?

stiff osprey
runic heart
#

What is actually the largest crocodile material found in hell creek, or near it?

charred hearth
turbid smelt
turbid smelt
charred hearth
#

can you break that math down in simpler terms? im confused..

turbid smelt
charred hearth
#

oooh okay, ty

tough parcel
#

Are we sure the cheetah would be overheated airfrier

charred hearth
#

dont cheetahs tire out quite fast? or is that just a misconception

turbid smelt
#

They do, not a misconception

tough parcel
#

I am sure it was a matter of energy, not that they overheat

tulip gyro
turbid smelt
charred hearth
#

i wonder, who would be the 3 fastest land animals in PoT?

tough parcel
#

Yea, I've no clue when it was re-evaluated but I wanna say it was fairly recent thinkingkitty so I'm not surprised it hasn't spread very far

Especially considering stuff surrounding cheetahs isn't as widespread as the late 2000s

charred hearth
tulip gyro
outer tusk
charred hearth
charred hearth
#

ty

#

how valid is nedo btw? not at all? or yes kinda?

runic heart
#

How can we infer those big scales on the tail when they look like imprints of vertebra spines on the inside of the tail print?

#

Same with those little ā€œscalesā€ on the underside of the tail

#

Oh wait they’re prints from the sides of the tail, not the top and bottom. Sorry, took me a minute to figure that out.

#

Just had to look at concavenator and juravenator real quick.

light osprey
tough parcel
#

Godsaurus newzealand

glad arrow
#

I don’t usually talk here but how are yall feeling with the prehistoric octopus fossils?

mental cloak
#
  • Durante el periodo CretĆ”cico en Australia habitó una gran diversidad de animales, entre ellos el mĆ”s grande y reconocido es Mutaburrasaurus.

  • Este 9 de Abril del 2026 fue publicado un paper que estudiaba la anatomĆ­a craneal de Mutaburrasaurus. Tanto el craneo y la mandĆ­bula estan muy bien preservados, y gracias a los escĆ”neres computar...

ā–¶ Play video
ashen wedge
mental cloak
# sudden wind

Oh they r fighting?
I though they were just cuddling all this time lmao

crisp matrix
hidden steppe
elfin pulsar
#

I think they mean irl

hidden steppe
#

Are irl dromaeosaurs genuinely right behind ornithomimosauria?

steep atlas
hidden steppe
#

That’s what I thought, it seemed odd to refer to them as fast runners

#

What family would be behind Struthio then?

steep atlas
#

hmmm good question. abelisaurids and nanotyrannids would be quite fast. also the smaller, leggy tyrannosaurids. also troodontids and oviraptorosaurs were pretty cursorial