#paleontology

1 messages · Page 62 of 1

proper hornet
#

It was a upscale to fit 3 slot size

#

Was Fasola bipedal? Because I would have to rework my whole suggestion instead of changing the dino

#

Dumb question

chilly knot
#

Lump with raptorex gigachad

frosty anvil
#

I keep forgetting if raptorex was a real animal or some uncreative hybrid that a 6 year old child came up with - "ah yes lets blend a velociraptor and a rex together"

bright veldt
proper hornet
#

Then it could possibly work

proper hornet
bright veldt
#

Sure

vocal breach
#

Where barina

bright veldt
#

That’s just an actual crocodile

vocal breach
#

How big

proper hornet
bright veldt
#

Sebecid anyway. It’s also 7 meters long.

flat pond
#

Meanwhile one the smaller end of things.

fossil ingot
flat pond
#

Trilophosuchus

fossil ingot
#

Tbh i love this cute fella

flat pond
#

A genus of mekosuchinae

#

Well this thing is tiny, I’d say probably the smallest crocodilian to have ever been around if the specimen was an adult.

#

Makes me want to have a land crocodilian to play as now

white matrix
flat pond
#

True but prehistoric Australian crocodilians are a bit underrated.

tough parcel
#

A) Kapro isn't more terrestial than say, a Cuban croc

B) Aussie crocs are bad joke

flat pond
tough parcel
#

Yarp + last I checked, horribly, poorly described

flat pond
#

Eh, fair point

flat pond
#

I still give points to Trilophosuchus for being cute

#

But oh well at least I’m getting Puru

wide glen
#

I’m trying to do dinosaur drawings for practice and stuff so how good is this australovenator skeletal I found?

tough parcel
#

AFAIK not that good

wide glen
#

Any good australovenator skeletal you can give me?

tough parcel
#

@wide glen (Tagging ya so you can find it easier UwU )

wide glen
#

Thank u my kind sir

#

More megaraptorian then I was expecting

tough parcel
#

I mean... Australovenator is a megaraptoran?

flat pond
#

I find it interesting that they compare Trilophosuchus to dwarf crocodiles and dwarf caiman, which I own the later, but still very interesting.

wide glen
tough parcel
#

Ahhh I see, megaraptorans are horribly fragmentary across the board except Australo (even then, idk how much exactly is preserved)

sullen cairn
#

australo's really only particularly complete in that has its limbs still

clever sable
tough parcel
#

Guh

sullen cairn
#

there's some assigned phalanges fragments or something as well that are marginally larger than the holotype

cloud dagger
#

If that’s all the material of austro how we can tell its back was arched like on the pic gaulicho sent? There seems to be more straight backed megaraptorans too

stiff osprey
#

This just uses Aerosteon/Tratayenia proportions, I think it's likely Australovenator had a straighter back and less deep torso but we can't prove it at the moment

somber tartan
#

Opinions on life on our planets inostrancevia? (Ik they call it just a gorgonopsid but idc im calling it inost)

I personally love it 100%, wish it had more screen time tho

snow python
#

How big was Mourasuchus?

white matrix
bright veldt
#

It’s not terrible but it’s definitely in the “broad strokes are decent but it needs another draft” like the rex

sullen cairn
#

scaled the actually referable to rugops kem kem thing

clever sable
fallow citrus
#

how heavy would an “average sized” apatosaurus be? dinothink

stiff osprey
#

not enough specimens have been measured to make an average

#

But the best specimen is CM 3018, which is like 24 tons

fallow citrus
#

ooh, okay. thankies

tulip dove
#

Speaking of Apato, wasn't there a massive specimen?

stiff osprey
#

there's 40+ tonners in oklahoma yeah

tulip dove
#

Yeah, that one

stiff osprey
#

but they could be Brontosaurus as well

bright veldt
#

Indeterminate apatosaurine #25

white matrix
#

the thing in your pfp isn't a dino

#

mb, no wait you edited it before it was "dino" first

tranquil quartz
#

Atopodentatus is not a dinosaur

limpid glen
#

brachi

white matrix
#

Dinosaurs are reptiles too

sullen cairn
#

no they're birds LatenLOL

west coral
#

they’re both

leaden elm
#

New spinosaurus at the field museum

white matrix
#

real

lavish frigate
abstract flame
#

I went there in Frebruary ._.

tough parcel
compact leaf
#

did a head crest thing actually come out? or are we breaking embargo again

tough parcel
#

It was mentioned in a news article, but the photos are embargoed, yes

tough parcel
lilac vale
tough parcel
#

Don't correct them, Table is a notorious troll and misinformation spreader. Imo, they should be locked in jail for their crimes

lavish frigate
tough parcel
#

Trug...

compact leaf
tough parcel
#

Yes!

lavish frigate
#

Crimes against abelisaurs should be punishable by death. If not for justice alone then at least because my spec evo project is Abelisaurs so I care for them 💀

west coral
tough parcel
#

Hey, that was funny af

west coral
#

still a crime

compact leaf
#

I say this knowing fully that if I started scaling miscellaneous sauropod bits I would commit horrible crimes against god

west coral
#

do it

compact leaf
#

I would but I don't have the effort

leaden elm
lavish frigate
#

Are gastralia not a thing for all dinosaurs or am I a forgetful boi

tough parcel
leaden elm
#

Yeah I think you're right

compact leaf
#

yeah their other mounts have gastralia I'm just assuming it's really hard to give them to a suspended mount

leaden elm
#

Lol it would be hard I imagine

spring lichen
#

I adore being in penned here with so many people who know more about dinosaurs than me, it's so cool

sullen cairn
flat pond
#

Gotta admit, they made Tarbosaurus interesting with its behavior.

https://youtu.be/yTgSxP3lJPQ?si=-FE9nx1mrGD7BcTs

The Camp Cretaceous Tarbosaurus has come to Jurassic World Evolution 2 via the new Cretaceous Predator Pack, in this showcase video I'll show you all of its skins, behaviours, kill animations, other animations, hunts and more.
⭐ Subscribe for more Jurassic World Evolution 2 news, updates and speculation ► http://bit.ly/2f8yPjo

🦖 Jurassic World ...

▶ Play video
sullen cairn
#

baryonyx walkeri with loosely speculative soft tissue and limb articulation

lavish frigate
tranquil quartz
snow python
#

Is alamotyrannus a valid genus or just a big rex?

bright veldt
#

latter, or possibly a second species of Tyrannosaurus

flat pond
#

I mean, they took what they could do with Tarbo the best they could do since Universal did want them to use the CC design but they tweaked it a bit to help it out some. Honestly the other color palettes that it is able to have makes it look better than the colors it has in CC. Also making it roll on the ground like a dog is actually kind of cool compared to the other large theropods.

sudden wind
#

"Tarbo is not unique!! You cannot differenciate from T.Rex!!"
Tarbo :
T.rex :

Though we indeed have some very robust Tarbo that lean toward T.rex like appearances.
https://fxtwitter.com/kta92751434/status/1700755807045087405?s=46&t=cDLUS8KUvySwENm6daWWuw
https://fxtwitter.com/ausar_the/status/1504256769589235714?s=46&t=H2GbZlCtjJzgMcESVWmA2A

#福井県立恐竜博物館
#タルボサウルス
#Tarbosaurus
ポーズが変更になったタルボ氏

獲物を追い詰めるかの様な躍動感のある素敵なお姿になられましたね🤗

It's something of a myth that Tarbosaurus had an extremely narrow snout (like in the left image). Greg Paul corrected this once; top right is his reconstruction (D is Tarbosaurus), bottom right is a Tarbosaurus skull with relatively minimal crushing.

viscid surge
#

I’m not very in-the loop right now with this stuff, but is the consensus tarbosaurus bataar or tyrannosaurus bataar?

sudden wind
#

Anyway i shall now disappear as I have to to finish data processing help me

sudden wind
# viscid surge I’m not very in-the loop right now with this stuff, but is the consensus *tarbos...

Tarbosaurus bataar. But both T.rex and T.bataar are sister taxon so you could lump them tbf. As far as I know both are pretty diagnostic and more fossils from intermediate animals (or Tyrannosaurinis) would be needed to clear out this situation.
I think they both have some of their own synapomorphies, which indicates that they could be 2 separate taxon. Anyway classification in paleontology works a bit different than zoological classification and in both it is quite suggestive.

tacit pine
#

Pot should have added tarbo instead of rex 🥱

#

They anyways wanted to add fancy names to most creatures

flat pond
#

I wasn’t saying that Tarbosaurus couldn’t be differentiated from Tyrannosaurus, I do agree that it should be quite slimmer than Tyrannosaurus and the spike be toned down a bit but I was saying it behaves differently in game somewhat. Most of the larger theropods, when laying on the ground simply rub their head on the ground while Tarbo rolls on the ground fully as if to scratch its back. It acts cautiously when exiting the hatchery compared to many of them bursting out of the gate. Those are the details that I like about Tarbo in JWE2.

white matrix
#

I really want to input my opinion on if the tarbo and trex are related

compact leaf
#

well we know they’re related the debate comes from whether or not tarbosaurus is it’s own genus or a species of tyrannosaurus, as of right now it’s regarded as different enough to warrant its own genus

white matrix
#

Well they are in the same family

#

That's what I gathered from a bit of research

lavish frigate
#

Woah are we talking about my favorite animal Tyrannosaurus bataar again?!

white matrix
#

Well the tarbosaurus became my new favorite dino recently

lavish frigate
viscid surge
white matrix
#

I believe you

lavish frigate
#

Ok but fr though I wouldn’t doubt that they share a genus. Just look at animals today in the same genus, some species are more gracile, some species are more robust, Bataar isn’t even that much more gracile or anything. If Tyrannosaurus was alive today we’d probably recognize Tarbosaurus as a species of Tyrannosaurus

white matrix
#

I have screenshot the facts of that

lavish frigate
#

I give you wolf and coyote dinoguns3

white matrix
#

Here is what I screenshot

viscid surge
white matrix
#

Same family group 2 different genus

analog tendon
#

How accurate is the pot Alioramus?

white matrix
#

That's a good question actually

#

This is a size comparison to the other members of tyrannosauridae family

sullen cairn
#

oh this is why everyone uses 31.5cm for rugops

#

despite the study explicitly on abelisauroid dimensions using 44.4cm

rose thorn
# analog tendon How accurate is the pot Alioramus?

It’s fine for what we have of the animal. None of the alioramines we have are fully grown animals, so it’s not quite clear what may have happened to their skeletal proportions as they reached maturity (outside growing larger)

#

Worst thing may be the crests being too large, but again, all of what we have of Alioramus isn’t mature so them being big in PoT’s is fine

analog tendon
#

Sweet thanks! It’s been my fav Dino since starting to play pot so I was curious if it was another stego situation 😭

heady thunder
#

Stego is not bad tho

analog tendon
#

No it’s not that bad it’s definitely a stego

heady thunder
#

It could be better, bigger plates would be nice.

compact leaf
#

stegos biggest problem is that it’s proportioned after an immature individual, that and the lack of throat armor

white matrix
#

PK ourano

compact leaf
#

another pk w

flat pond
#

Indeed

#

Especially like a skin like this that makes it stand out

tulip dove
#

PK just keeps cooking some of the best dino designs

lilac vale
#

Their Rex needs lips

compact leaf
#

I’m not entirely sure if it would actually show through or not but it had it

nocturne gazelle
#

So stego needs facetank as an ability LatenLOL

heady thunder
#

It looks like it has diseases

tranquil quartz
#

Why does stego have throat greyscale

light osprey
#

Why not

candid igloo
#

Hey guys, quick question.
As you all know, the vision we have of spinos is constantly being changed, so what is it currently? I just watched a video by Paleologic saying they were sort of semi-aquatic, but that was 1 year ago, anybody know anything new?

stiff osprey
#

Semi-aquatic just means an animal spends a lot of time in water, which is accurate, Spinosaurus did

#

Doesn't have to be the majority of its time, animals like water voles are considered semiaquatic but mostly live on land

candid igloo
#

Yes obviously, but it’s constantly changing so I just wanted to check

lavish frigate
#

Spinosaurus had the ecological niche of a duck and nobody can tell me otherwise IggyThumbsUp

sullen cairn
#

benthic durophage

light osprey
#

Suspension feeder

west coral
#

filter feeder

compact leaf
#

sift feeder

white matrix
#

aerial hunter

scenic flame
#

radiotrophe

fallow citrus
#

arboreal hunter

tranquil quartz
#

It was clearly a parasite, which spent its whole life attached to Carcharodontosaurus

steady rock
sullen cairn
tough parcel
#

Erm...do the smallest Sinoceratops and the largest Tarbosaurus to properly reflect population demographics

stiff osprey
#

either sino's smaller than i thought or the EVIL table used the more complete holotype as average instead of factoring in the larger specimen known from a random glupshitto bone fragment

little mauve
#

Have you scaled the giant Hypsibema material? Not sure if that's doable or not

#

Would be interested in that plus Appalachiosaurus for the tyrannosaur/hadrosaur chart

steady rock
storm heron
stiff osprey
#

a skull iirc

storm heron
#

Im assuming its a skull fragment?

rose thorn
limpid glen
#

whats iirc??

steady rock
tough parcel
light osprey
#

Why would you compare outlying sized Individuals of one taxa to averages of another 😭

steady rock
#

because i thought average sinoceratops was 4.6 tons while the largest tarbo was like, 5.5 tons

white matrix
#

P.S. we don’t have an average for like 90+% of fossil taxa, most largest specimens are the only specimens, especially with dinosaurs

limpid glen
tough parcel
spare knot
#

lookin at the skeleton, looks impossible to be quad xD

bright veldt
#

It was a mix

storm heron
#

This could be my intrepretation but, dont the arms of Ouranosaurus seem too small for it to be walking efficiently on all fours?

white matrix
#

Would we even realistically be able to care for a Rex in captivity? Doesn't seem like it to me

ancient crystal
#

I don't see why not, unless its like a Great White scenerio where the animal gives up by default when put in captivity

storm heron
#

It depends on the behavior of Tyrannosaurus rex,

white matrix
storm heron
#

Some animals do not do well in captivity,

white matrix
#

Ignoring behavior, would we be able to provide enough food and space for a Rex?

storm heron
white matrix
#

And?

ancient crystal
#

I wouldn't doubt we'd be able to provide enough food, space would probably be an issue though

storm heron
#

It just seems inefficient to me to use its front limbs for locomotion when it can just walk better bipedally .

stiff osprey
#

(this is not an exaggeration, an 8 ton theropod's food requirements are equal about two 500kg mammals)

white matrix
storm heron
#

Alright It seems I severely misremembered the size of their front limbs. Yea I can see them walking in fours.

stiff osprey
#

standing quadrupedally to graze, probably

#

but it's clearly moving bipedally if it wants to actually get anywhere

storm heron
#

Yea, that is what I was thinking

light osprey
storm heron
#

But then I see some other skeletal recons of it in a quadruped stance, and it seems it can comfortably walk so I am a little unsure.

stiff osprey
#

This skeletal was definitely changed proportion wise compared to Hartman's quadrupedal one

storm heron
#

Yea, speaking of, which one is more accurate? or are they both good?

sullen cairn
#

this is what quad ourano looks like

stiff osprey
#

I have no idea, Ouranosaurus was on my to do list once but it's been killed and buried by real life work

storm heron
#

If that frontlimb can support its front body, then yea I can see it walking on fours (But you aint convincing me it ran on all fours).

stiff osprey
white matrix
#

I feel like Ourano's digits were probably not as dainty as they look

storm heron
stiff osprey
#

eughghg

#

I saw a diagram of that once and it was offensive to my eyes

storm heron
#

Oooof

white matrix
#

Reminder that Rex could bench around 400lbs with its arms

sullen cairn
#

ourano manus for reference

storm heron
#

Stubby carpals and phalanges

#

Though, I wonder how the ROM of the shoulder is.

rose thorn
light osprey
sullen cairn
#

the paper describes the unguals as hoof-like although it doesn't elaborate much on what that actually entails

sullen cairn
#

well the paper mentions another paper says that but it doesn't seem to rebut the statement either

rose thorn
#

Love early ornithopod gait discourse

light osprey
sullen cairn
#

but yeah i think we can all agree it was largely if not almost entirely bipedal for general locomotion

rose thorn
#

Tenontosaurus, Camptosaurus, and Ouranosaurus, the permanent "So are we sure it's biped??"

sullen cairn
#

and of course baryonyx HappyCampto

light osprey
#

Trug…

rose thorn
#

Kill it

stiff osprey
#

The amount of times I've seen it discussed whether Mantellisaurus was bipedal or not is almost equal to the amount of times Mantellisaurus is mentioned at all

light osprey
sullen cairn
spare knot
stiff osprey
# sullen cairn

We could have this today if some rando in the 90s didn't decide that theropods were forbidden from pronating their hands

sullen cairn
#

i just remembered i also lost said biped edit because my computer nuked all my skeletal stuff five minutes after i made that baryonyx

worth it

rose thorn
#

Poor Brighstoneus, Barilium, and Hypselospinus

stiff osprey
sullen cairn
#

pretend this isn't brightstoneus and we're good

stiff osprey
#

woah.... mantellisaurus

sullen cairn
#

😠

stiff osprey
sullen cairn
#

shoulda kept it that way tbh

rose thorn
#

We love wastebasket genera saddab

light osprey
#

wastebasket speciose ☺️

woeful falcon
sullen cairn
#

welcome to megalosaurus, we have the abyss, including but not limited to, megalosaurus dunkeri (which isn't the same as altispinax dunkeri) and megalosaurus chubutensis (which isn't the same as tyrannotitan chubutensis) and there is a nonzero chance may be a 10m+ abelisaur, among other wonderful nomen dubia

woeful falcon
sullen cairn
#

brightstoneus has a stupid looking skull ngl

rose thorn
woeful falcon
#

Not incorrect. It could almost have a good looking skull if it didn't looked stretched out in mspaint

rose thorn
rose thorn
#

Selective feeder moment

sullen cairn
#

i like how its ostensibly literally just iguanodon with a sail

stiff osprey
#

nonavian dinosaurs when they're told the function has bony display structures

light osprey
#

Neural spines when they exist

rose thorn
#

Iguanodonts/Hadrosaurs when you tell them don't throw their backs out: Magnapaulia

woeful falcon
#

Shoulda just evolved feathers smh the coelurosaurs be KILLING it with em

sullen cairn
#

this and many more reasons is why spinosaurids are actually lambeosaurines

stiff osprey
#

-tall spine
-proposed to be quadrupedal
-semiaquatic (snorkel parasaurolophus theory)

yeah they seem similar enough

rose thorn
light osprey
#

Saurolophinae polyphyletic 💯

ruby patio
sullen cairn
#

appalachiosaurus and giant hypsibema

bright veldt
#

I forgot about that hadrosauroid

woeful falcon
#

I can see why

bright veldt
#

pfff

woeful falcon
#

I actually didn't know about it til right this second tbh

bright veldt
#

I’ve heard of it because of it being pretty massive. It’s the largest named Appalachian dinosaur tmk.

sullen cairn
#

you could probably argue astrophocaudia or one of the other albian sauropods are appalachian
that or they just miss the splitting of NA

#

wait astrophocaudia is tiny lmao

#

and why is there referred cedarosaurus material in paluxy

subtle sand
#

Hello there. Quick contest, I'm a student in game design, and we regularly have to create game concepts.
I have a game in mind, a game that make use of ancient mammals that lived between the paleocene and the miocene, and I need some info.

For now, regarding carnivorous species, this is my roster :

-Andrewsarcus : Brawler
-Hyenodon : Pursuit/ambush hunter
-Entelodont : Pursuit/scavenger/omnivore.
-Terror bird : Full pursuit
-Smilodon : Ambush/Brawler.

Because these are quite big animals, I would love to add a smaller predator, one that use pack hunting to make it more unique. Do you have suggestions?

bright veldt
#

I would recommend Cave Hyenas, given that hyenas are pretty underrepresented in Cenozoic media despite them essentially being THE top predator of Ice Age Eurasia

subtle sand
#

@bright veldt I saw your suggestion just after seeing a Instagram post about these creatures. The fact I scared of hyenas might make it a good challenge, or traumatized me even more when doing research 😂

subtle sand
#

Quick question, do Cave hyenas do well in hotter climate? Because the environment of the game is far from being an Ice age

candid igloo
#

Hey does anyone have a good phylogenetic tree for sauropodomorpha? I can’t find any complete ones online

#

I found some for theropoda and ornithischia but sauropodomorpha

bright veldt
light osprey
#

If it includes Titanosauriformes in some detail there is no such thing.

candid igloo
#

The only one that is seems kind of complete has Titanosauriformes so idk

flat pond
bright veldt
#

That topic reminds me of a very interesting youtube channel. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sIK9Jm2zv5g

Here is a video talking about the possible health concerns and welfare for the famous Tyrannosaurus rex, I hope you enjoy!

Credit: gorodenkoff
iStock
Stock photo ID:1312318034

https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0007288#:~:text=The severity of trichomonosis-related,disease%2C mostly likely through ...

▶ Play video
lucid ibex
#

Can i get some accurate deinonychus to human size comparisons? They might need to be upper estimates because it’s for a creative project of mine

bright veldt
#

by @tough parcel

magic monolith
#

Sp means we know the genus but not species right?
Just checking

sullen cairn
#

indeterminate species yeah

vapid lotus
#

sp mean space pop

sullen cairn
#

sp is short for sans undertale

vapid lotus
#

sans papyrus

snow python
#

Accurate?

bright veldt
#

What even is it6?

stiff osprey
#

Himalayasaurus?

woeful falcon
#

Beth

vapid lotus
#

perucetus

lavish frigate
#

Why is heli so big?!

bright veldt
#

Yeah it's huge. Basically as big as leedsichthys.

lavish frigate
#

Wait how big is Leeds

bright veldt
#

12 meters, 17 tons. Helicoprion can get to the same length and is only slightly lighter.

sudden wind
sudden wind
#

Tarbosaurus is often depicted with a substantially narrower snout than good ol' T. rex.

However, there are Tarbosaurus skulls with broad, T. rex-like snouts, or at least broader snouts than the generalised skull drawings you sometimes see.

Figures from Hurum & Sabbath, 2003.

#

Also laterally compressed mean that they are squashed on the sides, and so are thinner than what they are expected to be in life animal. So I don't really know what you meant by that except if you confused it with "dorsally".

#

More examples used restored uncompressed/undistorded materials.

sudden wind
lilac vale
#

Thank god

sudden wind
#

I hope their mods will come out more regularly after Pachyrhinosaurus.

candid igloo
#

I’ve been out of the paleo community for too long. I’ve forgotten everything, I had to look up what ornithischians were this morning. I have sunk low

white matrix
#

Howdy howdy everyone

heady thunder
viscid surge
bright veldt
#

Largely soft-bodied prey yeah, but I think it's been shown to have enough force to go through ammonites and nautiloids too

heady thunder
compact leaf
white field
heady thunder
#

Well, yeah

sudden wind
#

Just not the super stupid thin ones

heady thunder
safe pier
#

How long do you think an allosaurus could run for?

civic lava
#

Jugamos

ruby patio
#

Ah, found its skull

sullen cairn
#

I am happy to announce that you can downsize giant sino to <6t if you scale it with the sty gdi snout-femur instead of total length

sullen cairn
#

it was like 7t

#

the holotype was 4t
although i guess that'd shrink too

#

saying that it seems to go back up to 6.5t scaling femur-coracoid

white matrix
#

better

sullen cairn
#

stupid animal

hallow spear
#

real

sullen cairn
#

actually y'know what sinoceratops is like a conceptually stupid animal
like this thing shouldn't exist

#

its the single ceratopsid in asia and also a 6t+ centrosaurine just hanging around in the middle of the campanian

hallow spear
#

lmao

sullen cairn
#

cause gat's skeletal is an ugly potato and i must fix it

white matrix
#

You should totally make your own skeletal (real)

sullen cairn
#

i'm 90% sure the majority of the material in gat's skeletal is sitting around chinese collections at which point i'd be left with a wendiceratops headswap or something

#

yet another reason this is a stupid animal

white matrix
#

probably should stick with abelisaurs for now

sullen cairn
#

but all the new papers are closed access and about random teeth

#

now i would gladly scale the teeth but the closed-access part puts a slight damper in things

white matrix
#

tyrannosaurs? You made a chart afaik

sullen cairn
#

i was working on some basal ones until the hand of god smit me for making quad bary

idle talon
#

Is giraffatitan a valid genus?

compact leaf
#

yes

west coral
white matrix
#

Make pug quad and give them wings

steady rock
#

what was the largest paleogene - cenozic land predator?

west coral
#

Barinasuchus iirc

steady rock
#

how big?

tough parcel
#

50 tons (2 tons)

steady rock
#

crazy

west coral
steady rock
#

is there a list of top ten largest terrestial predators of the ceneozoic

white matrix
#

Paraentelodon, Arctodus, Megistotherium are some I know

west coral
#

Here’s nine but add paraentelodon

white matrix
steady rock
#

urus looks so sad

tough parcel
#

Yea, it's blue

white matrix
#

Btw why do so many creature size charts use the weirdest for scale humans?

light osprey
#

Ursus maritimus surprises me with its size

tough parcel
white matrix
#

I've seen so many that use anime girls for scale

tough parcel
#

Uhh yea?? That's a problem???

white matrix
#

Of course not, just amusing

ancient crystal
#

I saw a size chart the other day that used king kong so anything is possible

tough parcel
#

Trug...

west coral
#

tried to make a chart with big cenozoic land carnivores

lavish frigate
#

General accuracy rating on my boi I drew last night when I was bored?

west coral
white matrix
light osprey
lavish frigate
#

Any accuracy criticisms though?

white matrix
#

gives me albertosaurine vibes ngl

lavish frigate
#

i exaggerate the keratin in the lacrimal crests when I do Tyrannosaurs. That’s probably why

west coral
white matrix
#

Populator is the biggest cat atm

sullen cairn
#

operation make neutral sino not look stupid attempt 2

#

i am growing increasingly perturbed by this thing's monkey tail

stiff osprey
#

looks pretty good except the soft tissue distribution on the neck is mildly disturbing

white matrix
#

I meant more in weight being ~900lbs not sure of amphis weight estimates

stiff osprey
#

you mean 900 lbs right

#

900 kg is arctodus/andrewsarchus sized

white matrix
#

pounds ye mistyped kg

west coral
#

1 ton smilodon

sullen cairn
#

now i'm actually curious if there's a single gat ceratopsid without hideous inferred postcrania

white matrix
light osprey
stiff osprey
lavish frigate
light osprey
#

The booger holes yep 😎

lavish frigate
#

Maybe I’ll keep his design for my new lil project I might be doing about prehistoric animals in the modern day rex

sullen cairn
#

because i'm using gat's scaling until i remember the paratype's probably in the description and i could just scale it myself

#

now that you say it that doesn't seem like a half bad idea

west coral
#

piss indeed

light osprey
#

what does it all mean

sullen cairn
#

that 8m sino might be more than just a manic episode

white matrix
west coral
#

first shrinking centrosaurines, now growing them to unfathomable sizes

#

table is truly unstoppable

sullen cairn
#

i mean it was already big so its not really my fault...

lavish frigate
#

So was paraceratherium doing the lil trunk thing or the hornless Rhino face?

lucid ibex
lucid ibex
light osprey
white matrix
lavish frigate
#

👍

white matrix
lavish frigate
#

Hmmm….im faced with two conflicting opinions…..what shall I do…..

ancient crystal
#

Make its lip into a trunk

white matrix
fossil ingot
sullen cairn
#

i would like to wish all sinoceratops a very jesus christ

stiff osprey
#

zhucheng formation hadrosaur: largest hadrosaur that ever existed
zhucheng formation ceratopsid: like second largest ceratopsid
zhucheng formation tyrannosaur: top 3 largest tyrannosaurs
zhucheng formation titanosaur:

storm heron
#

The proportions on this animal is just weird

#

Maybe its just the silhoutte, but Sinoceratops front limbs are proportionally huge, Gorillaceratops

sullen cairn
#

yeah that's kinda just centrosaurines for ya

#

i have a stubbier version but it just looks weird next to every other centrosaurine

storm heron
#

It does look weird compared to other Centrosaurines, seems more . . . "elongated"? I wonder if that is the right word. Also, compare its scapula to other Centrosaurines . . .

sullen cairn
#

gat's skeletal at least seems to take after the wendi skeletal (which has barely any caudals actually) in having a long tail for a ceratopsid
and yeah scapula is really big (i'd assume gat saw it in a museum or something in china cause afaik none of the postcrania is described)

#

now that you mention it you can make the forearms a lot less beefy-looking if you tilt the whole body forward like the other skeletals

storm heron
#

Yea, though it still gives that Gorilla arm look, which isn't just due to the forearm size themselves, as its hindlimbs seem more short and stout compared to Pachyrhinosaurus for example.

#

How much can you tilt its body forward akin to its relatives until it starts falling forward.

sullen cairn
storm heron
#

Looks more similar now yea.

sullen cairn
#

the black space doesn't help it look any familiar either

storm heron
#

We got to work with what we got, till then we have stubbyceratops.

#

Very curious to what and how Centrosaurines were doing in Asia.

sullen cairn
#

evidently growing way too big for their own good

#

looking at it i think at least some of the gorilla-arm might be due to the less due to actual robusticity and more being extended and thus appearing more columnar compared to the more bent forelimbs of the other skeletals

storm heron
#

You could be right, it could be more comparable if other skeletals made their forearms more columnar than always bent (something im curious of why they do it).

sullen cairn
#

the bent articulation does look nicer i'd say

storm heron
#

Well for me, it looks like they are playing "floor is lava" and trying to stand on a small patch of ground ha

sullen cairn
#

and then there's the question of why the thing needs to be 8m long

storm heron
#

Perhaps the Zhchengtyrannus specimen we found was actually on the smaller end of the size range of its species

sullen cairn
#

tfw a ceratopsid is half the size of the resident sauropod

#

also i just realized the gorilla arms are also cause the thing has tiny metatarsals

storm heron
#

Yea, seems like its hindlimbs were short relative to its body and other Centrosaurines.

sullen cairn
#

and it looks even worse in gat's original

hallow drift
#

If someone has a picture of rex tooth can they dm me it

bright veldt
#

There is alot of new info on Thylacoleo ecology in this abstract that just released

white matrix
#

Yay finally

bright veldt
#

I don’t cause funni pre-release abstract

white matrix
#

trug….

novel atlas
novel atlas
rose thorn
# west coral *why*

North America when it saw Sino and Shant: Anything you can do, I can do better

chilly knot
#

with scalebar

vocal breach
rose thorn
compact leaf
rose thorn
#

Shant was simply too powerful to match

light osprey
rose thorn
#

Someone @ mods

bitter oasis
#

@storm tartan Please keep this chat about paleo discussion, thank you.

west coral
sudden wind
west coral
#

yeah pinaco is tiny

white matrix
#

Tarbo looks like a midget

tough parcel
#

I am like 99% sure Pinaco and Tarbo are misscaled

woeful falcon
#

Is it tarbo and not zhu?

white matrix
west coral
#

Zhucheng

white matrix
#

Oh mb

lilac vale
white matrix
#

No arctotherium is smaller, way smaller.

lilac vale
white matrix
#

Outdated information arctotherium was never bigger than arctodus.

sudden wind
#

Still not a huge ankylosaur.

tough parcel
#

Based on a private specimen that I know about, it could reach sizes of 10 tons

tough parcel
#

Me

sudden wind
#

you leading the way to me to the 10 tons private specimen

#

my grammar was atrocious on this one tho

tough parcel
west coral
#

still a tiny fella

heady thunder
#

Zycheng looks like Rexes kid

light osprey
#

Science is a beautiful thing 😊

sudden wind
#

Kinda depends of how you scale it (sometimes people use Tyrannosaurus lmfao). But yeah it seems to barely reach 10 meters.

I don't think we have any good skeletal though given that previous ones were based on older Tarbo iterations.

sullen cairn
#

headswap of joan's tarbo headswap with joan's newer tarbo

tough parcel
#

Isn’t that just…their newer Tarbo?

sudden wind
#

And that marginally increases Zuchengtyrannus' size.

sullen cairn
#

scaling down its like 9.7m and 3.8t

tough parcel
#

Ah

west coral
#

added new zhucheng and sinanky

snow python
#

Is zupaysaurus related to dilo?

sullen cairn
#

In the sense that they’re both in the mess of neotheropods grading into averostra yes

stiff osprey
#

Oh wait the red is north american, I thought this was a giant asian taxon

tough parcel
#

Silly random, being a silly goober again

rose thorn
#

Also no Mongol Giant M1_nobitches

light osprey
#

Mmm yes my favourite Wangshi Group taxon

west coral
#

definitely

compact leaf
tacit pine
#

Tarchia is W

sudden wind
west coral
#

and I also don’t know where you’re going to fit eotrike in there

sudden wind
#

I mean the size difference between Sino and Zucheng is legit the one of Eo and Rex in game.

sullen cairn
#

which is funny cause sino and eo are pretty close in size

west coral
#

maybe ingame rex is just zhucheng

light osprey
west coral
sudden wind
snow python
#

Do we have any skin impressions from ichthyosaurs and plesiosaurs?

bright veldt
#

Ichthyosaurs yes. Plesiosaurs not really tmk.

sudden wind
tough parcel
#

Probably climate change lmao

jagged trellis
#

rng with a dash of yes

warm quest
#

tryna draw opabinia but i have no idea which way its mouth opens... is there a correct orientation or do we just not really know? 😭 i see paleoart of both ways

bright veldt
light osprey
#

Remarkably tangible looking art of the fella

lilac vale
#

Part of a lot of extinctions going on at that time

warm quest
lucid gyro
fresh smelt
#

Can anyone give me access to pic of accurate para

bright veldt
white matrix
#

Cankles

tough parcel
#

I mean...I triiied?

#

It's a bit festive, but thankfully it's already that time of year again Nature so yayyy

light osprey
#

Horizontal stripes? Heresy

white matrix
lavish frigate
meager spindle
bright veldt
#

Thylacoleo was a mesopedator that wasn't hunting the same prey as megalania anyway.

meager spindle
#

@bright veldt True, however if you think about it, modern day Komodo dragons in their prime are able to hunt arboreal prey as well if given the chance. With the same body plan it seems more likely for this reptile to have the same intentions to hunt opportunistically. Especially hunting Thylacoleo. Idk maybe it's just me

bright veldt
#

Adult komodo dragons can't climb, let alone a lizard 5x the body mass

meager spindle
bright veldt
#

Ok fair enough

pearl briar
sullen cairn
#

walkeri's just a sissy next to the southwestern paras

pearl briar
#

WHAT

#

does that mean Fadeno is outdated?

sullen cairn
#

yeah
the big braincase got reassigned to a brachylophosaurin

scenic flame
#

do bear in mind that is one specimen of many of one para species

sullen cairn
#

afaik none of the canadian lambeosaurines got particularly massive

#

the largest in northern laramidia seem to cap out at like 4-4.5t tops

opal portal
#

Beep

surreal stone
surreal stone
#

assuming we dont know which one

#

also thanks, thats helpful

tough parcel
#

A little tidbit to note when reading paleontology papers not made by paleontologists (mostly the last half)

pearl briar
#

is 8 meters long and 907 kg-1 ton Ichthyovenator is still accurate?

flat pond
#

Well this was unexpected but I welcome it

viscid surge
scarlet moon
#

Damn that looks good

flat pond
#

It was announced this morning and was even in this trailer

https://youtu.be/yKrvqjhPD8M?si=nMsGYsfAinjAuZjD

Update 9 is coming soon on December 16! Introducing 3 new species, the grassland biome, and swimming, this major title update will give players the ultimate opportunity to expand their Prehistoric Kingdom.

Buy on Steam: https://store.steampowered.com/app/666150/Prehistoric_Kingdom/
Buy on Epic Games: https://store.epicgames.com/en-US/p/prehist...

▶ Play video
snow python
#

How big was Barsboldia after all?

bright veldt
#

11 meters, 7 tons

white matrix
flat pond
#

It is. Wasn’t expecting it come so soon

#

Also another update to PK so soon is really surprising

white matrix
#

Suspiciously aligns with the new JWE2 dlc

pearl briar
bright veldt
#

We don’t even have spino arms

white matrix
#

The arms look fine to me

#

real

#

The only issue I can spot is the debatable lips

Or rather, lack thereof

#

Honestly the only PK design I've ever had a problem with thus far has been their Rex

bright veldt
#

That’s something that nobody can really figure out though. Spinosaurus’s tooth config is really weird. You can go with lips for other spinosaurs (like bary and sucho) without much trouble, but spino’s weird.

white matrix
#

That's why I said debatable

bright veldt
#

And yeah PK’s Rex rubs me the wrong way. All the other dinosaurs are unapologetically accurate while the rex kinda feels like they tried to make a JP Rex under a more accurate lens.

white matrix
#

It just stands out like a sore Iguanodon thumb and I hate it

flat pond
#

Honestly, PK’s rex doesn’t bother me that much. Especially when you do a comparison like this.

PK Tyrannosaurus has partial lips but is done in a way that makes it seem a little natural.

PoT Tyrannosaurus’ partial lipped teeth clip into the lower jaw and feels a bit awkward

white matrix
#

Nah dude the teeth stick out and ruin the design

flat pond
#

Eh, I’m fine with it. Might be just me.

white matrix
#

Also I don't use the exposed teeth sub on PoT Rex anyways

flat pond
white matrix
#

At least the juvenile's teeth are temporary

flat pond
#

True but it’s still so awkward and the way they clip into the lower jaw is not visually appealing to me.

white matrix
#

I also kinda wished PK Rex had the elephant hair feathers but I understand that that was probably left out for performance

flat pond
#

Probably very hard to render in given how small they would most likely be

white matrix
#

Exactly

#

Btw speaking of dino zoo builders, JWE2 genuinely stuns me with a lot of the creatures that Frontier designs (in a good way)

#

Utah, Cheri and Conca are absolutely gorgeous

flat pond
#

Yeah Frontier does really well with their newer designs.

white matrix
#

You know it's a little concerning when the Jurassic Conca is more accurate than the PoT one

flat pond
#

They even tried to make Tarbo work, even though it is the CC one

white matrix
#

I give Tarbo a pass cause they had to use the CC design

flat pond
#

They did tweaked it a bit to give it a bit of Frontier’s flare

white matrix
#

I just hope they don't use the CC Smilodon design if they ever add Smilo

#

God I want them to add Smilodon...

flat pond
#

I dont think they will add Cenozoic animals to JWE2

#

From what I’ve heard anyways.

white matrix
#

I mean, if Smilodon wasn't canon I'd probably agree but Smilodon is a part of canonical media so...

#

Plus it'd add some much needed variety in the land carnivores imo

flat pond
#

True but I’ve heard people asking them to do it and they have stated that they would probably not do it.

exotic quest
#

I'd rather they add more Triassic or maybe Permian animals before they start heading for Cenozoic

white matrix
#

Also I want them to bring back the hybrids and add Spinoceratops alongside them but that's a different can of worms

exotic quest
#

A majority of the DLC packs have been about the Cretaceous, like give us some more Triassic or even Jurassic

flat pond
#

Yeah, the JWE hybrids were pretty cool

exotic quest
#

Maybe an updated Ankylodocus design though bc it looked weird

flat pond
white matrix
#

I'd also like mini-exhibits so I can have Microraptor

flat pond
#

Microraptor would be cool to have

white matrix
#

Mini exhibits would also finally give us good options for Compy and Homalo enclosures

exotic quest
white matrix
#

Give me mini lagoons for Cambrian bois

exotic quest
#

Give us kelp or a lagoon update that actually makes them feel alive

white matrix
#

Mini aviaries for Microraptor, Archaeopteryx and Anurognathus

#

Little pens for Compy, Homalo and Lystro

lavish frigate
white matrix
#

Also now that we have basking rocks in lagoons, give us crocs

exotic quest
#

yes

#

and also different types of 'land' for lagoons

white matrix
#

I also wanna change the water color

exotic quest
#

i want wall lights

white matrix
#

I wanna alter the terrain in lagoons

bitter oasis
#

I understand how the conversation got to this point but let's please keep the chat on the topic of paleo discussion Aliove

fossil ingot
white matrix
neat drum
#

If your that long and top heavy with such long arms, you're gonna go quad to stretch

frosty anvil
white matrix
frosty anvil
white matrix
heady thunder
neat drum
heady thunder
#

What tree?

#

Ok, wdym accurately predicted? Accurate as in model?

neat drum
#

The PoT rex is not accurate at all and one of the worst media depictions of rex in the 2010s-2020s Pepepeek

heady thunder
#

Its decently accurate, what I remember being wrong is the face in some places.

cloud dagger
#

Pot rex is still better than jp rex

heady thunder
#

Pot babies are not accurate 9/10 times.

#

It has a decent amount of abilities. Sound is subjective, I quite like it, the only problem I have with it is the sitting and sleeping noise being so loud.

ancient crystal
#

Its nails on a chalkboard

I don't know how rex mains can stand spam calling their atrocious broadcast

heady thunder
#

Rex doesnt have a headbutt.
Spino has stomp too.

And were not talking too much

lean egret
#

What’s the most inaccurate dinosaur in PoT?

heady thunder
lean egret
heady thunder
#

Facetank is a passive abilitity.

lean egret
#

I hate it so much.
If you want a generic plesiosaur, then choose one. Don’t pick a unique one and butcher it.

#

I dislike the Spino tbh, PK Spino is an example of a good Spino

tacit pine
lean egret
#

Devs can def make some good looking dinosaurs if they want, but it seems like they don’t even try sometimes

compact leaf
#

bars is pretty bad from an accuracy standpoint as well, and before anyone says we only have the vertebrae that’s not an excuse we still have its close relatives to base off

lean egret
#

PoTs roster itself is pretty bad

lean egret
compact leaf
heady thunder
lean egret
#

Some of the older Dinos genuinely look horrible, some of them also have really strange textures, just look so dry…

tacit pine
#

Spinos design changes alot over the years tbf

heady thunder
lean egret
#

Deinonychus needs a retexture tbh
Or even a slight remodel like Laten

fossil ingot
heady thunder
heady thunder
#

They havent said that.

Theyve said that dinos will get remodels if they need to fit with their new combat abilities

lean egret
fossil ingot
compact leaf
#

it just goes to quad when it stretches and drinks, it's not primarily quad

lean egret
heady thunder
lean egret
scenic flame
fossil ingot
heady thunder
scenic flame
# lean egret Bringing old dino’s to modern quality, yeah

the remodels are happening mainly due to older, lower quality models needing to be brought up to standard, and in the process Jiggy is making accuracy tweaks since they're being edited anyways, she isn't and shouldn't be expected to updated the models every time something new comes out

lean egret
heady thunder
lean egret
clever sable
#

Looks pretty quad to me

light osprey
#

I guess it all depends on a teensy lil specifics of can a big armed theropod support its weight momentarily on those phalanges

woeful falcon
#

Yeah in that one still it is assuming a quad position as opposed to how it moves in the rest of the vid

The real thing you should be targeting is it being on its knuckles

light osprey
#

I’m surprised it’s colourscheme is on the drab side

compact leaf
#

it probably has a brighter skin

onyx sedge
#

Does anyone have a accurate skeletal of ampelosaurus?

white matrix
#

iirc there isn't much good ones

compact leaf
#

yeah there isn't a great one out there

#

best you can do is base it off closely related titanosaurs, it has osteoderms but it really doesn't stray far from the generic titanosaur look

light osprey
light osprey
compact leaf
real swan
#

Please try to keep this channel on-topic to paleo discussion, thankyou!

lean egret
# clever sable

picks one frame out of literally every other where it’s bipedal Looks pretty quad to me

light osprey
#

something seems so uncanny about this fella I have no idea what it is

lean egret
#

Last thing to end this discussion: It’s primarily bipedal and only quad in certain animations, like the roar in the photo you sent👍alright back to paleo stuff

bright veldt
#

There’s nothing on what ampelosaurus really looks like outside of “generic titanosaur”, cause bonebed

clever sable
lean egret
bright veldt
#

I like how people are saying the spino is quad when we literally see its hand touch the ground in one animation, not even using said limb to move.

#

Like Jesus, they’re allowed to at least play with the idea a little bit.

sullen cairn
#

Needless polarization? In my Spinosaurus discussion? It's more likely than I think?

lean egret
#

I remember hearing Spino physically can’t walk on it’s rear legs, is that true? Like I remember recently hearing this, I don’t mean 2014

sullen cairn
#

that would be thanks to long bone allometry, which has also produced such wonders as 9t pentaceratops and 2.4t acrocanthosaurus

clever sable
white matrix
bright veldt
#

^ We don’t see it walk quad at all. People need to chill.

alpine island
west coral
stiff osprey
#

sees rex rearing up to look over an obstacle Holy [censored] guys, they made T.rex have retro posture! This game is terrible!

white matrix
#

real

jagged trellis
#

the game is terrible, just not for that, also ooh 9t penta the next eo mayhaps, would be funny

steep needle
#

how is the game terrible lmao

jagged trellis
#

just lacking in general, its not good a good game at all, but that debate has been done a million times over with the same answer, and gonna be frank i doubt it'll get far in paleo chat

#

so uhh insert topic here that won't get wiped out: diplodocus had color findings yeah, rusty red?

steep needle
steep needle
#

tis a cool tidbit for drawing it

jagged trellis
#

(|| and has lacked major baseline content and quality for many things while also being just very...back and forth on balance, and said early access being atleast 5+ years, i do like discussing the game and its ordeals but moreso just don't want it to get nuked by mods||) and yeah belly was yellowish white if i recall, just need to find the sources i do, it is genuinely interesting we have found out the color of a animal with no feathers, does change up the idea of how things preserve id imagine

woeful falcon
#

There are channels for talking about the game if you don't want to try and sneak convos in haha

jagged trellis
#

yup, just slightly tricky to keep it flowing is all, so idk i'll just end it here: dinosaur

woeful falcon
#

True. Dinosaur.

sullen cairn
#

i concur. dinosaur

steep needle
#

yes, dinosaur

surreal stone
surreal stone
woeful falcon
#

I was about to say you've done that with fred like 3 times lol

mossy anchor
#

Pteradactyl is not a real animal, right? I feel like I remember hearing the name “pteradactyl” does not belong to any one animal

mellow ruin
#

No it isn't a name, but I don't really know what it is.

mossy anchor
#

So it’s not a real animal

mellow ruin
#

Yes

compact leaf
mossy anchor
#

A place I go to has a pteradactyl as their macot, and I’m trying to get it changed because it’s not real (the design is also very behind and inaccurate)

slim needle
#

There’s Pterodactylus but not Pterodactyl

light osprey
bright veldt
#

Pterodactyl can be used as a short term for pterodactyloidea, which is basically all Cretaceous pterosaurs

hallow spear
#

yes but its an an animal itself which was the point i think

alpine island
#

What are some of the largest pterosaurs besides the giant azhdarchids

surreal stone
bright veldt
#

Pteranodon, Tropeognathus, and Coloborhynchus are among the largest non-ahzdarchid pterosaurs. Thalassodromeus I guess also counts even if close to the group.

alpine island
#

Dang I only knew about Coloborhynchus' existence from JW The Game, had no idea it was actually large

bright veldt
#

It’s remains are admittedly terrible

alpine island
#

I'm in despair. Seems like there's a paper that is suggesting Moganopterus wasn't a large pterosaur

lavish frigate
#

The next paleo nerf just arrived! (This is a joke 💀)

crude latch
lavish frigate
#

Then I just rounded out those fins to make it childproof dinoguns3

crude latch
#

Tbh in the lens’s of prehistory Heli is smol

#

Eh well kinda smol

lavish frigate
#

I used to think heli was like mako size 😳

crude latch
#

💀

lavish frigate
#

I’d never actually seen a depiction with good scale before the OG version of that skeletal

lavish frigate
#

Oh heck it evolved again….

crude latch
#

Bros a Pokémon now

mossy anchor
#

Any good papers on the history of paleontology? I'm not talking dinosaurs, I mean where the science all began, important figures, important events, etc. Thanks!

compact leaf
#

I don't have any papers but Georges Cuvier was really influential to early paleontology, he was a pretty huge figure in the early days of the field

white matrix
#

Whatever happened to Barnum brown

mossy anchor
#

I did find an article on wikipedia, but I don't know how trustworthy it is (it is wikipedia). at the same time, it is the only article I found on this

lavish frigate
#

Well there goes the childproofing….

crude latch
#

wtf 💀

lavish frigate
#

Arazoa paleo chat is an interesting place dinoguns3

crude latch
#

Nah lemme get in there

#

Arazoa you said

lavish frigate
crude latch
#

Strange I can’t find it, oh do I gotta be approved?

tough parcel
#

The feeble average Tyrannosaurus vs superior average Triceratops

lavish frigate
crude latch
#

On it

compact leaf
tough parcel
#

The caption says it DuckyGrumpToad

light osprey
#

But actually what is itstruthiothink

sullen cairn
#

subadult leptoceratops and scotty

compact leaf
#

leptoceratops is secretly just a really weird sauropod with some goofy ontogeny

light osprey
tacit pine
#

How big was Pliosaurus Kenvei?

west coral
tough parcel
#

crowthink I kinda just did

pearl briar
light osprey
light oxide
#


Anyways, that said, we sure there isn't any individual variation shenanigans going on?

iron python
#

Guys just an question, in last movie from jurassic world it says giga was the biggest carnivore in world. Is it right? For me it was rex bcs he's name, tyranossauros rex

stiff osprey
#

The biggest carnivore in the world is the blue whale (krill are still living animals), but if you only count animals that lived on land, either Giga or rex could be the biggest

iron python
#

I was asking abt the dinos but thxx

crude latch
#

They said land carnivore in the movie, and atm I think it’s Trex again

jagged trellis
tough parcel
#

Me adding 2 inches of neck tissue and suddenly gaining 5 tons

light osprey
#

Deja vu

mellow ruin
snow python
#

Is there any eurypterid bigger than Jaekelopterus?

bright veldt
#

No

tranquil quartz
bright veldt
#

When people say terrestrial carnivores they aren’t really including crocodilians

surreal stone
surreal stone
surreal stone
sullen cedar
#

I was using it as a example scan since most semiaquatic carnivores don't have lips like terrestrial carnivores

bright veldt
#

Here’s a study that basically summarizes all the arguments for lipped theropods (as well as most terrestrial animals, even amongst terrestrial crocodyliformes you can make an argument for it)

#

No lips in theropods is being held up by Carr (and only him) alongside a bunch of JP fans huffing copium

sullen cedar
#

So the argument about whether dinosaurs had lips or not is still a thing?

bright veldt
#

There isn’t really a debate anymore. Some people just act like there is

light osprey
sullen cedar
bright veldt
#

Why would carchar not have lips?

sullen cedar
#

Oh I thought carr was carchar

snow python
#

Is 12,5-12,7m and 8-9t mapu outdated? I wanna make a top 5 biggest theropods

bright veldt
#

The only dinosaur that has a genuinely good argument for being lipless is spinosaurus (Not spinosaurs in general, spinosaurus specifically) due its very dense and overlapping teeth

bright veldt
sullen cedar
#

I mean isn't the only spinosaurid that supposedly had lips is irritator

light osprey
#

Narp

light osprey
#

The Baryonychinae dentition is far more typical of most theropods

bright veldt
#

There’s nothing stopping most spinosaurids from having lips. Spinosaurus in particular has more unique dentition that might’ve got in the way of lips.

sullen cedar
#

I mean spino could have had partial lips spino with partial lips spino with lips and bare teeth spino

light osprey
#

Funny even Irritator escaped lip-limbo

#

Interpretion 3 would be a little odd, alas you may pick your poison nobody really knows

sullen cedar
#

Tho spino not having lip could also fall as into why most crocodilians don't have lips

#

Since they don't really need lips to keep their teeth moist since they spend most of their time in the water

ionic crescent
#

@woeful falcon ahoi, mind if I DM you? 👀

lucid ibex
#

Where are we at rn with the spinosaurus ecology debate? I kind of tuned out about a year ago simply because it was too much to deal with haha.

serene moat
lucid ibex
chilly knot
snow python
#

I'd put Deinocheirus bcuz it was over 7t but it wasn't a carnivore

white matrix
#

Oh you meant carnivorous nvm

solid vigil
#

I have a quastion for the good and smart people of this server. What is the most agreed upon size of Olorotitan, 8m or 12m? I'm seeing conflicting results online and I want to be sure.

tiny holly
#

Only 8m afaik, 12 would be one big hadrosaur BlobSweating

median root
#

8m

bright veldt
#

Olorotitan was average hadrosaur size yeah

solid vigil
#

Alright, thanks guys!

raven badger
#

Seeing Spino being discussed reminds me of the rabbithole of What the Spino truly look like. oh_god

#

It is never ending-

bright veldt
#

What spinosaurus looked like isn’t really a debate, regardless of what specimens are actually spino or not. We still have no idea how the thing was living ecologically though.

lost hedge
#

It lived in the moon but some dropped down to earth and died because they couldn’t survive with tiny little legs in earths gravity

frail robin
lilac vale
white matrix
woeful falcon
tight kettle
#

@storm tartan Please remain on topic of Path of Titans and/or the content relevant to the channel you are posting in. Refer to our #rules and pinned messages before posting.

elfin pulsar
#

Hey curious, what predator lived with/hunted bajadasaurus?

tough parcel
#

Seems to be nothing named

elfin pulsar
#

Well then LatenLOL

Thank you

compact leaf
#

abelisaurids are a safe bet

elfin pulsar
compact leaf
#

yeah none in particular but the family is basically everywhere in south america

elfin pulsar
#

Oh ok, is there any idea of what species or is it just a shot in the dark?

tough parcel
#

Shot in the dark, just don't copy Carno horns

white matrix
#

I copy pasted ez

tough parcel
kindred night
tough parcel
#

Isn't it Larson?

bright veldt
white matrix
#

is it just me or did that feel a little aggressive

bright veldt
#

Eh it was kinda warranted considering how much of a fumble that was on my part.

limpid glen
#

no lol js being mean for no reason

prob didn’t get their d today

sullen cairn
slim needle
#

Can I get an anatomy check fellas (T. rex and E. annectens)

(tagged for light gore)

lavish frigate
elfin pulsar
surreal stone
jagged trellis
#

the type of smile you put on for a camera

surreal stone
#

Fr tho

kindred night
#

Nah it was a little testy as he was my undergrad advisor

snow python
#

How big was Turiasaurus

pearl briar
chilly obsidian
#

Someone ping me with anything recent on Achillobator or a skeletal, anything

west coral
sand gyro
bright veldt
#

The bulk looks fine, I think we just aren’t used to Trex with longer legs (which it did have)

ocean drum
#

The main issue with the leg morphology ins’t that their longer than usual (which they are). But it’s that they are too skinny and flimsy compared to the extremely muscular and robust legs that the real animal is known to have.

white matrix
white matrix
#

erm opposite

compact leaf
#

it isn’t great from an accuracy standpoint

white matrix
#

first up its heavily oversized

compact leaf
#

we only have vertebrae but that’s enough to tell what it’s closely related to, and it doesn’t look like that

sullen cairn
#

I mean besides the size there’s nothing glaringly wrong with it

compact leaf
#

the head is what’s glaringly wrong with it

white matrix
#

texture is off

compact leaf
#

it just looks off

white matrix
#

Just seems the pot devs wanted their version of shant but failed

sullen cairn
#

Skull isn’t too offensive considering the closest thing with a skull is this

compact leaf
#

it just doesn't look enough like a saurolphine to me I guess, it has a weird roundness too it

#

I know we shouldn't rely on prehistoric planet for everything but they did a good job with bars, it's a better approximation than what pot has

white matrix
#

wasn't there something potentially lumping bars with saurolophus

compact leaf
#

the idea has been thrown around several times over the years

sullen cairn
#

Bars ended up as pretty basal within saurolophinae in the tlatolophus phylogeny which afaik is most recent

white matrix
#

idk afaik one of the subs are inspired by edmonto

sullen cairn
#

Bars is pretty much just a partial axial series and sacrum so there isn’t a whole lot you can do to make it more or less accurate

white matrix
#

holotype is this for ref (there is a few other pieces albeit)

sullen cairn
#

and its not like there's really any one particularly good skull ref afaik considering it doesn't even seem to be that stable

alpine island
#

The main problems with Bars in this game comes from its size and the godawful textures, the anatomy itself seems reasonable from what little we have preserved of it

compact leaf
#

the skull it has ingame still doesn't look enough like any saurolophine to me but there is definitely some wiggle room with it, the animations and textures are really what throw me but there's more that could be done to make it look more like a hadrosaur

white matrix
#

Hence few other pieces

rose thorn
#

I am personally of the opinion that Bars should just be remodeled into Saurolophus entirely, but its whatever at this point

compact leaf
#

the prominent nasal isn’t what bothers me, it’s just the way the whole skull fits together combined with the beak being very weird

#

it doesn’t look like it reasonably carries upwards into the rest of the skull like an actual hadrosaur beak it just goes straight back

sullen cairn
#

My like of fadeno’s saurolophus skeletal increasing exponentially after I realize I can make pot’s largest hadrosaur the size of sucho:

compact leaf
rose thorn
sullen cairn
#

Reason #7 tethyshadros or something would better fit bars’ role in-game while also being less fragmentary

white matrix
#

Just use Saurolophus, leave tethy

compact leaf
#

but that isn’t fragmentary and obscure enough

rose thorn
#

Saurolophus is…relatively obscure to most people

white matrix
#

or use magnapaulia for the funni

jagged trellis
#

nah we need lophus, none of those sauro part, folks know what a sauro is sometimes maybe...dinosaur

sullen cairn
#

Lophorhothon

rose thorn
sullen cairn
#

Saurolophus is also marginally larger than bars I’m not using fadeno’s dammit

white matrix
#

what about magnapaulia

compact leaf
#

we got robbed of big paul

rose thorn
sullen cairn
#

It uses the same 122cm(?) skull as the one in the gdi

rose thorn
white matrix
#

Edmontosaurus

rose thorn
#

Too easy

sullen cairn
#

Edmontosaurus vs rex brainrot is too prevalent for me to want that in a game

white matrix
#

Prosaurolophus?

compact leaf
#

this is verging out of paleo chat but you know what I would like? a sauropod that actually outsizes the rest of the roster

rose thorn
#

Pro is big, but not big enough

sullen cairn
#

Pro is bars size

rose thorn
#

Not big enough

stiff osprey
compact leaf
#

an official, we don't need a megasauropod just something nice and large

sullen cairn
#

Or make it shangt and scale it to the alleged 2m femur

rose thorn
#

Supposedly part of the problem with lumping Bars into Saurolo being the sheer exaggeration of the sacral spines in Bars isnt in any grown Saurolo we have?

sullen cairn
#

I think so?
Plus bars frequently being resolved far more basal

#

Although tbf I don’t know how many larger saurolophus sacrals are described in the first place

warped peak
#

Honestly

rose thorn
sullen cairn
#

Didn’t gat use bars for their recon? I could’ve sworn I read that somewhere

warped peak
#

They sould have used Charonasaurus instead of Barsboldia. It's the exact size they wanted, it's recognizable as an offbrand of a famous dino, and it's cool

rose thorn
#

Charon when it could have a reasonably different crest shape than Parasaurolophus :

sullen cairn
#

Man tlatolophus phylogeny ruined everything didn’t it

warped peak
#

Still more distinct than Barsboldia, and far less upscaled

rose thorn
white matrix
#

I still find it funny how table thought tethy could fill bars niche in game

sullen cairn
#

Wdym

woeful falcon
#

Tethy is miniscule by comparison

sullen cairn
#

So?

white matrix
# sullen cairn Wdym

In-game bars is essentially the games “shant” how is tethy going to fight rex and stuff

white matrix
rose thorn
#

Bite it’s ankles ig

white matrix
#

real

sullen cairn
#

Just saying the cutting edge of that beak could sever tendons and ligaments like nothing